[000:00:00;00] the national olympic committee, i think that in advance, on the eve of the olympic games in paris, it will be good to concentrate its attention on the preparation of the national team, specifically for the olympic games, so i wish personally and we, the chrop committee, wished him success in this endeavour. the committee on youth and sports, based on the results of the review, decided to recommend the verkhovna rada to decide on the statement of the minister of youth and sports of ukraine khutsait vadym markovych about the resignation, voting at the plenary session of the verkhovna rada of ukraine. thank you all for your attention. thank you, please sign up, two for, two against.

please, venislavsky servant of the people. i would like to pass the floor to hryshchuk, hryshchuk, please, and proshchuk, i apologize, yes, please eduard proshchuk, good afternoon to everyone, dear vadim markovych, to vadim markovych, he is busy communicating with our colleagues, first of all i wanted to say that this is a good practice when we are able to see the minister. not only at the beginning, when we appoint him, but we have the opportunity when a person has decided that he is completing his activity in this position, we have the opportunity to communicate, to see, i would like this practice to be adopted by all our honorable government officials whom we appoint, actually hire, dear vadim markovich, i want to thank you for your work, i want

to thank you for that we passed together with you as a parliament, i want to thank you for the successes we had at the olympic games in tokyo, at the third european games, it was also very significant, very symbolic, because during the war to take the overall third place, it well, definitely a great success. certainly, ukrainian athletes are excellent ambassadors of our country, the sports front is extremely important, it is very important that our athletes have... during the war the opportunity to perform on the international stage, the national anthem is played, the flag of our country is raised, and this is one of the signs that we are, were and will be a strong, infamous country, so in the future i wish you success in your new endeavor, that you concentrate, as was correctly said by the previous speaker at the activities of the olympic committee, next year is the olympic year, it is very important that our

the national team in all types of sports was represented as much as possible, we won a large number of licenses and represented ukraine with dignity at the olympic games in paris, so thank you for your work, glory to ukrainian sports, glory to ukraine, glory to the heroes, thank you, european solidarity is great. i would like to give the floor to oleksiy honcharenko. please, oleksiy oleksiyovych. glory to ukraine, dear colleagues, in accordance with the resolution adopted by us on some issues of organizing the work of the verkhovna rada of ukraine of the 9th convocation under the conditions of martial law, today we continue our plenary

session, dear colleagues. according to the parliamentary tradition, i propose to start the work with the performance of the national anthem of ukraine and glory to us, ukrainian brothers , fate will smile on us. our witches will perish like millet in the sun, i will rule my brothers in my shirt,

we will lay down our soul and body for ours. heard freely, and we will show that we are brothers, cossacks. we will lay down our family, soul, and body for our freedom and show that we are brothers, cossacks, glory to ukraine. 624 days of heroic resistance of the ukrainian people to the criminal russian aggression. the defense forces courageously repulse the constant attacks of the enemy and continue the offensive operation in the south

of our country, inflicting significant losses in manpower and military equipment to the invaders. i propose to honor the bright memory of our soldiers who died in the fight for a free, democratic, european ukraine, as well as all those who were not victims of the crimes

of the terrorist russian state, with a moment of silence. dear mps, yesterday the european commission presented its annual report, the 2023 enlargement package. for ukraine, the key an element of this document was the recommendation of the european commission, addressed to the european council, to start negotiations with ukraine on joining the european union. a decision that we have all been waiting for, for which we have been working for the past year and a half since ukraine acquired the status of a candidate country. i believe that yesterday was both an objective achievement of ukraine and recognition of the achievements of our verkhovna rada.

therefore, i thank all of you in this room for fruitful and coordinated work. she was not simple. we had to make difficult decisions with you. but in the end, we made significant progress in implementing the recommendations of the european commission. as we were told yesterday, we must understand that the reforms we implement for european integration are primarily reforms we implement for ukraine, which we ourselves need, and which ukrainian society is waiting for. our goal is membership in the european union. let's once again thank our defenders, thanks to whom we have the opportunity to gather and work on european laws. we thank the defense forces, they are one of the main participants and integration of ukraine, dear colleagues, soon in december the leaders of the member states will

