[000:00:00;00] partners, so that we normalize everything here, but what happened to us , we did not adopt the draft law that was supposed to be adopted , it was written in the budget that from the new year we will pay 70% of the salary, 30% of the bonus, but no one knows which there will be a salary, and panic began in budgetary institutions, they began to draw new departments, new departments , for which, well, the more departments, the more departments, the more managers, which means that a person will have a managerial salary, well, this is not a reform , but a dummy, because in fact we will spend money inefficiently, because they are inflating the staff, for example, we clearly saw at the plenum of the supreme court that even some judges spoke out against such inflating the staff list, and i hope that the ministry of finance will somehow influence this, because by the end of the year they have to issue some documents, a decision on what kind of salaries should we have, well, i wonder if the funds

that you spend on the activities of certain ministries will be mastered, well , the department and everything else will go on there, and why is this money accounted for, are there any possible questions arise to civil servants regarding the bonuses are illegal, again, is this not accounted for, and here so far, whoever was able to do as much as he could, drew as much for himself, well , as of now, everyone draws as he wants, and you cannot calculate what the final result will be the amount, because you don't know the salaries, and when you don't know the salaries, and you create heads of departments and departments, you won't say the final amount of the institution's budget, and when we talked with the deputy minister of finance about how to control it, then they promised that they would see if the institution did not go beyond the limits budget, which is provided to her, but this is a very bad signal that we are ending the calendar year and, in fact, the budget year, and we are entering a new budget year, and we only have unknowns, well

, it cannot be... this is how the civil service lives, it turns out like this , what will we say to our european partners: we have already done 70 for 30, we are well done, of course, they will not look at the state, but what kind of blow will this be to the entire civil service? well, i'll be very brief at the end, and what reforms are proposed, well, again, especially in light of the savings that are needed to the state during the war, when sending money for military needs, perhaps what reforms should be made, well, such timely ones, well, you understand, here are new reforms. it is definitely not possible to add to them, let them deal with the existing ones, because there are challenges that need to be solved, and it is necessary to 100% consider and adopt the laws that are in the verkhovna rada, because the parliament, for example, has kept for its apparatus salaries, and it is clear that other departments will act in the same way, i.e. they just have to cope with what they have to begin with, i definitely would not give them anything new, because it was not mastered, thank you very much for joining,

thank you for your expert comment, iryna. journalist, public activist about the expected reform of the civil service, well, but we see, there are requests from the civil service, but proposals from the civil service, how to satisfy these requests, are completely different, well, but not completely different, and the same yuriy fizar is with us and is ready to talk about the world, about ukraine, good evening, please, good evening to you, vasyl, good evening to everyone who joined us, i will indeed, as always , talk about what happened in the world today, in particular, i will talk about the following, aid to ukraine will continue, putin has already. talks about racism in ukraine, well, north korea brags about the fact that they even took a photo of the pentagon and the white house from space, about this and other things in a moment in the world about ukraine column. but let me start with this: anti-russian sanctions must be maintained until russia stops its aggressive war in

ukraine and withdraws all its troops from our territory. the minister of foreign affairs of japan , yoko kamikawa, said this during a press conference. so she answered the journalist's question about whether tokyo's aid to ukraine is just a waste of money. the minister emphasized that russia's actions violate the world order, which is based on rules, and added a short quote from the head of the japanese foreign ministry. under these conditions , japan... should stop russia's invasion as soon as possible, together with the g7 countries and the world community, resolutely promote sanctions against russia and aid to ukraine. it would seem that this japan is so far away from us, we are separated by many time zones, and nevertheless, they do not give weapons, but the sanctions are kept, strengthened and they say that this is necessary

