[000:00:00;00] well, the amendment of the smart policy team, well, respect me, respect yourself , respect those authors of the amendments who prepared it, just respect people, and then you and i, perhaps as people's deputies, will enjoy respect, and not as if there is no dezougl , maryana volodymyrivna, who submits the relevant polls, but does not go to the hall herself, but later, then we are surprised at the result we get in her so-called polls, i understand that the term of office is ending for someone, but it seems that some people's deputies they started to master new professions for themselves, to become sociologists, but you have to study there, it doesn’t work like that there , i just wrote a request on facebook and that’s it, and it ran, no, there you have to

do math, and you have to go to meetings there, because you have to count their salary, i think that everyone there is very good at it, because a colleague said to me today: and i get my salary on time, it's cool that you get my salary on time, there are just delays at the front, there are delays in salaries, you understand, and in there is no deputy, he is fine, and then we we are surprised by the results of such polls, which the deputies hate, so how do you want to be treated? if you want to be respected, you must respect the people, they elected here, hope that they will be smart, that they will be professionals, that they will be people who will worry about the country and not just about their salary, that who would there were no amendments, good, bad, but you should listen to them, because you didn't

have time to read them, you didn't have time to read them, because you actually received information that this law will be considered today, received in half an hour, yes, until the meeting, there are a lot of us, unfortunately, the chairman of the parliament has left , but in 10 days, well, it could be given, then, this is a big law, i absolutely adequately assess when there are small laws on several rights , you don't understand, that's right, we had a business trip with colleagues from intelligent politics, we...we were with our defenders, but we arrived, and they say, and you are all in an adequate place there, here you are issuing bills that we will to give the opportunity to travel abroad for 13,000 hryvnias, you know what they told me, let me now give you 50, so now i am 50, let's not only those who have not yet been mobilized, but we will adopt this law for everyone, and

it is the government that proposes this bill, i am now going to the cash register and leaving this state, this is what a person who volunteered on the 24th says and she fights the whole war, she doesn't sit in the rear, she doesn't hide in kyiv, she didn't run away to transcarpathia, she risks her life every day, i've been talking to her for some time now, i can see how they're changing. she has approaches, he has approaches, as he said a few months ago, well, who else us, and how he says it now, you understand, and they are codes when they call, they say, but we generally look at what is happening in the hall, he says, but please tell me, and if i have from the unit, well, in fact as

they offer there. it is a battle to form a parliament, so there are almost enough of us for a battalion, and please tell me, if there are any left from the battalion, how many of us are there, well, 25 people, yes , there are left in the hall, we hold our positions, you think, they don’t see it, no looking at the busy military schedule, they also have this enough time, and then they call and say, well, it shouldn't be like that, it's wrong, and i understand that it's so wrong, our colleagues with you somehow think that it is. right, if we don't, you know, there are phrases, if you don't feed your army, you feed someone else's, in this case, if you don't respect your army, it won't be yours, that's a good lesson to learn ,

thank you, yes 225, 226, 7th, eighth, ninth. all your everything, yes 235, arahamiya does not insist, you see, unaccounted for edits even of the leadership monomajorities, and you say, well, that's it. his case is rejected, the doughboy does not insist, 237 vasylchenko does not insist , 238 the bakunet does not insist, 239 the rascal does not insist, 240, yuzhannin is not there, 241 the mazurash does not insist , goncharenko 242, please, oleksiy oleksiiovych, thank you, thank you, i beg you, mr. oleksandr , the next amendments 242, 297, yes, 307, 352, 438, 455, 456 and 478 - these are eight amendments, please give me 6 minutes and

then i will put one of them to the vote, let's go again 352, 400, then 438, 455, 456, 478, okay, six minutes and one edit. minutes, whatever important, we are discussing this now, please, thank you, dear friends, it is extremely unfortunate that there are no deputies , but people will see it, and they will see it on the broadcast, and i think it is very important that they see that after all in the verkhovna rada , the issues that really bother them are raised, because people write, how can a nurse laboratory technician live on the 500 hryvnias salary that today. this is the question that worries them, but it is not discussed in the verkhovna rada, only how to take all the funds back to the central budget is discussed, but

this is a question that worries people, how can a young teacher live on a salary of uah 5,000, on uah 5,000, how to live, well, it's generally a shocking story , the government, this bill, tells us to take funds to help the army, we have people in the army today , outsourced. the so-called, for example, unsuitable for the dshv, withdraw, but suitable for the ground forces, unsuitable for the marine corps, but suitable for the ground forces, they are not transferred for months, taken out of state, to the dshv, respectively in the marine corps, or if it is limited- suitable for the disease, removed freelance, these people receive uah 500 - 700 per month, we constantly see news there, that deputy bought a new car, that one a mansion, that one something else, we have people who gave their health for the state

