holiday. [closing bell rings] david asman, melissa francis picking it up here for "after the bell." melissa: stocks slammed, major averages ending the day down more than 1%. i'm melissa francis. david: i'm david asman this is "after the bell." we have you covered on big market movers. here is what else we have for you this hour. donald trump unshackled launching a twitter storm against paul ryan and other republicans in congress who have severed their ties with him. we'll be speaking with one who is still standing by his man trump, calling his colleagues in the gop, gutless. new trove of emails released from clinton campaign chair john podesta apparently show collusion between the clinton team and the department of justice during the email investigation. the latest details on that to come. this as al gore joins hillary clinton at a campaign event in miami. what it took to get him off the

sidelines and what it means for her campaign. melissa: back to the markets. the dow ending the day down more than 200 points. only one of the 30 blue-chips is in the green. that is apple. we have a story behind that coming up. meanwhile oil taking a hit as well today. trader todd horowitz is watching action from the cme. ashley webster on the floor of the new york stock exchange. ashley, you were watching some of the biggest losers down there. reporter: yeah, absolutely. could be worse. we were down 267 at one point on the dow. coming back if you like, still down 197 points. no doubt about it, celloff today. look at some stocks were biggest drag on the dow. there you have it, merck, down 3%. unitedhealth group down nearly 2 1/2%. the health care sector biggest drag on the dow, the s&p and the nasdaq by the way. fears of perhaps a democratic sweep in the presidential elections would be hard on health care. there again donald trump said he wanted to lower health care costs as well. either way, health care stocks hurting today.

intel down nearly 2%. johnson & johnson also down nearly 2%. we're kicking off the third quarter earnings season, taking a look at alcoa. boy, oh, boy, did this set the tone. alcoa as you can see down nearly 11 1/2%. it missed on earnings and revenue. also the revenue guidance from alcoa was weaker than expected put that all together, not a great way to kick off the earnings season, alcoa getting punished down some 11%. vix volatility index up today as you might imagine, up well, 15%. one of those days guys, back to you. david: ashley, thank you very much. todd, as you heard some are blaming the stock dive on alcoa and other earnings. others say it is oil and the rise in the dollar. what say the commodity traders? >> what do you say, david? dollar is extremely strong.

oil based on rest of the performance of market held up remarkably well. i believe oil probably reached its pinnacle and start to head lower. i don't think it had anything to do with selloff and rumors of opec and other things we're seeing is little bit of fear in the oil space. fear of opec and based on yesterday's bombing in yemen or the firing missiles at ship. once those go away i think oil comes straight down. david: todd, thank you very much. melissa? melissa: alcoa reporting today, signaling the unofficial start of the earnings season not only leading market lower but raising concern what some are calling a earnings recession. we have scott shellady, and john petrides. what do you think about this? >> on raw material side, we're seeing an oversupply due to china but on aerospace side we're seeing a big slowdown or at least destocking which

verifies what honeywell said last week where they're seeing slow down on aerospace side. according to klaus kleinfeld, a slowdown on growth section of alcoa. melissa: scott, do you buy that? what is your market telling you? >> what i'm hearing and this is what i'm seeing, goes against what everybody is saying, how does that sound? for last five years we're waiting for second half recovery. every single start to the year we talk about the second half recovery. guess what? it doesn't happen, like we'll have four interest rate rises at the end of the year. at the end of the day they are guiding lower guidance. we don't have a strong enough economy. look what corporate ceos of america are doing. they're not expanding, not buying new plants, not buying new buildings. we don't see true growth. second half recovery, blame it on hurricane matthew, they will find a reason why. melissa: they're not just blaming it on hurricane matthew. a a lot of companies are blaming

election. that consumers are waiting until january to spend because of the election? john, does that make any sense to you? scott i will ask you in a second. >> that seems like a ridiculous excuse. only person i can see with organization wait something maybe a cfo to make some decision if donald trump becomes elected. but for consumers not to spend, that is ridiculous. melissa: scott, carnival cruise lines said bookings are down now as they get close toward election. huh? people are not going a cruise, why? they don't have television or social media can't follow election on the ship. i don't even understand that explanation. how can they get away with that? >> is the election excuse for the economy for the last seven years? like being surprised by cold weather in january. commodities traders just don't do that. no, it is not election. it is the economy, stupid. ultimately we just don't have growth. look at gdp. we're not expanding it. we're putting people back to work. something stinks here and

