your question, 5-foot eight and three/4. >> we'll talk about all of it on "outnumbered overtime." foxnews.com/outnumbered, click the "overtime" tab to get more the show. if you want more we're here tomorrow noon eastern. "happening now" starts right now. ft. lauderdale. you can see the foam there on the ground. the left side engine of this significant jet belonging to dynamic airways caught fire as the plane was taxiing out for take off. no reports of injuries. the firefighters have that fire extingui extinguished. that will be there for sometime as they figure out what caused it. dynamic's airways is a charter operator.

we don't have a great deal of information. that is the name of the craft, dynamic airways plane caught fire taxiing in the ft. hollywood/lauderdale airport. it should not be a huge problem. we'll have more information on "happening now". this fox news alert involving an aircraft. two russian war planes buzzing the uss ron would reagan aircraft carrier. they had to escort theñi bomber away. we are covering all of the news. >> it is like a french work week. >> plenty of fire workings. >> three days you show up. njeb bush and marco rubio. and ran paul. >> it is your grand parents

kids. >> and the damage left in the wake of the storm. >> and people inside of the building, we don't know until we get in. >> a dangerous robot designed to work in dangerous situation. it is all "happening now". >> the battle in boulder today. the third republican debate in the books. it will be one to remember. >> for many different reasons. i am jenna lee. there were fire works and they saved the sharpest attacks for the debate moderators. carl cameron is joining us from lake wood, colorado to break it all

down. carl? unfortunately it looks like we lost him. we'll have time to go through the moments and we'll discuss this debate more. we want to hear from you as well. which candidate won the debate. is there a clear winner. go to on foxnews.com/happeningnow to join the conversation. >> we'll have two of those candidates with us later in the hour. now to another election on capitol hill. a new eran in the house of representative. wisconsin congressman paul ryan sworn in as 62nd speaker of the house. >> paul d. ryan of the state of wisconsin. >> ryan is the youngest house speaker in 130 years. the wisconsin congressman didn't want the job, but fellow republicans insisted he is the only one toñi unite the party. and determination to do that

echoed in the acceptance speech. >> to me the house of representative represents the best of america. boundless opportunity tokc do good. but let's be frank. the house is broken. we are not solving problems. we are adding to them. and i am not interested in laying blame. we are not settling scores. we are wiping the slate clean. >> let's talk about it with our political panel. alex political reporter for the daler caller and betsy political reporter for the daily beast. sunshine and rain broubowsñi on the house floor. how long will it last. >> that's the question. will he get the conservatives that are upset with boehner and how long will it last. if you told me that eric cantor would be out of congress and conservatives push ryan out.

and kept kevin mccarthy from being speaker. i don't know if i would have believed you. and paul ryan knowing he has a problem with the conservatives in the house and haven't liked the way the house. he threw bones to them. listen, the house is broken and we'll do things to fix the process. there is a lot of things that the house works and conservatives want to see changed. they want a bigger say. >> he threw a bone to democrats in the acceptance speech. will he have more problems with the democratic side of the aisle or members of his own caucus. >> that is a good question. whether paul ryan disagrees with the house democrats than the 40 odd members of the freedom caucus. ryan has warm amicable relationships with the democrat

leaders and a number of lqsjpás praised his leadership role. that said members of the house freedom caucus gave him approval. mark meadows who filed the motion to vacate the chair and set the ball rolling on boehner. he voted for ryan. and trey gowdy, a favorite of the conservative base, gowdy nominatedrion in the republican conference to be their spokership nominee. there is an eran of good feeling. >> talk about a reluctant candidate. he didn't want the job and now he has the job. is the party and caucus going to unite. >> why would you want the job? how many of house speakers have gone on for bigger things. we know one thing that made him reluctant, it is a political job

and not a policy job. he is chairman of the house ways and moans committee. and this job involves a lot of fund-raising and given assurance he will not be john boehner to be on the golf course wooing donors. but whether or not he will get conservatives on his side. style wise he is different. but on the policy and immigration and trade, he's right there with john boehner. he said the committees will write the legislation. will that be enough to get the warm fuzzy feelings? >> it will get him a certain level of warm fuzziness. but the question is the source of contention over procedure. or policy? he is conciliatory of how it

