[000:00:00;00] today is november 7, something tells me that when i finish my speech , i would very much like the chairman to put the law to the vote, well, i want to believe that the chairman will not close our meeting and say, now we part ways, because here the deputies disagreed, well, we will vote on this law, i will not vote for it, but i see that the mood is there, as they say, there is potential, because it is easy to find the potential to take money from someone. they will vote, then something prompts me, there will be resolutions on appeal, then they will sign it, then they will be in a hurry, of course, the law will be finally signed anyway, well, in the second half of november, not earlier, explain to me how it is possible to take the funds from october 1 in the second half of november, well, no, i will have more of a record, 90 minutes i go

, this is anton, you didn’t see it correctly, so how can you once again take away the funds from october 1, retroactively , i say at the budget committee to the government representatives, or maybe you can take them away from october 1, 2018 , and the deputy minister to me answers, good idea, says, good idea, likes, well we are adults, we have families , that's all, but you are in your family... you already spent money in october and suddenly someone comes to you in november and says: give it back, how is it? and including the same military personnel, they have already given it, so how is it? well, what kind of state is this, in which they can say, from october 1, let's go back , well, this is madness, it is now in the law in our country, it is the law of ukraine, which colleagues are going

to vote, accept and live by it. and what kind of signals are these, to whom in general, how can anything be planned here in the country, how can anything be done to do, well, how? well, it’s some kind of, well, scary, i don’t know, a scoop, some kind, or something , that we will be retrospective, that there is no rule of law, these are important things, because, well , everything begins with such rules, everything begins with such rules, from struggle everything starts with corruption, and you know, it is possible in every situation. to find, unfortunately, now people are writing to me a lot about 128, you and i understand what we are talking about, we are talking about the 128 brigade and the tragedy that happened to it, a terrible tragedy, this is when this savkovoe construction, 30 km from line

front, wait for the commander, while they waited, they waited for the russian missile, killed... heroes, wounded heroes, shock in the whole country, and let 's be honest, this is the first time, this is the first time that we have such unnecessary losses, because simply no, there were no other flights to training centers, barracks, where no one for some reason thought about the risk, and why so, and because today we hear that the commander of the 128th brigade has been suspended from his own. and another question: how did a person who was convicted of smuggling in the 19th year become the commander of the 128th brigade of cigarettes, was convicted of smuggling cigarettes, and at that time a lieutenant colonel of combat, in the 19th year of combat, lieutenant colonel became the 23rd cambrig and colonels, well, you can

ask that. well, that's an interesting question, who appointed this person already after the 19th year , after the verdict that the person, well, because there are different officers, because there are different deputies, because there are different whoever, there are officers who are role models, but there are officers who, and there are officers who were engaged in completely different smuggling, crushing , look, there is someone shouting, it is not clear who, this, this is there, we have such people, well, we have them in the council there are different people, and here... there are also clowns, there are constants, there are racketeers, and there is a person shouting, who actually is such a person, and these are friends, tishchenko's racketeer woke up, and the rector of tishchenko shouts something it's a shame , i think he will take a cue and soon explain to us the truth, about his racket , about constants, about colt centers, about the forest, about the stolen, about quarantine, about velour, about everything,

everything, everything. oh, you see, yes, well, when , you look, people, when you see, this is the old lady, sitting over there at the end and screaming, you see him, hiding behind the column. by hid behind the column, well, mr. volodymyr, can we ask you to show the people a little closer that it is he who is shouting, thank you, who is shouting there, thank you very much, but now we will show that it is he who is shouting there, mr. tishchenko directly, that’s right friends, this is a very interesting question, by the way, what do people like him do even in the verkhovna rada, they don't sit in prison, they sit, they don't sit in prison, tishchenko sits, but he sits in the hall of the verkhovna rada and still shouts. and that's where everything starts, when people who belong in the verkhovna rada sit prisons, some servants of the people now meet this in sizo, i am such a servant of the people