somebody has to ring the bell. melissa: yeah. david: guys, samsung announcing today they are permanently killing production of the galaxy note 7. the failed recall has gone from bad to worse causing headaches for customers, wiping 11 billion bucks off the parent company market cap in one day and sending apple to new 2016 high. as they continue to convert angry samsung customers into new iphone users. first of all, scott, i love the fact that you're wearing your cme trading coat in london, england. you're a loyal guy. i love that. does samsung pull out of this at all? >> if i was marketing manager samsung now is new slogan wait for the eight. how does that sound? melissa: i like that. >> ultimately, this disaster in the short term. i understand why apple is higher in the back of it. they will miss out on customers. i tell you, i'm a samsung customer myself. i love their phones.

ultimately it will get it together but will take time like chipotle. david: i'm a samsung user as well but got to tell you in the future i may not be if they mishandle it. >> this is game, set, match, on high-end smartphone where they had a nice product, galaxy 7. off a ho-hum year with the iphone 7. you want a phone that will work. you don't want to buy one that will maybe blow up or go on fire. samsung had a window. this is gift for apple. apple iphone 7s will be 10-year anniversary from original iphone. it's a gift for the it phone. melissa: i love this next story. venture capital on demand. if you have the next million dollar idea or multimillion-dollar, celebrity three hour window on thursday in new york. you can give your best "elevator pitch" to actual investor. hail it on your phone, call uber. they send a vc guy over to you, you have seven minutes to make your best pitch.

scott shellady, what do you think? what is your pitch? >> before i was in finance i was art major. this is terribly creative. i absolutely love it. i wonder how it will work out. they don't screen ideas before you get into the car. three minutes into the ride if it's a bad idea do they send you home in a guber, not a uber? what happens if they don't like it. melissa: i was checking this out to look for all the dedays. you can't really find it all. they have done it in other cities. i have a feeling the guy comes to you, then leaves. they can't put you in the car with the vc guy. i don't know, sounds crazy, great ad for uber. they're always thinking of great stuff like this. >> i agree with you. fun idea. chance of getting idea hitting hitting lottery ticket, right person with right venture capital, in the right car at right time and seven minutes to pitch the person. anyway great market marketing for uber. melissa: they wrap it up with a panel.

giving out prizes at the end. that is cool. thanks, guys. david: look you how the big scott shellady, was an art major. that is pretty cool. we discover ad lot. donald trump unshackled in his own word on the republican establishment. lawn muching a twitter storm against paul ryan, john mccain and others who spoke out against him. one congressman says these defectors are gutless. melissa: former vice president al gore campaigned with hillary clinton in miami mime now. the two have kept their distance. why is he coming off the sidelines to join her? david: clintons offering a few tax breaks the wealthy will have to pay for. grover norquist coming up with his tax take coming up. >> hillary is interesting in killing the rich. what is that going to do to create jobs in america?

just like that, a moment turns romantic. so why pause to take a pill?

and when you're having fun why stop to find a bathroom? with cialis for daily use, you don't have to plan around either. it's the only daily tablet approved to treat erectile dysfunction so you can be ready anytime the moment is right. plus cialis treats the frustrating urinary symptoms of bph, like needing to go frequently, day or night. tell your doctor about all your medical conditions and medicines, and ask if your heart is healthy enough for sex. do not take cialis if you take nitrates for chest pain, or adempas for pulmonary hypertension, as it may cause an unsafe drop in blood pressure. do not drink alcohol in excess. side effects may include headache, upset stomach, delayed backache or muscle ache. to avoid long-term injury, get medical help right away for an erection lasting more than four hours. if you have any sudden decrease or loss in hearing or vision, or any symptoms of an allergic reaction, stop taking cialis and get medical help right away. why pause the moment? ask your doctor about cialis for daily use. and for a $200 savings card, go to cialis.com

