[000:00:00;00] eh, no, they can’t harm, to be precise, they shouldn’t harm the global economy, and above all those countries that introduce them, that’s exactly why they thought for so long about how to limit the flow of petrodollars to the russian federation, came up with this idea of ​​a price ceiling, here, but it is violated and so far we do not see how the west can effectively impose on other countries not to violate this ceiling, so let's look first of all at the implementation of these sanctions packages, there is a thesis of western politicians that , what the russian-ukrainian war may last 5 years, the world media are writing about it, about a long war, in particular, the leader gur budanov also says , well, these statements are not the first time that they appear in the media space, they always need some kind of reaction, how about you do you think that these statements are regular, it is somehow an attempt to possibly incline ukraine to negotiations on the part of european

politicians, who speak loudly about it. that the situation has reached an impasse, or is it possible that now everyone approaches and evaluates what what is happening at the front and what should be expected next? well, if we talk about europeans, we can divide them into putin's useful idiots, and of course mr. orbán fits here very well, and he said from the very beginning that it is necessary to talk further, negotiate, well, he doesn't care what happens, let's put it this way, he pushes ukraine must be renounced... not only from the territory, but from our fellow citizens , who are actually in concentration camps there, that is, it is a lawless territory, if russia is a lawless territory, you can imagine what is happening on the territory of the temporarily occupied ukrainian regions and the autonomous republic of crimea, the city of sevastopol, and as for other european politicians, you know, it seems to me that an evolution has finally taken place, and i have not heard any statements

recently by powerful politicians, primarily from the so-called old europe or heads of state, that somehow ukraine should think about the so-called diplomatic solution to our conflict, it is clear that this diplomatic solution currently only means territorial concessions of ukraine, as well as possibly regarding of our future in yeto, of course, that this is absolutely unacceptable, and we understand that such a diplomatic, such a diplomatic process will not lead to peace, it may lead to a temporary ceasefire, so that russia uses this pause for the next attacks therefore, it is very good that there are no such, let's say, pushes for us, it periodically appears in the press, but the noise has caused several articles, well, the last article, where president zelensky was quoted as saying that he does not listen to his advisers, that he actually

broke away from reality and here is his saying, that only i believe in victory, and others do not, of course, that this is such hyperbole, of course, that it was journalistic, i hope that it was a journalistic trick, and not an order from the kremlin, to submit such an article, next was our article, that is, the key military officer, mr. zaluzhny, who was headlined completely differently than it was in the text, that is, that ukraine is busimta, or our military is at a dead end, and therefore... something must be done about it, on the contrary, zaluzhny wrote about avoiding of this stalemate, he called it a war of position, it is necessary to give ukraine a technological advantage, a qualitative advantage over the enemies, and in fact, when such articles and speculations around them appear, of course, those who were skeptical of us 10 years ago, i am not saying a year ago, open their mouths

and so on, and they start... to talk about the fact that this war cannot be won, russia is big, so let's somehow push ukraine to negotiations, but thank god, these are isolated voices, those people, surnames , which have already been highlighted in the promotion, well, actually such russian narrative, so that in general the situation is more or less favorable for us, except of course what is happening in the united states with our help, and this is not the result of what is happening in ukraine, it is the result of ukraine becoming a factor in the united states itself, i have to interrupt you, because we don't have much time, there is still a very important question that i would like to ask you, the spokeswoman of the ministry of foreign affairs of russia, maria zakharova, stated that the russian federation will not tolerate ukraine's accession to nato, even if it is partial participation in the alliance, about which they have now also started to say that those territories that are not involved in the conflict are possible and so on, are nato currently afraid of russia's reaction to the fact that, for example , they accept ukraine there, is this issue

no longer on the agenda, what do you think, well, you know, first of all, the proposal to accept ukraine in parts is absolutely unrealistic, first of all, you can't divide security into one part and not provide it to the other, and there was actually a precedent when... germany was uniting, then the germans were ready to accept such a form, such a concession to gorbachev, but the americans said that it is impossible, either all of germany will be united in nato and will be protected, or this, well , there can be no other options, this is the first moment, the second moment, of course, we remember that russia is a nuclear power, and escalation with the russian federation, no one wants a direct confrontation with nato, and actually this is a deterrent factor , you remember how last year we asked to close the sky above us so that missiles would not fall on our heads and nato did not even agree to this, at least it wouldn't be a conflict shooting down russian missiles is not shooting down russian planes, i have to catch you up on this , because time is actually very limited, i thank you for taking the opportunity to participate, thank you for your expert analysis, oleksandr khara,

