actually from germany and from france, in particular , the chinese automobile industry has grown in many ways, due to its own cooperation with china, oh, china with germany, first of all, secondly with france. mr. volodymyr, let's return to ukraine and what is happening in ukraine, today the supreme commander-in-chief's rate was held and, as zelensky says, it was important. and difficult, because it was about mobilization, about demobilization, let's listen to what zelensky said, a significant part of today's meeting was devoted to of the set of questions regarding which our soldiers and the whole society expect fair answers, it concerns mobilization, ongoing mobilization, rotation in the armed forces of ukraine, questions about conscripts. who were

drafted before the start of a full-scale invasion. of course, special attention was paid to the situation with the work of the vlk and military committees, what the soldiers are talking about, what the teams are talking about must, must be resolved. today, in this regard, there were the first reports by chief of staff zaluzhnyi, minister of defense umerov, minister of internal affairs klymenko, minister health care lyashka. chief of the general staff of shaptala, i expect a more meaningful study of each of these issues, both by the government and the military, and specific proposals regarding state decisions. well, while zelenskyi was recording the video, and we were listening to it, danilov went on the air of ukrainian radio and said that inmates who have served the required term will be demobilized, i will quote a secret of

the national security and defense council. a meeting of the supreme commander-in-chief was held today, and a lot of attention was paid to this issue so that we rightly dealt with the issue of adding to our army those people we need for the country's defense capability. as for the mobilization of people who have completed military service, the president asked and the military agreed that these people will be demobilized in the near future, this process will take place and we understand how many... there are, danilov said. in front of you, mr. volodymyr, i spoke with a crooked nose, he generally says mobilization until the time there is martial law in ukraine, there is no need to speak at all, because, as a military man, he says, yes, this is not, it should not be done, in your opinion, in this situation, where there is that limit of justice and necessity, when people. have served and

cannot return from the army, and some people have not yet gotten there. well , in general, to be honest, the actions of the single marathon and this corruption in the government, it quite significantly turned people against, well, let's say, against their willingness to sacrifice their lives for the sake of the country. then. a time when troops are at war, when, well, there are losses, such, someone in power makes a pretty good living, and the power itself is not very reacts to this, that is, there is no justice in the plan to pursue looters, persecute, crimes in the government itself , instead, the government wants people to be ready to sacrifice their lives for the country, first of all,

it would be necessary to establish a more honest work with the military in the plan payment, compensation, because we have a wounded military hospital and receives 600 hryvnias per month. these are things that should be fixed in the first place, you don’t hear anything, look, just in one and a half years of the war, how many times the military payment system was changed, how the authorities constantly tried to to save the military, we know very well that today many soldiers simply use their money to buy fuel for cars, repair cars, buy clothes, sometimes food and the like, that is, there is provision, but such disparities occur when, well, without the help of volunteers it is difficult for the troops to survive, now no matter how much the government feeds us with these ambitious programs, an army of drones, but when

you read the reports of the military about the use of drones and the success, for some reason, thanks all the time volunteers for the provided drones, but where are the drones under the drone army program, for example. well, it seems to me that after all, the state in its relations with the army should be based on clear and honest principles, and not on the kind of infighting that happens very often. then all these medical commissions fall into... such a system of humiliation and contempt that they begin to curse everything and everyone, that is, a person who sacrificed himself for the sake of the country's independence must feel, well, upon leaving

for example, in retirement, in connection with an injury, especially, to feel respected and needed, and not abandoned, when only relatives, the closest must collect medicine to maintain the health of a former soldier, this is primarily a war - it is about justice and when there is talk of alleged injustice towards those who are not yet in the army and injustice towards those who have been in the army for too long, that there is no rotation, here you just need to build honest principles, because otherwise, when for each territory, so say... there is a form of encouragement, how many people, well, will enter the army, how many will be mobilized, not taking into account the level of the economy of these territories, very often, that is, it directly depends, well, the quality of the economy

