see this week in the judicial control program with tatyana shustrova. the beginning of the assessment of judges for their suitability for positions. she came up with a scheme according to which not only they, but in fact the rest of the unscrupulous judges can avoid this. but who is trying to disrupt the qualification assessment? this is for the entire period of my life of conservation. congratulations. judicial control is on the air. an effective judicial system and quality transformations in this area, one of the key requirements for ukraine's accession to the european union. the process has been launched and is progressing the reform is very weak. if unscrupulous judges continue to occupy positions in the renewed bodies, the construction of a quality judicial system is doomed, and in the best case it will take years. today, we will talk about the related challenges, threats and specific personalities that are hindering ukraine's path to the eu, but first. traditionally to the news. the court took

up the case against volodymyr kuksov, a judge of the northern commercial court of appeal, who is accused of collaborationism. after the liberation of kyiv region from occupation, kuksov complained acquaintance on these events and justified the atrocities of the rashists, instead he called ukrainians fascists. fuckers can force, well, we have the same situation, we have half of the salary, like there, and the supreme court decided to give creeper pay for the war, damn, i need this war. the judge of the northern commercial court of appeal, volodymyr kuksov, originally from crimea, was a judge of the alushta city court before the occupation. in 2014, he was transferred to kyiv. almost a year ago, the state bureau of investigation informed the judge about the suspicion of inciting collaborative activities and justification of russian aggression. the court chose

a precautionary measure for him in the form of a bail of 3 million hryvnias. since at that time the supreme council of justice was not yet authorized. prosecutors could not apply for an arrest warrant. if the court finds volodymyr kuksov guilty, he faces up to 15 years in prison with confiscation of property. in october, the highest anti-corruption court classified half of its verdicts related to top corruption. in particular , three out of six decisions were classified. this is the verdict. in the cases of lawyer oleg horetsy, who was an accomplice of the ex-head of the supreme court vsevolod knyazev, in receiving a record bribe of almost 3 million dollars, as well as the cases of former deputy and ex-head of the chamber of accounts valery patskan and deputy minister of energy and coal industry during yanukovych ihor kyryushin. as of late, not even the decisive part of the sentence has been published , which should include the articles under which he was convicted and what punishment was imposed. a package

of bills providing for large-scale inspections of judges of the supreme court on integrity are reviewed by the committees of the verkhovna rada. strengthening public trust in the judiciary has become an urgent issue after the discovery of large-scale corruption in the supreme court. the united states also demands inspections of fimida officials from ukraine, and while the highest judicial body is waiting for the introduction of new control tools, its representatives continue to make dubious decisions. so in the case of bilotserkivsk. the supreme court passed a series of decisions that prevented the return of control over the company to its shareholders. judge volodymyr students, a member of the board of the commercial court of cassation, decided at his own discretion to interpret the norms of the commercial procedure code and dismissed the plaintiffs' complaint against the decision of the northern commercial court of appeal. thus, contrary to the law, a measure was taken to ensure the claim in the form of suspension of the decisions of shareholders' meetings. subsequently, with another

ruling, the supreme court, as part of the same collegium headed by volodymyr students, granted the request of the raiders of the bilotserkiv thermal power plant. so the company had to abandon the lawsuit. the suspension of the decisions of prad's shareholders' meetings was called legitimate during the consideration of other complaints in this case. in particular, regarding the decision of the judge of the commercial court of the kyiv region, pavlo gorbasenko, who found the decisions made by the shareholders to be invalid. gorbasenko, we will remind, also forbade the state. to registrars, notaries, the ministry of justice and other bodies that can carry out registration, take actions regarding btstec offices. despite the illegality of such a decision and the fact that to the unified state register information about the new head of the company, igor vegularny, was already submitted , the supreme court, as part of a collegium headed by the same volodymyr studentets, left the shareholders' complaint unsatisfied, and the rulings of the lower courts remained unchanged. it is interesting that i will pass some decisions of the panel of the commercial court of cassation. before the expiration

of the terms for review of complaints in the cassation procedure. the shareholders of the bilotserkiv thermal power plant are convincing, the servants of themis deliberately make it impossible to return their control over the enterprise, and sami decisions of the supreme court are illegal and have signs of bias. this week, the higher qualification commission of judges of ukraine began evaluating current judges for their suitability for positions. we have all been waiting for this for three long years. the powers of the previous composition were terminated in november 2019 after amendments were made to the law of ukraine on the judiciary and the status of judges. and since then , the procedure for appointing new judges and transferring existing ones to another judicial body has been stopped, and unscrupulous judges have managed to keep their positions all this time. now that's all will be different. we fought for a long, long time to ensure that the composition of the supreme court of justice was decent, and now , well, at least there are hopes and signs that this composition will be much more scrupulous about the conclusions of the public