gunko, he is in sizo, he keeps, warms, warms shkonka there and for tishchenko, i have no doubts, and for many colleagues, oh, you are already here , it's a race, friends, the race is already with us, i didn't know that, don't forgive me, gunko is here, friends, he's not in sizo anymore. friends, people's deputy gonko is the one whom nabu showed footage of how she took 80,000 dollars in a bag of money, which we had together with tishchenko as the head of the investigative commission, tishchenko in the forests, and this one in the land village godarskyi, we still greeted him from the tribune in sizo. friends, cheers, gunko is back. hooray, friends, gunko is with us, he is here, that’s it, the sizgo is over, no need, friends, fantastic, gunko is already in the verkhovna rada, tishchenko is in the verkhovna rada, fantastic, yurchenko, who was taken, so, he is probably

sitting here somewhere, yurchenko he is also sitting here with us, no, who was taken for this, for 2,000 dollars, who stole several bottles of beer from a store before that, and then became a national dep, he is also here, i understand, yurchenko, friends, tell me so, everyone is a shame , i'm asking you tishchenko, yurchenko, make sure to give some sort of reply, well, give some sort of reply afterwards , let them tell us what experience they have, how to squeeze money, or tell us what is wrong and bad nabu, this, this is fantastic, friends, here you are , now, friends, you can see what's going on live here. why in the country is there all this without the un, this clown has become, look, why is there such a mess, why, because

people like tishchenko sit in the verkhovna rada, and not in prison, oh, look, look, such a scumbag has already returned , that is, imagine, and a person calmly says so, and what are you there you say i'm a race, i'm here, you were arrested for taking a bribe, and you say, no, i'm already here , everything's fine, there are no questions, friends, well, this is madness, this is madness, well, what are we showing, people, well i, i, i don't know, friends, come on, who wants to say something to our deputies, we'll try to hear directly from the people right now, and yes, yes, yes. and here i think that there are people who would also like to say something to the people's deputies, who, who see all this, all this mess, and

come on, friends, someone from our military, yes, so, let's try, you can imagine what is happening, just here people write, here people are sitting and writing now, one to zero, to zero. well, let's go, these, these, these shouters, look, where do they all need to go, right at zero, well, you see these here , who have such fantastic powers, i want friends, some of our military, maybe you know, so that you can hear, hear, yes, and this, and this, i think, would be very, very necessary, friends, if it is someone from the military, then tell them that they are military, and we will give you something... and also, because you see what is here it is happening, you are a military man, friends, yes, now, maybe we will just hear someone from our military, they have long wanted to say something in the verkhovna rada of ukraine, maybe now

we are giving them such a direct opportunity to say directly from scratch what they think , but right from scratch they would say, and this and that would definitely be, i think, necessary and important to hear. because as you see, what is happening in this verkhovna rada is absolutely not what people expect from this verkhovna rada and what should be, you are a military man, yes. you see, something here is not allowing us to contact any military officer, so that the military officer would tell us something about those people who are behaving like this and doing such things. friends, well, until we try, i will definitely continue the opinion that is, good day, are you in the military? oleksiy oleksiyovych, you are heard from the supreme council of ukraine, with all due respect, we do not have the kind of work that you are trying

to do now, we are happy to wait for our colleagues, let's not disturb the order for a second, mykola mykolavych, there are the rest in the hall , and then everyone will have the right to reply and in all of the above, well, then i actually, in order to support our colleagues , to give... the opportunity, well, what is it called, everyone had the right to a reply, dear friends, do not excuse the military, you see, they say, there is no such form work, what to hear from the military, i wanted to include you, well, then i can only yours , what you write, i can quote and ask your questions, but here it was said that colleagues, so there will be remarks, so i would like to hear remarks from others as well , and from our other colleagues, i would like to hear a reply from mr. gitmantsev, our colleague who was sivkovich's assistant three times, the sbu today says that sivkovich is the head of the russian

intelligence network in ukraine, which means that mp danylo gitmantsev was his assistant three times, but i also give mr. danylo the opportunity to reply, of course who else did yurchenko mention here, it was gunko who said, if people want to hear someone else, write to me, i will remember, maybe they will find the time and energy to give some kind of answer, mr. sabal, who... blocked the payments with his resolution military, i think he also has something to say, it would be great to hear his reply from him, we have many deputies here, whom people would really like to hear, so i am giving you all this opportunity to tell what and how it happens and why everything happens like that. now, friends, i will continue, today we are talking with you about the state budget, so that it does not look like i am talking, you know, about problematic issues, but i am not talking about

