espresso. verdict by serhii rudenko, from now on in a new two-hour format, even more analytics, even more important topics, even more top guests, foreign experts, inclusion from abroad about ukraine, the world, the front, society, and also feedback. you can express your opinion on the evil of the day with a telephone survey, turn on and turn on. verdict by serhiy rudenko, every weekday. from 20 to 22: espresso. thank you for waiting, it will be an extremely productive and interesting hour. he is in our studio people's deputy of ukraine, mykhailo tsimbalyuk. first deputy chairman of the verkhovna rada committee on social policy and protection of veterans' rights, lieutenant general of the reserve militia. glory to ukraine. mr. mykhailo, we congratulate you. heroes. glory, congratulations to everyone. well, the key story, yes , the verkhovna rada committee on national security, defense and intelligence, considered the appeal of the people, at least one

from the monomajority and the opposition was an appeal , yes, regarding the recall of ms. bezugluva from the post of deputy chairman of the committee and accordingly do you have any additional information? well, i don't have additional information, moreover, maryana bezugla is the secretary of the working group on drafting bills in the military sphere, to which i have the honor to belong and i represent the motherland faction, and i think that a meeting of our working group will be held next week, where one of the issues is possible, we can discuss this as well, i only want to express my categorical position, i do not at all, during martial law, accept any public discussions regarding the topic, the military, i believe that this should be discussed behind closed doors, experts should comment, and moreover, any

discussion, constructive or not, is not beneficial. moreover, it does not contribute to the consolidation of both the members of the verkhovna rada and the entire ukrainian society. it is very important to draw the line and move on. we have extremely difficult issues before us, this is the issue of developing new bills regarding mobilization and demobilization, this is also discussed at the meeting of the working group. and in the parliament, and we we want to hear the position of the military, er, their final opinion, they are currently developing a proposal, and moreover, we have things that concern the military as well, first of all, regarding the release, demobilization of those persons who are serving today, but are disabled of the first, second groups, cancer patients, etc., that is, there are more urgent issues than discussing who among the people's deputies said what, regardless of which... group, faction, committee, they

belong, by the way, quite scandalous information was made public today that four judges kyiv court of appeal stole the nabu for a bribe and the case concerns boguslaev, the former director of motorsich, in fact, who is currently being tried for treason, including judges yury sliva, viktor glynany, ihor palennyk and vyacheslav dzyubin, as you can. to comment on such arrogance, because ukrainians are not on the sidelines of judges, because ukrainians, well, this is a fresh case, it is not some kind of case, you know, a case that is already buried somewhere and no one knows about it, but this is a very relevant case, a very scandalous case against boguslaev, and here we see that a full-scale war, judges take bribes in our country, as it should be, and even more so this bribe concerns such a scoundrel,

boguslaev, well, first of all, i want to say that honor and praise to our law enforcement agencies, which demonstrate activity in the fight against corruption and crime in the higher echelons of power, it is commendable, but let's wait for the judge's decision on this case, because only the court, the court's decision, which has entered into legal force , can recognize who is a criminal and who is not. but the fact itself is glaring, it hurts to react to it ukrainian society and those guys who are at the forefront today, and i would very much like that the terms of the pre-trial investigation would not be violated, i know that it is not easy when it comes to such specialists in the legal field as judges, moreover, their colleagues have to consider the case

, judges, and it is important for themis to win, for the law to really prevail and the guilty to be punished, the fact that, as the case concerned, the person suspected of... boguslaev's treason, this is, as they say, an aggravating factor, i think that the court will take it into account, but again i emphasize that it is very important that this crime is well documented, so that it does not happen, as some people say, that sometimes law enforcement officers act for a photo shoot, catch, take a photo and let them go, because of that, this is also a problem, because we see according to many previous people, as they say, they are free, although large sums of bail, this is already a definite step forward, why, because after that all bails go to the armed forces, and this is at least one positive step in

the work of the entire law enforcement machine, moreover , our international partners believe the fight against corruption is one of the indicators that ukraine should... fulfill in relation to joining the european union, but there is another side to this problem, it is a judicial reform that will not end in any way, will not end during the 19th year of this government , and it is important that it finally ends, the verkhovna rada took certain steps regarding the higher qualification commission of judges, the creation and other subjects of self-government of the courts of the branch of government. mr. mykhailo, well, you mentioned matters that are without a doubt more important than the statements of certain people's deputies and female deputies, in particular, it is about the mobilization legislation and its various manifestations.