david: blast from the past. al gore speaking at miami-dade college. speaking about importance of millenial and undecided voters talking about climate change of course. adam shapiro with the very latest. adam? reporter: it's a speech about climate change from hillary clinton and al gore. clinton addressed crowd, clean energy in the united states should be the clean energy superpower of this century. there needs to be a transition to clean energy. she pledged to have 500 million solar panels installed across north america in the next four years should she become president. then al gore took the stage. he picked up the discussion

about the need to back and vote a climate change believer. but then he brought up the issue of what happened in 2000 with the hanging chads and the florida recount. he told everyone here it was crucial that they vote. that every vote counts. listen to what he had to say. >> i don't want you to to be in a position years from now, where you welcome hillary clinton and say, actually you did win. it wasn't close enough to make sure that all the votes were counted or whatever. elections have consequences. [cheering] your vote counts. your vote has consequences. reporter: so it is also important to point out this is the first time that al gore has hit the campaign trail for hillary clinton and with hillary clinton.

they say though that mrs. clinton will be back in florida as we get closer to the election, florida being a key state, 29 electoral votes up for grabs. one of her messages here on what has just been five days since hurricane matthew came through, is need to elect someone like her who will deal with steps to deal with climate change. david: adam, thank you very much. melissa: steve hilton, former strategy question for david cameron. mustafa timiz is democratic strategist. thanks for joining us. steve, let me start with you. they trot out al gore to connect with millenials. my only question, seems like in this election millenials are sort of suspicious and distrustful of the whole establishment, including hillary clinton. sort of everybody who was there before and that is why they were looking at bernie sanders. does al gore solve that problem? >> i think you're exactly right. i think we should be at least

grateful that they are not talking about donald trump's sex tape, not sex tape exactly but you know what i mean. melissa: right. >> i think you're right, even if you really care about climate change, if you are a true believer in al gore's change, the idea gore or clinton or that kind of establishment politics funded by big business of which this generation is particularly suspicious is going to actually make a difference to the real issue even if you care about it? i just don't they're buying it. i don't think this will actually have that much impact on the actual election. melissa: i mean although, kristin, the whole point of having him out there, the point he was trying to make in the clip there, was he feels like, what made the difference for him, were it not for ralph nader he would be president because people went out and voted for ralph nader. don't you do to hillary clinton what voters back then did for me, did to me, throwing away their vote on what would be now your green party candidate instead of her. you will only be helping trump. you have to get out there to

vote for her because your vote matters. don't throw it away on the green party. is he making that pitch? is it too nuanced for everybody in that audience to get? >> bear in mind that most of the folks in that audience were probably in middle elementary, preschool when the whole florida election went down. i mean i'm at oldest edge of millenial generation. i was not old enough to vote in the election. i remember hearing about ralph nader may have drawn votes away from al gore, did that swing the election? you have a lot of young voters who are flirting with idea voting for gary johnson, voting for jill stein, going to the polls to cast protest . he is solutely right f younger voters don't vote for hillary clinton it jeopardizes her chance to put together the electoral majorities she understood. fascinating all the message and folks are chanting you won, you won, when most were probably in elementary school at best when that election happened.

melissa: that is a great point. clearly someone told them to chant that. that is not a natural roar you hear from audience of people who weren't even old enough to be deep into politics that moment in time necessarily. mustafa, let me ask you, it does show you though how much better organized democrats are. they're out there cleaning up loose ends. they're addressing this issue with millenials that might vote for third party candidates out there. you hear reports, registering to vote down in florida or getting those absentee ballots that they're way ahead in florida on that organization. this, your thoughts on those? >> well look, from al gore to bernie sanders, the democratic party has come together while donald trump is on a tirade, you know, destroying the republican party and really dividing americans and so the democratic party is come together. they are three points ahead in florida.

