make the switch to the aarp auto insurance program from the harord. why wait? charles: a phone fight with billions of taxpayer bucks at stake. welcome back i am charles payne in for neil cavuto, remember this woman? >> you got obama -- you know. gave us a phone. >> how did he give you a phone. >> you sign up. you got low income, disability. charles: she is thrilled to get a government subsidized phone but now a push on capitol hill to hang up on that program. it has grown to $2 billion, now

track phone, is fighting to keep that money coming in. it is attacking my first guest with ads like this to pull the plug. louisiana republican senator david vetter is joining us now, must be a little intimidating going up against the richest man in the world. >> let's be fair, i think he bumped down to second richest. he is behind bill gates, he really needs the income stream, we're denying him these rate ppying dollars, talk about a welfare corporate kg. this is the poster boy. charles: we did not see him like this during carter administration. to your point, his company, they get $9.25 per month from every welfare track phone to goes out there, talking about a whole l of phones, a bunch of money. >> yeah, i think it will is a

smaller amount but still very significant, i think about $2 .75 per phone per month that is why they are handing them out on street corners like candy, that is happening in many cases with no control, no real verification of eligibility i, it big money. charles: perhaps, a friend of mine got one of those phones, he was thrilled about it, saying he had better self esteem. >> folks like free things, they like give aways, i'm sure some

the recent this, but there are more folks paying for it anybody who pays any telephone bill, land line or cell phone, is paying for this,very bill, every phone, every month. for family with a few kids that adds up to real money for middle class family, a lot more of those folksho are paying for this sort of entitlement mentally gone wild. charles: we must point out the connections here, ceo of acfone, he just last year had a $4,00 $40,000 plate dinner for president obama, his wife is known as a bundler. wh is your comment on that? it seems like a quid pro quo at taxpayer's expse? >> those are the facts, he cannot dispute them, this is entitlement mentally gone wild

arriv.this is rife with fraud, d abuse. the most who are benefiting from them is the two yo you highligh, including the second richest man in the wor. senator we wish you luck on this, this out of hand. it i unfair to taxpayer, good luck in this battle. >> thank youkin thank you, char. charles: okay government, they are giving out free phones but now doctors give out free prcriptions for food stamps, a quid pro quo also, two new york city hospitals started a pilot program, they willave low income people to use them to buy healthy food, katrina is worried thatteedthat the food stamp pros growing out of control. >> let's call them double val

coupons with a written prescription from your physician. charles: how does this work? is it because of th the -- you n go to your nearest doctor get health food. >> where theres a will there is a way with this government, neverine fact tha states shoulde in kr0e8 control, there is a flf what they call low income, this is new, they are backed with federal grants, but in the end it is you know picking winners and losers. because clearly charles your local grocery store has produce they decided is not very healthy rou. charles: okay this is a pilot program, i don't know how they will measure success or failure,

we have on sce, the 101 million people in combined food program, that is an extraordinary amount of people, it does not look like there is any end in siggt, to your point administration is promoting these programs, getting more people on them not less. >> it is the age of department see, in light -- age of dependency. they included a graph from heritage foundation that shows these types of resources do not go to families with an immediate need, they go to nonelderly adults and children who have been on assistance for greater than 10 years this is the age of dependency that means that federal government is out of control. and well boion it yondits -- wel beyond its sco in size tie.

charles: i can remember growing up in my neiggborhood, people born on food stamps and died on fo stamps, generation after generation, how come no one talks about it? this is a trap, you are not helping people you are harming them, you are giving them a way of never participating in the greatness of america. >> that is the purpose, they really are not trueing helping americans, when you give away things, and we know this thugh, birth growing up, i lived in a neighborhoo that way took some of us escaped, many of us don't. it is a helping handot a life style, that is what we've seen the government do. they have control, now food, and like your previous segment a ceel pho. charles: senator made a point that people like free stuff. >> they do. charles: free is not always good is not ease to articulate. >> it not, and it very easiest