will get passed and what will come up to a vote. the policy questions that particularly on the activist grass rots and none member of congress generate ire. like alex said ryan is not that different from the way speaker boehner was. rand paul is going after the deal. and making that a bone of contention and there is a likelihood that ryan might take hits down the road. and one hand and the other hand. and up sides and down sides and it will not be pretty forever. and we'll talk to rand paul and ask him about that. it would be nice to see if the public opinion of congress could come up a bit. alex and betsy, thank you. >> sure thing. >> how close is to close for the u.s. navy. russian bombers buzzes the uss

reagan and fighter jets escorted the russian planes away. and one exchange between marco rubio and mentor jeb bush. senator rubio saying this. >> i continue to have tremendous affection for jeb. i will run the campaign and they have a right to talk about the campaign. our campaign is about the future of america. what does governor bush think about that. he will be here.

big day? ah, the usual. moved some new cars. hauled a bunch of steel. kept the supermarket shelves stocked. made sure everyone got their latest gadgets. what's up for the next shift? ah, nothing much. just keeping the lights on. (laugh) nice.

doing the big things that move an economy. see you tomorrow, mac. see you tomorrow, sam. just another day at norfolk southern. ♪song: "that's life" ♪song: "that's life" ♪song: "that's life"♪ that's life. you diet. you exercise. and if you still need help lowering your blood sugar... ...this is jardiance. along with diet and exercise, jardiance works around the clock to lower blood sugar in adults with type 2 diabetes. it works by helping your body to get rid of some of the sugar it doesn't need through urination. this can help you lower blood sugar and a1c. and although it's not for weight loss or lowering systolic blood pressure, jardiance could help with both. jardiance can cause serious side effects including dehydration.

this may cause you to feel dizzy, faint or lightheaded, or weak upon standing. other side effects are genital yeast infections, urinary tract infections, changes in urination, kidney problems, and increased bad cholesterol. do not take jardiance if you are on dialysis or have severe kidney problems. stop taking jardiance and call your doctor right away if you have symptoms of an allergic reaction. symptoms may include rash, swelling, and difficulty breathing or swallowing. taking jardiance with a sulfonylurea or insulin may cause low blood sugar. tell your doctor about all the medicines you take and if you have any medical conditions. so talk to your doctor, and for details, visit jardiance.com. >> marco, when you signed up for this it was a six year term and you should show up to work. the senate is like a french work week. three days where you have to show up. you can campaign or resign and

let someone else taking the job. >> i don't remember you complaining the kanye voting record. and only reason now someone convinced you to attack me. my campaign is about the future of america and not attacking anyone on the stage. i will have admiration for governor bush. i am running for president. >> that was hottest exchanges/af last night. and republican debate generating buzz around governor bush and one- time protogee marco rubio. it is great to have you with us, governor. there is plenty said about your exchange with senator marco rubio. but yet to hear from you. in your reflection in the last several hours. what do you think of that exchange? >> look, i was cut off to complete the thought. i am a doer and i think we need

a doer as a president of the united states. we had seven years with a divider in chief who is spectacular as a candidate and great speaker and great politician, but divided all of the country and we are now suffering. the point is, pursuing your own ambition at the expense of service to others. marco is my friend and he is a gifted politician for sure. but we need to focus on on who can forge consensous and solve problems. that is my focus in new hampshire and i will campaign hard with the message that i can fix a broken washington. >> a few days ago in south carolina. i have a lot of cool things i could do other than sitting around being miserable. and listening to people demonize

me. why did you feel compelled to demonize marco rubio. >> oh, no, no, no. jenna,ç')z am not demonizing anybody. grid lock in washington, if you want to elect someone who preys on fears and angst i am not the right goichlt i can fix washington. i am not demonizing marco rubio by saying he will have the worst record. >> that is demonization and people think that. >> why? >> some think that it is a mistake. bush walks in rubio's trap. a donor remaining unnamed going after rubio was a mistake. no one cares about a missed vote in the senate and losing candidate cares about that. was it a mistake, governor? >> no, it was not a mistake.

