[000:00:00;00] spheres, because there will always be shortages in all spheres, however, when adopting the actual plan of action , the budget for the next year, we should talk about two things, about the money that comes in, will come in the next year, and about expenses, and about the receipts, it is clear that here it is necessary to turn to our international partners from this platform, with words of thanks for their support in this, last year, with words... a request for financial support in the next budget year, because this is very, very important for all social payments in our the country we should also thank those ukrainians who remained, officially work in ukraine, officially pay taxes , despite the fact that the verkhovna rada arranges additional inspections for them, despite the fact that it

is probably not easy to earn these funds today, but there are a certain tax base, thanks to which we can go to both the state and local budgets, and clearly, i want to emphasize once again that it was an absolutely wrong decision to take all revenues from the military pdf from local budgets, and therefore i want to believe that providing the ukrainian soldier with weapons, we will not allow local education and local culture to decline. and today, on the day of culture of workers of ukrainian culture, i will wholeheartedly win, and therefore i want to say that, after all , local self-government bodies are not forgotten by the cabinet of ministers, you and we, together with them, gave the communities the opportunity to pass the basic level next year, so we can help to the ukrainian soldier, so that everyone together

waits for this desired day of victory, with faith in god, in the armed forces of ukraine, in people and in victory, let's move on to speeches by people's deputies, please sign up for speeches by people's deputies for up to 6 minutes. come on, please. natalya igorivna, dear colleagues, today we heard speeches from groups, from the ministry , and from the committee, of course, this draft budget, which we will vote on today, has many very shortcomings, of course, i will not list them all, but this budget

does not even provide for it. for the next year , funds for the restoration of the losses caused by russian aggression to ukraine. in this last year there was a special fund in which there were specific funds for this program, in the next year there is none, but this is not the main, not the main drawback, the main drawback is that 42 billion dollars were stolen, so we understand that this is a war and god grant to all our leaders to plug this hole and find it. brahar yevhen vladymovych. servant of the people. brahar yevhennii, please give the floor to pavlo soshko. pavlo sashko, please. pavlo mykolavych congratulations, dear colleagues, and i would like to say that

no funds have been allocated in this budget. for the rehabilitation of children with disabilities, and that's a lot badly. our bulk chamber is publishing today a report on the use of funds, on means of rehabilitation, on prostheses that were used in violation, and so on. we need to carefully study this report, how it is used, how the funds are used, how the funds are used by the ministry of finance, and in general, in order to draw up... this budget, we need to travel around the communities a little and talk to people, and i am very grateful for solid fuel, because the pension belongs to the people today it is 2,500, and firewood costs 36,000 for the winter, so it has been increased more than 2.5 times, times, and it is very good, but i would like another such, such colleagues give you an example, we are often reproached in the communities

that you have appointed officials, and today you have no influence on them, i want to give the example of mr. balakhivets, who heads the chief forester of ukraine, and people say, well, the pension is small in us, this ok, but please tell me, why do you have a forest, a log is lying in the woods, rotting , simply, it is rotting, for whom it is lying there , would be distributed to people, as supermarkets distributed food, just at the beginning of a full-scale invasion, distributed, in order to people did not die of hunger, but today people have no way to take this dead land that is lying around, and you know that the balochivtsi answers, he answers that it is for bugs and this forest is lying down, rotting there and says that this is the only parliament, who didn't do anything, so colleagues, at a time when the european commission says that this parliament really worked very well, the chief forester

accuses us of not doing anything, both for the people and, and i'll tell you what we did, for - first, we appealed to the government and the government responded, subsidies are real the result, our colleagues and you, has been doubled, almost... more than twice, so i want to also appeal to the government, using the opportunity to work with mr. bolakhivts, so that he, as the main stakeholder of these woods, does something to ensure that they are not there rotted in the forest, thank you, honcharenko, oleksiy oleksiyovych , european solida, iryna volodymyrivna, gerashchenko, please, dear colleagues, we are considering the main economic law of the country for next year. according to the long-standing parliamentary tradition , the prime minister was always here. where is he now maybe we have the new prime minister is mrs. roksolana pidlas. in fact, this is evidence of

the attitude of the cabinet of ministers to parliament, which did not submit the budget of a warring country. because if there remains an increase in the funding of the prosecutor's office and other law enforcement agencies, i want to remind you that it is not the prosecutors who will go on the counter-nav. because if there remains a serial counteroffensive, a marathon counteroffensive, for which you allocate 440 million, 2 billion for the rada channel , another 200 million that are not shown by the parliament and where presenters from the medvedchuk channel work, you have there are absolutely shameful articles of an attack on decentralization, which does not correspond not only to the budget of a warring country, but also to the budget of a country that is joining the european union. after all, the eu is a strong region, you have about 60 billion of funds there, these are floating funds, not confirmed by anything, because you have already invested money from the military pdf in this draft budget, although

