[000:00:00;00] it is necessary to act on the basis of the current situation, and not to say that everything is the fault of the predecessors, sorry, four, almost five years already, enough time to correct, i emphasize once again, the mistakes of all predecessors during the 30 years of independence, for that and the people chose a monomajority, i will just add a small remark, since i was a participant in the student revolution, and our demands included the re-election of the verkhovna rada, it was in october 1990, and then, by the way, the representatives of the national democratic camp did not strongly support students from about the fact that it is necessary to restart the parliament and reset the eyes of the 239 communists who were in the verkhovna rada, that is, they did not go for re-election then, that is, this whole story has a very long, chronology, which we can

talk about, but here the question is, what should we do now to do during the war, when there are open collaborators who traveled to moscow to pay their respects, but boyko, who took a blessing there from medvedev, i think, or from putin at that time, and when he was running for president, including ukraine, and this, and it was very, very symbolic, but we will wait for something decision, because it has to be, it seems to me that it cannot be any other way, as is the decision today on the 2024 budget, the verkhovna rada of ukraine, 276 people's deputies. voted for the estimate for the next year. let's watch a short story by our journalist kateryna galko, she tells what kind of budget this is. on november 9, the verkhovna rada finally adopted the final version of the state budget for 2024 . 276 people's deputies voted for. the final edition provides for revenues in the amount of

uah 1,768 million. they were increased by 22 billion. so, the state budget deficit now amounts to 1.57 million uah expenses 3.35 million hryvnias. external borrowings - 41 billion dollars. the forecast for real gdp is 4.6%. inflation forecast - 10.8. assumptions about the hryvnia exchange rate on average for the year 40 g70 kopecks per dollar. the budget takes into account the main orientations of the future ukrainian doctrine. of the president of ukraine: expenditures on security and defense will be no less than last year, and also provide for investments in own production and improvement of the technological potential of the armed forces of ukraine. we will have more drones and our own weapons for the fastest possible victory it is planned to increase pensions and increase teachers' salaries , twice as much money as last year is provided to support veterans. business assistance programs will be funded,

because the economy... needs to grow. therefore, the main priorities of the state became the defense and security sector, for which more than a trillion hryvnias were allocated. social protection for citizens - almost half a trillion, as well as health care, education, business support and support for war veterans. the prime minister also noted that there will be more weapons and equipment, more drones, ammunition and missiles. every hryvnia of taxpayers will go to the army. we thank the parliaments for their support and constructive position. the budget clearly sets priorities. all our internal resources will go to resisting and defeating the enemy. we would like to remind that for the third time in the history of our state, all non-military expenses will be financed by partners. however, at present, the situation with them is shaky. according to the minister of finance serhii marchenko, we expect 5.4 billion dollars

from the imf, 8.5 billion from the united states. 18 from canada, norway, japan, korea and the world bank. well, here our journalist did not add that 2 billion uah will be allocated next year for a single telethon and 440 million uah for tv series. ms. maria, i am addressing you, the representative of european solidarity, because your faction abstained from voting on the budget, and why? you know, such a beautiful budget. that for the first time there was not even a prime minister who would present this budget, and in fact it is really very important in the conditions of war, and when we hear that there are increased expenditures on the ministry of defense, unfortunately, just as they are decreased, there are increased expenditures on on bp, on dbbr, the prosecutor's office, other law enforcement agencies, that's why, of course, we couldn't vote for this budget, because now the number one priority is that we have to unite around

the armed forces of ukraine, around the ministry of defense, to ensure as much as possible that what is necessary for our boys and girls to fulfill their tasks, so you know, funding. this is such a shocking number, it is reduced by 6%. but the financing of the general prosecutor's office and those other bodies that monitor the opposition, rather than looking for it, has also increased collaborators, so you are right that there is almost 2 million left for the marathon and 440 million for tv series. now let's go to the tv series, do you know how the support for the marathon is falling and now in the conditions of war, this is a priority, so of course we would like this budget to look different, and we are working on the edits, our nina petrivna

