a solution in order to end this active phase of hostilities on the territory of ukraine, as they say, to stop the war, er, then sit down, negotiate, determine how to coexist in the new geopolitical conditions, yes, because this proposal establishes the , that one sovereign state can carry out an act of aggression against another sovereign state, seize part of its territory and recognize this territory as its own, yes, well, this is a terrible dream for absolutely all lawyers, internationalists and modern geopoliticians, because then power again becomes decisive for us, and basically, well we could agree on this, yes, at the beginning of march 2022, at the beginning of april 2022 , and then it is not clear. why all this

armed conflict of interests, on the other hand, we must also understand that nato is founded on the basis of international god-poon, so we see that a large number of international treaties are being violated today, and membership in nato itself does not mean that the american military will appear here tomorrow, no, it is the right of the united states of america to act in response to... to aggression against ukraine, which is a nato member state. if we manage to prescribe that the united states of america , the united kingdom, i don't know, the republic of poland, yes, will have the right to act in response to the aggression of the russian federation without membership in nato, then why not, another question is that if we already have working mechanism, well, we don't know

how well it works, yes, because article five, it has never been activated, so here, too, the question is how effective is the mechanism, but if there is already a mechanism, then why create another one or some more new mechanisms with the same procedure, and that 's how far the same united states of america, the united kingdom will go, yes, how far they can sell it to their voters. that an american soldier can go to ukraine to fight with the russian federation, therefore, from the point of view of international law, it is not a problem to draw up such an agreement, from the point of view of international law, it is not a problem to demand compliance with this international agreement, but from a political point of view, how to get the consent of other states to comply of this international agreement, because you see, here well, you can argue for a long time, and what is aggression, and was it a... to set a goal

for membership in nato, because there is nothing better in the modern world that could guarantee our security, but if we manage to create something better, yes, other states will do it, then that will also be a great result, and we can feel as safe as possible. in general , under the current conditions, we heard you, mr. roman, roman yedeliev, international lawyer, associate professor of the department of international law, kyiv national university, was with us, thank you for your expert opinion, mr. ruslan, and what do you think about the idea of ​​a neutral ukraine, it has completely disappeared, but recently david rahamia, he spoke about the fact that russia at the beginning of the war, she said, let's say, you will sign legally and a document that will oblige you to have a neutral status in the future, and they say we will stop... khahamiya, of course, then said that

they say the russians have no faith and we do not have any guarantees, there will be no guarantees that russia at some time just won't go to the new one waves of offensive, as well as one of the most influential geopolitical strategists of the united states , henry kissinger, also changed his mind, already at the age of 100, yes, he decided that although i had previously opposed ukraine's entry into the north atlantic alliance, now he says that the ideas of a neutral ukraine, it is now completely ineffective, it has disappeared, or it has disappeared, and it has disappeared, because the idea of ​​a neutral country was conditional, it was a conditional context, in which there would be no escalation, the escalation took place, that is, the possibility of returning to there is no neutral status, because it does not guarantee us security, it means that if today we make concessions on russian terms, it will be a matter of time when we receive the next aggression in the format of the first or second chechen war, for a simple reason , if they received as a result of aggression. achievements, then the question is why should they

stop, they will simply have the task of taking a break, acquiring new resource capacity, preparing new equipment. to mobilize new potential and to attack again with a new wave when ukraine does not count on it, we are we understand, and the key players in the north atlantic alliance understand this, and i believe that if henry kistenger has already spoken about the fact that he is changing his position, publicly, this indicates that he is relaying certain opinions of the stakeholders behind him, i do not i think that he relays a personal position, he, as a former diplomat, a representative of the elite of the united states, clearly interacts with them and relays it. collective, i think, opinion and position, everyone understood that the question of neutrality does not really arise, the question is only in a format in which it is possible would be to guarantee security, and here is the question of the scenario, there mr. rahamya talked about north-south korea, i think this is not a very appropriate example, i talked about those

