actions to sow in putin the idea that they can potentially participate in a war with the russian federation, so in fact macron , with his latest statements, broke this paradigm, which unfortunately prevailed in the west for the past two years, that is, he actually started the management of uncertainty , that is, initially , unlike, by the way, from other countries that... immediately rejected and said, including the general secretary of nato, i understand that this is a political position, and he must certainly make certain statements, but instead to keep quiet sometimes, and don't declare that we won't be sure, sometimes you can just keep silent without necessarily commenting, let others guess whether your silence means support or, on the contrary, denial, so actually macron with his categorical statements, well, that's enough of a mess.

political, because the world is still suffering from this geopolitical procrastination, when a well-known and understandable decision is postponed that one way or another the west will have to act as an ally of ukraine in some role, because this is not ukraine's war against russian aggression, it is a war west against east, this is a war of democracy against despotism, this is a war of good against evil, and ukraine is alone here, no matter how much we want it, no matter how heroic our armed forces are, on... unfortunately, it will not be able to do it on its own, so the constant postponement of this important decision , it is not known when, is simply dragged into the war , and there is hope that perhaps this leadership is political, which macron is trying to take, of course, from certain of his political benefits, this must also be understood, but what does it matter, of which macron does it for reasons. for us it is important that macron makes these statements, i am convinced that they will encourage other bold decisions, other leaders.

especially now the issue of germany, olaf scholz, and this weimar triangle, france, germany and poland, it seems to me that they have to take the lead in conditions where the united states of america may give some slack, we don't know yet, but we can see , which has been happening in the united states of america in recent months, someone has to take that lead. now, to answer your question about the german plant, i am more united the last important for. that is, in general, this manufacturer has long been declaring its readiness to provide its balance, and here the problem was probably more with the timidity of the german government, because it must be understood that such monopolies cannot make decisions independently, that is, despite the fact that these are private companies that earn money, but it must be understood that they are also not free in making these decisions, so the fact that sometimes the german government may not publicly declare something, obviously there are certain agreements on

certain processes, so there is obviously a very large caution to the public, at least part of the german authorities, regarding their readiness to help ukraine, but obviously there are certain processes that are not public, i hope, well , the fact that we do not know them, it is good that we do not know them, because certain things need to be calm, once we we will learn this as a matter of history, so i hope that the german government will. will take an example from macron, obviously there is a competition in the european union and in general in the west, as to who will take this leadership, perhaps in the realization by the german authorities that it can lose not only leadership, but to be in the backyard and an outsider, will force the political establishment to take bolder decisions after all, because outside the chancellor of germany. there are many political forces

in the parliament that have long declared their readiness to help ukraine more actively, but since a certain consensus has not yet been established in german society, obviously, which already exists in france, but which is not yet in germany, we will have to , probably still have to wait and work a lot, like ukrainian to the government, deputies and our allies in the west, in order to convince germany to change its position, we have drawn a map, ms. oleksanronets, now i am giving you the floor. mopeds, the so-called shaheds , which iran supplies, or the russian federation itself manufactures, in the vinnytsia and khmelnytsky regions, they say, a small number in the vinnytsia region, it seems that there is damage to a residential building, damage, they write not destruction, but damage, we want to believe that everything is there okay, well , we understand that when shahedin is in khmelnytskyi, lviv is also not far away, maybe for us will have to finish this broadcast even in the bomb shelter. but we believe in the anti-aircraft

forces, which will effectively deal with the shaheds, this information is for those who are watching us, in particular in khmelnytskyi and vinnytsia, be careful. oksana yuranets, you have the floor. i just wanted to add my own, why not the president, sorry, maybe a provocative question, why didn't duda say it first? look, now, despite these troops, in parallel, maya sando had a meeting with macron and they signed a bilateral security agreement. it should be recalled that the threats against transnistria were coming from the side of the aggressor's own country, but apart from that, they are looking for opportunities. again, if we talk about the elections, maya sando won all the foreign... in the constituencies and actually saved the country, then her party won and her party became her government, that is, it is the country and the person who shows how to fight. now, sensing this threat, macron is trying to take the lead not only with regard to statements on ukraine, but also by embracing