thing is accept it but, more and more people are starting to hear, and understand where the money is going, and coming from, which is yours and my pockets, groups are getting word out to average voter, this is not my kid who is eating organic produce, we still have to shop the grocery store, when more and more people find out about this, i think you will see more attentn. charles: i hope so, 100 million people, and 100 billion-dollars if that does not wake the american public up, maybe nothing well. coming up. apple, already looking shaky. it is getting worse, next big thing could be a bigger bust. but first, detit is crumbling, we know, that and union are fuming, the labor big wig who is fuming, the labor big wig who is suing to keep the pension money

for our children is someththing the purwe all share.ter life but who can help prepare them for the opportunities ahead? who can show them how to build on your success, but not rely on it. who can focus on making your legacy last for generations to come? thatomeone is a morgan stanley financial advisor. and we're ready to work foyou. [ whirring ] [ dog barks ] i want to treamo dogs. ♪ our business nee more cases. [ male announcer ] where do you want to take your business? i need help selling art. [ male announcer ] from broadband to web hosting to mobile apps, small business solutions from at&t ave the security you need to get you there. call us. we can show you how at&t solutions can help you do what you do... even better.

♪ then you'll know how uncomfortable it can be. [ crickets chirping ] but did you know that the lack of saliva can also lead to tooth dec and bad breath? [ exhales deeply ] [ malannouncer ] well there is biotene. specially formulated with moisturizers and lubricants, biotene can provide soothing relief and it helps keep your mouth healthy, too. [ applause biotene -- for people who suffer from dryouth. charles: detroit is going bust, just days after city officially filing for bankruptcy, labor unions begin filing lawsuit, they are suing to keep their pensions, edward is a union representative for one of the groups suing, why do you think

that detroit can still pay its bills. >> because detroit has not shown that it is insolvent, a prerequisite in filing for bankruptcy they have to prove that, detroit is paying over 20 million in consultant fees, $20 million in vendor fees, they have not collected $800 million by people it is sod. and employees continue to work overtime. charles: so, the idea is kevin oorr said that unions did not really make a lot of points, you had a enough opportunity t make these points and bring your arguments up but things like you didn't top negotiate, have you problem is signing agreement,

always something that kept unions from bargaining table. hence where you are right now. >> well, that is just den genius ifay that mr. orr haa never met with me, he told other individuals he understoo he is an obligation to get back to me, he has never got back toe. i sense him an-mail, and taped a letter on his door to get in touch with him, mr. orr is being disengine wise when he said he indicates he has bent over backward to meetith unions, i have been in 4 different sessions, mr. orr was in first sessn at airport, that of the just a preliminary session, other three suggests was also preliminary t held with the law firm, in these particular meetings we talked to them, as ll ase gave back questions,

sent information back, while we were waiting on them to get things back to us, mr. orr has not been available. charles: we're r running out of time, but i want to ask, how do you feel, when a well the of people, including myself t be frank, from outside looking in, feel tha unions bear a huge amount of responsibility for problem that detroit has right now? >> well, i think that is a wrong statement to make. i think what people should focus on, that you have a governor who took an ocean of offic oath of p hold state constitution, he is now in violating of the constitution, i think that and i issue that people should be concerned about, you haae a governor that raised his right hand, and now in violation of the constitution. charles: i am sure a lot of people will talk about what shaping right the here and now, but evens that led to this moment, it did not happen

overnight, will sayhat happens? >> i think there will be a fast track hearing, what happens in jsteven rhodes does not decide in your favor wheis the next move? >> i think we will continue to move we'll appeal the decision if it comes down the other way, %-lookyou have to electric at at what mr. orr has done. they have not met the prerequisites, people need to stay focused and look at h this governor, as well as mr. orr has not been transparent with the public or workers, in city of detroit, even though he sa that. charles: right. iican tell you that is the largest bankruptcy in america's history, we will stay tuned and stay focused and probably ask you back thank you for your time. thank you. charles: you inlanding gear

fails in new york forcing a rough landing on top of crash landing in san francisco. where the entire landing failed. problems are adding up, and fear of flying piling up. any last requests mr. baldwin? do you mind grabbing my phone and opening the capital one purchase eraser? i need to redeem some venture miles before my demise. okay. it's easy to erase any recent travel expense i want. just pick that flight right there. mmm hmmm. give it a few taps, and...it's taken care of. this is pretty easy, and i see it works on hotels too. you bet. now if you like that, press the red button on top. ♪ how did he not see that coming? what's in your wallet?

how did he not see that coming? (announcer) at scottrade, our cactly how they want.est with scottrade's online banking, i get one view of my bank and brokerage accounts

with one login... to easily move my money when i need to. plus, when i call my local scottrade office, i can talk to someone who knows how i trade. because i don't trade like everi'm with scottde.ke me. (announcer) scottrade. awarded five-stars from smartmoney magazine.