scenarios that were successful, yes we are there east, west germany, the question of the scenario croatia, the issue of nagorno-karabakh, which in fact the last of the conflicts finally ended for 30 years, the territory was under de facto occupation, and we understand that if at the moment n a certain country does not have sufficient resources to resolve the conflict in its favor with the price that it is ready to pay, then it takes a break to acquire its capabilities, we saw that, for example, east and west germany, it happened in one night, without a single shot, conditions were created when the patronage of east germany was not able. .. continued to support the ruling regime, in croatia there was a different scenario, they acquired the ability to clear and return their territory by force, and at the moment when they left, they left several settlements, they said, well, now let’s deal with it, let’s talk about it to the two villages that are there, worthy of karabakh

, we all saw it from the recent news, fresh, i think, the viewers themselves remember well how everything was resolved there, also when, in fact, azerbaijan gained capacity with the support of turkey, at a time when the russian federation was not able to support armenia, as it was busy with all its forces in ukraine, azerbaijan took advantage of the situation, resolved a conflict that it had not been able to resolve for a long time, and here the question is exactly where the discussion is, i think rasmusyn raised this question, it is time to talk, look, well you admit that currently you do not have enough resources, but today you are ready to get these resources, and you, when you will be able to have these resources, under what conditions? so that we, not like children who want candy, stomp our feet, demand this candy, but understand whether we have it now, whether we have earned it now for that candy, when we can earn it for this candy until what moment , do we understand that we have to have other expenses, to cover our other mandatory

payments, and well, what i see from the side of the republicans who are communicating, they are talking in every way about self-charge and those appeals which was before the white house, i think, as a result of which the column of commander-in-chief valery zaduzh appeared. about that , and what about this help that we offer to provide again, how it will affect the successful achievement of goals, what, what is success, what guarantees achievement, in what way, do you have a business plan, when today, recently , the special representative for the restoration of the white house came, she actually hinted, but what if, if, for example, there is no help, how will you attract resources, not from an overview. that we will continue to ask for more, and how will we reach the moment of self-reliance, when we will start to close our revenue part of the budget on our own, i think that these are not the first such hints, which are direct, direct conversation, how the ukrainian authorities will ensure the ability to overcome the challenges, and as

soon as we to have our own plan that we can talk to as western partners, then we can negotiate different formats, because this or that scenario is part of this or that strategy, we have to have ... some kind of our own strategy that is shared by the western partners, and when we have the same understanding of the goal, the same understanding of the strategy, the same understanding of resources, then it is possible to agree on who, when and how these resources are provided. mr. ruslan, we have very little time left, literally one and a half to two minutes, but is a real scenario when ukraine itself leads a security alliance, even if it is of a smaller format, becomes an ambassador of a new entity, is it possible? well, let's recall the strategy of small alliances. which mr. dmytro kuleba promoted and tried to build before the invasion, yes, we remember, ukraine, poland, lithuania, ukraine, poland, britain, and these were steps, they were really more political, the question is whether someone from other countries is ready to take the risk of

standing side by side against a common enemy? i think the answer to this question will give us an understanding of whether we can have such an option or not, that someone else will not appear who is ready to dare to fight against the common evil. i think, then potentially ukraine could be the leader of such an entity. is this courage enough in ukraine? well, we have enough, we assert it every day on the front line, the question is, are others ready? well, even us we are not talking about politicians, you... we understand that such a decision should be made only with the support of the people, well, of course, democracy is always about whether society shares this position or not, this is first of all, ruslan rokhov, political technologist, was today we are in the studio , first of all, we are extremely grateful to you for visiting us, today we will end on a philosophical note, put three dots, but we will definitely return to this topic, well , finally, friends, let’s talk about where you can spend your winter the season, your holidays, rest, we understand that even in spite of the war , ours also return to vacations and in general , families reunite for the new year holidays, where

