then this is something that can somehow, at least a little bit , establish a balance with the russians, and in principle, well, i know, we have been talking about it for a long time, of course, i will not reveal the secret here, that it is not something that i invented there, our the negotiators there don't talk, they talk, but for some reason, i still think that in this matter we could act creatively, well, more creatively, in order to bypass this inflexibility. political position, and now, i think it will be difficult to see it until election day, and i think that even before election day in the united states in november, well, i think that with in the first days of november there, after the fifth, we simply saw the use of this type of partner rockets, now the question is how many, right here, not only the quality , the range, but the quantity, and by the way, germany, taurus, what are the arguments?

chancellor scholz will then have to keep these missiles, that is, it seems to me that this is all a political decision, it is overdue, and in fact we will find out sometime in november, the month of application. the european parliament turned to ukraine's western partners and asked and urged them to immediately lift restrictions on strikes of western weapons of ukraine in the russian federation, speaker of the state duma of the russian federation. and once again threatened the west with nuclear weapons. let's listen to what he said. just think about what they are discussing. they discuss the tasks of strikes on our peaceful cities. in addition, they discuss, believing that it will not affect them. this is not so. we will answer. and we have

something to answer, more powerful weapons are ready. mr. valeriu, they have been announcing their powerful, more powerful weapons for so long, but judging by what the director told cia burns, about how he communicated with naryshkin in '22, at the end of '22, and warned the russians about the consequences of using nuclear weapons. regarding ukraine, because such a threat was, as burns said, do they clearly understand in the kremlin what, what the consequences will be of the use of nuclear weapons, whether tactical or strategic, any, and how it will end for the current regime in russia? they understand everything perfectly, don't listen to what volodin is saying there or from the podium of the state duma, this is an internal messenger for... for them, there is a king, there is

oh boyar, but there are serfs, and serfs have to live in this sense, there are so many lies fed to the serfs that they can’t believe it, russia will not use any strategic missiles, it is obvious, for two reasons, firstly, russia’s potential is incomparable with the potential of the usa, together with britain there or, well, if it were comparable, everyone says that it will all be destroyed there, in fact, russia knows that they fly like that, not that the missile itself will be fired once in a while, but what about the charges , they don't know at all, although, you know, these bots are coming at me, when i comment that russia has not conducted nuclear tests, tests, but i state once again that, unlike the united states, which found a way to test without an actual explosion of a large-scale nuclear warhead, russia does not have such technology, and therefore russia does not have normal you...

nuclear weapons, without a normal test , no country will use nuclear weapons, except at such a moment, when hundreds of warheads are flying at you there, only at this moment it is already desperate, in another situation it will not be used, this is the first, second, why would they to use nuclear weapons, if they blew up the tile, that is, flooded it man-made with huge consequences, well, operationally, also an operation, then they have a ... station under control, which is constantly under threat, we do not know this, but there is constantly specialists know, the situation sometimes looms, then decreases, and when they hit our transformers at nuclear power plants, which then endanger the normal operation of nuclear power plants, in the crimea, if the west, the crimean titan, or whatever it is called there now, it is also a dangerous object, we had it in 1700 before... well, the russian invasion of 17

such dangerous objects on our territory, yes, why should they, they first of all think about how to use it. in fact, not nuclear weapons, which they are constantly loading there, that is, nuclear weapons are for china, they have a balance, it is for another, but it is definitely not for this war, and the second thing is that they know that if only they will do, at least one tactical charge will be used there, that's it, they, them, they are over, they are over, putin knows it, that is, they do not have such comparable forces in order to stand up to that kind of confrontation, they 've been warned, so... i think the threat is nuclear, it's in the course of the war as we see it now, it's not something that doesn't exist, it exists, but the way it's being inflated, eh out of fear, you know, in fact, the paradox is that russians have died now, i would say,

ten times more than russians, only, only the military, only those who entered our land. ten times more than would be killed by several tactical nuclear warheads. you realize they just aren't explain to their people, people do not know on what scale they are being killed there, so we need to give more information, not to follow their line, partners to explain the situation, i would now pay more attention to objects such as the zaporizhzhia nuclear plant, which are captured by the russians , this is a real threat. well, by the way, president zelenskyi congratulated today. the resolution of the magathe, which confirms the need for ukraine to restore full control over the zaporizhzhia nuclear power plant and the withdrawal of russian troops and personnel from this plant, he reminded that nuclear security and the first point of the formula for peace,

