the war of ukraine against russia, no, well, it is impossible to simply win this victory, and even more so when people who are part of the great people's war of ukraine against russia, are not initiated into this plan of victory, well, many questions arise, and perhaps the main question, in what way will this victory plan be implemented without the ukrainians, that is, if they are not told anything and... and zelensky says that the most important thing is that the united states of america does its job, well, the question is, wait, well, the united states of america will do this job but the united states of america obviously does not say that ukraine should defeat russia, but they say that ukraine should not lose, the question is, wait, how ukraine can win and whether it will be clear to joseph biden , marina? well

, let's start with the fact that not the american military, but specifically our military, those people who were mobilized into the alaf armed forces of ukraine, will hold the gigantic front line that we currently have with the russian federation, this is one, and second , you know, me the fantastic speed with which zelenskyi and his managers write all these peaceful plans for victory is always surprising, we remember that literally last week... antony blinken, david lamy, the head of the british foreign ministry, and the head of the pentagon loyt austin came to kyiv, and from what we read in the western press, they really asked zelensky if he had any realistic plan for victory, because we, well, we understand that this previous peace formula, where zelensky promised barbecues already in the christmas tree, i guess it is for now already unrealistic and... irrelevant, and now

let's count: in just one week , zelensky tells us in the evening broadcasts how he wrote a new victory plan with appendices and information, well, literally the day before yesterday he said that our plan is 90% ready, and now it is 100% ready, that is , excuse me, i write some script or article more carefully, so that it looks conscious and interesting, than zelenskyi and his team write: peace plans for ukraine, and you know, pieces of these peace plans have already begun to appear in the western press, and here, for example, i understand the office of the president that article by yuliyanke in the edition of the build really stirred and outraged, they traditionally have a disclaimer that pain is such a tabloid publication, this is a fake publication, you don’t have to believe it, it’s all fakes, it’s all authors who write such things, it ... pure russian ipso, but

let's remind ourselves that the previous plans for a full-scale invasion of the russian federation were exactly the evils of the publication of the bill, so i will not be surprised if a part of it promises that we will freeze the front line here, combat operations on in certain areas of the front, this is part of the peaceful type of the plan, which is now being actively discussed, but again, as a representative of ukrainian society, an active representative, i really wanted to... hear, and what do we include in the wording of the cessation of hostilities on certain areas of the front? what does this mean? we are demining there, we are following the scenario of 2020-2021, well, everyone remembers, yes, how we demined gold, how volodymyr zelenskyi personally went to the ukrainian military who were stationed there, convinced them that he was no longer a log, that he was better knows he is supreme commander like him addressed, by the way, to our civil borders'.

who lived in that area, don't worry, on the contrary, it will be great that we demined everything, people will not die, and now you are looking back at zelensky's old promises to demine everything, solve it diplomatically with russia, make your own the peace plan is preliminary, and we understand what it turned into, so we wanted to talk about all these peace plans, and if zelensky himself is afraid, then look, he has new promising communication advisers there, he appointed... such an adviser, who in 2010 advised, by the way, ukrainians, the ukrainian authorities, why it is necessary to disband the armed forces of ukraine, it is obvious that the adviser should not buy alcohol in goodwines, by the way, our colleagues often see him there, and go out a little to tell, but what kind of peace plan did bankova prepare for us, so that society would prepare and society would understand, and what awaits us next? with this

commander-in-chief who wants, let's say, the preservation of a certain territory under the control of ukraine, to pass off as a comprehensive victory. a fantastic victory, and i wonder how he justifies the fact that we now have a huge part of territories and people under occupation, i am already silent about the losses we suffered after a full-scale war. this is not yet, as i understand it, in the victory plan, but zelensky was asked about what will happen if this victory plan is not accepted in washington, and whether you have a plan b after this plan a, he said about. .. the fact that ukraine lives in plan b, never had a plan a for winning the war with russia. let's hear what he is said the reporter asked one question and said, what if president biden doesn't support your plan, do you have a plan b? i

answered frankly and absolutely: and we are already in plan b. we live and fight in it. we never had a, because plan a was to prevent... a full-scale invasion, plan a was to arm ukraine and pre-emptively sanction the russian federation so that it would fear even the thought of a full-scale invasion. bohdan, well, zelensky says that ukraine has never been a plan a, although there were plans to protect the country from a full-scale invasion, and they were not... formed even at the beginning of the great war , and obviously these plans were, or if this plan had not been there, probably the russians would have captured the ukrainian state much faster, perhaps in zelenskyi did not have a plan a, but the military had a plan a, or how should we perceive