exactly can you spend, if there is anything, a conversation, and if there is not, then yes, where is it, if there is strength for rest , yes, we will talk about this further, so ukrainians continue to travel, even despite the war, choose tours of their country, at least this is confirmed by an online survey of the state tourism development agency , almost half of ukrainians are ready to travel, but only a little more than 20% avoid compatriots are afraid possible danger. 500 people aged 14 to 34 took part in a large-scale survey by dart and the unicef ​​europort ukraine project. since the beginning of the war , almost half of the surveyed 45% traveled the country for the purpose of tourism. more than a quarter traveled to the regions of the country once or twice. well, more than 10%, 12, to be more precise, three to five times and more than five times , only 7% of survey participants traveled to ukraine. a lot of numbers were mentioned, we will ask maryana oleskiv, the head of the state tourism development agency, about them and their interpretation, she knows better than anyone what

tourist destinations in ukraine are the most popular this year among vacationers in the winter period, despite the war, ms. marijana, please welcome you, congratulations, actually, ukrainians travel in the most popular location, of course, this is western ukraine, the west of our country, the carpathian region in the first place queue, but many during the war and covid discovered other parts of our country for themselves, because we have in fact in every region very beautiful places that you can visit, there is also a hotel infrastructure, estates where you can stay, so of course that in winter, it will lead and entice ukrainians specifically to ski resorts, but in addition to this, there are actually such interesting places for recreation : our resorts are where there is water, where there is a sanatorium, where you can get treatment,

restore your health, there are also there are spa hotels and swimming pool complexes, all this allows you to bask in the warmth a little in winter, but also trips to our cities, that is, such a city vacation, let's hope that christmas towns and other such attractions will open this year, which will allow ukrainians to experience . after all, despite the war, especially for our children, christmas, new year's holidays, so such trips, they are also quite interesting to the cities of ukraine. ugh, mrs. maryana, do you have any information about who rests more often, women with children, i suspect, a little less, the older generation and obviously the least, it's men, because of course, the war in ukraine? yes, actually, many women with children, but also families, in principle. go to the carpathian region, i was on a work trip in the carpathians, somewhere during

the children's vacation, a lot of families actually rested in the region for a vacation, ugh, that is , in principle, ukrainians rest, even in spite of the war, they find a reboot for this time in order to still maintain this morale and capacity for work, rest, rest, it is important, and resting. well, regarding the financial support of our country by ukrainians who are on vacation, is there an increase in vacation prices, since we can consider several options, how much can be an option for the family, let's say, for the family, let's say, at how many, well, out of the three, such as people we can have such an average option, for example, there in the west of the country, if you want, for example, to take a ride on its budget, though, well, yes, yes, we are only talking. within the country, exclusively, of course, yes or to other directions, it is possible about this, about these options, please tell me, well

, for example, in vinnytsia, i recently also went on a trip alone, the hotel room there cost 500 uah, in tulchyni, cool, good breakfast with very good homemade food 100 uah, yes, that is, we understand that somewhere like 1000 uah per day, per person you can fully eat and visit some museums and attractions, but if we are already talking about such a more expensive vacation, then there are such rooms for a family for 2-300 hryvnias, with breakfast in the west of our country, of course there are more expensive ones, that's all it depends a lot. t, but in ukraine you can really find a vacation for any budget. and what unique events are planned for the winter period in ukraine, what will they be, what will surprise ukrainians, what will attract the attention of tourists. i think that these will definitely be celebrations, our traditional ones christmas, especially in rural areas,

because these are the traditions that we have kept for centuries, and they are becoming more and more. interesting for tourists, for example , the celebration of easter in kryvorivna attracted a very large number of guests and tourists in the frankiv region, malanka in the chernivtsi region, this is also such an interesting holiday that is visited by many tourists, in lviv, in ternopil, i am sure that in the cities christmas celebrations will take place, for the rest of the events it is really difficult to plan what will happen, since there is a war in our country again, we do not understand what will be the situation with... energy, but as i said earlier, our local authorities are still trying to create some minimal feeling of a holiday for us and the preservation of our traditions, because even when there were bans on caroling and celebrating christmas, ukrainians found opportunities and options, how to do it, it is also

