as if in an electronic format, i don't know yet how well it will work, but i hope that it will work, because it was wanted, and you are not afraid that there will be a paper record book, installing the army plus application on personal mobile phones composition, i don’t know, but i want to believe that it is not, because in fact i also understand that paperwork, which sometimes slows you down so much and does not give you time to plan your truly combat tasks, yes... when it is actually harmful, there is such , but we have learned how to work with it, so it slows down certain things processes, it is difficult to bypass all these processes, it is there, it interferes, but they have learned to work with it, that is, they do something so that, let's say, it was some kind of routine, as if it is necessary, you know, to come and drink coffee in the morning , i don't know, eat a piece of some bread and that's it, just like that... you

came, filled out all these documents, what you have to do, as if it's the most difficult job from the very beginning and the most boring, and that's it, and you work further you know, in conclusion , i will ask you whether andriy synever is considering returning to installing solar panels after the end of the hostilities and after the future demobilization, do you see any reason in principle to continue your work as a soldier. mega difficult question, probably the most difficult today. uh, despite the fact that i think what i will do there after the end of the uh war in general, i can tell you now that i don't know, i simply don't know, i was thinking about what i would do in civilian life, i seriously, i don't know what to do, it's very difficult to choose something, i don't want, for example, to work at a job that won't be...

benefit of some kind, and almost every veteran says this, and which you will not like, the truth, yes, and well, a very difficult, difficult choice, you have to make, but i still hope that i will get to that, what can you imagine the practice, we almost again with you now these teenagers who finish the 11th grade, who need to understand who to go to study, and this is practically the general condition now among most veterans, because a lot of my brothers, in particular, who are demobilized, they are no longer. .. they return to their previous place of work, and they say, finally i will open my pub, which i always dreamed of, or finally i will start doing the veterinary business that i dreamed of, do you have any such dream, some kind of dream from childhood about your business, maybe, well, i don't know exactly what it is, that is, there is some i didn't have a certain bar there or a bakery or something like that, a coffee shop, but i really want to have my own business, so that you can be roughly independent from anyone there, but the plus is that... it also brought some

benefit, benefit society, there general and so on, it's very cool that is being formed now different projects, there are allocations of funds, different grants, different enterprises are creating new opportunities for veterans there, and it's actually very cool, among all this it will be possible, i think, it will be possible to find something, you said the word independence very correctly, you know, bye independence of ukraine, i wish you to be really productively independent, no matter what you do, today i am a circle. the table was andrii synever, the head of the azov recruiting center in lviv, a combat medic and, i will not say a veteran, an active military man, a man who continues his work, my name is andrii zholob, this is a project without armor on fm halychyna, the next issue, very soon, the next interesting guest, the next conversation, and certain subsequent decisions and thinking about what to do in this war. exclusively on the air of our

channel. congratulations, friends, the politclub program is on the air on the espresso tv channel. the most relevant topics of the week. nato member countries have huge arsenals, and russia is already on the verge of exhausting its resources. topics that resonate in our society. this is the question of trump's victory, what is it? analysis processes that change the country. and each of us, what else can the russians do, are they able to use, let's say, the resources of the lukashenka army allied with them. vitaly portnikov and the guests of the project, read the philosophies, accept my opinion, thank you, it was difficult, but i was just interested, but it was absolutely not, they help to understand the present and predict the future, they offered the united states to conclude bilateral security with us agreement a project for those who care and think. political club every sunday

20:00 for espresso.

greetings, friends, today we will talk about how the perception of war, in particular in art , differs between us, ukrainians, and foreigners, and why it must be taken into account when we try to somehow influence these and... foreigners, we will talk about the film peaceful people, which was released, is a documentary film, which consists in particular of intercepted conversations, which we heard, which the sbu taught, and we, we could

observe all these completely wild conversations, which shocked us then, but now they are no longer shocking, but shocking to foreigners who, especially those who still believe that this is... that is, this is putin's war. this film can obviously convince them otherwise. we will also talk about the contenders for the oscar race from ukraine for next year. these are four films, from which one will be chosen, and we will also analyze which films are suitable for this and which are not suitable. i will explain to you why i state this so categorically. well, let's start with oleg vinnyk. i'll tell you why. well, this is also an important topic, although it seems to many that damn, oleg vinnyk, does not know anything about it at all talk on which serious tv channel, no, i want to tell you that we often underestimated the topic of culture before, this is one time, and the topic of show business, in general, the topic of bloggers, it is very

