Skip to main content

tv   Outnumbered  FOX News  March 15, 2017 9:00am-10:01am PDT

9:00 am
. >> heather: we'll see you back here in an hour. >> jon: outnumbered starts right now. >> heather: boi. >> fox news alert president trump hitting back at msnbc after releasing his tax returns. the much hyped doc released may actually be good news for mr. trump. i'm meaghan mccain, here today sand sandra smith, eboni williams and today's #oneluckyguy. former chief strata gist, steve hilton who is also the new host of the next revolution with steve hilton. congratulations. we're going to talk more about that later. first we remind you you're outnumbered. >> i always love it. >> it is so glad to see you.
9:01 am
we're glad you made it in. >> it was tough. i made it through the weather. it's good to be here in a very warm environment sgll congratulations all around. >> thank you. >> let's begin. the white house the calling the move desperate and totally illegal. msnbc's rachel maddow releasing two pages of president trump's 2005 tax returns. the documents revealing that the president paid roughly 25% tax rate on about $1553 million in income. president trump hitting back does anybody really believe that will a reporter who nobody ever heard of went to his mail box and found my tax returns? nbc news, fake news. >> i'm not quite sure what the tweet receivers to, does anybody believe he went to his mail box and found the tax returns? the fact that it's fake news doesn't have any relevance to the fact that the white house was quick to say that yes the
9:02 am
president paid $38 million of tax on $153 million in income. this is actually, you mentioned this at the top, may the began a pretty good story for this white house but the white house is professioning out abling over it, in a statement saying quote you the know you're desperate for ratings when you're willing to violate the law to push a story about two pages of tax returns over a decade ago:. you mentioned his effective tax rate. let's put up a page of comparison here so you can see what he did compared to other people. his tax rate was about 25.3% in 2005. that compares to president obama's tax rate in the 2015 of 18.7%. bernie sanders, 13.5% tax rate in 2014 and mitt romney who paid 14.# 1% in 120. the comparative numbers prompted
9:03 am
a cheek i response from senator rand paul who suggested maybe bernie sanders might want to take note of that, listen. >> since senator sanders is such a good social list i would think he would want to may his fair share. i'm happening him to send a couple hundred thousand dollars into the irs so he can pay his fair share. >> the president had $105 million of business losses. the wall street journal reported earlier he was eligible follow a $40 million charitable deduction for relation to a conservative easement that he would not develop ground into anything other than the a golf course which is allowable by the irs. the i are. s didn't argue with it. absolutely no suggestion in here of anything improper being done. again, it seems to paint the
9:04 am
president in a pretty favorable light, particularly when you look at those comparative numbers. meaghan. >> thank you so much, john. steve hilton, big breaking news last night. donald trump is a wealthy man who paid his fair share in taxes! it's amazing. there's this hold or british saying that relates to fox hunting. when something happens that under mines someone's argument they say we've shot your fox. this fox is well and truly shot. look at what they were saying about why it was so important to see trump's tax returns. one, because it would show that he's not as rich as he likes to think. that he doesn't pay as many taxes. he has something dodge i going on with russia. every single one of those things is shown not to be true. in terms of an media story obviously it's good for the president and not good for his critics. i think the really the important thing that underlies all of this is that they're not going to stop with this.
9:05 am
they're going to keep going because it's all they've got. it's all to do with the fundamental point that they don't think that he was legitimately elected. they can't believe he won the election. they hate the fact he's in the white house and they want to do anything to try to undermine him. that's why they're goingreturns. they hope in there somewhere is something to give you some kind of credence to this crazy conspiracy theory about russia colluded with the trump campaign. >> they teach us in law school you the don't ask a question you don't already know the answer to. the media was pushing the narrative of he's not as ruch as they say he is, he's not paying taxes. now i think they're regret feel. this notion of rachel maddow violating the law in what she did, there is actual federal code that says it is a felony. if someone releases tax returns if they're not authorized. but it's because that person is
9:06 am
an official felt government. irs, employee or something like that releases it. rachel maddow has protection under first amendment rights, it's muddy. >> so if the person got the return worked for rachel maddow. >> that could be a felony. >> what is interesting is donald trump's effective tax rate 25% i think is even higher than comcast's tax rates which runs nbc. let's just back up. should he release his tax returns? nixon released it when he was under audit. that's part of the debate, too. rand paul was pointing out bernie the sanders effective rate is so the low balls bernie sanders takes advantage of a lot of deductions that bernie sanders wants to cap for the upper brackets. he doesn't practice what he preaches in his own tax returns. >> we've seen the left reluctant to choose their battles. they've been attacking this president on everything.
