[000:00:00;00] the amount of 1.7 three hryvnias is what we have now, it is us, it is much higher than the taxes we collect, it is the amount we cover at the expense of all taxes and at the expense of borrowing, let's imagine that we have there are 17 three hryvnias, let's imagine, this means the following, with the gdp, with the gdp of all, well, next year, 7.8 17 is expected - this means the following, that we need to take another 10 tril hryvnias somewhere. er, it is more than 100% of the gross domestic product. these funds will not appear in any, er, absolutely cosmic, artificial or some magical way, this must also be understood. they can appear only if our domestic product will grow at a fairly

high pace. and we are ready to direct every percent of growth to the security and defense sector, but let's talk about reality, we are now directing all the resources we have to the defense sector, let's make this resource used effectively for its purpose, and we have the appropriate the result achieved on the battlefield, we are doing our best for it, so thank you very much for these suggestions. and we applied this time, this year several amendments were made to the budget, namely the increase of the security and defense sector, there will be a need , we will consider these issues, but first of all, understand correctly, if available, thank you, yes, thank you, serhiy mykhailovych,

thank you for report , the head of the committee of the verkhovna rada of ukraine on budget issues, roksilana andriivna pidlas, is invited to the report to the minister of finance, please, dear chairman, dear people's deputies and dear ukrainians who are watching us in the recording. by law, i have to inform people's deputies that during the preparation of the draft law. on the state budget to the second reading, the cabinet of ministers took into account 20 of the 21st proposals, which were formalized in the form of budget conclusions of the verkhovna rada of ukraine. the principle of budget formation remains unchanged: every ukrainian hryvnia for victory. the 2024 budget

is the budget of a warring country. which has one clear priority: defense. funds for security and defense in the project are fixed at the level of uah 1.690 billion, or 22.1% of gdp, as stipulated by the decision of the national security council and defense, regarding defense financing. thanks to our decision with you in this session hall, at 10:37, by which we directed the military pdf to the state budget until the end of the war. the year 2024 should become a landmark year for the domestic production of weapons. uah 43 billion is proposed to be directed to the production

of drones and anti-drones. systems, almost uah 51 billion will be used for the production of ukrainian-made weapons and shells. both of these programs will give a powerful stimulus to industrial production and contribute to the achievement of almost five percent growth gross domestic product. the second priority is the expenditure part. traditionally social protection remains in the budget. about 470 billion hryvnias are proposed to be directed to the support of ukrainians who have fallen into various difficult life circumstances or have reached retirement age. expenditures for the support of veterans of the ukrainian

-russian war will be doubled and will amount to 15 ml here i want to thank the ministry of finance and all the people's deputies who supported the amendment to redirect half a billion hryvnias from museums to prosthetics of our soldiers in fact, this is not a question of money, but of respect for the people who protect us at the front. before the second reading, the draft budget, the government and the budget committee made several important changes. first, we allocated an additional 1 billion hryvnias to the construction of shelters in hospitals. second, we have increased the funding of the academic scholarship program by uah 500 million so that all students who deserve a scholarship

receive it in 2024. third, we have additionally allocated almost uah 338 million for the treatment of ukrainians from oncological diseases in national cancer institute. finally , the additional two hryvnias will be used for the treatment of servicemen at the feofania departmental hospital. until the second reading, the budget remains balanced and realistic, therefore, the budget committee recommends that the verkhovna rada of ukraine adopt the amended draft law of 10,000 in the second reading and as a whole, taking into account the proposals of the committee with the additions given in the letter... conclusions of the committee dated 4 and on november 8, i am asking you to support the state budget for 2024. thank you roklana andriivna. please

people's deputies to write down questions to the chairman of the committee. please, european solidarity, savrazu, i ask you to give the floor and dear hiraschentsy, please, iryna geraychenko. thank you, dear ms. roxulano, unfortunately you did not go with us, although we invited you to the front line to meet with the military. sections, then you would personally see how difficult it is today in the bakhmut, avdiiv, and zaporizhia directions, including with the so-called counteroffensive, at this time