500 - 700 hryvnias per month, well, this is a disaster, we must talk about it and such laws must be adopted, well, no, there is no such thing here, there is absolutely no such thing, we have it today, well , everyone is already saying this, the industrious one is saying this... in his interview, the economist, he says, the main question is people, human potential, we have today, what about people, we lose people three times a day, and , of course, we were attacked by the enemy, and people die at the front and people die in the rear from enemy shelling, but people are not born here yet, but what we did, uah 860 per month per child, is not possible. to have a child with these funds, absolutely, but nothing changes, there are no changes in us, no indexation, again there is nothing about this in this law, we have a third one - people do not return from abroad, and why do they not

return , because there are women with children, mainly, where will they and their children study, and how will the winter be, and how will the school be heated, are there answers to these questions? no, there is no answer, these are the key questions, today we have assistance for the disabled, for a lonely disabled person monthly assistance to find someone who can take care of him, 50 hryvnias per month, 50, 5, 0, well, this coffee does not cost that much in a cafe in kyivskyi, 50 hryvnias per month, and then it remains with us. people have two pensions, 2,200, 2,300 per month, so we are talking to you now about the budget, which has there should be a budget, everything is obvious, the army, everything is for victory, and the second social system, so that people just

survive this difficult time, that’s it, there should be nothing more, and here we are again with tv series, drums, whatever you can find, and nothing is solved in this direction, we are silent about corruption when... time magazine writes that they steal like there is no tomorrow, well, we generally understand what we are doing and how dangerous it all is, so we should have a conversation. not only general, but also specific amendments, i will put the amendment to the vote 352, this is an amendment that provides, well, now you are going to withdraw the funds of the pdf of the military from local communities, the military , you say, we want for the army, how do you give money for the army, everyone already knows, eggs for uah 17, everyone has seen well, okay, these are the military, and what's the point of the policemen here, the policeman doesn't live in the community. does his family not live in

the community? why are we going to take away their pdf from the communities, why? not only that, they did not return the 30k to the military, police, rescuers, which, by the way, zelskyi promised, said he would until the end of the war, the war is not over, thirty is over. by the way, zelsky also promised us that he would not run for a second term , and he also promised that there would be no elections during the war, and now i hear that he wants to run for elections and wants a second term... again, well, what about him promises are such nonsense, so returning to the policemen, policemen, why do we have to take their pdf from the communities, what is the logic of this , well then, why don't we take everything, why don't we take pdf, doctors, teachers, well, yes, well, well, what's the difference, why do we take away, that's why my amendment is very simple, remove policemen, they live in the communities, their families live in the communities, by the way, the families of the military also live in the communities, well, okay , there, well, that’s what you want

to take away the pdf from the military, well, let’s not touch the pdf of the policemen, let’s leave something communities, and of course we will demand that they help the army, and not engage in, not spend money on madness, on cobblestones, etc., but who set an example for them, the central government, i put to the vote amendment 352, i put to the vote amendment number 350, two , on goncharenko's proposal, this is goncharenko's amendment, it was rejected by the committee, please vote. for 10, no decision was made, the correction was not

taken into account. 243 hirashchenko does not insist, 244 gerasimovich, please, what, dear oleksandr serhiyovych, dear colleagues , let's start, maybe two there, and two minutes, i 'll vote one at a time, everything is as it should be, so let's start with what, about what this bill, dear ukrainians, this bill is about taking money. in local communities and transfer them to the central budget, that's simple, but now pay attention to whether we trust the way the central budget spends money today, let's start talking about it, and here i am starting and holding in my hands the report of the accounting chamber, here i will show it to you, about the spending of funds by the ministry of defense in 20 in the third year and what it is about

says, we will talk about this in more detail in the next amendments, but he says that even after the scandal about yaitsa on 17, money was stolen at a double rate, and the amendment about putting to a vote the proposal of people's deputy grasimma to take into account the amendment number 244 of people's deputies, pavlenka, arieva, it was rejected by the committee, please vote. for nine decisions have not been made, the year has not been taken into account 245 gerasimo, please, thank you, oleksandrovich , this is how i hold this report and pay attention to what it is about, i guess everyone remembers how big the scandal was when... it turned out, that eggs cost 17 hryvnias, it turned out that