it is a mistake to run and serve. he can do both. a lot of people work full-time. they are frustrated and show up for work. a lot of people can't take time off unless they get reduction in their way. are we creating a separate union verse inhwb'w washington d.c.? that is part of the problem. people can work and run for office. and say it is not important and not show up for committee hearings and show up when military families are wondering whether there there is a budget >> they are serious time,d i have the experience to do that. >> why are you pointing out rubio and not the other candidates. and what is it that you feel passionate about in rubio? >> he has the worst attendance

his. the three senators on the stage that were there last night and gifted politicians, you can count on two fingers on the number of bills that they sponsored that are law. if we are asking them to solve the grid lock we will be mistaken. just as when barak obama run for office and fooled us. it was going to be all about united states of america and no] red and blue states but we are divided. >> you heard the bells qbehind you and a siren. they are not sound affects that we are using or planned. we appreciate you rolling with us. >> it is live television. and the reason we are asking about that moment last night not only because of the questions that are coming up nationwide about the debate. and it is about this.

over the last few months, you talked about showing people your heart. who is authentic on the campaign trail. you made a real point over the last several months to not go after the fellow candidates and you are making a different decision now and we see it in this interview. why do you believe you need to to that now and what turning point does it represent in your campaign? >> this is not personal. i am not attacking character. i am saying people need to show up to vote. and use their office in a way to help their constituents. it is not a personal attack at all. and that applies to every elected familiar. in tallahassee, you can't just campaign. you have to show up. most state capitols that is the case. we have big grid lock in

washington dc. we should shrink the government work force and people are suffering outside of washington d.c. and washington is living large and playing by their own rules. >> there are those who say that is terminal for the campaign. andñi it is the end of your campaign. and why would that sort of opinion are wrong about you and your campaign? >> we are not -- we are still in october. we have 100 days left before we go to the iowa caucus. we have an extraordinary team. jud gray is endorsing me here in new hampshire. we have a great ground game in iowa. and we have the best organization. i am going to work hard to earn people's support. i knew it would be a long journey and to say that the campaign is terminal. that is funny.

>> criticism can reach extreme. and as an experienced politician, i know you understand that. >> i think the process part of this is not why i am3«!v runnin is for everybody else. >> who ever gets to the end though, what we see from the democratic field, will have to face hillary clinton. and carly fiorina believes that she is hillary clinton's worst nightmare and she is the person that hillary clinton fears most. why do you think you can beat hillary clinton and do you think she should fear you. >> you look at where the criticism goes by the clinton attack machine. half of it comes my way. they do foreme. i have a campaign of success. and it will be different than republicans perhaps. and long ago, committees have banned the republican party. i am a solid conservative ta

campaign in committees and i ca% win. and that's why i am attacked by the left more than any other candidates. >> governor bush, you can hear the bridge bell and siren and working saw behin you. and you mentioned live television is real life. we look forward to seeing you again. thank you see much. >> thank you for letting me be on. >> two russian bombers fly within a mile of the uss ronald reagan. and how the navy responded and moscow was see close to our ship. phil! oh no... (under his breath) hey man! hey peter. (unenthusiastic) oh... ha ha ha! joanne? is that you? it's me... you don't look a day over 70. am i right? jingle jingle. if you're peter pan, you stay young forever. it's what you do. if you want to save fifteen percent or more on car insurance, you switch to geico. ♪ you make me feel so young...

it's what you do. ♪ you make me feel ♪ so spring has sprung.

awe believe active management can protect capital long term. active management can tap global insights. active management can take calculated risks. active management can seek to outperform. because active investment management isn't reactive. it's active. that's the power of active management.