integrity council, the facts of dishonesty of judges, than the previous composition. and since the new conditions for a positive passing of the qualification evaluation are stricter, not all judges are delighted. some mentioned that three years ago he had a positive opinion from the former members of the vkks, so now he is refusing interviews. in the last issue, we told you about the judge of the commercial court, inna otrosh, who had a magically fast career thanks to violations by the higher qualification commission and probably not without the help of her influential mother. today we will talk about the judge of the svyatoshyn district court of kyiv, who also does not want to take the skeletons out of the closet. a panel of judges along with some. people's deputies came up with a scheme according to which not only they, but actually the rest of the unscrupulous judges can avoid this and we will never fire them later. this is the judge of the svyatoshyn district court of kyiv, taras zayets, and he is also trying to disrupt the evaluation qualifications. zayets is the so-called judge

of the maidan. in february 2014, a judge arrested an innocent protester who was detained and beaten by the berkuts for two months, and then simply hid this fact in a declaration of integrity. when...' he filled out the judge's declaration of integrity, there is a relevant question that directly relates to whether you made such a decision, he did not indicate this fact, that is, he kept his declarations of integrity, but forgetting and hiding the fact that he made a decision regarding the participants of the protest. in january 2019, taras zayets participated in the competition for the appeals chamber of the higher anti-corruption court, then the higher... commission excluded him from participation on the recommendation of the public council of international experts as dishonest, however , changed his mind in two months and recognized zayets as fully capable of administering justice in svyatoshynskyi raisuddi capital. one of those judges who believe that they no longer need

to go through the plenary session, so they can continue to work with the judge. at the interview in the competition for the higher anti-corruption court , a lot of interesting and mysterious facts about the multiplication of fortunes surfaced. thus, in 2011, while working as an assistant judge, without substantial official income, taras zaits managed to purchase an audi q7 for $90,000. at the interview, he stated that his parents helped, of course, and he collected the $13,000 of savings indicated in the declaration from school. the specified documents unquestionably confirm the existence of official and legal sources for the relevant preservations. this is a saving for my whole life, to put it roughly, there from school university, earned something, saved. taras zayets led a rather active lifestyle: dubai, sharmelsheikh, vienna, dalaman, amsterdam, bodrum, doha. yes, we do sometimes travel abroad with our family. we have friends living abroad, friends to whom we have traveled many times and actually incurred expenses

only for buying tickets. actually, the standard set of judges, loving parents who provide real estate and cars, hospitable friends around the world who pay for travel. today, judge taras zayets believes. that has already passed the qualification assessment and refuses to go through it again. we understand that there is something to worry about, because in 2019 it was international experts who found him unworthy of the position of judge of the higher anti-corruption court. now that the entire branch of the higher judicial bodies has been reformed, with the participation of foreign partners, it will not be easy to overcome the new, high barrier of requirements for the administration of justice, and it is likely that this qualification assessment will eventually weed out many unworthy servants. it was the judicial control program and i, tatiana shustrova. if you have information about unscrupulous judges and facts of corruption in judicial system, let me know on facebook or at the email address

you see on the screen now. all the best and see you soon. wears treatment, let's start with washing, and the first thing to the nose - of course, maridoza, there are discounts on... maridoza - 20% in pharmacies plantain, bam and savings. i flew, flew, and the cough stopped me. cough is a symptom of a respiratory disease, so we treat it respiratoryly, we do inhalation. lordegial is an inhalant for cough. lordial is a direct way to expel phlegm. every day, every hour, every minute we receive a large amount of information. the most anticipated event of the year, which is actually happening on the front. which. losses of personnel and equipment on the battlefield. how the international community evaluates our successes and

what moscow is lying about. from the flow of news coming from everywhere, we single out the most important ones. the tweet is closely monitoring whether there will be weapons for ukraine and what kind, and what are the russian occupiers whispering about behind the commanders' backs? news, summaries of the week. this is an overview of important events only. a significant, credible event. these are analytics, fact-checking, professional comments. about this and much more in today's issue, about important things in simple language, available to all viewers. welcome to iryna koval studio, and these are the results of the week on the espresso tv channel. news, summaries of the week, every saturday at 21:00 on espresso. verdict with serhii rudenko, now in a new two-hour format. even more analytics, even more important topics, even more top guests. foreign experts. inclusion from abroad about ukraine, the world, the front, society, and also feedback,

you can express your opinion on the day with the help of a telephone survey, turn on and turn on, verdict with serhiy rudenko, every weekday from 8 to 10 pm on espresso. espresso - interesting facts. for 10 years of existence, the portal of the tv channel has been reviewed. more than 2 billion 230 million times. over 10 years , more than 575,000 pieces of news have been published on the tv channel portal. more than a song. what does jamala's victory mean for ukraine? it was a private, state-owned,

