greetings, this is svoboda live on radio svoboda. we have already come to the snake itself. the following shots may shock you. news from the scene, live. drone attacks, kamikaze. political analytics, objectively and meaningfully. there is no political season, exclusive interviews, reports from the hottest points of the front. freedom life frankly and impartially. you draw your own conclusions. verdict with serhii rudenko, now in a new two-hour format. even more analytics, even more important topics, even more top guests. foreign experts, inclusion from abroad. about ukraine, the world, the front, society, and feedback. you can express your opinion on the bad day by phone.

survey, turn on and turn on, the verdict with serhii rudenko, every weekday from 20 to 22. on espresso. shelter in the apartment building where i live, can strangers be allowed there? yes, during an alarm , people who do not live there can and should be allowed into the shelter of the house, because everyone has the right to civil protection, even if the person is not your acquaintance. everyone has the right to be safe. my people are, my people will always be, no one will cross out my people, all the werewolves and strays and hordes of conquerors of the wilds will disappear, you bastards of satanic cats, don't forget the bastards are nowhere, my people are, in their hot veins, cossack blood pulsates. and hums

good evening, we are from ukraine, we continue, and i invite oleksandr morchyvko to the conversation, money during the war. oleksandr, congratulations, you have the floor, please, congratulations viewers, congratulations to vasyl on the economic blockade, and also scanning urban planning. i will talk about this in detail in a moment. i am oleksandr morchyvka, congratulations, this is a column about money during the war. i'll start with a hot topic. polish farmers joined the blockade of the border with our country. therefore, on november 23, they will hold a three-day action at the medic shegenni checkpoint. lukash martyn, one of the organizers of the protest, told bloomberg about this. in this way, farmers will block the fourth checkpoint on the border with ukraine. another three polish carriers were paralyzed by a strike. it has been 10 days, they remind us that it is necessary.

review certain regulations, our trucks are blocked, queues have stretched over dozens of kilometers, so they say that they are hindered by excessive competition after the liberalization of international transportation between ukraine and the countries of the european union, and vasyl, in addition to the fact that products spoil there, and fish, but today our journalists talked on the air, talked with carriers, there is a lot of food there for tens of thousands of euros, they will simply disappear in these trucks, but we already have certain results, at least they were announced by the director of the a95 consulting group , serhii kuyun said that blocking the polish border led to a shortage and a 30% increase in autogas prices, an increase, he noted that the queues at the border are to blame for this , because carriers made significantly

fewer trips with fuel. well, ukrainian carriers also blocked the border for polish trucks. the action was held at the krakivets korchova checkpoint. they say it is a sign of solidarity with thousands of colleagues who now they are forced to stand in multi-kilometer queues on the polish side. there, local carriers are demanding a review of european legislation. well , the situation is complicated, because another border is blocked. on the territory of slovakia, transporters blocked the movement of trucks through the vyshne-nemetske checkpoint, this was reported to the state border service, the blocking of traffic was initiated by the slovakian transporters' union. the timing of these restrictions does not specify when the promotion will end, it is not known, but just let's hear what was said from this reason, direct speech. we cannot understand how exactly we create competition for them, because we do not have the right to...

transport in europe, we can do from ukraine to europe, for example, from ukraine to poland, ukraine, germany, ukraine there, i i don't know, denmark, and back and forth, but a polish carrier can carry out transportation within europe, and this is allowed, since they are members of the european union, so we are definitely not their competitors, this is what we want to convey with today's action. we monitor the situation and move on. ukrainian economy this year will grow by almost 6%, although this growth will slow down in the future. such a forecast was voiced by the head of the concord capital investment company ihor mazepa in an interview with forbes. he says: "we did not return to the 90s only because for us..." economically and militarily , our western partners fit in. the top manager also added that the increase in the public sector now exists instead of privatization, and the pressure on business from the state continues. also, according to the estimates of concord capital, the military expenses of our state for the current 10 months