so, we know what she was preparing, whether mrs. bezugla is preparing a suitable, appropriate initiative at the level of a draft law, and it has a lot of power to strengthen mobilization, on the other hand , we understand that there will be... reflections and so on, let's now talk about certain aspects of the data initiatives, so in what state or at what stage are they now, and is the draft law just pointless, or are there any alternative visions, well, first of all, these initiatives are being developed by a group of people's deputies, this working group is headed by david arahami, and this bill is not only of maryana bezuglya, it is of a large number of people 's deputies, we are about changes in the legislation, i emphasize once again with the military top leadership, because today they are the ones who should dictate and are dictating the positions as it should there is mobilization, demobilization, we are talking about those who have obtained second and third, higher and

other education, because the number of those who started to obtain second and third higher education since last year has increased, because of that there will be some. limitation, what is almost already resolved, the next thing, there is a discussion about demobilization, conscripts, they have all already served their terms , i think the issue is almost resolved here, we want to think about the next step, how to make sure that after demobilization they are not mobilized again as already persons who are subject to mobilization, the next thing already , it is agreed that today we have to tell all citizens of ukraine who are subject to mobilization, how long the state will call them to serve in the armed forces of ukraine, other military formations, that is,

there is a discussion, 16 months, 24, 36, and here, the military has not yet said its word, because any demobilization of those who, for example, served two years, will soon be 2 years, when a large-scale war, it involves the replacement of the same number, not just mobilized, but people who must be called up in advance and trained qualitatively, so that those people who have been on the front lines for two years, firstly, they have moral, physical, psychological burnout, this is what experts say, and on the other hand these are the people who are military professionals , they are not so easy to replace, and we are now we are working on it, but there is no longer any doubt or debate that a citizen needs to clearly say that the state is calling you, for a year or two, because unfortunately, the war is dragging on and we don't know when

it will end, these are the main ones parameters and what i said earlier, the discharge or demobilization of all persons with disabilities... the groups that are serving today, they are practically in the staff, but they are being treated, they need to be demobilized so that they can continue their treatment, and those who are cancer patients, their also needed. need to be demobilized, and today's legislation does not allow this to be done, because of that, unfortunately, the ukrainian state and ukrainian legislation were not ready for such challenges and we are forced to react, but i emphasize once again that the working group includes representatives of the armed forces of ukraine and all military formations, and none the verkhovna rada does not make a decision without their consent or without their proposal. mr. mykhailo, well, accordingly, you also mentioned about...' the medical aspect of the service of our military, so we have a new commander of the medical services,

the medical service of the armed forces of ukraine, mr. kazmirchuk, yes ms. ostashchenko, is no longer working, so to speak, on loan in the position he held until recently, what signals are you hearing about kezmirchuk now, well, in fact, the problem existed in the medical forces of ukraine, we spoke about this frankly in the verkhovna rada, we we heard it from volunteers, from the troops. there were some unclear things about the tourniquets , where there are domestically produced ones of higher quality , chinese and other ones were purchased or appeared at the front, the command of the medical forces explained that everything is fine, that these are not budget funds, that they are humanitarian aid, but the military doesn't care, because there was a problem with delivery from the front and medical people were dying because of the tourniquets, and these are what the people call their harnesses, er, mobilization cars, which delivered the wounded from the front line, there was also

a problem, and the replacement of the commander, that very positive thing. moreover, the current commander, he previously headed the military hospital of the city of kyiv, and is characterized positively and enjoys authority, both among medical colleagues, military personnel, and among military personnel who know him as the head of the medical field, there is hope that he will succeed to fulfill the obligations he undertook . his task is the manager of the medical military industry at the highest level, he is trusted by the leadership of the armed forces of ukraine, the ministry of defense, and we expect the improvement of medical support in the armed forces of ukraine. we will add to our conversation taras kremin, the commissioner for the protection of the state language, who will now share with us his thoughts on this matter

