arguments, they are quite dubious, but i think they will be used, that something is not working out, because while new people have arrived, people need time, but when they have already worked there for a couple of months, then we will actually ask them, in fact it all looks like this, although i think that in the best case, in the best case we will not just lose what we actually had in the context of the work of the government there until today, in the worst case we will have very big problems of course, because according to certain candidacies... there are questions, but here the main thing is not even that, the main thing is that all these people are new, they need time, they need time in order to understand the activities of their ministries, and there is really no time today, and sometimes people come there who are far from that areas where they will actually work, i.e. they will need even more time than for example, for a person who is still, even if it is possible, a professional in one or another field, here in fact the entire list contains questions about the fact that they are very... easy to understand

peculiarities of working as a minister, in the field that will be assigned to them, and will be able to effectively perform the tasks assigned to them. we will now listen to what zelensky says about personnel changes in the government and why they are necessary. please. first, we need more interaction between the central government and the communities, especially now during the preparation for the winter season. second - ukraine has already achieved significant results in defense production, this should be strengthened at all levels, in particular so that it is easier to attract investments partners in our strategic industries. third, we must significantly strengthen our work with nato. this requires a special interaction. the fourth - the european union - real negotiations regarding. membership, preparation

of the relevant parts of the future membership agreement, this is a very clear, simultaneous legal and political work, for which there will be personal responsibility, and fifth, should we combine everything that ukraine has achieved in relations with partners? well, in short , the president said a lot of things, the only thing he didn't say, and why actually, the president's office... initiates changes in the government, because we live in a parliamentary-presidential republic, there are only two ministers, or rather three: the prime minister, the minister of defense and the minister of foreign affairs, whom the president of ukraine can change or submit to the verkhovna rada, and in this situation, he said a lot about the fact that it is necessary to strengthen cooperation with nato, it is necessary to strengthen cooperation with the european union, many directions, and in this... story

, it is absolutely incomprehensible to me why the resignation letter was written by the minister of foreign affairs of ukraine dmytro kuleva, and today it is information that consideration of this issue has been urgently postponed in the verkhovna rada for the time being, and people's deputy yaroslav zheliznyak reported this without specifying the reason. mr. igor, do you understand the logic of zelenskyi's team's actions, given that dmytro kuleba is perhaps the most professional. and the most prepared minister in shmygel's government, but look, there is an interesting moment here, mr. arakhamia wrote that when they met with the president, andrii sybiga was going to the ministry of foreign affairs, that is, this issue was raised, and it was not actually considered by the factions, and i understood, it was one of the first, that is, maybe tomorrow there will still be an attempt to satisfy the resignation of kuleba and appoint sabiga himself, why is this happening with regard to the ministry of foreign affairs? well, look, this

is an interesting moment, on the one hand, it is really difficult to find any negative moments, well, such frankly negative moments in kuleba's activities. he was definitely in his place, he did a lot, tried a lot, was not afraid to make strong enough statements that represented the position of ukraine, but i think that here, well, somewhere, two things worked against him factors: the first factor, after all, when he actually agreed to the role imposed on him by the office of the president. dent, and i mean that according to our legal framework in general, he should be the second person in the country who is actually responsible for foreign policy after the president, but he gave up this place and a lot of functions that actually belong to him and his ministry, took over the office of the president and individual persons of this office, for example, the head of the office andriy yermak, we all know very well what issues he is engaged in, the president assigns them to him, and this is purely functional. of the ministry of foreign

affairs, kuleba agreed to it, he did not actively oppose it in principle, but i think that there were still certain fears in the office that he was not so much there... his own person, let's put someone who in worked in the office, i will immediately note, by the way, that there are no reservations at all regarding mr. sibigi, from the point of view of professionalism, he is a very high-class, highly professional person who is well acquainted with the work of a diplomat, has there is a lot of experience and so on, he will definitely be a good minister, but in this case we are saying, why exactly is the stake removed there, that is why, most likely, they want maximum, maximum loyalty and in general even the absence of any hints of... well his position, inseparable from the position of ukraine, but not agreed upon, perhaps with the office of the president beforehand. and there is another moment, it seems to me that there is a certain emotional fatigue in the relationship between kuleba and the president, his closest circle, well

