appointed to another, look, in fact, this is a small test for our viewers, he immediately explains what happened, nothing happened, just nothing happened, if eh, well, who expects a change in the results of the ministry's work, if a person who has been acting for six months yazuk, became a minister, and karandiyev did not become among other ministers who expect a change in the ministry, if it is close. a diplomat with many years of experience suddenly becomes the minister of culture, who can expect normal work from a person, this is the former head of the regional of the state administration of my native region, who in a year changed the position of the head of the regional state administration, the state property fund, and now went to mine the apc, this is just an imitation of the stormy activity of the president, which will not solve any of the serious... issues,

especially since none of the serious the ministry to which there are a lot of questions, er, in principle remained untouched, for example, the ministry of energy, 2 billion euros were buried in the ground with reinforcement and concrete to protect energy facilities in ukraine, how they are protected, now the whole feels ukraine, no way, is still protected from the shaheds in some places, from missiles. any. 2 billion euros, i emphasize. nearby, for example, the ministry of finance. the key ministry that prepares the budget. and suddenly it turns out, in the summer, that we do not have enough half a trillion to finance the armed forces of ukraine. and today there is news that from september , the payment of military personnel, er, to our heroes is under question. do you have any questions for the minister? no, no, he continues to work, i

can list all these ministries, well, for example, who is generally responsible for fortification, you know who, the minister of statistics, well, this is a wonderful country, with an even more wonderful management system, but what about fortifications, we see in the pokrovsky direction, and not only there, you can list endlessly, but this is just an imitation of stormy activity in the style of the show 95 th quarter for... a week of informational pretexts will be enough, what are you and i doing now, we discuss nothing, imitation, profanation in the show, let's listen to what zelensky says, what he expects from changes in the government, and what kind of effect it has be active work, please give zelensky's synchronism, government replacements have taken place, i am grateful to the parliament for supporting the relevant candidates, it is very important that government institutions work as actively as possible now, they are still active. than it was before, at

all levels, more investments by partners in the defense industry of ukraine, more active progress in the negotiation process with the european union, and this is also the preparation of the future accession agreement, more interaction and mutual understanding between the central government and communities. this government is still there the prime minister, who has been in office for five years. and from the very beginning, there was no government program and it was approved by the verkhovna rada of ukraine. well, there is a war, everything is clear, but the government as an institution, the war, everything is clear, so why should the government work without a program? for the third year , we have been working without a state defense order, and the ministry of defense does not plan what the troops need, it buys what they mentioned, do you understand this story at all, it is chaotic. work is not bound by any

government rules, but look, the president with all due respect, maybe in this phrase said in what i can believe is the intensification of the eu accession negotiation process. i really don't understand why stefanyshina, as a vice-prime minister , became the minister of justice, added the ministry of justice and this is the addition of new energy, i doubt it, but okay, okay, they say that it is necessary to increase the production of own weapons, they are filming at the same time the minister of strategic sectors of the economy, well, who is actually responsible for this, last year with great fanfare , a large part of personal income tax was transferred to him, you know what happened now, they removed them as soon as this the ministry launched the first long-range missile, after all these adventures with the freezing of missile programs in the 19th year, they finally launched a missile that gave a result of 500 km with a serious load of explosives and so on, in this ministry removed. pdf, zero. i

understand that no one reports this to the president. i understand that he is not really interested in this. there's just some kind of show going on, so this week will be full. and the news appointed nine ministers, whom, why, under what? but i absolutely agree with you, we have a prime minister, because in any case the government has a conductor, a manager who is in charge and instructs the government, sets them tasks, controls and so on, this is the prime minister, again, maybe the president will hear us with you, uh, the idea of ​​creating a new kind of military , armed forces. uav unmanned aerial vehicles was put forward by general zaluzhny. he wrote a report to the president's office, they waited until he was removed, and also, by the way, they said that this was a reboot and a new energy, well, how did it end after his resignation, we also see all of us every morning, looking at