. will we really have this rollback, that's another question, because it's not a fact that the people's elected representatives will vote for it, but mr. language obbutsmen , i know that you submitted proposals to the council for the draft law on the rights of national minorities, please share with us what these proposals are and actually, what do you consider unacceptable in this draft law? good afternoon, thank you for your interest in this issue, first of all i want to say that the registered draft law, number 10288, is actually prepared to implement the recommendations of the conclusions of the venice commission, according to which it is proposed to make changes to a number of ukrainian laws, in particular, to the law on language, to the law on national communities, to the law on media, to the law on education. on full general secondary education, to the law on higher education, etc., which, in our opinion, will

narrow the functioning of the ukrainian language as the state language in extremely important areas, so we offered our vision, i sent letters to the head of the verkhovna rada of ukraine ruslan stefanchuk, and to relevant specialized committees that will consider this document obviously next week and i will hope that our wishes will be taken into account. in particular, i would like to emphasize that this document can level the norms regarding the mandatory share of books in the state language for publishers and book distributors. the presence of the state language on television and radio will be significantly reduced due to changes to the definition of ukrainian-language programming. and this will also apply to those who will be trained only for 5 years. provisions for the russian language after the abolition of the military language. state at the same time, i want to emphasize that these answers, proposals and reactions to

such initiatives were already submitted much earlier, i want to emphasize that in july 21, in its conclusions, the constitutional court, on the implementation of the decision on the constitutionality of the law on language, emphasized that the rights of ukrainian citizens to information and services in the state language cannot be narrowed in any way, apart from everything else, some of the proposals that already exist, they were earlier in the 17th year and they contradict the constitution of ukraine in that number of considering the fact that the decision of the constitutional court is considered to be tough. the rights and recommendations of the commission are of an exclusively urgent nature, i will hope that the position mentioned above , as well as of course our official, official message, will be taken into account by the people 's deputies of ukraine, we fervently support the european integration movement, these changes are also recorded in the constitution of ukraine , but

the risks and dangers that may arise from the moment of acquiring this document must be taken into account, of course. go around mr. taras, well de facto, under the guise of european integration, they are trying to offer us something, russification, so in simple language, yes, well, accordingly, we would like to ask you about the reaction of the people's deputies, yes, well, in any unclear situation, we are used to refer to the venice commission, although i think most did not read one or another of the recommendations, so your expert word on the main dangers of this draft law? pros. no, i said it in principle, but now there are discussions on the sidelines of the cabinet of ministers of ukraine, but only on every day, both the prime minister and the relevant deputy prime minister meet with people's deputies of ukraine, a planned meeting with the leaders of the group of factions, with leaders of public opinion, with public activists, so i will hope that all arguments will be taken into account, on the other hand, i as

authorized, about such dangers, i speak publicly, and in the end officially sent. my proposals to the chairman of the verkhovna rada of ukraine, so i will hope that everything will be taken into account and implemented, i want to emphasize that the issues are really acute, we really conscientiously and we take a responsible approach to the requirements of the european community, but at the same time we must understand that among our priorities are national interests, the war continues, including over what language children will be taught in schools, in what language... news and entertainment programs will be broadcast, in what language the books will be written, which will be sold in the places where the national communities live, and finally, we must also emphasize that, in our opinion, the rights of nationals may be violated by this document communities for education and other services in the state language.