private bank in which more than 20 million ukrainians kept funds, it was declared insolvent and handed over to state management. the first thing the invaders who come to our lands do is cross out the letter i in the name of mariupol and put the russian i there. this is why it is so important to protect not only our land, but also our identity and culture. if it is so important to our enemy, to destroy our identity. i do not understand why people who live in this territory of the ukrainian people have questions. and flourishing of culture even during the war remains a question, and is it also important to document

the crimes of the occupiers on our land? documentary film, it is as if, a form of impact on the future, because after a certain time, the right documentary is the main thing that proves the existence of this past , to make sense of... war in all possible ways and forms, there are a lot of symbols, one is no longer relevant, that cossack, naked barefoot with a bow and arrows , is no longer like that, already well equipped, but then it was like that, and thanks to art, to convey ideas and values ​​to the next generations. art, if it can talk about the war, but not directly, and there in five or 10 years it... it will also be relevant, this is true art, and

in the same way to talk about russian aggression to the world, the more we talk about ourselves through culture and art, for western audiences, the more e hymers and patriots we have in our country, to protect our own, so as not to prove once again that ukrainian culture not russian, because it is against... cultural appropriation, this is one of the forms of resistance to the occupation, i will never be able to communicate with a person who will be from the russian federation, every person who currently lives in the russian federation is an accomplice of this to putin this is the second series of the documentary project culture during the war. north. each of us will have our own personal nickname. a bottle of wine held until victory, the first coffee in your city, in a favorite and

cherished place, the first normal night. not in a storage room between two walls, but simply in a bed at home, good evening kyiv, good evening phrayany, vernyakannya program, andriy sakalov, anton slipakov, today at a charity performance for musicians defend ukraine. this is a fragment of varnyakannya's performance, an art project created by the authors themselves called musical-documentary-therapeutic. the basis of the performance is electronic music and poetry that makes sense of the russian invasion. anton and andriy started creating this project from the first weeks of the war. passengers, we are leaving the train, waiting for the next train. the first words began to come, which began to be fixed in certain sentences, which already more or less seemed

like texts. i shared the first text with everyone, the second with only ... with andriy, and he told me that it must be recorded, i saw that not everyone is active were, then, it seemed to me that anton was also in a certain stupor, when i saw that the first lines appeared from him, it seemed that it was very important now to be busy with what you know how to do best, so the musicians began to create together, and presented your repertoire to the public, you say that i don't look good, when the face and hair are not fresh , i agree with that, my friend, but how can i look like before, when sleeping areas are ironed with rockets, when on peaceful buildings they shoot with guns, and they killed me with a target

and destroyed somewhere on the 24th or 25th, it's all about pain, about hope, about that whirlwind of emotions that everyone probably feels, while the red cross is on vacation, we hold an encouraging contest in the warehouses, how children create an anti-war drawing, with tracks about complex emotions of wartime, andriy and anton perform at charity concerts in various cities of ukraine, including front-line and de-occupied cities. cannot be compared with anything , for example, the feeling when you perform in kherson, after he was released, with what eyes people look at it, i would gave an example, probably kharkiv, kharkiv, yes, chernihiv, well, in short, all the other cities

that were beaten, humiliated, by the russians, in many of these cities, these were the first public events of any kind since february 24, 2022, so they accepted everything, it’s simple a kind of revelation when you come to a city that is closest to the border and suffers from constant artillery attacks, but when you go in, you see those people on the square, and that spirit that rages there, it's so... strong, that's it himself, only evil, in a good way, angry, and, well, then i'm like that, i think, damn it, kharkiv stands very powerfully, and it doesn't lose the most important thing, for all the destroyed houses and factories, shopping centers and tv channels,

yes, a lot from us too. depends the lyrics tell stories about how the war changed us, which became our new reality. for the authors themselves, the described experience also became a turning point. on february 24, like many people, the world was divided into black and white. for yourself, inside you simply decided that you will not be able to cut everything off in one fell swoop, because you. you are czech by blood, but you want to have a minimum in common with the barbarians who come here to rob, rape and kill, on one of the first days, i translated all my internet communication, and since it makes up the majority of my communication, it is in

ukrainian, i warned my parents about it, they treated it normally. anton slipakov also previously used russian, both in his work and in everyday life. of course, we didn't move to the same time, that 's all, we communicate only in ukrainian, but gradually, gradually, there has been more environment more people with whom you communicate, many more people who wanted to help you with this, just as gradually the musician began to cooperate with ukrainian-language projects and create in ukrainian. we, the dovzhenko center, were invited in the 16th year to make a soundtrack for the film arrest warrant, and then i asked oleksandr miched to help me. to adapt all the literary part that we use in this film, he adapted everything very coolly, and already in the reference album,