hillary clinton has a national lead, almost in double digits in national polls. so this is a, you know what was a competitive election and now she has got a substance lead and donald trump has only himself to blame. he is divider. melissa: we're not talking about donald trump in this segment. we were talking about is actually complimenting the democrats on their organization there. so that was actually not what we were talking about. >> look, i think, i think that you're right, that there is a lot that is happening but, in a way, thank you for complimenting democrats for doing that but in a way because of divisiveness he created it is uniting the democratic party. melissa: i don't think so actually. i think this is the game they play every election very, very well. thank you for your opinion. thanks to all three of you. david: dangerous flooding conditions remain in north carolina as emergency officials are urging residents to seek higher ground. plus the tension escalating within the grand ol' party but

some republicans are standing by their nominee. next congressman dana rohrabacher sounding off on the dangers of the gop of pulling support from donald trump. >> the issue you for next 28 days are you for donald trump, issue is are you prepared to have hillary clinton as president? you will get donald trump or hillary clinton. hillary clinton will be in every way worse than barack obama. is it a professor who never stops being a student? is it a caregiver determined to take care of her own? or is it a lifetime of work that blazes the path to your passions? your personal success takes a financial partner

who values it as much as you do. learn more at tiaa.org

david: donald trump versus the establishment. the gop nominee unleashing a series of tweets slamming house peeker paul ryan and other republicans for not supporting him. he kicked off early morning tweet storm saying quote, despite winning second debate in landslide, every poll, it is hard to do well when paul ryan and others give zero support, end quote. here republican congressman dana rohrabacher from california. congressman, i believe you used to write for ronald reagan. i was just thinking, what would ronald reagan think of what has

happened to the republican party? >> well, ronald reagan was a victim of the same party establishment negating his chances of being elected just like don trump. every time ronald reagan ran for office, whether it was governor, the first time, i was chairman of youth for reagan for l.a. county in 1966 when i ran for governor. oh, he can't win. the establishment, he can't, same when he ran for president. he can't win. he can't win. trump, it is same thing. the establishment is -- david: when ronald reagan became the nominee, he didn't attack the people that were sort of lukewarm about him. donald trump, according to charlie gasparino anyway, our own charlie gasparino is reporting that trump is actually encouraging a pac to run against paul ryan in his election? >> well i think that it is a natural for a guy like don trump to be upset when people who are supposed to be loyal to him now

that he has won the primary process, rather than betraying all the primary voters and backing the nominee of the party, now they're going to trash trump and throw him out because, they don't like what the result of the primary elections were. of course he should be upset with them. of course he should be, and i'm upset with them and most rank-and-file are upset with these guys who, they're betraying the republican voters in the primary. i wasn't a trump person in the primary but i respect the outcome of the primary process or i should get out of the republican party! david: would you go so far as to give support to a pac that was trying to get paul ryan defeated? >> you know, let me tell you something, paul ryan is doing everything he can do to get trump defeated. so why are you not complaining about that? that is much more significant because trump won the election, trump won the primary. betraying the republican voters

in the primary is a betrayal of the republican party. that is what ryan is doing by, by throwing trump under the bus. david: finally, what about the house and the senate? how does all of this translate into more trouble or support for the republicans who are running in the house and the senate? >> well, because we have our own leadership in the house and senate that is being disloyal to the winner, to the nominee of the party, that's bound to hurt us in our elections. the republican, the voters are bound to say, why am i voting for these nice. they don't even respect my vote in the primary? so it is bound to hurt us. paul ryan should have known that before he stepped up. and unfortunately it caused great damage but this is typical of the establishment of the republican party. yeah, as long as they're winning the primaries everybody has to stand in line, which we have to back them up but if we get

somebody more in the anti-establishment wing of the party or more patriotic, working class, blue-collar republicans, they get their nominee and all of sudden the elitists aren't going to back him up. that is what is destroying party and chances winning election. by the way trump is going to win and i think we'll keep control because we represent what people want. david: congressman rohrabacher, just for those who don't know, he was there in the beginning of the reagan revolution as he said. and was working for ronald reagan. he has seen this twice. congressman, thank you very much for being here, appreciate it. melissa. melissa: new reports coming out saying bully bush will be leaving "the today show" permanently following the leaked 2005 tape that surfaced last week with donald trump. big surprise there, right? nbc reportedly in the process of negotiating bush's exit from the show. we'll keep you updated with any new developments on this one, just in case you're wondering

how that part of the story was turning out. david: there is this story. more leaked emails coming out surrounding the clinton campaign sparking major controversies. >> hillary clinton revealing a new tax break for parents. how is she going to pay for it? what about everybody else? grover norquist's take on taxes. that is coming up next. >> hillary clinton is raising your taxes folks. you can look at me. she is raising your taxes really high. and what that is going to do is a disaster for the country. this woman owns this house, with new cabinets from this shop, with handles designed here, made here, shipped from here, on this plane flown by this pilot, who owns stock in this company, that builds big things and provides benefits to this woman, with new cabinets. they all have insurance crafted personally for them. not just coverage, craftsmanship. not just insured. chubb insured.

