gorbasenko's wife issued a power of attorney to tsvekr to dispose of her property on the peninsula, while volodymyr gorbasenko granted similar rights to his son, a judge. everything points to the fact that the head of the economic court of the kyiv region maintains close ties with the father, who may turn out to be a collaborator. we also see that there is information that he most likely maintains ties with his father, which can be a definite criterion for his being recognized as unscrupulous. the public integrity council paid attention and... the second is incredible the fictitious divorce of judge gorbasenko from his wife, kyiv city council member hanna sveridenko. they allegedly broke up for the first time at the end of 2014. however, they remained in such a wonderful relationship that they went to europe together 5 days after the divorce. in february 2017, the former couple had their first child, joint trips abroad became more frequent. in 2022, the couple married again, gave birth to a second child within a year, and divorced again. serve for this, two identical

divorce suits, probably for manipulation of the distribution system, one suit was returned, another was accepted and considered with abnormal speed in a matter of days, with violations of all procedural terms. the divorce took place just before the opening of the register of declarations, so there is every reason to believe that the purpose of the spouses was to hide part of the income and property. horoposenko submitted, firstly, a clarifying declaration for 2022, and secondly, we still have to... check some of his declarations, and we see that his wife sverdenko is listed again as a wife, and he has another daughter and we would like to too pay a little more attention to this fact. a lot of questions and benefits of the judge arise. most of the property owned by gorbasenko allegedly came to him from his mother. she gave two apartments in the capital of 116 and 136 m2 in the summer area on the obolon embankment, and she built a house of more than 800 m2 in the village of lebedivka. kyiv, while the woman did not run

a business, but was a housewife. the wife, or rather the ex-wife, during her stay with gorbasenko, from 2012 to 14 years, also acquired a considerable amount of real estate. a house of 122 m2, two apartments of 164 and 155 m2, two parking spaces and two plots of land, and all this with a total income for that period of uah 1 million. temporary real estate is also added to property in kyiv. occupied crimea, where anna sveredenko has four non-residential premises in gaspri, which is near yalta, as well as several plots of land in sudak and a house of more than 300 m2. gorbasenko refuses to explain these facts. the information that is compiled, allegedly in a new conclusion, has already been researched, has already been processed and refuted, as categorically against, adjournment, and i will appeal to honorable members. commission to continue

the review. after a closed discussion of the higher qualifications, the commission nevertheless decided to postpone the consideration of gorbasenko. based on the results of the discussion, a protocol decision is announced to postpone consideration of the issue. we asked pavlo gorbasenko about the probable intention to hide real marital relations, connections with the terrorist state and about fortunes that cause doubts. mr. pavlo, please tell me what your father did while roaming in the occupied kyiv region? rde your divorce from as a wife looks doubtful, considering that you have a second child, i don't want to answer you on the fly, if you want to do a good interview, then come visit, send questions, even about the wealth analyzed by the community council good idea, fortune analyzed and the conclusion is drawn that there are no questions about fortunes, so let's not invent a report from something that is not there. we hope, after a careful study of all newly discovered facts. which

may testify to the dishonesty of judge pavlo gorbasenko, the commission will decide on him fair decision the ethics council completed interviews with candidates for the position of member of the supreme council of justice under the quota of president volodymyr zelenskyi. currently, the vrp has 17 members out of 21. the president has to appoint two , and for more than a year and a half, the seats are empty, and the applicants are doubtful. this is a judge of the kyiv district administrative court on... and she has a wonderful friendly family and good social security, so she lives in her mother's apartments, which her sister bought, drives her daughter's car, and eats rations from the state. i am a person who knows how to save, and i had no need to spend. since 2022, panchenko and her husband have been living in an apartment designed for the judge's mother. 64 m almost in the center of kyiv, she bought it back in december 2012 for real estate. supposedly the whole

family was thrown out, the financing of this apartment took place, i say once again that at the expense of the savings of my mother, father, ah, brother. my mother, i also spoke about the fact that my sister also participated in the financing of this purchase of this apartment, during the interview, as a candidate for higher education of the qualification commission, judge, you said that the money for the purchase was provided by your sister, her income from 98 to 12 years was. perhaps i answered incorrectly then, two years before purchasing this apartment, the judge's sister bought another one for her mother in the capital, with an area of ​​34 square meters, and the woman never lived in any of them, instead