important for us now, because it is our culture, and it must be preserved, multiplied, developed. we understand that there are certain security challenges for travel agencies, for those who invite tourists, let's say, what are the steps is it possible for both the government and the central local travel agencies to ensure the safety of vacationers as much as possible? well, actually, if these are tourist trips with tour operator agencies, then they find out all the prohibitions that exist in the region before that with the local authorities of the state emergency service, it is mainly for hiking in forests and others. such hikes, but now it's winter, so people will go to the forest less if there are ski resorts where it is allowed, and yet the issue of safety is not necessary either, no you can forget about ordinary hikes in the mountains in winter, because there are various avalanches of snow, people get lost, so it is also important to do this with a guide, inform the emergency services about your hike,

take, download the appropriate applications that will allow... to track such a tourist in the mountains, but and of course we have, unfortunately, the biggest threat - this is russian attacks, aerial drones, missiles, so we still have to look for shelter, regardless of which region we are in, we understand that in some regions such anxieties are more real and threats are more real occur, but do not ignore them, because as we see, this arrival can happen anywhere. and even to places that sometimes seem completely safe. ms. maryana, you mentioned the shelling, it is clear that if the shelling hits critical infrastructure, then the light goes out, the water may go out, the heating goes out, and not only in homes, but also in hotel rooms, in estates, how did ukrainian

tour operators take care of that the guests were comfortable despite the russian aggression. for the past winter season, autumn and winter, in fact all places are touristic, they prepared for this and have generators and alternative sources of power, water, so there will be fewer problems with this this year already, because we are already ready, if our enemy does not come up with something new, then i think that we will be ready to survive this winter, as and the past, in relation to hotels that have stars and are... officially the state, they are obliged to have all alternative water supplies, power, generators and will function despite any external circumstances, and well, if we are talking about internal support tourism, we understand that because of the war, of course, the situation worsened and

travel agencies, in particular, maybe somehow the state supports them, let's say how they adapted during these almost two years of war. how devastating was this blow to the business, are the people who were involved in this industry recovering more or less? of course , the blow was quite strong, the industry is also stable, because we have had many different crises in recent years, and covid, and before that, economic crises that had an impact, today many outbound tour operators have relocated to other countries, opened offices in other countries, discovered for themselves... domestic freight operators, they have reduced capacity, many of them are also engaged in other types of business, but continue to keep people at work and make trips, it is not the same anymore. a business that was profitable , but it is important not to lose people, because when people leave the industry, it is very difficult to train new, tsegs, people who accompany, other

professionals, about the hotel industry, it depends very much on the region, in the west of our country , in principle, it works actively, new hotels are opening, if we are talking about the south, the part, unfortunately, is destroyed, occupied, and we will need many more tens of... years to fully restore tourism in the south, including demining and reconstruction. mrs. maryana, it is clear that because of the war, many specialists, among whom most of them are women, have gone abroad, is there a shortage and how much are there shortages of which specialists, which areas of the tourism business, maybe this will actually be a clue for those who are now choosing or a new profession, or chooses where to study next. a year, well, actually missing almost all personnel, always , especially professional, especially people with experience, these are

cooks, and administrators in the hotel, and other personnel, that is, today there are actually job offers, but we have something like this, sometimes not incompatibility, when our educational institutions graduate specialists, the business has somewhat different requirements for them, and in fact, we are also currently working on this, creating such a project, an institute of hospitality, where we will be able to combine the needs of business, the capabilities of our educational institutions, and really cook and cook quickly specialists for our industry, in particular after our victory, this tourism will become one of the very important elements of our economy for us, and many people will have the desire, and we are currently working on it, to go to ukraine, and actually people who will to serve, who will receive them, this is the key to the success

