[000:00:00;00] not hamas against israel, every day statistics are given, how many soldiers died, they talk about these soldiers , well, they honor, of course, there are probably different numbers , of a different order, a different scale, a different war, we have a full-scale war, of course, as you say, the absence accurate information about it, does it affect people, that is, maybe we have already passed the period when we were protected from some numbers, from some facts, that is, during these one year and nine months, we saw destroyed city bridges, we know about what happened in the east, we we know what happened in buchi, we know that many people died in mariupol , it is not known for sure how many more, or whether it is only related to this, that we cannot establish exactly, this number, we are careful

to talk about it and the authorities are trying to tell us also be careful not to hint or talk about it, well, look, the situation is more complicated here, eh, the fact is that at the very beginning of the invasion a tactic was chosen, perhaps historians will later say that it was the right tactic, but it was a chosen tactic of a half-truth, i.e. to make as much as possible so that people are mobilized so that they don't have fear and that this is a slightly different truth than it is, now if we go back to these realities that we have today, the war continues and the situation is not easy, and is the government today ready to take and tell the people completely the whole truth, i think that first of all it is necessary to tell them

to themselves, admit it, apologize, are they ready to do it? i don't know if they 're ready for it, if it needs to be done today, look, it needs to be done, because we're at that stage of the war when people and so know the truth, it leaks out, people have relatives, children, relatives who are at the front, there are other channels of information, so in order to avoid such a situation when the government lives in one world and the people live in another, the truth is needed, but is there now the understanding and the desire to discover this truth, well, so far we do not see it, maybe something will change, that is, this parallel reality that was last year, this year is no longer working, that’s it, it cannot be returned, it must end with this, and everyone has this understand, believe me, the last ones sociological studies show that

people do not trust a single marathon. because the true information that is out there, that is spoken, is different, and we can, in principle, very quickly distinguish the wheat from the chaff, so the question here is strategic, whether we will continue to hear a different reality from the authorities until the end of the war, and know our own, will they still admit and start telling us the truth, which is actually in this and you have already mentioned the single telethon, and sofya fedina started the process. speak, we have such a media monster now large in ukraine, which is financed from the state budget, that is, it is not just a private initiative of a few tv channels there , it is state funding for the next year , uah 2 billion, this is quite a large amount, these tv channels legally belong to the rich

of ukraine, the oligarchs, well, they are not they are called oligarchs, because the status of oligarchs... there is a status, but the status has not been assigned to anyone yet, because on may 1, 22, when this law was supposed to start working, this register of creation of oligarchs was removed, but we know that in this single telethon there is, for example, a pool from kolomoiskyi, kolomoiskyi is in prison, co-owner of 1+1, medvedchuk is in russia, he is accused of treason, one of the people, or... one of the faces 1.1 oleksandr dubinskyi is in sizo on suspicion of treason. the stars that shone there on 1.1 nestor shufry, chilik, is a prosecutor, also suspected of high treason, and 1.1 is in the only telethon, has state funding, well, there is a deyura or something, according to some documents, kolomiysky

trusted corporate... rights to manage the team, but isn't it time to just talk, ms. sofia, i don’t know whether those who have monopoly power, whether they are capable or inclined to this dialogue first of all with you, because i should ask whether the power communicates with each other, because you are also the power, but there is a monopoly power, or isn't it time to talk about it, because, well, how is it, the tv channel where the traitor is against the traitor, it turns out in a single telethon, forms a single state policy, and maybe there are people on the plus side who should receive state suspicion, suspicion in the state betrayal well, in fact, there is a lot of light in the united marathon in general people who have worked for many years to spread pro-moscow anti-state narratives, and i am very surprised why