>> fox news alert. we told you in the top of the hour that a plane caught fire while taxis in ft. lauderdale

airport. one. engines, apparently the left one exploded in flames. they have the flames out and you can see dynamic air flight sitting there on the taxi way in the airport still surrounded by fire- fighting foam. the civil engineer and space engineer as well. and he joins us now as a frequent guest of our program. oliver, i heard of engines sometimes basically exploding andt( throwing the compressor blades out when a run up begins and they are ready to take off. but i have not heard of a plane catching fire while taxiing. how unusual is this? >> it is unusual. thank you for having me on your show today. the general electric pfsix's or rolls rice 211 or cracked

whitney pw thousand. and it is oneñi of three turboengines. and usually when you see a major fire in the engine it is associated with the flow instability called surge. because essentially it is station that cools the reverse flow through the engine and that is associated with something especially pretake off condition. a big fire means that your engine and surging and usually with low instability. >> passengers on board we understand got off. no, no injuries and see forth as a result of this. is this something that people have to worry about every time their plane pushes back from the gate and start to head off to the wild blue yonder. >> no, we are rest assured that flying is extremely way of

travel. and we can congratulate the faa regulation and when you see a fire on board, we have 90 seconds to get off of the aircraft. and the airliners are doing the practice scenario to get through those cabins quickly and get off safely. any time i see the evacuation where there are no injuries and tell me the 90 second evacuation works. and read those cards, folks. it is telling you what are the exit paths in an emergency situation and in this case. it is. >> that can safe your life. >> again a dynamic's airways plane sitting on the taxi way in fort lauderdale airport. >> and another story we are watching. new information developing overseas. wo russian bombers trying within

a u.s. carrier in korea. thexd u.s. responded with u.s. fighter jets escorting them away. >> the uss reagan was conducting exercises earlier this week when the russian anti- submarine bombers. the super hornets escorted the russian war planes away from the carrier. the submarine bombers came within one mile and i am told low as 500 feet according to a spokesman. a u.s. navy spokesman told me this morning it is not unusual and the russian remained at a safe distance and it is the latest inñr the aggressive move probing u.s. air space and navy

reaction time. senior officials are concerned that the uptake of russian submarine activities near the fiber optic could cripple the u.s. and the spy ship cruised was en route to cubbia on the coast of the united states. and they made 12 close range altitude passes near the uss black cook all part of the russian probing the u.s. and the nato allies. >> it is a story to watch. >> a solar storm warning. ending just a short time ago. it was issued after a massive ejection from the sun sent radioactive particles through space. it may have had impact on the radio signals in the polar

regions. no satellite problems are reported. >> three years after hurricane sandy ravaged the jersey shore they are making sure it is ready. and moderator taking heat in last night's debate. were the questions fair or unfair or ones that the candidates didn't want to answer. >> let's be honest. comic book version of the campaign. it is not nicely asked question the way you said that. in reddi-wip. ♪ reddi-wip. (flourish spray noise) share the joy. share the joy.

.

when you look at him do you see someone with the moral authority to unite the country. >> i love donald trump, he is a good man. i am wearing a donald trump tie. >> just a nasty question. but thank you, governor. >> judge you want me to answer or do you want to answer? i got to tell you the truth, even in new jersey is called rude. >> let me say something at the outset. questions asked see far in the debate illustrate why the american people don't trust the media. [applause] this is not a cage match. and if you look at questions. trump, are you a comic book villian. ben carson can you do math.

john kasich instult people here. jeb bush why have your numbers fallen. how about talking about the substantive issue. >> see cnbc moderators critized for gotcha questions on frivolous topics. and drawn in fact checking on stage. were the?ó-!! candidates defenr did the moderators drop the ball. ellen and jonah, both fox news contributor. ellen, the point was made the kinds of questions asked the republican candidates were not the kind directed to hillary clinton and bernie sanders in the last debate. >> i agree. i am a liberal democrat. and i think they did a terrible

job. carly fiorina. she was asked and gave her tax plan. and said it was going to be three pages because the current tax code was 73000. instead they asked about fantasy football. give me a break. >> let's play a montage of what the candidates had to say after the debate. and jonnah i want your reaction. >> everyone was ready to talk about trade policy and debt and everybody was ready for that. and then you get questions like everybody got designed to get us to fight or say something embarrassing about each other. >> they promised to stick to economic issues and substantive things and they didn't. >> moderators last night were awful and the press in this country in general has shown over the last couple of months they are biassed against the