moldova. it is important to understand this from the point of view of those processes that are also starting in this country itself, that is, russia will not calm down and these lights she may yet seek others. or destabilizing around ukraine, she, he, russia is doing it. therefore, as of now, it is very key and important to actually, er, understand the message of evil, good, what colleagues said, actually, clearly formed. when we say that we need some consumables for artillery, everyone knows for a long time that it is exclusively south korea and also jordan. but now south korea, together with poland, has begun to manufacture it close, not far from our border, actually, understanding these. all, let's say so, and in a big way calculates its interests, therefore germany understands that somewhere it can lose, other countries, well, they want to be in time not only, as they say, to victory, but they also want to be in time to take advantage along the way , so the only guarantee of security, the only one is

there is, of course, nato, but bilateral agreements as a factor of prior agreement or prior such voting and support, they are taking place, so it must be understood that as of now in the format, for example, when... poland will celebrate the 25th anniversary of accession on monday in warsaw in nato, during this period of time it had the opportunity to prepare, and even the bases that are not far from our border, the nato ones, which are not subordinate even there to the polish government, are security guarantees. lithuania will also celebrate 20 years of joining nato this year, that is, we must understand that our plan, which we have to implement, is a security plan, it is achievable when the leaders of other european countries are parallel. talk about this repeatedly, when there will be no more countries that will have any doubts about, conditionally , the security of this eastern flank of nato, without architecture, by the way, what was said and shown by the president of the czech republic, who for a long time headed the military committee in nato and repeatedly came to lviv to the academy

of ground forces, he understands very well that without the eastern flank of nato, without ukraine, there is no construction of security architecture, that's why this plan is gradually being implemented, well, the only thing that says delays. time is not playing in our favor, in fact, it is the enemy who is trying to fit in, always playing on the determination very often of european leaders, so this must be prevented, and you are right they noticed, oksana said, actually, that european leaders sometimes run after what their voters want, and when such a low-level, linear system works well, among student diplomacy, some very popular child... female and other, it works out in fact, the narratives that already in those societies clearly understand where is good and where is evil, and china must be understood in the same way today, but if it comes true that the lists will be closed by our government, because there are so many countries that fall into the number those

who works and cooperates with the aggressor country , they want these lists to be closed, confiscation, reparations, confiscation of the reserves of the central bank will be very key and important, because that's right... it should be noted that actually in terms of gold, diamonds, they bypass even today china, they are becoming four countries, which, after all, are not economically destroyed, and this is very threatening from the point of view of their ability to drag out the war for years, and we must strike at them, the war must go beyond the borders of ukraine, it must be there, what with why did we start this broadcast, when it will take place, destabilization is as possible as possible in them, this... we will understand that then ukraine will win, when the war will be there who started it. olena zhivko. i actually wanted to add about macron's statement, i am not ready to give such a full legal assessment from the point of view of international law, but i want to note that france has been operating for a long time, the french legion

is the only private army in the world, and therefore today it is difficult to talk only about macron's courage, and possibly about legal possibilities, because this army, it has a completely... different status, in his statement he did not indicate whether it will be a private army, which, for example, france will pay, and they will join, but legally, they have completely different opportunities within french legion, which do not exist in, say, germany or the same poland, so this issue can still be studied, but the fact that they have an army that does not have a legal status in the world, this should also be taken into account, well there in general, actually itself the system of management, by the french president of the army, is quite like this, well let's put it this way, even putin cannot single -handedly decide on the use of nuclear weapons, on the other hand, it seems that macron can make such a decision, well, at the beginning, he and i did not... discuss it, because there were rumors on the internet that the legion would join, and actually we just discussed that

there are a lot of russians in the legion, as well as many ukrainians, and we also discussed in them that their statute prohibits, that is, participation if the legion comes to ukraine, that is, the participation of russians in this war, that is, therefore, these issues are somewhere hovered into the air, i really hope, because it is a very powerful army, a lot of our ukrainians served there, i am happy if there is such support for ukraine, mr. smilka, now it is irrelevant... we really expect help from the french and from other countries. one of the biggest challenges that we are talking about for our country is high-quality mobilization, and this is a topic that, well, in which you understand, this week, well, personally, i have, let's say this, hopes that ukrainian parliamentarians, once they will still pass this law on mobilization well, the little ones will disperse, because every week we hear about thousands of edits and so on and so on, on the other hand. ukraine is under martial law, mobilization continues, how

can we cope with this challenge? well, now i will add two more words only about macron, the only thing that i want the ukrainian people not to hide now is that this is macron's statement, and tomorrow the french will come, and we have already won and the like that we must win, our victory in our hands, and it depends primarily on us, no one will come for us and not will bring us... our victory on a plate, we must win, this is one time, the second time, i will be interested tomorrow, the day after tomorrow, watch some russian television if possible, you know, after such statements by macron, always like hell from a snuffbox, somewhere from alkoorbita the bears are the first to fly up and grab the nucleus, and putin is a sign, putin, if he starts to be afraid, that moscow maggot, he immediately also grabs the nucleus, and recently there was a very nice remark by macron on... that we, dear ones, also have a nucleus , not yours one, so what if he, the two of them

