will move, will be exactly the same as those of other people, and they are interested in conducting dialogue honestly and openly and simplifying the system, but in fact, not much has changed in the state management system, in the draft management system, and in the system the management of troops, and often densely a system of a smaller order, that is, the system of mobilization, governs the general life of the state. determines which business survives, which business dies, who goes to the army, who doesn't, it can't be like that, it should be a general state policy, maybe the president should intervene and appoint a responsible person, one authorized by the president to somehow modernize this reform of the mobilization process, to make it more humane, to establish reverse communication between hello and society, if

the president has a hard time with personnel, contact me, i will help, and i would like to return a little to the issue of technology, you are currently providing, well , really, i would say, an important role, so that new developments appear on the battlefield as soon as possible, but does the accelerator or other structures of the ministry of defense or the general staff have units, who analyze the russian experience, russian. trends in order to get ahead of them, because there were reports that a number of structures were disbanded that were engaged in this, and this probably has a negative effect on the analysis of the situation on the battlefield and on the analysis of russian tactics, whether it is true or not, what is your vision, how are we analyzing the russian experience? the analysis is carried out by several structures, not only the ministry of defense and the armed forces, but also other military formations.

there are such divisions, but now i am directly in a scientific institution, yes contacting scientists to get their latest developments to technological implementation, very interesting, i'm almost three hours, we were going to work for an hour, we are working for four, and i think it will not be finished quickly, but back to your question, analysis of use, combat the use of russian developments is being carried out, those parts that you mentioned, they were more engaged in modern developments of ukrainian production, not in the analysis of russian e-e weapons, types of weapons, i think that the reform of units and in the ministry of defense and in the general staff, which are responsible for the it cluster, for the cluster for unmanned systems, for the cluster

of ground automated systems, the system of automated control of troops, it will only improve, to a greater extent it concerns the reduction of certain units that do not have applied development, and people who have the appropriate knowledge, skills and abilities, they will not be lost, believe me, they will be redirected to other high-tech areas of development in... production and combat use of modern types of weapons, and we we are working on this so that not a single person from these teams is lost, as well as not a single project, we heard more than two hundred modern developments, both of an applied nature, from the whole array, promising developments, they will be implemented in the troops, that's why. ..

we have already learned to separate the wheat from the chaff, this is pavlo kishkar, we are now trying to restore contact, and pavlo is just the representative, the head of the project office of the ministry of defense, the accelerator of the ministry of defense, which directs its efforts to ensure that the best technological developments, which already have a high degree of... readiness, were tested, first on training grounds, and then in combat operations, and then in the format of orders they already became serial products and became part of the status of regular units, which will already use it en masse in combat, as it is now with unmanned systems, with ground systems, naval unmanned systems, and this is what is the basis of our technological advantage over the enemy, because the enemy has a numerical advantage on... over

us, we have to provide technological changes that provide precisely the technological advantage over the enemy. these were the main military results of this day, then vasyl zima will continue the broadcast, so stay tuned... thank you to his guest, we heard many important opinions, in fact, fair opinions, and i would very much like, let's say, that the phrase "perhaps the president should to say about it, and he will change something, was heard by the president, of course, we should not live in such a patriarchal state, but a monarchical one, where one person has to decide everything." tele very often, as we see, when certain information reaches the relevant people, certain decisions are made, regarding the fact that each person should preferably occupy the position for which he is most suitable in the armed forces of ukraine, for the sake of the effectiveness of the armed forces of ukraine, it is absolutely worth

supporting here, well but an ideal ideal society, an ideal army, an ideal relationship do not exist anywhere in the world, we strive for this, and of course in... the period of war, i would very much like that something in me does not want to work at all, well, then i have my own in other words, we are collecting money for our soldiers who are fighting in the solidarsky and zaporizhzhia directions, they need a minibus in order to deliver repair and restoration groups, mobile, closer to the front line, or this is the so-called gray zone, that is, not ours , not yours, where, as they say, they walk. ghosts and our and enemy troops, and this is a very dangerous area, because again it is not officially controlled by either side, and so in this gray zone or on the contact line very often our armored vehicles are blown up with explosives either by a mine or a high-explosive weapon or it is hit with a certain means of impact there or an rpg or