it seemed so to me, because i remember recently, when there was a press conference of the president, there the issue of the ministry of unity was touched upon, the journalists said that it was a kuleba idea, the president was not offended. said that in fact the situation is a little different, it was my idea in general, and why did it look like that, and why was it used for pr if it was kuleba, although koleba did not say anything extraordinary there, and it is possible that in the aggregate, well, all this leads to the fact that he also actually wrote this statement, but it is interesting that it was not really voted for today, and maybe there some negotiations are still going on and some decisions are being made, because it will be strange if he at least remains without a job and is not involved in some areas that are important. for ukraine, and you know, here's one more point, just the president, when he made his statement there, his first point was about strengthening and improving cooperation between central authorities and central authorities and local self-government bodies. i'm just looking at the list of those ministries that are being changed, well, except for the ministries of the ministry of the region, v

in principle, all others have a very distant relationship with local self-government, in the context of the heating season, the minister of energy had to be fired first of all, but everything is fine with him, he fired... instead, the head of ukrenergo, and the minister of energy continues his work, although i it seems that he is the biggest question and he should definitely be on the list of those who will leave the current cabinet. dmytro kuleba, still in the status of minister of foreign affairs of ukraine, commented on how mongolia violated its international obligations, in particular regarding the detention of people who, on whom the warrant of the international criminal court has been issued, he...

the signal after the visit began, it is also ignored, we will discuss in ukraine and with our international partners further actions after the visit of the military criminal to mongolia. mr. igor, it is obvious that what happened in mongolia is probably putin's touchstone, and it will not be the last. in the event that this will be repeated with other states that have signed and... ratified the rome statute, and perhaps even delegated their judges to the international criminal court, like mongolia, like mongolia, yes, yes, how can this all end, you know, i think that in fact there will be no other precedents yet, and at least for quite a long period of time, here this is

not an excuse for mongolia, but we have to just take into account the specifics of this country's situation, it actually, well, it didn't just have to invite putin, but we understand why it... happened and who asked them to accept putin in principle, but they physically don't have the opportunity, not even that to delay putin, even try to hand him, for example, a warrant, so i think that this situation will not go further for now, the only thing is that the international criminal court should really react to it somehow, introduce some certain, well, restrictions for mongolia, well, of course, not exclude it there and so on, but nevertheless some kind of punishment is certain, and it is within the limits of that regulatory law. it should be a base, and other countries should think very carefully about this precedent and understand what to repeat, well, how to repeat that, what mongolia actually did, something tells me that, for example, putin will not fly to the same armenia or some other country, because there will be a completely different situation, and, by

the way, he did not fly to the south african republic, because he is directly there hinted that it is better not to do this, i think that other countries that have ratified the roman statutes, they will now be very cautious about similar... russia will try to somehow use this whole story for informational purposes, but i will tell you that even for its own by the analysis of their internal publics, it is not achieved that result. which putin was counting on, the super-critical situation did not turn out, he did not succeed in showing himself as some kind of winner there, because everyone perfectly understands why mongolia in particular, why the visit took place now, who asked for it, and what were the real possibilities in mongolia has to somehow detain him there, so i think that it will simply continue until it goes, until it goes, but this is also a signal for the iss, including that it is possible to make some corrections in its own regulatory and legal framework, mutual relations. with various other countries and to do everything to ensure that such a precedent is not repeated in the future, because

then it will not look very good, you know, once it can be understood somehow, when it happens several times, well, this is already a trend, and the trend is clearly, well negative for the international criminal court as a whole, and also as international justice, by the way, the european union expressed its regret about the fact that mongolia hosted the head of the kremlin and did not arrest him, as required by the warrant of the international criminal court, well, let's hope... mr. igor, that this warrant is international the criminal court will still get putin sooner or later, especially since this warrant cannot be revoked, that is, it has been issued and that's all, it's already for life for putin, there can be no arguments and no objections from the kremlin, because a war criminal, certified is the head of the current russia. thank you for the conversation, it was ihor reiterovych, political. expert, friends, we work live on the tv channel, as well as on our youtube and facebook platforms, during

