>> i don't know, if i met one, but the media loves the kardashians and the kardashians love the media. they are both making money. >> judge jeanine: tonight on "justice." the baby lisa case. the man seen carrying a baby the night lisa disappeared has been identified by one of the witnesses. we have that story. plus -- >> a vicious beating caught on tape. but have these parents committed a crime? and -- >> i'm tired of looking at victims and saying we're sorry. >> judge jeanine: a sheriff tells women get a gun, a big one tortion protect themselves in attacks. you with is make my day justice the answer?

plus -- >> hello. >> judge jeanine: kim camden dashian. her 72 day wedded bliss. was it all a hoax? coming up tonight on "justice." >> judge jeanine: welcome to "justice." i'm judge jeanine pirro. new developments in the investigation into baby lisa's disappearance. mark fuhrman joins us. ing good evening, mark. >> good evening, judge. >> judge jeanine: the witness that we heard about who says that he saw a man carrying a baby about 4:00 a.m. in the morning has identified that man in a photo lineup. that man fits the description of the next door neighbor of the irwins who now has an alibi and has passed a polygraph. what do you make of the latest news? >> my -- there is no surprise, really. i can't imagine that this would have been connected with that

large time span of those two different groups of people seeing this one man. but judge, you know, isn't it kind of ironic that everybody surrounding this case the next door neighbor, the next door neighbor's husband, deborah bradley's brother jeremy irwin, this man, jersey, everybody involved with this has been effectively passed by the police as they are not suspects. they have been cleared. the only person that hasn't been cleared is the mother, the last person that saw the baby alive. >> judge jeanine: and clearly she is the one who told us that she failed the polygraph test. so mark, what do you make of the fact that although there were indications that it would happen this week or next week there is no scheduled visit and i confirmed this tonight, of the half brothers of baby lisa for an interview by the

investigators nor have the parents agreed to a separate interview with the detectives. what does that tell you? >> well, i think the attorney that represents deborah bradley or the family, however, you want to phrase it, has shut down contact with the media. obviously it didn't work. the police have not addressed that. wedeborah bradley's status directly. what they have done is cleared everything that the defense of deborah bradley and the family has brought up as possibilities. in a left-handed way they are letting us conclude the obvious and i believe that these two boys will never be interviewed in the status that the police would like. they might be in a grand jury or in a courtroom, but not that way. >> judge jeanine: i happen to agree with you, mark, on that one. by the way, it has been kind of quiet in kansas city.

very quickly, what do you think is going on now with the p.d.? >> i think that they would like to find a body. they would certainly like to find a live child but i think that has been hope that has been almost erased. i think they are trying to put their case together, hoping they get to interview the boys. and they would like to interview deborah bradley one on one but i don't think it is something that is going to prevent them from making an arrest in this case. >> judge jeanine: and mark, not just deborah but jeremy as well one on one. thank you very much for being with us this evening. >> thank you. >> judge jeanine: one of the worst fears for most women is being sexually assaulted. what one police chief recommends has sparked public outrage. >> i'm tired of looking at victims and saying we're sorry. >> judge jeanine: after a particularly violent assault in his county last weekend, sheriff chuck wright is fed up. one of his female citizens is attacked in a park, grabbed from behind, stripped and

nearly raped. monday, the sheriff calls a press conference. he says the justice system is failing them. and issues a call to arms for women. >> i don't want you to go for the mace, go for the concealed weapons permit. >> judge jeanine: he says women need to arm themselves with guns, big guns, to protect themselves. and the annies of spartanburg, south carolina, got their guns. the county saw a big run on firearms permits and purchases. >> over the last 15-16 hours i have had 16 women that have signed up to come through the class over the next two weeks. >> judge jeanine: critics immediately condemned the sheriff but we wanted to give him a chance to explain. sheriff chuck wright joins us now. good evening, sheriff. why did you say that? >> because i meant it. >> judge jeanine: okay. and you believe that if a woman is about to be raped she has

the right to shoot and kill her rapist? >> if the state you live in allows you to have a concealed weapons permit i say you should arm yourself if that is what you choose to do. i'm tired of looking at people and looking at victims and telling them we have had people in our custody over 20 times and can't do anything about people who attack them like animals. i'm tired of our justice system being broken. >> judge jeanine: how long have you been a sheriff? >> i have been a sheriff for eight years. >> judge jeanine: and you sound like someone who has been in for 30 years and just plain had t. but you are very aggressive about this and sparked a public debate as to whether or not women should go out there packing pistols, annie oakinglies. >> i want you to be trained and go through a safety course. people asking me these questions what about if they attack them quick do they have time to do this and that. we can what if it all day long.