was present at the committee, i would really like you to listen, but our amendments were failed, thank you, ms. maria, mr. mykhailo, are you satisfied with the current budget, of course not, but we must be well aware that it is already the second budget of the belligerent state. when there is a large-scale military or rather war against ukraine, the russian federation, and the first is the defense sector, i agree with my colleague that in general the defense sector has increased, the ministry of defense has been partially reduced, the second, the largest column of expenses is social, although for the sake of it, 25 billion plus, but we are also worried about why the motherland faction did not support this budget, because the subsistence minimum has been raised by only uah 300 and will amount to

uah 2,930 next year, and only by uah 300 the minimum pension will rise to 2,300, excuse me, how to live on these funds, and this is the biggest thing that we argued and convinced the ministry of finance that the real living wage, according to the calculations of specialists in social policy changes, is approximately 9,000 hryvnias, how to live for people, this is the first, second , what, after all, when we say that for promotion to the sector of veterans' protection - it is true, but 3 billion with something for the creation of a new service, which, by the way, there is still no understanding of what it will be, who it will serve. except for the common names, and we expect that the closest after all one of these days there will be a question hour for the government and the minister of veterans affairs will explain how, in fact, why there are so few funds for the purchase

of housing for the military, and other things, why 57 billion for internally displaced persons, and not more, as my colleague said, i agree, this it was not the first time that the prime minister was not present at the presentation of the foundations... the state budget , how is that possible, moreover, i spoke about this to the minister of finance today, why do they not foresee negotiations with the international monetary fund with a request for a write-off altogether debts, these are force majeure conditions, many states use this, and i'm sorry, almost a fourth part is debt repayment, debt service, that is, there are a lot of questions regarding the professionalism of the preparation. this bill, although it is important that it was still approved and we as the opposition faction , we did not prevent it, but the voting, but we expressed our position, a very difficult, extremely difficult budget, how

to implement it, 40, more than 40 billion, we are waiting for a loan, the minister of finance himself, in an interview with one of the publications, said that it will be very it is difficult for the partners to fulfill their obligations, although we are grateful to them that this year is the second year we are living thanks to the support of the united states, the international monetary fund, our european partners, and we hope that next year will be the same, and there is still a positive thing, that next year's budget foresees at least indexation of pensions in march, it is also important that we managed to defend it. mr. olezh, representatives of the opposition say that there are certain gaps in the budget, or something is missing, european

solidarity abstained during the vote, what do you say about the budget, the main financial document for the next year, i.e. what do you like about it, what do you not like about it, and what could be a different budget, the state for the next year in conditions of war, and the question, you said the opposition, representatives of the opposition, listen, well, there is a monopoly, if there is a monopoly, then everyone else is in the opposition, sorry, the confusion of the government and everything that is happening ended on february 24, as far as i remember, what we talked with representatives of other factions and they are this agreed that there is no position after february 24, if something has changed, then tell me so that i know who is in our opposition, mr. mykhailo, you are in the opposition, well, i want to tell you, then according to your logic, it was necessary to form a national government agreement, and then each of the opposition leaders would take responsibility and a certain part of the work, by the way, they did it.

i heard correctly, mr. mykhalo, we have, i heard correctly , mr. mykhalo, we have an opposition, thank you very much, ms. maria, you have the same position, but excuse me, but who moderates here and who is responsible for it you want to answer, well, then, it’s clear then, what does it mean that you don’t want to answer , mr. oleg, you don’t manipulate, because i’m sorry, you have a monomajority, you have all law enforcement agencies appointed, you completely control everything, and sorry, you took over. an example is also in israel, and they would see and listen to biden's speech again and maybe draw some conclusions, and maybe sometimes they would listen to the opposition, to the opposition's amendments, to professional proposals, to mature proposals, mrs. maria, i heard everything, that is we really have everything things have changed, we now have the opposition, the homeland and, i will say now, look, you

have all the power in the country, yours is political. power, the representatives of your political power have all the power, absolutely, everyone who is outside the power, outside the central authorities, outside the government, so they are in the opposition and this is absolutely normal, that is, they oppose you, but they are also representatives of the power, that's why when you say who is the opposition and who is the government, you are just manipulating and just manipulating, no, come on then, look, i agreed with you, if we didn't have the february 24th war, and after february 24th and martial law, from my point of view, i could be wrong, from my point of view a lot has changed, but i understand the point that if a person does not have a position in the government, then it is automatically the opposition, this opinion has the right to exist, let's go back to the budget, of course there is no ideal budget at all , well, it does not exist, there will always be people, someone is satisfied, someone is dissatisfied, but this budget, if you look very carefully, it is

