poor experts, this is because then you can direct the financial flows in a different way, because otherwise i can’t understand, if i don’t understand anything, i don’t understand anything from me, they tell me what to do with energy, i go to kucherenko , i go to x, y, z and ask, since i'm not a specialist, i'm a lawyer, i don't know, well, how is this boss, and they tell me, i need to make bags like this here, make them here, how much does it cost? 3 billion, okay, i go to the cabinet, say give 3 billion, they give me 3 billion, i do it, and it's fast, and it's more half reliably and so on, if this is not done, it means that it is profitable for someone, personally, no, you know, here the thing is that the money for all these construction works is written off and... they are put into the shadows,

there are no doubts , this is a classic of ukraine, not only on shelters, but also on fortifications, there is a large construction site, and in any regional center a hospital is currently being built, or a stadium, 30% there, well, i guarantee you, there somewhere the security forces share with contractors and with the authorities , the security forces must be there, mykola, of course, they check, they do yes, first, then they will get their, they will get their piece of this pie, but here... the main question is, even if you steal, or earn, as they convince themselves, that 30% kickbacks, you can normally make it protect , so they can’t even do that, you see, now about the experts, knock it out, it’s very simple, when there is a powerful energy company, it generates a very large multi-billion dollar flow, necessarily any manager around him at the expense of these kickbacks, you understand , there he has under control huge funds, he... creates a pool

of his experts, he receives a lot of money from them, they pay you 5-10 00 per dollar, not hryvnias, you for a month, you understand, and all these experts are starting, well, to become more active, here they are now and became more active, but now this scandal will not go anywhere in the near future, what kudoritsky signed before his dismissal, because he signed such that now those who are being dismissed, well, the company's employees, they can receive 12... monthly salaries as a bonus and that now it will be yesterday the head of the press service resigned, 2.5 million hryvnias, she took with her bonuses, bonuses, you know, she took them for this, they are now withdrawing the salary fund, i guarantee you, and it will be a very big scandal, because for this we will have to increase transmission tariff, here i am predicting for you, if not, i apologize, but this is the near future, so do not pay attention to... so-called experts, do not read

bolshevik newspapers, in this situation it is better to listen to official information and demand from the authorities officially , according to the law, with responsibility procedures, so i thank you very much, thank you very much oleksiy kucharenko, people's deputy of ukraine, first deputy chairman of the committee on energy and housing and communal services, added a little optimism, we will not freeze in winter, and there is even a suspicion. that something might happen, that there will be a little less stealing, i don’t believe much, but a little maybe, it would be a good idea, we continue to collect ours, the collection for our soldiers, we need funds for drones and a charging station for the reconnaissance of the third regiment of special operations forces, you have it means which are located in the vicinity of the time of the soldier in donetsk region, uavs will help improve the performance of combat missions, that is, kill more russians and destroy more of their equipment and equipment

and save more lives of ukrainian defenders. donat will increase the effectiveness of all that i have listed. the goal is uah 890,000. you see the details on the screen, please join, and we are counting on you. now we will have a five-minute story, then the same five-minute advertisement. personnel rotations, we will discuss in the plot. what was called, what was appointed, it's all in we will be in the story, and then advertising, and then about intelligence, because yesterday was just the day of military intelligence, about that, well, as always , intelligence officers talk quietly, so story, advertising, intelligence, this is our agenda, rumors about reshuffles they have been in the cabinet of ministers almost since the beginning of the summer, you talked about them... and every time they were asked in

the offreks, the reason for this was either the inefficiency of government officials, or their participation in corruption scandals, and even elementary ones. stability in the cabinet. as of the beginning during the week, five departments did not have permanent heads. the decision to reboot has been announced and postponed. and so in a circle. march brought a wind of change to the verkhovna rada. almost unexpectedly, six ministers and one high-ranking official submitted their resignations at once. oleksandr kamychyn and olga stefanishyna were released from the first attempt. ruslan strilets and denys malyusika, rostyslav shurma was also hit by ope. the release of iryna voreshchuk, vitaly koval, and dmytro kuleba was not successful the first time, but it was the second this was preceded by an evening meeting

