belongs to the state, etc., and this is already an empire not of the european type, but of the golden horde, when the ekhan, who is not limited by anything, there are no political institutions that would restrain him, there is a military-political or military-nomadic pseudo-democracy, which is called delegative, that is, he once delegated the authority of the khan, and after that he is not limited by anything and in no way. comrade stalin built one. from whom does he protect the russians? from banderivtsi? and who are the people of bandera? earlier, there were those who seized power in ukraine, but now this is all of ukraine. it turned out that the same russian people, which he proclaimed to be part of the great russian people, consists of traitors themselves. and this is a purely stalinist approach: the people are traitors, and this is a purely horde approach, when khan could deprive the uluz of their subjectivity. from one part of its territory to

some other part, here even putin's logic was turned inside out, starting from the fact that ukraine does not have subjectivity, and the ukrainian people do not exist, and all the way to the fact that in just over two years, this people should be destroyed because he disobeys us even the logical external contradiction is obscured and covered, and you just need to understand putin, collective putin. let it be impersonal, and that collective putin in the person of simonyan, solovyov, shuigu, medvedev, whoever, that system of values ​​that he is currently promoting and defending, does not correspond to reality, it is distorted, it contradicts the natural logic of the development of events. the natural logic is that ukrainians want to be in europe, so yanukovych could not overcome this natural desire for sovereignty by peaceful means, could not buy. ukraine on

it did not stick and yanukovych was expelled, and he cannot forgive ukraine for this and is trying to prove that he is such a figure by military methods, and he also cannot and will not succeed. the question is, what a terrible price for this natural experiment, the result is known in advance, well, what does it mean in advance, does anyone understand? someone does not understand, it seems to me that this result is known in advance, it is in any case a deep depression, not to say a disaster for russia. i am not talking about ukraine at all, because it is a victim of aggression. here it is clear that the loss of population, the destruction of the economy, was not initiated by ukraine, it was initiated by collective putin. answering your question, as i understood it correctly, putin is trying to resist the natural course of europe with armed force. broke through not rivers,

but big barrels of blood, and in the end they lost. putin will have the same story somewhere, it's just that russia is a very big country, has a lot of resources, so more blood will have to be shed, what can you say here, i can't imagine how to fight this, but look. borisovych, well, we understand that putin is not a power in himself, he has certain partners, trade, geopolitical, you know, china is already out of the question, and not only china, iran joins in here, but here the question is, what exactly for example, there brazil and china are giving certain signals regarding one or another peace proposals, we understand that a large part of them are not public, they are probing the ground, first of all in the united states... maybe in brussels,

maybe in london, so ukraine is simply surprised, any offers that come from the same celestial or from brazil, yes they boil down to the fact that it is called peace at the expense of ukraine. the capture of our territories is constantly discussed, the so-called realities on the ground are discussed, although our fighters have demonstrated that the realities on the ground are not so unambiguous. the armed forces of ukraine are in... the territory of the kurdish province, but we also suspect that both beijing and brazil and not only that, they give certain signals with the agreement of the kremlin, that is, with the agreement of the kremlin, they give certain signals, broadcast them, well and try to check what the reaction will be, and this possibly means that the kremlin is ready for something, but here is the question of the psychotype of this russian milosevic, well, first of all.

china, and the west, especially the western hemisphere , america, western europe, is not liked by many countries, such as brazil and others. it's not about the states at all, it's about what specific forces are currently there. brazil rules. there is no beast more terrifying than american imperialism, and russia has never occupied brazil, so why not support russia? all this is actually secondary, that is, putin broke away from the global trend development, which dominates and turned to second-rate, sorry for the directness of political

regimes, and brought russia there too. to me, as a russian, it seems terrible and counterproductive, and what is called... is a way out of the war in europe, there have been no such serious warriors on the territory at least for almost 100 years. the last one was hitler's, who talked about living space. germany, it turns out, can perfectly exist without the hegerstrand life space. europe's largest economy had no need to seize ukrainian black soil, baku oil or donetsk steel and coal, as hitler said. so, this is a normal development trend. putin is rolling back to the strategy of 19th century politics, geopolitics of squares, etc., and in this geopolitics he will also lose, because you are already in kursk region. in fact, it is getting closer to the point that