somewhere half formed on account financing of our western partners, our creditors, our allies, call it what you want, and when the budget is formed , this budget is certainly with them, taking into account it, their contribution to this budget, agrees with them, i think that no one from the opposition, which today called herself that, no person from the opposition would ever say that the representatives of the united states , great britain or germany do not understand budgets, do not understand numbers, do not understand the financial component, of course they do, it is with them agree it is impossible to make a better budget, do i like everything about this budget? of course not, well absolutely not, but i understand the existing state of things and the need to coordinate it with these partners, from my side , for example, i would increase the part on the informational super, because we underestimate the informational propaganda campaign taking into account what will happen now, for example, in the countries of our partners in western europe, how russia will further deepen its information search. company to

shake them up, and in this case we must give repel this and repel this and fight with them on equal terms, and this requires additional funding, but it is so, if the situation changes, accordingly , there will be changes to the state budget, let me tell you, as a person who is in touch with of the information sphere, look, you put in a single telethon presenters who were presenters on the medvedchuk tv channel, and you say, and now we will defeat everyone, because they are such, such a good telethon, and we will take 2 billion uah and invest there, you understand, but three tv channels that have been switched off from digital broadcast espresso, whatever we're on now , fifth and direct, we've switched off digital because it 's interfering with something, no one can explain why it happened, but well, well, that's what happened, everyone else just .

they simply take and distribute state funds among themselves, or the state has distributed funds between them, that is, when you conduct information policy, you must understand, and why you are doing it, if you want to compete with russia, then make foreign language normal, and work for the west , work for russia, tell them what is happening here in ukraine, and it turns out like this, well, forgive this profanity, i can answer, yes, look, i am very glad that you understand the importance of informational resistance and struggle and funding, i very much agree with you in this case, what is needed to increase, regarding presenters, well, look, there are different situations, for example, those presenters who worked on medvedchuk channels, or those employees who worked on those medvedchuk channels, by the way, there are direct, and were on direct, there are different situations, so we yes let's just say that in our country, for example, the direct or the fifth, they do not correspond to the statesman's position, because some, people

who just earn money, they work there, probably not, you have to look at their professionalism as well, let's say yes, on their effectiveness, do they exist? or now for an effective telethon or propaganda company of ukraine? of course not, it is necessary to improve and increase funding, and here i completely agree with you, let's do it, mr. serhii, to add according to the report of the european commission regarding the beginning of our negotiations, well, i'm just listening to oleg's panels and i'm surprised, because it was the european union that financed the reform of our information space as well, and not in any democratic country. there is no oligarchic channel financed from the state budget, there is no such thing, you understand, that is, the policy must be completely different, i am speaking now, it is possible, i will finish as you say, and when you talk about the opposition, when you talk about the opposition, then we definitely not in opposition to ukraine, but we are in opposition to stupidity and corruption, and believe me, we are very

we want ukraine to definitely win with you, mr. olesha, and with zelsky, but that , when it does not win, it does not become an authoritarian regime for belarus. what you are doing now, we have to take a short break, excuse me, mr. oleg, i have to take a technical break, because i have a regulation, you have a regulation in the verkhovna rada, we should just go for a short break, excuse me , why am i here, i have sensitive teeth, eating ice cream, pain. cold air - pain, sweet, pain. the dentist prescribed lacalot sensitive, which effectively reduces tooth sensitivity if i had known lakal sensitives earlier, i wouldn't have had to come here at all. lacalot - reliable protection against pain. pain can become an obstacle. walk up the stairs, not with my knees. for pain in