of the servant of the people faction, which was attended by the president himself for the second time since the beginning of the full-scale war. and if the coalition contributed to the reboot, then... the opposition did not catch either the logic of the rotation or the lack of explanations. i invite everyone to support this, let's say, flash mob, to teach ministers to respect the parliament that appoints them. we can't get up and leave. we work because we are part of this country, we have to work as parliamentarians, and they don't even think it's necessary to come and say what they did. to the halls of the parliament did show up with the final speeches. myshchin, malyuska, koval and vereshchuk. everyone was met with a standing ovation and still for some reason they were released. i solemnly swear allegiance to the ukrainian people, i undertake to abide by the constitution of ukraine and the laws of ukraine, to strengthen the sovereignty and independence

of ukraine, to defend the rights and freedoms of man and citizen, to take care of the welfare of the ukrainian people, and the sustainable democratic development of society. yes, in just one session day, nine. government departments received new ones leaders andriy sebiga became the minister of foreign affairs, previously he was the first deputy of dmytro kuleba. olga stepanishyna, now the deputy prime minister for european and euro-atlantic integration, minister of justice. her resignation was formal in order to combine the two portfolios. oleksiy kuleba took the post of deputy prime minister for reconstruction and minister of development. ma and territory. oleksiy himself came to the cabinet from op. matvii bidny secured a position for himself and is now not temporarily, but permanently, the head of the ministry of youth and sport the new minister of environmental protection and natural resources, formerly the deputy

minister of energy, svitlana grynchuk. the ministry of culture and strategic communications now has a permanent head. the position was taken by a diplomat and a deputy. mykola tochytskyi. nataliya kalmykova, formerly umirov's deputy, is now the minister of veterans affairs. vitaly kovel, who headed the state property fund on the morning of the appointment, was appointed to the position of minister of agrarian policy and food. herman smetanin became the minister of affairs strategic branches of industry. he is a new man, at the age of 31 he headed ukroboron prom. at the faction of the servants of the people, the president talked about the creation of a new of the ministry of return of ukrainians, and he is not there yet, as the issue with the head is open. it is very important that government institutions now work as actively as possible, even more actively than before, at all levels. thus, in just two days, the cabinet was updated

by almost half, but the head of government surprisingly turned out to be the strongest player, because it was his dismissal that was discussed on... more actively and they even placed bets on successors, and denys shmygalyu in the whirlwind of rotation stood and continues to be the record holder for the longest tenure among all the heads of the government of independent ukraine. it is certainly too early to judge the effectiveness of the new composition of his team, but the president, as well as the entire nation , has a lot of demands and results for the renewed cabinet, at least the head of state. expected already in autumn. the sudden resignation of a minister is not the first during the tenure of volodymyr zelenskyi, but it is certainly the biggest reshuffle of the government since the beginning of the full-scale russian invasion of ukraine, and the tradition remains unchanged. officials leave without the procedure of reporting

to the ministers and explaining the reasons for dismissal, but those who have not yet died of scandals and still continue to work for the good of the country. now i have a toothpaste that does more. lacquer active++ with plus active ingredients, i use. to overcome gum problems and bad breath. lacalot activ+ with two-phase technology. actively overcomes bleeding gums and gives fresh breath. lakalut active plus - action that you feel immediately. fm. galicia listen to yours. tingling, numbness or

crawling of ants in the limbs arise spontaneously and worry you. a special complex of active substances of dolgit antineuro helps to normalize the functioning of the nervous system. dolgit antineuro helps to return to usual activities without tingling and numbness in the limbs. capsules dolllid antinevro - help to your nervous system. september discounts on bronchial tubes. 20% in psarynyk, bam and oskad pharmacies. in september, there are discounts on combi mushroom, 20% in pharmacies, plantain, bam and savings. and what do you think about lacalot fix? does it fix reliably? my dentist advised me. yes, and particles of food do not get under the prosthesis. and the price is good, the right choice for my retirement. lacalut fix is ​​a new cream for extra strong fixation of dentures and healthy gums. so, your choice is lacalut fix. there are discounts for sinum in september. 10% in pharmacies along dorozhnyk for your savings. exclusively on the air of our

