for five, no decision has been made. 839 gerasimos, please. thank you, ruslan oleksiyovych, and you know that the key moment is when the money will be taken away, especially in the frontline communities , as i already said, for example, mykolaiv - 2 billion 700 million. kramatorsk - 600 million uah will be taken away, this is according to the minimum estimates, what the central government offers, what the team offers. zelenskyi , word for word, mr. shmigal: no community will have a smaller budget than it had in 2021, it will not suffer, and here i am now, why this again i repeat, because i really want to be heard , by representatives of local communities, to write down this information, and then according to the conclusions for the first quarter, second,

third and for the full year of the 24th year , we saw whether the prime minister lied or i didn't lie, but please take the correction into account. gerasimov's amendment 839 has been rejected by the committee and is being considered, please vote. for five solutions. not accepted, the next amendment 840 artur volodymyrovych, please, thank you ruslan oleksiyovych, you know when we talked about the promises of zelenskyi's team about the promises of shmyhal, mr. prime minister, he did not just promise that he would not suffer, he stated verbatim that the resource of local budgets, this is also his verbatim text, will be uah 75 billion in the 24th year

more than it was in 21. before the full-scale invasion, that is, he did not just say that he would not suffer, he also said that uah 75 billion would be additional, but i also suggest that everyone remember this information and carefully monitor it in quarters, or this promise will be fulfilled, something tells me that with these 75 billion hryvnias promised, the same will happen as with billions of trees with smartphones for every grandmother, and please take the correction into account. amendment 840 gerasimov and colleagues of the vinkhylna committee, please vote for seven decisions not by factions, show me , volodymyrovych, please, everything is exactly twice as many.

your faction supports, well, i don’t know why, artur volodymyrovych, you need to work with the faction, probably you, yours, the servant of the people faction gives twice as much for you as yours, well, what’s the difference, well, the fact itself now the results are on the scoreboard artur volodymyrovych, please 841 gerasimov, thank you ruslan oleksiyovych, apart from what you and i said that in principle and we will say so, from the point of view of common sense, this draft law cannot be adopted as it is currently drafted , also, it really does not correspond to the constitution, it is, as they say, not the first time that zelenskyi’s team violates the constitution, in a harsh way, but nevertheless, well, here in front of me are the remarks of the main legal department, so it is clearly written here that it is proposed to enshrine such directions

use of funds, attention, october 1, 23, well, listen, well, if you say that there is no reverse use, as they say , study the material part, here is the text where it is written, and i will open it, i can also find the article, where it is written, that's why you can't vote for it either, and i ask that the amendment be taken into account, gerasim's 841 amendment, rejected by the committee, i ask for a vote. for six decisions were not made 842 girasimov please thank you roslav oleksiyovych, so key and basic, if you vote for it, the money will reach the fighter much later,

the amount of money will be much less, these are approximate calculations, you will allow to potentially steal more than 30 billion, this is not constitutional, and it is simply that you are demonstrating to everyone in this country what kind of investments, if at this level you violate the law, then you will be violating the at all levels, but also in this bill there is a very serious anti-social provision, and it concerns that this bill does not meet the requirements of the tax code, which protects our citizens in the event of death or injury, i will carefully quote this provision during in my next speech, and now i ask that this amendment be put on count 842. the amendment of gerasimov and his colleagues was rejected by the committee, i ask for a vote, four, the decision was not

taken. amendment 843 gerasimov, thank you ruslan oleksiyovych, yes, this is er, this draft law currently includes a provision according to which you cancel the fact that the money from the personal income tax, which is now taken roughly speaking, from the salaries of policemen, er -er, state fire protection, civil defense units, and you know, these guys are now heroically helping people and carrying service at the front, including many in those territories that are located at the front, so it is written in the law that this pdf for these people should be directed exclusively to the payment of equivalent and full compensation for the loss of income of this category of citizens in the event of death or injury, with these bills you cancel it, and you didn't even look at it