, in the context of clashes with people who undermine the honor and dignity of servicemen, who spread pro-moscow narratives, there are not all these people who are now sitting and running single marathons. the second point is that, well, let's remember that there is not only that. paul kolomoiskyi and medvedchuk, but there are also firtash, pinchuk and akhmetov, in particular, the inter tv channel is present in a single marathon, and we all know how many years, it was a total pro-moscow position, and individual journalists who were despised by various tv channels for having to go online, they all suddenly lit up in a single marathon . that is not adapted and not necessary for ukraine on the fredom dom tv channels and so on, that our people abroad even spit that what is there

is shown to us, and i will emphasize this all again, for the money of taxpayers, i.e. rich people decided to give their channels to the state so that the state would maintain them with taxpayers' money. and to be honest, through these channels i did nothing but glorify the government, because in the previous question you talked about the dead, about heroes, it is not necessary to say these or other numbers, in fact, we do not see the stories of heroes in a single marathon, we do not we see the exploits of our soldiers, we don't see the exploits of our volunteers, we don't see the exploits of our civilians, who in the most difficult circumstances yet... the official authorities, do a huge, huge deal with saving the state, the environment, and so on, all this is not in the marathon, and that is why people go online, that is why people are looking for other sources of information, and that is why i

, if you allow me, literally a few more reflections on the previous question, whether it is necessary to talk about the dead, i think it is necessary, but we need to find an appropriate form so that people do not have a total shock, we need to talk about... and about the military in a discrete way, so as not to let the moscow federation manipulate this, but especially we need to talk about dead civilians, because i apologize, mariupol is at least 100,000 dead, and this is given by only one morgue, about 76,000 accurately identified and missing persons, who most likely will not be able to be identified anymore, and the morgue was not in mariupol one, but why does this problem arise, why the government. does not want to talk about all this, because the question of responsibility is at stake here, because society needs to answer the question honestly, and why there was no preparation for the invasion, why there was

no aggressive preparation, why they tried to mediate to destroy and humiliate everyone who spoke about the need for training, the allocation of funds for the army, who spoke about the need to build defense lines, and about the same demined... chongar, kalanchak and the southern line near the crimea, well, that is, there are more than enough questions, and to be honest, i am very impressed by the position of the israeli leadership of the israeli special services, who have already publicly apologized to their citizens for not preparing for their military operations, for the fact that they were engaged in politics, for the fact that they were engaged in some wrong issues that were critical to israel's security, and what i really like is that many politicians have publicly said that after repelling the attack, they will answer politically, but our politicians are not yet mature enough to take responsibility

and honestly say, yes here we got through, so here we did not want to listen, so we did not understand here, so we did not understand the issue, now we understand, now we are forming, for example, the government of national unity, now we are working, there is also a critical problem that stands out now, but in these of all the issues we are currently discussing, this is trust in the authorities, because new fighters will mobilize when they know. what demobilization will be, how the documents will be drawn up, how they will be able to be sent to this or that profession, that they will not be treated like cannon fodder, that there will be no, shall we say, demonstration liberations on this or that date, which on unfortunately, they are practiced now by order of the highest political leadership of the state, sacrificing people, that every life of every soldier, every civilian will be valued, here when the state can respond to these things,

then there will be an opportunity to mobilize more and speak more honestly with society, and society will respond more. thank you, mrs. solomia, tell me, and your political force also shares the opinion of the representatives of european solidarity, because they repeatedly articulated the opinion about the need to create a government of national unity, well, as it was in principle in the same israel, that they simply rejected all misunderstandings simply formed a government of national unity and this allows them to hold the entire political elite and the entire people are united and oppose hamas, are you ready to delegate your representatives to such a government of national unity, and is anyone in the parliament still talking about this? you know, it's a very good question, the truth is that i left the political force when i joined the armed forces, i joined the military... the voice today belongs to the faction, but

it certainly seems to me that a person with or a people's deputy with a healthy blues, from the beginning full-scale war, clearly supports this idea, moreover, encourages it, and i am very sorry that during these 20 months, the monomajority did not just ignore them, but they, well, they have their own political agenda, they have their own political vision, how they will solve all this, despite the fact that they are applying with a bunch of professional proposals other factions, other political parties, starting from defense, ending with the sphere of health care, social policy, and so on and so on, but nobody needs all this, i am generally very surprised that after kovid we do not have there was a change of government, let's be honest, yes, yes today, few people in our country will remember who our prime minister is, who we have, i don't know who heads it or temporarily heads it, for example, the ministry of youth and sports, but i want to tell you that