zelenskyi’s statement that we are already living in plan b, and they say that the plan is something that our allies did not fulfill, i understand, you know, i can not very professional from a journalistic point of view, but i listen less and less to what volodymyr zelensky says, because i have less and less, well, more and more precise impression that - he says completely different things that contradict each other, and you know, it's not even the same story that, for example, there there is some kind of system, he says one thing for some, and another for others, i will not speculate on the adequacy or inadequacy of this person, but to be honest, well... you don't have to think of something to blurt out during the war plan a, plan b, well, you understand, i'm saying, in principle, this person never had any plans, he is a man of the moment, he is a man of hype, he is a man of some momentary decisions, momentary there are some hyped ones there, he has basically

ruled for five years and they, by the way, once even there learned that we don't have any strategy more than a month ahead, i think it's the same story now, although now they already have a plan. i think i already said what it is, he stated a lot there, pay attention this week, he said there that we are planning already there for october-december to go there to a peaceful, to a peace summit, so that everything, and now he has to finish everything, and here they say, if the west does everything in these three months there, then there will be peace, friendship of chewing gum, that is, they certainly have some windings, as regards , did he have a plan, well i 've thought about it many times, my view is that this person until the last seconds before the start of a large-scale invasion... did not believe that she would be this statement, i'm sure there was a person on surname yermak, who assured him of this, i don't know if that's why that he himself is a russian agent of influence, or because he just played a little in his larochnichev games and did not understand that he is now breeding not larochniks, but bandits, and bandits can also strike first,

it is about russians, about chekist bandits, i don’t know, let the investigation be sorted out later, i hope when these characters cease to be in power, well, but zelensky's behavior, i repeat, really shows that this person did not... believe in the fact that there would be a war, he did until the last second did not give me the opportunity to properly prepare for it, i i will just remind you that in the book of zelenskyi’s once-funcional journalist simon shuster, it is written in black and white, and not only there, it was written in many places that the country’s defense plans, which he was developing, including valery zaluzhnyi , were not shown to zelenskyi until the last second and were not they showed it even to the americans, because they were afraid that the americans, well, because they are still more systematic people, they would show it to the supreme commander-in-chief, and if they show it to the supreme commander... in command, he would completely stop everything, you see, and all that's why i have a clear impression that this person never had any plan, he constantly acts with a planning horizon of a couple of two or three weeks, but these are very sacramental, that's why when this person starts talking about some plans, i get very, very scared, because not

at the intellectual level, and most importantly even at the level of this person in terms of the possibility of delegating some powers to someone, these people are simply pathologically incapable of normal system management. no to any kind of managerial approach no, in principle, for some kind of strategizing, that’s a shock, you understand, so do they have any plans, i think that they have everything in principle, well , let’s wink here, we’ll do it there, we’ve already decided there, there... marina, here plans a, b, c, these are all topics that sound, and obviously, in this situation,

zelenskyi really could not know that there was a plan, and other plans were in the armed forces of ukraine and not only in the armed forces of ukraine, that people were preparing for war, and bohdan correctly says that zelensky probably did not believe that there would be a war, because i remember how four hours before the start of the great war at one o'clock in the morning... zelensky spoke and addressed the russians in russian and said that we hope that we, you will not be there, we are brotherly peoples, that this madness will not happen after all , i think that zelensky as a person who was brought up in russian show business, because the quarter grew up from russian show business after all, that he did not even fully realize that russia could leave and did not believe that russia could to go to war, that those people who clapped their hands to him there in... murty, buryatia and in various regions of ukraine that they will come to kill

ukrainians. what can you say about these obvgdei plans, about which zelensky says? you rightly mentioned these statements of zelensky about the russians, i will remind you that on february 19 he had a speech in munich at the security conference, you can, you can quote every munich security. conference with the participation of zelensky, because at one, by the way, in the 20th year, he said that i do not have time to think strategically, when a journalist asked if you have any strategies regarding the fact that the russian the federation is preparing attacks there, he was asked back in 2020, and just a few days before the full-scale invasion, he told in munich that the russians are also people, and i do not believe that they will go to war against us, i am sure that zelensky until... . the latter hoped that if the russians laughed at his tv series "matchmakers",