, well, to be honest, you don't have enough arguments why you can't vote for it, the next amendment 843, authored by gerasimo, was rejected by the committee to vote, for four, the decision not accepted, the next amendment 844 we welcome, please, thank you, ruslan oleksiiovych, and here it is, by the way, precisely related to what the ubd is, a participant in hostilities, because, well , many things were precisely related to this. and you know what's interesting, before that we were talking about the social protection of employees of the state emergency service, policemen, and that's it, but here we can talk about the ministry of veterans, because the amendment also concerns this, by

the way, listen, european solidarity submitted a specific bill on automatic assignment of obd. well listen, well why is it not being considered in parliament now? you are considering anything, 10 billion in changes to the budget of the 23rd year , you stuffed your pockets there for the salaries and bonuses of officials, and you do not want to consider the automatic ubd proposed by european solidarity, that is why at least in this law, as for obd, the request to support, the amendment to support and put on 844 gerasimo's amendment was rejected by the committee, please vote. for five decisions, the next amendment was not adopted 845 gerasimo, please, thank you, i would

i wanted to continue about the ministry of veterans, you know, the number of complaints, the number of complaints that we hear today from the military, from veterans, from those who received, well, very serious injuries in the war, relative to the minister, it is off the scale, and i am very sorry that for a long time, the position has been calling for the minister, the minister of veterans' affairs, to be summoned to the verkhovna rada and asking her direct questions about what is happening, why she is not constantly present in the verkhovna rada, and does not constantly demand that deputies adopt laws in support of veterans and our military personnel, why is the situation with the provision of veterans so fundamentally lost, yes, round tables are held, but they once again prove that there is no politics, that is why, dear colleagues, i ask you to support the amendment, and as for the ministry of veterans affairs, the head of this ministry the request will be invited to the verkhovna rada, amendment 845 authored by

gerasimov, rejected by the committee, please vote. no decision has been made for six, the next amendment is 846 gerasimo, please, thank you ruslan. oleksiyovych, look, you told me what during my speech, i listed certain people's deputies there, majoritarians from the people's servants, but i just now prove with these statements that in principle it was not necessary there, i really wanted to name each of them, these amendments again relate to what is not it is necessary and wrong to take money from it from the local level to the central one, and the proof of this is that we have already mentioned it many times today, the report of the accounting chamber on procurement... the ministry of defense, but i just want to quote one sign for ukrainians now,

it is open, you can find it on the website of the chamber of accounts regarding how certain products of the ministry of defense were purchased in comparison with other services, lines of troops, for example, the ministry of defense bought eggs for 9 hryvnias, the sbu bought them for 5.46 hryvnias, border guards at 527. national guard at 5:23 846 gerasim's amendment was rejected by the committee, please vote for six, the decision has not been made, by factions, please show, artur volodymyrovych, well, four times the servant of the people supports you or your faction more , dear colleagues,

amendment 847 gerasimo, please, thank you, ruslan oleksivych, that’s how i finish, and the main intelligence department, i buy eggs for 5.30, that is, this line shows that the ministry of defense boiled twice as much on eggs alone, let’s move on to another, to sugar , and here... what is interesting: at the time when sugar was bought by intelligence, the main intelligence department for 31 g, the national guard for 34, the border guards for 30 hryvnias, the ministry of defense, well done, 46 hryvnias, don't you think that this is a little overestimated prices, let's go further, bread and flour, so here we already talked about it, the overcharge on one loaf was 8 hryvnias, serozha. that is why, these are just a few examples, and i will go further right now, it is not possible

to transfer these purchases from the local level, where there is a much higher level of control and actual morality, to the black hole of the central budget, that is why i ask that the amendment be taken into account, amendment 847, authorship gerasimo and colleagues, rejected by the committee, please vote. for seven, show me by factions, volodymyrovych, five times, it's time for you to change factions, the second faction is bigger than you supports, what is yours, listen, please, continue, 848 we welcome, please, thank you, ruslan oleksiyovych, let's move on, i'm not just saying this on the transcript, because you know , well, maybe not all ukrainians will read this tolmut account report , but... solidarity, you know, it carefully prepares for each session, we read