the war is winding down, it seems to me that way, because on both sides there are great losses, on both sides fatigue has accumulated in two years, on both sides there are problems. with the economy. that's why european wars stopped, because they don't give out finally defeat someone. victory happens in a less developed socio-cultural space, here you will still have to negotiate at some point, and for putin the presence of russian territories under the control of ukraine is a very serious geopolitical mistake, because in this value system in which russia lives, territory is the most important thing. and it turned out that putin undertook to free the russian people, this fairy tale is happily swallowed by public opinion on the territory of ukraine. well, ukraine is not a subject, but a russian territory, as putin dismisses, as solov'ov says there. but

it all pays for those territories, the kurdish region, which is an internationally recognized territory of russia and is under the control of ukraine. it is not clear how you will get out of this situation. therefore , i think that in the near future, the biggest topic for putin will be the return of the territory of the kurdish region under his control. this is a propaganda fact, because until this is done, putin cannot say that he is an effective defender of the russian people. and in this sense, ukraine struck a very painful blow straight to the heart. and if our... military, for example, would approach kursk, that is of the regional center, and maybe even take it in a vise, remember how at one time putin's guderians drew various arrows, how they capture ukrainian regional centers there, but what if the armed forces of ukraine surrounded

kursk? again, if i understand you correctly, it seems to me that sooner or later the war will end and the exit negotiations will begin. from this unnatural situation. now the armed forces of ukraine have brought zelensky a very big trump card in these negotiations. because putin needs to get out of this war it is clear that he will no longer be able to conquer either kherson or zaporizhzhia, and all talk of reconquering these four regions, which he has already declared russian, has turned into nothingness. but if you start negotiations with a part of kurdish. therefore , i think that in the coming months it will be the main task for putin to push the armed forces out of the kursk region. and what will happen next, in relation to

pokrovsk, the same kurtsk region does not allow russia to advance with a wide front. russia now has the opportunity to advance in only one wax direction, to pokrovsk. it is clear that this will be an important point, but even if russia in 3-4 months, maybe sooner or later will take it under control and at the same time a piece of the kursk region will remain. it will not be good for putin, but he needs to paint a victory on his flags, explain that he has ensured the security of the russian people, and after that move on to those onerous agreements that are still waiting for him. all those conflicts end when both parties feel exhausted and unable to seriously move forward. it seems to me that the situation has already approached such a state. we can see that the front line has generally stabilized, if we are not talking about

pokrovsk in particular. there are some advances, but they cannot be called rapid and successful. and so, from a strategic point of view, it is clear that putin's plans for densification, demilitarization, removal of the bloody kyiv regime, nato, have not been implemented and will not be implemented. now the collective putin is thinking about how to deal with the beautiful. which means that the strategic idea of ​​abandoning european value systems and transitioning to the sino-kadyrov-north korean value system is a strategic failure. thank you very much, dear dmytro borisovych, for this extremely interesting and informative conversation with us. i want to remind tv viewers that dmytro areshkin, a political scientist, professor at ryssky

free university, was working for them now. thanks again for this analysis. thank you, goodbye. well, the time of our program has run out, leave it with the espresso tv channel. my colleagues will inform you about all the most important events of this day. take care of yourself and your loved ones, no ignore air raid signals. god help you. see you on air. exclusively on the air of our channel. congratulations, friends, the politclub program is on the air on the espresso tv channel. the most relevant topics of the week. nato member countries have huge arsenals, and russia is already on the verge of exhausting its resources. topics that resonate in our society. this is the question of trump's victory, what it is. analysis of changing processes. and each of us, what else can the russians do, are they able to use,

let's say, the resources allied with them lukashenka's army. vitaliy portnikov and the guests of the project, read the entire explanation, accept my singer, i thank you, it was difficult, but i was just interested, but this is absolutely her, help to understand the present and predict the future, offered the united states to conclude bilateral security agreements with us, a project for those who care and think. politclub every sunday at 20:00 at espresso. watch this week in the judicial control program with tatyana shustrova. doubtful wealth and unreliable declaration. whom the vkk weeded out on interviews finally, his non-compliance with the criteria of professional ethics and integrity. but as a judge from donetsk region, she escaped. liability for bribery. i was inconvenient for the local authorities. congratulations.

