on the defense capability of the entire state. ukrainian rocket launchers continue to perform tasks in all directions, including the hottest ones, and hit targets both in the occupied part of ukraine and beyond. systems, ranges, tactics are changing, you have to adapt to everything, choose priority targets, save money. valuable rockets. the only thing that remains unchanged is that very little is known about the work of rocket engineers, and they themselves promise to tell about it after the war. these were the realities of donbas, my name is roman pagolych. see you exclusively on the air of our channel. congratulations, friends, the politclub program is on the air on the espresso tv channel. the most relevant topics of the week. nato has huge arsenals, and russia is already

on the approach to exhausting its resources, topics that cause a resonance in our society, this is the question of trump's victory, what it is, an analysis of the processes that change the country and each of us, what else can the russians do, are they able to use, let's say, the resources of the lukashenka army allied with them. vitaliy portnikov and guests of the project, read the entire review, accept my song, thank you, it was difficult, but i was just interested. but this is absolutely not true, they help to understand the present and predict the future, they offered the united states to conclude a bilateral security agreement with us. a project for those who care and think. politclub every sunday at 20:00 at espresso. greetings, this is svoboda live on radio svoboda. we have already come to the snake itself. the following shots may shock you. media news. political

analysis objectively and meaningfully, there is no political season, exclusive interviews, reports from the hottest spots front, speak openly and impartially, you draw your own conclusions, see this week's collaborators program. illegitimate ministers of occupied donetsk region. on the territory of the dpr there is a state constitutional guarantee. how traitors build political careers under the auspices of the kremlin. i express my support to the commander-in-chief. greetings, i'm olena kononenko, and this is a collaborator program about traitors who, following the call of their hearts and wallets, went to serve the russian occupier. in today's edition , i will continue to talk about bubbles ministries, which russia. in the temporarily

occupied territories of ukraine and about those who manage them. in the donetsk region, the rashists created 17 illegitimate ministries. some of them are under the control of russian tourers who have moved to the temporarily occupied territories, and some are managed by local traitors. they proudly call themselves ministers of the dpr. one of them is mykhailo vasyliovych zhaltyakov, born in 1961, a native of kryvyi rih. he is an honored worker of culture of ukraine. we hope that all events planned by the ministry of culture of russia and the ministry of culture of the donetsk people's republic will work for the benefit of our republic, for the benefit of the entire great country. mykhailo has two higher educations, but looking ahead, i will say that they did not add to his intelligence. well, can an educated person thank the russian soldiers? separate words of gratitude and...

we would like to express our condolences to our soldiers who defend donbas and all of russia at the front lines. we are sure that by joining forces under the wise leadership of our leader, we can achieve victory in 1982, zholtyakov graduated from the kharkiv kotlyarevsky institute of arts, majoring in drama theater and cinema. he received his second education in 2004, when he graduated from the donetsk state university of management and became a master of business administration. in parallel with his studies, since 2003, mykhailo was the chief specialist of one of the departments of the donetsk city center of social services for youth. and in 2006, he took a position in the department of culture of the donetsk regional state administration and was a leading specialist of the department of arts and educational institutions. in general, mykhailo devoted his whole life to culture. it would seem that this should have instilled in him a love for ukrainian national traditions. and to raise a patriot,

but something went wrong, because when donbas was occupied by the russian army in the 14th year, zheltyakov did not leave the captured territories, but stayed in the region, so to speak, to study. already another culture - russian, although what to study there, but zhaltyakov liked it very much, here is a video where he stammers with delight, thanks the russian singer shamanov and invites you to visit russky in donetsk. on behalf of all residents of the republic, residents of mariupol, residents of donetsk, we hope that in the near future you will be with us in donetsk, we wish you creative success and the same as you. we feel like russians. for recognizing himself as a russian, mishka received thanks in the form of the post of first deputy minister of culture, the so-called dpr. he organized numerous celebrations in honor of the invaders, rolled out a red carpet for them and,

taking a full chest of air, blew a loud fanfare to personally honor the murderers. on behalf of all cultural workers of our republic, i express my support to the supreme commander-in-chief. the president of the russian federation with such a striking initiative , zholtyakov did not stay as deputy for a long time, he became the acting minister of culture of the fake dnr, a higher chair, accordingly, and more tasks from the kremlin, complete destruction of ukrainian culture in the temporarily occupied territories of ukraine. russification of libraries, theaters, promotion of the russian military as heroes, and this is far from a complete list of his urgent tasks. to as soon as possible these events ended, and we were all under a peaceful sky and felt that we were under reliable protection. for his services, zhaltyakov received the title of honored worker of culture of the donetsk people's republic.