david: let's go to ashley webster for what was driving today's selloff? reporter: david, the health care stocks are dragging down the dow, the worst-performing sectors. some of the stocks for you here merck down 3%. unitedhealth down 2 1/2%. j&j, johnson & johnson down nearly 2%. pfizer down 1 1/2%. a lot of discussion here on the floor about the presidential election and what does it mean for health care stocks. both candidates in the sunday's debate talk about driving down health care costs. a lot of investors deciding to get out of health care. that was the leading drag on the dow. i want to look at 10-year treasury yield as well. we saw that jump up to a high we haven't seen since back on june 2nd up to 1.76.

oil down, the dollar strong. put it all together, we have a selloff today, guys. david: ashley, thank you. melissa? melissa: more emails coming out with the clinton campaign in the latest batch of wikileaks dump. blake burman sifted through the mountains of emails. he has got the details right now. blake, what sticks out to you? reporter: melissa, there are more than 1000 emails in the third document dump in wikileaks and john podesta, hillary clinton chairman. we'll give you a couple of items that caught our eye. may 2015, month two of the clinton email story, campaign spokesman bryan fallon emailed the top campaign aides he was given a heads up from within the department of justice about a filing for proposed production schedule for clinton's emails to be released. as you might imagine that did not sit well with republicans. in fact the rnc set out a statement saying of clinton, i'm quoting here, instead of facing consequences for her actions like others have she has been protected at ery turn by the

obama administration so she ca continue failed policies of the last eight years. i asked the clinton campaign for a response? their statement targeted trump. quoting here. donald trump has once again cheered on russian hacking after he willfully misrepresented at debate that hacking may not be happening. separately, additionally wikileaks shows coziness between the clinton campaign and media outlets, "new york times," cnbc, univision and cnn in one email donna brazile, then of cnn acting democratic national committee chair, shown to have emailed clinton staff ahead of cnn debate a question she shays she saw beforehand. the title of that very email was quote, from time to time i get the questions in advance. now brazile put out a statement today denying any wrongdoing. writing quote i neve to questions and would never

share them with candidates if i did. two out of a whole long list from that third batch earlier today. melissa: i don't understand. there is email right there. i never had access and i never shared them? reporter: part of her statement. i have the question. the question was about criminal justice reform and what ended up making it into the debate was pretty much spot on and get that statement from her. melissa: well, all right. anyone can say anything i guess. blake, thank you for that. whatever, just say anything. david: the leaked emails are sparking controversy as the rnc criticizes the clinton campaign. our panel back with us to react. kristin we heard one story, cnn working possibly working in tandem with the clinton campaign in a way. and cnbc also. does it surprise you, because for me, i mean, i think it kind of goes without saying that the media basically supportive of the clinton campaign, right? >> i don't think that is quite it. i think that there is a, there

is sort of bizarre relationship that happens between journalists and their source as lot -- david: by the way, john harwood of cnbc we're seeing, go ahead. >> yes. somebody like a john harwood would have, these really cozy relationships with potential sources. john has reached out to me in the past, asking me what is your take on x, y and z. journal its do that hopes of getting comfort level with people. when it comes to the cnn issue and donna brazile, the fault in that case false on donna, less so than cnn doesn't seem like concerted for cnn to help with the clinton campaign. when you have partisan commentators you have dual loyalty thing going on. at do you do if you have a piece of information that can help your campaign? clearly in this case the email says one thing. donna's comments afterwards say another. that is par for the course. david: let me give steve a chance to weigh in here on the russian angle. the clinton campaign is trying

desperately to link donald trump and russia and they are helping wikileaks because they want to see donald trump. do europeans or british in particular buy any of that? >> i don't think they focused on that part of it and the reason that is something relevant here in america you hear all this stuff about russians hacking and trying to influence the election but you haven't actually had the president make a serious intervention on that because if that is true, and if they know that that is true, then why aren't they really raising it officially with the russian government, making a big deal of it. david: good point. >> if they did that, that would be a big international story and people might take it seriously as well as people here. david: mustafa, one angle, the clinton campaign is talking about elevating the paid pipers of the republican party, in particular donald trump as somebody who would divide the party and pull it to an extreme that the independents wouldn't go for.