9:07 am
does this put the tax issue to rest or will they continue to go after him? >> no, i don't think it will. they're going to keep going. like i was saying, to me there's something really deck ka dent about that. what i mean by that, right now in america you've got a really big crisis. you've got an academic crisis across the country. not across washington, d.c. and among the media and political establishment but you have people desperate for a job. social crisis, opioid crisis. it seems bad that the media establishment are just obsessed with chitchat around this kind of stuff when there's such big problems to solve. >> that's a great point. >> i want to go to this tweet: december's should return focus to trump care and not get distracted from a 2005 tax return. whoever got rachel maddow to
9:08 am
bait and switch and with flewsterred before her own show is brilliant. this will go down as one of the geraldo rivera al capone vault moments. it was ridiculous. i fell for this hook line and sinker. i was set to watch the real housewives of beverly hills, clicked over to msnbc instead. she teed it up, connections to russia. >> we are going to talk about the out rage from the left and right about the way she approached this at the top of her show. there was a moment where she did try to tie this to russia. she was trying to make something out of these taxes. she talked about that $40 million property that trump bought and sold to a russian ohly guard like that's supposed to mean something. >> that narrative is out there, right? about russia. so it's already out there, they're trying to tag the president with that. i don't know how you get more
9:09 am
information out of a two-page tax return. the took an hour and-a-half for the reveal to happen. all the buildup and a lot of disappointment. >> many on the left get this narrative wrong. my mother voted for trump because she said i don't want to pay this many taxes either. seriously. i think a lot of people on the left, on the right, in the middle are saying there's a lot of issues i might have with donald trump, this tax one isn't one of them. if he's smart enough to figure out a legal and legitimate way to minimize what you're giving the government who is not being a good steward of our money, i want in. >> most of this was in the form of the alternative minimum tax, something he's trying to get rid of. >> all right. don't worry, we're going to have much more on this story. what it all says about the liberal media and if rachel maddow will face back will be for over hyping the story that was called a nothing burger. law makers on both sides of the aisle running out of patience.
9:10 am
they want to see information if president obama asked for a wiretap of president trump. you can click on our overtime tab after the show, and you can tweet us any time, anywhere, see you there. pass liberty mutual won't raise your rates due to your first accident. . >> heather: >> jon :
9:11 am
>> jon: >> heather: >> jon:.
9:12 am
date. >> speaker3:. >> speaker4:. >> speaker5:. >>
9:13 am
9:14 am
>> announce . >> meghan: law makers on both sides of the aisle demanding evidence of president trump's claim that president obama ordered surveillance on him during the 2016 presidential campaign. >> sandra: the republican chairman giving a status update on their investigation just moments ago. watch. >> to date i've seen no evidence of that, supports the claim that president trump made that his predecessor had wire tapped he and his associates at trump tower. it deeply concerns me that the president would make such an accusation without bases. >> sandra: they also confirmed that james comey will testify on monday's hearing on russia. white house press secretary sean spicer saying president trump is confident the investigation will
9:15 am
vindicate him. watch. >> how confident is president trump that any evidence will rise to support his claim? >> i think he's extremely confident. i meaningsed this before. i'll let the house and senate and doj report this, but as i've commented in the past i think there is significant reporting about surveillance techniques that have existed throughout the 2016 election. i'll leave it to them to issue their report. he feels very confident that what ultimately will come of this will vindicate him. >> sandra: lindsey graham has asked director comey for evidence supporting the white house's claim. senators say they expect an answer from comey today. i want to go back to schiff's response to this. he said the reality is i don't think they have the foggiest idea what was behind potus's claims.