something else, it must be repaired very quickly, because again, a working apc or bmp or a tank is a plus, because a tank can be hit. the enemy can be hit by the accumulation of manpower, it is possible to hit the enemy's armored vehicles. the armored personnel carrier makes it possible to move the infantry from one point to another, under the cover of armor, again, well, the bmp can also conduct effective combat operations. you see a qr code. we need to collect on a minibus in order to mobile repair teams could be sent to repair this equipment very quickly. we have already been able to collect with you, now i will tell you how much we have been able to collect already 571,663. we have uah 60,000 left, i hope that for today and tomorrow, plus my colleagues will join in on other channels, and we will be able to collect this amount and close this issue, and finally give our military the opportunity to purchase the necessary transport, contact us mr. petro obukhova, deputy of the odesa

city council, mr. peter, i congratulate you, i congratulate you, good day, first of all i will ask, i am i read today, i have information about odesa, odesa region, i will still ask how the last day has passed in terms of enemy attacks, shelling, if we are talking about odesa, odesa region, please, well, the only thing this morning was an attempt to attack the odesa region with one missile, as far as i know i understand, this missile, well, as they say, lost its capacity or maybe was shot down, ugh, well, but still, the enemy does not leave odessa, odesa region, for quite a long time, more or less in terms of infrastructure on... other objects , on energy objects, on those objects about which we don't say, the enemy is trying to hit, or sometimes he succeeds or fails to hit, in any case causes destruction, what is the situation with the provision of water and electricity in odesa, again in odesa region, because it is important to understand how these enemy attacks now make

it possible to provide people, at least with these humanitarian, humanitarian needs that people have, water, electricity, please, well, electricity... damn, everyone has 5, 6 hours, there is water, we will get i don't hope so, already this year gas generators from japan and all large boiler houses will be provided with electricity in case of blackouts and also water supply, that is, i hope that this winter will pass normally in odessa, well, actually, i will also hope for it , by the way, it's very good, let's say odesa, i understand that you... on your own at the level of the region of the city negotiated with the government or with some japanese organizations regarding the supply of these gas generators, that is, it is a local initiative, as they say , this is how our mayor and vice-mayors traveled in the past year to japan, to the sister city of yokohama, and

there we agreed, japan helps odesa a lot, it also provided us with water purification systems, in case someone is with our main water supply, then we will be able to take untreated water. to make drinking water with it, that is, some work is being done here, well, it is very difficult, these generators, they cost a billion hryvnias, and we at the session that took place, by the way, yesterday, we allocated 30 million hryvnias in order to... equip them , that is, when they arrive, it will be necessary to make some kind of foundation there, to connect to the network, this is what we are already doing at our expense, well, this is actually a very cool initiative, we know that a number of countries help one or another region of ukraine, for example, the neighboring odesa, mykolaiv region actively cooperates, let's say with the kingdom of denmark, we see odesa with japan, i think not only with japan, it is very good that there are people who find opportunities and realize them. and convince our partners to convey exactly what is needed, i will ask what this topic is about,

it has been around for a long time, well, not so long, but it has flashed very brightly in the ether, the topic here is this fight that happened, well, if you can call it that, between, well, it's not a fight, it was a tense situation between the workers of the tsc and the ambulance workers, although there were again different people there, i won't update it here, well but the story had to continue. in that sense, thank god, not in the sense of a fight, not in the sense of clarifying relations, in the sense that the reservation of ambulance workers in odesa, at least now we are talking about odesa, well, the city council supported the application for the reservation of ambulance workers assistance, i would also like to add that 600 employees have been laid off from the emergency service, again, is this true or not true, what kind of people are they and to what extent will it be possible to solve this issue specifically regarding the reservation of ambulance workers, who are all employees or only individual specialists who provide assistance, who drive this

ambulance, please, what is the status of solving this issue and whether it was possible to establish a dialogue, most importantly, between the local council, local authorities and representatives of the city or regional of the territorial center of recruitment and social support, please, well , look, when that situation and that fight happened, i even saw information about it in the western, western press, it was on the bbc, it was on other media, and it was it is very shameful, very unpleasant that we have become famous in this way, but in fact at that time the emergency workers were not booked, by this, they were all tricked by the regional structure, we had a session of the regional council this week, first, and then the city council, and on session of the regional council is very strange history, they turned to the cabinet of ministers with a request to book, what a pause, from the employees of security agencies, and

the amendment to add at least ambulance workers to this request, the deputies of the regional council failed, unfortunately, we have such a coalition there servants of the people from the opzh, and they support such ridiculous things, and they do not support some reasonable ones, and after that the deputies of the odesa council and the odesa city council decided to make their appeal to the governor and to the cabinet of ministers in order to... ask to reserve emergency workers , indeed they were not booked, uh, the dialogue continues, there are more of them, well, no one is stopping them in the way that it was, there is indeed a release, by the way, women, doctors, they are also conscripted, that's why they are also may be at risk, but i understand that this scandal he... led to the post office, and this situation will be resolved. yes, well, let's hope, again, this is a question