is there any truth to that? >> well look, donald trump is dividing the republican party. that is obvious. david: but did the dnc have a plan to do that, to push that strategy? >> nobody has to push that strategy. donald trump is look at his tweets last night with paul ryan. but look, there is a consensus amongst the intelligence community that the russians are the ones that are behind the hacks. we found a russian company on an interview that said they're the ones that have been doing it on behest of the kremlin. the evidence is overwhelming that the russians are behind the hacks. they're giving it to wikileaks. david: do you think the russians are working with the trump campaign, that is the question mustafa? >> look the last chairman of the trump campaign was a registered foreign agent connected to, you know -- david: you're going there? >> resigned because of that. david: kristin, sounds like mustafa is going there. >> i'm not trying to hide it. the former chair of the trump

campaign was a registered foreign agent. david: all right. >> that is not a secret. that is why he resigned. david: i understand. i'm surprised you would bring the trump camp into this but gang, there is a lot more to come with all these wikileaks, leaks. thanks very much for being here. appreciate it. melissa. melissa: hillary clinton unveiling a new tax break giving additional thousand dollars a year to parents with young children. how is she going to pay for this? if she is vowing not to raise taxes on the middle class? >> we've got to make it clear as i have, i am not raising taxes on middle-class families, period! melissa: grover norquist, americans for tax reform president. he is also and he is the founder. he joins me now. grover, thanks for joining us. what do you think what she said? >> it is not true but i know she

has said it but endorsed wage tax, which hits everybody who earns less than $118,000 a year. that hits everybody in the class. class and lower middle she endorsed soda pop tax and u.n.-endorsed her idea of a soda pop tax internationally. that is tax particularly hit hits low incomes people. she advocates a gun tax of 25%. she endorsed the seven of the obama 20 taxes, that directly hit middle income people including a tax that forces you into obamacare. she endorsed and promised and threatened many taxes that only hit poor people. and yet she keeps saying she is only going to tax the rich. she hasn't finished the sentence, i will tax them first but been very free and her tax hikes on middle income americans and her chief of staff, podesta, not from wikileaks, but from his

own mouth, he endorsed the, he said they are going to do a vat, not just right away on energy. melissa: don't want to, if we look at them side by side, on the screen and hillary clinton's complex brackets. had a hard time making foul screen. david: wow. melissa: those are groups we're talking about, no income tax rate cuts for anybody. nobody is paying less. everybody is paying the same, probably more. given all the things that you just said. no reforming the tax code. she has never talked about that. she has no interest in doing that. look at donald trump's tax plan by contrast. he has three tax brackets, simply filing it. not enough for everyone. what do you think of donald trump's plan? how you would you critique or change that one? >> trump's plan dramatically reducing business tax rate and full expensing and going to tear tore ralty would be tremendous pro-growth policy it is almost identical to paul ryan's which

is very funny two of them are having an argument. it is not over tax policy republican party is united. "wall street journal," i don't know if this can be seen, every quintile, top 20%, bottom 20%, all do better under trump's entire plan than hillary's entire plan, even with the new tweak. this "wall street journal," using brookings own numbers based off of hillary's data. so, hillary's people admit that, however much money you make, whatever whether you're rich, poor or middle, donald trump is better for you taxwise than hillary is. melissa: grover, thank you. appreciate you breakit down so quick. david? david: no doubt you have seen the stories about creepy clowns. people dressing up as clowns in order to scare and prank people, it has gotten so big, that mcdonald's famous clown mascot seen here is keeping low profile. mcdonald's is being thoughtful in respect to ronald

mcdonald's participation in community events in spite of the current clown sightings in communities. melissa: what is this world coming to? ronald mcdonald -- he is going low-key and hiding on the sidelines what is going on. amazing. democrats finding campaign snares in hillary clinton change of heart when it comes to vetting refugees. this story is getting lost. it is very important. president obama's red line statement is coming back to haunt hillary clinton. that is coming up next after the bell. you can run an errand. (music playing) ♪ push it real good... (announcer vo) or you can take a joyride. bye bye, errands, we sing out loud here. siriusxm. road happy.

