minister of foreign affairs oleksiy kuleba, deputy prime minister for reconstruction, minister of community development, and worked as the deputy head of the president's office, herman smitanin, minister of strategic industries, and worked at ukroboronprom, vitaliy koval, minister of agrarian policy, currently the head of the fund derzhmaina, moreover, the head of the rivne regional military administration, mykola tochytsky, is generally a staff diplomat, and he was behind... the deputy minister of foreign affairs and was the deputy head office of the president of ukraine, and became the minister of culture and strategic communications. natalya kalmykova became the minister of veterans' affairs and matviy bidny, the minister of youth and sports, he was acting, svitlana grynchuk became the minister of environmental protection. well , to be honest, i've heard half of the names of these people, but i don't know anything about them, but... well, from this list

, of course, such names as mykola tochytsky deserve attention, because he became the minister of culture and strategic communications, judging by everything we have is being created, well, apparently, this ministry will now be called rather, well, the minister, the ministry of propaganda and counter-propaganda, well , maybe during the war it is justified, but by the way, i wanted to emphasize the only positive story in... those appointments that the ministries, who for a long time did not have leaders, where there were acting responsibilities, finally got their leaders, and this is really positive, because when any organization is managed by a temporary leader, then the efficiency of this management is not very good, subordinates think that it is temporary the boss, and you can not listen to him very much and perform your duties quite formally, when... now managers have already been appointed to the

same ministry of information, for example, then obviously the work should go faster, this is the only plus. what else i would like to note, and what, by the way, the deputies themselves are saying among themselves, i heard it from one of the deputies from the parliamentary majority, the monomajority, that in this way the authorities decided to remove the fears and such a request of the people for elections. because during the war it is difficult to conduct elections, well, not as formal as russia is holding where it was simply painted, and real elections are difficult, because some people are abroad, some are in the trenches, and with such a change of government they showed that it was as if some kind of renewal of power took place, well, this is also a purely psychological story, i don’t think that ukrainians will feel this, because i think that somewhere around 60 or 70 percent of people

cannot even identify or even say that who oleksiy kuleba became the minister of intelligence, there was already such a kuleba dmetro, so this is the one kuleba can be a brother or a son, either way or there sibiga as a minister of foreign affairs, well, that is, even for us, for people who have been watching politics, personnel appointments and ministers for a long time, i remember, well, 5 years ago . years ago, we clearly tracked who or how he came, what kind of person he was, and now they all basically follow the passport of one or two people, each minister used to be an individual, we looked at what plans this minister had, what approaches , as he, well, i remember he wrote a lot about transport, there was a minister from vienna, he primarily developed the railway, and when was pivovarskyi, he developed in...

first of all airplanes and brought low-cost islands here, that is , everyone had their own personal approach, and now, when we look at these ministers, well, the names change, but the approaches do not change, but in terms of i heard positive reviews even before he became a minister, it seemed that he was one of the president's speechwriters, he helped write these speeches, which... then they gathered this applause in all the parliaments of the world, and when he was appointed the first deputy minister of foreign affairs things, then it became clear that he was already being prepared to become a minister, and when the scandalous order was issued not to issue, not to provide consular services to men from abroad without presenting military registration documents, despite the fact that the law itself on mobilization was still at that time ... did not enter into

force, so this scandalous order was signed by sybig, not dmytro kuleb, and then it became clear who is the master in the house, and who is us? is really a minister, that is, it was already clear at that moment that sibiga was in fact in charge by the ministry of foreign affairs, and what claim was there to koleba, as colleagues from ukrainian pravda and other publications write, that he did not want to execute, i read it, that he did not want to waste his hands, he did not want such, doubtful from from the point of view of laws, orders to sign the law, well, accordingly, they got rid of him. well , it must be said that in the renewed government there are now three people who are staff diplomats, that is, people who, or rather, two for sure, this is andrii sybiga, because he is not an accidental person, he was an ambassador, an extraordinary and plenipotentiary ambassador