of the territory from the number of mobilized from one or another territory , but the pddfo was taken away, but look, in those cities where there are many soldiers, there are a lot of pdtfo, now many ... soldiers from the war are starting to come back wounded, they need quality treatment, money from the pdf, in local self-government bodies, goes to maintenance and schools, and hospitals or clinics, and here we see that the more people are fighting, the more the pdf is taken from them for the central needs of the central government, people come back wounded from going to the hospital, and there the quality of these hospitals is such that they have to pay for it at their own expense, is this fair, well, there is a lot of injustice , you are absolutely right, mr. volodymyr, especially when they start to accuse top officials of corruption, in particular the state intelligence service, and that they buy some kind of software and

use it to make 62 million hryvnias just on the spot, well then it arises question, a what kind of money is this, if this money , which was taken from local budgets and they say that it goes to, and it turns out that it goes not to the war, but simply to the development of these, mr. serhiy, with the state special liaison with chigol, this is it an even more shameful story, because it was the state intelligence service that delayed the certification of the latest software, and the military uses windows 7, windows 10, which are simply morally so outdated that it is simply a disaster, and where does this person get 60 million, money , there are many questions, absolutely, we have answers to all questions, of course we won't find it. let's put an end to this, mr. volodymyr, i will once again remind our viewers that tomorrow there will be a presentation of my book, my book battle for kyiv, one of the heroes, as you can see, is volodymyr

tsibulko, who survived the occupation near kyiv, i also wrote about him , this presentation will take place in lviv at 7 svoboda avenue, this is a bookstore... yes, come, let's chat , let's talk about this book, about the heroes and about what happened in february, march 22 , near kyiv, friends, i also remind you , that we conduct a survey, we ask you about such as, can ukraine make compromises with russia in order to end the war, now let's see what the results of the poll we have on the phone, i can say that on youtube right now at the moment... 18% said that it is possible to go, 82% that no , in a telephone survey on the tv channel 15% that it is possible to make some compromises for the sake of ending the war, 85, no, categorically, well, i will put an end to this in the first part

of our program, in 15 minutes we will meet in the same studio, no tune in, we will have the best journalists of ukraine on the air, olga len, bohdan butkevich and maryna danylyuk yarmalayeva, please wait. greetings, dear viewers, on the tv channel studio zahid program, we will analyze the most important events of this week and try to predict how the situation may unfold in the near future. our guests today are retired british army colonel glen grant and former head of yushchenko's administration oleg rybachuk. our first guest is oleg rybachuk. former vice prime minister for european integration of ukraine. yushchenkovskyi's ex-chef secretariat, the founder of many public organizations, in particular, the legendary movement

honestly. glory to ukraine, paneg, i congratulate you. glory to the heroes, congratulations. well, putin's extremely strange speech at the g20 meeting, joseph biden was not there. xi jinping refrained, and accordingly, putin began to issue yet another fake, maybe not fake, signals that maybe russia is ready for one or another negotiation, yes, well, and further, all for the method. that they say ukraine is not ready and so on and so forth. the key story, we understand, is the withdrawal of the russian invaders from our country territory and compensation, whether in the form of reparations or in the form of a contribution, this is already such a thing, well, it is not the first time that putin, in my opinion, has been repeating this mantra for a year that it was ukraine that left the negotiations, waving a piece of paper that was there signed, apparently in istanbul, but he never says what he means, peace, what he means... what the negotiations are about, what the essence of the negotiations is, he does not reveal this to anyone, but from other sources ,

we know that russia wants to leave behind , the conquered territories, it wants to ukraine refused membership in nato in order to, well, in fact, to lose our sovereignty , there is nothing new about this, but the timing of the speech is not accidental, because putin very rarely has such platforms now, russia was once a member. now, as you said, two key states, because it is very symptomatic that at the meeting between shidzimpin and biden, they said that the globe is big enough, there is enough room for two, and the third is extra, and about what in the world there are three there, or two superpowers or two poles, languages, there is no language, just a lot it is symbolic that russia was thrown out of, from such poles, thrown out of the big geopolitical schedule, yes, putin would like to return, in particular through war and