i'm going to the bank, to discuss a mortgage. ugh, see, you need a loan, you put on a suit, you go crawling to the bank. this is how i dress to get a mortgage.

i just go to lendingtree. i calculate how much home i can afford. i get multiple offers to compare side by side. and the best part is... the banks come crawling to me. everything you need to get a better mortgage. clothing optional. lendingtree. when banks compete, you win. okay! ...awkward.

(announcer vo) you can sit in traffic. or you can crack up. (man on radio) but if it isn't refreshing... (announcer vo) sorry traffic, we laugh 'til it hurts. siriusxm. road happy. melissa: that blurry red line clashing over syria at the debate. denying trump's claim that she was secretary of state during president obama's red line comment from 2012. >> she was there as secretary of state with so-called line in the sand which -- >> no, i wasn't. i was gone. >> but you were in contact, you

were -- >> that is why we need to do fact-checking here. melissa: okay. turns out she was, that was not true. he was right. here now is retired lt. general thomas mcinerney, fox news military analyst. he is a donald trump supporter. so, here's what we know about that, doing a fact check. she was secretary of state when president obama said the president obama said it would be the a red line in august of 2012. she left after that. what is the significance of the red line and of them setting it and then of assad just crossing it? she is trying to distance herself from this, but she was secretary of state when all that happened? >> she was, melissa, and that's a very good question. the fact she was the architect of obama's foreign policy going all the way back to when president obama came in and made his first major foreign policy speech in cairo which really started the arab spring, which became the arab winter.

so getting up to this particular issue, she was the architect although the president announced it as secretary of state she was the architect of the red line. granted she was gone in august of 2013, when they broached the line, but the fact was, she was in the administration in the white house on september 2013 when they cut the deal and, transferred munitions, the chemical weapons out. she approved it that day. melissa: yeah. >> so she is completely involved with this, melissa. melissa: she approved it. so her fingerprints are all over it. another one, so she is now admitting, or admitting the real danger of refugees. hillary clinton saying vet something nearly impossible. this is according to new wikileaks documents from 2013, despite calling for 65,000 from refugees to enter the united states right now, the document is in reference to jordan's syrian refugee crisis and she

says, quote, they have hundreds of thousands of refugees they can't possibly vet them. so they don't know all of them. part me, they can't possibly vet all of them. so they don't know if jihad its are colling in along with legitimate refugees. lt. general mcinerney, give me your take on that one. >> again the fbi director comey, the director of national intelligence have all said and now hillary has said we can not vet them. and so the fact is, by common sense and passing the smell test we know, since those governments disintegrated there is nothing to vet them with. we're not against them. the fact is, we know we're going to let in known radical islamists who are isis members. melissa: right. >> melissa, that is very dangerous to our national security. melissa: great, she says the truth. >> yes. melissa: we don't know if jihadists are coming in along with legitimate refugees.

we feel terrible legitimate refugees. we don't if they include jihadists. we wish we had more time. we have breaking news. david: which do indeed. breaking news about a small plane crash. this is east hartford, connecticut. it's a huge fire as you can see. the smoke is billowing for miles. you can see the flames. a few power lines were clipped when the plane crashed. that might have led intensity of the fire. thousands are without power because of the clipped line. two people are reported in the plane. unclear how if they got out alive. hard to consider that they could considering that crash. we'll bring you new details as we get them here on fox. melissa: the danger has not receded from the flooding in the tarheel state. that is next. ♪

approaching medicare eligibility? you may think you can put off checking out your medicare options until you're sixty-five, but now is a good time to get the ball rolling. keep in mind, medicare only covers about eighty percent of part b medical costs. the rest is up to you. that's where aarp medicare supplement insurance plans insured by unitedhealthcare insurance company come in. like all standardized medicare supplement insurance plans, they could help pay some of what medicare doesn't, saving you in out-of-pocket medical costs. you've learned that taking informed steps along the way really makes a difference later. that's what it means to go long™. call now and request this free decision guide. it's full of information on medicare and the range of aarp medicare supplement plans to choose from based on your needs and budget.