will speak for the kernel, it means that they were really scared, and they take it very seriously, as far as mobilization is concerned, you know, this topic is very painful to me, many people want it, i always i say, people , you want our victory, of course, but if you want someone else's hands with someone else's sons, well , it won't happen, it's the first, the second, remember the first weeks, months, mobilization, did someone run after someone, someone caught someone, someone packed someone there, as they say, there was no such thing, people left themselves, and our people ukrainians prayed for us then, guys , did you hold the front, guys, not constantly, they prayed for us, now many guys are wounded, spread out, well, they can’t because of their health, they lost health, shed blood, got disabled , serve in the tsk, and here it is... a guy who fought from the first day, went as a volunteer, then approaches a person and says: "friend, why, why don't you

go to serve?" you understand, if everyone fulfilled their public duty and came voluntarily, the tsekan would not follow anyone, let's really look at the eyes, but from the second parties, or a person, why don't people go, well , that's right, when he saw that he had a former head on the street, well, for example, i know on the street who does not serve me, but could serve, i i also have a question for them... there are three sons of the former head of the village council, three sons went to the gym , one, i personally went with him in my time, you see, no one is serving, and when he sees them, he says that he is not is coming, secondly, you understand, the state should be involved as much as possible in providing for the military, well, look, well, we see it everywhere and everywhere, i understand that it is not maybe the state, but there are times when the military announces a collection for repairs, a repair base for equipment, help with a diesel locomotive, help... with drones, he understands that if he gets hit, he will go to serve the army, and that he should be with an extended

with his hand, just like those soldiers who ask , seeing this, it does not encourage a person to serve, because he will, like everyone else, call the village, call the city, tell the deputies, their priests, it is necessary, it is necessary, of course, war is an expense, war is a loss of equipment and the like, well, but first of all , the state must ensure as much as possible, as much as possible, the war is lossless. it happens, no matter how much we want it, no matter how much we pray, the war is without executions, it is also repulsive somewhere in itself, but on the other hand, you know, when i recently watched just wild shots of men. someone with such a body of mine is being dragged into beads somewhere and he is screaming , people, save me, you know, it’s a bright day, people, save me, god, ugly ugly, you know why , if you’re already screaming, people, save me, scream until the end, people, save me, but don’t save the country so shout, save me and continue, but because i won't save the country, the country, don't

save, save me, and how will you be then, you will be 60 years old, your grandchildren will come and ask you, grandfather, what are you? i thought you were going to lie, you won't tell the truth , you'll say it there, i couldn't, i'll say hello, something else like that, look, go to the mirror and look, you can fight, but you're looking for a reason, i understand, it's difficult, i understand that you want a lot of things, and you don't want a lot of things, but if you don't protect your street, if you don't protect your home, then look at the government, the government, thank god, we are not in russia, and we are this government that does not exist today, the elections will come, we will sort it out, we will change it, we do not have a government... permanent, like in muscovy, we change it, did not like it , we will choose another one, protect our homes, what should be done about mobilization, well, first of all, a person must be, you know, when i went on the very first day of the start of the war, i did not think about salaries, i did not know how it would be, i somewhere i partially understood that we are leaving, we are half-dead, i

understood it, but in a different way, well, i couldn’t, well, well no... well, my sister or my little child or my wife won't go, well, they won't go, i'm a man, i have to, i have to be a man not only, you know how many men we have in the bar and in the kitchen, especially holidays, they already won all the wars over there in the kitchen, but first of all you are a man, yes, war has a woman's name, but war is primarily waged by men, he should go and know that this is how the state pays, he for that salary, he is paid, his family will be well provided for, there is no need to talk about who will feed my family, wait, that's not the second world war, where we didn't pay money, we went in the first days, we went for a salary in general, i didn't have a salary for how many people, in the 14th i fought for months in a volunteer battalion, i knew in advance that there was no salary , the guys fought with their hands, let's take the same da vinci from the 14th , he had no salaries in the right sector