map a presidential decree is issued instructing the government to create an appropriate regulatory framework and to create appropriate. for four months the cabinet of ministers wrote regulations on the new type of troops, i guarantee that any captain specializing in record keeping in the armed forces, as it is called specifically, would have written it in a maximum of 5 days, but for four months the government worked out the bill and adopted it, after that they looked for a commander for another two months, they appointed him, and for another four months after that they looked for a chief. the headquarters of this type of troops, which is currently being checked by the sbu, and as of today day, the law on the armed forces did not make the appropriate changes and there is no type of uav troops there, no, there are uavs, but there is no type of troops in the law. tell me, can the government act effectively? no, this is not

an efficient government. and the person who heads it, even after the decree of the president, who organizes its implementation for six months or more, those related to the war, is... a completely ineffective, i would say, inhibitory factor in the work of the state apparatus. why does this happen? and here we come to the point, because the issue is not that we do not have a prime minister, we have yermak's squire. it everyone has known for a long time. but why does it happen that the most important documents drag on for months, and sometimes are not executed at all. and, for example, funding does not go anywhere at all, and some crazy decisions are made about burying money in concrete. and that. it is necessary, it is not purchased, everything happens because the constitution of ukraine, in general, has not been opened by the current government for a long time, because according to the constitution, the cabinet is formed by the parliamentary majority and bears full responsibility for

its work, and the office of the president helps the president to fulfill his two main functions: work on the defense of the country and work in the international plane, period, but everyone knows that ... any government cough, sneeze, especially a piece of paper, and even more funding with subsequent divergence, is agreed in the office of the president on the street of the bank and this process is managed by the head of the president's office, yarmak, and five or six effective managers who have no responsibility, most of them are not even office deputies, they are advisers, they do not sign anything, and they really hope that after this they will not carry no responsibility, because there is none...

and they hope that it will be so, and they rule ukraine. and the entire government from the office of the president without any prescriptions of the constitution, well, that is, the ministers who are appointed, these are the next goats from the buffalo in the current system of power, this is a sham, this is not even the movement of beds, because the beds are actually the same, well, some moved, some they moved it, yes, but they put new characters there, whose last name is only one thing: nothing will change, because it was half of... acting duties, that is, those the people themselves, the second half, as always, people who have nothing to do with the relevant industry, and above them are the key supervisors, these five or six effective managers from the office of the president, who basically manage all the processes, how they manage, we

see , well, in his everyday life, in your opinion, why shmygal was not changed due to, well , let's say this, behind-the-scenes conversations in the parliament that are happening now, and not only in the parliament, they want to remove him for a long time, but the leader of the faction. servant of the people of david rahamia defended the continuation of his premiership in force their long-standing close relationship. he proved to the president that it is not yet time to drop this ballast from the balloon of power. shmygal's long-standing relationship with arakhamia or arakhamia with akhmetov? this should not be addressed to me. in this case, arahamia is a serious political figure, he is the leader of the faction, he... has access to the president, he has access to the prime minister, he influences his faction, he simply

has the opportunity to say: i don't have votes in the faction under this , and this can lead to a relationship with any official, in this case we are talking about prime minister, regarding the results of his work, well, from my point of view, he proved his inefficiency a long time ago, a long, long time ago, and i am not talking about prokhmetov, by the way, sergey, because you should never confuse a person with the place where he once worked. well, someone, each of us worked somewhere, for example, i was once an assistant to the prime minister, that does not mean that i am a valery person, i remember that you were with oleksandr moroz once and many times, so look, the one who works where, well , he worked as a manager at one of akhmetov's energy facilities, of course in he has some contacts, but this does not mean that akhmetov appointed him, well, in fact, these are myths, it doesn't happen like that in life, he has been an independent figure for a long time, but he knows the rules of the game now. ukraine, first of all, don't stand out, don't show any of your ratings, any of your publicity, and

clearly, clearly fulfills not what the country requires, but what the banks on the street demand, and he fulfills these rules. but look, i want to end with something, but at the same time, mr. yarmak sent to his government, well, let's say, a very trusted person, who seriously proved himself among these five or six managers, this is uh... sybigu, no, no, no, this is the minister of regional development, kuleba, this is not the former minister of foreign affairs, but oleksiy kuleba, his namesake, who will be mastered in the government corridors cabinet, in order to probably occupy the post of prime minister, what would i comment on, if the president really wanted to restart the government with more energy and... more responsibility for the tasks set by him, the parliament, society, i would make the office unification