a humorous counteroffensive is underway in kyiv, every day quarter 95 comes in the october palace and so on, and you left 440 million in the draft budget for the 24th year for tv series, which the parliament voted in principle for the treatment of our military. how can this be? in israel , the minister of informatics and information resigned from the ministry, he was liquidated and the money was transferred to the army. why in this budget do you support 2 billion for a lying oligarchic marathon. committee on issues. of the budget took into account volodymyr tsabal's amendment from the vote to reduce the budget for the state cinematography agency, on

production of entertainment series, for 445 million hryvnias. the ministry of finance took this amendment into account and noted that the funds of the state cinema, state cinema, or state cinematography agency will be directed to the production of documentary products, films, and tv series about the ukrainian-russian war. the committee supported this proposal of the ministry of finance on repurposing and changing the purpose of the use of funds, the servant of the people of bakumov, please, dear rukselana andriivna, first of all, i would like to thank you for preparing the state budget to the second reading, this is a really complex and tectonic work that you, together with the members of the committee, have done, but i would like to repeat myself because the minister of finance, unfortunately, who is present in

the government box today, did not answer my question, maybe the chairman of the committee will explain the actions of the government, in particular the ministry of finance, in which way the position of the parliament was ignored in the ukrainian parliament of the verkhovna rada of ukraine, which did not take into account amendment 1262 in the first reading, and therefore the project was supposed to provide for... 120 million in maintenance expenses for the example of the national academy of legal sciences, and before the second reading, the ministry of finance ignored the position of the parliament and still removed 35 million hryvnias from the funding, these are salaries for our scientists, except the committee, here the committee on budget issues, here in the issue of salary calculation fee for various budget institutions

rely on the calculations of the ministry of finance, the calculations that they gave us regarding salaries, the national academy of sciences, required additional funding. you are correct in saying that these are salaries and wages public services, and we in the committee are aware that if the salary is not paid in budget institutions, it will lead to unemployment, highly qualified... workers who will simply be dismissed from the public service, the service for ukrainian science and return to the private sector. i think that it is not appropriate now, and we should preserve our scientific potential for the future. princesses, please, thank you, thank you, dear colleague, i can't see you. but i'm far away from here, please leave,

dear colleague, you answered incorrectly to the question of colleague herashchenko, since the funds allocated for state support of cinematography always finance ukrainian cinema, on the other hand, tv series about povoroznyuks were financed with another article, like the telethon, this article is the production and broadcasting of television and radio programs for state needs, and this article was allocated this year in 2.5 times more than in the past, a billion, 510 million. and it is these funds with a surplus of 196. and it is these funds that should go to support the ukrainian army, to support the ukrainian military, and ultimately to the real propaganda of ukrainian earnings abroad, and not for the production of cheap tv series and the support of a lying marathon, which was condemned in the conclusions of the european commission regarding the recommendations of our accession to the european union, that is what

my colleague dagrashchenko asked you about and i will ask you. thank you for the question, i perfectly understood the question that was asked before and answered it correctly, because in the draft budget for 2024, the funding of series was placed under the state agency for cinematography, that is true, appendix three, i encourage anyone of people's deputies to open appendix three of the state budget and get acquainted with these figures. thank you, the time for questions to the chairman of the committee is over. thank you to roksola andriivna for your comprehensive answers, dear colleagues, please sign up for speeches from the deputies. fractions of groups for three minutes,

please, please, restoration of ukraine, hnatenko, valery. good afternoon, dear chairman, dear attendees, let's start with the positive, and the verkhovna rada finally has a strong tradition of adhering to the calendar schedule for adopting the state budget. necessary it should be noted that over 90%

of the verkhovna rada's proposal was taken into account by the channel in full or in a different version, everything was done to make the budget balanced in the conditions of martial law. the sphere of security and defense, social spending, as well as the life activity of our education in the sphere of health care, these are the three whales of this document. the veterans' policy is also being developed, and funds are being laid for the restoration of our economy. at the same time, let's be realistic, our own incomes today are entirely and completely going in the direction of security, and the marginal deficit reaches more than 15 hryvnias. we are grateful to our partners in the world for systematic financial support in this difficult time. we expect that in the end we will be able to attract uah 41 billion in foreign aid already next year. today, we must do everything to prevent misuse of funds for or overestimation of public procurement in