republican party. >> it was a crazy set of moderators and ted cruz whose comments was right got a rousing round of applause and why the moderators got booed. >> has media or ted cruz succeeded unighting the republican party? >> certainly for a short period of time. we saw earlier in your program we are back to disunitty with jeb going after marco rubio. i agree with ellen it was a badly run or moderated and lots of silly questions and they made a mistake not focusing on economic policy which is cnbc's brand. it is less than the republicans get tough questions, i think it is fine in a democracy, but in democratic debates, the premise begins with asking democrats to prove how compassionate and

normal they are. and the republican debates. justify your bizarre and strange opinions on all of these strange things. it is an amazing thing. in the democratic debate no one asked how the democrats are paying for trillions in new programs where they will be spending other people's money. but everyone of the republicans are asked for how they will let people keep their own money. it is a strange thing. nboulder is a bastion of liberalism. but the moderators did not get a lot of support from the crowd last night. listen to this. f2dzy [crowd çóboos] let's talk about -- >> the cameras were pointed at the candidate but the moderators were not doing a good job.

>> but talk about who the audience is. who gets in the audience is people who are associated with the campaign and donors to the republican party. there are locates. and see you can't really rely on the audience. i am talk radio. and most american people thought moderators did a terrible job. >> you are in favorit. where did i read it? >> i don't know. you people right this stuff. >> that was cnbcñi becky quick asking donald trump where she and seemed like the research was not necessarily done for the debate. >> that came through powerfully even though i am tongue tied about it. when the fox debate happen.

they hunkered down intensively to. cooper came in loaded for bear. and these guys came in with sort of a condescending attitude that they are smarter than republicans and they didn't need to do the research. and the burden of proof was laid on the republicans. >> if i was the president of msnbc. that research department would get something the next morning. they did not do a good job either. and they feed the anchors the questions. >> spoken like a liberal democrat. >> thank you. >> super storm sandy rolled ashore three years ago. that process includes making sure the areas are ready for the next big storm. and the state plans to protect

the coast line are running into trouble. abbey has more from new jersey. >> reporter: that's right, jenna. three years ago today sandy slammed the state of new jersey and destroyed 4000 homes. as a result governor christie is planning to spend over $1 billion to reconstruct the beaches and building sand dunnes on the coast line. not everyone is happy about it. they don't want sanddunnes. and they think they have what they needed to be protective. >> they will be 50 feet deep and walk down to the beach. and see the beech would be consumed. >> jeff spent summers here as he has ten years and he believes the bulkheads are enough to protect the south beach community from another storm and

dunes are unnecessary. >> to say you have to have a dune system when the citizens don't want it is a big issue on citizen's rights. >> it is not about losing the beach front view. >> it is the cost of the system. and 150 yard beach and half consumed by the dunes. >> governor christie disagree. >> to towns like mar gate. you are amongst the most selfis jersey. >> now the republican actions using imminent demand to get the properties. >> we are not taking their land or doing anything but building a dune. we are trying to build protection for them and their neighbors around them. >> in terms of what happened

next. >> reporter: both sides will make a chance to make their case. obviously christie and the administration hope it moves quickly. folks in mar gate are not going down without a fight. xd >> interesting story. >> gop presidential candidates weighing in on the debate. you heard from governor bush. and senator rand paul and he will join us live next. >> you have the republican establishment making an agreement with the president. and they will raise the debt ceiling by an unspec foyed amount. they are giving the power to president obama to spend whatever he wants to spend, no limits. did you know that good nutrition

is critical for brain health? brain food, hmmm. ensure has b vitamins that help support brain health - now that's smart nutrition. ensure's complete balanced nutrition has 26 vitamins and minerals and 9 grams of protein. ensure. take life in. ♪ everything kids touch during cold and flu season sticks with them. make sure the germs they bring home don't stick around. use clorox disinfecting products. because no one kills germs better than clorox.