[ bleep ] >> open the door. >> calm down. >> we're not there. we take your seats. charles: that was brand new cell phone video of hard landi yesterda in new york. due to front landing gear

failure, add that to fatal plane cras in san francisco just two weeks ago, and boeing's dreamliners nightmare, charles said it is time to worry about plane safet charles, there is no doubt with thesemages, in our mind over and over, that there will be serious growing anxiety what can be done? >> you continue is summertime, planes are hefry used because of weather interruption, and the we tend to r out of time when it comes to maintenance. it happened every summer. sadly our most accidents happen

in summer. it is usually be traced to a mistake, or weather. but planes are safe. >> yeah, i like how you did that, you had me drinking a vodka and sweat bulletshen tell me they are safe. from what i read for planes that have an accident, you need peorm storm, a black swan even, 6 major things in a row human error have to occur. and you say that these that we're seeing i an example of that? just this closely back-to-back, a huge red flag? >> sure, let me add that, 1 have you an accident, which is highly publicized ued such as asiana ft 214, we look at what is going on in country, we have a plan taking off this united states, commercial airliner about 30,000

times a day. there is a takeff and a landing, so volume is huge, we do have accents, most of them thank god are in the fatal, not even serious. but they do consider, given the volume. and the numberf people, so it does occur,et me say, planes are the science of aviation is almost flawless, however people do make mistakee in summertime %-don't have as much experiences might findn winte months that is because, the more experienced pilots need a rest, the young guys have to learn to fly. in san francisco, had what really came down to pilot error, here, some guy on the ground probably did not check maintenance of that nose wheel. and when it came down it crushed or pilot came down at too sharp

angle it hit too hard it broke. that pilot, probably does not have as much trainin as guy sitting next to him. charles: let me jump in here, i want to ask, are we seee saying for most part, this all goe back to airline, who have taken a lot of planes off of the system, so all these planes that take off they are filled to capacity, they can maximize fault of airlines, who probably are trying to save money, and running into typical seasonal constraints? >> i can't say that, it depen on what caused a plane to fail. and itt may be airline or strain on the pilot, it may be sudden storm. maybe a break down in weather tower. so i wouldn't want to put the buzburden on airline.

>> okay challenges before we let you go -- charles, airplanes for safe? >> i tell you, i would rather fly in a plane than drive my car around thh block in midtown manhattan, how about that. charles: life it, charles slepian thank you. thank you. charles: looking at president obama health care law score card, with eva longoria, jennifer hudn, and -- now ♪ ♪ ♪ ♪ [ male announcer ] if you can't stand the heat, get off the test track.

get the mercedes-benz you've been burning for at the summer event, going on now at your auorized mercedes-benz dealer. but hurry, offers end july 31st.

i took my son fishing every year. we had a great spot, not easy to find, but worth it. but with copd making it hard to breathe, i thought those days might be over. so my doctor prescribed symbicort. it helps significantly improve my lung function starting within five minutes. symbicort doesn't replace a rescue inhaler for sudden symptoms. with symbicort, today i'm breathing betr. and that means...fish on! symbicort is for copd including chronic onchiti and emphysema. it should not be taken more than twice a day. symbicort may increase your risk of lung infections, osteoporosis, and some eye problems. tell your doctor if you have a heart condition or high blood pressure before taking it. withopd, i thought i'd miss our family tradition. now symbicort siificantly improves my lung nction, starting within 5 minutes. and that makes a difference in my breathing.