the corresponding draft law has not yet been adopted, it is not fixed, this is a violation of the constitution , and believe me we will go to the constitutional court about how you destroy decentralization by spitting on our commitments regarding accession to the eu. you destroy our obligations according to the copenhagen criteria, when you pledge funds to oligarchic tv channels, if brussels very clearly told you: fight the oligarchs, not feed them out of your hand, you give taxes that are paid, including by the military, to oligarchic tv channels, you're putting billions into investment nannies again, instead of creating equal rules for all businesses, and that's after you return the checks, on business, so of course we're holding off on that, the draft budget, of course we we will monitor how you spend these funds, and you know, when you turn to the event with a request to provide financial assistance to ukraine,

you hear a very fair answer: on military rails, why today and until now you have not created the enterprises that are supposed to produce shells, why you don't invest in fortifications and mini fields near the contact line? many reasons, but the answer is, the government is not here, the finance minister is taking pictures with the girls, everyone is having fun, everyone is, you know, having a cultural counteroffensive, at a time when we should be discussing real problems in the economy and to create a national government united in the session hall, it seems to me that it does not matter the gender with whom the minister of finance took a picture, dear colleagues, we have received a separate opinion of deputy honcharenko, we will now give him two. minutes to express this separate opinion, but oleksiy oleksiiovych would like to note that next time, send the separate opinion in advance, because we have to give it to the deputies together with the committee's decision, otherwise, if you do not send it, we cannot

allow you to speak then , ok thanks, well, when already there is an opinion, that's already good, and when it is separate from such a budget, it's doubly good, friends, because actually, at a time when the state is facing such...' tests, we have, well, a very strange draft budget. what should be the draft budget of ukraine? it should be very simple. there should be an army, there should be social. support for those who need it in order to survive, and that's it, nothing should be there , we see if we have an increase in maternity expenses, so-called, no, we leave uah 860 per child for what we have, but there is with us for investment nannies, billions of hryvnias for industrial parks, what nannies, let's give money to real mothers, not some mythical invyasnyam, well, let's do something real.

go on, do we have the money here to screw it up, and what’s a plus, a plus, of course, we have a telethon again, that’s right, i understand that when the orcs move on, we ’ll turn on the tv for them, and bury them there , to see, maybe they will stop when they see this propaganda from the president's office, and then , as i understand it, everyone will stand up, maybe we will give them more, you know, a zakop. let's give them a newspaper the voice of ukraine, because we also add money for it, we are sure that we will include the tv series of the 95th quarter, because we also give money for them, friends, what we give and what is a direct priority for us is a shame, not the budget. we are going to vote, dear colleagues, there will be several votes, so please be careful, we are going to make decisions, the discussion is over. dear colleagues, in accordance with article 158 of the regulations of the verkhovna

rada of ukraine, i am putting the draft of the law of ukraine on the state budget of ukraine for 2024, registration number 100, please vote. and 274, the decision has been made, by fractions, please show, in accordance with paragraph four of part one of article 85 of the constitution of ukraine, article 158 of the regulations of the verkhovna rada of ukraine, i am putting to a vote for adoption as a whole, taking into account the conclusion of the committee on budget issues, the draft law of ukraine on the state budget of ukraine for 2024. study the rules, please, who just proposed

to discuss, thank you, on issues, the committee on budget issues, draft law of ukraine on the state budget of ukraine for 2024, registration number 1030, please vote. for 276, the decision was made law of ukraine on the state budget, by factions, show , please, a break has arrived with a replacement for pip's performance, nataliya romanivna, please vote for the future, let's not disagree on the estimate yet. anyone who has been to lviv has seen and knows svyatoyurska gora. everyone knows the yura church, they know that

andrey sheptytskyi prayed for lviv. andrey sheptytskyi, who directly influenced that the spirit of the ukrainian state that we have today. we know how strong, wise, a state church figure he was, how much of his own money he invested in the development of the then state. we know that he was tortured by the same enemy that tortures us now. for every lviv resident. and it is very important for every ukrainian that st. george's hill remains st. george's hill, that metropolitan gardens remain metropolitan gardens, that there are no buildings there, and that we have today, when the same ones that exist today came, and then under the guise of soviet power, they erected a tower that jammed the radio, and in particular the frequencies of radio liberty, respectively, in the 1980s, svyatoyurska gora is a

unesco world heritage site. accordingly, in 1998-2000, unesco obliged to remove this tower, and in 2017 the lviv city council handed over the metropolitan gardens to the church to which they originally belonged, these gardens were erected under athanasius shepptytskyi in 1740, today a special communication with is sued and already won by the court of first instance at the end of september, so that these lands, the question why ukrspetszvyazo, specifically this one is important for the city, and the main the land, which has always...been owned by the church, that is why we call on all those involved and the ukrainian special forces, and that you understand this situation, and most importantly, i, as a person who represents lviv and lviv residents in the verkhovna rada, that the townspeople should have the holy yura mountain as a place where you can pray and from which you can

contemplate lviv. and historical justice must be restored once and for all. thank you. dear colleagues, in accordance with clause 35, part one of article 85 of the constitution of ukraine, the verkhovna rada of ukraine is empowered to approve the budget verkhovna rada of ukraine. according to article seven of the regulations of the verkhovna rada of ukraine, the estimate of the verkhovna rada of ukraine is approved by the verkhovna rada during the verkhovna rada for 2024, it was provided to you together with the conclusions of the committees on regulations and budget. dear colleagues, can we do without discussion? then sign up, for then let's use a shortened procedure, i'm putting to a vote the question to consider this issue according to a shortened procedure, you