of a wise approach, but pain we are talking about people, well, let's say, you said about security workers, again, i will not to judge, because i don't have that right, who should be banned, who shouldn't, maybe circus workers, maybe representatives of football clubs of the first league, the top league should be in favor, i don't know, again, i don't know, but sometimes, well , if you look at kyiv, look, after mobilization, again, mobilization is a necessary process and... it continues and the ministry of defense says that there are good results, that is, we see results, but it is just a fact: 27% of the employees of the kyiv city council are booked , lack of personnel 14%, well, this is a light for people, and these are people who solve urgent needs, it is clear that there may be some people who do not solve, do not repair lights, they just sit in an office somewhere in kyivmiskvitla and are booked, and the efficiency of their work for the communal, communal sphere of the city is zero, such it also happens, well, let's be honest, people are also different. t, but the question is that, after all, it is necessary to approach so that the city can live, transport, utilities, ambulance, elevators

to be repaired, excuse me to clean the pipes from shit, some other things must be done, well, that has to be done be, it should be, or when you look at the fact that 700 thousand are booked, and these people are not at all clear, why they and not others, well, it should not be, so the fact that there is a dialogue is important, i think that ukrainians nevertheless, as a result of the dialogue, although sometimes passions flare up somewhere, but they find a common language and it is very important. i think that during the first stage of the law on mobilization, all these difficult points will be agreed and resolved, the issue of beaches, you know, well, there are many people in odessa now... take from other regions of ukraine and maybe local residents too, although they say that odessans go to the beach most often, but, but, i haven’t been this year yet, yes, we see a lot of people, you know, and when our side says so, well, the military, in particular there, why the russians they drive people to crimea to rest on the beach, or talk about the holiday season in crimea, because crimea, as ryfat chuvarov said, is

a front-line zone, and therefore the russians are to blame for the fact that rockets can fall, because the fragments of rockets are on the beach. you don't need to rest in crimea, well, excuse me, odesa is also actually a front-line zone, if you can say so, if not front-line, because odessa is constantly attacked from the air, and the people on the beaches are also people who, well, they all flew from turkey there or from another place, the sea ends, odessa immediately begins, that's all, that is, there is no more conditional rocket or shahede where to go, how to solve this issue, because on the one hand we say, look, they are setting up their people there in the crimea, they will say, so look... and you also have in odesa, we are shooting at you, although we criminals, well, they won't say that, but you have people lying on the beach, yes and we are innocent, but what did you beaches reveal, how to find a solution here, well, there are different situations, first of all, they in russia do not feel that there is a war there, for them it is still quite strange that something flew to them, they don't understand why, how it happened, and

it's obvious that it's the fault of the russian authorities, and they, by the way, admitted that they shot down our missile there, this atacoms. and because of the actions of their air defense, this is what they constantly accuse us of, that it is our air defense that is allegedly to blame, but their air defense was to blame, they themselves admitted it, it was very strange for me, well, as for odesa, we have one officially open beach, there is even a storage facility on this beach, there are also plans to place several concrete storage facilities on the beaches, but excuse me, well, everyone knows that we are at war, everyone knows that we have rockets flying , shaheds, even... several times this year i have already nailed sea mines, or even landmines, to the shore, which still come from the shack, and everyone must take this responsibility upon themselves, this is one of the reasons why i have not been yet on the sea, and well, officially these beaches are not open and the authorities did not tell you to go there swim, we will protect you, there was no such thing,

but we understand that it is impossible to stop people, and even there in the times of covid and it was very funny, when it was with... defense to swim on the beaches, then the police came first, they it was such a task to take pictures every day that no one was swimming, and they first came and asked people to come out, well, to take a picture, and then they didn’t ask for that anymore, they asked to be a little quiet, save yourself, we will take a picture, that the sea is clean and that’s all let's go, well, that is, to prevent people from bathing, it needs to be shot some borders from the police, no one will do that, so everyone should have their head on their shoulders. or he who is responsible for his children, he must understand that he is responsible for them. we already had a case, about a month ago, when serhii kivalov was flown here and there, such an irony of fate, but there was an arrival of rockets, rockets with a cluster warhead, several people died there, it seems like six or seven, some were still in hospitals, then died, and it was just