the entire broadcast we conduct surveys, we we ask about this, do you consider it timely to renew the personnel of the ukrainian government? yes, no, everything is quite simple on youtube, either yes or no, if you have a separate opinion, please write it in the comments under this video, and i will remind you, voting phones, we will continue in the second part of our program , this is a vote 0800 211 380. if you consider the personnel update of the ukrainian government timely no 0800 211 382, ​​if you show now, dear directors, the interim results of our television survey, yes 26% yes, 74% no. when you sleep on an uneven surface, the spine takes the wrong position, because you cannot feel energetic in the morning and productive in the afternoon, and with the matryk toper you will forget that you are sleeping on an imperfect surface. order the

mattrik topper for comfortable sleep at an affordable price. more and more ukrainian families choose topper matrix, which comes in a convenient package that is easy enough to remove. within a day after removing the factory film, it can be used. a unique case in which you can hide your topper will not only a new item of interior, and still quite a functional thing. you can use it both while relaxing and while working at home, the toper itself is quite easy to take out and spread out. a topper from the factory means faster production, one to three days and prompt delivery. delivery is carried out throughout ukraine within two to five working days. with us, you know what you're buying, not choosing a set of features. mattrik is your universal thin mattress for uneven surfaces at an affordable price. order. from one of the largest manufacturers in the country orthopedic mattresses and furniture, and also with

a 20% discount. almost any sofa, even a small one, will become a comfortable sleeping place. fold out the sofa, spread out the topper and enjoy a flat sleeping surface. joints are almost always an integral part of folding sofas. simply spread the topper matrik to get a flat sleeping place without joints and unevenness. shop now. join the families who have already forgotten what the inconvenience of sleeping on sofa beds is. orthopedic air foam cover with winter-summer function and an affordable price thanks to the order from the manufacturer. here are three advantages for which ukrainians choose topper matryk. call or follow the qr code and order right now. in september, there are discounts on nephrobam, 10% in psyllanyk, bam and oskad pharmacies. in pharmacies plantain, bam and oskad.

a journalist who joined the armed forces, a political expert who became a special agent, taras berezovyts in a new project on espresso. the real front is a thorough analysis of the main events. reports, comments of leading... and expert analysts from the major of the armed forces. how to make sense of disturbing news and distinguish truth from hostile propaganda. the real front program with taras berezovets every day. 21:30 at espresso. verdict with serhiy rudenko is now in a new two-hour format. even more analytics, even more important topics, even more top guests: foreign experts, inclusion from abroad. about ukraine, the world, the front, society, and feedback. you can express your opinion on the bad day with a phone

survey. turn on and turn on. verdict with serhii rudenko. from tuesday to friday from... greetings, friends, live on the espresso tv channel, the second part of the verdict program, my name is serhiy rudenko, and for the next 45 minutes we will talk about the following. putinsky. rocket terror continues. the kremlin increases the degree of hatred of russians towards ukrainians. how long will ukraine's western partners avoid interfering in the situation. restoration of nuclear status. all agreements that were in effect after the signing of the budapest memorandum have been destroyed. what is now preventing ukraine

from launching its own nuclear program? shower. resignations in the ukrainian government, regular an attempt to change the amount by changing the places of terms, isn't it time to change approaches to the formation of recruitment principles? friends, i remind you that we work live on the espresso tv channel, as well as on our youtube and facebook platforms, so join our platforms and subscribe to our pages, like this video so that it can be promoted in youtube trends. and facebook, and take part in our traditional poll, the poll that we conduct throughout the broadcast, today it sounds like this: do you think are you in time for personnel renewal of the ukrainian government? yes, no, everything is quite simple on youtube, or yes or no, if you have a personal opinion, please write it in the comments under this video, if you are watching us on

tv, take your smartphone or phone and vote for the numbers, if you think it's timely personnel... no 0800 211382 all calls to these numbers are free, vote, at the end of the program we will sum up the results of our vote today. so, today we have viktor boberenko, an expert of the analysis bureau, on the air politicians mr. viktor, i congratulate you. good health to you. thank you for joining the broadcast. and sergey taran. political scientist, mr. serhiy, i congratulate you, thank you for being with us today, i congratulate you, because gentlemen, we are asking our viewers and tv viewers whether they consider it timely to renew the personnel of the ukrainian government, let's take a blitz survey, you will answer to the same question, let's start with mr. viktor, mr.