reached the mark of 86 billion dollars, which is 6 billion more than last year. well, here it is only necessary to say that with the beginning of the large-scale invasion, the economy of ukraine fell by 30%, if i am not mistaken, so this is growth, we are returning it, we are not even returning, we are trying to roll back what is already, we are recovering, crimea the economy is recovering, and perhaps in the coming years, this growth will be really moderate, insignificant, as the head of concord capital says, but there are also forecasts of international experts, the world bank, the imf, well, significant growth the verkhovna rada appointed a new head of the state property fund. he is the head of the rivne military administration vitaliy koval. people's elected representative yaroslav zheleznyak announced this. the corresponding decision was supported by 279 deputies. let me remind you that earlier this position was headed by rustem umyerov, who was appointed

minister of defense back in september. businesses in germany are ready to attract our refugees to work as soon as possible. the ukrainians have already passed the integration course, said the minister of labor of germany, hubertus gail. he emphasized that it is necessary to attract people to work faster than now. employment of refugees should become a priority. any opportunity to employ ukrainians is better than leaving them on social assistance. this was reported, in particular, by the german employers' association. and the blackout is not terrible. the german government and the european union will allocate funds for the construction of five more energy-independent hospitals. this is stated in the message of the german fund giz ukraine. medical facilities are built from modular structures according to european energy saving standards.

equipped with autonomous solar power plants, as well as diesel generators. the first such hospital has been operating since september this year in lviv, now it's the turn of dnipro-petro. mykolaiv, sumy, zaporizhzhya and chernihiv regions. over 572 million hryvnias of grant funds were paid to farmers for the development of horticulture and greenhouse farms. 134 ukrainian agricultural enterprises received the money within the framework of the state program yerobot. they will direct them to the development, among other things, of berry growing and vineyards let me remind you that the yebot initiative is a program. micro-grants for the opening or development of one's own business, in particular, the creation of processing enterprises. ukraine cannot implement urban planning reform and must strengthen cooperation with local authorities. this is stated in the report

of the european commission, which outlines our country's path to joining the european union. what is the problem and what is the role of the government and local self-government here, what is the conflict, we will talk about it. with the guest of our studio, iryna fedoriv, ​​a journalist, joins conversations, good evening, good evening, mrs. iryna, well, the topic has been going on for some time, last year the espresso tv channel was monitoring the development of events, but there is no development as such, because europe is blocking, well, urban planning reform, ukrainian deputies are trying to advance some legislative initiative, and what is the conflict here, why are there no such... local authorities, well, the authors of the legislative initiative, and why does the european union not accept the changes? well, it's all very simple, because when the bill was created, it

were done in the interests of developers, but the interests of local self-government, the interests of citizens and the communities that live in them should have been taken into account, for example, if in germany there is no detailed plan of the territory, then the reason is that the community did not plan any development there, but in our country , the legislators, and i will remind you, submitted the draft law the head of the servant of the people party, olena shulyak, believes that, well, if the community does not have plans here, then the developers can build what they want, that is, if you take the european model and ours, well, it 100% cannot work in normal european conditions, when voice community and local self-government is not heard, and of course, when they give us their resources for reconstruction, and it is the taxpayers of their countries who pay the money, they are interested in ensuring that the funds are not stolen here, and what the legislators proposed to do is private control, not state control, it does not eliminate corruption, corruption... there will be, it will simply be transferred from the public sector to the private sector, and it turns out that there will be less

responsibility for this corruption, and then they will tell the western partners, and you see, corruption in our country has decreased, but she remains, well and that is why the western partners understand that they are being sold a very old piece of candy in a beautiful wrapper called urban planning reform. ms. irina, as i understand it, there were suggestions from the public, from experts, whether the legislators took these suggestions into account. or just ignored them? well, when proposals were submitted for the meeting of the committee , which is chaired by the same mrs. shulyak, who heads the servant of the people party and submitted this draft law, they could not get to the zoom meeting of the committee, here is the draft bill, it promotes digitization, then they could not press the button in the zoom to attach, and of course, our recommendations were ignored, as far as i know, the recommendations of the architects. and other sectors of the association of cities of ukraine were also not taken into account, and everyone should understand this, and i emphasize

that the transcripts, which should have been recorded and displayed publicly on the website of the verkhovna rada and on the website of the committee, are still missing, and there are already cover themselves with whatever you want, blackouts, that they cannot be reproduced, but when we got the text of the transcript and there were people's deputies talked about the fact that we could not read these thousands of pages, how should we vote for it, then they tell us, well, it's chernetko. ms. iryna, what is the alternative, currently this is the only legislative act that is proposed to be signed by the president? well, which one is offered, yes , but the work of the working group is currently ongoing, a working group has been created in this committee, it is headed by anna bonddar, a people's deputy from the servant of the people, the maximum number of stakeholders has already been involved, the maximum... number of parties from all sectors and public organizations, architects