make a political decision regarding the opening of negotiations. we are convinced that yesterday's recommendation will be decisive in making a political decision. in the coming weeks, all our diplomatic and other efforts must be directed towards this positive solution. there is a lot of work ahead, the start of negotiations will require additional efforts from ukraine, including from the verkhovna rada. we are already studying the recommendations that were given yesterday and are preparing further steps, in particular those bills that we will discuss with you here, you and i have proven that we can work quickly, efficiently, even in conditions of extraordinary challenges, work as a team of like-minded people. once again, i congratulate all of us on yesterday's important event and call for joint work for the realization of our common goal, membership. in the european union. dear colleagues, today is also a very important milestone: 28 years ago, on november 9-9, 1995, the ceremony of ukraine's accession to the council of europe took place. this significant event outlined the vector

of democratic choice of our state. in that day ukraine undertook to adhere to the principle of the rule of law, to ensure the fundamental rights and freedoms of all people under the jurisdiction of the council of europe. just then to strasbourg. square, the state flag of ukraine was raised, and now ukraine is bravely demonstrating its commitment to these principles, protecting the democracy of the whole world, let's congratulate ukraine, the council of europe on the fact that we have been together for 28 years. also, today is the day of cultural workers and masters of folk art, dear colleagues, a sense of national dignity and awareness of one's identity, preservation of cultural traditions, these things are very important for any nation, through their activities cultural workers ensure the stability of the development of ukrainian culture and its spread outside ukraine, now in wartime their mission to inspire and support our soldiers during their service has acquired special importance . on behalf of the verkhovna rada, we congratulate the workers of culture

and masters of folk art on their professional holiday, wish them creative success, inexhaustible energy, and, like all ukrainians , the fastest victory. thank you to the employees cultures and now to business, colleagues, signal vote. according to article 28 of the regulations of the verkhovna rada. of ukraine before the start of consideration of the issues, i propose to hold a signal vote. i would like to remind you that, when receiving the touch button, you must press the green button for and receive these two buttons at the same time before the end of voting, that is, before the results appear on the scoreboard. please take part in the signal vote.

214 green, one red, four red, two yellow, signal, yes, sergey volodymyrovych, dear colleagues, we did not start yesterday, that's why i want us to go into draft law number 1006d, the draft law on amendments to the tax code and other laws of ukraine regarding the cancellation of the moratorium on tax audits. we will have up to half an hour of speeches and discussion of amendments, and then we will vote, so please plan your time. and then we start the discussion, we have dmytro oleksandrovich razunkov, the first edit, please, 15 minutes, 15 minutes of brains, please.

thank you, dear colleagues, thank you, oleksandr sergeyevich, i never get tired of repeating, thanks to your work, the work of olena kostivna, we finally see people in the hall , i hope they will also vote, and voting for this shameful law can still be called legitimate, but it is definitely not in the interests of the state, which speaks to the ukrainian people. society law 1016 states that, unfortunately, you cannot trust the authorities, and this lesson will be learned by both the ukrainian people and ukrainian business. everyone remembers the beginning of the war. at the beginning of the war, all the authorities, realizing that the state is in trouble, that no one understands what will happen tomorrow, all the political elites, who are in this hall, united to support not politics, to support

the people, to support the army, to provide for the army, and for this it was necessary for the economy to work. at that time, the president, the cabinet of ministers, the verkhovna rada of ukraine, all officials promised new rules of relations, honest, transparent, constructive, predictability. this was promised again, but again not fulfilled. ukrainian business was abandoned again because they promised to introduce low taxes and no inspections until the end of the war, plus at least one year after our victory, maybe for someone we have already won, or we have a different vision of what a ukrainian victory is, nevertheless, they first canceled 10, 8401, which canceled taxes. minimum taxes for ukrainian business and returned

part of the checks. i remember how representatives of the office, representatives of the monomajority, as the deputy of the president's office, mr. shurma told us that the imf would credit us, and you in this hall voted for a law that violates your own promises, you lied to the business, which began to pay more to the state budget than he did until february 24. how are you then you plan to build this state and restore it during the war and restore it after our victory. i think the question is rhetorical, lack of strategy. this is exactly what you and i will get today, we have turned, in fact, from the parliament of unity, which was on february 24, 2022, into