in order for... world order to be in the world, and the countries that are members of the group themselves, which we are also used to calling the big seven, working on long-term security support for ukraine. this was reported by the minister of foreign affairs of canada, melanie joly. ahead of a meeting with her nato counterparts in brussels, she stressed that her government was the initiator of such discussions, and active work is currently underway to prepare such support. at the same time , the head of the foreign policy department of the wedge leaf country did not specify what kind of guarantees it was about, but promised to tell more about it in the coming days. well, i'm really looking forward to when in the next few days she will go to the journalists and make public, if not the list, then at least several items from this list, well, but a little more veil of secrecy opened the mystery of

what i just said, actually not me, and the minister of foreign affairs of canada, the minister of foreign affairs of france revealed, also before the start of the meeting with colleagues in brussels, which i have already mentioned, panic... colona said that the primary goal is to ensure guarantees of long-term support for ukraine in three directions. the first is economic, the second is humanitarian, the third is military. the latter involves, in particular, the training of the military and providing them with the necessary equipment for victory. well, here is a short quote from minister katrin kolona. france has started discussions with ukraine, they have been going on for several years weeks and progressed well peace. we expect to complete them at the end of this year or at the very beginning of next year. that is, the work is already in progress, we have to wait very little long

before we learn the results of this work. the hostilities in ukraine may intensify in the near future, and therefore it is necessary to intensify the assistance and provision of military support to our armed forces. this was said by the secretary general of the alliance, jens stoltenberg, before the start of the meeting of foreign ministers of the member countries in brussels. he emphasized that he is very careful to predictions about how the situation on the battlefield might develop, since wars are by their very nature unpredictable. but he added that in any case, the countries of the north atlantic alliance should continue to help ukraine. and then we listen to jens. in direct speech. it is our duty to provide ukraine with the weapons it needs, because it will be a tragedy for ukrainians if president putin wins, but it will also be a danger for us, because then the message

to all authoritarian leaders, not only in moscow, but also in beijing, will be such when they violate international law, when they invade another country, when they use force, then they get what they want, so it's about the whole and rules-based international order that respects territorial boundaries. by the way, in one more interview , but not now to journalists, before or after the meeting with the ministers, jen stoltenberg, in particular in an interview with the hungarian publication index, jen stoltenberg said that nato allies have already allocated financial military aid to ukraine in the amount of 100 billion dollars, and that's it. very and a lot, and he also said, quote: ukraine is now closer to nato, more than ever, and we continue to work on it, in the implementation of the necessary reforms on the way to ukraine's membership in nato, and tomorrow, as i

already did yesterday said, tomorrow there will be a meeting of the ukraine nato council, and the minister of foreign affairs of ukraine, dmytro kuleba, should even attend it, so we will see, well , i think that the most important thing is that they finally put an end to... in those conversations that ukraine is offered to join nato in parts territories, and which parts of the territories may someday somehow return, or may not return, let's say such signals were received , well, in fact, this illusion was dispelled in my opinion, well , jen soltenberg constantly talked about the fact that this is not even discussed, it's not what they said there in different countries, different people from the netherlands, the former head of andrmusen, the head of nato, still like that, well, they were just trying to earn some points for themselves from these conversations, because you know. that some part of society can perceive it and someone may have conducted it research, say, please tell us, they said, and they people recorded that there is no support, they think, well , let's not even touch this topic, that's why ukraine should be in nato, it should be, it will be in nato

completely, so demo further, the chancellor of germany assured us that the aid to our country will last as long as it is necessary for our victory, even despite the problem with the formation of the state budget in germany for the next... year, all because ukraine needs support from berlin , about this olaf scholz said today during a speech in the bundestag that, according to him, aid to kyiv is of exceptional... importance for ukraine itself, which is quite understandable, but mr. scholz says that it is also very important for europe, and here is his short quote: we have spent significant resources on this and are now the second largest donor to ukraine after the usa, it will definitely remain so, and we definitely thank you, and he already said that germany is the second donor after the united states, so it is logical to switch to the united states and till help