'll get a higher salary, in between, let's go to the heroes so that we do it. maxim arkadyvych buzhanskyi, please dear colleagues, let's proceed to the vote, thank you for your brevity, please, european solidarity, gyrachy. oleksiy goncharenko, european solidarity, what's up friends, we are now accepting the estimate of the verkhovna rada, and again, you know, we have funds there, as it turns out, a lot of things, first of all, we have uah 10 million there for international business trips of the verkhovna rada .

friends, i want to say once again that it is not only that someone is not allowed in, but money is also allocated for it, an interesting article, another interesting article, an increase in spending on the voice of ukraine, what is this, why is it, what is the need for it, the rada tv channel, and what about without it, of course, by the way, i immediately turn to the rada tv channel, when i walk on the sidelines and the camera of the rada tv channel is there, it seems to me that i am a stranger, because they are somehow going or somehow , then it will surely be more honest and we will call things by their names, so in the budget... the verkhovna rada has money for international business trips, there is the voice of ukraine, there is the tv channel rada, all the same priorities, friends is this correct or should our estimate be like this? yes, today everything that can be given must be given to the army, and there should not be a rada tv channel, which

, you know, for broadcasting, turn on the broadcast from any smartphone of our meeting, it is free, and the rada tv channel, the citizens of ukraine will give almost 200 million uah for this, explain to me, for what? let's give uah 200 million for drones, let's give uah 200 million for anti-drones, let's give it all to those who make sure that the council exists, and not to this estimate, thank you, okay, i'm putting the project to a vote for adoption as a whole

resolution under registration number 10222. on the estimate of the verkhovna rada of ukraine for 2024, please vote, for 263, the decision was adopted, the resolution was adopted as a whole, please, olena kostivna, regarding the requests, and, dear colleagues, so, for the announcement at the plenary session of the verkhovna rada of ukraine 50 parliamentary requests were submitted to the council of ukraine, of which six to the president of ukraine, five to the bodies of the verkhovna rada , 19 to the cabinet of ministers, 18 to the heads of other state authorities, and heads of enterprises, institutions and organizations located on the territory regardless of the requests to the president of ukraine, i am putting to a vote the proposal for preliminary support of the deputy's request to the president of ukraine regarding the awarding of the honorary title of honored doctor of ukraine to vasyl anatoliyovych ryabak. this is a request from oleksandr

horenyuk, i ask you to vote for 239, the decision has been made, i am putting to the vote the proposal to send the deputy's request to the president of ukraine, please vote. out of 230 proposals by a group of people's deputies, marusyak, tsimbalyuk and others, only 13 deputies, a proposal for preliminary support of the deputy's request to the president of ukraine regarding awarding the title of hero of ukraine posthumously to the serviceman of the armed forces

of ukraine, kushlyk. please vote for 254, the decision has been made, i am putting to the vote the proposal of a group of people's deputies, gerega, mazurash and others, nine deputies in total, on the position of preliminary support. of the deputy's request to the president of ukraine regarding the posthumous awarding of the title of hero of ukraine to the serviceman of the armed forces of ukraine marshal maksym for 246, the decision was made, i put to a vote the proposal to send a parliamentary request

to the president of ukraine, please vote, for 247 , the decision was made, i put to the vote the proposal of people's deputy serhiy nagorronyuk to the president of ukraine, regarding the awarding of the title of hero of ukraine, posthumously, to the commander of the department, the commander of the machine of the engineering and technical company, the engineering support group of the military unit a-2167 to the senior soldier ryabokony anatoly igorovich, please for 247, the decision has been made, i put the proposal to send a deputy's request to the president of ukraine for voting,

please vote. for 244 decisions have been made, i am putting to the vote the proposal for the preliminary support of the deputy's request to the president of ukraine tetyana hryshchenko, regarding the awarding of the order of courage to bidyuk vitaly anatoliyovych hrushka eduard. posthumously, please vote for 240, the decision has been made, i am putting to the vote the proposal to send a parliamentary request to the president of ukraine. for 236 decisions have been made, i bet on

the vote was 152, no decision was made, dear colleagues, these are all requests to the president of ukraine, i will read your requests, please. and only quietly, so the requests of people's deputies bodan torikhtia to the minister of agrarian policy and food of ukraine, regarding the division of duties between