i will quote president zelensky: "i am glad to see that today's resolution of the general conference of the magats" contributes to these important efforts, only thanks to collective determination and... typical actions we will be able to force the aggressor to stop blackmail and terror," he wrote zelensky on the social network x. mr. valery, does the resolution oblige the magathe to react to russia and can the magathe apply to russia and to rosatom, in particular, any sanctions, because we know that russia is building a lot of nuclear power plants around the world and no one... so far has not applied any sanctions against rosatomu, if i am not mistaken, there are one or two cases of personal sanctions against rosatomu, but you are right that rosa somehow feels very comfortable in this situation, and the reasons for not applying sanctions

against rasatom - this is not magate, let's be fair, here are the decisions of many countries, including european countries, and the usa, by the way, as well, and this surprises me. because there should have been sanctions on rosat a long time ago, now with regard to magathe, they are adopting such a resolution for the second time, the un also mentioned these question, the magat is a structure of oonivsk, but what is interesting is that mr. grosti always says, it is not a question of the magat to talk about leaving the station, here it turns out that we are at the level of the general conference, that is, it is all announced when 150 members gather. well, 178 are members of the magat, well, 150 have gathered now for the 68th, it seems, general conference in vienna, so everything is fine, the magat can make such statements, and it is our task for ukraine to make as many such statements, resolutions, and fixing documents as possible for two purposes: first, this

a constant process of pressure on the release of the zaporizhia nuclear power plant, because it is in danger due to the occupation now, first of all, and... even the people who work there, the russians were not able to get their own, replace the ukrainians, and there people keep it all by professionals, just so that it doesn't explode, that is, they keep it all, and it's been the third year, so it's all very complicated, that's the question, and the second question is the responsibility later for these crimes, this still needs to be considered and convention on nuclear terrorism, that is all they haven't reached their hands yet, why haven't they? here i will tell you a very good example, the resolution, the president stated, i see, the prime minister stated, everyone made statements, in fact, in fact, this is just an example when the ministry of foreign affairs of ukraine works correctly, we must give credit to mr. tsimbalyuk, he, when he was in vienna, engaged

in this as a representative, and now, when we had an absolutely unjustified pause with the appointment of pospred in vienna, he took it from kyiv and... i think so, the new minister is also visible, he paid attention to these issues , and the work began, a week ago worked there for a week in difficult conditions, i will remind you that there are still elections for another body of the magat, in addition to the general conference, there is still a row of leaders, 11 new countries were chosen, as far as i know, i met with these countries, that is, normal diplomatic work went on, well, i have a big question, if we can do it here, and the ministry of foreign affairs can, why do we have a delegation in the governing council of the magat, which does not cope with its tasks, as we see what can be achieved, why then, well, that's the thing let them decide in the office, the minister of energy is in charge, they go in pairs

times there in vienna, what is the point of this, you know, not that the minister of energy has a task here in ukraine, we have a winter that we do not know how to get through, and vienna is traveling here, the minister of energy, i would first change , well, at least japarova, who is not there today, is no longer working, was replaced by tsimbalyuk in the delegation of the board of governors, and i would still consider the second one based on the results of the work... i would look at replacing the head of the delegation, this is a task that will increase efficiency, here is a concrete example of how they worked well in this in a specific case, but the russians work constantly, with money, the russian representative meets, he has dinner, well, i don’t know, he has dinner there every week, ours can have dinner, talk, maybe only the ambassador, and there is no ambassador, we don’t have a post-predator, that’s why these are simple questions, they... add efficiency and should be resolved, i think that this issue is already overdue,

a diplomat should be in charge of the council, this is the first thing, and now at least giving the representative of the ministry of foreign affairs a representative will help more resources, work opportunities, he tsymbalyuk showed that he can achieve this even from kyiv. mr. valery, the very end of our long conversation, and i would like to show you and the tv viewers a fragment from the interview with the ukrainian truth of the eu ambassador to ukraine kateryna maternova, who will talk about the fact that it is a realistic forecast that ukraine can join the european union before the end of this decade, let's hear what she had to say. i have already said in an interview before, and i will repeat, i believe that the goal set by president michel is the accession of ukraine to the eu by the end of this decade. is realistic yes i believe that this is real, but the accession to the eu, and