which we are waiting for from there, the american congress can allocate aid to ukraine by the end of this year, said mike johnson, the speaker of the lower house of the highest legislative body of the united states, the house of representatives, during a trip to the south of the usa to the state of florida. according to him, they are currently finalizing a document in which all proposals should be taken into account and there is already an agreement on its adoption. at the same time, mr. johnson. who is part of the so-called trump group, said, quote: "we feel the urgency of this because there is deadline, so i'm sure we can do it, that's the end of his quote, but more than that, let's hear him speak directly. ukraine is another priority, of course we cannot allow vladimir putin to march through europe and we understand perfectly well the need to provide aid to ukraine, but we have repeatedly. talked about the fact that in order to allocate additional support

to ukraine, which most members of congress believe is important, we also need to change our own border policy. that is, i suggest putting together the puzzles of this puzzle, pieces of this puzzle. yesterday, in the upper house of the american, the upper house of the american congress was told that the bill on support for ukraine, israel, taiwan, as well as on the completion of the border on the fence on the border with mexico will be put to a vote on this bill from december 4, now the speaker of the lower house said that it will be adopted as soon as possible before the new year, so there are some movements, and let's hope that these movements will lead to a result. but hungary, wow, this hungary will continue to defend the rights of ethnic people hungarians living on the territory of ukraine, in particular in transcarpathia. this statement was made by the minister. minister of foreign affairs of hungary peter sziarto during a meeting with the

un high commissioner for human rights volker türk in geneva. according to the head of the hungarian foreign policy department, for his government this is a red line beyond which official budapest will not back down under any circumstances. he reminded that the hungarian government demands to restore the rights of transcarpathian hungarians in the field of culture and education, which they enjoyed until 2015 . well, that is, he demands that in schools taught in the uvro language, on the one hand it is not bad, if it were not for one thing , but anyone who has been to zakarpattia in berehiv district knows very well that if you stop the car, for example, and ask, especially the older generation, to ask something, ask something in ukrainian, then they may not even answer in ukrainian, but younger and middle -aged people, they will... answer in russian, so the younger ones already know

ukrainian better, maybe because it is not possible, namely because this training was implemented, i am interested, by the way, and also the fact that there were inscriptions on the names of ukrainian-hungarian streets, this was back in the day, shufrych once went there and was the minister of transport, in my opinion, it was a long time ago, but i am interested, and orban, he also protects the rights of hungarians in germany, as i understand it, they only have hungarian schools, they study in germany, or in italy or in spain, i think that in hungary , in hungarian absolutely, well, in general, they are citizens of another country, i understand that they are hungarians, we give rights, we do not restrict anyone, but you are citizens, why do you climb to citizens of another country, these are some russian methods, i think that hungarians in hungary are not as protected by orbán as hungarians in ukraine, even more so hungarians in russia are not so protected, probably, by the way, they also probably study hungarian, well, 100% to find out , i think that the rights of hungarians to rosilky uhorska are protected there like nowhere else in the world, so let's move on, it seems that, in addition to the words

russophobia and neo-nazism, the kremlin also knows other smart words and at the same time they use them not where they are needed use. what happens in ukraine, directed not only against the russians, but also against all the peoples of russia, the president of the terrorist country putin said today during his speech at the opening of the world russian people's council. according to him , the way the west treats all the peoples of russia is the result of prosperity. in other countries, russophobia, racism and neo-nazism. it is impossible to overcome the most difficult demographic challenges that we have faced only with the help of money, social payments, allowances, benefits, individual programs, in many thank god, the tradition of a strong multigenerational family is preserved in our peoples, where four, five, or more children are raised,

let's remember that in russian families, many of our grandmothers, great-grandmothers, children had seven, eight, and even more children. let's preserve and revive these wonderful traditions. well, you just heard how putin is trying to correct the demography because many of his compatriots, subordinates were sent to ukraine to fight racism, well, not only racism, nazism, and that's it, have children, ladies are affecting, payments for the family, for health care, for all other things, the growth of social guarantees is frozen there, everything is given to the war, but you give birth, yes. well, let's not talk any further, and it's also very interesting that before this, before the beginning of this council of the russian zemsky sobor, they are, well, russian, but the zemsky spirit called it, it's called, well , there, no, there russian people's council , so before the start of this council, another one was held yesterday, now i'll tell you what it's called, the defense and