foreign and security expert of politics, the center of defense strategies, we talked about the current topics surrounding the russian-ukrainian war. and we will immediately go to the topic that you are discussing so hotly in the comments in the chat under the broadcast, this is the dismissal of iryna ferion from the lviv polytechnic, keep writing your thoughts, besides, like this video, share it with your friends, and subscribe to radio liberty's youtube channel. iryna farion announced her intention to file a lawsuit over her dismissal from the lviv polytechnic national university. the previous evening , a message appeared on the website of the national university of lviv polytechnic that the institution was terminating the employment agreement with varion. the dismissal order, which is said to have been prepared according to the article of the labor code, cites the commission by an employee who performs educational functions of the admission of an incompatible with as a continuation of this work, the vice -rector of the lviv polytechnic roman korsh confirmed to radio svoboda the existence of the relevant order, in the meantime a draft document was published in the media, we are trying to get its final version from

the university administration. dismissal without any signature is something new in labor law, iryna farion wrote in her telegram channel, reacting to the information and published this very project, adding that she is preparing a lawsuit. those who work in the large walls of the polytechnic became very small at once consecrated their time with their lives, stepan bandera and roman shukhevich, kateryna zarytska and ostap mashchak, petro franko and stepan chernetskyi. i thank each of my students for the joy, luxury and depth of communication. i thank the collective department that we have been a common soul for more than 30 years. minister of education and science oksen lisovyi also commented on the notice of dismissal of farion. he thanked the students, i quote, for their concern and the ability to stand up for themselves. values. obviously, referring to the student protest near the main building of the lviv polytechnic university, which took place on november 14, when they demanded the dismissal of professor iryna farion because of her negative remarks about ukrainian servicemen who speak russian. let

's listen to a fragment of a quote from the minister of education of ukraine. the position of the ministry is unchanged for people who do not share the values ​​of dignity and do not feel respect for soldiers, there is no place in the education system. i hope the sbu within the limits of. the criminal proceedings will give a fair assessment of the statements of the former teacher of the lviv polytechnic. it must be said that we are addressed to the minister of education himself for additional comments. his press service said that there will be no additional comments, he expressed everything in his social networks. the notification of the educational institution about the dismissal of iryna farion was preceded by a statement from the security service of ukraine that they are starting criminal proceedings under four articles and appointing a number of examinations to study and statements and publications. iryna farion. according to the material. investigation, in one of her interviews , the linguist stated that absolutely not perceives russian-speaking servicemen of the armed forces of ukraine and cannot call them ukrainians. in addition, the security service of ukraine writes on its social networks that she published a post with a screenshot of a message from

a pro-ukrainian student in occupied crimea, which included personal data, which allegedly became the basis for his persecution by russian special services. it is about the detention of student maksym glebov in the occupied crimea. in her telegram channel , the linguist published an email from an allegedly crimean student who wrote words of support to her in the struggle for the ukrainian language, however , his name, surname and place of study at the department at the crimean university were not hidden on the screenshot, after that a video appeared on the telegram channel of the pro-russian blogger in crimea, oleksandr talipovov, in which a guy who calls himself maksym glebov declares that because of farion's post he is in the center of the fight against extremism of the so-called ministry of internal affairs of crimea and what was conducted after him and what was conducted with him, quoting an intelligent conversation, he also says that he renounces his views and admits , what was wrong the project opening team of the scheme, this is a project of radio liberty, verified maksym glebov, a person with such a surname, first name and patronymic does exist, he was born in kerch, his parents

and relatives are registered there, he is 17 years old. in the photos published by his relatives on social networks, a person whose appearance is similar to the boy who was shown in the video and the student card, which was published by the russian telegram channel crimean smersh. in october 2020, he received a russian so-called passport, his parents also have russian documents, and here it is worth noting that without a russian passport in the occupied crimea, public services and medical services are not provided, and it is impossible to get an education and a job. settle down we should also add that throughout the morning we tried to get the lviv polytechnic's position regarding the dismissal of irina farion. however, both in the rectorate and in the press service and in the personnel department, we were constantly transferred to other units , the press service said that there will be no comments on this matter, it does not comment on this situation yet, without the full text of the order and the educational ombudsman, with whom we communicated, and the office of the commissioner for human rights also said that this topic is not theirs yet and they do not comment on it. at night, israeli fighter jets struck the house of the leader of

