to understand that the binding of ukraine to telegram is, you know, no longer such a neutral thing, which is simply a convenient messenger that can be used, no, it is not quite so, and such things must somehow be resolved, must be understood , that maybe the whole country should be moved to some other messenger, the whole country can't be, well, there are all alarm messages, everything goes through the tv. and a bunch of government services go through telegram, which probably has to end somehow, because having such a situation, having even persecution of telegram by western countries, we can simply find ourselves in such, you know, absurd situations, when we have a messenger that is completely open to the influence of our direct enemy, and we continue to use it, think that everything is fine and ... we somehow protected, no, friends,

it doesn't happen like that, it just doesn't happen like that, so think, see you later, the book women in war is a joint project of the espresso tv channel and the spirit and letter publishing house, a book based on the reports of the espresso tv channel host khrystyna parubiy. 20 stories, 20 fates, 20 women who defended the country. a book dedicated to women who chose the path of fighting the enemy in the ranks of the military. women at war, search in bookstores of ukraine. with the support of the kostyantyn zhivago charitable foundation. laughter, physical activity, sneezing. even during such a small load, urinary incontinence can make itself felt. feminost uro helped me. thanks to natural ingredients. uro helps

restore control over urination. feminost uuro - urination under control. there are discounts until independence day in bane. 20% in plantain, bam and oskad pharmacies. vitaly portnikov, khrystyna yatskiv, andriy smoliy and invited experts on... based on the facts, they give their assessment and forecast of the development of events. if you want to understand how our today will affect our tomorrow, watch the saturday political club. every saturday at espresso. greetings, this is svoboda live on radio svoboda. we have already come to the snake itself. the following shots may shock you. live news from the scene. kamikaze drone attacks. political

analysis is objective and meaningful, there is no political season, exclusive interviews, reports from the hottest points of the front, svoboda life, frankly and without prejudice, you draw your own conclusions. see this week in the program judicial control stetya. shustrova qualification of acting judges. who failed the interview with vkks? criminal proceedings were opened in relation to the property. but do all judges underestimate the value of their property? this apartment is located in a fairly old housing stock. congratulations. you are watching judicial control and i am tetyana shustrova. despite the full-scale war, ukraine continues its path to the european union and does not stop at implementing reforms. the topic

of judicial reform. qualification evaluation of judges is ongoing in ukraine, almost 200 representatives of local and appellate courts have to pass it. however, during the first year of work, the vkks managed to conduct only about 130 interviews, so now it is actively trying to catch up and announce verdicts, in particular, regarding those servants of themis who want to keep their positions. we will introduce you to the brightest candidates. but first to the news. the supreme council of justice dismissed the judge of the heniche district court natalia sharko of the kherson region, who has sided with the occupiers and makes illegal decisions against citizens of ukraine. in particular, she arrested the ukrainian lenur khalilov, whom the russians accuse of participating in an illegal armed formation. in 2021, judge sharko sued the state judicial administration for the payment of a judge's fee. from this lawsuit, it became known that sharko has up to... access to state secrets,

but for more than two years, the judge, despite cooperation with the russian occupiers, remained a judge in ukraine and received a salary with all allowances. a video of the wedding of marina barsuk, a judge of the northern commercial court of appeal, appeared on the network, the recording was made in 2021, but it is interesting not for the festivities, but for those who came to the pompous party. the wedding was organized on a grand scale, the atmosphere of a real palace, the precious design of the stage, which would be the envy of eurovision stars. by the way, show ballet, virka serdyuchka, tina karol and others spoke about the stars. ukrainian oligarchs pavlo fuchs and igor were spotted among the guests kolomoiskyi. the last old friend of the family. with this friendship, he easily secures victory in court disputes. judge viktor barsuk's husband, according to zmi, works in the oligarch's office. marina barsuk has repeatedly made decisions in court cases regarding kolomoiskyi's business. in particular, in 2022