today, we're ready for whaver swims our way. ask your doctor aut symbicort. i got my first prescription free. call or cck to learn re. [ male announcer ] if you n't afrd your medication, astrazeneca may be able to help. charles: my house is your house at the white house. seral celebrity attending a private white house pit. president giving stars hard sell to help him roll out his new healthy care law after the unions turned their back, and nfl said no way to helping out, and hollywood is only support that president has left, if it is, that is not too bad circumstance it? >> i don't know if only support but, president needs hollywood. to sell his healthcare plan, hope they get the young people in exchanges they need young, in healthy and subsidize the sick and hold, if they don't get that, if everybody changes that open octob 1, the bill will be

in trouble. charles: jamie, considering the busts this year, at the box office, can they sell anything? >> have you to convince young people to give up a lot of money, for coverage they don't think they need, it a tough sell, but you should jim carrey trying to get out in front on gun issue he made videos that he thought were funny, no one thought they were funny, that hurt his selling power, sometimes you try to sell something it comes back, as unpppular and hurts you. chles: are they going to be tasked with being honest about it? reading the bill, if hey do they will join a select few, are they going to beasd with given pros and cons? >> well, i don't think they will give a very in2 intellectual

discussion on health care bill, i don't think they will read it, i don't think that many people in congress read it, i think they will preach when the president wants hem t them to preach, i don't think you will get a pro and consaid argument. charles: they like the president, they share a lot of traits, but, also this last fiscal cliff, where everyone took a big hit, morn public there -- american publics there are a $40 million carve out for hollywood. sov and film production could be made in america this is to a certain extent, a quid pro quo. hollywood benefits from takes pair dollars is outrageous. >> they love the president, so he could give them you know $400 million or nothing, i think they would come to president's

aid, they are in love. charle they may love the president, it will be a tough hurdle, you think playing hamlet is tough, jamie appreciate it. >> thank you. charles: okay from desperate housewives to desperate celebrity, spike lee using kick-starter to help fun his froproject. rich celebrities begging for cash is not doing the right thing, i was shocked by this, is this the guy that sits in front row seats or $10,000, at a game @% yes. this is to fund a movie, he does not need this money, his last movie made $186 million. he does not need this. charles:sao the web site, he referred to the people who made -- faithful, like this is a calling not about mon, just a

calling to help him out. >> you have to have faith to believe that spike leonine lee,o money, it is absurd, he told people for $5 donation he will tweet them a thank you. are these people's lives so empty they will give ts manmohan jusmanmoney just to ge. charles: i have filing that spike lee is cutting and pasting a thank you 355 times and more. here is the thing, he is not only one dig it zach practice of braft, 2 million, a veronica mars, someone told to that spike. >> if they want tooou their cial capital and celebrity for something good, there are so many better things to do, me and

spike lee are nyu.kyu alum needy not direct that t a college scholarship fund or homeless or hungry, why help himself save money. charles: where do you put this? ego, arrogance or i am a star you are not. >> he knows he can save himself a few bucks, at the end of the day, this is america. i hole it again the people who are giving him money to perpetuate the cult of celebrity it is beyond the pail. charles: it is, you can go to public and say send me money, i will tweet you a thank you, a thankou? are i am not sending you anything. but there arenough people out there cult personality society we live in? >> sleetly, you know worse thing is that spike lee has been bemoaning the hollywood executives that you kno it impossible to make a movie

less you are doing something about a hero or exploding planet. about h said it is about human beings with an,dictio, addictioo drugs, and there is a lot of sex in it too. charles: we'll do something else on fracking and how to harm the environment. you know sething like that. but, it isust your basic run of the mill, flood, gets and sex, and you know you can kic in the cash i'll make the money, catch me at knick games and i'll tweet you now and then. >> is it that easy? if you come up with a 3 word slowing know like yes, we can, you can probably get yourself elected president. charles: i bet someone will figure tat out. let me write that down, yes, we can. anything or just we can?