channel. congratulations, friends, the politclub program is on the air on the espresso tv channel. the most relevant topics of the week: nato member countries have huge arsenals, and russia is already on the way to depletion of resources. topics that resonate in our society. that's the question. analysis of the processes that change the country and each of us, what else can the russians do, are they able to use, say, the resources of the lukashenka army allied with them, vitaly portnikov and the guests of the project, read it, accept it, thank you, it was difficult, but i was just curious, but this is absolutely not true, they help to understand the present and predict the future, they offered the united states to conclude with us'. a project for those who care and think politclub every sunday at 20:00 at espresso.

sakerzonnya is a lost homeland. berehy horishni - the former boykiv village on january 1 , 1939, 790 people lived in the village, 750 of them ukrainians. on the 12th. in june 1946 , the ukrainian population was forcibly deported to the ussr. creative: a vanished ukrainian village on the banks of the sian river. in 1939, 960 residents lived in the village, 900 were ukrainians. in 1947, as part of the vistula operation, the residents were evicted, and the village was burned down. yablinky is an ancient ukrainian village in the mountain ranges of the western biskids. in the village by state in the 38th year, 600 people lived there, 562 of them ukrainians, part of a part of it was deported to the ussr to the north of poland, the village ceased to exist. in total,

there are more than 800 villages and towns with a ukrainian population in the republic of poland. almost 700,000 ukrainians were deprived of their small homeland, forever. verdict with serhii rudenko, from now on in a new, two-hour format. even more analytics, even more important topics, even more top guests: foreign experts, inclusion from abroad. about ukraine, the world. front society, and also feedback, you you can express your opinion on the evil of the day with the help of a telephone survey, turn on and turn on, the verdict with serhiy rudenko, from tuesday to friday from 20 to 22. cheers again, you see behind my back, a subtle hint that yesterday was the day of military intelligence of ukraine, we congratulate all scouts, we love scouts, we hear,

we know about their work, we just don't know any details, because sometimes they say that it doesn't explode just like that, and here in ukraine something doesn't just explode and something is happening somewhere in africa, such a miracle, an amazing miracle, well, it’s all very interesting and pleasant, we invited... mr. vadym chernysh, head of the sens security research center, minister of ukraine for the issues of temporarily occupied territories of internally displaced persons, you already you see and i wish him good health, mr. vadim, thank you for joining us. mr. vadim once defended his thesis on intelligence, what we know about, so we will need it today, and i have the following question for you, the first tricky question, mr. vedimo, this is richard moore mi6, who runs, that is , the head of intelligence in britain, there is one in william

burns, who runs the cia, they literally became known yesterday, they... crowded it was such a week financial times in london , and they got together, first printed in ft, here in this newspaper a huge article under two signatures, this is the first time in the history of development, in general in the history of civilized humanity, that two major intelligence officers of the world jointly signed an article, and then also in london and met and sat down on the panel and sat and explained to people what was happening in the world in the sense of intelligence, this... they greeted me in such a cunning way, because it all happened yesterday, the day before yesterday and the day before yesterday, with ukrainian intelligence with their presence in london, it was them if they waved a pen, we remembered you we know that you have a holiday, dear ukrainian intelligence officers, or is it just a coincidence, mr. mykola, i hope so, but to be serious, britain and the united states

have also extended the agreement between them indefinitely. well, practically an ally, and that's why i want it to remind that the american and british intelligence are such participants of the so-called five eyes, that is, five pairs of eyes, that is, this association where information is exchanged almost automatically by five intelligence agencies, and they have powers that are quite serious, no one in the world cannot compare with them, and of course there, no matter how much russia wanted, and china did not... want, but so far there are no such opportunities, this is the first, secondly, uh, these two intelligence agencies are in principle very actively helping ukraine, and the heads of these intelligence agencies personally, and the institutions themselves, so i think that these are the biggest intelligence partners , some of the biggest that we've ever

