they remain ukrainians, they leave ties with their homeland, they send money, they defend the ukrainian position abroad, go to protests and call on the governments of other countries to give weapons to ukraine, this work must be coordinated, and this is a possible joint work of the ministries of foreign affairs, and the mini- ministry of culture, and there may be a third ministry, the ministry of the return of ukrainians, also quite such an interesting story, and i do not rule out that kulebi may have been offered to head this ministry, because it in fact, it will carry out part of the powers that the ministry of foreign affairs currently has, but i know mr. knyazhytskyi's proposal to create a ministry of demographic policy or a ministry of solving the demographic problem, so it's a similar story, let's say, with the return of ukrainians to... . no more

skepticism, because, unfortunately, in a situation where the return of ukrainians depends on many factors, security, economy , housing and everything else, that is, everything that our citizens have now, who were forced to to flee from the war, but when it comes to the ministry of return of ukrainians, well , not in the literal sense of return, ukrainians are already all over the world until... enough, that is , maybe this is the ministry of diaspora or i don't know, but what scares me the most in this story the word ministry, when i imagine that it will sit down, a whole bureaucratic machine will sit down, start stamping these orders, certificates, there is something else and it will return, return, return ukrainians, and the ukrainians will not want to return themselves, well, we will create there prerequisites, we will conduct negotiations there to finally return these ukrainians. we have

many such ministries under which there is actually no large developed infrastructure, even the ministry of strategic industry, despite such a great name, well , in the first years of its existence, i remember, we analyzed the purchases of this ministry, they purchased furniture, cars, that is the activity of the ministry consisted in simply mastering the budgets for salaries and for furniture and for cars, then when kamyshyn already managed the ministry and when the ministry was actually transferred. defense industry department, well , something has already started there, some kind of movement, but to create a superstructure over ukrabronprom simply in order to have an additional voice in the government during voting, ronprom can itself be a ministry, well, this is the main asset of all this, so to create a new ministry, i constantly remember the words of viktor penzenyk, who was both the vice prime minister and the minister of finance,

the minister of the economy, who said that if you if you do not want the country to have no apples, then create a ministry of apples, it is not always fair, it is clear that some ministries are needed, but why create them on every occasion, i think that these ministries that already exist can to deal with the return of ukrainians, simply create conditions, create programs, work, because in fact there are no secrets here. people are afraid to return because bombs and rockets are falling even in the west of the country, we recently saw a tragedy in lviv, and in poltava, er, that is, not even in pre-front territories, we see what problems we have with education, uh, the year began, and a lot of children came to school and saw again that there are no normal shelters, there are no teachers, uh... these are

elementary problems, if we solve them security and quality education, it will be easier if we find money to support families, because many people simply have nowhere to return, there are no bombed-out houses or occupied territories where these people can settle, in other countries they are provided with housing, they are provided with furniture, they are provided with money for clothes, for food, as ukraine can here compete, you have to watch, create special programs. regarding personnel rotations in the government, people's deputy of ukraine yaroslav zheleznyak urges not to look for logic in these personnel rotations. let's listen to what yaroslav zheleznyak said. this is a banal technical replacement of some people in power, well, really from the executive branch of power, with other same people who are from the executive branch of power. all. there is none in this. logic from the fact that

the business card of the minister or his deputy will change, it seems to me that it is unlikely that anything in our system will change, with all due respect to them i absolutely support. there is nothing to say here, there is no logic in this, also because when the changes were announced, it was still, as far as i can remember, when they were changing the staff, in february, they said, and the position of the president was that we are not just changing the head, we will have wide-ranging major personnel changes, and 16 generals were fired then, well , i don't know which generals, but it was about the same as the government. to change everything, everything changes, but we see that these changes have stretched for more than a year, that is, in words and actions, very often there is no unity, that is, if it was absolutely necessary to change some ministers and make qualitative changes in the work, then this should have been done

immediately, that is, when he said in february, i don't like the work of this minister, this one, that one, and not to do from this show, i.e. not to recruit this pool of... nine ministers to change them, and there are also a lot of questions about these ministers, like olga stefanishyna there, colleagues write, yes, colleagues write about this anti-corruption, higher anti-corruption court, on october 3 of this year , the case, which appears now, is being considered the new minister of justice, that is, this is nonsense and looks very, very bad, or the russian relatives of the minister of youth and sports, the poor man, because he is the son-in-law of dashutin , a former people's deputy of ukraine from the party of regions, and he is accused of working on the russian federation in the interests of the russian federation, the military-industrial complex of ukraine, and this is also a big issue, big challenges,