there is a distinction from the rashists, now the most important distinction remains in the form of suspicion from our law enforcement agencies. another traitor with a mandate who believed in the russian peace and its prospects - oleksiy serhiyovych is from donetsk, he is 51. the ministry of justice of the donetsk people's republic also participates in law-making activities, carries out introduction of the state information system. oleksiy has a law degree. in 2003, he graduated from the donetsk institute of internal affairs at the donetsk national university , majoring in law enforcement. since 2006, he has started an individual law practice. he provided his services not only in donetsk, but also throughout ukraine. he was a member of the council. lawyers of the donetsk region. shamov also worked in the law enforcement agencies of the donetsk region in the positions of deputy prosecutor and prosecutor. and in the 14th year , he opened his own law firm. when donetsk region was occupied, oleksiy quickly retrained, studied russian laws

and began working according to the rules of the russian federation. for all notarial matters, i recommend contacting the notary chamber of the donetsk people's republic, or notaries operating in the territory of the donetsk people's republic. at first, the traitor provided his legal services to the occupiers and ringleaders of the terrorist organization dpr, for which he was appointed acting director of the department of registration of regulatory and legal acts of the puppet ministry of justice, shamov was later promoted to deputy minister of justice, the so-called dnr. after years of blind and devoted service to the kremlin, in 2023 he finally earned the chair himself. minister of justice of the dnr. the ministry of justice will be entrusted with the authority to introduce the register of municipal normative legal acts of the dpr and several other new powers. in addition , the seller also received a russian lawyer's license on the telegram page of the so-called ministry shamov tells the public about

how to annul a marriage, how to get a work book in the allegedly liberated territories and how to register a legal entity. all this, of course, according to the laws of the russian federation. for our part , we advise oleksiy not to forget ukrainian laws, especially the criminal procedure code, according to which sooner or later he will be tried for treason . and finally, i will tell you about one more minister in the dpr, who in a peaceful life did not achieve anything in particular, that is why he decided to realize himself at least under the occupiers, using all the talents of an adaptor. meet denys ihorovych strelchenko , born in 1976, native. the state constitutional guarantee of the russian federation, the minimum wage, is in force on the territory of the dpr. almost nothing is known about strelchenko's pre-war life. pomi's russian media started promoting him when in 2022 denyska

was appointed the fake minister of labor and social policy of the dpr. as a minister, of course, he glorifies the bloody murderer, talks about how the region declined during the time of ukraine. and popularizes russian state programs among the local population. cash payment is made on the basis of the lists submitted by the pension fund and the ministries and departments of the security forces . on the contrary, denysko got himself a harsh prison sentence. we hope that the skills acquired in the fake republic will help his social adaptation in the ukrainian prison. it was the program collaborators and i, olena kononenko. if you want to tell us about the kremlin sellers, write to us at this e-mail address or just on facebook, together we will send all the traitors after the russian ship. see you in a week ether espresso. great return of

great lviv, conversations, discussions, search for solutions, ukraine's largest conversational format in the evening prime time. in general, i believe that we need two things: money and weapons. we did not start this war, but we must finish it and we must win. all the most important things every thursday at 21:15 in the great lviv speaks project on espresso tv channel. new week on espresso. weekly summary information and analytical program: a clear understanding of the key events of the past week, analysis of the causes and consequences of these events from experts, forecasts of the development of the situation for the current week, the opportunity to ask your own questions and join the discussion. spend the final monday evening with us and confidently step into the new week. the

new week project with khrystyna yatskiv and andriy smoliy. every monday at 20:00 at espresso. exclusively on the air of our channel. congratulations, friends, the politclub program is on the air on the espresso tv channel. the most relevant topics of the week. nato member countries have huge arsenals, and russia is already on the verge of exhaustion. resources of topics that resonate in ours society, this is the question of trump's victory, what it is, an analysis of the processes that change the country and each of us. what else can the russians do, are they able to use, say, the resources of the lukashenka army allied with them. vitaly portnikov and the guests of the project read the entire presentation. accept my song. thank you, it was difficult. i was just curious. but he absolutely did not eat it. they help to understand the present. and predicting the future suggested that the united states enter into a bilateral security agreement with us

a project for those who care and think politclub every sunday at 20:00 at espresso.

saturday's political club is live on the espresso tv channel, and today we are returning to our traditional format. andriy smoliy is in the studio, vitaly portnikov is now joining us via skype. mr. vitaly, good evening. greetings, mr. andriy, greetings, dear viewers. so, today, for two hours with vitaly portnikov, we will analyze, talk, discuss, discuss what happened during of the current week, what concerns the whole country, what is important for the whole country, and what, of course, will happen in the coming days. and , of course, we will traditionally start with the security

block, from the security direction, because this is perhaps the most important thing for our country. well, for example, from the latest news that is being discussed by the whole society, it is actually the destruction of the first board of the f-16, and actually the resignation and dismissal of supreme commander-in-chief volodymyr zelenskyi. the head of the air force, mr. oleschuk, and all these things, of course, many people associate them, including statements. maryana bezogloi, mr. vitaliy, how would you assess these changes, how would you assess society's reaction to it, and why this reaction is often quite violent, quite contradictory, and why to some extent it creates a split in the unity of ukrainian society.