security military section, they voted at it, attention, head of the synodal department of the russian orthodox church on interaction with the armed forces and law enforcement agencies, metropolitan kyrylo, the co-head of the section was lieutenant general veyatokhin, i think you understood everything, well, that’s it, here we are talking about the russian orthodox church, well, that’s all for me today in the world about ukraine section, everything is only for today, because tomorrow there will be much more , which vasyl and i will tell you about, but not everything in our further broadcast, in a few minutes, my friend... oleksandr morchevka, as always, will tell you everything in detail from world

of money, so don't switch. hello, this is svoboda ranok, an informational project of radio svoboda. top guests. every day, this is the shipping district, kherson, live inclusion. we are somewhere in the vicinity of bakhmut, we are telling the main thing. on weekdays at 9:00. verdict by the outcast rudenko. from now on in a new two-hour format. even more analytics, even more important topics, even more top guests. foreign experts are included from abroad, about ukraine, the world, the front, society, and also feedback. you can express your opinion on the bad day with a phone survey. turn on and turn on verdict by the outcast rudenko. every

weekday from 20 to 22: espresso. good evening, we from ukraine continue, and now i invite oleksandr morchyvka to the conversation, it's time to talk about money during the war. oleksandr, please, i have the floor, good evening, greetings to the audience, greetings to vasyl, we will traditionally remind you that the international aid of our partners is ongoing, what debates are currently taking place there regarding funding, you will learn about the state budget for next year, and also business can insure , own business during the war, which technology and who will finance it, all in detail in a moment. i'm oleksandr morchivka, congratulations, this is a column about money during the war, so additional funding for ukraine and israel by request. which president joe biden has addressed to congress is urgently needed. this was announced by the coordinator of strategic communications of the national security council of the white house, john

kirby. he noted: approval of the aid package is currently a priority. according to kirby, the financing situation is becoming more and more acute, especially with regard to ukraine. current ones support packages from the states have less funds. he reminded, frost is coming. it has become more difficult for the ukrainian army to conduct operations. military, the weather is getting less favorable, let's get some straight talk. i would like to remind members of congress when they return to work that the numbers in this supplemental request were obtained from our ukrainian and israeli partners. we didn't just pull these numbers out of thin air, they are exactly what our partners have told us they need in the coming months. indeed, vasyl, the expectation is real it is important, the expectation is exciting, in fact

, today volodymyr zelensky signed the state budget for the next year, and it is clear that there is a huge amount, these are funds from international partners, that is, the document is there, but will there be money? well, at least it is good that it is already being said that it can be approved before christmas, because before that there was information about january 14, well, that's another whole month, but in any case we need... guarantees for the whole year , it is quite unpredictable, in fact, well, so far , the macro-financial assistance package also remains stable from the european union, there is also a rate on this money in the budget , well, we follow the debates in the united states, the financing of our state, i also follow consumer lending, an interesting figure appeared, in particular today, since the start of the yeosel program, 5,200 families have already taken home loans, the total loan amount is almost uah 8 billion. 65% of these funds went to military personnel and security forces. these categories

can take a mortgage at a preferential rate, it is 3% per annum. as well as doctors and teachers, and scientists, reported in our ministry of economy. the most frequent loans were taken for the purchase of housing on the secondary market and from the developer, as well as five families took loans for housing that will soon be available. well, let's follow the hot topic. the ukrainian economy lost 400 million euros due to the blocking of the border by a group of polish carriers. these are the data of the federation of employers of ukraine, at the same time several dozen companies, members of the polish ukrainian chamber of commerce have already declared losses in the amount of 100 million zlotys. and about the increase in the costs of their automobiles. what is happening at the border, which are economic losses were analyzed. our correspondents, let's look at the material.