well, very much, and i also want to note about the logic when the minister was removed, when the minister was removed. infrastructure and regional politicians said before kubrakova, they definitely said that they would divide the ministry, and we see that it is not that they were not divided, they even added the ministry of reintegration irynak iryna vereshchyuk, and it turns out that instead of separating the ministry, since it is impossible to just manage with only affairs , the minister simply did not address attention to regional politics was engaged only in the infrastructure. or on the contrary, only regional politics and not infrastructure was involved, here we need to dilute these flows, but we are promised to do it in two, three, four months, and i will also remind you that it was announced, well, it was not publicly announced, but it was announced in the press that there would be

a replacement of the head of the government, so the replacement of the head of the government did not happen, and as my colleagues say, in fact shmagal once again beat everyone and defended himself. to his chair, but he agreed to internal changes, well, they say that he was defended by arahamia, david arahamia, the head of the faction, a servant of the people, but watching these endless divisions and mergers of ministries, over the past 30 years, i cannot understand the logic of this division and its distribution section, then summing up again, then there were state secretaries, and then there was more. there have been a lot of such things for 30 years that this system, in the end, does not work here the way we would like, the way the ukrainians, voters would like, but the way the office of the president would like, it works because it is very profitable , when you have civil

servants on a low salary, there are few of them, they have a lot of responsibilities, and it is easy to fire them, and these people... well, in fact, there are either good people who seek stability and are afraid to simply show some initiative, or people unclean on the hand, and rule over everything, mostly not these people, who are full-time employees, but a bunch of advisers, consultants on grant funds, here by the way, i want to say hello to all our foreign sponsors who support the public service in such a strange way, when money is not given for good reason. salaries of civil servants, which would be logical, for some additional positions that are not fixed in any way in this civil service architecture, which are external, which today are there, tomorrow they are not, they may be super professionals, but all their efforts then go together with

them, and we do not build this institutional memory in this way, changes, the government changes, the sponsor who credits advisers and consultants changes, and everything is lost , all the hard work that has been done. well, do you have the feeling that zelensky is in some kind of... personnel capsule, and in isolation, one might say, and maybe he doesn't see everything, or he doesn't see it the way it really is, exclusively through the prism of these five or six managers, one of them shurma resigned this week from the position of deputy head of the president's office of ukraine, but the same oleg tatarov, the same andriy yermak, the same, now iryna. which goes back there, that is, to what extent

do you think the president is already in the sixth year of the presidency, how much does he understand what is happening and what needs to be done in the state administration? i think that not only the president, but also the president's office and the employees of the president's office are very often biased and are in such an information bubble, that's how we are all in our social networks surrounded by our friends, surrounded, have some circle of communication and receive. not balanced, not balanced, but from these people, including the president, we remember the investigation by bigus-info, when they published analytical reports that are given to the president, transferred to the president's office, about what kind of criticism is broadcast on ukrainian tv channels, and all the negativity that came out there was written that it was all nonsense, the opposition, that is, even when it was not about political criticism, about objective criticism of affairs in the state. for some reason this analytical contour, which, by the way, is connected with one of the deputies of the servants of the people, it is

painted as a proist position, that is , any criticism in the office of the president is perceived in this way as non-constructive, political, politically colored in the first place, and therefore they do not react to it, or even worse, it happens that they do the opposite, we see very often, as journalists already ask questions to the president at a press conference, why are you holding? oleg tatarov is in office despite the fact that there are a lot of questions for him, and the president reacts to this quite emotionally, and as a result, it seems to me, the entire effect of his press conference, and with these statements about tatar, tatarov is not mentioned, because he actually said a lot of important things there, but everyone remembered only about tatarov, who killed chechens in kyiv. it is still not clear what it was,

the president's reaction was quite sharp, and she simply extinguished everything that was the main thing at this press conference. well, in principle, we will monitor how events will develop with those nominees who were appointed and who were appointed by the president of ukraine, the verkhovna rada voted, the only thing what i listened to today. stream on natali mysiychuk's channel, where serhiy leshchenko talked about the fact that iryna vereshchuk is a super professional, and her return to the office of the president is actually a promotion, he said, well, that is, from the position of vice prime minister and minister, the office of the president , promotion, but he said one thing there that absolutely answers why such personnel appointments. because since february 24 , 2022, she was next to the president, that is, she

did not leave the office anywhere, and this loyalty and this sense of the elbow just becomes decisive when determining who is in which position. it seems to me that it is obvious that we need no longer a government of national unity, we need a government of national salvation, in the situation. that has developed today, in general, i am not only talking about the military, but also about the socio-economic situation, we see a budget deficit, we see problems that force us to raise taxes, and it would be a logical decision to create a technocratic government from the best specialists that are in this country, regardless of their political views, but we see that the logic of appointments is completely different precisely because personal devotion to the president and lack of political ambitions. in those who are appointed, and what, that, how it is communicated