judicial control and i, tetyana shustrova, are on the air. reorganization and reformatting of judicial system bodies is underway in ukraine. after receiving the status of a candidate for joining the european union, judicial reform is one of the main requirements for continuing our path to the eu. the higher qualification commission evaluates current judges for their suitability for positions. servants themis. continue to surprise, from wealth that cannot be explained by income to professional incompetence. today we will tell you about those whom vkks has already weeded out. but first to the news. the state bureau of investigation completed the pre-trial investigation of the case of the judge of the economic court of the dnipropetrovsk region , eduard bondarev, who is suspected of kidnapping his business partner. according to the investigation, the judge started working in 2017. farming, and since he is not allowed to do so by law, he found a fake person, on whom

a part of the business in the sumy region was registered. later, the judge decided to remove the partner from the cases, blackmailing him with a million dollar loan. however , the man did not want to leave the company without pay. then, according to the investigation, the suspect ordered the kidnapping of his partner for $17. the man was to be deprived of his liberty and forced to sign the necessary documents for the transfer of ownership of the farm's property. judges reported on... surveillance in the organization of a completed attempt to kidnap a person and deprive him of liberty. soon the case will be considered by the court. eduard bondarev faces up to 5 years in prison. security service. ukraine has appealed to the supreme council of justice and is asking to punish the judge of the brovary city district court, volodymyr serdynskyi, who is accused of receiving 4,000 dollars in illegal benefits. the judge is also suspected of forging documents for a cruise to the caribbean. according to the resolution of the second disciplinary chamber of the ukrainian people's republic of ukraine, the complainant requests to bring the judge of the brovar district court

of the kyiv region, serdynskyi, to disciplinary responsibility for the admission behavior that discredits the title of judge. or undermines the authority of justice, in particular in matters of morality, honesty, incorruptibility, compliance with the judge's lifestyle and his status, compliance with other norms of judicial ethics and standards of conduct that ensure public trust in the court. earlier, the security service of ukraine informed the judge of the brovary city district court, volodymyr serdynskyi, about the suspicion of forgery of documents and fraud. in the summer of 23 , he allegedly used a forged letter of invitation to attend a conference on issues to. migrants, families with children and orphans from ukraine to the eu in order to illegally leave the country with their roommate. during martial law, the judge went on vacation on a cruise ship in the caribbean. to do this, minister themide, in collusion with a lawyer he knew, forged an invitation to an alleged conference in austria. on the basis of this

forgery, the court issued him a business trip abroad. last year, the anti-corruption bureau of the national anti-corruption bureau arrested volodymyr serdynskyi for bribes of 4,000 us dollars. the judge probably received an undue benefit from the representative of one of the parties in a civil case for making a decision in her interests. during the searches, $15,600 packed in different envelopes were seized from the judge. the higher qualification commission of judges continues to assess the current themis employees for their respective positions. confirmation. qualifications do not pass as quickly as we would like. the public integrity council and experts are doing a titanic job of investigating judicial integrity and identifying dubious fortunes. qualifying committee members need a lot of time to analyze all the information. in turn, the judges themselves try to delay the possible dismissal as much as possible, ignore interviews, suddenly fall ill and

invent very original ways to hinder the process. 10 months from the start. qualification evaluation commission held a meeting regarding 172 judges out of almost 2,000, 27 were dismissed, while 43, who were found to be dishonest by the public integrity council and the foundation's analysts, were retained by the supreme court of justice. last week the qualification assessment was conducted by the judge of the rivne district administrative court andrii salo. i am constantly engaged in self-development and try to maintain my qualification . andriy salo is known for his anti-european position. he supported the appeal of judges' associations, which demanded the president to promise the law on the reform of the supreme council of justice, in particular through the involvement of international experts in the ethical council. in particular, the judges emphasized that the reformation of the grp threatens the sovereignty of ukraine, as it contains instruments of influence