the bottom line is if we arm our men and women and have them not be standing there looking wide eyed victims of crime and fighting back maybe some of these people will quit attacking innocent people. >> judge jeanine: you call this guy an animal. arrested 20 times in the last 20 years. a failure not just of the courts but it is a failure of the system as a whole. you have seen said that. >> i think it is a failure as a whole. we have had him 20 times and he has been charged with rape before. so, you know, i'm tired of looking at victims. it goes deeper. when a woman is raped i'm telling you it is not just the woman who goes through it. it is the husband, the children, the children's children, the people that she goes to church with, the people she works with. i'm tired of saying i'm sorry. >> judge jeanine: i got 30 years in. i totally get it. the ripple effect is enormous. some who say that maybe you are abdicating your responsibility and saying to everybody it is

vigilante justice time, you are on your own, annie, go get your gun. >> i'm not advocating vigilantism as all. >> judge jeanine: you even tell them the kind of gun. a .410 gun in it. even the fan any pack. >> i didn't bring the fan any pack. that was an opportunity, i used it from the cameraman that was there. >> judge jeanine: at the end of the day, sheriff, i think when you have vigilante justice you have to make sure that women understand there are only certain circumstances that they can use those guns. >> judge, this is not vigilante justice. this is arming yourself to not be a victim of crime, that is all. i totally get it. i have a lady that works with me in my office that says i don't want the responsibility of taking someone's life but i don't have a problem with mace or some other form of defense. >> judge jeanine: when you have seen enough you realize that sometimes the system doesn't work the way it should. and this guy in particular only picked on women, you said.

domestic violence, sexual assault. >> he wouldn't big on a big 'ole boy like myself. he would pick on a woman. this woman was walking her dog on a sunday afternoon at the milliken research park. it as private facility. they are good enough to let people go out there and enjoy their facility. and he made friends with the dog first to make sure he wasn't going to get bit. >> judge jeanine: that is a predator for you. >> that's correct. >> judge jeanine: do you have daughters? i have two daughter in laws and a granddaughter. don't ask that question on tv, please. >> do they pack? >> one is in the air force overseas and the other one has signed up this week to get her concealed weapons. >> judge jeanine: saw your press conference. sheriff, stand by. my next guest wants to shoot some holes in your argument. then, highlights from tonight's debate between herman cain and newt gingrich. ♪ [ country ]

[ man ] ♪ gone, like my last paycheck ♪ gone, gone away ♪ gone, like my landlord's smile ♪ ♪ gone, gone away ♪ my baby's gone away with dedicated claims specialists... and around-the-clock service, travelers can help make things better quicker. will your auto and home insurer... be there when you need them most? for an agent or quote, call 800-my-coverage... or visit travelers.com.

>> judge jeanine: we are joined by melly merik, executive director of people against rape. melanieers doesn't have the sheriff have a point that women are on their own to defend them sals because the police just can't be everywhere? >> he does have a point with that. my problem is you make is sound like victims if they are not carrying a gun and they are sexually assaulted it was their fault. that is where i have a little bit of a problem with it. >> judge jeanine: what do you mean by that? >> what happens is -- well, for instance, if someone assaults a woman who has a concealed weapon, she is carrying a gun, he tries to assault her and she shoots him and kills him and finds out he doesn't have a weapon then is she going to be charged with murder because she can't prove in the law -- eyes of the law that she was sexually assaulted. >> judge jeanine: how do you respond to that, sheriff? >> i don't agree with that at all. i don't think you have a time to interview a guy that is telling you, demanding you to