viktor, we have... some communication problems, obviously, please restore the connection with viktor boberenko so that he can hear us and we he was heard, the main thing. mr. victor, can you hear us? mr. viktor, can you hear us? unfortunately, there is no connection, mr. serhiy, please speak to me, do you consider it timely to renew the personnel of the ukrainian government? well, the word renewal sounds nice, but until we understand the motivation of these changes and what is behind these changes in a practical sense, for example, what the newly appointed officials will do differently compared to the previous ones, until then it is very difficult to evaluate anything. because it's easy to replace one with another without explaining why, for what, well, very much

it's difficult to even approach this from value judgments, so i think that still... that during the appointment of new officials, there will be reports on what has been done, and then we will have some programs announced, or at least those that will be released at least a little material will appear that we can cling to and talk about something, but now there is not much information, just the word update, changing people, this is not yet an update, it is simply changing, it is simply changing surnames, which are very difficult to evaluate yourself by itself, without specific cases that are for these last names stand. thank you, mr. serhiy, mr. viktor, do you think that personnel renewal of the ukrainian government is timely? i agree with serhiy that actually... in the office of the president, who manages everything, then what, it doesn’t matter what surnames, if the ministries will be managed by, let’s say, not ministers,

but yermak’s deputies, yes, well, de facto, but also i believe that it is not timely, that is, they had to do it, well, it is clear that it is populist, well, the entire government is populist, and they have to do it. it was late autumn, say, somewhere at the end of november, when something goes wrong, they would say: well, something is wrong, then we will fire these ministers, we were recruiting new ones, and now everything will go like this, now everything will be fine, but then we will have to, perhaps, now at the end of november , shmygal will have to be replaced, just to say, well, how do all populist governments do, so that zelenskyi cannot be bad, he is a priori. the greatest leader of our time, it is necessary to change the beds in our brothel, well, somewhere like that. thank you, mr. viktor, president zelenskyi

confirmed that the latest personnel changes in the government are the previously announced reshuffle of the cabinet of ministers, but at the same time he did not give a direct answer regarding the further fate of the minister of foreign affairs dmytro kuleba, who also submitted his resignation, although the verkhovna rada of ukraine has not yet... did not vote, let's listen to what zelensky himself says. we need new energy today, and these steps are related, only they are related to the strengthening of our state in various directions. international politics and diplomacy are no exception. i'm not today i can predict what this or that minister will be doing, and there are answers to this when they are offered. mr. serhiy, what changes from these rotations in the cabinet of ministers, when the state

is run by five or six managers of the office of the president of ukraine. you understand that it is even difficult to evaluate these changes, if only because they are very different. each ministry is a separate world, just as each position is a separate world, we cannot evaluate them all together, because it turns out to be some kind of average. temperature in the hospital, but to evaluate each minister or every official, for this it is necessary, well , from where, for this it is necessary that there be programs announced by the new officials, it seems to me that this is an attempt, an attempt to show that something is supposedly changing for the better in the government, well, this government, the new government , she came on the slogan of the total replacement of the old ones, but the new government has already become the old one, so it is necessary to change someone anyway, because... well, this is her original slogan, so they start to change their own and from time to time sometimes they organize personnel purges that have no