, the panel of judges, which included barsuk, upheld the recovery of almost 2 million hryvnias from the state budget in favor of ukrnafta. also , barsuk was a member of the panel of judges who considered the case of rape. 40% of the shares of poltava mining and beneficiation plant at the international company ferekpo for the benefit of the former owners. these are four offshore companies associated with kolomoisky and his russian associates. the current deputy chairman of the russian state duma, oleksandr babakov, and the president of the central sports club of the russian army, yevhen ginner. the ukrainian state bureau of investigation directly called them the leaders of the luzhniki organized crime group. if the judge plays a million dollar wedding, that 's it. would be an ethical violation in any civilized country, the presence of an oligarch, tim moreover, the oligarch in whose interests the judge made a decision, especially in the conditions of ukraine, when judges are usually very reasonably suspected, and often this is simply proven by facts in the work for oligarchs, this

would cause immediately the very next day this judge would be summoned to a very serious conversation, at least in the bodies responsible for the ethics and integrity of the judge. the oligarch's representatives in the northern commercial court of appeal appealed to all panels of judges until the case reached barsuk. later, through the media publicity barsuk recused herself and the case went to her friend, judge of the northern commercial court of appeal lyudmila kropyvna, whose panel eventually gave the shares of the company with multibillion-dollar assets to offshore companies connected to kolomoisky and the russians. lyudmila kropyvna, as it turned out, was also there. at the wedding of the barsuks, together with igor kolomoisky, the conflict of interests is obvious, through corrupt judges, oligarchs get access to property, they evade taxes, they get a monopoly position on the market, they evade fines for environmental pollution and so on and

so forth, and this makes them oligarchs, the presence of an oligarch at a judge's wedding, and even more so an oligarch once again, regarding whom the judge made a decision, well, this is an absolutely... absolutely unacceptable story . the decision to expropriate the poltava gzk was eventually declared illegal and annulled by the grand chamber of the supreme court. and the national anti-corruption bureau began to investigate the possible corrupt actions of ludmila kropyvna, because it was at the time when the judge was resting at a wedding with kolomoisky and began the case of transferring poltava gzk shares to the oligarch's companies, she got an elite estate in kozyna worth $1 million. qualification evaluation of judges is ongoing in ukraine - an extremely important process for cleaning and reformatting the country's judicial system. the more qualitatively we implement this reform, the more confidently we will continue our path to the european union. unscrupulous judges are very resourceful in their attempts to avoid evaluation.

they get seriously ill right before the interview, invent other good reasons not to come, are on trial or are trying to run away from being released into an honorable retirement at the same time. but fortunately. most of them do not succeed, so we continue to introduce you to ukrainian judges who have to confirm their suitability for the position. this is yuliya burzel, a judge of the yagodinsky district court of the kyiv region, and the members of the commission had a lot of questions about her. the judge has two privatized plots of land near kyiv and an apartment in the capital since 2020. however, the judge declared its value to be almost twice less than the market value. this apartment is enough to the old in the housing fund there is a house from the 38th or 39th year, but it was in a rather terrible condition. julia burzel works in yagotyn, which is a hundred kilometers from kyiv. she assures that she covered this distance every day to get to work.

it turns out that the judge spent more than two hours each day on a one-way trip, and a total of four hours a day for the trip. to the court, every day i went to yagotyn by car, minibus, electric train, but i could really stay, sometimes, at... at a certain address in the city of yagotyn. in 2015 and in 2016, the judge did not declare the corporate rights of her husband, roman svistovich, in two companies. she says she didn't know anything. he just didn't tell me about it. he explained to me that the company truboil, it was actually founded by him back in 2012, we did not even know him during this period, and he simply for the reasons that he... no, it did not work, he did not receive any dividends from he did not receive it, he simply forgot

to tell me about it, just as he did about it in the uz recruitment agency. in general, not only forgetfulness is inherent in a family member judge julia burzel. in 2018, the firm, where the judge's husband was a co-owner, appeared in the case of forgery of documents during the alienation of land near kyiv, and yulia burzel's mother, a retired judge from... in 2018, appeared in the investigation, where it was found that she received gifts for almost 2 million hryvnias. above, the judges' qualification commission took a break before announcing the final decision regarding the suitability of yulia burzel for the position of judge. and this is pavlo hutsal, the judge of the lubarsky district court of the zhytomyr region, and he has repeatedly understated the value of the property in the declarations, or forgot to declare it at all. for example, in 2016. he and his wife bought a mazda-3 car, he assures that for 149 hryvnias. instead, this amount is significantly lower than