when people ask me whose fault is it that medicare is brokening out of money and

social security is brokening out of money. it is not republican or democrats fault it is your grand parent's fault for having too many dam kids. >> that was senator rand paul. one of the few chances he got to speak as he and nine rivals senator rand paul joins uslwsuz fromñi capitol hill. i was stw(i by the line that you used. don't blame republicans or democrats, blame your grand parents. elaborate on that. born after world war ii. but they had fewer kids than parents did. we don't have as many worker ares. when the programs started 16 workers for one retiree. with a lot of workers it is

now? >> there is blame to go around. i usually use a humorous line to let people know. what is the problem? i think it clearly defines the problem for people once they know it has to do with the size of workers and sometimes it gets the point across. republicans and democrats bear the burden of not bringing a solution. it is simple and different to do. and they are afraid the public doesn't like them.

i think the public wants to know the truth. we are outñi of money and we ha toñi fix the entitlement progra. >> you are outspoken in the opposition to the budget deal reached. you are planning a filibuster and mitch mcconnell maneuvered around it see you will not filibuster what you want. >> that's not true. there will be a legitimate filibuster and i will force them to come in at 1:00. and only way to stop is if they get to 60 votes. it is a filibuster in the traditional way but it matters if i get 41 votes. if they will say that this is a stinking rotten piece of you know what maybe we stop it. i object to it because it gives the president unlimited power to borrow unlimited amounts of money and bust the budget gaps.

this is why you are going vote. republicans and democrats want to bust the budget caps. >> senator, we have a commercial break can you stay with us for a couple of minutes more and we'll ask you another question or two on the other side of the break.

>> we are back with with presidential candidate senator rand paul. senator, you plan to filibuster the budget deal you don't like but you can not stop it can you? >> i can with a certain amount of votes. any time you have a filibuster the other side will try to shut you down. they will do it by trying to get 60 votes. if they do get 60 votes it will

end. and we will have delayed it untilñr a final vote. the reason i am making this. i am not sure i can get to 41 votes to continue the filibuster. this is why i run for office because i was concerned about the debt. we borrow a million dollars every minute. i don't think we can do this. and what disappoints me, right and left spend more money and raise the debt ceiling and we would let president obama borrow an unlimited amount of money. >> the senate is a collegial place and up to. by dragging in fellow septemberors in the wee hours to forts a vote. you don't thinkñi paul ryan on e house side will make much of a 6é:çdifference.

will you affect change on capitol hill if you don't win friends? >> i travel the country a lot. i haven't met one republican outside of dc that supports this. every republican i mote, don't raise the debt ceiling unless there is budgetary reforms. i am in not in the minority. even in congress house republicans voted 2- 1 against it. over half or two- thirds of the republicans were opposed to the deal. it is rotten and not conservative and going to explode the debt and see i don't know that i am trying to make enemies, but i am trying to do what the taxpayers of kentucky to do. not add more debt. b9u7h] >> you critized militaryxd spending and we opened our hour with russians sending more

planes by the aircraft carrier and the chinese threatening our navy ships when they sailed past. is this not a time when military spending might be prudent. >> i think the number one thing and obligation of the federal government bar none is defending the country. i will always prioritize spending on defending the country. but we don't get stronger by borrowing more money and going into debt and i think the number one threat to our national security is the debt. you can't borrow money for a good cause. and say we'll build planes and tanks with this. if you are doing it by further miring yourself in debt makes you weaker in the country. >> rand paul, thank you, sir. >> and we'll be right back. jeb bush: this president, with all due respect,

believes that america's leadership and presence in the world is not a force for good. america has led the world and it is a more peaceful world when we're engaged the right way. we do not have to be the world's policeman. we have to be the world's leader. we have to stand for the values of freedom. who's going to take care of the christians that are being eliminated in the middle east? but for the united states, who? who's going to stand up for the dissidents inside of iran that are brutalized each and every day? but for the united states, who? who's going to take care of israel and support them - our greatest ally in the middle east? but for the united states, no one - no one is capable of doing this. the united states has the capability of doing this, and it's in our economic and national security interest that we do it. i will be that kind of president and i hope you want that kind of president for our country going forward. announcer: right to rise usa is responsible for the content of this message.

>> big hour >> this is dynamic airways flight 405 with about 100 on board. the plane was taxiing for take off when the plane caught fire. fuel was leaking out of the aircraft b