if the russians once went there to watch the movie "love in the big garden" with the participation of volodymyr zelensky, then they would refuse to conquer ukraine, but in reality this is not the case. you can watch the series on the tablet "matchmakers", and with the other hand to kill and torture ukrainian women who fell into the occupation. unfortunately, as time shows , zelensky's firmware has not changed, and although in 2022 he tried to pull on cherchel's skin, his insides have now come out, which is still greatly strengthened by his close communication with andriy yarmak. when he declares that there was no plan a in ukraine and we are living in plan b, zelenskyi completely distorts reality, distorts reality, distorts what is already known from behind... them intelligence, all these articles of the foreign press, there were quite thorough investigations into who

was preparing for the war, and we must give credit to the two ukrainian commanders-in-chief, and to zaluzhn and the syrian one, and i can also say that kyrylo budanov also prepared much better than volodymyr zelenskyi, but you know, our supreme commander-in-chief is constantly measuring top-level ratings of ukrainian servicemen. and that is why he will not listen to them, if you could notice, they are now trying to find the culprit, who did not win this plan a and plan b, and because of whom, ah, by the way, our western the allies don't give enough weapons, maryana bezogla has already written a post about the fact that she will now talk in english about what kind of alcoholics we have in the ukrainian army, there is a very interesting quote in that post, but then... precisely because we have such a bad military command, the west does not provide us with the necessary

weapons, this is an absolute lie and a shift in emphasis, because i read a lot of foreign press, and one that does not read it there, and there is always such a red thread what is going on is that distrust of the ukrainian government, distrust of the banking system, distrust of these powerful managers, unwillingness of these... to make reforms that would at least seriously reduce ukrainian corruption, precisely in the sphere of security and defense, contributes to the fact that very often... our western allies do not trust zelenskyi and are somewhat reluctant to hand over their own developments, but we see that there are efforts to find the culprit, and the culprit of volodymyr zelenskyi is always one, it is the armed forces of ukraine. of course, you already mentioned budanov, it's a rumor now there are rumors that they want

to remove budanov as the head of the main intelligence department of the ministry of defense, and this is connected with because of the rumors that were in the heart of the matter, budanov's two deputies were dismissed without agreement, it seems that they want to transfer the general and budanov to another position somewhere without agreement, well , there are such rumors, i don't know how true they are, let's see how they will develop events, but for now friends, i remind you that we are working live, and i remind you that in the middle of the entire broadcast, we conduct a survey, do we ask you about this or not? are you serious about the kremlin's nuclear threats, yes, no, everything is quite simple on youtube, either yes or no, write your own opinion under this video and in the comments. if you watch us on tv, take your smartphone or phone and vote on the numbers 0800-21381, if yes, no, 0800 211 382. all calls to these numbers are

free, vote, at the end of the program we will sum up the results of this vote. maryna danylyuk yarmalayeva and bohdan butke. today we have two beautiful journalists on the air who are the authors and hosts of two youtube channels censornet and showbike, if you are not yet subscribed to these youtube channels, please subscribe, join their projects, and of course, we take this opportunity to call on our the entire audience to also join the bisykyu and censornet shows. another topic, colleagues, is... the national bank of ukraine has restricted the use of the telegram messenger in state bodies of the tzsu. today it became known that the national cyber ​​security coordination center, a structural unit of the nsdc, banned the installation and use of telegram on the official devices of employees of state authorities, military personnel, employees of the security and defense sector, as

well as enterprises of operators of critical infrastructure. to be honest, i don't... everyone understands how the nsdc is going to administer this whole story with applications, with the telegram application and this platform, wouldn't it be easier to follow the path that the nsdc once followed with vkontakte classmates, when just these two networks were banned there on the 5th years in ukraine, then they extended this ban, and here are some half-measures, that telegram is, like, a platform that is controlled by the russians, but we are forbidden for civil servants to install in the phones of military personnel, and will it work at all in the conditions of this management chaos? bohdan? well, look, by the rights of a person who at one time took a very active part and was also in the committee for the preparation of banning vkontakte classmates,