important, because all these people who maybe sing songs that some may not like it, although i think there is a lot of respect among our viewers. in oleg vinnyk, who knows, and there are also bloggers who, in general, may be engaged in the treasurer, some kind of game in general, but then it turns out that they are not just used, they are used effectively, and we also know about this let's talk today, oleg vynnyk, a man who had a huge audience, so big that they joked before the last election that if oleg vynnyk ran for the election, someone... who knows him, who would become the president, because really there are a lot of people who loved his work, why i say that they loved, because his fans have significantly decreased, and even we can claim that oleg vinnyk has been banned from our country, this word is used very often, but it is not used in the right way for

criticism, and generally kenseling or culture cancellation happens to people, in fact, when they commit some misdeeds that are not accepted by society. and these people simply disappear from the information space, society ceases to accept them, but most likely this is exactly what happens to the culprit, because in previous programs we talked about how he left for germany during or immediately after the full-scale invasion, where, however, he already has property and lives for a long time, but he left and remained silent for a very long time, thereby completely losing the respect of many of his admirers, then... he tried to somehow break back into the ukrainian show business, but it was a failed attempt more than a year ago, and now he also made another attempt, and it also turned out to be unsuccessful, he announced his new track by august 23 until the day of the flag, but as far as i understand and

as far as my colleagues from the radio station told me, many heads of radio stations and editors decided not to take it. this track is in rotation, because oleg vinnyk's current behavior is not well accepted, and the second point, the second point is that there is such a show. ours colleagues at 1+1, which is called the whole country is speaking, this is in particular a show that is produced for the average fan of oleg vinnyk, this is the type of viewer they have, and they invited andriy kravchenko as a guest, who is claiming a place for it, which is already vacant oleg vynyk's place, now we can watch his videos there... his music videos, if you don't know him yet, he's trying now, well, it's been a long time since he's been promoted

as a clone of olena oleg vynyk, he really looks like him in some ways, more measure he copies it, which is not very successful from my point of view, because when you are not yourself and you want to be someone else, it often looks fake enough, that's how it is here, but your... songs, style of songs and his behavior, it is andriy kravchenko who is trying to win over this target audience, he has so many winches, he was invited to this show clearly with the aim of promoting it and at the end they included oleg vinnyk from germany via skype or some kind of video link and absolutely he was crushed, that is for their viewers, the power of television should not be underestimated, as we know, and just in the studio, well... they just threw shit at this poor oleg vinnyk, very uncomplimentary,

to put it mildly, they spoke about him, and he himself, it's not very good i faked an interview, they also edited it as it should, and therefore we can state that such a star, such a star, is probably no longer on our show business horizon, and perhaps another will appear in his place, let's listen to an excerpt from the song of andrii kravchenko, or? can you find something similar? what do you dream, my queen, when i am not around, tell the queen that you have a dream, well, as for me, the capital stone is simple, but i will only say, in defense of oleg vinnyk, perhaps, well, many people did not treat him seriously, especially men, but i see... at his concerts, i've been twice, there were a lot of men who

pretended that they didn't care, we just came as our women, they dragged us here on purpose, but for some reason they knew the lyrics to almost all of his songs, sang along a lot teenagers who were just fanatical about him, and that's why it was such, he was very professional, by the way , an artist in his field, but i am aware that this is not the first example when ukrainian society really does not... has male stars who went abroad, we see it from potap, we see it with vlad yama, we see it even with serhiy babkin, who returned to ukraine and, by the way, left it under legal conditions, he has three children, but still they had a very, very negative attitude towards him, therefore, you see what colossal changes we have in our society, well, now let's move on to bloggers, more precisely to female bloggers, more precisely to one blogger who can also be taken not too seriously now and in the past, her name is also alina shamanska, we can

now look at the clothes from her instagram, she is such a typical blogger with a big, by the way , an audience that has been living in the united states for a long time, lives its best life, it can be seen that she has a lot of money, well, usually bloggers can earn if they have such a large audience on advertising, she does it, she lives there, she by the way, the ex-wife of everything scandalous ruslan. hanumaka, a friend of the 95th block, i don't know, he's a comedian, what did he identify with there, even some musician for a while, and now he recently fled to the united states, citing that he wants to be a good father, to be with his son and see how he grows. elina shamanska is his ex-wife, and here is a blogger who always dealt with some topic of beauty, the topic of beauty, the topic of cosmetics, the topic of a beautiful life, some restaurants and everything else. and now we see that this blogger is invited by the office of the president, i'm sorry, the office

the president invites her in order to conduct interviews with officials, with the heads of ukrainian regions, and to speak with them in such a simple human language, to convey some meaning to people in every possible way, well, it's like that... you know, a very standard story with our current government, which uses various bloggers with a large audience, here is the deputy head of the president's office, oleksiy. and kuleba suggested that alina shamanskaya record these interviews, and he said that he invited her because she is such a professional, although nowhere was there an interview specifically on political, socio-political topics, and here, well, there are suspicions, you know, such that they invited her, they invited a person, not a journalist who can ask sharp questions, but such