the interest that we see today in the ukrainian language on the part of citizens of ukraine, regardless of ethnic origin , gives us the reason to talk about it, so let's hope that our recommendations will be taken into account, as well as the best european experience, in particular countries of the baltic states, it is quite interesting for us and one that can be implemented in our further state monikum, mr. taras, we were contacted by taras kremen, the official for the protection of the state language, in our studio people's deputy mykhailo tsymbalyuk, mr. mykhailo, what is your opinion about these attempts, so to speak, under the eurointe sauce. propose changes that can be called russification changes in simple language. well, first of all, i want to say that we are indeed moving towards the european community, and this is our task enshrined in the constitution, regarding the european union and nato, but here you need

to read very carefully the proposals of the venice commission, which, by the way, have... character, this is clear, but very important, so that this does not become a certain trump card of the representatives of the european commission in order to block the beginning of the negotiations, which are expected in the near future, this is clear, on the other hand, mr. taras said that there are discussions in the government, the government is planning meetings with people's deputies, or already pass, but it is very important to me. to hear, because i have not yet been to such meetings, what position the ukrainian government takes, whether the ukrainian government will defend the interests of ukrainian society and the law on language and other laws, there are also those on education, on minorities, etc., will the ukrainian government and the deputy prime minister and the prime minister advocate that all proposals of the venice commission

be taken into account, if all proposals, i emphasize once again, are recommendations. this is not the responsibility of the ukrainian authorities, then there may be a risk that we will return, and in some things the ukrainian language will be oppressed, this cannot be allowed, but i emphasize once again, the price is extremely high, and it is like a scalpel in the hands of a surgeon , the main thing is to do no harm, we will conduct serious consultations, and here it is important to join forces presentable of all factions of the groups, so that there was a positive result. i think that from next week such discussions will take place, including in our faction. if we return to the topic of mobilization. which is now very actively bothering many ukrainians, and military personnel who have been fighting for a long time, and are waiting for rotation, and are waiting for demobilization, it is important to also talk about

the process of attracting new people to the army, the right approach, giving up soviet property, we are talking about recruiting companies, which can help the armed forces and other defense forces, encourage potential conscripts, to join the army, such a proposal, oleksiy danilov, and here the question is important, whether there will be support from the people's elected officials, if possible some specific bills will be passed, or if it will be there, conditionally speaking at the government level to adopt, in general, what is your opinion about recruiting companies to encourage potential conscripts to the army, this is one of the ways and methods, let these recruiting companies ... work, definitely, but i do not believe in big crazy results, but they emphasize once again that this is important, because their task, first, after studying

the market for the needs of military specialties, to offer, and at the same time, this is a very difficult issue, to guarantee that the conscript will be drafted into the military unit in which he wants to serve in the specialty that he has, or the profession that he is ready to acquire during pre-conscription training, this is extremely important, or already in the process of training, as mobilized, but there is an example of european states, nato countries, including, and we we are studying this experience, there are many different proposals, i do not want to voice them, because they immediately cause a certain reaction in society. but i want to emphasize once again that such discussions are ongoing, now experience shows that those young men who passed the draft age and

lived in the kyiv region, these are irpin, bucha and those territories that were occupied, and kharkiv region and others, they are not even knew how to hold a firearm in their hands, that's why there are ongoing discussions about whether we should restore it, even during the martial law of conscription. conscripts who will serve on peaceful territories, will not engage in military operations, but will undergo military training and then be demobilized, that is, in order to teach, other options, we know that the ministry of education will introduce teaching, training in all higher educational institutions from next year, military training so that young people and not only... boys but also girls could master asia and already have a military specialty. to date , no specific decision

has been made on these bills, the working group is working, i just heard again there was a message that work has already been done in the social protection of military personnel, we are working on it, and i think that next week we will pass at least one bill related to the social protection of military personnel and members. of their families, this is the number one issue today, and it is very important that those people whom we are mobilizing clearly know under what conditions, we finally prohibited by law the sending of unprepared people to the zone of military operations , but unfortunately, different facts happen and we we receive a message about it, because of that very big task, on the one hand , to protect the serviceman. on the one hand, to support the middle rank of commanders, but on the other hand, so that everyone understands that during martial law, the challenges are extremely