the president and the cabinet, it would work, of course a little autocratically, but at least honestly, and i would appoint andrii borysovich yarmak, who is already in charge of everything, the prime minister, so that he manages these processes with full responsibility, not by plotting, not by declarations, in his government office, that... would be fair, but that's not how this team works. and now i will allow myself one more story, because we talked about efficiency, and now about political responsibility. it was not for nothing that i reminded that according to the constitution and laws, the government is formed in the parliament of the parliamentary majority. as you know, there is in the parliament most servants of the people. according to the law, the head of the faction, by the way, this is about arahami's influence, makes a submission. on the prime minister, on the removal of certain ministers and on the appointment of certain

ministers, only they deputies are authorized for this action, after that the prime minister submits these nominations to the parliament and they vote on it. yes, now it's simple, because i found a time when it was necessary to coordinate the candidacy with two factions, with three and even with five, but now it's simple, there is one faction, formally simple, but are there votes, yesterday's and the day before yesterday's vote . in the parliament showed that these ministers did not receive votes, sufficient votes of the servants of the people, from 170 to 167 votes against the required 226 were received by all ministerial candidates, where the rest of the necessary votes were taken from the opz faction and its fragments, therefore, in fact, we can debate for a very long time about the qualities of individual ministers and this government, but since yesterday we have openly a government of servants of the people and opzzh. after two

maidans and in the third year of the war, it seems to me a terrible, moral degradation, a terrible political cynicism, but he actually, yesterday, well, it was simply openly demonstrated on the scoreboard of the verkhovna rada. servants of the people - 167, for the same kulebu. there are 20 of them, 10 more fragments, 7, 8, as a result you have 240, this society must know and must understand that... that we are dealing today with a government that actually represents two political forces, servants of the people and opzzh, and therefore they will be responsible. why did dmytro kuleba leave the post of minister of foreign affairs? here is a separate song. dmytro koleba has always been a white crow in this government, well, how come his predecessor, by the way, is the minister of foreign

affairs prystayka. they were professionals. willing to do serious work in their field with achievements, with certain, well, plans, strategies and so on. prystayka, i well remember that i met him more than once in a diplomatic position, it was clear that the person is intelligent, ambitious, and this is normal, in principle, especially for a young person, and he has his own vision of ukraine's actions in the international arena, and when he became a minister, well, for me he was... such a bright spot in this gathering of dilettantes and populists, but the rules were by the rules, and little by little they forced him to wear sneakers and a sweater, instead of a diplomatic suit and a cot, it was obvious how unpleasant it was for him, because he, well , it is clear that he is such a diplomat by life, he devoted himself entirely to this profession, but entered

this history, well, then he realized that he would be made... just give him the furniture, because during the war, already in the second year of the war, it became clear that foreign policy would be managed by andriy yarmak, and at first they traveled together, and then it became simply obvious , that of the minister of foreign affairs, who carries all the responsibility, which by law must implement all policies in the priorities set by the president, is used simply as furniture... during the visits of the head of the president's office, who in principle does not have any constitutional powers regarding international affairs, and then mr. yarmak generally became undisguised already without the minister of foreign affairs, to dictate policy, what i mean, for example, has passed, well, about a year, the entire diplomatic machine of ukraine

has been engaged in peace forums with great energy. she he was not the only one we remember in switzerland a few months ago, there were four more, heads of various states were gathered in different countries, and the task was one: to gather more than 100 heads of states and governments in switzerland, for what? in order to proclaim the formula of peace, they gathered, proclaimed, the fair took off, he actually led this process, the photo from that forum shows everything, that is , the vice president of the united states hariys... looks somewhere behind his shoulder, he is in the center, he is the main key event, but what gave birth to this conference, you and i, we talked about it here, it is a huge swiss mountain gave birth to only one mole until the next forum, where the russian federation should be represented. what do we have for today? today we have the president's statements that there is no point in conducting any negotiations with russia,