confrontation, he did not succeed, and the world war was localized as russian aggression against ukraine, although we it is not easier for the other side, well, we hoped that president biden and xi jinping would be able to agree on something, so to speak, in particular about how to put pressure on putin, well, but it was quite, well, symbolic, painful and insulting, when ...' it is clear that with the appearance of putin, at least in online mode, at the meeting of the twenty-two, shijin pinen and biden simply did not take part, this cannot be understood as just a very powerful signal, and all the more so that at the very meeting of biden and shijin pinen, they demonstrated a desire to somehow agree on the world the rules of the game, it is clear that putin really has no place there, but he did not offer anything new, he is trying to work on...' the big south, sending them a signal that russia has always been for peace, that

russia opposes colonialism, imperialism , and he is also trying to push the west to do something with ukraine, because i am for peace, it is necessary to sit down at the negotiating table, this is probably not what putin is doing for the sake of a good life, but for me it is not something there news, and why is he lying, well, he won't convince president biden, he won't convince the ukrainian people, he won't... convince xi jinping, well, he won't convince anyone, serious players who support ukraine, such a key story - this is the withdrawal of russian interventionists, a lie that breathes, is it his, or is he already in that state, when, you know, there is such a state, when what you are talking about there, you begin to believe it yourself and live in this world, but recently, somewhere there , ilarionov gave an interview, and when he was asked, he worked there for six years with putin as an academic advisor. and to the question, who is putin, he said that putin is extremely responsible

and works with documents, he checks everything, he is so, well, thorough, yes, so to speak, when he is already doing something, he reconsiders all options , this means that to count on the fact that he has some, well, i don't know, mental shifts, that he falls under some misinformation, no... it doesn't matter, it's impossible, and it's not worth it, most likely, it became part of his worldview, well, he he is no longer young, and he suddenly fell into his own world, from which he no longer emerges, he has lost this connection with reality, with our reality, reality in the sense that we understand it, as the world understands it , he it seems that he can achieve some kind of change with the methods he demonstrates, and the lie has become his for him the truth, and accordingly, how can our friends act now in the current situation, i do not dare to call

the people's republic of china our friend now, but maybe after the conversation between president biden... somehow it is possible to push china to some possible more concrete movements, i would not make china our friend or supporter, because what putin believes in, ideology, and what the world should be, what democracy is, how to govern, what should be the agenda, putin and shijinping, in their views are the same, simply china is more pragmatic, china sees what they actually say, putin is not winning this war, and china is good at calculating economic, risks, and profits, and the economic situation in shizin pinya is the most difficult for many, many years, there is a real economic downturn, there is not enough workers

unemployment, declining birth rates, inflation is rising, and this construction bubble is bursting , which used to be, the construction business used to be very... so rapidly developing in china, all this is a problem for china, and it is again for china and the united states, the european union , the largest trading partners, well, really , looking at the situation, what is happening, shizenpin cannot help but understand that putin is not going to win now, but shizenpin would very much like that at least russia does not lose, that it exits this war weakened, but we are interested there , what you said, will china provide weapons, now... i have much more confidence that they will not do that, that they will, well, provide moral support, there are some other ways, china can there through north korea, through there iran, through some countries, so carefully, carefully, because it is clear to everyone that everything is being monitored now, but we will not see directly, most likely,

military cooperation between china and russia. the american situation is quite delicate now. congress, i am putting it very gently, and at the same time we understand that when the head of the pentagon, the secretary of defense of the united states, lloyd austin, flew to us , accordingly, he also brought some signals that cannot be broadcast, so to speak , even in closed mode special communications, well, me very closely follow what is happening in the united states, i watch their live television programs there every day, they have non-stop coverage of the situation now, of course there now... the events in israel are in the first place, today they have a car exploded there, or yesterday on the canadian border, on the canadian border, that is, some news appears there, but stable attention now is on the war in israel and gas, they have much more, to be honest, than on ukraine, but ukraine is not disappearing in any way out of order