the hamas group, ismail haniyeh. this organization is recognized as a terrorist organization in the eu and the usa. this was reported by reuters with reference to the israel defense forces. the israeli military says the house was used as a militant infrastructure and often served as a meeting place for the organization's top leaders. the times of israel notes that hamas has previously claimed that the idf struck two houses belonging to the haniya family, but this is the first strike confirmed by the israeli military. meanwhile, the un security council passed a resolution calling for extended humanitarian pauses in the gas sector. this is stated on the website of the organization. the resolution, tabled by malta and adopted by 12 votes in favour, calls for early and sustained humanitarian pauses and corridors throughout the sector for a sufficient number of days to allow aid to reach civilians in besieged territory. the resolution also calls for to the immediate and immediate release of all hostages held by

hamas militants. in the united states and the european union, this organization is recognized as a terrorist and other groups, and also requires that all parties fulfill their obligations according to international law. qatar , meanwhile , has been trying to negotiate a deal between israel and hamas to implement a three-day ceasefire in exchange for the release of about 500 civilian hostages taken by hamas militants during an october 7 attack on israel. the agency writes about it reuters from the link. to a source familiar with the negotiations. according to reuters sources, hamas has agreed to the general terms of the agreement, while israel is still negotiating the details. the day before, the israeli military began an operation to liberate the alshifa hospital in gaza. it was reported in the tzahal, israel said that the military found weapons and cited terrorist infrastructure inside the hospital complex. hamas denied the statement, calling it propaganda by reuters. witnesses of events, witnesses of events. who were in the hospital during the tzahal operation were described

the situation as calm. gunfire was heard intermittently, but there were no reports of casualties inside the hospital. the day before, we managed to talk to a doctor, a refugee and a gas worker, who has ukrainian citizenship. he worked at the alshef hospital and told us how the doctors helped the wounded and how the hospital functioned during active hostilities. my name is ayman al-sahbani, i am a graduate of your crimean medical university in 2002, i have a wife from the odesa region, we met when i was still in fifth grade course, it was in 10998, then they got married and went to crimea for specialization, finished residency in 2002, after that went to work. to palestine as doctors, she as an obstetrician-gynecologist, and i as a

urologist. two children were born in ukraine and three children in palestine, he worked as a doctor for 13 years as the head of the reception room in the alshifa hospital and as the head of the polyclinic for 3 years and for the last four months as the director of the hospital in beid hanoun. the situation, what happened for 38 days, you can say it's terrible, i'm a doctor i have seen so much in my life, i have never seen anything like this. 70% of the victims are women and children, currently there is no hospital, doctors, medical staff, they have no electricity, no medicine, even no drinking water and food, nothing. for example, almost 1,000 wounded people and almost 500 dead people are admitted to the alshifa hospital every day.

it is very difficult at the moment. we, as doctors, could not help the sick, because there was nothing, many were operated on in the hospital without anesthesia, people die because it is impossible to help them, so we hope that this horror will end, because the war is not for anyone, not us, not them, not for good. we hope that it will all be over soon. at first it was what it was, and there was a little water in the first few days, but... less and less, less and less, already eating, then probably once a day, and then, i washed once every two weeks, i didn't wash, but showered, clothes were changed once or twice. weeks, in general it is very difficult, we worked all the time in the hospital, saved the lives of the sick, but the situation is more than when we saw injured children, when we received hundreds of injured, seriously injured

in intensive care, in operating rooms, many dozens, even hundreds, and they are waiting in line to operate on them, and there is no electricity, currently there is no fuel at all, most hospitals are not working at all now, pregnant women with cashiers frosten i don't know what's going on, how are they, nobody can move from the house to the hospital, no one can get there, it is difficult when the women scream, cry, the war is already in general, and wait with impatience every hour for us to be taken out of there, and it lasted for more than a month, until on the 9th they were able to take us out . now there are many corpses on the streets, many of those who died, many wounded. the wounded die, not only people, but also animals, animals die because there is nothing to eat, nothing to drink, and wounded too, because there is no internet, there is no signal to call someone, there is no electricity, and guess who gets injured , now almost no one even looks at them, because it has become so

difficult to get to the hospital, even those who are now in al shifa hospital, a large hospital, still remain there. dozens of premature babies, 1 kg - premature, now there is no oxygen, there is no light, that's why three of these premature babies have already died, and if in the near future they will provide diesel fuel or fuel, then dozens of them will die in borochambers, so that the whole world can see what happens to inhuman lives. of course. we are very grateful to the state of ukraine, it is a second homeland for me, the fact that both the delegation that came from ukraine and the embassy in egypt met us at the border, gave us the opportunity to leave this horror, what was happening cannot even be described words, we were traveling with almost 200 ukrainians, women,