had, they're the closest sister organizations to us, in my opinion, i think it's either...whatever you like, and i'll just tell the audience, it's nova zealand, australia, the united states, canada and britain, these are five eyes, these are five states, and if you look at a map, better at a globe than at a map, you will see that they shoot their curious interests all over the world. new zealand, australia - this is the pacific ocean, this is the indian ocean ocean, it's obviously china, it's japan, it's india. they are such serious players, well britain is europe and latin america, so all of europe and africa, and obviously it's all involved, and they have the best analysis, given that they cover the whole world. i have the following question for you then, i saw such, as our russian brothers say, disorganized, these

two chief scouts put ukraine first. the problem, as far as i understood, was also put on the first, and the revival of the islamic state, and already the second, china, politicians usually say that china is a big problem, at least american politicians, and european politicians, and the american european intelligence people that you see say, no, no, no, the main issue is russia, its not... security , her war, her absolutely insane behavior, what do you say? china is estimated to be in the medium-term, long-term perspective, that is, it is gaining weight gradually, gradually, gradually, but it does not create the kind of crises that it creates, the so -called immediate crises, yes, that it creates russia, russia created this so-called crisis, well

, so-called, it's a war, but it entails a lot of consequences, that's why it's now called an emergency, right? an urgent challenge that needs to be solved, but it can also affect long-term plans, that is, it unites the so-called authoritarian regimes, it is not just words, that is, look now, they are helping, they are helping, they are helping, china is helping or trying to help, that is why now is a critical moment not only for ukraine itself, but intelligence officers are talking about it, analysts are talking about it, it can the whole configuration in the world is not only there, as we... used to say the crisis of the international system there after the second world war, this is all correct, but it can create a completely different configuration of the so-called distribution of power or distribution of power. and when we approach the so-called power politics, that is, the politics of power, and not these multilateralisms, all these agreements, when a small country is equal to

the voice of a small country is equal to the voice of a large country, this can all change very much, who has more power, in the more rights the distribution of zones of influence, the third option, not always war, but such subversive operations, so of course they talk about it. but in the long term, that is, in the medium and long term, no one predicts that russia will gain weight, on the contrary, they predict that it will be a so-called declining power, that is, a power that goes down, and china will increase its power, look, well, intelligence and space, and electronic, and such, and such, but no one canceled the agency, when i think about it, this is also such a half-joking question, but... but there is only part of the joke, when i think about agent intelligence of the people's republic of china, well, i need this in order to become a spy for china, well, i have

to do this, i guess, yes, well, because spies, they have to somehow look like locals, and the chinese definitely don't look like locals even in russia, if they will pretend to be buryats, for example, then they can pass as locals, that is, how powerful can china be in general... in intelligence, to what extent, or will they simply recruit the same russians, europeans, americans, canadians and pay money , and they will already be something to rummage through secrets, say something about this, please, yes and yes, let me remind you that president trump, when he was the acting president of the 45th, well, he remains so, but during his period of rule, he is just spoke about the fact that many chinese who were educated or are being educated in the united states... the high-tech industries that are there, in which many people from china work, are precisely the main target for the penetration of the chinese intelligence services, for

obtaining scientific and technical information , or so-called technological secrets, that is the first story, that is, these are natives or people connected in one way or another with china, this is the first, then the possibility of using other... people, as you said, there are russians, or people of other nationalities, who can usually work either in chinese companies or to chinese companies or in representative offices of these companies controlled by the government of the people's republic of china, well, or the people's republic of china, if completely, so such opportunities still remain with them, moreover, i want to tell you that a very large part of russians who, well, or rather, several russians... who manufactured these missiles, zircon, dagger, there and so on, just now arrested, for giving secrets to china itself, that's why chinese intelligence

works, and it's just that, well, style, culture, some features, they don't allow us to master completely, but well, for example, i want to say and remind that the people's republic of china wanted to buy a motorcycle in our country through various persons. january is also unknown there, when i came to zaporizhzhia, to zaporizhzhia in particular, i stopped in front of donbass, i stayed in one of the hotels, everything was in chinese there languages, i.e. chinese magazines were lying there, there was a calendar with chinese watches, so this suggests that the influences remain, this is business, this cover is diverse, especially due to the global nature of the activities of such huge chinese companies. that is , there are opportunities for both technical and agent intelligence without any doubt, moreover, bill burns said about this that he considers the chinese intelligence agencies to be