nataliya panchenko and her husband used the real estate. why did you live in this apartment? your sister bought the apartment where you lived, why so? purchase motives? this apartment for my sister would not like to make it public at all, but due to certain life circumstances, she acquired it. at the same time, she stayed where she lived. there was no need for me and my family to purchase an apartment, due to the fact that we understood that in the near future we would receive an apartment from the state. natalya panchenko always had a lot of hopes for the state , for example, she even managed to buy a new audi q7 with the help of social security, which was issued for her daughter, but the judge herself used the car. it was in our country such as the maintenance of officers and their families at the expense of the state was introduced, and i want

to tell you about what exactly i can get confused in the hands of now, at the same time , they are my daughters somewhere up to the third grade, because i just remember , as we lived, so we were provided. we didn't spend money on housing, because the state compensated for it, we didn't spend money on food, because the state also provided us with it, and that was the concept of rations, well, in russian, ration, well, that is, when an officer was given food on him for his family members, obviously the whole family of the judge knows how to save money, her husband managed to buy... a motorcycle with a market value of more than 7 thousand dollars 15 times cheaper. it is a completely ordinary motorcycle. what i see, as far as i can tell from an outside observer, there is nothing like that at all. please explain. such a huge difference between

the real price of the motorcycle and the agreement of the parties, and why was it like that? the price, i do not know, because i was not a participant in this relationship, why he sold it at that price price, i don't know. perhaps panchenko does not see the problem, because she herself gives away her own cars for nothing. she sold her toyota rav-4 for uah 100. he says that the car was badly damaged in an accident. in general , the ethical council had many questions about the integrity of the judge of the kyiv district administrative court natalia panchenko. soon we will find out whether the minister managed to convince these themis. experts in their respective positions, members of the supreme council of justice. and for today i have everything, it was judicial control and i am tetyana shustrova. if you know the facts of corruption in the judicial system, or you want to report

an unscrupulous judge who makes illegal decisions, write to me on facebook or to the e-mail address you see on the screen. all the best, will meet. in exactly one week, congratulations, this is the beraber program together with crimean tatar into ukrainian, if translated, but it can be translated in both directions, because it is a joint project of the crimean tatar tv channel atr and the ukrainian tv channel novinnoy, i am andriy yanitskyi. and with me in the studio khalilovul khalilova and silya malikum, we welcome you to the air of the tv channel and the first crimean tv channel, and of course today we will talk about crimea, we will sum up this week and we will read from the military

component, because now we already have our guest on direct communication , this is mr. andrii klymenko, project manager at the institute of black sea strategic studies, mr. andriy, congratulations. you have silya maliyko. good day. good day. mr. andriy, we would like to start with such news. recently it became known that the minister of foreign affairs of great britain, david cameron, promised to arrange. hunting for the price fleet of the russian federation, and, well, it can be said that he announced such a hunt for the russian price fleet. i would like you to first explain, in a popular way for our viewers, what is the price fleet of the russian federation and how does it use it to circumvent sanctions on its oil exports? well, look, yes, we 're joking here that since cameron uh... voiced his ideas about a week after we published and circulated our suggestions for

that he will support us, well , actually, the ways of information are not known, but it was nice that this is really the most important in our opinion, safe problem, i emphasize, such an authoritative international politician voiced what it was about? in russia, for many years, export revenues have been formed almost entirely at the expense of energy exports, in this energy export, well, you know, we have always paid a lot of attention to the topic of gas, so it was somehow believed that gas is the main thing there, and that... the cessation of activities there are northern streams,

it was very damaging, gas accounted for only about 20% of the revenue structure of russian energy exports. 80% is its sea export of oil and oil products, and there is also 10% of coal and oil. ugh, this situation is still ongoing, so that our viewers and listeners understand the scale, well, i will name the following indicators, the results of our monitoring for the month of may: baltic sea, approximately 12 million tons of crude oil, and another 4 million oil products, uh, the black sea of ​​russian

oil, i mean, crude, yes, the black sea, about 4 million tons of russian oil, and approximately, 3.5 million tons of russian oil products, if you add it all up, multiply it by 7.3, that is, transport it in barrels and... er multiply it by 70 dollars per barrel, er, and even 80, there the numbers are different in different months, it turns out that russia will receive up to 15 million dollars per month, er billions, uh, dollars per month from this, of course , and i always say this. it has been more than a year that as long as this channel exists, as long as this export exists,