children and husbands, all citizens of ukraine, were able to pull us out of this horror that is happening in the gas sector, they stayed there, of course, my parents too. and my brothers and their children, of course, this cannot be explained in words or paint a picture of what happened and is happening there to this day, she took us by bus, and then by plane to moldova, then some went to ukraine, some stayed in moldova, and some who, for example, have relatives in europe or acquaintances, it is very difficult, my wife was in romania, a few months ago before this war, so went quickly from moldova to romania. while we are sitting, we do not know what to do, how to proceed, but while we are thinking, we are thinking about the fact that , thank god, we have already been able to leave the conflict zone, almost four hundred volunteers and volunteer organizations from ukraine and the world on the website of the european congress of ukrainians

published an open letter to the president of ukraine, the chairman of the verkhovna rada and the prime minister with the demand to stop the entry into force of the resolution on some issues. the passage and accounting of humanitarian aid in the conditions of martial law. it is about the introduction by the government from 1 in december of this year, a new system of passing and accounting for humanitarian aid in conditions of martial law. in particular, this document provides for the cancellation of the simplified regime for the import of such aid, which is in effect today, and introduces additional requirements for the accounting and reporting of humanitarian aid. in addition, the cabinet of ministers proposes to introduce an updated automated system for the registration of humanitarian aid, according to the ministry. policymakers in order to conduct assistance to organizations that plan to do so will have to register on the website of the automated humanitarian aid registration system, log in there, form and submit the relevant declaration. the government explains such changes by the fact that they want to make this process transparent.

the volunteers say that the mentioned system has not yet been properly tested and it is not clear how it will function in the event of power outages, only the head of the organization will be able to fill out all the documents, the volunteers say that the burden on him, it will also be mandatory to enter a unique identification number code, according to volunteers, it will create even longer queues and possible corruption at the borders, and the new procedure for importing humanitarian aid could complicate and damage the supply of defense forces. our guest, dana yarova, is a volunteer, a member of the public anti-corruption council under the ministry of defense of ukraine, as well as a member of the collegial body for rear support of the ministry of defense of ukraine. i welcome you. greetings, ms. dana, thank you for taking the time and opportunity to join, what are the biggest threats from your point of view is generally carried by the new resolution of the cabinet of ministers from december 1, and how it can complicate supplies for the armed forces . what is the volunteer environment of ukraine talking about now, you want humanitarian aid, right?

yes, yes, oh, here, you know, it's scary, and sad , actually, because large funds can still count on the fact that they will attract accountants who will sit and deal exclusively with filling out the forms provided for by this resolution, and this is , you know, monotonous work from morning to evening, in fact, this is operational activity, if to take, business processes, this is an operational activity, on which the back office always sits, to fill out the primary documents, to introduce this accounting, in fact, volunteering is now involved in such a business structure, but i would like to note that in the business structure there is where to pay salaries for people who do this in volunteering, well, finding a person who will provide free service from morning to night... volunteering is quite difficult, so maybe large volunteer organizations will find funds somewhere

to support a staff of accountants, and small, volunteer organizations will be in a very difficult situation and in general , in my opinion, this is some kind of story about stopping the volunteer movement, i would like to note in this matter that count us: they have been trying since the 14th year at in various precedents, they tried to count us on the meaning of volunteers, that's right, yes, to count and drive them into some kind of framework of relationships, but if we take the essence of volunteering, people from different fields go into volunteering, volunteers are generally a volunteer environment, it is not regulated, it is somewhat anarchic, that is why all the efforts of the authorities to somehow drive us... into some framework, well, it seems to me that they, let's put it this way, will not give any result, this is the first thing, and secondly, if you

ask me, will i report as the state is asking now, no , i won't, i don't even want to bother with it, although i have all the original documentation, i sign all the transfer acts, but the way they are trying to establish the rules of the game for us now, it's impossible , but it is really impossible, ladies and gentlemen, but now there is a simplification. humanitarian import procedure assistance, in fact, how do you assess the procedure that is in place now and the one that the ukrainian authorities have been seeing since the first of december, when will there be the reporting that you mentioned, when will there be this single system in which it will be necessary to register and fill out documents? look, what is now, it is absolutely logical, any, any serious volunteer or volunteer organization, must keep reports, these funds came to you, you spent them, you made a transfer to the units, for example, yes, if we're talking about