>> i think just yes, we character let people project what they want. charles: thank you, david. >> my pleasure. charles: from abou baja to booh. big government lawsuit that is putting administration on notice. [ jackie ] its just so frustrating... ♪ the middle of this special moment and i need to run off to the bathroom. ♪ i'm fed up with always having to put my bladder's needs ahead of my dadaughter. ♪ so today, i'm finally taking to my doctor about overacti bladder symptoms. [ female announcer ] know th gotta go feeling? ask your doctor about prescription tiaz. one toviaz pill a day significantly reduces sudden urges and accidents, for 24 hours. if you have certain stomach pblems or gla,

or can not empty your bladd, you should not take toviaz. get emergency medical he right away if your face, lips, toat or tonguswells. toviaz can cause blurred vision, dizziness, drowsiness and decreased sweating. do not drive,perate machinery or unsafe tasks until you ow how toviaz affects you. the most common side effects are dry mouth and constipation. talk to your doctor about toviaz.

>> apple stock jumping after hours, big iphone sales, but big troub could still be ahead, ipad sales missed mark we're hearing reports o production iphone' 5s is hitting the roadblocks. scot marn and dave mainy o plates it out, you think that apple has missed its comeback shot already? >> eah, i do, he is the -- i

guess, the issue with high-end phone market. it is all going low-cost, so without this breakthrough product, we have heard about what itv forever now, it has not come out, now phone prices coming down to get more people, any time you have a product that was a higher margin productou have to cut prices on to get exposure in a new market does not sound like good business. charles: dave, no doubt that apple benefiting from low expectations in afternoon market, but it is not the juggernaut that had the amazing pricing power of the past. >> it is not. i think, let's give them a little bit of a break in that it is very hard to be that innovative cutting edge world changing company with a new pruct all of the time, you think of what that looks like in consumer electronics, you really have to stretch, the panasonic

with the transisistor video in 60s, and vcr, if you say can they keep doing it are they going to bat .500, ion'think so it looks like rough water. charles: if they can't bat500 any more, where should the stock be? >> you know, i don't know, i i am not a stock price predictor guy. but if you ask if there is positive or negative momentum, if all of the air is out of it, it does not feel like it to me. charles: scott, you feel the same? >> i do, other thing we are not mentioned is competitors caught up to them, they were the big grower, now competition caught up, dave is right, the arrow is down because the other arrows

are up. charles: taco bell, telling children no mas taking away children's menu, focus on college kids. the 20 somethings cing home late from night partying, scott, is this a good move on their part? go for munchies? >> for what it worthy still go there and eat tacos late night that is their demograic it smart, look at revenue in u.s. and worldwide it is not the kids menu. i think it is smart to get out of that business, mcdonald's gets attacked every other month about their markets to kids, that is not a great place to be in fast-food. charles: in a way this is inresting i never knew they had a kids menu, getting out. >> this is a funny story to me, i look at ceo quoted today saying, it is not consistent for

an edgy 20 something brand to be to have kids meals, i thought, boy to me nothing says, edgy and 20 sething like artificial cheese, you know, that is where it is at. i don'tet this one, i was on with you last week we were talks about kfy makinga similar move, a another yum brand company, now i am waiting for pizza hut to announce they will he mp3s on the jukebox. charles: i think, 1:00 in morning friday and saturday night is key. >> one more, homeowners fliing out, housing prices are rising fast, and more people are flipping their houses, is now the time to take advantage of housing, which, is going to be a topic we'll delve in to terse

dathis thursday 8:00 p.m., heren fox business. >> i think all things are harder than they look, popar culture notion of what it takes is what they saw on hgtv last night latest of two identical twins house flipping that is not a good basis for making an investment. it is a good thing for the housing market this is happening, flippers are arbitragures, buying low, putting lip tick on. they help the market be more efficient, this is a good thing for the market, i can't say whether it is a good strategy for a individual investor. charles: i like that point, not necessarily an indictment on housing market but, a group of people who are adhering to a

business model, they took a big shot when the housing market was falling apart, they have been rewarded that was their goal, do you think other people who are not necessarily professional flip irs should tryt? >> no, i think it will be tough, your point is well taken, this is clical, now that housing prices are on is up swing, i have to disagree with dave, fundamental of housing market today are not that strong like in mid 2000s, there is not a lot of supply there are more buyers, that is an issue that i think with flippers they are drying up and liquidity because actual buyers who want to buy house say long-term are getting beaten up by the flipper guy charles: if someone is watching th, rates are bouncing a little bit prices hav come back nicely. they have been on the fence for a few years, should they just jump in find a home of their