the knees, try dolgit cream. kremgit relieves pain, reduces swelling and improves joint mobility. with dolgit cream. dolgit chips - the only yellow cream for pain in the joints with muscle spasms, dolgit anti-spasm tablets , dolgit anti-spasm tablets for muscle and calf relaxation. laughter, physical activity, sneezing. even during such a small time stress, urinary incontinence can make itself felt. feminost uro helped me. thanks to its natural ingredients, feminost uro helps restore control over urination both during the day and at night. oro femininity. urination under control. ask at pharmacies. nose treatment, let's start with washing, and first to the nose, of course, maridose. there are discounts on maridoza, 20% in pharmacies, plantain, bam and savings. what, vasya , i drank an antibiotic, i took an antibiotic, i drank probiz, gavrila, you are also sick, bad, i drank an antibiotic, i drank probiz in your stomach, i was flying,

i was flying, but a cough stopped me, a cough is a symptom of a respiratory disease, so we treat it respiratoryly, we do inhalation. lord hyal is an inhalant for cough. lords a direct way to remove sputum, there are discounts on karsil 15% in pharmacies plantain, pam and savings, bleeding and inflammation of the gums, my advice, lacquer active. lakalut-active actively overcomes bleeding gums, protects against periodontitis and visibly tightens the gums. lakalut active - an action that you feel immediately. new lakalut active plus with two-phase technology and a plus of active ingredients. for even more active protection, lakalut active plus. greetings, this is svoboda live on radio svoboda. we have already come to the snake itself. the following shots may shock you. news from the scene. live kamikaze drone attacks. political analytics, objectively and meaningfully. there is

no political season, exclusive interviews, reports from the hottest points of the front. shot. freedom. frankly and

unbiased, you draw your own conclusions. friends, we are live. telekanaluso, this is the verdict program, we are visiting today online, however, mykhailo tsimbalyuk, maria ionova, oleg dunda, we already started talking about tv channels before our break, and oleg dunda wanted to add to what he already said about the financing of a single telethon, which includes a pool of tv channels owned by the rich, the ukrainian rich , and they will now receive from next year. for financing from the state budget in the amount of uah 2 billion. please, mr. oleg. you and i talked about the propaganda of information in response to

the struggle, i will remind you that there was also a statement that the european union supports, let's say, slightly different principles regarding the creation of an information field. i want to remind, and still ask, in which country the struggle is going on and the issue of survival and statehood is at stake. probably, there is no such thing in any country. ago. i'm sorry, in this case we have to make decisions on our own, by the way, just like on the issue of political lustration, because, for example, the venice commission or the european commission there can tell us that it may be inappropriate to conduct political lustration in ukraine now, but that's all after all , the threat of statehood in our country is much higher than conditional on the czech republic or belgium, they, yes, i was in brussels yesterday, they sometimes absolutely do not understand what threats we face, and yet here we must make decisions on our own, because it is not for them to lose statehood, for us, accordingly, these decisions, even if they sometimes don't like it, nevertheless we need to accept it for

what it is for, so that our state wins this war, and we have the next elections after the victory, as the opposition representatives want, and about the elections in my opinion you spoke and your representatives, foreign affairs of ukraine, dmytro kuleba, said a week ago that he does not rule out that next year... there will be elections, but we do not know how to hold them, and only after that mr. zelenskyy made a statement that not until elections now, well, let's be, and now let's remind as representatives, as representatives of the opposition, who admitted themselves, how they shook up this topic, like fakes, tried to do it, and regarding the elections, believe me, mr. serhiy, i would be glad if we would have elections tomorrow, for one simple reason, because i understand and am aware that any election in our country will be held after victory. accordingly, if the elections are tomorrow, then we have already won, therefore, if kuleba believes that elections are possible next year, it was necessary to ask, and

when these elections will be held after the victory, accordingly, he would have approved, yes, after the victory, and he is sincere in this believes, well then you ask, this is your minister of foreign affairs , you appointed him, mr. serhiy, mr. serhiy, we do not have your or our ministers, he is the minister of ukraine, ukrainian, he is as mine as yours, good, good, but is there corruption in ukraine? or ours, that is, if there is a monopoly, and the monopoly controls everything, then to whom are the claims of the european community, regarding the strengthening of the fight against corruption, to all those who are engaged in it, accordingly we will hunt out corruption and we will plant it, this is not a question of bodies, it is the question is not only before, look, i don't want to report to the european union, i want to report to our ukrainians, and this is our task, despite what the europeans say, and we will build our the state, as it is necessary for our ukrainians, for our citizens and for our victory, and not because the europeans