take your clothes out and lay down or be still or i will shoot you. >> judge jeanine: which is what this guy did. he maided her strip down in the park. >> we can what if this all day long. i didn't say anything about it being anybody's fault if they had a weapon or not. i simply said i'm tired of the justice system being broken and i'm tired of women feeling like they have to stand there and take it. i want them to do something. i want them to defend themselves. it is real easy not to get killed woman, just don't attack them. >> exactly. that is true. >> judge jeanine: what should a woman do in that situation? >> we con doan -- we docon done self-defense classes. it is about getting away, saving yourself. not necessarily staying around to fight but getting away. >> judge jeanine: you have dealt i'm sure with thousands of rape victims as have i. sometimes you just can't fight these dudes off, they are big

guys. >> but the thing is nobody knows what they would do until they are sexually assaulted. you could have a gun. >> judge jeanine: wouldn't you rather have a gun, wouldn't you rather be a defendant than a victim? >> absolutely you would rather not be a victim. i think when you make a statement like that then i think that -- don't get me wrong, if a grown woman wants to go out and get a concealed weapon and get a gun i would support a woman in doing that. i have no problem with that. >> that is what i was advocating. >> not every woman wants that or needs that or feels comfortable. >> judge jeanine: but not every women thinks she will be raped. >> why do you buy a fire extinguisher hoping there is never a use for it but you have it on hand just in case. that is why you get the concealed weapons permit hoping and praying you never use it but if you need it you have it right there with you. >> the other thing that i would liking to bring up is that this while this assault was horrible and i actually applaud the sheriff for being so proactive about this case and finally

getting this guy behind bars and hopefully he will stay behind bars. most assaults are not strange assaults. >> judge jeanine: is it less of a rape if a family member rapes you? what i'm saying is if you are with somebody that you trust or an acquaintance that you meet out that is different than someone coming you behind you on a blitz attack. >> judge jeanine: probably worse if you trust them. talk about a betrayal of trust. the downside to women's defending themselves legally under the second amendment to the constitution? >> certainly their right to do that. i hope that we could learn some other ways to handle that. and education is the answer to all of that. >> judge jeanine: of course. >> education is not the answer to all of that. fighting back and making sure that people don't do that again is the answer to that and our justice system being broken and it needs to be fixed across the country, not just in south carolina. i'm tired of telling victims sorry. >> judge jeanine: got to wrap right now. sheriff wright and melanie,

thank you so much. around the disgusting video of a judge whipping his daughter. is there any recourse for her? and for the people who find themselves in his courtroom? and then, the highlights from the presidential debate between republicans herman cain and newt gingrich. the markets never stop moving. of course, neither do i. solution? td ameritrade mobile trader. i can enter trades on the run. even futures and 4x. complex options, done. the market shifts, i get an alert. [ cellphone rings ] thank you. live streaming audio. advanced charts. look at that. all right here. wherever "here" happens to be. mobile tradi from td ameritrade. number one in online equity trades. [ male announcer ] trade commission-free for 60 days. plus get up to $600 when you open an account.

>> judge jeanine: it is a video that brings home the horror of true -- the true horror of child abuse. in 2004, hillary adams is a 16-year-old girl living in rock port, texas. suffering from a rare form of cerebral palsy, she seeks solace in computers and music. one night after she is caught by h her father downloading

illegal music. >> go get my belt. >> millary sets up a hidden camera in her bedroom because, she says, she knew what was coming. >> bend over the bed. bend over the bed! the teen captures a vicious 7-minute whipping by her father with a belt. he hits her 20 times. at one point, her mom enters the picture and lays down a lick, telling hillary. >> you turn over like a 16-year-old and take it! >> hillary says this beating is common in her house and sick of the abuse she wants proof of what is happening. >> i'm going it take you in and wear your [ bleep ] this belt. >> no one with sees the tape until last week, 7 years after the incident when hillary uploads the video to youtube.