i think it's the most important thing that we don't have a certain trust in opaque actions, as you understand it, that's a real problem that's worth talking about, and i think in principle that we should go the way of those states , which such critical moments create transparency. for the decisions of the top political and military leadership. well, what do i mean? i have before my eyes the experience of israel, which won many wars, in many wars there were serious problems before this victory, and always the parliament, i will remind you that israel is a parliamentary state, created special commissions from people who were respected by

society from people , who were trusted to investigate the actions of the political. of the military leadership, at this, i would say, critical moment for the country, and as a result of these decisions, these commissions also adopted personnel decision, and the decision about the political responsibility of many important people for israeli politics, for the israeli state. of course, i will not say that this should be done precisely during wars, but maybe... there is a certain form of interaction at such a moment, i keep reminding you that we live in a parliamentary-presidential republic, the function of the president, let him even be there the supreme commander of the armed forces, let him be responsible for defense and foreign policy, they are quite limited, according to our constitution, deputies should have the right to at least

understand the logic of the president's decisions, deputies could... commissions either in the parliament or from people outside the parliament, but those who usually have access to secret information, which would investigate certain critical incidents. we do not know to what extent the resignation of the commander of the air force of ukraine is related to the f-16 plane crash. we don't know what happened at all, but it needs an investigation. according to the results of this. we have never heard anything clear from the president of ukraine explanations for why he makes certain personnel decisions, although this is logical in the state, especially in a state that is fighting for its very existence. well, when

valery zaluzhnyi, the commander-in-chief of the armed forces of ukraine, was retiring, he will explain clearly. why it happened, it didn't happen, because all the talk about rotation, it doesn't look convincing in this situation that you and i are in. we need efficiency and not spin, efficiency must be backed up by some clear reasoning about what is going on. well, that's the principle, after ruzhen's resignation, and even before this resignation there was a lot of talk about why it happened at all, right? well... there were talks about the fact that this is connected with the political situation, that in the president's office they are afraid of the popularity of the head, that he enjoys popularity with much greater authority than the president of ukraine himself, and this is of course terrible, if society at all discusses, because it believes that for the president of ukraine and for his closest circle, the issue of preserving power is much more important, than the issue of preserving the country, who

needs it for such thoughts to prevail in society at all. now what... before the resignation of the commander of the air forces, well, if the president simply signs a decree, and people do not know the reasons for it, one way or another they start creating their own versions, for the plane, for what went wrong with maryana bezugla , for the fact that he had some involvement in the military leadership that was formed during the time of zaluzhnyi, well, all this certainly does not help. mutual understanding between the government and society, i repeat once again, y the height of the war, it's not just some kind of situation that the war is ending or starting there, i would say it's the height of the war, no one in ukraine knows even the year when we will... get out of the war, which means we will have a very long time to live in such a state, when public trust in the authorities is needed, and in order for this trust to be preserved, because of course

the lack of such trust helps , as we understand, it helps those who are trying to destroy our state today, of course in such a situation it is very, very an alarming symptom, mr. vitaly, but how are you... appreciate the statements of people's deputy maryana bezugla, it's just that the situation in our country is such that, in fact, very often at first mariana bezugla comes out with certain accusations or disclosures of insider information, and then we see the release of these people, whether it is a wave of such hate in some mass media, including some. telegram channels, well, in essence , a very similar situation arose with mr. olyschuk, a blunt statement,

then a heated discussion, allegedly, again, before any was made public official investigation of information about the alleged downing of the f-16 again. i will remind you that bezugla said that it was a shooting by the patriot system, yes, that's according to her. officially , we did not receive such information, and then , in fact, oloschuk's release, do people's deputies have the right to bring such information into the public space, and does this de facto undermine trust in the armed forces of ukraine and in the actual top military leadership of our country . well, once again, the only cure for this situation is transparency, if we... will be completely uninformed with you about some important points in our defense, this will be used by those who will try to hype this situation, transparency is a more important condition

for the survival of the state in the conditions of war, i do not mean how you you understand, the disclosure of secret information, but the authority of the armed forces of ukraine must be based on the sincerity of communication with those people whom the armed forces of ukraine protect, we cannot have inviolable zones, the government, the armed forces, economic. countries, all this should be transparent until the moment when we are not talking about secret information, and this is a very important moment that we should always remember when we talk about what is happening and will happen in ukraine during these difficult russian-ukrainian years war another topic that we wanted to discuss in our security block is, of course, the offensive of the occupiers. to pokrovsk or the pokrovsky direction, so there we see selidove, there we see pokrovsk, in fact the so-called pokrovsk agglomeration, and this is what