, the only one, as far as i remember, there was not a single salary all these years, not a single one, you understand and... here it is necessary, you know, if you don't change it, here you have to change the specifics, first of all, convey normally that you are a man, you have to go, you can fight, you go, yes , not everyone, there are professions, eh, i fought, i know that the minibus, then ride, whoever he is there, although he will tell you somewhere later, where are you obd took the same thing, but i am fighting so that my mother, if she needs to go to the hospital, gets on a minibus and goes, because the same minibus is behind the wheel, so i know that my mother will go to the store or not? a child will buy bread, buy that, that is, there are professions that must be really armored, but there must be, you understand, justice, here one must approach very clearly so that a person i felt, i am leaving, because i know, yes, the son of the deputy has left, the son of the rector has left, the son of a businessman has left, well, who am i going to complain about, i now give mr. buchyn my word, a lot of things

are happening dynamically, now they are writing about the fact that well, maybe macron didn't say everything so categorically. but this is the same, mr. rad, about which you spoke, this strategic uncertainty that the french president is currently creating, because the russian public is simultaneously dispersing information about what is being sent to romania, french troops, and this may be the first step to introducing them to odesa, which was also talked about, that is, we really want to believe this story, that the french somehow tactically competently hang it up, and strategic uncertainty during the war is what really works, mr. bucha ? actually, i want to continue mr. vitaly, he spoke from a professional point of view of the military vision of mobilization, i certainly want to say my visions as a political scientist and as an ordinary citizen of ukraine. well, the first thing i want to say is that we are already waging war against russia more than 10 years. and for sure, this law, which is currently suspended in the verkhovna rada, should

have been considered back in the 14th year, well, it should have been considered unequivocally without options in... the year immediately after the full-scale invasion, we are now actually, as they say, we are breathing and thinking hotly, and accordingly , that is why we now have many problems, and many nuances, and many elements of the social political situation and mobilization policy, as a result of the fact that we did not make this decision in time, then the second point, which i i want to say when we we are talking about the fact that mr. vitali, you said that there you are... amendments are being accepted and so on, you know, we are actually already late, but even now we probably don't need to take it all at a gallop, because there is a lot there are many nuances, that is, the law is complicated. there are a lot of problematic nuances , a lot of debatable issues, and obviously, it is necessary to make sure that those issues are polished as much as possible and the law is as

effective as possible, because if we adopt it, let it be fast, but the law, which will cause a lot of questions, is surely again will play anyway is not to our advantage, so perhaps there is a certain logic in the fact that they want to work out this law in detail, because as i said, it is already too late, so it is better to make everything the way it is now... thirdly, i i want to say, well, we are talking about the day of the volunteer , probably, it may not be by chance, because there is a general universal truth that the mobilization policy should be based as much as possible on the voluntary, motivational element, it has been like this since ancient times, and it is like this now, that is, the state has carry out a motivational, propaganda policy, which must combine all the other legislative acts there for... the activities of the tcc and so on, that is, we must show the maximum advantages, opportunities, talk about what you talked about, about civic duty, about

the fact that it is important, and exactly to neutralize certain scarecrows, this is the third, fourth, russia now directs a very large part of the information war ipso and so on, to actually destabilize, stop the mobilization policy, prevent effective mobilization. there should also be a lot of, let's say, activity special services and so on , in order to counteract those possibilities and those attempts of russia, because in fact, well, quite effectively , certain such, you know, dubious or provocative videos, messages, and so on are thrown in, unfortunately, they very often work among ordinary citizens, and especially when there is no official explanation and no refutation, then it gives a negative for ukraine. and one more thing i would like to say, i don't know, for some reason, you know, it surprises me that russia has been very effectively using such

phenomena as private military armies for a long time, the wagnerites, there are redoubts and so on , by the way, they worked well, unfortunately for us, in the russo-ukrainian war, but what is important is that this way russia very effectively realizes its foreign policy interests in africa, for example, on other continents. i believe that such a mobilization state policy should be well supplemented by some private recruitment campaigns, which would possibly create some private structures, where there will be good military equipment, where there will be good salaries, where certain funds, possibly foreign ones, and where it will also be possible to, say, combine our official state mobilization policy with such private military structures, which will probably also be from... well, by the way, mr. khrymchytskyi, maybe you are familiar with this issue, well, there is this one, i don’t know, a myth or the truth about black water, yes, the largest

