faq for being a part of the show. keep it here on fox business. >> good evening, i am lou dobbs, the obama administration has -- there is a possibility they will reap the world wind, president obama nuclear treaty with iran appears likely to generate a nuclear arms race in the middle east. saudi arabia putting little trust in president obama. they are troubled by terms any of nuclear deal with iran so troubled that saudi arabia made it known that "the kingdom" is considering developing or acquiring nuclear weapons much their own. if so other arab nations are certain to follow suit. these development as senate today passed legislation that requires congress to

give -- to be given the authority to review, approve, reject or take no action on any agreement between president obama and iran to reduce iran's nuclear capabilities. we discuss that agreement likelihood of coming to agreement with iran could talking to fox news military analyst, major general robert scales. also a major blow to bush administration and obama administration. a federal appellate court ruled that national security agency mass collection of citizen phone records is illegal. decision potentially making it far more difficult to fight the war on terror. we take it up with some of the best attorneys in the country, mercedes mers call -- and so-called wells report does not prove anything. but does claim that patriots were quote -- or probable

than not -- to have deflated game balls. and that tam brady of quote at least generally aware end quote. of what was going on. what does that really mean? we'll talk with sport marketing legend, tony ponturo on the wells report. and the nfl should do next. lou: but we begin with an arms race in middle east, egypt, turkey, saudi arabia, right now weighing development of nuclear weapons. move comes as saudi arabia and its arab state allies are in a broadening conflict with iran across the region from syria to yemen. where the saudis proposed a five-day ceasefire to allow for delivery of humanitarian aid if the houthi rebels

agree. iranians releasings maersk . let's start with situation right now. with the prospect of an arms race in the middle east, this is not -- this is not the intended consequence of any negotiation that the administration embarked up on know, what do you make of it. >> the saudis don't have to follow entrail with iran and develop a nuclear weapon program. they are rich enough, and influential enough to just buy a bomb.

they know that teal we're about to strike with iran will result in iran having a bomb. they are firing a shot across the bough saying if you build a nuclear weapon we'll be driven to the same thing and we don't want to. saudis are clear about this they don't want to get into a nuclear arms race. but if this agreement is weak -- and it is -- and the iranians decide to develop a bomb -- and they will, then saudis fell compelled to follow entrail. lou: senate passed a bill with 98-1 vote bipartisan piece of legislation that is rare enough in washington, that will require congressional approval of any deal within 30 days of it being struck between this administration and iran. is that sufficient to guarantee to you it would be

a reasonable and well qualified document in the interest of the united states? >> no. not at all. look. this is not about the united states this is not about the deal. this is not about what kong think -- congress thinks. this is about the iranians there is no strategic compelling reasons for the iranians not to build a bomb other than the sanctions. the gates will be open for them to complete the development of the bomb, and they can do it on their schedule. i think that the horse is out of the barn. i think that the iranians are committed to becoming a nuclear power, it is their strategic best interest to do it, they have learned from united -- they fear the united states they have learned only way to is to

have a nuclear capability. i am sorry, but that is the fact. lou: it seems that a number of analysts are looking at iran and acknowledging acknowledging that this is the negottion has -- negotiation paveed way for acceptance of a nuclear ran, which is here to for been intolerable thought they would ever be permitted eye nukea nuclear bomb. >> can you imagine the consequences once they do this. they could sell or give one of these devices to one of their terrorist affiliates like hezbollah next thing we have a direct nuclear threat to u.s., that is the nightmare scenario. but, let's face it. one of the things that united states has to think about in years ahead is how to build a strategy, how to

build a -- capability given the fact that some day the iranians will have the bomb, and our whole strategy in middle east as you know will have to change, who knows sometimes in future, saudi arabians may very well be the sheerest gare guaranture against the iranian aggression particularly against israel, which is a grave threat. >> are describing a brave new world. general bob scales. >> thank you lou. lou: obama administration losing a mayor battle in court today. federal app la -- appellate court ruling that they cannot collect telephone records of american citizens it illegal for nsa to collect metta dit av phone records every day authorizes in view of against under patriot act.