i of course completely agree with you that just a telegram should be just as well do as they did with the contact. it is clear that even now those who want to use vkontakte simply put a vpn on their phone and use it, this is not a problem, we just understand very well that any such blocking, in fact, is not directed against those who consciously does something, but against the conditional two-thirds of people there, who are honest and sorry, they will not do anything extra there, it is not opened, well , what with him, something else will be opened, as for whether it will work, see, well, first of all, we have to understand that telegram is the social network brought here by the green government. by and large, it was these people who made and brought the russian social network and the fashion for it here to ukraine, i.e. if before that it was such, you know, an underground messenger that we used wherever we needed it, relatively speaking, yes, that’s it such a mainstream, especially, you all know, the format with these anonymous telegram garbage, it is of course

a factor of politics, in essence it was done by zelensky and his team, and they usually rule there, it is obvious... but they do not want to give up this social network, because where it is still possible in your shitty cesspools, pretending that it is not you, pour mud and lies and manipulate about anyone and not bear any responsibility for it, well, i am actually very saddened by the fact that, for example, according to the latest polls, which conducted interviews, still two/thirds of ukrainians use telegram, it is in the first place for receiving information, and of course. that half of the people are against there being any regulation there at all. i understand that the popularity of telegram is a lot why is it also caused by, of course, the absolutely bastard policy of american social networks, for example, that... on that facebook or youtube, in which you simply, for example, cannot cover the war, that is, any frame with a real war, well you you immediately have a full chance to get blocked and that's all, and you won't

prove anything to anyone, and telegram, of course, left because it is so uncensored, well, the russians have always been very good at fighting against democracy with the methods of democracy itself, so now what about whether it will work this story look, it's thanks to god that finally this decision has at least been made, it's obvious, but again, it's very half-baked. why because we are talking about a work phone, well let's be honest, friends, most people don't have work phones, they have the same phone that they have, it's also a work phone, relatively speaking, it's one time, two times, you you understand very well that, again, what does it mean, like, you can’t set it, he says, it’s my personal phone, and that’s it, and go to hell, as volodymyr oleksandrovich zelenskyi says, then the third point, and let's just say, overriding, as far as i know, has been for a long time. in all adequate units in the army , it has long been forbidden to conduct any official correspondence by telegram, and everyone who has even a little bit of smut in their head, who does not want to get a missile on their head, has long

ceased to conduct any negotiations there, that is, the military have long been communicating or in whatsapp or in the majority of signals, and i think they know this very well, but as for civil servants, well, look, this is a very important decision that really needs to be taken before deanonymization telegram so that there could be no anonymous telegrams, so that it would be possible to clearly ... security, about which, by the way, the budanov you mentioned, for which i thank him very much, constantly said that this is a danger, this is a huge danger for the ukrainian state telegram, well, it was impossible not to react, especially after the fool was detained in france and so on, but you see, it's a lot half-hearted decision, as soon as it was made, deputy renbolotven immediately started running out there. "this head of the cpd personally, there are only civil servants there, that, kovalenko, no, no, you will understand, it is not a ban and in general it is in your phones , that is, look, it is absolutely obvious that this decision is very half-hearted, and who will make it

to control how it will be controlled, that is, well, i take it in a positive sense, only because it is the first step, it is the first step to this stinking cesspool finally being de-anonymized and put under control, whether it can be blocked without problems, despite the fact that it has a slightly different structure there." it's cloudy there, it does n't matter, it's simply necessary, the state should work with the largest providers that provide a lot of traffic to the country and then its distribution and everything, and so on, please, those who really need it, they will certainly go there, but most people will abandon it, but i am 100% sure that while zelensky is in power, while in his presidential office there are people who , sorry, i personally lead these shitty telegram ramblings, how for example, telegram moves vertical, which, for example, according to rumors... is directly led by dasha zarivna, the right hand of andriy yarmak, and so on and so forth. remember the investigation of our colleagues, about another joke joker and so on. i think we all understand what we are talking about.