all plans like these let you choose any doctor or hospital that accepts medicare patients, and there are no network restrictions. unitedhealthcare insurance company has over thirty years experience and the commitment to roll along with you, keeping you on course. so call now and discover how an aarp medicare supplement plan could go long™ for you. these are the only medicare supplement insurance plans endorsed by aarp, an organization serving the needs of people 50 and over for generations. plus, nine out of ten plan members surveyed say they would recommend their plan to a friend. remember, medicare doesn't cover everything. the rest is up to you. call now, request your free decision guide and start gathering the information you need to help you keep rolling with confidence. go long™. ♪

david: it ain't over. hurricane matthew wreaking havoc all over the u.s. southeast after causing devastating destruction in haiti and the caribbean. now there is massive flooding leaving many north carolina residents stranded without power, their homes destroyed. fox news's steve harrigan is standing by in lumberton, north carolina, with latest on the toll from the storm, steve? reporter: 15 dead in north carolina, despite we're having good weather past few days, things are getting worse, the water levels are rising. first-responders have a raft ready of the we've been watching them go out in rafts and small boats all morning long where people are pretty much trapped by walls of water. the really boats are only way in or out much of this part of north carolina. we've been seeing people come out carrying pets and small

plastic bags of their belongings. visibly shaken. a lot of people have not had running water for electric power for last two days. initially making phone calls for help, getting on social media. in the last day we've seen people crying out, calling out for help when rescuers go by. things will not get better here soon. some major rivers are expected to crest as late as friday. david, back to you. david: you think of things like snakes in the water, other stuff like that. steve, thank you very much for your reporting. appreciate it. melissa. melissa: so kim kardashian sparking another controversy. one company is trying to profit off a real-life nightmare.

..s a combination of see products.. and customers. every on-time arrival is backed by thousands of od employees, ...who make sure the millions of products we ship arrive without damages. because od employees treat customer service... ...like our most important delivery. od. helping the world keep promises. i'm jamie foxx for verizon, introducing lte advanced powering america's largest and fastest 4g lte network ever. and i'm also jamie foxx for sprint. and i'm also jamie foxx for t-mobile. (both) also america's largest, fastest network ever. oh, you're just repeating everything i said? (both) oh, you're just repeating everything i said? i'm switching to verizon right now! (both) i'm switching to verizon right now! (announcer vo) there's no better time to switch to verizon. now get the next gen network and the best value .

to help those that need it. the ability to collaborate changes how we work. what we do together changes how we live.

>> the uk cabinet ministers have now been banned from wearing apple watches at all meetings! [laughter]. >> very interesting.

the telegraph reporting this rule coming down in response to concerns that the smart watches could be hacked into by russian spies and perhaps others used as listening devices. >> i wonder if the meetings are that interesting. >> why bother? so in a world where people dressed up in ebola hazmat suits for halloween, there is a kim kardashian inspired robbery costume called parisian heist robbery victim. as if we don't know who that is. just any heist victim. it's $69.99 it includes a long black wig, white robe and a fake ring that is, quote, not worth more than $4 million. >> it's receiving a lot of harsh criticism on social media. the company behind the design telling fox 411 that there are no intentions of taking it down because i guess, it's been selling pretty well. we should mention, by the way,

you've had your suspicions about that. >> no, no, no, no, no, no, no. >> i'm going to write it down, and if you're suspicions prove right, i will trade on air. >> i don't know what he is talking about. meanwhile, i think that does it for us, "risk & reward" starts right now. >> department of justice where bill clinton gets in the back of an airline for 39 minutes just prior to a determination being made. of course, you and i know that the determination was made a long time ago. but gets together with the attorney general because he happened to be in arizona playing golf. it was 110 degrees out. nobody saw him on the golf course. happened to be the attorney general, let me get back up on that. >> a third batch of e-mails released through wikileaks, the clinton campaign and white house under fire. exchanges show the justice department was coordinating with the clinton campaign about the timing of release of