the market value. presumably, in this way the judge could try to avoid financial monitoring, which set a limit for cash payments up to uah 150,000. if the amount is greater, it was necessary to explain the origin of the funds. in 2021, pavel gutsal's wife bought an audi q5 for over uah 2,000. but the declared money. it would not be enough. my wife received an advance. and tell me, please, who was the counterparty under this contract? who is the counterparty? who paid the money? yes. yes, who paid this advance? private notary. a private notary with whom your wife is in a certain relationship. well, at birth, yes. it is also known that at the beginning of the full-scale invasion pavlo hutsal made 14 short-term crossings of the polish border for... unclear reasons. the panel of the higher qualification commission referred the judge's case to the full

composition of the supreme court of appeals, which must make the final decision decision regarding his suitability for the position. and finally, we will introduce you to natalya semenova, judge of the apostolivsky district court of the dnipropetrovsk region. as for the judge, criminal proceedings were opened for official falsification of documents. it was later closed, however, there are obviously gaps not only in integrity, but also in... criminal proceedings were opened against me, about me, me, the prosecutor, the prosecutor can open criminal proceedings, the investigator, what does the investigator do, i did not understand the question, i'm sorry, supreme council justice brought nataliya semenova to justice for the fact that she constantly returned to the police reports on administrative violations without legal grounds, if you stated in response to a question of the public integrity council that the prosecutor's report was... itself correct, drawn up in accordance with the law, then what are the grounds were

to return it, when at the same time your decision is simply not fulfilled. no. it is also known that nataliya semenova systematically delayed the consideration of drunken driving cases, which allowed offenders to avoid responsibility in particular, of the 16 cases closed by her, which were discovered by the public integrity council, in 13 cases the judge had more than two months to... consider the case, and in three cases , postal correspondence was not sent for more than a month, which is why deadlines were missed. well, that is, the term of bringing a person to administrative responsibility, who was missed? deadlines were missed, i consider it not the court. in the end, after investigating all the circumstances, the panel of the higher qualification commission dismissed judge semenov. today in that's all about me, you watched court control, i'm

tetyana shostrova. tell us about the facts of corruption in the judicial system that you know. write to the email you see on the screen or to me on facebook. see you in exactly a week. there are discounts until independence day on estazipin 25% in pharmacies psylansky bam and oskad. fm halychyna. listen to yours. there are discounts until independence day on detoxyl tablets, 15% in psyllanyk, bam and oskad pharmacies. do you suffer from heartburn? i

recommend izoto. isoto interacts with acid in the stomach, which leads to a decrease. your water if it bothers you. read in the august issue of the magazine kranaya. how maidan and the volunteer movement formed a new ukrainian identity. the phenomenon of ukrainian stability. why the enemy underestimated the power of freedom. from the gray zone to the european stronghold. what lesson did ukraine teach the world? ask at press outlets or pre-pay online. the country is in the center. the main events are discounts until independence day on citramon darnytsia 10% in podorozhnyk, pam and oskad pharmacies. maria gurska meets with the head of the polish foreign affairs committee every week to the sejm by pawel koval, authorized by the government of poland for the restoration of ukraine. as

always, we talk about the most important things that happened this week in poland, ukraine, and europe. what is being said about ukraine in the eu? how should we perceive the statements of european politicians and what will our accession to the eu look like? in the project close to politics close to the world with maria gurska every sunday at 15:30 with a repeat at 22:00 in cooperation with sestra au. an unusual look at the news. good health, ladies and gentlemen, my name is mykola veresin. sharp presentation of facts and competent opinions. for example, if mykola veresin did that, he would have gone to prison. a special look at the events in ukraine, so it is not necessary to say that the fish is rotting . no, not off the top of my head, but outside of it, who is china then, my heart aches, all this in the informational marathon with mykola in september, saturday 5:10 p.m., sunday 6:15 p.m. at espresso. see this week in the collaborators program. illegitimate ministers of the occupied donetsk region. on the territory of the dpr there is a state

constitutional guarantee. how traitors build political careers under. kremlin, i express my support to the supreme commander-in-chief. greetings, i'm olena kononenko, and this is the collaborator program about traitors who went to serve the russian occupiers at the call of their hearts and wallets. in today's edition, i will continue to talk about the bubble ministries that russia is creating in the temporarily occupied territories of ukraine and about those who manage them. in the donetsk region, the rashists created 17 illegitimate ministries, some of them have been suspended. is under the control of russian tourers who moved to the temporarily occupied territories, and part of it is managed by local traitors, as they proudly call themselves as ministers of the dpr. one of them is mykhailo vasylovich zhaltyakov, born in 1961, a native of kryvyi rih. he is an honored worker of culture of ukraine. we hope