a parliament of madmen and sane people, but the latter, unfortunately, are much less in this hall, because that , what is happening today is the destruction of the economy. of our state, this is the destruction of small and medium-sized businesses, this is the destruction of businesses that and it barely survives, you did nothing to provide it with loans, you did nothing with the preferential loans that you could give last year, when you received financing from our international partners at a preferential rate, you think one cell at a time , you do not understand that tomorrow after the victory you will have to pay back... the loans that the state collects today, you do not understand that if there is no business, there will be no salaries for our army tomorrow, there will be no shells with which they will destroy the occupier, there will be no resource that will help the country to fight and win the war, you are actually doing everything to

destroy the ukrainian economy, and as a result to destroy the ukrainian army, i understand that many of you do not...' everyone is doing their own thing, it's not about roads and quarries, it's not about 2,000, it's not about many other things that worry the government, it's not about those 42 million that were stolen from the ministry of defense, and everyone in the hall is silent, it's not about those billions , i'm sorry, it's not about the billions that were shared between us and you yesterday and painted over a completely transparent, primitive scheme of how the finances of the state budget are stolen on defense purchases, you would be much more interested in it, i think so, but nevertheless, the accounting chamber directly

accuses the ministries of spending shamefully, it is not clear why are you taking money from the local government? you take money from ukrainian business, you don't care about the billions that you stole for 17 hryvnias per egg, you don't care about the money that went past the ukrainian army, or you don't care about those jackets that were bought at exorbitant prices prices, and today our defenders cannot get a normal winter uniform , and many other examples, it is not enough for you that you have been allocated, but not... resources to secure substations for the eve of winter, this is not enough for you, you want more, you understand that today you are sawing that tree, in fact, on which you are sitting, tomorrow people will come to you for pensions, for the fact that there was heat in

the apartments, there was light, there was water, there was sewage, because shit, sorry for slang in our country. too much today, and this is not about the significant consequences of our life activities, our life activities, we are in a hurry with you today, we are in a hurry, because we are told again that this law will provide some additional resources for our economy, law 1016, i said about it the day before and in the last reading, in the first reading of this law, it gives zero to the ukrainian economy, it puts money into the pockets of tax collectors and those deputies who are connected with it, it puts money into the pockets of those who crush corruption, it puts money into the pockets of those who make money from it , but he does not give anything to the ukrainian economy, i told you in this hall of the same tribune at

84.01, dear colleagues, do not vote for it, it will not give money to the economy, you oppressed zelena without listening to it. but i would like to remind you all, to remind you that this law , as we said, as the smart policy team said, brought to the budget, or rather , perhaps will bring to the budget, this is the information of the ministry of finance, 4.7 billion uah. with the budget in the trillion budget that we have in 2.5 - it's not about anything, it's just not about anything, if you count how many businesses went into the shadows, how many people were dismissed from their positions , how many... enterprises closed, you will actually get a minus, not a plus for financing our economy, you wanted to take away the salaries of the military, we didn't let you do that either and returned 30,000, unfortunately, they are still blocked, ruslan stefanchuk is not here today, i would like to ask him, and the author of the resolution is not there, why it has not yet

been submitted to the walls of the verkhovna rada, they were in such a hurry with the law on oligarchs, yes so it was necessary to quickly vote it in violation of all possible laws. two years have passed, where is the law on oligarchs, where is the register, can it still work on the picture... maybe you need to work for the state, or did you take it solely to block this process and not really fight the oligarchs, or you, now you will say that i am not telling the truth when i said that it is necessary to introduce antitrust legislation, lobbying law, strengthen responsibility for corruption, and this will lead to a real fight against oligarch, no, you voted by paper. which did not give anything to the state, the economy, or the people, but they made a great show of it, now they have

actually received from our international european partners all the demands that i and my colleagues in the field of intelligent politics have said, but you are not listen, you need it to work exclusively in the face-to-face mode . the time of consideration of amendments, etc saturday and other days, and why are there 20 people's deputies in the hall, why is no one working , why, why is there such an attitude towards the laws that are adopted, you don't need to hurry, you need to have quality, you need to have a strategy in what you adopt, how you work and who do you work for, stop working for yourself, you and i can also talk a lot about the principles of many people's deputies in the labki principles in this hall. colleagues, yesterday i put an amendment to the vote: to give