court disagrees folks news white house correspondent kevin with our report. >> reporter: in 97 page ruling a three-judge pab el frompanel from court of appeals, held that a second of patriot act buzz not allow fur bulk collection of domestic calling records saying it cannot bear the weight that government as us to assign to it, and does not authority the telephone metadata program authorized by president's george w. bush then barack obama the nsa program has been approved in secret by judges certainingcertain -- serring on the fiso court creating after 9/11, program was exposed to by former nsa employees edward snowden. today's decision is a major victory for the aclu which appealed a lower court decision that the program was lawful. >> no today disagrees that the nsa has allyity nat

interest in tracking the communication of suspected terrorist, but the nsa of collecting everybody's information. >> reporter: in a statement a spokesman noted president's desire for quote, creating an alternative mechanism to reserve the program's essential cape bill we without the government holding the bum accident -- bulk data. >> the congress according to the court, did not authorize spying of this level and if the congress wants to authorize it, it can do so, then the court will review the contusionality of that. >> reporter: react on capitol hill was mixed. rand paul calling in a monumental decision for all lovers of liberty.

>> today's ruling does not end program all it really does it put onus on congress now to act with that, next week the house is set to consider the usa freedom act, that is an extension of patriot act. supporters tell us it will have better provisions. >> thank you very much. kevin cork from white house. >> thank you. lou: much more on nsa ruling our panel is going to join us. stay with us. >> coming up, president blames slavery jim crow laws and federal government neglect for violent in baltimore. he could not be more wrong. zuckerman is with us next.

>> tornado tear across oklahoma. leaving a trail of destruction, we'll have the latest for you next.

congratulations. you're down with crestor. yes! when diet and exercise aren't enough, adding crestor lowers bad cholesterol up to 55%. crestor is not for people with liver disease or women who are nursing, pregnant, or may become pregnant. tell your doctor all medicines you take.

call your doctor if you have muscle pain or weakness, feel unusually tired have loss of appetite, upper belly pain, dark urine or yellowing of skin or eyes. these could be signs of serious side effects. i'm down with crestor! make your move. ask your doctor about crestor.

in garland texas, fbi director said his

agency sent ought a -- out a bullet 10a bulletin just hours before the attack. it had simpsons photo and license, but not clear whether garland police received a pollute bulletin or knew anything about it, not clear why the fbi did notableo act on the spot to be certain they were at the center in garland texas. of that not addressed. >> woman targeted in the attack is criticizing obama administration saying no one in federal government contacted her despite islamic state death threats

against her. >> no, and this is interesting because this is not terrorist threat -- this is a terrorist threat, and fbi, president obama should provide security there is no question about it because he created an environment that raised stakes on this. lou: and director did not mention whether he warned pam geller of an impending attack. there are a lot of questions around this fbi bulletin. some irony, united nations yesterday held an event to press freedom to focus on protecting journalist safety and their rights. journalists were not allowed by the united nations to attend at all. >> joining us now billionaire real estate, mort zuckerman. let's start with the idea this negotiation with iran may have set off a nuclear

arms race among arab states in the middle east. >> it will. there are a lot of states that are arab states that are concerned about the growing power of iran. saudi arabia, egypt jordan, the emirates and turkey, all of our allies are those who are threatened okay? and all of our enemies are those who are supported by this thing. i -- i have to agree with what you you saying i do not understand what this is about, in is the silliest, most counter productive policy i could imagine. you put iran in a position they have nuclear capabilities within a short period of time that could you have to assume they will use it to try to destroy israel.

and they will have this weapon? and we're participating in it in some way. lou: as you suggestion, where is the countervailing influence in this debate. what should be a debate over u.s. policy. instead republicans have receded, and prime minister netanyahu had been one clear voice in opposition, his voice has been muted. or he has decided too withdraw from the public discussion. which is it? >> i think the latter, i know for sure, that the israelis very nervous and rightly concerned about what happens if you have a radical country like, ran with nuclear weapon that threatened the destruction of israel, and a country that is sort of active not a terrorist government but they are against the current organization of. these are -- this problem

how could we in a sense act in a way that strengthens our most serious adversary iran and basically threatens all of our friends in the region. lou: are your concerns, should concerns of american people be allayed by senate vote today 98 move-1 to authorize, congressional review of any deal that the administration reaches with iran. to reduce its nuclear capabilities, do you believe that significant and freuh protection. >> i think it will is a start there is a position by if the president rejects and vetoes, what the resolution they come up with they will have to go back and that is when the -- the -- the you will find whether they have enough to override the president's veto. the general belief is they won't. lou: well, that is deeply

troubling as well. >> hugely trouble troubling. >> mort zuckerman always good to have you here. >> now deflate gate? who should be -- cast your vote. oklahoma has declared a state of merge and a dozen counties more than 50 tornadoes across parts of the midwest more than a dozen people were hurt, twisters destroyed homes and overturned cars, no reports of deaths, more tornado unlogicly tonight but a slight chance of thunderstorm across the great plains and parts of texas. >> tornado are common in tornado alley they are not in northern germany, that is what happened yesterday. an am tush video capturing approach of the twister tornado causing damage one

person was killed. >> up next earnings many faces of hillary clinton to display as she pandered her way to the dem thecrattic president -- democratic presidential nomination.