dreams. >> if they find one. you know, best thing for housing market higher prices, i tell you that will get people off of keisters into the market and buying homes. charles: dave, you think that is sort o right way to look at this? >> i -- w i don't agree it is a bad thing for market, markets are efficient, they are efficient in part because they are allowed to be efficient with people like flippers. right now, on your core question, is it a good time? i voted with my feet bought a second place for our family in mountains in colorado. it feels well -- acheegreat time to me. charles: -- it feels like a great time to me. it would feel great to me as well, as usual. >> ccme on up. charles: i will. >> you are fantastic. thank y. >> thank you, charles. charles: when government is watching you, here is a question for you, who is watching the government? next a lawyer suing because

agency meant to protect you is

charles: this agency was formed to protect people, my next guest said it is way too powerful. they are suing the bureau -- the consumer financial protect bureau, kimber please. who got you -- what started this? walk us through this series of events that brought to ushis point. >> well, i represent people all over conneicut, they come to me, to represent them. and to protectheir confidential information they have given to me, everyone i think in america, knows what attorney-client privilege is, when clients come to me, they

expect i will keep their confidens,' fortunately what happened here is that, the -- unfortunately the government has overstepped their bounds, and tried to come in take that confidential information that my clients have giveno me, in confidence as their parent, that is what brought us -- as their attorney that is what brought us to where we are today. charles: your clients in connecticut, are they hedge fund managers weahy people? why would consumer protect financial bureau be interested in yr clients? >> no, actually, the 07 sit. my clients -- opposite, my clients are near indigent, and lower middle class families who are in middle of financial crisis, which is destroying their lives, by the time they come to me, it is destroying their lives and marriage, and families, these are the people

next door who are barely getting by, these are people that i representative, these are people that government want their information. charles: randy, how doe this happen? they pull a name out of a hat? i cannot see why she would be targeted on the face of it. >> this is an agent gone way beyond its mission our lawsuit targets, really emanating from structure of the cfpb we think they look typical oversight, i t does not have types of internal checks and bances from an agency like ftc . with a mull -- >> what -- what know that t goal of it? they were putting it together sing this agent are not powerful enough that was not powerful enough we need a

superpower full agency on go out, destroy and protect. >> that is the idea, it is an unconstitutional idea, our system is about checks and balances and limited power. not a super agency that goes on does what it wants. we see t steps, first demand for this type of data, this is personal financial data we have information to indicate the are ag gateaguanga -- agragating it. and lawyers practicing law this is not pervue of a federal agency, we think that is all sort of a consequence of fact there is no sufficient checks and balces. charles: kimberly, what support are you getting so far within

lawyer community. >> i think that everyone is concerned. this is a slippery slope. if this government agency is allowed to step in take, mdle america's information, at will without control all attorneys in every type of practice of law will havv to be worried that, we no longer have an attorney-client privilege,,@ people are concerned. charles: we hear a lot of things happening in dc are constitutional, working through the system will take a long time, will you be able to keep your kleilient's infmation confidential. >> we're doing all we can to keep it confident. >> randy, your firm right now representing two clients, but this seem like something that could spread like wildfire,

could that grow into a large class actionype of event? or keep it small? >> we're trying to do is ask court to expedite proceedings and enter a prelimina injunction to stop the agent right now until the court has time. the agent got its first director mr. cord a, on july 16 he was confirmed, they have to have a senate confirmed director they are ready to fly into action. charles: he is chomping at the bi waiting a long time. >> he has been at starts gate, we're asking the courts to just put the brakes on until we can have a hearing. charles: i have to tell you, kimberly, everybody understands attorney-client privelage and confidentiality, a corner stone of arica, this is not the direction we want to go in, thank you, we wishou luck, come back keep us filled in