of ukraine leaving the best impression, they recommend us to visit their friends, and we must be ready for this. thank you, mrs. maryana, maryana oleskiv, head of the state tourism development agency talked about what the winter vacation period will be like in ukraine, to what... celebrating in the family circle at the table, remember, thanks to whom all this is possible and thanks to whom it is possible, of course i am talking about our defenders, who we, who we thank you just now for being able to be with you for the last hour, thank you, thank you very much, and with you were oleksiy homan, kateryna derkach, thank you for your trust, come. chevorons approaching victory,

assault troops - the path on which a soldier becomes a warrior, where the brave become relentless where the strong become mighty and the determined become invincible. this is your way. choose the cheap one. hrobchik, how are you? i feel it is difficult for you. maybe you are confused and it seems to you that nothing is working out right now. you know what i do when i'm confused? i go to the mirror, look at myself. i remember what i have already succeeded in and say: i am well done. at the same time , you just need to pat yourself on the head, whether it's a fight or a real one. you see how

well done we are, doing what helps. on how are you.com, caring people from the program mental health professionals and their friends from unicef have gathered tips on how to help yourself and your child cope with stress. chevrons approaching victory. time to attack and fight back. turn your people into weapons. join our fighters of the national rage police brigade. you can fill out the questionnaire on the nabir website. or by calling 097 725 25 13 with...

bridges and crossings are appearing on rivers, reliable barricades are growing at combat positions, thanks to them we can effectively attack and defend. they destroy enemy equipment and save the lives of the infantry. they go ahead of the first, to break the way to our victory. glory to the engineering troops of the armed forces of ukraine. on christmas night, we'll be there. mentally in the chat, in the family circle. from now on, together with the whole christian world, on december 25 , we celebrate christmas together.

since the beginning of the full-scale invasion, they have been spending their weekends and vacations away from home with their families, in de-occupied cities and villages near the front, helping people who, because of the war and russian aggression, cannot get. quality medical care. they do it for free at the call of the heart. these are volunteer doctors of the international mission of frida. for a year and a half, they provided assistance to thousands of civilians. the work of the mission is coordinated and managed by my lovely guest, the heroine of the face today program, vladyslava romaniuk, doctor, head of the medical volunteer mission, frida yukrai. congratulations. but i want to start not with fried's mission,

but... from your recent post on facebook , you wrote that you worked for a month in the hospital where our heroes are recovering, how is it to treat soldiers who have just arrived there from the front? for more than a year, our clinic has been providing free treatment together with our partners to our fighters, and this treatment is quite complex, it is about rehabilitation mainly, and about all the tangential things that are bothering this person now, and everything that can be done , everything is done there, there is a separate department, separate doctors who deal with our fighters, and of course the whole clinic is related to this, because sometimes you need advice, a gastroenterologist and the advice of any doctor, it doesn’t matter, and there was a month in the summer when i was asked to replace the doctor who went to vacation, specifically, which works with... i won't say

that it was easy, because basically now i work at a consulting reception, not at the station, but it's a station complex big job, at first it was difficult, you know everyone, to understand what's going on with everyone, because you want to hug this person from all sides, let's say so, not to miss anything, and the most important thing is to make it clear that you know, not to give any slack, yes, no, not to break anywhere, not to show that you are struggling somewhere , and somewhere you just want to discharge on the spot and start hugging, huh you still want to show maximum resilience and that everything is okay, and we will pass this stage with you, unfortunately,

we have very different fighters. separated , that is, this is also the battle of amputees, these are fighters without, without limbs, without eyes, without, well, with various pathologies, and it is not easy, here, but what particularly struck me every day was their absolute such steadfastness and smile and understanding that everything will be fine with me in the future, cool, i will be treated, some of them definitely believed that she would go to the front, that's why everyone who was involved was very happy to be in it process, well, i think, there is no longer only about physical rehabilitation, there it is very important to provide moral assistance to the soldiers in the hospital, it used to be that you just came and they wanted to talk, to tell something, of course, it was different, especially...