er, then - putin will have money to produce and buy abroad chips, optical devices, everything that is needed for production missiles that are flying at you and me all over ukraine, and especially in the odesa region. isn't it every day, about a year ago, yes, in june , two years ago, it was in june 22nd of the year j7 the european union announced an embargo on the supply of russian oil to its ports, and the so-called price cap was introduced for the rest of the ports . coming out, and it was said that if this oil or oil product

is transported, that means, ships of the european union, then there may be a fixed price of no more than 60 in the contracts, because, well, yes, we laughed at this decision, honestly. saying, because it was clear that there is no control system for this, that it is a matter for the russians to forge any contracts... 2-3 minutes and finally, for a year , putin's decree has existed, which directly states that those those who sell oil and those who transport oil are expressly prohibited from specifying the price of that price in

the contract text, in the annexes to the contract, or even mentioning it. and that is, putin canceled this whole story at the beginning of the 23rd year, and of course, well, here you are, means to buy oil, or whatever, and you, the european union, j7, say that you can buy it for only 60 dollars. and the seller tells you: yes, to your health, i have a price of 80, that's all. mr. andrii, that is, they formed a shadow fleet that does not fly under european flags and does not belong to europeans, but how many vessels of these oil tankers are there now, or

what is the correct name for such vessels, tankers, tankers, yes, well, i, about the concept... the shadow fleet, i will make a separate remark, and as for the number, not everything is so simple there with the europeans. on today, 32% of tankers transporting russian oil from the baltic are tankers from the european union countries of greece. ugh. approximately 12-15% of european tankers carrying russian crude oil from the black sea. these are also greek tankers, well, in total, 30% can be safely said to be european tankers, and even then, no pricescape can be maintained there, since, as you rightly said, russia has reoriented its exports to asian countries, mainly india, china, and it all goes,

and it all goes there, and i don't know which ones are there greek shipowners, therefore, provide the dock'. ments are contractual, but there are already dozens of investigations into non-compliance with the price ceiling, and they were carried out by such giants of the world media as bloomberg, routers, the associated press, cnn and others, they all prove that it is impossible to control this in india and china, which means that and therefore... it does not work, however, our friends in the united states in the european union, friends, allies and partners, for some reason they stubbornly want to, well , it seems that we need to reduce it, listen, well, since it cannot be sustained and there is no mechanism control, you can reduce, increase, well

, the russians will laugh at this and drive for it like this, one more argument, russia has money, then the prices were different for oil, and if you completely block the russian export of russian oil, then the prices will skyrocket, this is bad for the world economy, it will overheat, the goods in europe, in the states, let them sell little by little, not as expensive as before, but the main profit. the margin remains in china and india, well, this is the logic that the defenders of these sanctions broadcast, and even in america and we heard about the fact that america is just, well, they are worried about the fact that it can provoke the so -called inflationary pressure on the oil market and even an increase in prices for gas and

oil, but what are you doing, it can do, but eh. .. experts of the energy market are sure that this will happen, if it does happen, then there will be a small increase, secondly, that this - it will be short-lived, er, why, because russia's share in this market, well, up to 10%, that is, it is not critical, it is by 50 and not 40, not 70, and russia is not a monopolist, and finally eh... already more and more experts say that: well, remember how the economy of the soviet union collapsed, the united states negotiated with saudi arabia. increased the export of their own oil and collapsed world prices, but in principle the same thing,

in fact, we need to do it now, because anyway, the more, yes, the longer putin’s opportunity to finance the war lasts, the more countries there and america and europe will spend on ... ukrainian weapons, for ukrainian shells and missiles, yes, there for production for ukraine, all of this, and they will spend such considerable funds on the support of those many millions of our citizens who went there with their children from the war and live there, and the main thing is that it is not easy. then, if they want the war to last until the last ukrainian, then probably it should be done, as they are doing, so

now, but we are trying to change this, i will tell you, so the thesis of the shadow fleet, i don't even know anymore, who invented this legend, that there is some shadow fleet, it is not known where it was registered. unknown by flags, very old, ecologically dangerous, so there is no shadow raft, we know everyone by name and patronymic, conventionally speaking, every tanker, we know when, so they were built, we know that there are no ships there, and most of the ships were built after... a year, that is, it's very, it's, it's new vessels, yes, up to 20 years of the tanker, this is very , very normal, so these are some legends, mr.