by serhiy leshchenko and other agitators of the president, well, sometimes, it seems to me, too like that, even too sweet, we remember serhiy leshchenko as a very sharp journalist -investigator in his time, and when he chose for himself the path of being a politician, well, i hoped that he would be like that... also a sharp whistleblower, a sharp critic, but with this president and with this government, he is their lawyer. er, i hope not a lawyer the devil, er, but, er, sometimes his arguments, er, well, how, at least, er, can be questioned. friends, i would like to remind you that we are working live, we are conducting a survey throughout our broadcast and we are asking you the following: do you expect the work of the government to improve after the replacement of nine ministers? yes,

no, everything is quite simple on youtube. if you have your own opinion, a separate opinion, how? goes beyond the limits of an unequivocal answer, please write in the comments under this video. unfortunately, bohdan butkevich did not join our broadcast, although it was announced in this program, i immediately apologize to our viewers. well, if you watch us on tv, vote on 0800, 211, 381, if you expect the government to improve after nine ministers are replaced, no 0800 211 382. another thread is short enough but... i hope it important for everyone, directly, who is watching us now, and for all ukrainians, this is what is happening in the energy sector of ukraine, as a result of the russian shelling, denys shmyhal, the prime minister of ukraine, stated that russia is already preparing new attacks on

ukraine's energy sector. let's listen to what the prime minister said. if the situation is... fixed as it is now, then we will get through the winter, we can get through without blackouts, but we understand that the enemy will not give us such luxury, just live peacefully, their terrorist and genocidal policy will continue, we we already know, intelligence data that the next massive missile and drone strikes on our energy system are being prepared, well, accordingly, we have already lost 9 gw, for understanding, this is half the volume consumption. of electricity before the war, it is obvious to our viewers that it is not clear how many gigabytes there are 9, 10 or 20 gigawatts, it is clear that our energy system, which was in principle built centrally and then was privatized, corporatized, this entire energy system, it is now vulnerable, and

it is clear that in the current situation the language must be maintained. about the need for alternative sources of electricity that can provide, well , there are solar panels, they will not provide such in the winter, but, but there are different types of power plants, portable, small power plants, and i just didn't hear about it in shmigel's speech, maybe something is being prepared, something the government is planning to do, because , well, hoping that the russians won't ... shell us, well, there's no point, because the main argument of putin and russia is the terror of the civilian population, and bringing this civilian population to such a state that its people will go out into the streets and say: listen, let's have some peace, because it's cold, because there is no light, because not all ukrainians are they will do it, but part of it

ukrainians will do it, which scenario looks to you, well... the most realistic during the next six months, because it is just the beginning of winter and winter itself. i think there will be problems, of course, there will be blackouts, possibly long blackouts, and we need to stop hoping that the government will do something for us and take, as our former prime minister said, that shovel in our hands, and nasky do... is led to provide heat to your family yourself if you have the opportunity to purchase a battery that lasts that can hold electricity for hours, then buy it, if you can’t, cooperate with neighbors who have such a battery and so that you can come there, for example, to warm up in winter, if there is

an opportunity to install a solid fuel boiler in a private house, arrange it, buy firewood, well... . i think that we need to save ourselves, not to hope that shmegel will bring warmth and light to our houses. i hope that the russians will not bomb our gas storages and gas distribution points, and at least those who have gas will be able to heat themselves, but there are also you remember, autonomous gas stoves and the ability to heat the house. well, you need to insulate yourself, you need to get used to living not at a temperature of +25 in the house or plus +20, but perhaps like our westerners. partners sometimes keep the temperature at +15 at home and it is normal, well, in the same germany, and in the same germany, in britain, it is a common story that

it is very expensive to light a fire in the house, then it enters in the clothes, in the house, we can do that they are not used to it yet, but you have to be ready for that, and if you have the opportunity to move from the 20th-30th floor, if you live in a big... place somewhere lower, because the elevators are unlikely to work, then move, if you can buy a generator, buy a generator, you have to think about yourself, and i think that we are unlikely to reach shmygel, or mr. herman hlushchenko, and the minister of energy, but here it is easier to reach your mayor, your village head, the head of a territorial community and... and local authorities should act here, especially since local budgets are not so poor after decentralization, and mayors and deputies of city-regional councils are

all elected well people, they hope, i think still to be re-elected when the elections will be held after the war, so you can turn to your deputies and ask for them, and what has been done to prepare for winter, that is, i urge you to start with yourself and... go back to your deputies and mayors, well and we must remember that our neighbors are close to us, he will be there for a long time, and here we must also understand that in this history, and our politicians must seriously talk to the ukrainians, explain everything to them, because russia will not go anywhere if it does not collapse or for some pieces there, and they will still have it, even if will be frozen. conflict and the war will stop for some time, they will still have the option of shelling the territory of ukraine until we are members of