, and the association of cities of ukraine, and everyone gives their suggestions, and we all hope that this working group will work fruitfully and propose the urban planning code to the verkhovna rada, and it will be an important big document. well, the situation is really difficult, but some advice is possible and some possible, well , there are such decisive steps on the part of the european union, because the draft law is really needed. they are waiting for him in the european union, and there is no answer, or simply, as they give, they will give, as they let us analyze in the eu, that is how we will analyze, that is, the urban planning reform, well, the draft law that exists clearly inhibits urban planning reform, if the committee, instead of working closed, involved citizens and took into account proposals, then the country would have urban planning reform, but this did not happen, and we see... such a unique phenomenon as a separate

government website with the goua domain for this urban planning reform 565, well, our european partners, parliamentarians, the public, the media see this, and we understand that they are trying to sell this low-quality product to partners, but we were clearly told in resolutions of the european parliament, the european commission in its report that this cannot be allowed, that is, in fact, it is mrs. shulyat's fault that she did not involve people, she slowed down the reconstruction of the country, well, in fact, for several years, because she worked on this draft law for several years , and the whole parliament sincerely believed that we would have an urban planning reform, and now we have a shame at the international level, when the international partners who give us resources put one red line after another that we cross. thank you for the conversation, iryna fedoriv, ​​the journalist was in touch with us, these changes are really important, vasyl, they are important, because now the funds of international partners are going to reconstruction, essentially from points, and the legislation, which should be adapted to european requirements, is still in the works.

for a second, i see, and now they are already taking bribes from people who want to get money for reconstruction, but as i understand it, with certain kickbacks and to put in their own pockets, so the problem exists, it is open, i will complete the release , but the big broadcast continues, more to come, watch us. thanks to oleksandr morchyvka, we continue, and now we will invite serhii rudenko to the conversation, he will tell you what will be discussed in the verdict program, which starts at 20:00, serhii, congratulations, good evening. good evening vasyl, today, as always, we have a two-hour broadcast, starting at 8:00 p.m. and continuing until 10:00 p.m. in the first part, we will have the diplomat and politician valery chaly. let's talk about the visits to ukraine by two defense ministers, germany and the united states of america, as well as how germany and the united states americans are looking at the future

of the russian-ukrainian war. there are many signals for zelsky, there are many signals for partners working in the west, and meanwhile they want to see lavov at the osce ministerial conference in skopje, and tomorrow putin is speaking at the g20 virtual summit in india, and these are also signals for world, what these signals mean, i hope that the former ambassador of ukraine to the united states of america, valery chally, will explain to us in the second half of the program how...' it will start at 21:15, immediately after the bbc news broadcast, there will be three people's deputies. oleksiy kucherenko, andriy osatchuk, and we will also have oleg synyutka. actually, here are three people's deputies, we will talk on the day of freedom and dignity, about why this day today turned into

a day of corruption, because today three people's deputies of ukraine were handed over. suspicions of involvement in corruption, in bribery, because they tried to bribe officials, why despite everything, despite 10 years that have passed since the day of dignity, freedom and dignity, the beginning of the euromaidan, why are we still fighting this evil, with corruption, which volodymyr zelensky promised to equate it with high treason, the draft law did not reach the verkhovna rada. but the number of corrupt people has not decreased either, although zelenskyi constantly repeats on international platforms that there is zero tolerance for corruption in ukraine. why, despite the zero tolerance for corruption , should the corrupters be rowed, as the people say. we will talk about all this with three people's deputies of ukraine. we start in 13 minutes,