that is, a year of diplomatic efforts have gone nowhere, meanwhile the same president... quite rightly says that we have problems with the western allies, regarding the supply of weapons to us. the question is, maybe it was necessary to spend a year with all the diplomatic machines of ukraine, not the decorative peace forum, scaboverde, and san marino, which are all the same to us neither money nor weapons are supplied. maybe we should have held victory forums with those who give us money and rockets. and at these negotiations, in the offices, if necessary... public ones, to achieve what is needed for victory, this is the difference between a professional minister of foreign affairs and a populist figure who knows how to organize a show, a film producer. now it has become clear that all these forums are talking about nothing, well at least for the time being, and it is necessary to find the culprit for the fact that the work with

our partners in the supply of weapons, and the fact that how the minister of foreign affairs dmytro kuleba was filmed. shows that he will be made extreme, because he was not simply removed, during the election of his successor, mr. seba, from the rostrum of the verkhovna rada it was actually said that kuleba was removed because he was carried away by his publicity and allowed himself pr, ate bananas in africa, you know, without authorization for a video camera, although we all remember who sent him there, even today. yesterday, for example, the trumpeters of the united marathon already openly told that he was rightly removed, because he got carried away by the ratings. that is, i say once again, the only professional in this in... was not just removed, they want to make him extreme for the policy pursued by another person with the surname evrbak, i.e. the failures in washington,

berlin, london, now they want to push it on the one who was not given to work according to one's powers, unfortunately, that is, dmytro kuleba is being pushed into politics, but no, i think that dmytro kuleby will be offered the position he is good at. knows, because he practically worked near her, i think that he will head the representation of ukraine in the eu, or the representation of ukraine in nato, or he already worked there, as i say, an acquaintance, maybe he will be offered some new form of combining these efforts, because now european integration and problems with nato supplies are probably on the same level of priorities , dmitry will cope with this, but if he is thrown out at all. with the power hierarchy, i will not be surprised, because unfortunately, there has never been a case when

zelenskyi's team has any gratitude towards those who helped them with their professional advice, i am also talking about prystayk, i am also saying about, well, there are many soldiers who were thrown out without any chance of being useful at the time. war, yes, general zaluzhny was sent to the embassy, ​​and 16 more generals, heads of the military, that is, well, unfortunately, only personal loyalty is valued here, and as our great lina kostenko said, because there is a struggle for the will of ukraine, and there is a fight for arms , so the wrestling is valued more, well , there are two ministers or, one vice-prime minister and the minister of justice. stefanishyna and matviy bidny, who was appointed head of the ministry of youth and sports, and there are problems with law enforcement

agencies, stefanyshyn is on trial and it continues, but on october 3, another session is scheduled to take place in the higher anti-corruption court. we are talking about the period when lukash was still in charge of the ministry of justice, and this case has been going on since then, and it is still about embezzlement. funds of the state budget by abuse of official position, how correct is this, i ask you, as a former prosecutor general, when the ministry of justice is headed by a person against whom there are claims of the higher anti-corruption court, his the case is being heard there, she is one of the accused, it is wrong, i will say it very simply, a person who, although not directly, has a certain influence on the courts, because in fact the minister of justice does. cannot influence every judge, it does not have such a function, but it influences the institution, the financing of judges, their formation, mergers, reorganizations, the recruitment process there,

and many other things, er, and at the same time being in process and not just any district court, but a higher anti-corruption court, and also with corruption charges, well, it’s wrong, why couldn’t we wait for at least the completion of this process and after it appoint it to... the garden, i don’t know, the fact that it contradicts any european standards that it currently has in terms of functionality, to be implemented in ukraine, well it's obvious, but - well, what to say in the servant of the people faction, you can already create a deputy group, well, you already know in our legislation, in the parliament, if you have 18 people, you can create a group, it's not a faction, but here, for example there, but... or a separate group of deputies or an association, that's it within the servants of the people, you can create a group of szo, there are already exactly 18 people who have suspicions, some have already fled, all the rest calmly go to