are talking about it, well, excuse me, well, we have to live, after all, live our own lives, the money is not given to us by the europeans, we will not listen to them , i understand, mr. mykhailo, you have the floor, first of all , freedom of speech is an important requirement not only of our european partners, but also of ukrainian society, and it is important to comply, although i agree that there should be information. hygiene and not we should not forget that we are still in conditions wars and information resistance, information security is also one of, one of the aspects of our defense, and here it is important that we oppose the enemy together, as for anti-corruption bodies, the fight against corruption, then indeed this is also a requirement not only of our european partners , as they finance and provide funds for the implementation of these reforms, as well as the demand of ukrainian

society, and it is not for nothing that our people pose one of the problems, except... er, victory in the war, they still pose corruption. corruption exists not only in ukraine, in many states, but i emphasize once again, here it is important, defending national interests , to remember that we want to join the european community for a reason, we want european values ​​to be in ukraine, i agree with my colleague that we have to go our own way , but when we ask, to - a single, community where values ​​are professed, when we want, and our goal is enshrined in the constitution, that is membership in nato, then these values ​​are also enshrined there, and it is important for everyone to remember that whether

the government, or the opposition, i agree here, here we are melons and the adoption of bills related to these requirements, whether the conditions of our partners are voted by both the government and the opposition, thank you, mr. mykhailo, we don't have much time left, ms. maria, please have a minute, thank you, thank you, on in conclusion, i would say that in fact , during the revolution of dignity, our society determined the euro-atlantic path, and politicians are obliged to fulfill the will of the voters, and not to forget those people, including those who died during the revolution of dignity, and who are already dying... a year from russian aggression just because we we really want to become a european country and a member of nato, and that is why i would strongly advise politicians to read the 152 -page european commission report, which states that the role of the parliament has also been reduced, and that

the coverage should be more objective, this is also a democracy, and we all realize what censorship is like in wartime... there is no reason to give skeptics from those countries in the european union who do not want to see us in the european union, to send deputies on professional business trips, where to work for levels of bilateral relations and to strengthen the policy of the president, the government of our country, the armed forces, so that the financial assistance continues, so that the weapons are increased, so that the sanctions are strengthened, because we will not solve this internally in the country, and this... unity is not in words, in action, and please believe me, there must be an adult policy, an adult, because we are dealing with the survival of our country, not populism, i am very grateful to mr. mykhailo, who mentioned the enshrining of the euro-atlantic course in the constitution in the previous convocation, and we thank to all, from the president

poroshenko to civil society, to the ukrainians who supported it in principle, so do not stop the path to european integration, mr. serhiy, i apologize, and then we see your thanks, and then we see in the washington post the statements of gerashchenko and honcharenko that it is necessary to consolidate the demarcation zone and the new minsk agreements. thank you, well that's something you're saying, sorry, the end of the program, it's not clear to me, i didn't read it, so i'll drop the link, yes, please, thank you, ladies and gentlemen, for participating in the program, mykhailo tsymbalbalyuk. maria ionova and oleg duda were guests of our program, during the program we conducted a survey , we asked you about this, friends, whether there is a place for mps from opzh in the current government, according to the results of our telephone survey, yes 6%, no, 94%, over 1,400 people voted by phone and over 800 people voted on youtube. friends, we put an end to

today's verdict, tomorrow there will be a new verdict, and it will start at 8 p.m. 0:0 please follow our broadcast, we remain on the air, i wish everyone good health, take care of yourself and your family , goodbye, why am i here, i have sensitive teeth, i eat ice cream, pain, cold air, pain, sweet, the dentist thinned the lacquer sensitive, which effectively reduces the sensitivity of the teeth. if i had known the lacquer sensitive earlier, i wouldn't have had to come here at all. lacalot sensitive - reliable protection against pain. pain can become an obstacle. walk up the stairs, not with my knees. for pain in the knees, try dolgit cream. long-acting cream relieves pain, reduces swelling and improves joint mobility.