public outrage is immediate not only because of the abuse but because hillary adams' father, william as dams i adams is a fy law judge in texas. the scene is difficult to watch. but is what judge adams did a crime? and why did hillary wait 7 years to release the video. joey jackson, criminal defense attorney and dr. john sharp psychiatrist with the esteemed harvard medical school. this was criminal, joe. >> absolutely. this is outrageous behavior and should not be tolerated and i say this from a criminal defense alternative. he is lucky this the statute of limitations just passed. he is beating his child and cursing at his child. he should be embarrassed and ashamed and resign his judgeship immediately. >> across this country parents have the right in every state to use physical punishment as

long as they do so in a reasonable way. there is an exception, you can hit your children. >> there is punishment and there is punishment. this crosses the line. not only did he whip her, ferociously and horrifically. he left and came back to finish up the job. that can't be done. the belt is a lesson. >> he turned out the lights so the neighbors couldn't see. he knew. dr. sharp, what is going on with this family? >> it is terrible. you can see by your emotional reaction this is revolting. there are two kinds watching this. some say this is just that a revolting unacceptable experience to endure or put upon your child. others kind of shrug and say you know what, i had this growing up and it isn't as bad as it seems. >> judge jeanine: i heard both sides people coming down but the mom joins in and now says i was brain washed. do you buy that? >> i buy that. she can be a victim of this, too, and that may explain why

hillary had to wait inform she could get to a place of safety before she could get forward. >> how do you explain the fact that hillary lived with the father after she could give with the mother? >> i believe that she didn't feel safe to take this bolder step and i don't believe that she could have done it until she had the kind of courage and safety and space to be able to. >> judge jeanine: joey, do you agree with the doctor? she waits seven years to release a tape and by the way, her 10-year-old sister is in the joint custody of her father. if it is dangerous shouldn't she have said something earlier? >> perhaps she is protecting him as a result. she protected him by visit too of not releasing it. if she released it earlier, remember, the statute of limitations is five years. there will not be a state prosecution as a result of the statute. the feds have declined to prosecute and therefore in the event she released it earlier he would be in boiling earlier. remember this, the mother takes the belt from the father. had she not taken the belt it could be worse.

he goes and gets another belt and goes and continues the beating. >> judge jeanine: the father, doctor, says that hillary is being spiteful because he threatened to take away her mercedes and financial support because she dropped out of college. by the way, she was a piano prodigy. does this change your opinion of what her motivations are? >> t doesn't. i believe that she had to make sense of how to deal with t. probably had conflicted feelings. if she love her dad and he did this to her she learnd that people who love me beat me. she probably had to wrestle with that in order to get h her head on straight and say you know what, this is unacceptable. >> judge jeanine: will he be removed from the bench? >> if he doesn't the people get to elect him and vote for him in three years i would expect that they will throw him out if the state judicial commission doesn't do their job and take action to remove him. >> judge jeanine: they have taken him off these child abuse cases. thank you very much for being

with us this evening. and herman cain and newt gingrich slug it out in the ♪ it's true. u never forget your first subaru. you know what else is early? medicare open enrollment. now through dember 7th. can i stick with old medicare plan? sure! or find a new plan with better coverage, less cost, or both. medicare plans give you free cancer screenings and wellness visits and 50% off on brand-name prescriptions when you're in the doughnut hole it's part of the healthcare law. so it's time to look, compare...

and choose the right plan for you. learn more at 1-800-medicare or medicare.gov.

live from america's news headquarters i'm marianne rafferty. a 5.2 magnitude earthquake striking oklahoma less than 24 hours after another quake struck the state. the quake hitting just before 11:00 p.m. local time 45 miles east of oklahoma city. it was a shallow one, 3.1 miles deep and struck the same area where a 4.7 magnitude quake hit arubanly saturday morning. that was the second -- early saturday morning. so far no, reports of damage or any injuries. former heavyweight boxing champion smoking joe frazier is seriously ill with liver cancer and now in hospice care in philadelphia after being diagnosed a month ago. his manager revealing "this is very serious."

he is famous for being the first man to defeat muhammad ali in the 1971 fight of the century. i'm marianne rafferty. now, back to "justice" withacko judge jeanine. judge. jonz this is a fox news alert. things just wrapping up in the herman cain newt gingrich primary debate. here is a clip. >> joining us this evening, two candidates from the state of georgia. herman cain and newt gingrich. [ applause ] >> at this particular juncture, i'm supposed to have a minute to disagree with something that he said but i don't. so i would like to instead i

don't medicare started in 1965. our government told us that it was going to cost $6 billion to roll it out. we were also told that by 1990 it was going to cost $12 billion because of population growth, because of inflation, but in 1990 they missed the target of $12 billion. it wasn't 12. it wasn't 24. it wasn't 50. it was $109 billion. >> what do we do about rising healthcare costs? >> we have the best healthcare in the world. [ applause ] we have a healthcare cost problem. you are absolutely right.