such a seaside resort area, so everyone, everyone understand this, mr. peter, i... at the very end, here is the good news that during the 10 months of great odessa sports, a record amount of cargo was transported, this is again, glory to the armed forces of ukraine and to everyone who joined this work, and literally in one sentence, but it is very important, they will build in odesa, i read that in odesa, maybe in odesa region, maybe the information is wrong, they will build a waste incineration plant that will produce electricity, i just have one question, it is when it can happen, not because i say let's hurry up, no, just wondering when it is it can be implemented, because it is... a very good idea actually, well, look, this will also be implemented by the japanese, they will do it in odesa, yesterday at the session we allocated 4 hectares of land for the construction of this plant, but it will be quite slow, we were not given any deadlines, but it is years, i understand, yes, but still the idea is good and god forbid that it be implemented and work for the good of the city, thank

you very much, petro obuho, a deputy of the city council , odesa city council was in touch with us, do you remember this famous phrase on... kharkiv and all kharkiv residents. yes, well, but we were talking about odessa. thank you, mr. peter, and now we will move on to domestic political issues, contact us, just one second. oleksiy koshelya, doctor of historical sciences, head of the committee of voters of ukraine, is in touch with us. mr. oleksiy, i congratulate you. good day. we discussed this a little yesterday, but today i want to talk more substantively, the results of a sociological survey provided by the razumkov center, and there in... all the headlines, the news got into the headlines, probably the president read it, he thinks, well, there is a woman there are other results, but why did you bet that trust in me is falling, i was probably offended, but i'm just kidding. but the news that trust in the president has fallen, but the issue there is that trust in the president's institute and specifically in volodymyr zelenskyi, these are slightly different trusts,

volodymyr zelenskyi is allegedly trusted more than the president's institute itself, please explain how you evaluate these results in general, the key, at least, moments regarding trust in state institutions, the economic situation there, as evaluated by the people of this center razumkova, which were made public yesterday, please, i always used to read the first part... and carefully read the text of the study of the razumko center, to be honest, this media campaign that zelensky personally is trusted more than the institute, well, i see such signs just an active media campaign, i don't want to imply anything to anyone, but i didn't like it very much, that is, there are certain natural things, for example, president volodymyr zelensky's confidence indicators are falling, and we are observing this at... approximately from the end in december, the drop there actually occurs every month, for example, last month, according to the kms, trust was 61%, now

, according to the zumkov center, it is around 54%. so there is a fall, there are reasons, there is a logical explanation, i.e. the scandal with the resignation of a good man, minus 5% trust in the head of state, there are any scandals in the faction of the servant of the people, corruption there tyshchenko. and everything else, it is also affected, but there is nothing catastrophic, that is , the president has a confidence level of 54%, these are absolutely normal natural processes, but it was like this the campaign about the fact that there is a miracle that for some reason zelensky's personality is higher than that, it is incomprehensible to me, these and these are political games, i see, and i am very unhappy that a lot of media was tied to it, maybe some people just don't know that he... in addition to the fact that he is volodymyr zelenskyi, he is also the president, well , of course i am joking, but i fully understand that there are certain people who may think that this is the president, this is some one person, and volodymyr zlenskyi is a different person, well, there are many different people in ukraine, but i am also completely different

i agree with you, well, listen, to trust and love and connect some hopes with the same person for the sixth year already, in wartime, in times of economic hardship, when it is difficult, when mobilization, when people die, are injured, when so far that the evidence is not visible, but... the forces of the armed forces of ukraine still manage to restrain the enemy, to strike, to say that in this situation people will love the president, general syrskyi, relatively speaking, even those people on whom the premium depends of the prime minister, well, it's very difficult, that's why 50 z percentage hook, it seems to me that in principle this indicates that there is still a safety margin or not, i think that the authorities have a safety margin in general, by the way, the parliament has a safety margin, so... our organization conducted research , just yesterday we made it public, there are negative pages there , for example, the number of votes of two groups of the former

opzh for draft laws that become laws, that is, for the support of the authorities, increased threefold, from 20% to 60, this is an extremely large figure, and now we are considering even groups of former latecomers as members of the coalition, this is also by the way affects ratings and trust in institutions. personalities, and on the other hand we see that every fifth vote is accepted by a constitutional majority, this means that the parliament has a margin of safety, the president, the government also has a margin of safety, strong enough, but the question is that if we if we do not get out of political games and do not increase the efficiency of management decision-making, then we can quickly destroy this margin of safety, but weak efficiency is... weak quality, low quality of management decisions, it is is reflected in literally everything, according to this we can, can we talk about a parliamentary