areas ranging from the army to reconstruction projects. the fight against corruption must be strengthened, any corruption is treason. in the budget for the 24th year the following expectation is laid: a two-stage increase in the minimum wage from uah 6,700 to uah 800. the subsistence menu for all categories is increasing. mandatory automatic indexation of pensions will be carried out in the spring. all this is included in the budget for next year. expenditures for subsidies are increasing, assistance for all internally displaced persons is maintained. this draft budget cannot be called ideal in any case. this document is about the survival of our state in the conditions of war. at the same time, we are laying the foundation for our further reconstruction and transformation. always

you can find something to criticize, but we will not find a better estimate in the current conditions. deputy. the ukraine recovery group will support this budget and will put it to a vote. thank you. thank you. european solidarity nina petrivna yuzhanina. dear colleagues, dear ukrainians, what are the problems of the draft state budget. of ukraine for 2024, first of all, it is the insecurity of the income part, from the very first reading, we also have the conclusions of our accounting chamber, that the macro forecast is based on significant assumptions, and this to us very clearly demonstrated

the draft budget prepared for the second reading, when the figures changed significantly, and at the same time, for example, the negative balance of the trade balance doubled. which led to recalculations of the increase in revenue from import vat and import duty, as well as other indicators , which you know, took place in an arbitrary form, you can say such changes, the budget in general , the word balance reminded me of a rubber toy, yes, everything can be balanced, only how real figures that are indicated in this budget. balance is again means going to that budget deficit, which is slightly reduced, but it is more than one and a half trillion, and when we talk about whether there will be enough external and internal borrowing, and when we have the figures that the minister of finance has already announced, regarding which there are difficulties, if you convert these billions into

hryvnias, billions of dollars into hryvnias, then we may have close to one trillion unsecured. with a deficit of 15. i am very impressed by what we say, say, when we talk about reducing money for the army, we again give some explanations, incomprehensible and those that are not correspond to reality, because when we add the money that will be taken from local budgets to two ministries, the others to strategprom and dssti, then we reduce the ministry of defense itself. but don't forget, the number of troops is increasing in our country, we are talking about increasing monetary support, we have adopted a number of laws on the return of thirty and other payments, so how can we reduce, literally, the amount compared to 2023 , the fact that the increase security

agencies instead of financing the armed forces can be listed, and these are specific figures that are in the state budget. it seems that if we now had the opportunity to analyze all the articles of the textual, textual part of the state budget, you should concentrate that according to article 45 of the state budget, you know, this kind of revenge against local self-government is a hook from which the disobedient will not be able to jump off , and when the ministry of finance prescribed this article, i think, well, you should not lie. thank you, koltunovych oleksandr serich platform for life and peace. thank you dear. dear colleagues, our group will support the military budget for the 24th year,

well, as an alternative, period, further, look at the macro-economic macro and monetary architecture, which was partially modified, but the fragmentary changes that were made, they do not globally solve the financial and budgetary collapse that we have in the country, the first most important moment - two key figures of the state budget. the first figure is that with expenditures of uah 3.3, we have borrowings of uah 2.2. 67% of the budget is covered by borrowing expenses, these are two key figures that characterize this state budget. uah 1.7 is military the budget, of course, these are obvious things, so this figure is supported, further, see what concerns the expenditure part, appendix two, uah 620... 7 billion for repayment of state and state-guaranteed debt, for maintenance in appendix 3, uah 420 billion,

that is, we give more than 1 trillion hryvnias to service and repay the state debt. that is why the government's actions to restructure public debt payments are so important. we have a place to spend this money. further, i cannot help but pay attention to the specific points of the budget tax policy, to the deposit certificates for tax exemption. ovdp, without limitation of minimum wages, not minimum, or rather, excess vip wages for members of supervisory boards. all this remained and i think that it will be necessary to level it. further, the level of the minimum pension in ukraine remains critically low. even if we take the new dollar rate, which was set at 38 hryvnias, 60 kopecks, it is 61 dollars. we are 10 years old in 2013. back it was 119 dollars, twice the level of the pension in dollar equivalent, according to the purchasing power of pensioners. it