in order to solve the healthcare cost problem we must use market-driven patient centered approaches. i have talked to doctors. i'm sure newt has talked to doctors. market centered -- patient centered market driven approaches. here again you cannot micromanage healthcare costs out of washington, d.c. it is impossible. every program that we have that has been administered out of washington, d.c. and a bureaucrat tries to make a decision that is going impact a patient or hospital or doctor has failed. >> the mess of the health system is an everything problem. it is a federal government problem. it as state government problem. it is an insurance company problem. it is a hospital problem. it as doctor problem and it as patient problem. all of us have a hand in making this thing a total mess. think about going to mcdonalds.

we have no national hearings on fraud at mcdonalds. think about it. you show he up and say i would like a quarter pounder with cheese. they give you a quarter pounder with cheese. you give them money. they are happy. you are happy. if you open up your bag and there is no quarter pounder are with cheese you are unhappy. and you go back and say where is my quarter pounder with cheese? there is a direct relationship. >> how do you get people up a then titlement roles and turn this in an equation and say you are not going to make it at 65, you might have to be 66. we would like to have you take your health safety management account and who will it into a life safety account. >> why is it so hard for the comcongressing to decide before you impose any penalties on honest people you quit paying

crooks. >> defined benefit plan or premium support? >> a defined -- you go first, newt. [ laughter ] >> i think everybody -- as a c.e.o. what your advice is to other c.e.o.s and how they think about this? >> my advice to them is something that i realize when i first became press and c.e.o. of godfather's in 1986 that if i didn't get involved in these issues they were going to collapse our entire free market system. so my advice is quite simply to c.e.o.s don't play it safe, get involved and be part of the solution. you have got some of us out there that are fighting but we need help in renforcement.

one of the three biggest things that you have come to realize by being outside the bubble during this period of time? >> set very big goals with tight deadlines. delegate like crazy. don't let any experts in the room. >> we are going to try to tackle the problem of social security entitlement. if you have your own personal social security savings account and you want to retire early on a smaller amount of money because you are willing to have more are free time, why would the congress tell you not to? and on the other hand, if you are like andy rooney who just passed away, having worked until he was 91, and you decide you love what you are doing and you want to stay active, why should the congress tell you you can't? and so i this think let's get politicians out of that decision process. return it to americans and let americans control their own lives. i became speaker in part because i told the truth to the

house republican party for a decade and they finally decide it was okay to become a majority. he became a leader at godfather's pizza because he had what it takes to make the company successful. ronald reagan on lessons he learned at general electric. compare regan's ability to talk directly to the american people, make sense and have the american people move the congress with the current president. with president is about as candid and accurate as bernie madoff and what he tells the -- in what he tells the american people. >> judge jeanine: up next from politics to paternity to divorce. and then my summation on kim kardashian and the as far as farce that was her wedding.

>> judge jeanine: the fall of the house of kardashian is a spectacular as the 20-carat diamond engagement ring kris humphries cave to kim a few short months ago as their marriage hide hits the skids, m learns the spot light. can can fade very quickly. a few years ago, kim kardashian is nobody, the daughter of o.j.

simpson lawyer robert kardashian and friend to paris hilton. then she shoots to fame after, of all things, starring in a sex tape. an unauthorized video of him and her ex-boyfriend entertainer ray jay. but when the bedroom romp is released kim doesn't hide. she cashes in. she sues vivid entertainment the video distributors, eventually settling for a reported $5 million. and scores a reality show for her and her family, keeping up with the kardashian, which follows the whacky lives of the kardashian clan. >> either they want to be a part of the family or they can relate to someone in the family and i think it has just done well because we have been so real. >> hello. >> judge jeanine: the incredibly popular show in turn helps kim build an empire including a perfume line, clothing stores and even a line of diet products. but this season on keeping up with the kardashians things

take a serious turn when kim reveals a new relationship with probasketball player kris humphries. the whirlwind romance of less than mine months culminates in a televised over the top wedding. the nuptiala split into two, two hour e channel specials reportedly earned kim and kris big bucks. licensing of still photos in the millions. their usual pay check for the show itself and reportedly one third of all ad sales which aired over and over and over again. but this monday after only 72 days of holy matrimony the marriage goes to hell. and kim files for divorce, leaving many to wonder was this marriage a sham?