day and you know what's going to be there now they're killing their turkeys over there, how do you say, and turkeys, yes, they have a turkey genocide there, now biden pardoned two, it's very strange, american traditions that on thanksgiving day, on the day thank you, the president gives life to a couple there, or one or two turkeys, but he did, he joked about his age, he recently turned 81, but formally biden, the biden administration, the state department, the department of defense addressed the congress publicly and today i once again listened to the spokeswoman of the white house, who spoke about the fact that for more than a month they submitted to the congress a document on aid to ukraine, israel, taiwan, about documents that are extremely important for

the national security of the united states, it is very important that they don't separate, they don't... they don't fall for this game of dividing aid , they say that these are all linked chains, that it is about national security, for the national security of the united states, it is very important that the forces of autocracy, authoritarianism get a decent fight back, and this, and this is about the struggle for these ideals, there is talk in ukraine, in israel and in taiwan, in particular, and further, the information that comes from the congress, and the senate, it is calmer in the senate, in the senate there bigger there are democrats and the senate is now like this, it is more foreseen in the congress, it is about the fact that they created a working group, half of the republicans, half of the democrats. and this task force will be active after thanksgiving and until christmas until the 25th, from november 23rd to december 25th, with a high

probability that they will agree on why, i say with most likely, because the american, well, they have elections, they are very responsive to the mood of the voters, and recently there was an interesting study that showed that 56% of americans are simply angry about what is called american politics, what is happening in congress, these internal discords, the long speaker row, the fact that intra-party interests are sacrificing the national interests of the united states, and americans are already openly mad, and in every election year it is dangerous, and republicans are even more often criticized for their inability to be guided by national interests because they forget about national interests in the pursuit of their short-term party interests, for them it becomes political, they will give us money, mr. oleg, i

approach the point of giving, not giving them money is politically suicidal, that is, they they can bargain, and they do, they can take a little time, but i don't imagine the situation to be negative, as our partners in the russian pubs say. vote on providing that aid, i repeat that the white house insists that it is about one package, this money to ukraine, israel, taiwan, and that otherwise biden will impose a veto , that is, biden has already demonstrated this readiness, this is a very serious game, and it must also be said that in fact the votes in congress and in the senate are , if the issue of providing aid is put to an honest vote, then such a resolution will have enough votes, it is not that there are no votes, the struggle is to simply not put this issue on the agenda, because the right to put it to a

vote , is in the hands of the speaker, the speaker is now newly elected, he is a republican, in many respects a trumpist, he made certain statements there, but now he must realize that a colossal responsibility falls on his shoulders, and there are already some , to put it mildly, interests or the interests of this small the belligerent faction of the trumpists may take a backseat because the stakes are so high and i don't see how you can not vote for the bailout package that the white house is pushing for, so i'm predicting that they'll reach some sort of compromise there in the task force, maybe there will be some changes most likely, something can be reduced, because we still need to somehow save face, well, reduce something, you know, we have everything calculated, that is, our budget is largely maintained thanks to american aid, that is , we understand that if something decreases, it also decreases in us

, and the key story is whether we will be recredited from where at the macro-financial level, but we are talking about military aid here, first of all, and here i do not think that there may be a decrease, the decrease may be about budget financing, and here we go to be honest, we need it here to think, rethink the budget process, well, but that would require appropriate procedures, meetings and, i don't know, amendments to the already voted budget, but it's not about that , it's about the fact that every year our budget loses, not dozens, if not hundreds , then there are definitely many tens of billions of money that should go into the budget, but do not go into the budget, and we are talking about income from the tax office, about income from the customs service, we are talking about many things that are already frankly... says the ukrainian press, that is, we have such holes in this system, that instead of working for the budget, many officials work for their own

pockets, and this cannot not, cannot not not know about it, well, our president, our office of the president, because things of this scale cannot happen without patrons there are banks on the street, the americans also openly talk about it, remember, we received recommendations. there were three months to start putting things in order, and somewhere literally yesterday, in my opinion, or the day before yesterday, they finally voted on the law on increasing the powers of the anti-corruption bureau, on the special anti-corruption prosecutor's office, that is, as usual, in recent days they have started to stir, but it is about something else, it is about the fact that similar leaks from the budget take place, well, precisely, with the knowledge of those people who hold high government positions, and pritzker, special the representative of the united states on the economy, she spoke about it directly