today there was news that the wife tv is temporarily under suspicion of treason, you know, i am not sad, it is a huge shame for us, and the restart of the government could be done much earlier, easier, faster, more dynamically, the rather, by showing everyone a broad gesture, correct, both within the ukrainian society and externally number, because we have a strong hand of the leader, and we position ourselves as a nation that goes to... wins, together, because we all have the sense to speak of one voice when we speak abroad, and moreover, we did not start an internal political struggle during these 20 months, and it seems to me that it was started by our representatives of the monomajority, but definitely not by someone from the opposition parties or factions, or someone from the independent deputies themselves, this whole attack started, on alas, and this one, starting, by the way, from the only marathon which is far removed from reality and

which is heard less and less, because every second third family is involved in the war, and this gap between what we see on television and real life, it simply becomes colossal, so unfortunately , for example, i have not heard of such conversations in the parliament today, we hear only periodically that there will be a replacement of not only individual ministers, but there should be a reboot of the government, maybe it will happen even in december, but think about it. that it could be done correctly, historically, even correctly, and, and it is beautiful, of course, because it is a dialogue with the representatives of the faction and the voters, and therefore the voters, unfortunately there is no such thing, and in fact, i am very sorry that today parliamentarism in our country has sunk far below some kind of plinth, and even though we are a parliamentary republic , but since we are not allowed to go abroad, even on a business trip , and each of us, even from my friends here , we have to... prove why we need to go to certain events, why we don't want that

at the economic forum, represented in poland, someone, we don't want aristovych to represent, and for it to be a parliamentary choice, there or any other traitors, official legal or illegal, this is simply a collapse , this is nonsense, moreover, it concerns, in particular, our colleagues, city regional councils, where, where in the city council is not even wages are received, and women also hand in ... because at the beginning of the war it was a matter of survival of children or some security things, and that's all, how can the cabin ban the parliament from leaving, how can the president's office give instructions, that is? with all due respect, but this nonsense, when the ministry of foreign affairs is not independent, when the decision is made backstage somewhere in the office, it is not explained, when meetings with delegations, there in particular of states, it is only the office of the president, never in any case not the parliament, it is such, it is such a lack of parliamentary

control, and the time has passed for parliamentary control, we have already left the first months, we have recovered from the horror, we need to systematically and competently launch the state policy for the long term, and when we come for more, all of us abroad and at security conferences, in particular to us they ask serious systemic questions: how do you return your refugees, how do you start the economy, how do you build a military-industrial complex, we do not have these isolated questions, because we do not form as a parliament, and the government does not even sit down to this at all, and she says , listen, and she just looks at us with standard eyes, then we live in which country, then this is how can one hand think, the other just be absent and say that it is there, because we have those pictures of her hand, well that such an imbalance. and chaos, that just thank you, lady straw, i will remind ours tv viewers, we are conducting a survey during our program and we ask you whether you are satisfied with the dialogue between the government and society during the war, there are two options for answers, yes, no, if you are satisfied,

then call 0800-21381, no , 0800, 211-382, all calls to these numbers are free. call, at the end of the program we will sum up the results of this vote, now there will be a short pause, do not switch, we continue the conversation with our guests, problems with the joints restrict movement, it is unpleasant and painful. strengthen them with dolgit joints, these are bags with collagen and vitamin c to restore joints. longitudinal cartilage contributes to the normal functioning of joints and has a positive effect on bone health. stretching the joints improves motor functions. stretch your joints, move freely. laughter, physical activity, sneezing. even during such a small load, urinary incontinence can make itself felt. feminost

uro helped me. thanks to its natural ingredients, feminost uro helps restore control over urination both day and night. femost uro. urination under control, ask at pharmacies, buy with a 10% discount at the antz pharmacy, the kopiyka pharmacy and the shar pharmacy. i flew, flew, and the cough stopped me. cough is a symptom of a respiratory disease, so we treat it respiratoryly, we do inhalation. lordegial is an inhalant for cough. lordegial, a direct route to expectoration. turn on well, that's when everything is as you want. click and now you control the game. bird, and you're on a tv show. oh, what is needed, blink. turn on hundreds of channels, thousands of movies and sports. there are discounts on helpex, 20% in pharmacies plantain, memory and savings. oh, there are no potatoes , you will bring them already, ass, something has caught, i remind you, apply dr. tys's bone marrow ointment and get back to work. ointment with comfrey is