the military volunteering you're helping, or the wounded, whom you help, and all the volunteers have these documents in their hands, and even today it is not so difficult to introduce such accounting, accounting is not so difficult, but this is what we are offered from december 1, 2023, well, i i say that it does not enter into any framework and it is not possible to do it, because especially with the cargo that is going, relatively speaking, here you are now showing a video, and 40 tons of some humanitarian is going, well, you can imagine how she, let’s say, to balance myself, i don't, please tell me, how do you assume, how do you predict, if from 1 december, after all, this resolution will be in force, it will work and the volunteers will be forced to work within these frameworks, which the state of ukraine will build for them. how can this actually threaten the armed forces of ukraine, for example, the fact that there will be less humanitarian aid, the fact that it will go more slowly, because the process of filling out these

documents will go on, what exactly, it is absolutely true, it can stop altogether, because i say once again that it is necessary to call people who will sit and serve, the issue of this volunteer, yes this help, to account for it, to serve it, therefore... in part it will definitely stop , there may be in part a union of volunteer organizations that will, well, let's say, divide one accountant into two, and will it slow down, of course it will slow down, will the volunteers tear their hair out , there will be, that is, nothing good, this resolution is not beneficial for us, for the volunteers, for the state as well, you know, i don’t understand why, the only thing i understand is that this is a moment when we are forced into some kind of framework, well, it must be said that it is in the government

they explain that in this way it is possible to avoid certain schemes that may be with humanitarian aid , that is, this process will become about i am asking you, this, yes, they can say whatever they want, but what will stop it, that that it will slow down, that it will create some obscure, let's say, difficulties in volunteering, that's a fact , so they can say anything, but it's not true, madam, and one last question, government representatives, in particular there, i don't know, the ministry of social policy or any others ministries, they communicated with the volunteer environment, in particular with you, they asked what is your position on this matter, they listened, they did not communicate, i may have missed something, but i did not hear from anyone, but from, you know, the volunteer environment , it is quite tight and quite capacious, we know each other very well, and i have not heard from anyone that anyone was approached, invited to some working

groups and involved in the creation of this... moment, i did not hear such a thing, that is, maybe i invited someone, but all volunteers, like me i personally know that they are either in the same position as me, that we will not do what is required of us, or they are running and panicking about the fact that they will stop volunteering . ms. dana, and here is a brief conclusion, just a few seconds, what do we have left, do you think, will the ukrainian authorities be able to prepare, for example , the implementation of this resolution, if the volunteer environment, in particular you, your colleagues who work in this direction, will they actually express such a position, as we just heard on the air? well, i suppose it is it would be normal in a dialogue with the authorities, and this is a normal feedback that the authorities received from the volunteer environment, and i would like to emphasize once again, dear authorities, yes, volunteers are a somewhat anarchic structure, do not touch it, because while we, let's say so,

in our environment, we can quarrel very seriously, but if someone... is picked on, well, then everyone becomes defensive, so i think that it would be reasonable to get rid of it now, make changes and make it so that the accounting during volunteering, it was , it is necessary to, normally, it it was possible without spending days and days to fill it, so i think that the authorities received feedback on how it will behave, well, we'll see, you know, it's not predicted. i thank you for tuning in, for finding the opportunity and time, dana yarova, volunteer, member of the public anti-corruption council under the ministry of defense of ukraine, also a member of the collegial body of style support of the ministry of defense of ukraine, a guest of our broadcast, we touched on many important and interesting topics today in broadcasts that you want to hear in our broadcasts, in the future, write in the comments, in addition, subscribe to our social networks, in particular, radio liberty reports that

the newly appointed head of the ministry of foreign affairs of great britain has arrived in ukraine, he already had president zelsky, the ukrainian president in particular wrote that it was a good meeting, weapons for the front, strengthening air defense and protecting ukrainian people and critical infrastructure, this is a direct quote, besides, on the radio liberty website, you can also find a lot of interesting materials, one of them that i recommend reading is about that, actually with fragments video of how the residents of the front-line liman are preparing for the frost, subscribe to our social networks, comment on the date, share this video with your friends so that as many people as possible can see a high-quality contact, we will meet with you tomorrow, this is the freedom

of mornings project, take care. it's 10 o'clock on the clock, it's time to find out what 's happening in ukraine and the world at this time, khrystyna parubiy is working in the studio. the explosions rang out in khmelnytskyi region, where the pppo forces were working - reported the first deputy head of the regional military administration, serhiy tyurin. of france launched shahedy from the southern direction, alarms sounded in the mykolaiv, odesa, kirovohrad and vinnytsia regions. one person was injured due to enemy shelling in kharkiv region, a 74-year-old resident of the village of dvorichna is in the hospital. also, around midnight, the russians struck chuguiev with s-300 missiles. in the city, the building of an educational institution and a private residential building were damaged

- reported oleg senigubov, the head of the region. in the village of kruglyak.