serious, it is necessary to take care of the personnel, of their support, and today, when the question is being decided in the united states, when there will be allocated additional funds, it is also a challenge to have enough ammunition and weapons for our military. who today carry a difficult service. thank you, mr. mykhailo. mykhailo tsimbalyuk was working now live at the espresso studio people's deputy of ukraine, first deputy chairman of the verkhovna rada committee on social policy and protection of veterans' rights, lieutenant general of the reserve police. well, what an extremely important conversation on an extremely hot topic. well, what about us, for today we will gradually finish. we have some more fresh news, and i would like to turn it around a bit. let's say this, the agenda of today's broadcast, we have already forgotten a little about the situation with covid, but the situation with covid reminds us again, information

appeared from the chief sanitary doctor... of ukraine, ihor kuzin, that three regions of ukraine may be quarantined due to covid-19. we are talking about the ternopil, zhytomyr and chernivtsi regions, where the indicators are already higher than the standard for this period, that is, these regions can already introduce certain restrictive anti-epidemic measures. this is the situation, you have to be very careful, now is the season of flus, all kinds of diseases are in full swing, so please take care of yourself. we will say goodbye to you today. so were with you today, worked for you, informed you about everything important, this is the situation , goodbye, see you soon on the air, usual things become unreal, heavy bags are not for my sick back, from back pain, try

dolgit cream. kremgit relieves pain, reduces swelling and improves joint mobility. with dolgit cream, whatever you want, i'll pick it up. doll heat. the only yellow cream for joint and back pain. for black friday, eva buys a supply of cosmetics. and a stock of impressions from megago. minus 50% hundreds of channels, thousands of movies and sports. megogo turn on discounts agency wivinil presents december 3. 18:00 feest republic invites you to the fabulous concert of solomiya chchubai koleskovi for oleksa. time to believe in miracles. jalapita rococo band - school of arts of the free and indifferent. a concert of light and goodness on nicholas day for children with love. december 3, 18:00 fefestreblik. ticket equals charity, live sound. see

this week in the judicial control program with tetyana shustrova: applicants to the constitutional court, to whom the council of judges gave the green light. they delegate there those who are representatives of the old system. but why do candidates register property for relatives. my sister received quite a good salary from 2005 to 2013. on thursday, november 30, at 5:45 p.m., watch the judicial control program with tetyana shustrova on the espresso tv channel. vasyl zima's big broadcast, this is a big ether, my name is vasyl zima, and we're starting, two hours of air time, two hours of your time, many important topics we will discuss today, two hours to learn about the war, right now and about the war let's talk more, sergey zgurets with us, and how the world lives, now about what has happened in the world, yuriy fizar will speak in more detail, yuriy dobroveche, please, you have the floor, two hours to keep up with economic news, time to talk about money during war, oleksandr morchevka with

us, oleksandr, sports news, a review of sports events from yevhen pastukhov for two hours in the company of favorite presenters. thank you very much lina chechenna for the information about culture news. the presenters, many of whom have become similar. natalka didenko is ready to tell us about the weather on the day of advent. and also distinguished guests of the studio. andriy parubiy, people's deputy of ukraine, was also the chairman of the verkhovna rada of ukraine. events of the day in two hours. vasyl winter's big broadcast. a project for smart and caring people. espresso in the evening. the shelter is in bad condition, where to turn? check the shelter yourself. instructions from the ozone public monitoring group will help with this. download it, check the shelter and pass the information to the representatives of the state administration in your area. they will forward the comments to the person responsible for the condition shelter, balance to the recipient and control the performance and quality of work. try it

safely. everybody, i congratulate you, dear tv viewers, this is news , annayeva melnyk is with you, and i start this issue with the following: the rapid growth of the coronavirus : restrictive anti-epidemic measures may be taken in three regions of ukraine, according to the chief sanitary doctor ihor kuzin, the infection threshold has already been exceeded in ternopil, zhytomyr and chernivtsi regions. in general, throughout the country over the past week, the number of patients has increased by 20%. 56 people died.