work with accusations of anti-corruption and other crimes, so if a faction independently, one such faction forms a government, then it is logical , that they should send their own kind, well, that's normal, well, here's matvyi bidnyi, about whom i spoke. this head of the ministry of sports and the ministry of youth, or the ministry of youth and sports, there were also stories about how he extorted money from athletes and destroyed military sports, banned measures to prepare young people for service in the armed forces of ukraine, there were also questions about him, and about him and his father-in-law dashutin, dashutin in general, well, you know who dashutin is, the whole country knows here, but really. of course, you can't make a person guilty for his actions, well, there are your relatives, but i don't know anything about this person, honestly, i don't know anything, listen, well , ministers have to undergo some kind of inspection,

not like with the chief of staff of the forces . drones, i don't know anything about this minister and i believe that in recent years, well, there has probably not been a normal minister of sports for 10 years, and unfortunately, the influence of the regionals on this department has always been very high, since the time of the formation and its huge group of influence, which were scattered throughout all federations, throughout the ministry itself, therefore, on it's a pity... we have to revive sports almost from scratch, the fact that this person is not capable of this is obvious to me, the fact that the verification of these candidates was carried out in the same haste as the familiarization with them during the voting in the verkhovna rada, well, that is, two minutes each the presentation of the program and the answers, yes, this is an imitation, everyone perfectly understands that, look, these ministers do not mean anything, all decisions are made in other rooms, such...

a topic we remember from the time of yanukovych, in principle, except for two- three ministers, the country did not know anyone, because everyone understood that all decisions are made in the administration of president yanukovych, by the appropriate observers, and today around president zelensky, people who thought differently have fallen away, and those who came from that system, tatarov and him, have remained similar in accordance, they form the system that they got used to when they were young, when they were still runners around. now they independently form the same thing that they saw then, or rather, what they were a part of then, only then they were on the middle rungs, and now they are already at the top, and they have formed the same vertical system, where the cabinet is just a scapegoat , look, you and i have been talking for more than half an hour about the complete imitation of the process, i am not criticizing, i just want people to understand perfectly, there is no point in asking questions to the minister of sports or

to... the minister of pc, or to the minister of energy, or to all issues are resolved in the president's office, the very end of these personnel appointments, the questions arose to the chief of staff of the unmanned systems forces, roman gladky, there his wife seems to have a russian passport, his daughter spoke for in russian, for russian athletes at competitions, now they say, well, it is necessary to conduct an additional investigation. the sbu has some verdict to give, how can a person be appointed to such a position without a verdict from the sbu, is this possible? so that's half of them question. there is another question: what does he know about uavs? what can a person who has served in the crimea in the navy all his life know about a modern type of weapon that actually appeared 2 years ago, well, let's say 2.5 years ago, and to which

he has no experience in his service... practically nothing to do with it, except that he knew that the shaheds were attacking the ukrainian odesa, that is why these two halves, that is, the person does not know for sure, did not go through with his hands, feet, head, the system of using uavs, and on the other hand on the other hand, among his relatives, well, there are so many questions that i apologize, well, with my head sirsky could probably find a place. candidacy, of course, i am not, no, i am not concerned with the details, and this should be done by the aparadshtab before signing these papers, the security service of ukraine, military counterintelligence, but well, it seems to me that even taking the lens in my hands, well, there is i understand that it is better for such a highly sensitive unit, if it were true, in fact, we understand that today the entire defense of ukraine is based,

unfortunately, not on artillery and not on rockets. would lead, so it is here that a 100-times-tested person with practical experience should be appointed experience of use, and not just a desire to be, well, have more stars. friends, i would like to remind you that we are working live on the espresso tv channel, as well as on our youtube and facebook platforms, throughout our broadcast we are conducting a survey, we are asking you about whether you expect an improvement in the work of the government after the replacement of nine ministers , no, everything is quite simple on youtube, if you have a separate opinion, please write it in the comments under this video. if you watch us on tv, pick up your smartphone or phone and vote by numbers. if you expect better government: 0800-211-381, no, 0800-211-382. all calls to these numbers are free. yury vitalivych, the month of the kursk operation, zelenskyi, speaking today during the meeting of the contact group on ramshtein defense issues.