a blogger, which can be directed, which can be asked there... to ask the necessary questions, although on the other hand, journalists are also pro-government, journalists can also be used, as you well know, and it was, there are influential media which, journalists which they absolutely agreed to always write down here such complementary interviews, but here the question is that the blogger, who has never been involved in socio-political topics, usually asked questions that were quite unexpected, to put it mildly, to the head of zaporizhzhya ova, mr. fedorev, for example, she asked him whether he considers himself sexy, whether he considers himself handsome, for which the zaporizhia people love him, and we can see under the comments of this video and in the very instagram of alina shamaska, shamanskaya, that even her

devoted fans are somehow not very understood this orientation, let's in... let's show two excerpts from this beautiful interview, first, let's listen to how they discussed weight, i'm worried about the figure, then you're worried about the figure, you're serious, friends, write in the comments who we should take care of our figure, it was a joke, i understand, yes, you are serious, how much do you weigh now, if it is not a secret, what is your goal, do you want to lose more weight or keep it off. i am in my weight 85 kg, during fasting i can go down to 80, 81, you fast, yes, yes, of course, you are a religious person in general, time i go to church from time to time, i know prayers, so

what, well, yes, yes, i'm a religious person, simple. holy man, you know, i have a lot of acquaintances in zaporizhzhia, they reacted to all this, to be honest, some with irony, some with sarcasm, some were completely annoyed, and i will also say that usually journalists do not allow themselves to eat in the frame, because it's not always a good look, especially in this format, in some entertainment, it's possible, but not here, i think a lot of you also got a little sick of the fact that and people something... they talk and eat, and also, let's listen to what mr. first of all, alina shamanska asks federev about his salary, what he answers, and then we'll talk about it. you said in one of the past interviews that your monthly salary in melitopol was uah 70,000. can you

tell me your salary today? it is approximately the same, maybe plus or minus 7-10 00 hryvnias. uh, it’s the same, it’s about uah 80,00, is it enough for a month for a comfortable stay, of course not, of course it’s not enough, my god, how good, i’m sorry that you you say of course no, but you don't say yes, it's enough, no, of course it's not enough, look, i don't use company cars, i don't use, i don't refuel, of course, this is budget money, so all this requires a lot of expenses, there are representative expenses, unhappy, of course. the unfortunate leader of zaporizhzhya ova with such a salary, i will say that on the one hand, of course, there are many people, especially there from business and the same bloggers, they earn quite a lot, and for them the amount of 80 thousand hryvnias is really small, and well, that's cool that people know how to make money, and it's in every way, i don't know, it deserves praise,

if it's in an honest way, of course, but if we 're talking about... communication moments, if we're talking about a project, it's a youtube project that's specifically made, first of all for money , about these regional councils, and which is designed to evoke some kind of sympathy for the authorities, for representatives, for officials, yes, somehow it seems strange to me to provoke the audience to an expectedly not very positive reaction, because we know, especially in zaporizhzhia.. . and there are, well, that, first of all, there are many immigrants, and the situation is alarming, and materially, in particular, people are worried, and to ask such questions here, and even more so, is blatant. on the fact that , well, we know that these are some measly amounts, well, alina shamaska ​​once said somewhere that she is, well, now in the economy mode and

tries to live on approximately uah 100 per month, so as not to spend on a lot of moments, just 100 00, no more, here is the economy mode, one should somehow be more careful with such expressions, well, now briefly... we are talking about a new possible trash content that the russians make, we sometimes we like to follow them because they are preparing another propaganda series on the tnt channel, it should come out, it is their entertainment channel, and it will be about joe biden, joe biden will be played by their actor, who is under sanctions, dmytro dyuzhev, who is known for his neckbreakers interviews in which he always said very strange things, maybe. under the influence of some substances, or he's just such a fun guy, and here he is playing joe biden. the fact is that the script of the first

episode has already been leaked to the russian media, and there are discussions there, there readers, that it will be an absolute masterpiece of scum, that is, that it will be something bad, although i thought that it would be something a little better than the usual russian propaganda of this time, because there is a director. more or less not bad, he once filmed interns, it is a popular series and it was popular in our country, but the script is really very, very bad and it starts with the fact that the head of the cia comes to joe biden's office and complains that the sanctions do not work in russia, what should we do, mr. president, mr. president is holding his head, how come, we already have 30 years we are suffocating, and they are not suffocating, they are still surviving, and the head of the cia says: look, how resilient the russians are... how can we deal with them, such a great people, such a great economy, and in the end, joe biden packs up and leaves to russia, in order to understand why these sanctions do not work, we take it in quotes and