foreign countries. i cannot know what threats to national security have manifested or seen in general. it would be more appropriate for our national state authorities to be formed by our specialists and experts, that would be more correct. we did not see the participation of international experts as appropriate and did not see such an example in other european countries. the public council of virtue and the high qualification commission of judges also have many questions regarding the property of andriy sal and his family. for example, the judge's parents were able to buy a bmw x5, real estate with a total area of ​​approx. and an apartment in lviv for over a million hryvnias, which is used by the judge himself. while their combined income for 10 years, according to the public council of virtue, was less than uah 500,000. the judge is convinced that the grd allegedly did not take into account all the income. parents led a thrifty, reasonable lifestyle, married since 1984, all savings, own

funds, funds withdrawn from personal. of the economy, which is not a farm, drew the attention of the commission members and is not taxed, all property, everything that they were, what was earned, what was saved, everything, in my opinion, was used wisely, purchased and corresponds to their income. according to the public integrity council, the judge used bmw and mercedes cars for years and did not indicate this in his declarations. the servant of themis systematically violated traffic rules, he was arrested several times for allegedly drunk driving, but the court closed these cases for formal reasons or due to the expiration of the statute of limitations. the judge decided to keep silent about these facts in the declaration of integrity. first, by the first form of declaration of integrity, at that time there was a different interpretation regarding

the information that was to be reflected in this information, in this declaration. in general , there was an opinion among the subjects of the declaration that the information should be displayed there, which is precisely related to prosecution for acts related to corruption. it was the deeds that were done. but after regular interviews there, and i followed them at that time, i realized that it is probably more appropriate to display such information even in the protocols for violating the rules traffic in 2018, andriy salo tried to become a judge of the higher anti-corruption court, but he was found unscrupulous. it was decided that the candidate for the position of judge of the higher anticors. did not stop participating in the competition, because the commission, at a joint meeting with the public council of international experts, established his non-compliance with the criteria of professional ethics and

integrity. this time, the higher quorum commission announced a break before making a final decision on the suitability of andrii sal for the position and is waiting for additional information from him documents and explanations. the higher qualification commission of judges of ukraine dismissed the judge of the avdiyiv city court of the donetsk region. in 2011, when she had worked as a judge for only a year, elena panchenko was bribed with $600 for reducing the defendant's sentence. the higher qualification commission then removed the judge from his position, but did not dismiss him. the kuibyshiv district court of donetsk sentenced panchenko to five years in prison with a suspended sentence with a three-year probationary period and confiscation of property. panchenko appealed the verdict, but the appeal... was not considered due to the capture of the courthouse by the russian army, so the verdict never entered into force. i was inconvenient to the local government, in my opinion, and

i applied to take an administrative position in this court. of course. is this your inner conviction? yes. i believe that this became the basis for creating such an artificial criminal case. it is also known that in his scientific article. olena panchenko, contrary to the rules, used information from a russian-language source, by translating it through google translate. of course, a coincidence, under no circumstances would i use anything russian and would not want to use it, but this is a literal translation of three sentences. i don't know how, if you didn't use it, how it could get absolutely verbatim into your work. maybe i didn't accidentally link to, well, i'm not ready to say now, but come on. but it's not on purpose. for 10 years, the judge has been living in kyiv and renting an apartment, allegedly by verbal agreement. he assures, during this time yes

and could not find real estate with an official lease. for the 14th year, i have lived in the city of kyiv, in different periods in different apartments, i did not indicate that i live with relatives or relatives or somewhere else, i clearly indicated the apartments in which i live. it was necessary to be registered as an internally displaced person, i did not conclude an official written lease agreement with any landlord, so i actually did not mention it, about the lease, apartment owners do not want to enter into such contracts, as they did not want to in 14- what year are you taking us? for these apartments and to rent these apartments, that's actually how a higher qualification happens in the end. the commission of judges recommended the dismissal of olena panchenko. now the submission must be considered by the supreme council of justice. today