a german ointment for joint and muscle pain. opa,ko turns, movement, from pain in the joints and. natural ointment with comfrey from dr. tice. ask at pharmacies for a good day pharmacy and one social pharmacy. venison with ham 100 g with a 20% discount. there are discounts on kvayt, 10% at podorozhnyk, bam and oskad pharmacies. greetings, this is svoboda live on radio svoboda. we are already approached the snake itself. the following shots may shock you. news from the scene. live, kamikaze drone attacks, political analysis, objective and meaningful, there is no political season, exclusive interviews, reports from the hottest points of the front, svoboda life frankly and impartially,

you draw your own conclusions. the tv channel broadcast continues, we work live. this is the verdict program, my name is serhii rudenko. during the program, we conduct a survey, we ask you whether you are satisfied with the dialogue between the authorities and society during the war, yes no, you see the phone numbers on our screen, vote, at the end of the program we will sum up the results of this vote, all calls to these numbers are free, today we have sofia fedina, solomiya bobrovska, oksana savchuk as our guests. so, madam, i wanted to talk to you about what he is saying. about what is happening inside the country, because zelenskyi said yesterday that the special service reported that someone deliberately incited... something inside the country and we will listen to what zelenskyi said, i will note the meeting with the representatives

of the law enforcement sector, in particular the head of the security service of ukraine, reported on counteraction by a collaborator and on the protection of ukrainians from those who deliberately incite enmity within our country. we should remember everyone in ukraine, and especially those who stopped noticing the war. because he gives all his attention to politics, russia is still capable of carrying evil, turning a blind eye , no one will succeed, we have to fight, we have to protect our defense as the main priority, and we have to add more strength to our state every day. mrs. oksano, about whom says zelsky, who enmity inside the country, except for collaborators, because he took them out separately, well, look, i said it differently

, maybe someone does not notice it, the previous year of the active invasion we lived inside with such feelings of certain internal compromises, where we talked about what, well now the active phase of the war, we will not say something, we will not spread something, we will do all this after the war, and even we, as politicians, including the opposition ones, we said that we also have things that we do not like, but we don't talk about them openly, because we don't want to stress society, etc., but when we see that the country is going in the wrong direction internally, and this is seen by a lot of people, military, volunteers, just socially active people, as a political nation, yes , it took place, but now it is very important, where this ukraine will go, whether it will be truly

pro-ukrainian, or it will be, you know, with such a soviet, pro-russian character, and these are very valuable discussions in the middle, they are actually very important, and they outlook, and this is also such, you know, a very important front, which today is being led by a lot of... many people, why is this front being led like this, i would say, verbal, first of all, because the volunteers are not in favor, they realized that no one needs them , they are constantly being poked and prodded, as if it were government decrees, then bills, where some unknown amendments appear at the last moment, like some bloggers who are probably friends with one of the president's advisers, who constantly comments on everything. for some reason they protect the taxi driver who says that in russian

the language should be spoken, not ukrainian, and everyone writes how beautiful it is, how fashionable it is, and that 's normal, for some reason we are blurring the things that we started with last year about our identification, that ukrainians and the ukrainian language are the direction to which we should move forward, instead of a high-quality cultural product that would inspire us, show us who we are, what traditions we have, what kind of lineage we have, we are being pushed low-quality, you know, something so incomprehensible without giving us anything in return, some series , which not only remove for our state funds, and then someone will say that there is a conflict, there is no conflict, there is simply a desire and a need to convey very basic things, a war on the front with the enemy, and today we are also talking about the fact that ukraine will not follow a pro-russian path, no, but those people who instigate it really need to be caught by the sbu, and