in turkey, ukraine, and worked, as you said, as a speechwriter for zelenskyi, then he was yermak's deputy and since april. began to perform the duties of the first deputy minister of foreign affairs, but mykola tochytsky is also a diplomat, and a staff diplomat, these are all those people who were in the diplomatic service for a very long time, he was the ambassador to belgium, worked in euro-atlantic structures and a person , who graduated from the kyiv institute of international relations, although he was the first there... he was educated at the faculty of philology, he he was a translator from the french language, by the way, he studied at the time when i was at the university, i remember him from tochytskyi university, and he was recently about to be appointed,

that is, instead of sybig, he came to the ministry of foreign affairs instead of him , and he went to the office of the president of ukraine and now he is the minister of culture and... strategic communications, this should obviously be enough, such a separate serious job, despite all these managers who are in the office of the president of ukraine, because after all during the war strategic communications are not only communications with a single telethon, we are talking about the creation of a system of propaganda and counter-propaganda that will work both in europe and throughout the world, because in our country, unfortunately, broadcasting as such does not exist, i.e. there is freedom, there is a home, and what else is there ce united 24 is a formal, at least not a state history, but rather as a public one, although we understand very well that it is still a tool, of such resources as, for example, the same russia

abroad, the united states of america abroad, germany is actively working for border, well, many powerful countries, they have their own mouthpieces to which. which influence audiences abroad, that is, we don’t have that, obviously tochytskyi will do exactly that and do you think he will succeed, well , i don’t know him personally, i also read his biography, i liked it, he worked a lot and with kuleba and kuleba, well, i would actually see kuleba in this position, well, i understand that after the ministry of foreign affairs, the ministry of information policy will be headed, now strategic strategic communication, this is not ee... probably in his eyes, it would be a demotion, i don’t know where he hasn’t gotten tired of over the years, but, if we talk about resources, then not everything always depends on resources, it is clear that we will never be able to compete with russia in the amount of funding of information campaigns, but

let's see what russia has achieved, all its attempts to influence the world through rasha today, through affiliates, where they poured millions, billions. billions of dollars over the years, they did not lead to anything, and here are the last showers of the ephesians, who exposed christ the thunderer and bellenket and the insider show that the fsb officers themselves recognize that spending on rusha today is no longer effective, and no one accepts such lab propaganda, so they begin to act in a different way, mimic ukrainians, local activists and... imitate hyped up already mass media, for example, to create fake pages of fox news and thus try to influence the citizens of other countries, well, in the states they even thought of using artificial intelligence to create simply millions of these

advertising messages in order to personally to influence everyone, every group of voters with those messages that can push these voters, that is, i am leading to the fact that it is not... how much it is about money, how much it is about innovations and approaches, and if the new minister can find some innovative approach for promoting ukrainian messages abroad, it will be good. well, it must be said that in reality no one tried to create a full-scale invasion since the beginning, no one tried to unite all journalists working in ukraine and make of them some kind of strong fist in opposition to the russian occupier, that is, well, they will tell you about the telethon, but the telethon solves a rather serious internal problem, but i mean, well, quite a lot of people. who could join this great propaganda in the good sense of the word and in

some formats to work with, there is a big problem that our government has spoiled relations with ukrainians abroad, i once again spoke about this, but i will repeat, the problem still exists , we have refugees who left, maybe russia also affects the split here, tries to quarrel those who left and those who left... and this cannot be allowed, ukrainians who are abroad, they remain ukrainians, they leave the connection with their homeland, they send money, they defend the ukrainian position abroad, go to protests and call on the governments of other countries to give weapons to ukraine, this work needs to be coordinated, and this is a possible joint work of the ministry of foreign affairs, and the mini-ministries of culture and... a third ministry may appear the return of ukrainians, and this is also quite such