lou: a few thoughts on hypocrisy, most of us have grown to accept as normal behavior among our political class when presidential season warms up. there are those candidates who are hyper-hyper critical. thus attract unwanted attention to themselves. hillary clinton is just such a candidate, she met with a group of magadanors who

contribute big money. the democratic super pac. hillary in face-to-face meetings with super pac donors just days after railing against so-called unaccountable money. >> we need to fix our disfunctional political system get unaccountable money out of it once and for all. we have to get rid of the unauctionthe -- it may take a constitutional amendment to say no unaccountable corporate billionaire money flowing into the political system. lou: the clintons don't demand accountability of themselves with donors of their clinton initiative. their foundation. and hillary claimed that ridding politics of unaccountable money is one

of her campaign's big four fights. it appears that hillary is ripping the obama playbook on super pac money out of its binding expa and stamping her name all over it. and flip-flopping on illegal immigration. >> i will fight for comprehensive immigration reform, and a path to citizenship. and if congress continues to refuse to act as president i would to everything possible under the law to go even further. lou: nice to know she would at least try to stay within the law. hillary did president obama one better saying she would spare parents of dreamers from deportation.

but since 2003 she has said she is against illegal immigrants until she wasn't. on justice issues she calls for criminal justice reform. >> it is time to change our approach, time to end the era of mass incarceration. lou: who ushered that era in? her husband in 1994, who signed violent crime control and law enforcement act that imposed -- harder sentences for repeat offenders. hillary is not doing a lot of explaining about it, she has yet to answer any questions about her hypocrisy, and her brand-new positions. since he launched her campaign, she answered only 7 questions from reporters.

7. can this nation take another president like president obama? so open, so transparent so accessible to fourth estate, so -- well cognizant of their responsibilities to allow american citizenry to know what they are doing. i'm not sure we can handle two presidents in a row like that do you? >> our quotation from the evening. if a politician found he had cannibals among his constituents he would promise them missionaries for dinner. we're coming right back, stay with us. >> coming up, a federal appellate court said that nsa cannot collect phone records of ordinary americans. what do our attorneys say? and the nfl accuses tom brady and the patriots of cheating -- sort of, kind of. at least the odds are they were said the nfl.

we'll see what sports markets legend will life begins with a howl, we scream, shout shriek with joy. until, inhibition creeps in, our world gets smaller quieter, but life should be loud. sing loud, play loud, love loud. dentures shouldn't keep you quiet life should be ringing in your ears. live loud, super poligrip.

>> >> the long-awaited much-anticipated report charging the patriots to dr. football star in the championship game alleging tom brady was at least generally aware but the

controversy began earlier is in the season for all of the 60th of october the jets complaining grimly through the entire game of the over inflation of the tobolsk complaining to the officials 20 of 37 passes. they did squeak out though with. then with the chicago bears completing 31 of 35 passes and the patriots destroyed the bears and 51 / 23. the difference? brady's claims he sat down with the equipment assistant and they read the rules for the air pressure for the very first time during that meeting brady said he said keeps an inflated at the lowest permissible level. now to bring us up-to-date a

sports marketing legend and the sports marketer from anheuser-busch and u.s. homeland's security agent joining us tonight. set to start with this background not a lot of emphasis. the emails between the equipment and the officials assistant but those are nasty messages in part it looks like brady has been railroaded in the patriots have been railroaded and very few people are talking about that. >> we talked for months ago once the nfl allows the

quarterbacks to manipulate the balls it started to unravel a little bit. i have to believe these men did not do this without some sort of direction. and may not have done anything to hurt the integrity. so it is not exactly quality control in a men's room. [laughter] so that you have human error that he is trying to defend himself against. >> i take it is direct air and undelivered but wait you look at the report to it speaks for itself talking about probable cause it sounds like that to me because i am the investigators. >> it is a reason to

investigate but the odds are is hardly the stuff a man's reputation and should be indicted publicly the nfl makes them look like fools. it could have been handled in so many ways. it is clear they did not care enough about the pressure in the football to put somebody assigned to cover that. what responsibility does the nfl have? >> you cannot take five months to investigate. you have to believe this is the are you don't want it out during the super bowl but when you're that indecisive and you need the