so wait for the big verdict, and the big evening with the donkey. it continues, vasyl, you have the floor, thank you, 20:00, program verdict by serhii rudenko, don't miss it, and now i will give the floor to lina chocheny, but first i will tell you what will be discussed today in our cultural, our cultural column, the revolution of dignity and culture. euromaidan became an incredible push for ukrainians to understand the importance of culture and their own culture. over time, during this time , an incredible number of transformations and changes took place, which continues to this day. lina chuchennina, our art viewer, will tell about them on a specific example, on which lin, please tell me, i congratulate you, good evening. vasyl, congratulations to you, greetings to our viewers, ukrainian culture has undergone absolutely colossal changes, positive ones, of course, but let's talk specifically about cinema, i think, using the example

of a comedy called donjonna yashkova, i will be able to perfectly explain what these changes how they happen and what we do not agree with each other, literally in a moment. so, friends, donjuan from zhashkov, the trailer for this film is now on youtube, you can watch it, this is one of the most expensive projects that i have supported the state cinema in recent years, and i... i want to say that the revolution of dignity really started a surge in the development of ukrainian cinema and we started going to see ukrainian films not because we want to support ukrainian culture, but simply because there were a lot of very good reviews, and now we see, we see this film in general, it will be a comedy about a certain

hero, a photographer, who, well, i understood from the description, is looking for himself, but on... the authors say here and are trying to find, there will probably be sad and funny, but i want to say that since we saw jidzi , we have reason to think that this film will collect a good box office at the cinema, why, because jidzi has already proven several times that he has loyal fans, and if he films some tape, if he is filmed in some tape, then a lot of people come to see it, well, this is one of those moments of the development of ukrainian cinema, ukrainian cinema, and starting from 2013, it even started to be profitable, thanks to such to artists, like a dragon, which has a big one the audience, well, for now... we are waiting for this film, i will say that its director, viktor butok , has not yet been seen behind any successful, big films, he shot a short film, you can watch some

excerpts, and his films all, almost all of his films were russian-language, and here is another problem that we are currently facing, these are directors, in general, cinematographers and producers of tv series, who for a long time could not tear themselves away from the russian market and stubbornly cooperate with it... now, of course, when they undertake to do something, especially patriotic, god forbid, they rely on some ruskomir ideas, yes, just as we recently had a scandal with a tv series about a girl from a village, kolomyia, this village is, according to the authors, the village is imagined by the authors as very stereotypical, it is ruscomirsk, so very backward, i don't know whether mr. viktor remained with such ideas. that he had them, we will look at it on the example of his film when it comes out, but the most important thing in this film was nadiya maker, i think you remember her well, she took

participation was a member of such a group as viagra, and well, nadiya, nadiya, here she was, that was a famous singer, well, vyagra performed in russia, but then everyone performed, but such a story happened with her, after a full-scale invasion, she . she only recorded a video addressing the russians at first, then all such videos were recorded, and then she simply disappeared from instagram, her page is closed, she deleted all the posts, all because she has a russian husband, a russian businessman who lives further in russia, and who is not going to leave and abandon his business, but let's hear what hope said at the beginning of the full-scale invasion?

well, yes, for sure, i see that we won’t hear it, but that’s not the case, after all, she wrote a very similar appeal to the russians, our other stars wrote, they said that let’s go out on the streets, think about it, and we have a war and that’s it other things, as we can see, no one organized any rallies in russia and so on, but here is nadiya maker, now she is in the cohort of those people, famous ukrainian people, who are silent about the war and we will watch movies with her too, this is such a very ambiguous situation, because on the one hand we are trying to cancel them, on the other hand, well, listen, don't throw away this movie, especially, for example, on ukrainian television, a tv series called the house was released for two seasons. the actress halyna bezruk participated there, who is also silent about the war in russia, she has a husband and a son there, but don't throw out two seasons of the series. let me also remind you that during all these years, we

have seen enough of these, enough of so many ambiguous situations, if any absolutely, pro-putin actors appeared in ukrainian films because they had time to film before the revolution of dignity. and they did appear on our screens, such as the film peace to your house, there was an actor who signed, remember, when the russians occupied crimea, he acquired such a letter from among the artists who signed, approving this act, and literally, then, literally two years later, the tape with him was released in ukrainian distribution and even opened the youth film festival, this is the story, until now we we are raking in this cooperation with russia and russian peace in our culture, but i think that in... a few years we will finally overcome it. vasyl very lazy. lina chchennina told her story, and in just a moment we will now hear about the weather, what