party funding to the armed forces of ukraine, you want to fill the budget, don't you you are doing everything in order to take away local authorities, destroy ukrainian business, well, let's tighten the belts a little for ukrainian parties as well. this year, more than 800 million hryvnias will be given to the party, next year more than 8, for understanding, the servant of the people party, which did not vote for it yesterday, will receive 400 million. colleague, you will not have too much, maybe it would be better to give it to the army, 89 people voted deputies in the hall, i ask everyone to take a look at yesterday's vote, who voted for it, and for whom instead of the army much own party boards are more important, because they were preparing a lot for the elections, i will not return to your question now. fortunately, there is a point in the fact that elections cannot be held during a war, i heard again what

i and my colleagues from the intelligent politics were talking about, this is absolute profanation, this is an attempt to usurp power, this is an attempt to transform a democratic state into what is indicated, today we already see the position that this will not happen, we really wanted this position to correspond to the realities, and for tomorrow, so that no one comes out again and does not said that we are again returning to the history of elections, dear colleagues, i understand that you will not vote for the amendments, i will not insist today on returning people to the hall, they are, i hope that you will not have enough votes for this law, i just really hope that common sense and conscience will win over you in front of your chosen voters. at the same time, i would like to put two amendments into consideration, i understand that even you are not listening, but nevertheless, these are amendments on the increase of uah 1 million to uah 1.5 million limits

for income, in which it is mandatory to register the vat payer. this law was adopted in 1 million hryvnias before the exchange rate of the ukrainian hryvnia was 25 hryvnias. today we have 37 with you, well, let's approach it somehow logically, well, not about that... the imf said, let's somehow help ukrainian business, this will be the 224th amendment, and the second amendment, which i would ask you to support in the hall, so that you are consistent, so that you are responsible for your words, although for ukrainian politics, this is unfortunately an exception rather than a reality, so that you they did what they said... at the end of february 24th, when

the enemy was standing under the walls of kyiv, when it was not easy in this hall from a moral point of view, but then it was at least honest, no one understood what would happen tomorrow, no in the hall, not at enterprises , not in erpin, not in buch, not in a guest house, not in izyum, not in many other cities, and then we worked, we worked for the state, and for this state we promised that we would not do to them bad, let's not destroy ukrainians. because when you destroy business, you destroy jobs, you force them to leave the border, to seek a better fate, sometimes, no matter how scary it is to say, one gets the impression that this is done on purpose so that there are no people left in the state who can restore, rebuild and make it successful, so that they all

go to germany, france, to poland even to other countries of the world, instead of staying here. therefore, i urge you to vote for amendment 531. it postpones the introduction of total background checks for ukrainian businesses until the end of the war, plus at least one year after our victory. that's what he promised the president, the leader of your political force. this is exactly what the government promised, this is exactly what you promised, i really hope that reason, common sense, conscience will win in this hall, well , i wanted to believe it, i think that not only me, but the voting results will show it, thank you , dear colleagues, thank you oleksandrovych,

we will make corrections now and then, yes, two. amendments 224-531. colleagues, get ready to vote on the amendment. 224. people's deputy razumkov, i propose to take into account his edit number 224. authorship razumkov, babiya, saladukhy and colleagues. it was rejected by the committee, please vote. for 81 decisions, the amendment remains rejected, and the 531th amendment, also authored by dmytro oleksandrovych and colleagues, was

rejected by the committee. please vote. for 82, no decision was made, the amendment remains rejected. thank you dmytro oleksandrovych. the next one is dmytro seriyovych mykysha, where are you, you are there, yes, you want from the podium, too, please, yes dmytro seriyovych, 5 minutes mykysha. if you make any corrections, tell me its number, okay, then the speech, thank you oleksandr serhiyovych, colleagues, well, you know, this is yet another draft law that gives me the impression that we are taking some kind of revenge and taking revenge on all those who

first of all tried to help ukraine, ukrainian men and women, in the first days of the full-scale invasion. yesterday, and last week, and the week before last, we saw bills 10.038 and 10.037, where they took away absolutely everything that is, almost everything, absolutely everything that is in the local government, free balances, additional funds, yesterday they took away the military pdf, also took money from of the road fund, most of which also goes to local budgets, it is such a thank you to the state, local self-government, which did not abandon citizens in difficult times, today we are considering the next bill, 1016, and what is in it, in it we return tax audits, for whom , for ukrainian entrepreneurs, for ukrainian manufacturers, for

our domestic business. these are precisely those people