media to structure the conversation but then to move on. lou: what is your reaction how the nfl handled this? >> there were complaints of over inflation the officials did not warrant the patriots a and it did not discuss its but made it look like a sting operation. >> when you talk about over and under inflation everybody tries to get a competitive edge. these are murky waters now that it has come to light i think it will protect themselves but talk about oh for inflation of calls calls, usually you see that going from the east coast to the west coast miami to denver because of the air

pressure a and the altitude. then from denver to the east coast those balls were under inflated. i think they will make sure this does not happen again. is the integrity check he won the game where it is even. lou: did you ever grab a jersey? >> yes i did. lou: that is illegal. how could you do that? >> you could grab you can't and told that. [laughter] >> just a little pinch. [laughter] >> you got me on that. lou: i know your coaches

never would have talked to you about how to get past the defensive back. that wouldn't have been but the point i'm making is obvious. if the nfl wants to shut it down they will it seems like such a management screw up on the part of the nfl he could handle this we weren't having this discussion. >> just as a parable to pine tar or paper add the pitcher's mound so it is a new era in the n.f.l. i think they will take charge because i believe they will protect that shield. >> day you think they should be punished like a common criminal? they have been made to look terrible by the nfl.

>> there should be some sort of punishment and how to make sure this does not happen again. lou: how much responsibility does the nfl commissioner bear? when i see what he has done with domestic violence he lives like he is capable to screw it up and he sits here to put the patriots and a crazy position. >> your respective boards of directors be repaid $35 million to be the boss may want to see roger to be the boss. he is listening to too many people the orders have voices then you start to scramble a little bit.

but it is time for him to step forward to do what he thinks is right and if there is consequences i would rather have those that have us criticized for not doing the right thing. lou: should there be a significant penalty for tom brady were the patriots? >> i think two games with a fine which i hope would be given to some and been positive like domestic violence. lou: i.e. where the justice research committee. [laughter] be sure to vote who should be assistant -- suspended? we will give you three choices. cast your vote we would like to hear from you. a shocking incident from possible hate crimes to

gateman claim the fight erupted after lobbying and it quickly spun out of control to smash a chair over their heads them of hate crime task force is on the case. world wide leaders show bring new products to revolutionize industries we will take you there live and a successful bank robbery goes wrong a remarkable story. next. when cigarette cravings hit, all i can think about is getting relief. nicorette mini starts to relieve sudden cravings fast. anytime. anywhere. i never know when i'll need relief. that's why i choose nicorette mini.

lou: stock's closing higher 82 points and the s&p up eight believe on the big board 3.7 billion shares. listen to my records three times a day coast-to-coast. posted the largest gathering of industry leaders from all across the globe with a

drone technology a main to revolutionize life on planet earth changing now the news is gathered and agriculture is observing and maintained and homes are being sold more we have the report. >> bedroom behind the attack helping us out with a live shot is the connect system for what they can do is transmit video from long distances more than half a mile away with no delay. so here at the show waiting at the gate for commercial use to give the go-ahead it will have a significant impact on the economy. the trade group that puts on the show. >> once we have regulation

will be $83 billion in this industry allowed -- allows. >> the - - they are still reviewing public comments but the agency announced it is expanding research with a handful of private companies to explore the use of commercial drones operating behind -- beyond line of sight in the rural areas because that could pave the way for routine use for agriculture and utility inspection yet even package delivery. >> instead of waiting one day you could get delivery from stores in local area from 30 minutes or that piece itself within five minutes. >> this is called alice it looks like it is from "star wars" but the shape helps it to navigate indoors.

you don't have the benefit of gps because the ceiling box a satellite so it can of the into walls and roll on the ground to lend itself without causing damage to the propeller. the creators envisioned it to be used by firefighters for search and rescue or searching for flames there is a lot of potential in this convention hall. lou: that is incredible. reporting from the international money and systems conference. >> 50 found out that humility does have some advantages and benefits. behind bars tonight after posting this video. his video of his bank robbery in virginia beach. but he himself from the bank. he did pretty well 150

grand. police caught up with him 20 minutes later he claims that simply asking for money is not a crime. he has a point but apparently he did more than just that. the president called her the best looking attorney general in the country but her career isn't looking too good. we will take that up next. the world is filled with air. but for people with copd sometimes breathing air can be difficult. if you have copd, ask your doctor about once-daily anoro ellipta. it helps people with copd breathe better for a full 24hours. anoro ellipta is the first fda-approved product containing two long-acting bronchodilators in one inhaler. anoro is not for asthma.