appriate it. charles: thank you. charles: remember the pick of anthony weiner that he texted out. guess what more are coming out, they are worse. is he toast? ♪ [ villain ] well mr. baldwin... it appears our journey has come to a delightful end. then i better us the capital one purchase eraser to redeem my venture miles for this trip. purchase eraser? it's the easy way to erase any recent travel expense. i just pick a charge, like my flight with a few taps, it's taken care of. impressive baldwin. does it work for hotels? absolutely thank goodness. mrs. villain and i are planning our... you scare me. and i like i let's go what's in your wallet? [ whring ] [ dog barks ] i want to treat mo dogs. ♪ our business needs more cases. [ male announcer ] where do you want to take your business? i need help selling art. [ male announcer ] from broadband to web hosting

to mobile apps, small business solutions from at&t have the security you need to get you there. call us. we can show you how at&t solutions can help you do what you do... even better. ♪

charles: the scandal that is now more scandalous, there are more texts and pictures, they are so bad, we can't show them to you, is new york mayor hopeful toast? we askohn david ree jedediah bi. >> this is nee york, they still glorify bill clinton, do i think it will hurt him?

yes. do i think it will help his wife stood by him? absolutely, we never know what is next with anthony weiner, but he is a disgrace, he lied to us, to his wife, and american people, and regardless of what do you i in your living room, if we can't trust you to actual us th truth about this, what can we trust you about. chles: julie, you dressed alike, maybe you are thinking alike? >> i think that new york voters ar forgiving about personal foibles, the question is, is this something you want consantly hounding your mayor, it distractions from business at hand. charle that happened after the other scandal broke, he was contrite, and apologized. what is wrong with him. >> there are issues that i don't top grasp for begin to think

about, more buzzis wife -- nor does his wife, horrible. >> i would have loved to see her extricate herself. not stand beside h. charles: you know, new yorkers are forgiving and americans are, but none of us yet have seen these pictures that i understand are -- >> i saw them. >> oh, excuse me. >> people have to understand, when people show you who they are, believe them, he has shown us he lacks credibility, as a candidate, and as someo in was, he did this not only when he resigned from congress this happened after the resignation from congress, he have to recognize, that he has

rationalized this, and tried to tell voters, but i told threw would b--i told you there woulde that tells me you cannot accept responsibility, you tell us, i warned you. you did not tell us you bought her a condo, andhe is 22 years old, and he sense her pictures of his last name to her, come on this is absurd. charles: his name was carlos danger. >> you have to give him credibility for -- >> carlos danger. >> i can't believe you hav so much disrespect for the voters, these are people, what about pele whh pore gave yo fore gave, you know what i'm going to give yoo another shot, and media that

said he is a changed man now, h cares about his wife, and family, you have to say, he has proven himself time again to be a disaster. charles: julie, how can a politician respect voters if they don't respect the themselv, but we have a habit, one hand is forgivenesbut on other han, we keep votin in these kind of guys. >> anthony weiner is leading in polls rht now or was until today. i will tell you why, it is beuse people know his name. why? not because of his great work in congress. t because of the whole celebrity culture, "people" magazine, why? because he had a whole scandal. so, if you are a celebrity right now, either side on the aisle, odds of you becoming a

congressman mersenator is better than someone mosticking their no to the grind stone. charles: we put up a poll, christy quinn now taken a slight lead, jesse, what do you think? does this speak to new yorkers or voters or maniac? >> he is narcissistic, people have to think about, not that he just lied to voter, bu his wife, she was pregnant when he resigned from congress, this went on after he said he caught demption, counselling and help then he did it again. the temptation is too deep for him to resist, getting on-line, and doing inappropriate activities, pictures with sexual conversation over telephone, promising someone to purchase a condo, this is beyond what he has done to voters, how can you trust a man who would lie to his own wife to this extent.

charles: we'll fd out, you are fantastic. audience, watcher my special thursdays, making your m francis next. melissa: i'm melissarancis and here's what's "money"onight. goldman sachs is under fire. its scheme to cash in on the aluminum market sparks outrage from wall street all the way to capitol hill. you are going to hear from a top ecutive from one of the country's biggest aluminum companies just how bad this is. plus the does the length of your hair influence how hones you are with money? honesty, he is laughing over here on the sidelin, honesty, conduct as nationwide experiment d everything from your hair to your hometown affects the outcome. honesty's ceo is here wh numbers. who made money today. they're eating mcdonald's lunch or big mack is more appropriate. can't figure