andriy, if, if we know all this, then i do not call for anything, but just such a question, why suddenly some troubles with these vessels do not become at sea, there are some pirates there, i don’t know, well, you understand, so there is a right wars at sea, yeah, and of course there are a lot, when i write my posts on facebook, of course there are a lot of comments, that they should be drowned there, sabotage by that tanker in the black sea and so on, well, here we are, ukraine positions itself as a legal state that adheres to international norms, there is a law from... war at sea, it has existed since the beginning of the last century, it seems that the first geac convention was in 1909, then it was there,

so these conventions were updated, but the essence does not change, the warring countries do not have the right to detain, sink , and confiscate ships belonging to non-belligerent countries, that is, since there, well , look, i said, in the baltic sea 30%, yes, in the black sea 12%, this is for crude oil, these are european ships, then we say, listen, you don't need to tell, i say, you need to take away european tankers from these routes. uh, so, that is -30%. in numbers, it is like this: approximately 100 tankers from the baltic, and approximately

20-30 every month from the black sea. take a third, that's a lot. let them look for, er, tankers in other countries, there, of course, what the freight price of these tankers will increase, of course, which will decrease, uh,... uh, so it will increase, the costs will increase, so in addition to what you said, they get less, they get less just because of the fact that the way has become, that is, before they were transported from the baltic, from leningrad, ustluga, and other ports to the parks of the european union, it is very close, cheap and so on, now, of course. that when they transport oil from st. petersburg by tanker to bombay or shanghai, it takes a month or more.

a month, yes, it is more expensive, but it is not critical more expensive, and besides, we don’t know, since this whole topic with contracts, it is closed in this situation, we don’t know what goodies russia promises to the same india, the same china, and other countries, they can means to have some other agreements, which... as if it does not apply, to someone the supply of weapons, to someone benefits, in a different way, some benefits in other directions of economic cooperation and so on, that is why we say that there are, there are ways out, and these concrete ways, you see, their cameron just so, a little indicated that it should be done, we are now promote a topic like this. er, if time

permits, we still have four or five minutes, mr. andriy, it is possible, uh, that is, what should be done, first, well, first, i already said that it is necessary to take away the er tankers of the european union , there are american tankers, they transport from the port of novorossiysk there from the baltic ports, er, mineral fertilizers, vegetable oil, we tell them, listen, well, don’t be ashamed of these two or three tankers, yes, take them from these routes in addition, it means that what needs to be done, each tanker has its unique name, er, this is the registration the international maritime organization's amo number, which is assigned to every ship in the world at birth and is no longer used

after. how the ships ceased to exist, that is, impose sanctions on all these thousands of tankers that carry, what will it mean? the ship goes through the english channel, or through the straits, kogtegats, kagerak, from the baltic to the north sea, in the first case - this is denmark, in the second case - britain and france. they all pay the european companies, the british companies, the channel fee, they pay the pilotage and all those the services that go through the strait, as soon as you put them on the sanctions lists, they lose the ability to make those payments, and by the way, in the bosphorus, i

think that... our turkish neighbors, they will think very hard, and what to do with these tankers, which are entered vessels, not the owners, yes, but the vessels themselves, about these sanction lists. thank you, that is, ugh, and finally , the ecological maritime service of any country can stop ships in its economic zone, that is, in the baltic sea and in the straits. and check them for leaks there is that top, that oil and everything else, it must be done, thank you, yes, andriy klymenko, the project manager at the institute of black sea strategic studies, talked about the russian fleet, which they export their crude oil to, and now we have to take a break literally for a moment, we're back, a new week on espresso,

weekly recap. non-analytical program, a clear understanding of the key events of the past week, analysis of the causes and consequences of these events from experts, forecasts of the development of the situation for the current week, the opportunity to ask your own questions and join the discussion, spend the final monday evening with us and confidently step into the new week. the new week project with khrystyna yatskiv and andrii smoly every monday at 8:00 p.m. on espresso. every week, the saturday political club helps to understand the process. what is happening in ukraine and the world, if you want to understand how our today will affect our tomorrow, watch the saturday political club every saturday on espresso. congratulations again, khairla kunier, you are watching the joint project of the first crimean tatar tv channel atr and the tv channel, the program is taken together.