that all events planned by the ministry of culture of russia and the ministry of culture of the donetsk people's republic. everything will work for the good of our republic, for the good of the whole great country. mykhailo has two higher educations, but looking ahead, i will say that they did not add to his intelligence, well, can an educated person thank the russian soldiers. i would like to express my gratitude and support to express to our soldiers who defend donbas and all of russia at the front lines. we are sure that by joining forces under the wise leadership of our leader,... we can achieve victory. in 1982, zholtyakov graduated from the kharkiv kotlyarevsky institute of arts, majoring in drama theater and cinema. he received his second education in 2004, when he graduated from the donetsk state university of management with a degree in business administration. in parallel with his studies, since 2003, mykhailo

was the chief specialist of one of the departments donetsk city center of social services for youth. and in 2006 he took a position in the culture department of the donetsk regional state administration, was a leading specialist in the department of arts and educational institutions. in general, mykhailo devoted his whole life to culture. it would seem that this was supposed to instill in him a love for ukrainian national traditions and raise a patriot, but something went wrong. after all, when donbas was occupied by the russian army in the 14th year, zhaltyakov did not leave the occupied territories, but remained in the region. so to speak, to study already another culture, russian, although what is there to study, but zheltyakov liked it very much, here is a video where he stammers with delight, thank you russia. to the singer shamanov and invites him to perform rusky in donetsk. in the person of all residents of the republic, residents of mariupol, residents of donetsk.

we hope that you will be with us in donetsk in the near future. we wish you creative success, and just like you, we feel like russians. for recognizing himself as a russian, mishka received thanks in the form of the position of first deputy minister of culture, the so-called... dpr, he organized numerous holidays in honor of the invaders, covered the red carpet, and, taking a full chest of air, loudly blew into the fanfare to personally pay tribute to the murderers. from all cultural workers of our republic, i express my support to the supreme commander-in-chief, the president of the russian federation. with such a striking initiative, zholtyakov did not stay as a deputy for long, he became acting minister of culture of the fake dpr. the chair is higher, and accordingly there are more tasks from the kremlin. complete destruction of ukrainian culture temporarily occupied territories of ukraine. russification of libraries, theaters, promotion of the russian

military as heroes, and this is far from a complete list of his urgent tasks. we wish that these events would end as soon as possible, and we would all be under a peaceful sky. and we felt that we were under reliable protection. for their own. zhaltyakov received the title of honored worker of culture of the donetsk people's republic. there is a distinction from the rashists, now the most important distinction remains in the form of suspicion from our law enforcement agencies. another traitor with a mandate to believe in the russian peace and its prospects oleksiy serhiyevich shamav is from donetsk, he is 51. the ministry of justice of the donetsk people's republic also participates in law-making activities, implements the introduction of the state information system. has a legal education. in 2003, he graduated from the donetsk institute of internal affairs at the donetsk national university , majoring in law enforcement. since

2006, he has been in private law practice. he provided his services not only in donetsk, but also throughout ukraine. was a member council of advocates of donetsk region. shamov also worked in the law enforcement agencies of the donetsk region in the positions of deputy prosecutor and prosecutor. and in the 14th year he opened his own law firm. company, when the donetsk region was occupied, oleksiy quickly retrained, studied russian laws and worked according to the rules of the russian federation. for all notarial matters, i recommend contacting the notary chamber of the donetsk people's republic, or notaries operating in the territory of the donetsk people's republic. first the traitor provided his legal services to the occupiers and ringleaders of the dpr terrorist organization, for which he was appointed acting director de mentu of the registration of regulatory acts of the puppet ministry of justice, later shamov was promoted to the position of deputy minister of justice, the so-called dpr. after years of blind

and loyal service to the kremlin, in 2023 he finally earned the seat of the pseudo-minister of justice of the dpr. the ministry of justice will be entrusted with the authority to introduce a register of municipal regulations legal acts of the dnr and several new powers. in addition, the seller also received a russian lawyer's license. on the telegram page of the so-called ministry, shamov tells the public about how to annul a marriage, how to get a labor record in the supposedly liberated territories, and how to register a legal entity. all this, of course, according to the laws of the russian federation. for our part, we advise oleksiy not to forget ukrainian laws, especially the criminal procedure code, according to which sooner or later he will be tried for treason . and finally, i will tell you about something else one minister in the dpr, who in a peaceful life did not achieve anything in particular, that is why he decided to realize himself at least under the occupiers,