how to solve them, yes, well, you can really say , so what, well, there are problems, we all do we see, but how to solve them, well, some problems, i clearly said today how to solve them, the problems of the military, i said , we need a law on replacement, that is , the demobilization of some and their replacement, i submitted such a bill, let's consider it, let's decide, i propose solutions, and not just saying that it is bad there, everyone knows that it is bad there, but this is how it can be solved, i submitted a bill on rotation, because there are units that are at zero for 20 months, they are also not steel, yes, this we say our steel warriors are made of metal, but even metal gets tired let's solve the issue of rotation, worked for three months at zero, defended the state, left, at least rested for a month, well, that's how it should be, and that's how it was promised, unfortunately, this is not the case for many units, so this is also a proposal, and what to do ?

what to do with the economy, here they tell us , here is what to do, yes economically, well, i will say what to do with the economy, it is necessary to put it in the corner, nothing else, not taxes, not how to squeeze money, not a racket, not to change these taxes 500 times a year, and put the main workplace, and any entrepreneur who creates a job, it just needs to be supported as much as possible, does not ask for anything from the state, pays salaries to people. thank god, and some kind of pedestrian tax comes from this, at least the one that you now want to divide, what do you want to take away, you want to take away from the personal income tax, this is the salary, this is the tax that is taken from the salary of each person, pdf, and how is it to create this tax, and how is it to give people this salary, give her this salary to people, and for this she needs to be ours, the next question here is the top.

would be glad to return checks to businesses, friends, they still want to return checks to businesses, that's right, but what's wrong with our taxpayers, i understand, they feel, even more so, let's create opportunities to extort business, all these bureaus of economic security, the tax office, all these endless people who walk, demand, take away, friends, well, this is reality, you and i all know it, so can you and i, here is the answer for you, and what should be done, yes like prohibit these checks, this baby in the form that works today, it does not bring any benefit at all, then we spend hundreds of millions on it, take these funds , give... the opportunity to those who create a workplace, do not touch them, do not touch them, absolutely, but what are we doing, we we are doing completely different things, this is in the economic issue, and this is also very important, but what should we do in the issue of foreign policy, where it is very difficult, today it is very

difficult, and finally to reveal the potential of the verkhovna rada, to stop doing stupid things when the speaker is sitting here determines who can go abroad, who cannot, only somehow it turns out that when they are servants of the people, they somehow cannot, in the maldives they find themselves in a strange way, in thailand they find themselves in a strange way, in other places they find themselves in a strange way, and when you want to go to protect the country, work, for example, like me there in the parliamentary assembly of the council of europe, no, they don't let you in, because you talk too much, because you have too many questions, and they don't like it. we won't be here, what have you violated, said zelenskyi's father about the scholarship, and after that, where are you at all , why are we here, oh, we'll arrange that for you, so that means there was no place for you, well, because i don’t know, it’s a separate story, so

we haven’t heard any answer to that, why, why or who framed the president with this scholarship , if he didn’t frame it, why doesn’t he refuse it, well, that’s the same it's absurd, well, we told today how difficult it is for people, at the same time, the president's father has a lifetime scholarship, with all due respect, well, thank god, his son is able to support his father as needed, he has everything for this opportunities, why are there 6,000 hryvnias from the state, then let's give them, well, there are those who need them more today , well, the truth is, well, these are things from which everything starts, which people see, from which they draw conclusions about everything, about us and you, about relationships. about the situation in the country, we have to remember it with you, we have to talk about it with you , come on, they didn't give me the opportunity to include people, then i will try to ask a question, people write, where is the mobilization, here i am , what people write, demobilization, 30ka, salaries