anoro contains a type of medicine that increases risk of death in people with asthma. it is not known if this risk is increased in copd. anoro won't replace rescue inhalers for sudden copd symptoms and should not be used more than once a day. tell your doctor if you have a heart condition, or high blood pressure. tell your doctor if you have glaucoma, prostate or bladder problems, or problems passing urine as anoro may make these problems worse. call your doctor right away if you have worsened breathing chest pain, swelling of your mouth or tongue, problems urinating or eye problems including vision changes or eye pain while taking anoro. nothing can reverse copd. the world is filled with air and anoro is helping people with copd breath air better. get your first prescription free at anoro.com.

. lou: joining us now, two of the best attorneys in the country. mercedes colwin, and rebecca rose woodland. great to have you here. >> great to be here. >> let's start with the deflategate. odds are there's no proof here of anything! is there some vulnerability from the nfl? >> did you see the text messages? it's so clear that tom knew or obviously from the text messages it implicated him pretty much the equipment assistant and the locker room assistant talking about the balls. lou: other messages look like they're setting him up. >> well.

lou: they're saying epithet tom brady or tom, actually. >> i think that was in the context of why doesn't he give us more for what we're doing in exchange for him? now, that can't be -- lou: it was in the context of why --. >> are you a patriots fan? that's what i'm wondering? >> are you defending tom brady. lou: i'm really not a fan, i respect them as a team they're amazing, i think brady is an incredible quarterback. >> wait a minute wait a minute, wait a minute. footballs that aren't regulation. lou: wait by the way. the previous games they were using footballs that weren't regulation either. and overinflated to beyond 16 pounds for crying out loud. >> what's going on then? when you have text message that say i want a size sneakers, i want balls. >> jerseys. autographed footballs. >> talking about the footballs and talking about how he's a

jerk and he's an f-jerk and all that stuff in the text messages over and over and over again. lou: do you like tom brady? >> i do not. lou: why is that? >> giants the giants. they're the best! >> there is evidence, and i'm very middle of the road here. there is evidence that tom had phone calls only at certain times with people he would never normally interact. lou: is it a misdemeanor or felony. >> goodell has to take care of it within the nfl group. lou: you are corporate law here if you are advising the nfl owner's committee and you have a commissioner who decided to blow this thing up into what it has become instead of handling it as he could have in the instant case when the balls were overinflated and saw the patriots were allegedly, at that point, adjusting them back

toward what mr. braidy wanted, why didn't he just say, look, warning, this is it. stop it now. this is the way it's going to be and we're going to have an nfl official look over the balls. instead goodell has trotted out the nfl and hung them out to dry publicly when it could have been handled like that. >> with a $40 million paycheck. isn't that what he makes? neil: 45 million. >> run the organization like it should be run. incentive to have a football and super bowl with the patriots in it is incredible money. huge profit in that. why goodell didn't do it maybe he thought this could have a problem with the patriots. maybe he said let's do this afterwards. afterwards he should have taken care of this internally. that's his job. if tom brady did something, didn't do something, kraft says my players didn't do anything do the investigation make a decision, close it out. that's it. lou: 103 days to say the odds

are. we could have done that after one day and three hours. >> by the way, a white shoe firm wrote the 243-page report. how much did that cost? at least seven figures. lou: at least. and now what have they got? they've gotten by the super bowl, by the draft and the combine, and what are we into, the slowest period in football. this is what's going to be talked about. i would call -- if i'm an owner i call mr. goodell and say mr. goodell, you've got to start acting like you are smarter than you are and do better than you have beginning now. >> exactly. lou: or we're going to suspend you for a year. thank you, both time for a look at our online poll results. we asked --

thanks for participating in our scientific poll. we appreciate you voting. coming up tomorrow, former national intelligence director kheryl in for neil cavuto thank you for watching. >> deep in the swamps of central florida. >> we have a couple,000 alligators. -- a couple hundred crocodiles. >> lurks one "strange inheritance." >> my ideal all along was that i could build something that i could pass down to my family. >> always in the back of your mind? >> always. jamie: can we name this one jamie? >> absolutely. >> passing down an enterprise like this can be trecherrous. >> we might have to hit the road. >> it might be soldout from under us. >> it is risky business. >> what happened to your finger? >> a correct deal bit it off -- crocodile bit it