which we started working on in the 17th year, ukrainian texts finally began to appear, in which i simply felt some more stable ground, that i can, i can, now the musicians themselves are ready to share the experience of transitioning to ukrainian and shchi... support others in this, you listen, you here, yes, we know distance and angle, we can know height, range, angle, height, protect people, defend cities, stop, you have already flown away, stop, and count to 100, communicate more, read ukrainian, translate everything into ukrainian their gadgets, in everyday life to talk, understanding that russian now can really traumatize some people, it's just respect for all other ukrainians who are now with you in

one or another space, well, in transport, on the street and so on, even a year ago it seemed like it was possible to release some tracks now make texts shoot a movie, and now look, some books have already been announced, some films have already been shot, there are whole albums, that is, this process is happening, the labels are working, the existence of culture during the war is generally a very important function, because when a person surpasses something other than the biological, begins to be created... its certain identity, some identity of this people living in this territory, the first thing the invaders who come to our lands do, what they do,

they cross out the letter i in the name of mariupol and they put russian there and, burning books, it is very eloquent, because they very precisely cut out... the meaningful component, the cultural component, the essence of ukrainianness for the people who live here, if it is so important for our enemy, to destroy our identity, i i do not understand why the people who live in this territory of the ukrainian people, the question of preserving and flourishing culture, even during the war, remains a question, there are some physical things, such as preserving that and there is the preservation of meanings, gnashing your teeth, but bringing culture to the end cancel, buy the first post-war book. according to the musicians

, it is important not only to realize the negative influence of russian culture, but also to get rid of the feeling of inferiority in relation to ukrainian possessions. for many years, ukrainian culture was in the shadows of russian culture, because it is much stronger, it is much more influential, this is how it happened historically, and for many years, it dominated, very often ukrainian musicians were invited to warm up russian headliners, because they had to be present at all concerts, festivals, dj at parties, because of course, it is cooler to bring them from there, from somewhere, ours, well , they are always there, they can always be called last. so, now we have a unique opportunity, er, to finally get rid of this influence, grandiose, which was being built up

for millennia, it is necessary. it uses the varniakan project continues to record complex and painful emotions in candid songs, as well as to collect concerts. yes, these are scratches, they will always be there in the winter, unfortunately. artists during the war, if they have something to say, they should not be silent, but they should share it. we don't stop working. on to our victory, you can't get tired, you can't switch gears, because the victory is still very, very far, but it will definitely be, glory to ukraine, goodbye friends, have a quiet, calm evening, we will definitely see each other, it seemed to me that now is a bit out of time, well, to be creative, in its purest form, but documentary filmmakers told me

that they don't think, but just...' camera and start filming everything that is happening around now, well i roughly acted in the same way, if musicians capture feelings in songs, then cameramen and directors create documentary video evidence of modern times. we also talked to masters of this genre. you felt this miracle, the interaction of art and its viewer, and it was born. as this is our activity. affects the real reality red will raise our glorious ukraine gay-gay amused, this is footage of babylon 13, a creative association that arose from the first days of the revolution of dignity and became a mirror of these events for ukrainians and the world in general,

the concept was the first time that we do this . the social component during the maidan there, yes, and what will it tell the world there, that these are not some radicals there or there, well, because we are showing ordinary people, yes, and where and when did we decide that we had to go? literally after a week it became clear that in fact what we do is primarily needed by these people who are on the square , that is, they see themselves, and they perceive it, what they do, the artists of babylon 13 in a completely different way helped the participants of the protests to understand their experience, it helped many not to lose faith and move on.

towards a common goal, on the one hand, there are some reports there, and on the other hand, they see themselves as part of some reality that has already happened, some document, some cultural space of this maidan, and through they perceive themselves in a different way. babylon 13 has been around for almost 10 years. today, they are recognized in the world of cinema and continue to release films about the russian-ukrainian war. we have such a rally, we have installers here, we have a place there where we store equipment, a place where we built a server, after all, they are very powerful. from the first days of the war in eastern ukraine in 2014, babylon-13 documentarians filmed the course of hostilities. on february 24, we were, i would say, a sect of

war witnesses. that is, we did about it, babylon's creativity was generally directed primarily at what was happening in the east, and there was a war there, which was first called ato, then oos, that is, these were processes that, for the most part, society, well, somehow it was not ready to talk about it very much to talk, and that, well, that was a big problem, that problem, it turned out to be a lot of problems that now... in fact, and actually , we, we were doing what we said, no, there's a war, there's a kill, there these are the problems, that's how people get hurt here, that's the people who are there fought, they are here now, that is, this process always existed for us, and the threat of russian aggression, it, well, it was not for us too, if it was obvious, we knew that it would happen.