well, are they really going to give up such a resource, especially since the situation is not so rosy for them in other social networks, they lose in youtube, you know, in facebook they did not try to fight and so on. on instagram, of course, they ask bloggers flirt, but there is a very dull audience and it is difficult to get them there in politics. so yes, telegram is very real for them. strategic history, they, they will pretend that they are regulating something, but they will do their best not to lose this resource under any circumstances, so i would not be happy just yet, thank you, marina, well, why can't you do the same with telegram as you did with vkontakte and your classmates? i agree that the ukrainian authorities, in the person of zelensky and his team, have, let's say, legalized it. and popularized the kilogram to the maximum. i will remind you how they first entered politics, there was such a quote from andrii bohdan, the former head of the president's office, who

said that look, we will communicate with ukrainian society directly, we don't need any journalists, and after that they started very be actively used for highly direct communication, just like telegram. but, as time has shown, ... telegram is a rather shaky thing, because look, today the vertical works for you, and tomorrow can work in the conditions of elections for your competitor, today you are kissing dyosna with a kiss and inviting this very telegram channel to your press conferences, and tomorrow you can be pelted with mud there. next, let's be honest, i read too. the survey that was recently published on the opor website, telegram is popular, but the fact is that telegram is mainly used

by either the youngest audience, who are just... somewhere around there and they say that it is very convenient, or its audience , which is older. that is, they realized that it does not bring an increase in the audience, their telethon did not take off and it finally died down, let's say, the channels that they telemarathon, that's the fifth and espresso, they live their own lives and in the principles don't even live a bad life, because the audience watches them, there is some adequate information, it can be seen, after all , professional journalists work there, and not those who hatched there in medvedchuk's nest, so now they are looking for options, how to save this telegram, and that is why they issue such half-hearted ones decision, and the second point, they are now trying to pull out some popular instagram blogger and

plant her instead of... professional journalists, but we have already seen the cases of alina shamanska, who, by the way, according to my information, does not leave the headquarters of the servants of the people party, i.e. she is already there, although they say that no, she works as a volunteer, but this person very often appears in the office of the servants of the people for banking, and apparently receives some tasks there, we need to follow up, because rumors spread very actively, but that's it while there they tell more entertaining bloggers, that such a blogger as ramina is very actively lured to work in the office of the president of ukraine, because they realized that they are losing their audience, and somehow it is necessary to further spoil that audience, and it is obvious to convince why zelensky's moderate plan, according to which we will have freezing of hostilities, and a huge part of our people and territories will be under occupation, why is this good, so we will follow

this... and i really like the thing when there are individual representatives of the national security council and the center for countering disinformation, you know, they themselves made a bet on the development of their popularity in telegram, so of course such people will defend telegram. i will say about myself that i don't have any telegram channel, i use telegram exclusively to communicate with my electrician, that's enough for me, i don't get new information there, and if they write some bad things about me on separate... telegram channels , then good subscribers always send to another certified american white messenger, which i advise every ukrainian citizen to install and use. thank you marina and more literally, colleagues, the very end, i wanted to ask about your reaction to the escape of andriy odarchenko, a deputy from the servant of the people, he is there on a case related to attempted bribery.

mustafa nayem, the former head of the agency for the reconstruction of ukraine, is not the first servant of the people to flee, does this mean that they feel that the end of their power is just coming, bohdan, i think that the dude was just completely beaten , as if they told him uncle, you are there be lazy, because otherwise i will have to make you a bobo, and i'm sorry if it's a coincidence that he fled through transcarpathia. the head of which has now become the new first deputy head of the office of president volodymyr zelensky andriy yermak, you tell me, please, is it easy for a person to leave the country even with a passport, even if everything is okay with his documents, they will laugh, believe me on the full program, here the guy without a passport was quietly lazing around, you know, you can declare him an international wanted man as much as you want, an international wanted man was also declared for dmytrukav, things are going smoothly in london, thank you, but marina, three weeks ago from...

zelenskyi said, there are border guards, customs officers, we are all there, so we will check and draw the appropriate conclusions after the escape of artem dmytruk, well, almost a month has passed and there is no news about these clashes, and i think that we need to follow, so that volodymyr oleksandrovich zelenskyy himself would not take advantage of the same life hack of his deputies, dvymitruk, and this odarchenko, then trubitsin and other predecessors who... so powerfully fled the country using foreign passports or other schemes, at a certain time, so that i didn't want to wake up in the morning, and you read the news that zelensky disappeared somewhere , disappeared somewhere, went to europe through zakarpattia oblast. as for this odarchenko, i want to tell the ukrainian viewers that for me the most terrible thing is his offer of a bribe to mustafa enay.