i have everything, it was judicial control and i am tetyana shostrova. if you know the facts of corruption in the judicial system, or you want to tell about an unscrupulous judge, write to me on facebook or to the e-mail address you see on your screens. see you in exactly a week, all the best! the guest of this part of our program is pavlo grod, president of the world congress of ukrainians. congratulations! thank you! you are our studios, thank you for coming, thank you for coming for... some new, real opportunities to support ukraine in these difficult times, when you see kyiv and other ukrainian

cities under missile and drone attacks almost every day. attacks by the russians, and i want to start precisely with the topic of your stay, which, if we talk about your meetings, about your conclusions, which is the most important thing in this visit, well, first of all , i wanted, most importantly, we brought with us an additional additional package of assistance to the armed forces of ukraine, and since the beginning of the full-scale war, we actively participated in it, created our project. the united with ukraine platform, and we alternately bring aid packages, we work with the leader of the armed forces of ukraine, with various departments, with gur and others, in order to understand what they need most next, then this time we brought long-range drones, armored vehicles and another, other things that we cannot talk about, but we are actively involved, so we call on all

concerned ukrainians and friends of ukraine to actively participated in this collection of funds, because those drones must be constantly updated, because they are destroyed in advance, and this was the main direction, the second was the political direction, that is, one military, the other political, in order to communicate, get to know the new ministers, well, i won’t say get to know do we know a lot of them very well, but to discuss with them the strategy going forward and how we can work closely together, because we know the most effective way the government can carry out a... border mission when they work closely with world congress by ukrainians and with our constituent organizations everywhere in the world, and to ensure that we closely cooperate, as well as the state, diplomacy and civil society. well, what are the conclusions of these meetings with officials, as far as i know, you also met with the new minister of foreign affairs andrii sebygo, with other such representatives of the ukrainian leadership, what are their moods, and if we talk about this plan for the victory of volodymyr zelensky, how did you see the further

development of events? well, their mood. like all of us very combative in understanding that we understand the goal, that time is short, that we absolutely need to get this military aid as soon as possible, that there is a shortage, that what we need, we heard repeatedly that we absolutely need air defense, and we need a lot more, we need additional financial assistance, so that it does not at least not decrease, because there is a risk in this, and that is why we specifically heard... questions about, say, the return of ukrainians, how can we join this strategies, and we asked, we do not get involved, we already do that we do, we do all those things to facilitate this return, or if not a return, then at least so that ukrainians remain ukrainians abroad, so that they do not assimilate, so that they become our huge potential lobby that will work in favor of ukraine, well and these are two, i would say two such parts of this question, by the way, here is the question of the return of ukrainians,

as far as it is possible in general... to talk about a real return during the war, or are we talking about some kind of strategy after the end of hostilities, but at the same time it must rely on some time intervals, no one knows when the war will end in 2020, relatively speaking, in the fourth or fifth year or in 2030-31, well, there is a call today to return specifically to men who are of an age that can serve , and they just count that there are approximately one million men, citizens of ukraine. who are qualified to serve in the army, and they will call them and find various ways to encourage them to return to ukraine to fight for their independence, so this is a real strategy that is being worked out by the government, and the second - this is to help in the reconstruction today, because there are opportunities to come, to help rebuild today, because there is a lot destroyed, it is not necessary to wait until the end of the war,

that is why it is important today, and the second thing is that... the return must be today prepare and ensure the possibility of her return, i will give one very specific example, this is education, if we do not provide the right education, so that ukrainian children do not study in ukrainian schools, then it will be a whole generation of children that will be lost, because if a child does not lose his ukrainian language, then it will not return, won't fight with mom, what mom, i'm not going back to ukraine, then something... will happen, not only mom and children won't come back, but the men who will come back after the victory, they will also leave to join their families, so this there is a big security risk, as the children will not know their language and will not have a ukrainian education, so we are working with the ministry of education to facilitate the conditions, for example, there are now 600,000 school-age children of ukrainian citizens abroad, 600,000 have left, from there are only 300 of them...