using all the talents of an adaptor. meet denys ihorovych strelchenko, born in 1976, a native of donetsk. the state constitutional guarantee of the russian federation, the minimum wage, is in force on the territory of the dpr. about pre-war life. almost nothing is known. pomi's russian media started promoting him when in 2022 denyska was appointed as a fake minister of labor and social policy of the dpr. as a minister, he of course, it glorifies the bloody murderer, talks about how the region declined during the time of ukraine, and popularizes russian state programs among the local population. cash payment is made on the basis of lists submitted by the pension fund and ministries and agencies. power structures, pressures and sentenced denisko to a harsh prison sentence, we hope that the skills acquired in the fake republic will help his

social adaptation. in a ukrainian prison. it was the program collaborator and i, olena kononenko. if you want to tell us about kremlin traitors, write to us at this e-mail address or simply on facebook, together we will send all the traitors after the russian ship. see you in a week on espresso. will volodymyr zelensky decide to fire the head of the antimonopoly committee, who was on trial for illegal enrichment. he convinces the court that he acquired his elite movable and immovable property from the sale of raspberries. we will explore this in the second

part of the program, but here we go. from another topic. officially, ukraine lost the first f-16 and one of his best pilots. my name is vlasta lazur. this is svoboda live. ukraine lost the first f-16 fighter jet received from western allies. but that's not all. along with the plane, ukraine lost one of its most experienced pilots. oleksiy mesi with the call sign moonfish died during the accident. he learned to fly the f-16 in the united states. he was buried the day before. in the city of shepetivka, khmelnytskyi region. the f-16 crash happened three weeks after volodymyr zelenskyi officially announced that ukraine received american fighter jets, but this photo was published the day before by lilia averyanova, the mother of another ukrainian pilot, andriy pilshchikov jus, who died last year. cadets juice and moonfish,

says the caption to the photo. sawdust and mes were among those who actively lobbied for the provision of f-16s to ukraine. they visited the united states, met with congressmen, convinced american officials, and actually became the face of this large-scale campaign. ukraine was the first to report the loss of an f-16 fighter the american edition of the wall street journal with reference to an unnamed american official. journalists then wrote that according to preliminary data, the plane was not shot down by enemy fire. it was august 29, the same day. the ukrainian voice of america service , citing an unnamed representative of the air force of the ukrainian armed forces, reported that various versions of the disaster are being considered, including pilot error, technical malfunction, and even the so-called friendly fire of its anti-aircraft forces. in favor of this latest version, a resonant statement the day before, the deputy of the defense committee of the parliament, maryana bezugla, did. she said that the f-16 was shot down from the rk patriot

because of...discoordination between the units of the armed forces. she also reported that this disaster occurred during one of the most powerful air attacks on august 26, and she also bluntly accused the air force command of lying. war is war. such episodes are possible, but the culture of lies in the command of the air force of the armed forces, as well as in other higher military headquarters , leads to the fact that the system of managing military decisions does not improve on main truthful, consistently collected analytics, and it deteriorates and even collapses, as everything happens in the pokrovsky direction, and none of the generals is punished, general oleschuk remains in office. well, today air force commander mykola oleschuk answered bluntly. he said he did not withhold information about the f-16 crash. according to him, the top management immediately received the report and partners from the usa have already joined the investigation into the causes of

the accident. i assure you that a detailed analysis is already being conducted, an investigation is underway, we have carefully understand what happened, what the circumstances are, whose responsibility it is, and it will be done. information about such incidents cannot be immediately released into the public space and cannot be detailed for the media. there is a war in ukraine, but it doesn't matter to the people who chose maryana bezugla as a tool to discredit the top military leadership. it will not work to hang all the dogs on the army. joins our broadcast. romanenko, aviation expert, leading researcher of the state aviation museum of ukraine. i congratulate you. yes, good evening. first, let's just consider this story in theory, what could have caused the plane wreck without relative to the context, what are the reasons, what are the possible options in principle? any. and...