among the most powerful. now about russia and about what we will be pleased to hear, these two great gentlemen, very to, they are serious people, they are not people like mykola veresen, they are not joking, they are no joke, but they said that in russia, not for good, russia hires bandits, criminals in europe, because simply their networks are cut quite actively, and therefore they are forced to turn to mafias, well, that is , these are all official russian intelligence centers, they turn to the mafia, simply to hooligans, to bandits, to criminals, but help us blow something up there, that... lay down and so on, that is, we can talk about enough a serious crisis or decline, because that's what the cia and misx are talking about

these are already people who... don't throw words to the wind, but they say that they have a big problem with the russians and it's not them, they don't have networks anymore, can you confirm that? there are still networks left, i am convinced of this, and not only me personally, but there is a whole analytical selection of materials that say that russian networks remain, the only thing that is changing now is the opportunities of the russians really for the worse, because all diplomats who were under cover, well not all, almost all identified, are expelled, and those diplomats who still remain in status diplomats, although they may be, half of them are known, half are unknown, they work for various intelligence agencies of russia, they want to deny them the opportunity to move outside the country of residence, that is, the opportunity to cover work under the roof of international organizations , well, for example, vienna, there they are or geneva, well, switzerland, where there

are these international un organizations, there are various international federations, there is an opportunity to hide, of course it is difficult to work there, but constantly, constantly, russians are pressed there, that is why they change work models, well, for example, several, we have already talked about this before, several cases of detention in the international criminal court, recently in slovenia, who were exchanged, natives from latin america, supposedly, that is... it is easier to get corrupt documents there, to convert a place in the cemetery, as if someone from a distant relative is buried there, that is, to create a legend, there are fewer opportunities for cooperation than in western countries, so they try to enter through other regions of the world, but this is a long, painstaking work, and well, it’s not all that fast is being adjusted, therefore, of course, the capabilities of their

e... are significantly undermined by the activities of western special services and to and governments that limit diplomatic cover there, but this does not mean that ukraine does not remain there, mr. vadim, ukraine, it, well, how to say , has grown in the intelligence sense during the war years, it has become something more, that is , attention is already being paid to it, it is being consulted, or is it all that... a secondary country in the world, which, well, how, what was it before the 14th, even more so, until the 22nd year. well, it should be divided into two components. the first component is opportunities for gathering information, such technical opportunities, well, for example, if 60-65 pieces of intelligence information are collected there, for example, they are collected through technical means, well, for example, the united states, the states, yes, then we have such opportunities there is no that's why we speak. about

the possibilities of collecting information at the expense of other sources, first of all agency intelligence, is really not a bad school, but to say that it is very, very difficult to evaluate successes in the short term, so this is the first component of information collection, such a large component, here we are not we can for now, and analytical processing of them too, well sometimes, to be honest, its strategic dimensions are weaker, but in relation to the operations of certain operations. so here it is really ukrainian intelligence, well, on the territory of the enemy, the russian federation, here it is really ukrainian intelligence that demonstrated several such, well, let's say, ukrainian intelligence agencies and the security service, which in principle is not quite an intelligence agency, not an intelligence agency at all, has certain functions there, they demonstrated really very, well, let's say so, cool operations on russian territory

operations and in this dimension, of course, that such operations are to a certain extent a method of conducting them, a method of training personnel for conducting them, of course, it arouses a certain interest among representatives of the intelligence community of western countries, so i think that it is, well, intelligence agencies, as in in principle, the armed forces have grown, but this does not mean that we are there now, well... everything, everything, well , the budgets cannot be compared, yes, the intelligence community, the community of america receives 83, 86, more than 80 billion dollars a year, so of course we cannot compare with with such finances, so does masat, so do other bodies, so of course, what to compare, well, from the limited resources we have, well, we have to give credit there...