all right. dylon, what is your take? was this true love? >> i think after 72 days, judge, nothing could be true love. in fact, that is what the critics are suggesting that kim didn't even give this is chance. she reportedly didn't even see a marriage counselor. instead, she blindsided her husband and filed for divorce. kim has been conspicuous in her singledom absence since returning from australia. her behavior erratic. she didn't tell kris she was filing. then after 24 hours in australia said she couldn't deal with the hype and news surrounding the divorce and returned home. she hasn't been seen since. she has gone into hiding and now there are reports that she is trying to attempt not to have this become part of the reality show and the only reason i tell you that, judge, the only reason she wants that

is one simple reason. they are under damage control mode at the moment and they are doing more damage than they are controlling the situationing. >> well, you know, and there is talk of not running the wedding any more on e. have they pulled that one also? >> well, they haven't. and the a network must be licking its lips because for them, even this drama surrounding the kardashians means money for them, more viewers. at the same time, though, for the very first time the kardashian brand is suffering. credibility at an all-time low. reputation .com said more people now dislike kim than they ever have and that is concerning for the kardashians because they built an empire off the back of, well, nothing. >> judge jeanine: so to speak. joey, going to you, they did build an empire worth tens if not hundred is of millions of dollars based on the sex tape. how do you think this is going to impact the kardashian

empire? in a negative way. this was predicated and fraud, your honor, outrageous. >> judge jeanine: she is suing for divorce. how does that impact the divorce? prenuptials a preup inual agreement. but is there fraud in the stan tard sense? in is case you can argue this was done for the hype, judge, the publicity. to get everybody to look and to make money. >> judge jeanine: so then he, kris humphries who was blind sided by this can sue for fraud saying she never really married me. how do you know -- she never really loved me. how do you know if she ever really loved him. does this meet the smell test? remember the smell test in law school. if it smells bad it probably is. do you really think all this money, e shining all inth monitoring i, even you, right,

you go to the wedding, what do you get. >> any one who ever donated anything should get it back too,. >> judge jeanine: back to that. talk about returning the gifts or talk about returning anything? >> when i talk about damage control this is how they are doing more damage than they are controlling the situation. as the outrage exploded this week, kim appearance announced that she was going to donate -- not return the wedding gifts but donate $200,000 to a charity. a charity that looks after disadvantaged people. now, to me that sounds great but, of course, it is a tax write-off and what is the bet that that becomes a key part. >> doing this as a tax writeoff, making charitable contributions all the time. how about that $2 million ring. maybe it was a fraud on kris. does he say i want my ring back and can he get it? >> surprisingly he has been silent since the divorce made

news and that is part of the pre-nup agreement as i understand that both parties can't necessarily make negative comments about the other. he hasn't said whether he wants that giant dazzler back in his hands. of course, kris jenner the mom as they call her, the mom manager went on morning television and rosstr made an c slur. >> judge jeanine: what it was, dylon. >> she said she doesn't like indian givers. hello. damage control. damage, damage, damage. >> getting the ring back. >> joey, stay with us. up next, the saga over justin bieber and the woman who claims he fathered her child. justin may pay but the cost could be very high for her.

>> judge jeanine: did justin bieber father a child with one of his fans? the sordid details of an alleged quickie and i do mean a quickie in the bathroom sal after one of his concerts with a 19-year-old raises questions about culbability and criminality. the legal drama is sure to last more are than the sex act allegedly did. dylon, what is the latest? >> judge,ky tell you exclusively tonight that justin bieber appointed an attorney to represent h him in this matter and not just any old attorney. the high profile hollywood attorney howard weitzman who is what the hollywood reporter considers a superlawyer. he has represented o.j. simpson