an interesting story, and i do not rule out that kulebi may have been offered to lead this ministry, because it will actually carry out part of the powers that the ministry of foreign affairs currently has, but i know mr. knyazhyvskyi's proposal to create a ministry demographic policy or the ministry, as you happiness solution demographic. problems, but this is a similar story, it is, well, let's say, with the return of ukrainians, i am more skeptical, why, because, unfortunately, in a situation where the return of ukrainians depends on many factors, security, economy, economy, housing and everything else, that is , everything that our citizens who had to flee from the war have now, but when it comes to the ministry of return of ukrainians. then, well, no, not in the literal sense of return, there are already

enough ukrainians all over the world, that is, maybe this is the ministry of the diaspora or i don’t know, but the word ministry in this story scares me the most, when i imagine that it will sit down, it will sit down some kind of bureaucratic machination will begin to stamp these some orders, certificates, there is something else, and the ukrainians will be returned, returned, returned, and the ukrainians will not want to return themselves, well, we will create the preconditions there, we will conduct negotiations there, so that these ukrainians can finally be returned home, we have many such ministries under which there is actually no large developed infrastructure, even the ministry of strategic industry, despite such a great name, well, in the first years of its existence, i remember, we analyzed the purchases of this ministry, they purchased furniture, cars, that is the activity of the ministry consisted in simply mastering the budgets for salaries and for furniture and for cars, and... then, well, when komyshyn was already in charge of the ministry and when the ministry was actually transferred to the ukroboronprom

department, well, something had already started there, some kind of movement, but to create a superstructure over ukrabronprom just to have some additional voice in the government during voting, ukrabronprom can itself be a ministry, well, it is the main asset and all that, so i am constantly creating a new ministry. i remember viktor's words penzenyka, who was both the vice-prime minister and the minister of finance, the minister of the economy, who said that if you do not want the country to have no apples, then create a ministry of apples, it is not always fair, it is clear that some ministries necessary, but why create them for every occasion, i think that the ministries that already exist can deal with the return of ukrainians, just create the conditions, create programs, work on it, because in fact there are no secrets here, people are afraid to return,

because rocket bombs are falling even in the west of the country, we recently saw a tragedy in lviv, in poltava, that is, not even in the front-line territories, we see what problems we have with education, the year has begun, and a lot of children have come to school. and saw again that there are no normal shelters, no teachers, eh, these are elementary problems, if they are solved, safety and quality education will be easier, if they also find... money to support their families, because many people simply have nowhere to return, no bombed out houses or occupied territories, where these people should settle, in other countries they are provided with housing, they are provided with furniture, they are given money for clothes, for food, how ukraine can compete here, we need to look, create special programs, regarding personnel rotation in

the government, people's deputy of ukraine yaroslav zheleznyak. urges not to look for logic in these staff rotations, let's listen to what yaroslav zheleznyak said, it's a banal technical replacement of some people in power, well, really from the executive branch of power to other the same people who are from the executive branch of power, there is no logic in all of this , from the fact that the visiting card of the minister or his deputy will change, it seems to me that it is hardly something of ours. the system will change with all due respect to them, i absolutely support it, there is nothing to say here, there is no logic in this, also because when the changes were announced, it was still, as far as i can remember, when the zaluzhny was changed, they said in february, and there was a position the president,

that we are not just changing the head, we will have extensive, major personnel changes, and here are 16 generals. then they were released, well, i don't know about all the generals, well, it was about what and the government will change and everything, everything will change, but we see that these changes have stretched for more than a year, that is, there is very often no unity in words and actions, well, that is, if it is necessary to change some ministers and make qualitative changes in work, then this it had to be done right away, that is, when he said in february, i don't like there... the work of this minister, this one, that one, and not to make a show out of this, that is, not to recruit this pool of nine ministers, change them, moreover , there are also a lot of questions for these ministers, like ulha stefanishyna, there, colleagues write, yes, colleagues are writing about this anti-corruption, higher anti-corruption court, on october 3 this year , a case is being considered in which