crisis, because you know, after this ongoing story, it has only just begun, well, if this story began a long time ago precisely with the scandalous and scandalous stories surrounding people's deputy mykola tyshchenko, no i will call him popularly, after all, well, let's respect ourselves, at least whoever wants to call him by some nicknames, we... we are talking about a people's deputy, elected, by the way, by the people of kyiv, in honest elections, this well, because always, when they say, there is such a handsome man, no, you, you elected him, well, the people elected him, he is a people's deputy, mykola tyshchenko, but now this story has come out and entered a critical phase, and they are already starting to talk about a parliamentary crisis, now mr. tyshchenko will be there, then there may be others there, in general it will fall, it will fall, at least the majority, there are some signs that it will fall, apart from the fact that a certain number of people's deputies, it's not... red, want to leave their seats, their positions, although there are gentlemen like that on the approach who is called a joker, and there is the 153rd number on the list, may by the way get to

the verkhovna rada, i don’t know if it will be strengthened to... improve work, but are there signs of a parliamentary crisis, or is it better to talk about it closer to in the fall and not in the middle of summer? i thank you very much for your question, because really often, when considering this or that crisis, considering this or that scandal, corruption fact, they immediately start talking about the crisis, eh, i have seen the signs of a parliamentary crisis for a long time, let's say the last calendar year is exactly, what is it? it manifests itself in being ignored. bills of the opposition, this is manifested in the ignoring, what is worse, in the ignoring of government initiatives, and we see that there more than 70% of the government bills are simply not adopted, i see signs of a crisis in the fact that the parliament does not know how to set priorities, and a number of bills, in including the military, accepts with a very significant delay, but i always brought up examples, duty-free import, duty-free import and vat

of drones, spare parts for drones, guys, these were all separate bills, these the decisions were made with a delay of a year and a half, but as far as i'm concerned, in the conditions of war, this is simply a verdict for the government and for the parliamentary majority. these are actually signs of a parliamentary crisis, a very serious one, but again, there is a safety margin in the parliament, here is an example of our research, in six months of this year, the parliament adopted 70 draft laws. for no draft law in the monomajority, not you, the monomajority did not give 226 votes, well, in principle, this is not surprising, until the 22nd year, we observed approximately the same trends, but there are approximately 180-190% deputies vote, that is, the majority can still work at the expense of the allies, unfortunately, including at the expense of the opzj

decision. will be adopted, why, why rightly so, because i see that now in the parliament one of the key problems is the dependence of the government on the two groups of the former opposition platform for life, and when we speak, we ask the question, why is the church bill not adopted, why is not accepted, may i tell you, mr. oleksiy, it is from the groups of someone, the fugitive medvedchuk and the now present boyko, or about or what, i just no no i don't know what other groups there might be. are there any other groups, two groups of the former opzh, but if, if we actually trace who votes for bills that become legal, then we see that the informal coalition today is really a servant of the people, the parliamentary group of dovia and the revival group of ukraine and the platform for life and peace, i.e. two groups of the former opposition platform for life, actually now these political forces, these groups are... more

actively working as allies in the parliament, well , at least we are talking about the acceptance factor draft laws, but this dependence on the opzh, it is obvious that it can also explain the lack of a decision to take away the mandates from the deputies of the local councils from the banned parties, by the way, conduct a lustration for politicians, at least the assets from the banned pro-russian parties, in order to they are for the nearest... election cycle, i.e. for 10 years to delete them from active political life and a number of other decisions that we attribute to the block of de -russification, decolonization, i know that at one time, when we were really waiting for the elections, well this it was more than a year ago, they already started to collect ratings there, something else, conduct such surveys, order for themselves,

some even organized headquarters for themselves, and then everything... it immediately disappeared, because it is clear that there will be no elections, i am very briefly, literally 10 seconds, but now there are some such powders about the fact that we are starting to prepare for the elections, somewhere it appears to someone that now in this sense it is dead, and everyone understands that it is not worth preparing for it now, it will not be, according to my observations, six months ago we definitely saw it and the activity of the headquarters and such pre-election games are extremely large, now i do not personally observe it, but this is the season of political intrigues. completely open, at least in terms of drowning their alleged political opponents, now they are working, working non-stop, thank you very much for joining, thank you for your comments, oleksiy koshr was with us, historian, head of the committee of voters of ukraine, and literally for a few moments of news, good evening, we are from ukraine, so that's it. let's start, cerebral

without...