american private army in the world, what is the prospect in general, today we started talking about the legion, the french legion , the potential use, yes, other private armies, maybe we will wait when there are americans will find themselves in the context of a private military company, i would first like to ask whether we need it at all. may i first want to return to the law on mobilization, in fact, this issue should have been started in the 14th, in the 16th year, moreover, the defense capability of ukraine should have been raised in 2003, when the first infiltrations from the side began of russia, after that we saw a lot of destroyed warehouses, directly, if we talk about what is happening now in the armed forces of ukraine, i often visit on the military training grounds, when we present our... products there, and it really surprises me when i hear from the military there, and this is this drone we bought there at the expense of that fund, at the expense of the village council there,

this weaponry, and here, here, and we, you can , we don’t, we don’t buy, we don’t buy the ministry of defense, it buys volunteers, our rap there, means of support, and it’s very, very painful, and i want to ask the 22nd year was 2003, it was 2014 year, 22nd year. and we will win the war with our own funds, with our own forces. of the direct involvement of possible armed private legions of the military or military. i would give an example here, for example , let's start with the fact that, for example, on monday such a powerful article from the new york times came out about the fact that we will not be provided with f-16s, only 45 will be given, the pilots are not ready. here i would like to draw attention to what the new york times journalist who described actually did. the whole situation in 22-23 years , they wrote an article about the fact that our military will not be able to quickly learn to work on patriot, as we can see the result, our

military learned very quickly. and regarding very important information, what is happening now is that the russians know the names of the pilots who are in training and the families who are in training, that is, exactly the information, how many planes and when we will receive them from such countries, we will not hear, yes we ourselves will not hear which of the legions will appear in the open space, that is, this information will be day by day as it was applied to the attacks, so it is quite ... profitable that the use of french troops or what else is possible troops, but we will learn about it from time to time. coming back, i asked ms. oksana this question, you know, we are now talking about the aid of france, we are talking about the aid of other countries, but at the same time, i know that you are researching this topic and it is close to you, but at the same time, we have some kind of simply unresolved situation on the polish border, where how much today one point works, kraków's

korchova, if i'm not mistaken, for travel. well, there was such information about the passage of cargo trucks, everything else was closed, and there was some kind of misunderstanding, although, well, sort of the closest neighbors understand what the russian federation is, they were impatient with it as well, yes , it is a very important and very difficult problem for us, it is not unexpected, although for those who follow bilateral relations, i will not say that it was unexpected, and this if in fact, a parallel track, very sad... that these events are taking place in parallel with what is happening on the fronts, yes, because it seemed who, who, but from hungary it could be expected, but it seemed from poland not, but the point is that this problem should be viewed from the point of view of the future membership ukraine in the european union and in general those problems that have accumulated in the european union itself, so we are now talking about agriculture as the most drastic, the one that triggers. well, most

of the countries of the european union, but as ukraine, as a future member of the european union, well , it is a serious competitor in fact, and next to ukraine, no other country of the european union can even come close to competing in the field of agriculture, and therefore it is necessary to understand that it is such a kind of unfair competition, this is such and such a way protectionist policy, i would say, which is not officially conducted by the polish government, but de facto... it is carried out by private hands by groups of farmers, a fairly influential segment of society, as farmers, respectively , due to the fact that the previous government is still piss pissu and the current government of tusk's coalition, which inherited this problem from the previous government, very often not having ready-made solutions and being in a constant non-stop election

process, then parliament... elections, now local, then soon elections to the european parliament, in the 25th year of presidential elections, she actually due to unwillingness to lose ratings, is not ready to make important and bold decisions , accordingly, the government very often removed itself, although the negotiation process is taking place, well , it is ineffective, yes, because without the government's readiness to make certain important, bold decisions, you are not you, you are not, you are not, no, you will not be able to move the situation from... your point and de facto farmers have taken ukraine and the de facto polish government hostage because, on the one hand, they cannot deal with them, they are not ready to make bold decisions, and accordingly, because of this demonization, as if, here is the classic politics of populism, in fact, polish farmers are looking for simple solutions, they demonized ukrainian grain, although denying the fact

that ukrainian grain really... had a negative impact on both the polish market and the european one, denying this you can't, but there is a large set of other factors that caused a certain crisis in the european union, and because in this triangle kyiv, warsaw, brussels, warsaw is just waiting for a decision in brussels, brussels is tied hand and foot, because it agricultural policy is a policy. which has been in the works for years, and the last time this policy was reformed in 2003, when there was the largest expansion of the european union, and the future accession of ukraine to the european union will also force the reform of the rural sector, which shares the agricultural policy of the european union, and in the combination of all these large number of factors and war, about which they are somehow modestly silent, that the war has a negative effect on the market situation, that the market.