the new minister of justice appears, that is, it is nonsense and... it looks very, very bad, or russian relatives of the minister of youth and sports, yes matvyi bidny, because he is the son-in-law of dashutin , a former people's deputy of ukraine from the party of regions, and he is accused of working for the russian federation in the interests of the russian federation, the military-industrial complex of ukraine, and this is also a big question, big challenges, well, that is, very much, i also want to note about the logic when filming. minister, when they removed the minister of infrastructure and regional policy, they said kubrakov beforehand, that's right, then they said that they would divide the ministry, and we see that it's not that they didn't divide, they even added the ministry of reintegration iryna veryshchu, iryna veryshchuk, and

it turns out that instead of disbanding the ministry, since it is impossible to just manage alone. with his affairs at the same time, the minister simply did not pay attention to regional politics, was only engaged in infrastructure, or vice versa, only regional policy, and did not deal with infrastructure, here we need to dilute these flows, but we are promised to do it in two, three, four months, and i will also remind you that they announced, well, they did not announce publicly, but they announced in the press what would happen the replacement of the head of the government, so the replacement of the head of the government did not happen, and as colleagues say... that in fact shmakhal once again beat everyone and defended his seat, but agreed to changes internally, they say that he defended him, arahamia, david arahamia, the head of the faction the servant of the people, watching these endless divisions and union of ministries, during the last 30

years, i cannot understand the logic of this division and division. then again the consolidation, then there were state secretaries, then there were many such things over the course of 30 years, that this system, in the end, does not work the way we would like, if only the ukrainians, the voters wanted, and the way they wanted to the office of the president, she works because it is very profitable when you have low-paid civil servants, there are few of them, they have a lot of responsibilities, and... and it is easy to fire them, and these people well, in fact, there are good people who seek stability and are afraid of just some. to take the initiative, or people are not clean-handed and manage everything, mostly not these people who are full-time employees, but a bunch of

advisers, consultants on grant funds, here by the way, i want to say hello to all our foreign sponsors who support the civil service in such a strange way, when money is given not for raising the salaries of civil servants, which would be logical, but for some additional positions that are not fixed in any way in... in this state architecture services that are external, which today exist, tomorrow they are gone, they may be super professionals, but all their achievements then go with them, and in this way we do not build this institutional memory, it changes, the government changes, the sponsor changes, which credits advisers and consultants, and everything is lost , all the hard work that has been done. well , do you have the feeling that zelensky is in some kind of personnel capsule, and in isolation, one might say, and he

may not see everything or see it differently it is in fact, exclusively through the prism of these five or six managers, one of them abruptly resigned this week from the position of deputy head of the office of the president of ukraine, but the same oleg. tatarov, the same andriy yermak, the same, now iryna vereshchuk, who is returning there, that is, to what extent is the president, in your opinion, already in the sixth year of the presidency, how far does he understand what is happening and what needs to be done in the state management i think not only the president, but also the office of the president and the employees of the office of the president very often biased and are in such an information bubble, that's how we are all surrounded in our social networks. surrounded by our friends , we have a kind of communication circle and receive information that is not weighted, not balanced, but from these people, as well as the president, we remember

the bigusinfo investigation, when they published analytical reports that are given to the president, transferred to the president's office, about , what kind of criticism appears on ukrainian tv channels, and all the negativity that appeared there was written that it was all nonsense, the opposition, that is, even when it was not about political criticism, about objective criticism of affairs in the state, for some reason this analytical contour, which, by the way, is connected with one of the deputies of the servants of the people, she painted it as the tricks of the opposition of such, er, that is, any criticism in the office of the president and perceived in this way as unconstructive, political, politically colored in the first place, and therefore they do not react to it, or even worse, it happens that they do the opposite, we see very often. as journalists are already asking the president questions at the press conference, why do you keep oleg tatarov in office, until

because there are a lot of questions for him, and the president reacts to it quite emotionally, and as a result, it seems to me that the whole effect of his press conference, with these statements about tatar , about tatarov is not revealed, because he actually has a lot of important things there... who said, but everyone remembered only about tatarov, who killed chechens in kyiv, it is still not clear what it was, the president's reaction was quite sharp, and she simply extinguished everything that was the main point at this press conference, well in principle, we will monitor how events will develop with those nominees who appointed and appointed by the president of ukraine, the verkhovna rada of the proclamation.