who are they, all of medvedchuk’s networks, and by the way, i want to tell you who will now give a guarantee that she will not work for the next election under some a new, conditionally white-blue project and tries to further capture those voters who were among them before the war, they are mobilizing, they will create special such... fake things for them, so first of all, if we take a deeper look at it from the inside, on the contrary, i advise the authorities today to do everything possible in order to hear from them, what, what will be ukrainian society, the status of the ukrainian language, what it should be, it should not be discussed, not debated , this is the ukrainian language, ukrainian culture, this is not low-quality sovietism, but this is to rise to the level of that and show who we are, and thirdly, stop, lash out at those who are

patriots, but to really catch those who were surrounded by medvedchuk, who were stuck last year, and now they have all got out and are very successful and feel at ease. thank you, ms. oksana, ms. sofia, who do you think zelsky was talking about? i don't know who zelskyi was talking about, but i would advise him to look in the mirror and see his monomajority in the verkhovna rada. i apologize, more than opzzzh and around opzhn shusher, no one incited. he incites enmity, but for some reason the servants of the people in ecstasy merged with the opzzh in the parliament, squeezing different half legal, semi-state institutions that only harm the ukrainian people. i would also advise you to look in the mirror regarding the persecution of military personnel and volunteers and veterans, because nothing has changed since the 19th year, and chervinsky's case only confirms that the authorities persecute those who

dare to speak the truth, who dare to defend the ukrainian state. i'm sorry, the authorities should look in the mirror, because it looks like they are trying to negotiate with the moscow hebi church, instead of doing everything to ban it, they one should look in the mirror , because it is the advisers of the president's office who are, let's say, riga's coddle, who call the revolution of dignity, mass riots with the use of force, who opposed the maidan activists, justified the berkuts, defended all kinds of tailors, and now they remain in power , i apologize, and let's ask one more question, what about bakanov, what about bakanov, he led in particular to this situation that we had with the lack of preparation for war, one of zelenskyi's team, and he is having a good time, and what about us with all those traitors and mediapians, they walk quietly and no one moves them, that we have those people who have been spreading moscow propaganda for years, they also

walk, that is, the government, having... years of monopolies and i have hope for one and a half extreme years having at least some idea of ​​what the ukrainian state should be, it should decide these things, and the opposition would definitely support all this, but no, they are starting to harass opposition channels again, they are once again rolling the barrel on opposition politicians who are actually working for assistance to the armed forces of ukraine, and they are trying to destroy those soldiers, thanks to whom the ukrainian state held its ground at the most difficult moment. please, mr. zelsky, and your monomajority, look in the mirror. thank you, ms. sofia, ms. solomi, we don't have much time, if possible, put this in a minute , you know, i remember how boyko on the first days of the full-scale invasion, first, on the first day, in the first hour, he came out with us to the first breeching from the parliament, when we voted for the introduction of a legal regime

of martial law, and he stood like this almost unhappy, but understanding that he would be assigned a role during the occupation, far from the last, who was supposed to be the speaker there, they shared all these positions among themselves, who was the prime minister, unity, and with the muscovites and so on, and i then i still remember how in the first week or two he gave an interview to solovva, and it is very disgusting and disgusting to look at them, the truth is in the parliament, and for me it is actually a big mystery, apart from the votes, for what, how can a person explain to a ukrainian, why, what he makes these enemies of the state, what they do in the parliament, what he does... in the parliament until now pir lies dead half-dead and such a burden, all our slaughterhouses for the prohibitions of the russian orthodox church, in the end we adopted an absolutely spineless bill, but now your time is running out, i apologize, please, we have to finish, because we have our own regulations, so i i apologize once again, solomiya bobrovska, oksana savchuk, sofia fedina were guests

of our program today, thank you ladies for participating in the program. program, we conducted a survey, we asked you about whether you are satisfied with the dialogue between the government and society during the war, 94% dissatisfied 6% satisfied, over 1400 votes in this poll. i'm putting an end to this, i wish everyone good health, take care of yourself and your relatives, goodbye. do ordinary things become unreal? heavy bags are not for my sore back. for back pain, try dolgit cream. dolgit cream relieves pain, reduces swelling and improves joint mobility. with cream, whatever you want, i'll raise it. dolgit is the only yellow cream for joint and back pain. agency wivinil represents. december 3