, she speaks about it directly on... european partners, that is, it is not a question of revising some articles, it is a question of patching those holes from which flows out financial assistance, and we have to think about it quite seriously, it is impossible, with such a system of government, there will not be enough money, and the americans are already directly hinting at this, that listen, you have huge internal reserves, and you want the internal reserves went somewhere in the pockets of ... unscrupulous officials , and we have to compensate you for this at the expense of our taxpayers, here we do not have a very sincere position, we must admit it and work on it, which could bring lloyd austin, chief the pentagon, and we remember that before him the visit was another extremely interesting visit, the visit of the ukrainian delegation to the united states, which was attended by who, the head of the presidential office yarmak, what kind of visits are these, what kind of signals? it's just my first time.

watched yermak, an excerpt of his speech on fox, i couldn’t calm down for two days, well, it’s such a combination of terrible english and terrible body language, i know americans very well, how to work with them, i started working with americans there in the mid-90s x years and started with the fact that when i was invited to a group that led by dzhezynskyi and henry kissinger, not the last americans in american, in the history of american diplomacy, there for several years , i studied there, i know well how to talk to americans, and this is definitely not what yermak does, well, first of all , for the american establishment, the head of the administration, or the chief there, the president's office, the president's chief of staff, is absolutely not a public person who can travel abroad at all, in which delegations, lead some delegations, the vice president can do this, and yermak us himself

and tries to put it as a vice president , but he does not have such powers , nor does he have such specialization experience, that is, he does not really pull out the things that he strives for, and the way he does it causes, well, simply deep rejection, so if we want to improve cooperation, and the americans talk about it frankly, but i was told in direct text at my meetings that, well, advise zelsky not to do this, they meet with diplomatic courtesy, but... yermak still tried to work on the general public, well, it looked very terrible, we need to send to washington completely different, well, i have one question, if the mission is so important, why there, why was there not a foreign minister there, we have a lot of smart diplomats, we have a bunch of deputies with excellent english, we have a number of public figures with excellent english, we have someone to talk to, we need to show washington washington not yet that

we have ... elites who understand, speak and who inspire confidence, with which can be dealt with well, but this tactic of zelenskyi to deal only with his office and all external contacts to conjure up his office , which is incompetent, well, this is just a terrible thing, and lloyd came to us, another story, what he brought, what he is beautiful and convincing spoke, met, we understand all this, but his visit in itself means that he brought something, well, about... what can be, so to speak, not written in press releases, and i would like to decipher what we could to hide behind his visit, we cannot go so deeply, well, there are certain things things, the time when he arrived, he arrived at a time when in ukraine, well , we have autumn now, well, if not depression, then something close to autumn depression, in the ukrainian information space there is a lot of talk about it, muscovites brothers, in every way

they spread the narrative that everything is now, with israel, the world will not be yours, aid will be reduced, they are intensifying the process in congress in every possible way, trying to sow another betrayal, and therefore the time, which was very close to the anniversary of the ukrainian holiday of dignity and freedom, too non-accidental, and the fact that lloyd and the german minister of defense and the president of the european union are there, they are in fact. these last days, they came in such a package, it is also not accidental, that is, in ukraine very much, every diplomat who comes to ukraine, this is his first interview, he says what he came with, and lloyd said about it, and about the german minister also said that, but they came, well, let's be honest, they didn't come just like that, so that their comments were broadcast in a single telethon, we understand, yes, they brought specific ideas, and that's why what...