the north atlantic alliance and we do not have the umbrella of nato, and this must also be understood that no matter what we do now and no matter how no matter where we moved, we always have to remember that russia is next to us, and i was born and raised in the sumy region, that is, 30 km from suja. from kursk oblast, about 35, and we sometimes lived with them all our lives, and of course, this is a different life, it was in ukraine, and in russia, it was visible in the wealth, in the estates, in everything, eh, and now i understand that this is the minus of the fact that this neighbor is nearby, because they are nearby and shelling the places where i grew up, where i was born, they shot at my school with kababs, and i understand that the whole

of ukraine is in the same, approximately, the same situation now, because their weapons allow you to hit all over the territory of ukraine, and therefore, dear friends, dear ukrainians, you must be patient, it is necessary, as andrii rightly said, to take care of oneself, one's families, that's why that a difficult winter is ahead, shmigel says that it is not known how we will get through this winter, although we can get through everything quite normally, i do not believe that we can get through the winter quite normally, i also do not believe that that our top-level politicians are afraid to tell the unpleasant truth, we remember how we were not told that there would be a full-scale invasion, how until the last they were told that there would be barbecues in may, and we remember how they are telling us now about cache'. back and about free food in schools for schoolchildren, but not about bad news for us like to report, we will talk about both good and bad news, because we

work on the espresso tv channel. friends, we are finishing our program, thank you to andriy for participating in the program, it was andriy yanitskyi. friends, let's look at the results of the survey that we conducted throughout our broadcast, do you expect the government to improve after the replacement of nine ministers, 3%, 97%. no , 3% only believe, we put an end to this with faith in the future and with faith in ukraine, it was the program verdict about her serhiy rudenko, before hello, congratulations, we are looking for this boy, his name is oleksiy koltsov, he is ... years old and he went missing in the city of henichesk, kherson region. this happened on february 24, 2023. genichesk is temporarily occupied, so find out

more. disappearance of oleksiy is currently not possible, but we really hope that we will be able to find the boy with your help, so please look carefully at the photo of oleksiy, look into his face. maybe you know something about him, maybe you know where he might be now, or if you have information about his relatives, acquaintances or friends, then do not delay and immediately notify us on the hotline of the child tracing service. by number 11630. calls from all mobile operators in ukraine are free. it is also very important to share the video about the search for oleksiy on social networks. so please repost this program on your facebook or instagram. it's the least you can do to help find the boy. let's not be indifferent, and let's try together to find 15-year-old oleksiy. of course. it is possible that the guy

may still remain in the temporarily occupied territory, and if this is indeed the case, of course, the search process will be significantly complicated, but even in such a situation, we have hope that this video, at least on the internet, will be seen in the occupied part of the kherson region. we understand that it is problematic to call ukrainian-controlled territories from the occupation. moreover, people are afraid, and it is understandable. so, if you are in... occupation, but know at least something about oleksiy koltsov? please at least write to us on the children's tracing service website or the service's chatbot search for children in telegram. we guarantee your anonymity and urge you not to remain indifferent to the fate of the boy. we are also looking for this little girl, whose name is amina dorokhova. five-year-old amina also disappeared in the kherson region. it happened on

november 17. in 2022, the last time the girl was seen in the city was a naked pier. actually , just like in the first story, due to the fact that the child disappeared in the occupied territory, unfortunately, almost nothing is known about the circumstances of the disappearance. therefore, in such situations , the hope of witnesses, people who could somewhere, is very high see the missing child, do they know about him or his family, at least some information. therefore, i ask everyone who sees this video to be careful. look into amina's face. please let us know any known information about the girl. you can do this by dialing the short number 11630. this is the magnolia child tracing hotline, which is open 24 hours a day. you can also write to the chatbot of the children's search service in telegram. all in all, after the full-scale invasion, we got a lot of wanted calls and the vast majority of boys and

girls disappeared precisely during the occupation. of course, for obvious reasons, the search process in territories not controlled by ukraine is extremely difficult. however, general advice if you have a missing child in occupied territory is this: if possible, contact the police or magnolia children's tracing service by any means available and report the child's disappearance with any information you know that may assist in the search. collect data about the child, write down his full name, date of birth, circumstances. and place of disappearance. of course, if possible, find it photos of the child and tell about his special signs and circle communication. in the future, follow the instructions of the police or child tracing service hotline consultants. magnolia. i also ask everyone who sees us to go to the website of the child tracing service. if you recognize any of these boys and girls, please immediately call

our hotline at number 116. calls from all mobile operators in ukraine are free. we have created a resource thanks to which you can report any crime against a child. in any place, in any time. just go to the site and report, and we will launch all possible mechanisms to punish the criminal. stopcraim.ua. exclusively on the air of our channel, congratulations friends, the politclub program is on the air on the espresso tv channel. the most relevant topics of the week: nato member countries, huge arsenals, russia is on the verge of exhausting its resources, topics that resonate in our society, this is the question of trump's victory, what it is, an analysis of the processes that change the country and each of.. .