all the bills to the last line in order to find your corruption schemes, so let's move on, so that you ukrainians can hear, the onion is ribbed and here's what's interesting, in that time, while the border guards bought here for 39 hryvnias, the ministry of defense for 42 hryvnias, well, the sbu here, let’s say it was noticed, bought for 27 hryvnias. well, it’s not a huge overestimation, but nevertheless, let’s move on, here are interesting numbers, beetroot, well, it’s important to cook porsche, so here the ministry of defense bought 20 hryvnias, while everyone else bought 10, 12 hryvnias, and no one exceeded this bar, 848 amendment authored by gerasimov, please vote.

six decisions have not been made 849 artur volky , please, let's move on, and this is an important point regarding amendment 849, so i will explain it concerns acquiring the status of a participant in hostilities, but when you want a participant in hostilities: the one who was fed in the trench, you must do as the chairman of the verkhovna rada so that the money for this meal is not stolen. and now the attention is on the cabbage, which everyone is right. along the border, the sbu buys at uah 19, the ministry of defense at uah 25, well, this is already a serious story, potatoes , all ukrainians will understand this, yes, so at the time when the sbu buys there at 7.76, the intelligence department at 8.16, the ministry defense, 17

hryvnias 70 kopecks, twice for potatoes, to you nothing stands out, yes, despite the fact that the volumes are much larger , that's what these amendments are about now, why am i reading it, thank you, well , amendments about something else, amendments a little about something else, so i would ask, please if possible to the amendments, amendment 849, gerasimo was rejected by the committee, i ask you to vote for five, the decision has not been taken. 850, thank you, please, artur volodymyrovky, these amendments really apply because you are not introducing a draft law on the obdd, they relate to the specifics of acquiring the status of a combatant martial law, that's what they're about, but i can't ignore what the central government is doing now with these combatants, and to be honest, we

've talked about regular potatoes, and then there's early potatoes, that's an interesting moment, but while the border guards buy it for 18 hryvnias 39 kopecks, and this is an official document, i’m sorry , i’m quoting it to you, the ministry of defense, for participants in hostilities, including, buys these early potatoes for 28.50 , you know, well, what can i say about these numbers, eh to every ukrainian who is sending the last hryvnias now to help the armed forces, that's what i have to answer them, and we are now talking about it so that people will hear about it. i will continue to say this now, because it concerns combatants, what this amendment is about, and the amendment , artur volodymyrovych, you know, we would be happy to listen to other laws, if we did not sit through so many amendments, which are repeated, which no one reports, it's just a waste of the verkhovna rada's time, but we this is your right and that's why we listen to the report

invoice, which we can download and read, and everyone has already done it, so the 850 gerasimov amendment was put to the vote , i ask you to vote, for five, the decision has not been taken, please, 851sha, artur volodymyrovych, thank you, ruslan oleksiyovych, i i can say that if you think that we are wasting time when the opposition demands that you resolve the issue with the status of the ubd, from him. automatic receipt, well, this is an interesting report from the chairman of the verkhovna rada, but i was interested, but i was interested in something else, ruslan oleksiyovych, you said that you are all presidium downloaded this report, i already know it by heart, if you downloaded it, ruslan aleksivych , i will ask you a question, at what price did you buy buckwheat, for example, the main