it will be like in ukraine tomorrow, where it will snow, where the frost will hit, winter actually in prose. mrs. natalie, i congratulate you, good evening and please tell us about what kind of weather, what kind of weather we should expect tomorrow, congratulations to vasyl, congratulations, dear viewers, we will talk, of course, about the weather and not only about the weather as usual, it's all literally in a moment. the frosts came to ukraine, we felt it all very well, and therefore we will now talk with you about the frost-free period, how long it lasted and , in general, whether it was late or early, according to the data, of course, the official data of the central geophysical observatory named after borys sreznevskyi in the capital in kyiv

is frost-free. the period ended on november 18, it was on november 18 that the air temperature dropped, well, that is, it still reached, or how to say it correctly, dropped below zero, oh, and our frost-free period lasted from march 31, the average multi-year date of the first frost in the air is october 21, the duration of the frost-free period is 197 days. climatologists of our observatory inform us that the shortest frost-free periods in the capital were in 1902 and 1945, and the record-long 232 days , set now, the previous record held , just for the time being, well, that is, we last year, just a year, and of course, despite to the fact that winter has already clearly reminded of itself, its official, such debut will take place when

there will already be a permanent, permanent transition of the air temperature to... towards zero and a decrease in the average daily air temperature, that's when we can safely say that the real winter has already arrived, and for now it's still november and autumn, albeit with snow, well, we go further and talk about magnetic activity, now for your attention is a forecast chart, and now it is clear that tomorrow it is expected to have increased magnetic activity, magnetic storms, so please, who reacts to this, feels, reacts negatively especially with it is clear that pay attention to this forecast, and actually we return to the weather forecast, to the highlight of our column and talk about what it will be like in the coming days. traditionally, we start, we start our forecast from the western regions of ukraine, and tomorrow, in the western part of ukraine, rain and sleet are expected, the air temperature, as you can see, is somewhere in the low minus range, and

traditionally, more in zakarpattia and also tomorrow in chernivtsi oblast, in the north of ukraine, tomorrow will also be cold, at night somewhere between three and five, maybe in the outskirts and up to 7° of frost, in sumy region, maybe even lower, on a day, as you can see -2 -5, but without significant precipitation, just cloudy. in the east of ukraine, precipitation is unlikely tomorrow in kharkiv oblast, but in lughan oblast and donetsk oblast, it will snow tomorrow, the air temperature is low, even during the day, you see -4, in luhansk oblast, donetsk oblast, in kharkiv oblast, even during the day it is about 7° of frost . in the central part of ukraine, wet snow is possible tomorrow, in places, however, the air temperature will range from one to 4 degrees of frost. in the southern part of ukraine, because it the southern part of ukraine, it is traditionally warmer there, it will be the same tomorrow, as you can see, somewhere around 4-8, well, it is much warmer in the crimea.

therefore, the precipitation will mainly be in the form of rain, but still, when the air temperature drops and approaches zero, these rains can also turn into sleet, even in the south of ukraine. and in kyiv, tomorrow the weather is expected to be cloudy, significant precipitation is not expected, cold, at night up to -4x -5, during the day tomorrow the maximum, about 2° of frost. this is the nearest synoptic situation that awaits us, and i... of course, i congratulate everyone from today's day of dignity and freedom. i thank natalka didenko, and at the very end i just want to join in the congratulations that she voiced, from 10 years since the beginning of the revolution of dignity, well, actually what has turned into a war and continues, the struggle of ukrainians and for dignity, for

the right to be ukrainians on this earth. many thanks. to everyone who actively participates in this struggle. thank you for being with us, in a few moments, the verdict program, let's watch together. good evening, we are from ukraine. glory to ukraine, this is the verdict program, my name is serhii rudenko, i congratulate everyone and wish everyone doro- health. in the next two. hours on your screens verdicts, we talk about the war, about the world, about victory, about ukraine, about everything that you talk about among yourselves, dear friends, well, today in the program, the situation on the battlefield and not only that on unexpected visits to kyiv, austin ipistorius, about the infamous attempt on life and