they then buy kilograms, or rather, they wanted to present it that way, but nevertheless, after this scandal, the ministry of defense of mr. reznikov reported that everything was corrected, the prices were reduced, and after that, this report was ordered, which showed that the prices were really reduced, eggs began to be bought from the ministry of defense not at uah 17, but at uah 9, but in this report, i would also like to thank the deputy head of the accounting chamber, mr. meisner, for this truth. the same report shows that all others. the bodies of the security and defense sector bought these eggs for uah 5, 5, 5.30, 5.40, and the security service , and the border guards, and the national guard, i am putting to the vote amendment number 245, people's deputy gerasimov pavlenka ariyev for gerasimov's proposal, please vote ,

it was rejected by the committee. for 10, no decision was made, the correction was not taken into account. 246 batenko does not insist, 247 fripachina insists, 24849 we discussed , please, dmytro oleksandrovich 250th, which one, 48th, 48, and you said 249 just last time, then not mine, 48 not mine, okay, 248 mikisha, please. oleksandr, 248, if possible, 25,50 and 253, i have three minutes, so that i do not, do not interrupt, please, mikisha three minutes, first, please, what are these corrections about, we all know what

exists in ukraine such a road fund, too have already created for him, let's say, a dubious, infamous reputation, because he... this road fund provides great construction, but, but not only that, the road fund is discredited in the same way that local government is now discredited, but the road fund, it not only about the huge roads, there are international, national, regional ones, it is also about the fact that it provides critical infrastructure, it provides bridges that are now in an emergency and falling down, it is from this fund that funds are provided. funds for security are also allocated from this fund roads, this fund also allocates funds for local roads, 35% of this fund goes to local roads.

let me remind you that the draft law we are considering 10.037 takes away the military pdf, takes away the pdf paid by the policemen and employees of the state emergency service of the state emergency service, that is, the community will not have funds if you, your community needs the necessary, fast, repair of the corresponding road surface, and the corresponding equipment, which is aimed at safe traffic on the roads, it will not be possible to do all this, not only because the fact that the military pdf is taken away, and because this draft law takes money from the road fund. that we, what we see, are taking military pdf from local self-governments, taking funds for roads, for the safety of movement on these roads, precisely on the roads in those communities that are near, near the front, near the combat zone, there, in general, heavy equipment moves , and

the road surface is destroyed, another is destroyed, and pedestrian crossings, and stops, and all from... that's all, it comes from this road fund, and we are now it is not we who are taking away this, but precisely this draft law, it is precisely reasonable politics that says that this amendment, these amendments say that this initiative should be excluded, everything should be taken away, communities and, first of all, the road fund, i repeat, even those bridges , which are destroyed, which will fall soon, because they are emergency, it also goes from this corresponding road. and we take the funds from them completely, this cannot be, what will exist, this is a critical infrastructure, we will not be able to provide our economy, we cannot deliver goods, we must get our

infrastructure, respectively, with these funds, so please support these amendments, will you put them, yes , i am putting to a vote the proposal of people's deputy mikisha , to take into account the amendment number 248 rejected by the committee, stomikisha, zagoruyka, babiya and so on, please vote for 10, the decision not accepted, the correction is not taken into account, from the 251st dmytro oleksandrovich, please oleksandr serhiyevich, 251, 252, 254, 25 and the sixth, give me 3 minutes, please, three minutes of calculation, this is really, hardly anyone, enough conscience, name them technical corrections. corrections about the name, this is precisely about the so-called big construction, when it was convenient for you, you allocated funds there

in full swing and spent them where you cannot, for example, on the construction of the odesa highway, in the summer of 22, when we were traveling on a business trip, there was construction going on, not road repair , just what my colleague, dmytro mikisha, said about the fact that you spent exactly where you needed to go, you didn't spend on roads, just on filling so that the boys from the front line, it was possible on medivacs to bring to 100 points, they did not spend, there were such roads, a healthy person was traveling, she could have arrived unwell, and i am completely silent about the wounded, i am already silent that it directly destroyed the equipment on which it happened, minibuses, jeeps, pickups , which broke up their chassis. completely, but thanks to our defenders, they took their comrades from

the front line, and many were saved, but if you spent money on the repair of such roads, and not, for example, as now in chernihiv, then perhaps more boys and girls would remain alive, simply physically remained alive, they would have been taken to the 100th point, after that they were taken to zaporizhzhia, kramatorsk and rescued there, but you did not do this, you should have spent these funds on the construction of those roads that did not need to be done, on the construction, not for repairs, i repeat once again, our editors propose to take these funds from the entire road fund and send them to support the army, 50% to purchase weapons, 50% to ensure payments to our defenders, so that