9:16 am
>> steve: i think the sad thing about all of this is that because of the actions of the fbi and the intelligence agencies during the obama administration people lost trust in anything they say. it's all very well for clapper for example to say i can absolutely tell you that this is false and there was no wire taps, he's the person that went to congress and lied directly about surveillance about the whole of the american people. and then comey, the way he behaves, people just don't believe what they're being told. that's not because people have become neurotic and conspiracy theory, it's because of the behavior of those people in power themselves. when people say those cliches we have to get to the bottom of this, got to clear it up, i think we'll never do that until we get a real grip, until the president gets a real grip of these intelligence agencies and the government and actually puts them on a much less oh lit at
9:17 am
this sized footing. . >> elizabeth: the president could call the fbi and say give me the information. but there is a report out there that there was surveillance of the russian computers talking to trump tower computers, worrying about the rush shaz helping with money. but now we have senator jeff grassly saying i'm going it wait and sit on the election of the deputy attorney general. >> meghan: i worry about the levels this is going to get to. i think it's very difficult for people to dee listen great between who is political and what is the truth. sean spicer says he's extremely the confident that the white house has proof. i think sunshine is the best disinfect tant. the problem is as you noted earlier there's reason to believe that these in telly genes agencies would do things
9:18 am
for political reasons. they feel better about the obama agency and the president who brought them into their news. >> sandra: fbi director james comey is expected to react to the questions about this, about evidence supporting the white house's wiretap claims. they are suggesting they could hear back from comey by end of d d day. >> eboni: look i said it yesterday, mr. president i'll hear your argument. show me the receipt. i think that's a simple and reasonable expectation at this point. i believe when sean spicer talks about the president and the white house being indicated. i think he's acknowledging a truth for had some supporters that president trump's credibility is a bit on the line with this accusation. that's a fair analysis. it's really an opportunity to rehabilitate that credibility until a clear and plane way for everyone. >> sandra: there was a conversation that took place at
9:19 am
the press beefing and there was talk about whether he meant this literally with the tweets with wire tapping or not. going back to our discussion about the fact it was in quotation marks. >> eboni: or he meant it to be surveillance. >> elizabeth: it can surveillance smart phones. >> steve: if that's true. you have reports from the new york times and lots of others that used the term wiretap to say it was going on. you're exactly right. saying people say let's get to the bottom of it, i don't think that's going to happen. it will leave people in the end if you're a trump supporter you will say you have a deep state against him and the establishment against him, they don't like him, they want to get him out. if you hate trump like the establishment you think he's a fan at that sift. whatever they say is not going to clear it up. especially comey. who trusts comey on anything? on either side. >> meghan: it's why he should step down. >> sandra: we'll be hearing from him today and possibly monday.
9:20 am
house speaker paul ryan says he's willing to anything go shat over the rockies' healthcare overhaul. democrat say they're ready to come to the table but only if rockies' give up on repealing obamacare. what's next in this fight? plus we're just hours away now from president trump's revised travel plan going into effect. but critics making a final effort right now to stop it in court. will they succeed? you don't let anything keep you sidelined.
9:21 am
that's why you drink ensure. with 9 grams of protein and 26 vitamins and minerals. for the strength and energy to get back to doing... ...what you love. ensure. always be you. experience exciting offers on sales event is here. our most elevated suvs ever. get up to $2,500 customer cash
9:22 am
on select 2017 models for these terms. experience amazing at your lexus dealer. ( ♪ ) i moved upstate because i was interested in building a career. i came to ibm to manage global clients and big data. but i found so much more. ( ♪ ) it's really a melting pot of activities and people. (applause, cheering) new york state is filled with bright minds like victoria's. to find the companies and talent of tomorrow, search for our page, jobsinnewyorkstate on linkedin. tech: at safelite, we know how busy your life can be. seamom: oh no...age, tech: this mom didn't have time to worry about a cracked windshield. so she scheduled at safelite.com and with safelite's exclusive "on my way text" she knew exactly when i'd be there, so she didn't miss a single shot. i replaced her windshield giving her more time for what matters most.