, ah, borders, where, deputies, many are concerned about the question, but where are the deputies, well, i don't know, colleagues, where are the deputies, where are they? everyone left, we have today, today, november 7, the second working day of the verkhovna rada this month, no way for the military, who do not have days off, no way for a doctor or teacher, who have a five-day work week there, we have the second working day in 7 days , on the first day , on saturday, we had 17 deputies here, now we have maybe 30 deputies here, well, it was just that there were probably 200 deputies here. how many will end before the end? and you and i started at 12 o'clock today, we haven't worked for another two hours, so why not getting tired, such tiredness, some kind of tiredness, chronic fatigue in the deputies, such a complicated story that they cannot, well, if they could stand it, 860 uah, people, well, it’s for the children,

it’s obvious, it’s all, well, tishchenko is a traitor, it’s clear, it means , there are no questions here, ah, well, then the 128th brigade, well, i hope there will be an investigation and this will never happen again, such a horror, it is certainly a tragedy, he people write, they are not tired in advance, yes, well, it is 100%, fatigue , fatigue ahead, jobs, people write, people write, jobs, give us where we will work and we will return abroad, people write, but we want to work, they write that we don't get 100, that's military pomp. 500 hryvnias was paid to me, here is a soldier writing, probably discharged from the state, so what , what to answer to this person, so what should i say to this person, well, i don’t know, so i’m telling the deputies, today i told about it 10 greaves, we will be able to solve a simple issue, the people who have been removed from the state, our military already, well

, let's not throw them out for begging, well, no , not 500 uah, well, not 500 uah per month, well it is impossible to live. because of the price of gas, people write questions, weapons, yes, well, what about weapons, well, these are all important questions, why does the ukrainian defense industry work, why does the ministry of defense work, and why, unfortunately, well, we do not see enough of our ukrainian defense industry, from our ministry of defense, because this is a matter of the survival of the state, and this is what zaluzhny writes about in his article, the economist. and we understand everything, we understand that if everything is complicated there, by the way, pay attention, this is also indicative, zaluzh does not write articles, he does not write any criticism on address of the president, what the president is right and it cannot and should not be like this, he is the commander-in-chief, the president , the supreme commander-in-chief, but

after the article yermak’s deputy, mr. zhovkov, appears on the screens of the national telethon and criticizes the hard-working man, then i do not understand this at all, even if, well i don't want to go in, maybe something is wrong, so solve the issue behind closed doors, why are you showing the whole world that there is... at least friction in the top military and political leadership of ukraine, why do we need this, why are you doing this, on telemaaran nothing nothing happens by accident, friends, no one gets there by accident, if he appeared there, then it was necessary, and then the question is how the commander of the sso was released, that is on the same day, a signal, without this, he is the commander of the sso, he says, i found out about my release, he says from the media, then i sat, planning military operations. and then i will find out who you are, you are no one anymore, you are dismissed, general , commander of the special operations forces, what have we

gone crazy at all, how can this be, no, there, who should be dismissed, who should be the commander of the sso, is up to the supreme commander-in-chief, it is better for him, but you cannot release a person so that he learns about it from the media, i.e. from the internet, it is good that he was subscribed to some telegram channel, preferably honcharenko. and learned from there, and if not, that the driver would have been in charge for a while, well, well, we, well, what in general , how can this be in the country, in principle, how can this be in the country, this is also a show of respect to the same military personnel, it all starts with the private, who is taken out of the states, paid 700 hryvnias, to the general, who is given kopniak, what he learns about from the internet, well, the explanation of words, how is this, why is this , friends, what is happening in our country, well, how can this

be, how can it be, to me, yesterday i was in rivne, in lutsk, in nitini, i want to say that i, it seems to me, was in rivne , i was asked, no, in lutsk, sorry, in lutsk, people asked me and told me a story, a woman was caught there, how she stole a piece of lard and they gave her five years and two months in prison, it was not her first time there, unfortunately, the theft of a supermarket and theft is theft, but for a piece of lard, she was given five years, five years in prison, and people's deputies who were caught for bribes $80,000.