no one runs out again, in the middle of the year, without whining and did not tell me that the military asked them to take thirty ten, asked to take one hundred from them, generally asked them not to pay their salaries, and then someone will come out very clever and say that they asked them to pay extra for the construction of roads themselves, because some officials simply do not have a conscience and now it looks like a joke, but in six months it may actually look like a reality, i will not be surprised by this, so dear colleagues, i will ask for these amendments to be confirmed, i would like to hear the position committee on the 252nd or 254th, these are the ones that are just fundamental, why don't you want to allocate these funds specifically for the army, you don't need to tell me that you will simply give them to the budget, thank you, please, yuriy mykhailovych, 252-254, thank you, dear... so, look, this norm that you propose will lead to the loss of the general fund of the state budget by 95.2

million, and i want to remind you that the payment of the labor of military personnel is not made from a special fund, when where do you propose to redirect these funds, but from the general fund of the state budget, and it is precisely at the expense of these funds that the payment of labor, and assistance for the army and so on will be formed , therefore, after all, the proposal to exclude the 59th item, it... is not supported by the budget committee, because there is already, there is already, let's put it this way, the position regarding the fact that this money is sent to the general fund and used for the country's defense capability, in particular, for the calculation of salaries for military personnel, thank you. do not put dmytro oleksandrovych, 252 and 54, i put

the proposal of the people's deputy to the vote razumkov to take into account amendment number 252 authored by petrunik: razumkov's committee, it was rejected, i ask you to vote for seven, the decision was not taken, the amendment was not taken into account, and in the same way i put the proposal to the vote, the proposal of people's deputy razumkov to take into account amendment number 254 moka on zagoruiko, my colleague, the committee it has been rejected, i am asking for nine decisions not taken, correction not taken into account dmytro oleksandrovych 257 257 264 please give 5 minutes 5 minutes wisely please, dear colleagues, you have now

left funds for designers, for pans, what else was bought there, the kyiv military administration, appointed by the cabinet of the minister and the office of the president, and we also had drums there, i forgot, i’m sorry, how could i miss such an important aspect, that is, you left the money for this, for the military no, because mykhailovych, you said correctly , in particular, it is spent on payments to our defenders, and i do not propose in particular, i propose exclusively , in one word, absolutely approaches, where the money will go, in particular for apples, in particular for eggs, in particular shells, which no, in particular on pans, on constructors, on large -scale construction, on huge corruption, in particular on things that cannot be

spent on in a normal state during war, and in particular on the salaries of our defenders. and we with the smart policy team propose, not in particular, but exclusively to direct these funds to pay our defenders once, for purchase, repair, armaments, two, so that the authorities do not have the opportunity to take these funds and redirect them somewhere else, you do not know how it is done , do not know how to create such funds? let me help you, you are ready to sit down now, that's it the chairman of the committee, there is also the first deputy chairman of the verkhovna rada, we can write such a bill quickly enough, if there was a desire to support it, you know how to do it, i am sure you know, if not, i will help my colleagues with pleasure, especially since now, taking into account what is happening in the hall, we

cannot vote for any bill at all, including gas stations, but none the less. are quickly violated and we follow these amendments, you know how to write such a bill, right? just answer that later, whether it is possible to prescribe if you wish, if you wish to make the army better, if you wish to increase the defense capability of our country, and not if you wish to once again send dragonflies into the cauldron from which and into the trough from which everyone around will eat, except for the provision of the armed forces of ukraine, you understand, that’s about it we differ, this is where our approaches differ from what you vote for, well, it's not normal when someone makes a decision, and then you try to put it on the globe, it doesn't work like that,

it's just a direct, direct demonstration of what you don't care about the army, you don't care about the defense capability, you don't care about... our defenders, i don't take you personally now , i take the government's approach in general, because the funds, today every hryvnia in the account, should be sent as much as possible to the defense security forces , and you send them anywhere, and then you will come out again in january and say, there is no way to pay salaries to the military, or state employees, or doctors, or teachers? you won't skimp on your roads again, will you? you won't, because the team will continue to finance them, but provide them those who definitely deserve it, doctors who are actually fighting on another front, teachers who are preparing our future with you so that this state remains, you do not do this, sometimes

it seems to me that everything is being done to destroy the future of this country, to sow disbelief among our advocates, to sow disbelief among our people that we're on the right path and we can be a successful country, just everything is done to make people stop believing, you know, and unfortunately, communicating with the military communicating with people on the streets, do you succeed? you manage to destroy faith in our state, faith among our fellow citizens, faith in our future, which will be successful after victory, but this is definitely the wrong way, which of them are you putting to the vote, well, 257,