it is also necessary to equalize and bring it up to the minimum wage. next, what i want to say is that we definitely need a new adaptive macroeconomic and monetary model in order to solve and settle the issue of reducing the budget deficit, which amounts to 1.6 three hryvnias. in the conditions of the staflation debt crisis. it is extremely necessary to take into account and make changes to this draft law on the state budget in the 24th year and to take into account the risks that the national bank says about, including the first, a decrease in foreign exchange earnings from exports in as a result of the embargo by the countries of the european union. the second is the rise in energy prices. next, an important point is the failure to obtain additional loans, i asked this question and so on. therefore, then integrated macroeconomic and monetary. it will be competitive, and the budget, homeland,

mykha tsymbalyuk, mykhailo tsymbalyuk, homeland, dear mr. chairman, presidium, dear people's deputies, this is the draft of the second budget during large-scale aggression, and the first amount of expenditure, of course, the defense sector. the second is social policy, i would like to to focus on social expenses, which , for the sake of justice, should be noted, increased by 25 billion. but when analyzed, there is actually something to think about. uah 2,000,920 is a living wage, i would like to ask

the leadership of the ministry of finance, on what basis they formed such a figure, by the way, on which several dozen other payments depend, how can you live on uah 2,920. and the minimum pension will increase by only 300. with a penny, this is actually a problem, even understanding the conditions of large-scale aggression. next, colleague, by the way, i thank kucherenko, a colleague, a colleague from the faction, who gave me the floor , he and i discussed local budgets, yesterday the funds for the month of october were taken or withdrawn, this is also nonsense, when the law does not have retroactive effect. amine.

but how could it be possible to withdraw funds and today demand that local budgets continue to be able to... critical infrastructure, water canals, other facilities that have practically become unprofitable, the budget does not include a single penny for repayment of the difference in tariffs, which are growing, there are definitely questions in this regard. next, dear colleagues, when we talk about the budget, 57 billion at the expense of the internally displaced, is it a lot or a little, well, of course, there is no understanding when these people will return to their homes and losses, will lose the status of internally displaced, because of this, these funds will have to be added during the year , clarifying the budget, and in conclusion, the previous ones talked

about how much we still have a problem with repaying or servicing the debt, and whether the ministry of finance is talking with the imf about restructuring and debt cancellation in general. chevrons approaching victory. russia continues to commit the most brutal crime against ukraine. the war continues on the sports front as well. at every competition, ukrainian athletes express their position. do not shake hands with a russian athlete,

raise a poster - no, the war in ukraine is ours. appeal to the sports community: yes, we risk disqualification and our careers, but this is nothing compared to the pain and the price ukrainians pay every day. for us , the most important thing is the victory of ukraine and the preservation of lives. while russian and belarusian athletes with their participation in competitions intensify the propaganda of a bloody war, ukrainian athletes die on the battlefield, or, returning home with victories, see ruined houses and destinies. i call on the sports community to act and prevent terrorist athletes from international sports. it's long overdue, time to act, silence kills. this story is about the occupation of kherson region. residents of the kherson region saw endless columns

of enemy vehicles entering from the crimea. and people who did not wait. at the invaders, they loaded him onto petr and took him somewhere, i was walking along the path, a tank was coming at me, who were behind one step away from death, and he was running at the age of 76, and the one with the machine gun was behind him and shouted, i will shoot you, but they did not despair and fought for their lives, people began to be transported by a regime boat to re-trials, they waited for ukrainian military documents... november 12 at 10:15 p.m., exclusively, on the air of edinye novyn. we follow the main events of ukraine and the world every hour on the air of single news. only up-to-date and verified

information so that you are informed... live news in a single telethon every hour i am a russian warship, i offer to put weapons and surrender, military ship, glorified in the snow for fate, our little eyes will change like