is now also the most discussed rank among ukrainian society, among the expert environment and among the military. on the other hand, this offensive of the russians is often compared with, or conducted. an analogy with what is happening now in the kursk region of the russian federation. to what extent do you currently assess the ability or desire of the russians to push in this direction after all, and why putin still decided not to pay attention to the offensive of the armed forces of ukraine in the kursk region, but conditionally speaking, to push in those directions. which, for which they have opportunities on the territory of donetsk, luhansk, kharkiv regions. well, it seems to me that you and i were talking at the beginning

of this whole situation, andrei. and i told you that i don't see any signs that russia will abandon the offensive on donetsk region, luhansk region and kharkiv region, in order to liberate the territory of the kurt region from ukrainian troops. for. it was absolutely obvious to me from day one. i have always characterized the kurdish operation as a primarily political moment, as a moment that transfers the war to the territory of the russian federation itself and thus makes war by war, if you will, because it is a very important moment when the war, even if it will continue for several years in a row, and this is absolutely real, a promising development of the situation, more promising than the end of the war in the coming years, if it will take place on territories of both states, because the war... to attrition ukraine must be parallel to the war at the attrition of russia, only if it is a mutual war at the attrition of two states and peoples, at least the ghost will appear so that in russia

part of the elite... part of the population thought about the need to end this war, at least on this line of contact, where the troops of the warring countries will be at the time of its end. no other possibility of ending this war exists in nature. and that's why i believed that the fact that ukrainian troops moved into the so-called sovereign territory of the russian federation, that they control this territory, that they imposed another front of this war on russia, is an important political moment. moreover, this political moment is still and showed the so-called red lines of the sunset. he showed that western countries are absolutely now calm about the possibility of using their weapons, their weapons on the sovereign territory of the russian federation, that they have no complaints against the ukrainian troops who use these weapons, this is also very important to me , i would say, an instructive moment, as you understand, but at the same time, it did not even occur to me that putin would withdraw troops from

the donetsk front. transferring it to kursk, because it is necessary to look at this situation through the eyes of putin and his generals. in putin's eyes, the war is generally taking place on the territory of the russian federation, because donetsk, luhansk, kherson, and zaporizhzhia regions have long been annexed by russia, they have been mentioned in the russian constitution for two years together with crimea as subjects of the russian federation, and the viewpoints of russian constitutional law are no different from those of the kurdish region. why would it be necessary to transfer v... sk from russian donetsk region to russian kurshchyna, if you look at it through putin's eyes. of course, even such an opinion could not be eradicated from putin. and i think that if anyone in kyiv had such hopes at all, then he still does not realize how the russian leader thinks, because volodymyr zelensky can think in terms of his own state. he fights for the territorial integrity and sovereignty of his own state, but the person who fights against him thinks

in terms of empire. for volodymy. putin and for millions of his compatriots, their own state is the soviet union, and ukraine is only a separatist entity on the territory of this state there is an abscess on russia's goals, which must be destroyed for the sake of the further prosperity of russian statehood, and this is exactly how they treat it and will continue to treat it. i do not think that the russians' point of view of what ukraine is will undergo significant changes in the next ten years. and i always convinced that there is no need to even try to change this point of view. we need to fight back, not change russia. russians, this is the first moment, the second moment, from the point of view, even from a military-tactical point of view, to move troops from this territory, where they go successful battles for russia, on the territory where the ukrainians can now control only a small piece of the kurdish region, this means stopping their own operation, thus falling into the trap of the ukrainian raid on

kurshchyna, well, one could assume that... the russians are capable of this, however again, if they had political considerations, if they believed that there they are fighting on ukrainian territory, here they are fighting on russian territory, but since there are no such political considerations, it was immediately clear that they would first try to deal with the donetsk region, and then think about kursk, how this principle should look, when it turns out that the ukrainian troops will be able to stop the russian troops at a certain bridgehead. in the direction of donetsk and kharkiv, and the russians understand that they will not break through any further, that they have stopped, and that they now have to hold this contact line and possibly prepare for a new offensive there, i do not know there in the 25th year in the 26th well, it's hard for me to say that, then they will transfer part of the forces of the donetsk direction on kursk to try to recapture this

territory. by the way, i hope that by then some other territories of the russian federation will be under the control of ukrainian troops, the more we create such problems for the russians, the better for us, but it will be in this sequence, and in no other. and we can expect, for example, that russia, putin, the kremlin leadership will carry out some kind of minimal mobilization in the fall, or at least in the next few months. or will still form with the help of hidden mobilization of some brigades or battalions and will throw them, for example, on this essentially small piece of the kursk region, will they still be a priority, in your opinion, politically, again, a priority...