this must be realized, is not only a technical process of membership negotiations, which of course also takes time, but it is also a political ratification in all member countries, because the accession a new member means changing the eu treaty, so it must be ratified in the format required by each of the eu countries, and this always takes a certain amount of time, so during the 2004 enlargement, it took about a year and a half, well, that is, mr. valery, six years ahead, if, if ot to proceed from this deadline, that by the end of this decade, six years are for us to go through all the procedures for joining the european union, or whether we will go through it so quickly, given the claims of some of our neighbors on various issues, first, without. .. joining nato or in some way guaranteeing the safety of this umbrella from

russia, there are no further prospects , there is no eu to help this situation, the eu is not involved in this, there are no effective levers in the security sphere, so i look at it calmly, on the contrary, i think that statements of the prime minister, that we have to enter by the end of next year, they sound more threatening to me than what mrs. maternova said. that we have time, because in fact the path to the eu is, i understand, that we accept the rules of the european union, but still there must be some kind of adaptation, our farmers, many of our producers are not ready for this just today, and politically just being in the eu, well, it's important, but when you haven't provided security, it doesn't help, so i look at it calmly, i think that there she is closer to ms. maternova, until the dates, because this is just the budget of the european union. in order for there to be an expansion, the budget must be calculated, you understand, and the 30th year is just tied to the procedures

of the european union, that's all, and what ours declare there, that next year in two years, is well, these are absolutely unrealistic plans, so i am alarmed by the political part, yes, that is, in principle, it is rightly said that there should be ratification, but if it is meant that ukraine unilaterally accepts all political demands, starting with of historical memory, starting with the game, there to give up your heroes, that, or there, as the hungarians demand, something new every time, well , that, you know, that's the kind of blackmail that... uh, we shouldn't give to use the negotiations with the eu on the chapters of accession to the european union as a political tool for our neighbors, i would say so, because mainly they are neighbors, i.e. poland, hungary, i.e. slovakia, we will see all of this, and new ones will come there lira leaders, politics will be, elections will always keep us this way

you know, bait, what do you want in the eu, then let's give it to us. you, you need this, so i would now focus on nato, on security, poest said to our partners, listen, integration into the eu is a two-way street, and let's go, ukraine is in a hurry, taking its time, calmly working on the negotiating table position, we have made political decisions, ukraine will be in the eu, there is a candidate, we will calmly work on the working bureaucratic agenda, and nato... this is an issue that needs to be resolved in this or next year, here is the key question. thank you, mr. valery, for the conversation, it was valery chaly, diplomat, plenipotentiary and extraordinary ambassador of ukraine. friends, we continue to work live on the espresso tv channel. i would like to remind you that throughout our broadcast we conduct a survey and ask you about whether you take seriously the kremlin's nuclear threats against ukraine, forgive me

and ukraine. so, everything is quite simple on youtube, right, and there is also a function to leave your comment on this, that's the first, well, let's see the results of the intermediate television survey 33%, yes, 67%, no. in september, there are discounts on glycyset, 20% in psyllanyk, bam and oskad pharmacies. in march there are discounts on linex forte 15% in pharmacies, plantain, bam and savings. dynamo, lazio only on mego. kyivans are ready to write a new history of the club in the europa league, and it is necessary to start with a victory over the eagles. tune in on september 25 at 10 p.m. exclusively on mego. september discounts on rezi table, 10% in psarynyk, bam and

oskad pharmacies. in september, there are discounts on sudokrem. in pharmacies , plantain, bam and oskad. vasyl's big broadcast winters my name is vasyl zima, this is a big ether on the espresso tv channel. two hours of airtime, two hours of your time. my colleagues and i will talk about the most important thing, for two hours, to learn about the war, about the military, front, component, serhiy sgurets. what does he live for? time to talk about what was happening outside of ukraine, yury, good evening, two hours to keep up with economic news, time to talk about money, during the war, oleksandr morchivka, come with me, and sports news, i invite yevhen pastukhov to the conversation , two hours in the company of our favorite presenters, about cultural news, alina chekchenina, our tv viewer, is ready to talk, good evening, the presenters, who have become