in the past along with arnold schwarzenegger and the late marlon brando. it remains to be seen haboober bieber is going to do. he says he has never met mariah. there is only one way to confirm are whether he is, indeed, the father of her 4 month old baby tristan and that is to take the dna test. he has been silent on that claim. >> judge jeanine: he has hired this high profile attorney. what facts does she have to allege in the petition to get the court to say you have to take a paternity test. >> here is the real answer. the real answer is were they on the stage at the same time. did he invite h her back. did they have the opportunity to be together. >> judge jeanine: she says i had unprotected sex with justin bieber following the concert and will thy is no one else that could possibly be the father of my baby and we went into a bathroom stall and had

sex for his first time. >> does the judge believe the series of accounts. depends upon what the facts are. there is an easy way and a hard way. they way if he want to get out of it. volunteer to a paternity test. if he doesn't voluntarily he submit the judge can compel it. >> here is the question. if she sues him for child support and and is saying i had sex with this kid isn't shed a mating to statutory rape under the laws of california since she was 19 and he was 16? >> she certainly is. here is what is boding well in her favor. generally they are not prosecuted because of the proximity of the cases. usually in a case like this there is a gross disparity. >> judge jeanine: it is on the books statutory rate. >> apparently she wanted to take that risk as a result of the money. >> so, too, is the fact that justin bieber is in a relationship with his current

girlfriend salina gomez. she is 1 is 19 and he is 17. >> judge jeanine: what do we know about this woman who is suing justin bieber? she is on social services and getting food stamps and has a front row seat at a justin bieber concert. what is that? >> there are certain questions over this woman's credibility. already we saw a past boyfriend come out and say that she told him that he could quite well be the father of her child. we spoke to that boy's grandmother yesterday and she tells us that it is physically impossible, the time frames just don't match up. in fact, she was already pregnant at it. so while there are credibility issues over mariah's claims. >> what is going nap that instance is that she is saying there is only two people possibly and conceivably who it could be. my boyfriend who she approached about it and he denied it or justin bieber and if you look

at the time frame, something is amis, judge. nine months. >> judge jeanine: i was counting and everybody else will be counting. thanks so much. >> judge jeanine: and now for my thoughts. every girl dreams of the walk down the aisle, the beautiful gown, the fairly tale wedding. kim, 4 million people witnessed you walk down the aisle and your promise to love and honor your husband. 72 days later after care consideration you want to end your marriage. some things just don't work out as planned. really, kim? i think your plan was brilliant. well, core row graphed and marketed to make you millions. some say $15 million from tv alone. and then you high tail it to australia to sell purses. you send your mother/manager out to say you made less than $700,000 and you will give the money to charity and then she adds if your husband wants the $2 million ring back he is an indian giver. that is, by the way, what you

call an ethnic slur. even most toasters have a 90 day war ranty. reports are are that you didn't even have the courage to tell your h husband you are filing for divorce. i bet you spent more time for your fittings for your three vera wang gowns and your lawyers preparing for divorce than the marriage itself. where i come from people are are judged by their word and their vow. i haven't heard you were a victim of domestic violence or fraud or that your clearly blind sided husband was having an affair. friends say his not working bothered you. really? have you heard there is an nba lockout. should women whose husbands lose their jobs just dump them? i didn't need a body language expert to tell me this was theater and by the way, you are no liz taylor, you can't sing, act, or dance. you are famous for your sex tape. your owe an apology to thousands of young girls who look up to you. you didn't marry for love, instead for fame and money and

even that can't buy your happiness. that is it for us tonight. thanks for joining us. e-mail us your comments. captioned by closed captioning services, inc. hut! go! here it comes! right on the numbers! boom! get it! spin! oh, nice hands! chest bump. ugh! od job, man. nice! oky, halftime. now, this is my favorite play. oh! i'm wide open. oh, fumble. fumble. don't want to fumble any of these. [ male announcer ] share what you love, with who you love. kellogg's frosted flakes. it's up... and it's good! good?! they're grrreat!

[ horn honks ] ♪ oh,hose were the best of days ♪ ♪ still feel the summer rays ♪ that graced our backs as we went down the lane ♪ [ horn honks ] [ male announcer ] when youcar is more than just a car to you, the right insurance matters. aryou getting the coverage options you need and the discounts you deserve? for an agent or quote, call 800-my-coverage or visit travelers.com.