this is actually a promotion, he said, well , that is, from the position of deputy prime minister and minister, the office of the president, the promotion, he said one thing there, which absolutely answers why such personnel appointments, because it was from february 24 in the 22nd year, next to the president, that is, she did not leave the office anywhere, and this loyalty and this feeling of the elbow just becomes decisive when determining who ends up in which position, it seems to me obvious that we need not the fact that... a government of national unity, we need a government of national salvation, in the situation that has developed today, in general, i am not only talking about the military and the socio-economic situation, we see

a budget deficit, we see problems. which force to raise taxes, and it would be a logical decision to create a technocratic government from the best professionals that are available in this country, regardless of their political views, but we see that the logic of appointments is completely different, precisely because of personal loyalty to the president and the lack of political ambition in those who are appointed, and what that, how it is communicated... by serhiy leshchenko and other agitators of the president, well, sometimes, it seems to me, too like that, even too sweet, we remember serhiy leshchenko as a very sharp journalist -investigator in his time, and when he chose for himself the path of being a politician, well, i hoped that he would also be a sharp whistleblower, a sharp critic, but

here in... with this president and with this government, he is their lawyer, i hope that i did not act as a lawyer, but sometimes his arguments, well, at least you can question it. friends, i would like to remind you that we are working live , we are conducting a survey throughout our broadcast, and we are asking you about whether you expect the work of the government to improve after the replacement of nine ministers, yes, no, on youtube everything is up to... just , if you have your own opinion, a separate opinion that goes beyond the boundaries of an unequivocal answer, please write it in the comments below this video. unfortunately, bohdan butkevich did not join our broadcast, although he was announced in this program, i immediately i apologize to our viewers. well, if you're watching us on tv, please vote on 0800, 211, 381 if you expect the government to improve after

nine ministers are replaced by no 0.800. 211 382. another topic is short enough, but i hope that it is also important for everyone, directly, who is watching us now and for all ukrainians, this is what is happening in the energy sector of ukraine, as a result of shelling, russian shelling, denys shmyhal, the prime minister of ukraine stated that russia is already preparing new attacks on energy of ukraine. let's listen to what the prime minister said. if the situation is fixed as it is now, then we will get through the winter, we can get through without blackouts, but we understand that the enemy will not give us such luxury, just live calmly, their terrorist and genocidal policy will continue, we already know, divorce data that the next massive missile and drone strikes on our

energy system are being prepared, respectively. but we have already lost 9 gw, for understanding, this is half of the volume of electricity consumption before the war, i.e. obviously, it is not clear to our viewers how many gigabytes there are, 9, 10 or 20 gigawatts, it is clear that our energy system, which was originally built centrally and then was privatized, corporatized, this entire energy system, it is now vulnerable. it is clear that in the current situation we need to talk about the need for alternative sources of electricity that can provide, well, there are solar panels, they will not provide in winter, yes, but, but there are different types of power plants, portable, small power plants, and here i am in shmyhal's performance i just didn’t hear about it, maybe something

is being prepared, the government is planning to do something, because hoping that the russians will not fire at us, well, there is no point, because the main argument of putin and russia is the terror of the civilian population, and the proof of this civilian population to such a state when its people will go out into the street and say: listen, let's have some peace, because it's cold, because there is no light, because not all ukrainians will do it, but some ukrainians will. do whatever scenario seems most realistic to you for the next six months, because it's just the beginning of winter and winter, actually, i think there will be problems, of course there will be blackouts, maybe long blackouts, and we need to stop hoping that the government will do something for us and brothers, as our former said...