intelligence agency compared to the ministry of defense, well, you downloaded it, tell me please i would really appreciate this reply now if you can't find it i will let you know the price in my next speech but you said you downloaded it so i would appreciate it if you have this report handy too will lie thank you thank you arthur volodymyrovych, i have the table for the draft law at hand, and now it is the subject of our consideration, not the report of the accounting chamber, you must have made a little mistake, i would very much like to go by the table, and not by what papers are lying around at your fingertips. because in this way you will have some fairy tales or fables and we will be forced to listen to them, and i would like a substantive conversation of a serious discourse on this matter, but i put 500 851 an amendment, which unfortunately we never got to hear what it is, but in the following we will find out the cost of buckwheat porridge, please, i am putting

gerasimov's amendment 851 to the vote, please vote. for five decisions, artur volodymyrovych, with impatience, greek krupa , the 853rd amendment has not been adopted, how many there will be. so , you know what is interesting, answering your question, the main intelligence department, well done, buy buckwheat dill at 50 hryvnias 57 kopecks. ministry of defense, attention, as they say a drum for 87 hryvnias 60 kopecks, well , they do not steal at all at the central level, and the amendment by ruslan oleksiyovych concerns precisely how the obd is appropriated, and we want to persons... who, due to injury , contusion, trauma, disability related to the performance of combat tasks, directly in the areas of military operations, and are undergoing inpatient treatment in health care institutions, and so on

and so on, yes, this story was automatically appropriated, that's what it's about, and if you think that these are fairy tales or fables assigned to obd, then this is just for discussion here in the verkhovna rada, and we will raise it in every bill, while it will not be voted on by the verkhovna rada, but the amendment, please, pro put into consideration and i suggest everyone to support it, because this is a probd, thank you, thank you, i will be happy to put amendment 853, it is not at all about what you said, but an attentive reader could read it, an attentive people's deputy, that's why i put amendment 853 authorship of gerasimov for voting, please vote. for five decisions were not made artur volodymyrovych 854 amendment we are interested in what you do 53 we just voted 53 we

voted artur volodymyr you see you are confused and i see again i carefully follow your amendments unlike you, but you carefully follow the purchase price of buckwheat, this is also very important, please 854, please first. thank you ruslanova, look, we will continue, and i want the transcript of this meeting of the verkhovna rada, and it remains forever, you and i know it, she really kept these prices, even if this report is destroyed, i do not know how it is at all the authorities released it into open access, so, pasta products, now a lot of ukrainians buy them, and you know what is interesting, the gur buys for 27 uah, the national... guard for 30, what is interesting, in

in general, the border guards buy us for 20 hryvnias 46 kopecks, and here is the ministry of defense, 41 hryvnias 70 kopecks, twice the price increase, here you go, and this, sorry, is not a fable, it is an official document of ruslan oleksiyovych's accounting chamber, which is, attention, if anyone does not know, as a body of the verkhovna rada of ukraine, i really support those colleagues who today made proposals to invite, thank you artur volodymyrovych, it is a pity that we never managed to hear the content of your 854 amendment, to supplement the bill with the fourth part of the corresponding content, but i am forced to put it to the vote, amendment 854, i ask the people's deputies to vote, i would like to hear its content, of course. in three, the decision has not been made, artur volodymyrovych, amendment 855, where you also propose to add, and that is possible

first, time, because a little, please, first, give those 3 seconds more, thank you, but now attention so that you do not they said that these amendments are not about obd, i will read this amendment to you verbatim, the draft law after point one should be supplemented with a new paragraph of such a message with the reason: to acquire the status of a participant combat operations by the persons specified in the first part of this article, during martial law operations, there is a combat order of the commander of the corresponding military formation, to send such a person to the area of ​​military operations in the pubic area for the direct performance of combat tasks, related to measures to ensure of national security and defense, repelling and deterring armed aggression of the russian federation. ruslav oleksivych, all the amendments before this clearly relate to this, and i will tell you, we will be realistic submit amendments to all draft laws on the obd until the verkhovna rada of ukraine votes on it. we believe that the ubdd automatic status is one of