at first glance, the strike of carriers on the polish-ukrainian border has economic prerequisites , there are carriers, there are a number of demands, but if you look in more detail, this partial blockade has all the signs, primarily of a political strike, according to experts and activists in poland, this is evidenced by the , who exactly organized it. this strike was organized by a transporters' committee, which... is not officially registered anywhere, it's just people got together and formed a committee. they formed it in september of this year, that is, already during the election campaign , which was quite active in poland at the time, it was formed by its representatives, the confederation party, and one of the activists of this committee, mr. meckler, is actually an activist of the confederation, an official representative of this party , in this region, where today are held. representatives of the polish confederation party repeatedly expressed anti-ukrainian views during the election campaign, but as a result

, the party received the lowest result on parliamentary elections. the second, no less important point, small transport companies in poland are participating in the strike, these are local transporters, usually small firms, so family-owned, i would say so, there are no large transport organizations, they are really afraid of competition, and they demand, as you know , return to licensing for carriers from ukraine. experts believe that the issue of this group of entrepreneurs could be solved at the local level, the character is very local, and its consequences are felt throughout the country and on international level. however, the strike continues in a strategically important area even during the period when the government is changing in poland. representatives of the polish ministry of transport, several representatives

from the ukrainian side, and representatives from the european side have already met with the protesters. commission and they continue to be unable to find a compromise, here i have suspicions that it is possible, after all, that the representatives of the strike are not talking about the economic part as much as about the political part, because politically, now is a very favorable moment in poland to to conduct such a strike, it is connected with the transition of power, who benefits from a long strike on the polish-ukrainian border, tension in polish-ukrainian relations, financial losses... of both countries and destabilization of the situation in the eu, the answer of the experts is unambiguous. i am convinced that as long as this conflict continues, as long as the blockade is not settled, as long as the trucks are standing at the border, the russian side is getting the most profit from this situation. unfortunately, not poland, not polish carriers, not the polish economy, especially not ukraine, but clearly russia and

russian politicians, whose number one goal today is to isolate. to isolate ukraine from the world, to collapse the ukrainian economy, all those interested in this situation are, firstly , protectionist forces, secondly, nationalist forces, thirdly, forces interested in the deterioration of polish-ukrainian relations, they are working to weaken ukraine, because this situation weakens ukraine, complicates the export of goods from ukraine destined for foreign markets. the polish-ukrainian chamber of commerce believes that the issue of... unblocking the border should primarily be dealt with by the polish authorities, because the blockade is taking place on the territory of poland and the right to freedom of mass assembly of citizens should not bear such huge losses. maria chernyakhivska ihor antoniuk for espresso tv channel from warsaw. well, the plot really confirms the opinion of many experts who voiced their position on the big air, it is really beneficial, first of all, to russia. well,

let's move on and monitor the situation. the verkhovna rada supported the draft law on investment insurance, the new mechanism should become operational from january 1, that is, ukrainian enterprises will have the opportunity to use such a truly unique type of insurance, what kind of tool is it and where will the funds come from? we are in touch with oleksandr bondarenko, managing partner of the bureau of investment programs, good evening, greetings colleagues, mr. oleksandr, here is a really important and long-awaited draft law, the law will come into effect on january 1, really. but i have a question, where will the funds come from, because we see the risks, in particular the industrial region of nikopol region, it suffers like this, almost every day, kherson region, that is, we will have to settle with the victims enterprises, well, these are realities, who is financing it, well, first of all, let's make sure that this product is insurance, it will, in fact,

work for most likely new enterprises that will... be built on the territory of ukraine, that is, it is essentially such an investment incentive, to build something, factories, primarily industrial projects on the territory of ukraine, because currently there is no ukrainian insurance product that would cover these risks, arrival, let's just say, so the issue is really important, and i, as a co-founder of the industry parks in volyn, yes, i am constantly faced with this question, that polish and german companies, they want to come in and build and take advantage of our tax benefits of industrial parks, but really the issue of the lack of military penalties of the ukrainian, ukrainian government stops them, fortunately