logical motivation, maybe they are very good, maybe they are bad, i don’t know, well, there is simply no information, and there is, i think that the only motivation behind this is that such personnel purges will be positively perceived by people, by voters, who will say, well, if they changed some others, then now, now, now we will recover, that is, that is why it is... what motivation can it be, is it good? well, i don't know, again, i think it will be good when we have very clear explanations from the authorities, what they are doing, why they are doing it, and when they will explain why this frame is going to replacing something else, what was wrong with the old one, what will be new with the new official, then it will be clearer, then it will really be better, then there will simply be more responsibility for actions. authorities, but simply replacing one surname with another, well, it can be good for someone, because some will perceive it as an update, but it will only be a replacement of the surname,

but the real update will be when the officials, coming to their positions, will clearly bear responsibility for their words, for what they will do, and then at the end of their term it will be possible to check whether did they do something there or not, but then it will really be better, and then it will really be possible to say that this was a qualitative renewal of the government, well... but to understand by what marker to compare the work of this or that minister, there is no such marker , that is , there is no program of shmyhal's government, he has been a minister, prime minister of ukraine, of the government for four years, the government did not submit a program, this program was not approved by the verkhovna rada of ukraine, and that is why this statement about some... energy looks very strange in that government, which programs there is no, and it is not clear what goals he wants to achieve, and why and in what way, about

what... let's listen to what the railwayman said. there is a khaluschenka carrying a lot of black cash, of course he should be left, there is dmytro kuleba, for some reason people like him more than some officials from the president's office, and he has some rating, of course he should be fired, what if? otherwise , the office of the president will exist after that, so the logic seems clear enough to me. mr. viktor, judging by these actions that are now being taken by zelenskyi's team, can it be perceived as the channeling of people's dissatisfaction with these or other actions or these or other events in ukraine, that now we are changing some of the ministers, there will be new energy, everything will be new again,

somewhere... in the elevator, which was launched in the 19th year, there was a crash a bunch of new managers who graduated from international universities, but now we will find someone here in the office of president sybig, we will find another specialist somewhere in the deputies at yarmak, we will make them ministers, in november, as you say, we will change the prime minister and in general let's make andrii yermak the prime minister, and it will be called. powerful new energy, yes, i say once again what they did untimely, that is, yes, there is discontent, yes, there is no need for zelensky’s ratings to fall, they need to be contained somehow, and therefore it is necessary, if the discontent were to be channeled, everything is correct , political-technological, clear move, ancient, we didn’t

invent it, that’s the way it is... that’s how they always do it, they transfer, they look for a shooter, so that there’s a goat from a buffalo on him, to throw it at him, but everything was wrong, everything was not so, and now everything will be so, and from the point of view of this, that is, the move is unsuccessful, premature , premature, they made a false start, yes, and on the other hand, i agree with the same railwayman that there is someone useful, he please'. the office of the president, that's why we don't yank him, yes, we want to yank someone, not only that, we see that the servants have started a frond, yes, why did they stop at kuleba , there were not enough votes on vereshchukka, there on kula, because they predictably see there , that now there will not be enough votes, and therefore it is necessary, yes, it is necessary to carry out additional work, which showed us today that... the green government does not, not

even, not completely control the parliament, and that we still need to understand in this vein that we are facing a situation where it is not explained only to us, well, okay, they didn't explain to us, well, who we are, just some experts, some scientists, some, well , even just people, but there's like, well, someone who speaks simply. people, why explain something to them, how to explain something to society, let society guess itself, or there is a type, or even if there is an explanation, it will be untrue, yes, they still haven’t explained to us, they fired a hard worker for something, we know because he poked zelensky in the eyes, what should be done, what shouldn’t be done, and such a person is not forgiven, the greatest leader of our time, here is some hard worker something is being blamed on him, but it was not explained, guess for yourself, but the worst thing is that they do not explain to the servants

of the people and they have 130-150 servants who vote just like that, because they vote, because , well, yes , well, damn it, that's how it's supposed to be, that's how the arachamia was explained to him, really they told the truth, yes, and to explain to the rest why, well, and now these good people, yes, are trying to tell us all, something that... some new energy is needed, which passionarians are new there or something more passionate, what did he mean , the president, in general, he always speaks in gibberish and in riddles, because if he talks about passionate people, there is a popular ukrainian proverb, a fool is worse than a fool with initiative, yes, we need new fools, perhaps competent ones people or just...