the points that we are obliged to resolve as soon as possible. as for the amendment, please consider it. thank you. undoubtedly, amendment 855, which concerns the status of the ubdd, but of course, it would be better if it were in a separate special law, which we cannot get to in any way, to it... we cannot get to it in any way, because we are sitting in these amendments in to the second law, but i am a saint the right to democracy artur volodymyrovych 855 your amendment was rejected by the committee, please vote for four, no decision was made, show us by factions, artur volodymyrovych, well again... 800 856 amendment arur volodymyrovych, let's go, please, where are you and you here , thank you, ruslan oleksiyovych, 856th

amendment on the same topic, i wrote it. please take it into account, but i will continue with this table, i’m just about to finish, but there are very bright things here: sunflower oil, right at the time when the border guards buy this sunflower oil for 58 hryvnia 701 kopecks, mr. reznikov's close-knit ministry of defense bought it at 89, and please note that this happened after the ministry of defense... did not lower purchase prices after the egg scandal at 17 hryvnias, that is, the border guards have nothing it is necessary, they frankly and honestly buy as it is, the ministry of defense overestimates almost twice, the attention after the scandal, this leads me to the fact that if the verkhovna rada really wants to protect the participants in the battles of our soldiers on the front line, do not let them steal from the central equals, 850. sixth amendment

our proposal was rejected by the committee, i ask you to vote for five, no decision was made. 857 on adding a new paragraph to the first paragraph, artur volodymyrovych, please. thank you, ruslan oleksiyovych, and here i would like to move on to another point , you know, i just brought to your attention the ministry of defense of mr. reznikov, the flamboyant representative of zelenskyi’s team, so that ukrainians could see that even after the scandal of 17 hryvnias, they reduced the prices are in quotation marks, and now they are making noise , they are all discussing these prices after the reduction, but what do they say to us, we are taking away the local pdf, because there is no money, ruslav oleksivych, and why then did they leave money to finance oligarchic tv channels, as

far as i remember, 1.1 is still not there, it belongs to mr. medvedchuk, and they left money for tv series, but they were not changed, even for the 24th year submitted, please tell me, if everything is for the needs of security and defense, then what happened to the series and what happened to the marathon, which, if i am not mistaken, goes to 2 billion uah, that is why the money is there, it just needs to be spent correctly, and please confirm the edit, thank you, 857 amendment, i will put it on but, artur volodymyrovych, regarding the various cooperation with medvedchuk, it is definitely not up to me, i think you will be enlightened more by colleagues who are not there somewhere now, but they are definitely sitting in your corner, somewhere there, 857 gerasimov's amendment , it was rejected by the committee, please vote

for five. the decision has not been made 858 artur volodymyrovych, please, thank you ruslan oleksiyovych, you know, a lot has been said today about the presence of deputies in this hall, but one aspect that i want to draw attention to is that if there on that tribune journalists were present during the meetings, and i still don't understand why you don't allow them, you are afraid, probably, then i think that many more people's deputies were present now, because you don't want control? and how should i behave now, when we are sitting in the verkhovna rada , nobody is there, journalists are not allowed in, you say, everything is fine, pass it on to the central level, they will not embezzle, yes, if the verkhovna rada, excuse me, is afraid of control and is afraid launch journalists, what can we say about the cabinet ministers, where you don't dig into any ministry, you can simply, well, to be honest, write treatises and reports of the accounting department, so what am i simply leading to, that ruslan oleksivych, let's still

accept... the decision on the return of journalists to the verkhovna rada, there is no need to be afraid of them, israel has shown us this example, and please put the amendment 858 amendment, which concerns the addition of a new paragraph, new content to the draft law by the committee from rejected, please vote. for five decisions, the next amendment was not adopted 859 we welcome you, please, thank you, ruslan oleksiiovych, and you know, here we go to another such interesting page , which concerns the provision of our servicemen, those who sit in the trenches, they are volunteers, but there is no need to hope, but i always had a question, tens, hundreds

of hryvnias go to the ministry defense