familiar to many, are already next to me, ready to talk about the weather for this weekend, as well as distinguished guests of the studio, mustafa dzhemilov , the leader of the crimean...tatar people is in touch with us, mr. mustafa, i greet you, good day, events of the day in two hours, vasyl zima's big broadcast, a project for smart and caring people, in the evening for espresso. exclusively on the air of our channel. congratulations, friends, on the air the politclub program on the espresso tv channel. the most relevant topics of the week: nato member countries have huge arsenals, and russia already has them. on the approach to exhausting the resources of topics that resonate in our society, this is the question of trump's victory, what it is, an analysis of the processes that change the country and each of us. what else can the russians do, are they able to use, say, the resources of the lukashenka army allied with them. vitaly portnikov and the guests of the project, read everything, accept my song, thank you, it

was difficult, i was just interested, but that’s it absolutely did not eat, they help. gather in the present and predict the future suggested that the united states enter into a bilateral security agreement with us. a project for those who care and think. politclub every sunday at 20:00 at espresso. congratulations, friends, live on the espresso tv channel. part of the verdict program, my name is serhiy rudenko, today is the traditional friday journalism club at espresso, and today we will talk about the following. 100% ready. volodymyr zelenskyi will present his victory plan to the president usa to joe biden already next week. what

surprises can await ukrainians when the content of zelenskyi's plan is also announced to them. a new stage of decolonization. hundreds of settlements received new names without imperial narratives, but there are ... exceptions, how did the parliament become the weakest link in the process of toponymy cleansing of ukraine? servants flee abroad. people's deputy andrii odarchenko, accused of trying to bribe the management of the reconstruction agency, is wanted. why the border remains transparent for the defectors' deputies. that's all and not only we will continue to talk. for the next 45 minutes, i remind you that we are working live on the tv channel, as well as on our youtube and facebook platforms, for those who are currently watching us live on these platforms,

please subscribe to our pages, be sure to like this video in order for it to be promoted in the trends of youtube and facebook, and take part in our survey, today we are asking you about whether you take the nuclear threats of the kremlin seriously, yes no, everything is quite simple on youtube and the answer is... unambiguous, if you have the answers go beyond straight answers please comment below this youtube video if you watch us on tv pick up your smart phone or phone and vote the numbers if you take the kremlin nuclear threats seriously 0800 211 381 no 0800 211 382, ​​all calls to these numbers are free, vote, at the end of the program we will sum up. of this vote, i want to introduce today's guests of our studio, these are my colleagues, journalists, authors and presenters of two youtube-

of the censornet channels and show-bisics, as well as tv journalists and journalists who write and comment a lot on social networks, including on the espresso tv website, maryna danylyuk yarmalayeva and bohdan butkevich, maryno and bohdana, i congratulate you, i am glad to see you you are on the air, congratulations. well, since we are asking our tv viewers whether they take the kremlin's nuclear threats seriously, let's try to answer this question in a blitz poll format, maryn, i don't take them seriously, let's put it this way, if we could, it would have been terrifying somewhere. thank you, bohdan. well, i agree and i think that, considering that for putin, the main task before him , it will simply remain. alive, that is, to remain in power, he perfectly understands that the use of nuclear weapons will greatly accelerate his physical death, but i would say, i absolutely agree with you, and i think

that all these nuclear scarecrows, in principle, are designed more for the western audience, not even to western politicians, and to the domestic audience, but definitely not to the ukrainian audience, because it seems for 10 years of the war and 2.5 years of the great war. russia's invasion of ukraine, they have already tested almost all weapons here, well, except for nuclear ones, so i think that our audience also takes it all not seriously, well, at least in the first part of our program, the results were 37% to 63, that is, a third of the tv viewers took it seriously the nuclear threats of the kremlin, two- thirds do not, well, but less than that, on september 26 in ... the tone, the president will present the plan for the victory of ukraine, and this plan for the victory of ukraine is already fully prepared, we saw this