they say, but we are here, we are doing well, and the people who have questions for billions, they are doing well, everything is fine , five years for a piece of lard, for billions, a state award, what can even be given to the hero of ukraine, what not , this is certainly a huge one, and this is a huge problem that, well, well , is killing us, just killing us, and this is what creates, splits society, this is what causes a lot of questions, this is why we have today the problems we have, and they need to be solved, and if you and i continue to ignore them, if instead we break everyone at the knee, if instead we just listen to no one and hear nothing, well disaster and trouble, i said that i will now say what needs to be done, i have already named things: economic policy with a priority for the workplace, a real anti-corruption fight, a real, not for

a piece of fat for five years, finally take on those who steals billions, or millions, of real things, the entire infrastructure is created, nabu is there, sap is there, the anti-corruption court is there, everyone is there, they have money, there are laws, everything is there, let them work, let them show... the result, because when i see the news on the nabu website that they sent the case to court for the fact that 3 million hryvnias worth of seeds were stolen, are there two truckloads of seeds there, or something , at the same time, i do not hear any news about how the head of the dnipropetrovsk regional military administration, 15 billion hryvnias, under construction contracts on the roads last year, during already gave wars to a fitness instructor and her company, which then by some strange coincidence of circumstances. with him travels abroad together, crosses the border, well , he constantly trains together, and 15 billion

hryvnias are given to her, but we do not hear the result of this case, but where is she? well, it's not a piece of fat, it's true, it's 15 billion hryvnias, but where is it, it's the next thing that should be done in the state, the next thing, but i'm not stopping there, i'm saying the next important thing, we said that the elections are not on time, and thank god, and we hope that the authorities will come to their senses and stop doing this, but then what about time, friends, it is really time for unity, but what about this to finish the union? and i will tell you, in our country at the beginning of this invasion, many people in the world compared president zelensky with churchill, they said that churchill, he is that one, and for ukraine, i am not going into it now, there is a question that is called about this similarity, but for it was good for ukraine, actually a good comparison, because the whole world , well, cherchel is a historical figure, and when they say that ukraine is led by a strong leader, super, well

, that’s good for the country, i’ve never been anywhere abroad... doubt is a comparison, but on the contrary, yes, yes, of course, that's why what is it for the country, but let's be honest and say a few things, first , what did the real churchill, not this churchill of ours, but that churchill, do when he became prime minister in may 40, at the moment of the greatest trials exceptional challenge for great britain, but he invited the opposition. he called attlee, the leader of the opposition, to become his deputy, he united the entire parliament of great britain, 600 people, by the way , i think that the parliament of great britain then went to work better than the parliament of ukraine goes to work today, as we can see, on saturday there were 17 people, now there are 30 people, the pereftom, and he united them all, there was one

huge coalition, there were no elections in great britain , between 19 and 1945 the country was engaged in victory, by the way, after the victory, churchill lost the election, well, this is life and democracy, but there were no elections for 10 years and no one questioned the legitimacy of churchill, there were no questions, because the whole country was united, everyone is together, there is no one who is excluded, which made netanyahu, the prime minister minister of israel, when n after the terrible events of october 7, when this one was there the attack, and the killed people and the disaster, despite the fact that in israel, here too, we all do not like each other very much, but in israel the level of political hatred, it seems to me, is even higher than in ukraine, well, looking from the side, this is a colossal level, yes, thank you, a colleague brought me a bottle of water, this is a true

comrade and friend, colleague, mp savraz. so friends, so friends, what did netanyahu do? netanyahu called on the opposition to join him in the government. the first thing he did, despite the fact that we understand with you that the attack of hamas on israel, does not constitute existential danger for israel, hamas can't destroy israel, and russia, unfortunately, could destroy ukraine, i hope it can't . but it was an exceptional challenge and it remains for us, well, for sure, why not compare hamas with putin, well, yes, from the point of view that they kill terrorists, yes, but not to compare from the point of view of danger, a nuclear state is on us attacked, and what did our churchill do, he marginalized the opposition,

suppressed everyone, transformed the parliament... well, we are not solving anything here, realistically, well, that’s they just sit here, press a button, actually from the parliament, it seems that there is one person who can go into the president 's office, she is not here now, there are two more people who probably can on work issues, at least somehow, maybe our speaker and his first deputy , they can at least knock there, we can have someone answer something, that’s all, in the president’s council we don’t see if he comes, but you only speak to us, and he left, we sang in the choir of the ropes, he listened, left, but there is no contact, there is no, i appealed to the president by letter in accordance with the law, this the issue of the status of a people's deputy, a people's deputy has the right to receive any leader, i made a request to the president, i want, i asked, i demand a meeting, in the fifth year of