find out about the soul of the russian people, then he loses his documents there and has to live with a simple russian in khrushchevka and earn money for a return ticket to the usa by taking english lessons, that's right, and by the way... sometimes the cia, who are losing, well, the cia officers, we get it, they're totally incompetent, they lose joe biden, but then they find another elderly man, they think it's biden, and they take him, and he becomes president in america, this kind of plot, these plot twists, they're absolutely standard for many comedies, for example, we know sasha baron coyne's famous movie called the dictator, it's about some imaginary eastern dictator who goes to... to the united states, they put a very similar doppelgänger in his place and they have an altercation there, but this movie is made talentedly, played talentedly, like this

eccentric comedy, here we can see from the russians again, well, i hope we won't see it, we don't need it, but we just state that they are doing propaganda, and we don't forget that , that here in ukraine they also try to do this kind of... propaganda, propaganda films, on the one hand, it 's not bad, some light films that morally support ukrainians, but usually they are made at a very low level, they are quite opportunistic , and i would not like it our cultural, cinematic space consisted of only this, but unfortunately, the absolute absence, in fact the absence of a state policy of state cinema, starting there from the 19th year, and it leads to the fact that now we can see the production of exactly commercial ones. product or tv series, but such serious cinema that carries some meaning, it is less and less known, when in general such directors and directors will be able to receive

funding for it, but in the end the oscars, what we are offering this year for the oscars, i will say that how this procedure takes place from, and we traditionally apply for the category of the best foreign film, and there, well, usually in our country... we first see a list of those films that were first submitted, and secondly, films that pass technical characteristics, and then the oscar committee chooses one film from them, well, i will say this, from my point of view, two of them absolutely have a chance, and one of them i would vote for at all, and two i do not even understand why they were submitted , first we were rec. this is a tape by lubomir levytskyi, which you know from crazy wedding third after stolney, this movie was very necessary, very well made with a purpose.

popularization of recruiting, this film is such a big advertisement of the third assault brigade, and it was also a very good communication moment, however, it was made quite weakly from an artistic point of view, and obviously its purpose was not to have any artistic incredible characteristics, but the function of communication is advertising, it was performed, but it is not clear what oscar has to do with it. then the house of the word, the endless roman, taras atomenko too claims, i also really liked this film, i especially liked how ukrainian society and social networks reacted to it, there were simply heated discussions, and it was a very timely film, because the interest in the 20s, in the shot revival is extremely high, we see which projects devoted to this period are gaining popularity, and the film, well... for such

a superficial acquaintance of people who did not know who the waveman was, did not know who all the other representatives were, there was les kurbas and so on, it was very helpful, but again, this film is not of the level to claim an oscar, but an oscar statuette, well, then we go to representatives of more serious ones, philip sotnichenko's stupid lysiad, here is another story, this film, firstly, it received international awards, it received a lot of... good, good characteristics, feedback from ukrainian film critics and from the cinephile public who loves good cinema, this film tells about the period about, first of all, investigators who untangle some, well, untangle a murder his colleague, and secondly, it tells about the last case of the death penalty in ukraine,

it was in the 90s, it was shot very... this is one of the most interesting, most original ukrainian films, filip sotnichenko is also an extremely talented director, and this film is really not it's a shame to let go to the oscars, and oksana karpovych's peaceful people, which we 'll talk about now, because it was released, and this tape consists of documentary footage that was filmed already when kyiv region and kherson region were de-occupied. kharkiv oblast, as well as on against the background of all these landscapes, we hear intercepted conversations of russian soldiers with their relatives, wives, girlfriends, sisters, brothers, and we can simply be horrified by what they are saying there, and it is clear that the reaction of people at film festivals was even more obviously emotional than ours , surprised faster. now we can talk. with

the distributor of this tape, with the head of arthause traffic, the distribution company, with denis ivanov, hello, hello, denis, yes, it was not possible to talk to oksana, but i also have a lot of questions about the distributor, i wonder how different the perception of this film is in general here and there at the same berlinale, where it was shown, or at all at foreign venues, because for mine. observations, there are a lot of viewers, i watched this film twice and stayed afterwards to discuss with the audience that our audience often reacts in such a way that here we once again felt this hatred for russians, but it is obvious that oksana laid a little deeper meanings, and she would , probably wanted these meanings to be seen, and they may be seen more by the foreign public, tell me if it is so, well, of course, the foreign

audience does not... lives in our context, therefore and that is why it watches this film with completely different eyes. for the foreign public, they didn't hear these intercepts when it happened almost in real time, our special services shared these intercepts, posted them, open, open platforms on youtube, you could listen to them, i listened to them a lot, i think our viewers. so they listened, viewers abroad did not experience them the way we did, that is why they are mounted in such a mosaic, all of these interception, they really show what hell is in russian society, how it is really beyond the line of good and evil, what they think, what they share with their relatives, and therefore for many foreign...