information, this information support, that there is 90%, then 100%, that there is this plan for victory, let's listen to what zelensky says as a result, and already today. we can say that our victory plan has already been fully prepared, all the points, all the key points, the necessary appendices with details to the plan have been determined, everything has been worked out, the most important thing now is determination, to implement, there is and cannot be any alternative to peace, no freezing of war or any - any other manipulations that will simply transfer russian aggression to another stage. bohdan, is it enough that the ukrainian authorities have communicated about the victory plan, because the western audience learned about this plan from various international publications, which

were mocked there. parts of this victory plan in the ukrainian press were only president zelenskyi's statements, but nothing more. well, you know, if i'm being honest, first of all i'd be interested not even in the opinion of the western audience, but rather the ukrainian one, because i'd like to ask all of us, and you, do we know anything about this victory plan? shame to say we have one a body called the verkhovna rada, i understand, of course, that everyone has already forgotten that it is a parliament in general. and we have a type of parliamentary-presidential republic, among the deputies of this so-called parliament, someone is aware of this victory plan, what is written in it, and so on. that is, look, volodymyr zelenskyi, i will be honest, it makes me angry that this person for some reason believes that if he became the president, it gives him the right to decide something without asking anyone, in such serious matters, unfortunately, we see, i think that there is no plan for victory, there is...

let's say, the plan of some hotels, which vladimir oleksandrovich will most likely not get 100%, after which he will start negotiating with shouts that you see, the damned west is pouring, because excuse me when i see that reuters yesterday, for example, reports about , it turns out that ukraine has already agreed to the supply of azerbaijani gas from our territory since the beginning of the 25th year, we understand that this is not about azerbaijani physical gas, but about russian, to put it mildly, when i saw how ukrainian the government... signs some agreements, for example, about the supply of substation russian oil through ukrainian territory for hungary, it’s just that the hungarians will now formally purchase it at the border with belarus, where the southern branch of the druzhba oil pipeline enters our territory, and you think so, where is the victory plan, what does it consist of, this plan for victory has already begun, or when everyone is satisfied with the whole politician, that these negotiations on behalf of zelenskyi with the russians are being conducted by timur mindich, an unknown character,

former business partner of kolomoi. a person who, how to say, was at one time a chain between the 95th and kolomoisky quarters, and now i understand that he is finally working with vladimir aleksandrovich, you see, that’s why i’m just curious, and the most important thing is not even that, but what the hell is the victory plan there, what’s new can we hear in this plan of victory, give us a nuclear bomb, we will attack moscow or something, i just don’t understand what is new, give us atacoms, are there stormsheds to hit russian airfields, well , yes, i understand, but to think that this is a plan victories, well, i... somehow it was a little, i felt it would be quite strange to demand more sanctions, well, that is, look at what i'm getting at, i don't expect anything new for the simple reason that after almost three years of war, it's difficult, in fact unrealistic, to create anything new, so i'll say frankly, everything volodymyr zelenskyi does, unfortunately, is about pretending, not being, and i really don't like the trends that are happening around all these movements right now, so i 'll be honest, i'm not just

skeptical, i'm really very... in a bad mood as to what all this is for is being done and what will happen next, because excuse me, the story with russian gas, which is right in front of our eyes, is now developing so brazenly that even prime minister shmyhal says that i have no relationship with the ministry before the negotiations, who then he should, tell me who, well, it is a clear matter of the president's office, so you know, it is very interesting to go to america to tell that we will bring a plan for victory, prepare 100%, and we will win tomorrow, and with the other hand, it would be fine to weed.. . to negotiate with them, but to build again the same entanglements on which ukraine burned so many times in my history, well, i don't know what it can be compared to, so sorry, i don't know what a victory plan is, but i know that if andryusha irmak is around, then we have to be very careful of such plans , that's all, i think that in this situation, it should probably be said that the victory plan is without the participants in ukraine's war against russia. no

, well, it is simply impossible to win this victory, and even more so when people who are part of the great people's war of ukraine against russia, are not initiated into this plan of victory, well, there are many questions, and probably the main question is how this victory plan will be implemented without the ukrainians, that is, if they are not told anything, and zelenskyi says that the head is there... they would have the united states of america do their job, well, the question wait, well, the united states of america will do this work, but the united states of america is obviously not saying that ukraine should defeat russia, but they are saying that ukraine should not lose, the question is, stop, and how ukraine can win, and whether it will be clear to joseph to biden, marino.