9:23 am
tech: how'd ya do? player: we won! tech: nice! that's another safelite advantage. mom: thank you so much! (team sing) safelite repair, safelite replace.
9:24 am
[ music playing ] . >> sandra: the gop and white house stepping up efforts to move healthcare legislation forward. house speaker paul ryan telling fox he's confident there's room for compromise. watch.
9:25 am
>> the budget committee takes this up on thursday. so those discussions about what kind of modifications, those are ongoing discussions. >> so you are open to changing? of course we are. >> sandra: chuck schumer pushing for a public position. if the gop stands down on scrapping obamacare, they're willing to compromise. >> if senator mcconnell, speaker ryan, and president trump say tomorrow they're giving up on repeal, we'll work with them to improve an aca. >> sandra: let's get first to paul ryan. okay, what got you there steve? >> i know this is not the level of political analysis people have come to expect on this show. but when i watched that, his eyes are like something, really weird going on, blue laser man, it was a little disturbing. >> i like that. >> sandra: we've heard a lot from him lately. let's go back to paul ryan,
9:26 am
weigh heard from him last night saying there's room for compromise. >> meghan: can i the jump on this? i can't handle this will when i saw the clip. he's been going on t.v. saying this is a wine nature ri choice, you're either with nancy pelosi, or with the republicans, the end. everyone in the freedom caucus needs to get in line. what changed last night? that little clip is very significant. >> elizabeth: where is the compromise? the big issue it seems is we have to take care of the poor. paul ryan said the medicaid block grants to the states, let the states handle that issue. the gop cannot fall down on this. they have to come out saying we are going to take care of the poor. can i make a point? the cbo scoring, they're saying 24 million people will not have insurance within ten years, that's about the same number on the cbo said were going to be in the obamacare exchanges and it's less than half of that. >> steve: they don't have a clue.
9:27 am
they can't predict how people would respond years down the line to changing market. but the underlying point here is actually not about healthcare. it's actually deeper than that. it's about how congress works. and the fact that it didn't work. i think the problem is, that if you look at the detail of this, be there's a whole bunch of things that paul ryan is saying will happen in the future, that may actually get some of those freedom caucus people on board, to create some kind of consensus. he's saying that we can't do that in this bill, because we can do it by regulation and we need other regulation and blah blah blah all this kind of in the weeds, the process of congress. that's what is driving this into the ditch. actually what everyone knows, that washington isn't working. the president was elected in order to make it work. i think the most important thing that needs to happen is someone to say to them, forget about your stupid rules and processes, it's not working for the american people. you have to make this all happen
9:28 am
quickly p. >> present a concise bill. just start with the bill you want. how about that? what about the one you put on president obama's desk in 2009? i think paul ryan understands there's blood in the water. >> this is upsetting. obamacare had in it health contracts saying to the states you can sell insurance across state lines, five states did it. the insurance industry has a lock on state capitols that it's hard to do that. >> the rob lobbying behind those insurance companies are so overwhelming, that's why i think we're not seeing that being taken advantage of. chuck schumer proposes a non-negotiable, the political promise that this whole thing is predicated o ultimately, you're right, the narrative around health care has changed per
9:29 am
obamacare. the one thing obamacare care proponents can talk about is more people have coverage. how do you keep the quote, more covered with reducing premiums, making it more affordable and improving healthcare. >> steve: market competition, get rid of the regulation that force people to have premiums they don't need and allow the competition in the insurance industries. it's not in the bill. >> eboni: insurance companies will let off and allow that competition to take place. >> meghan: it's conservative ideology that should be in this bill. we promised this for six years. the fact it isn't included is why a lot of people myself included are disappointed. >> eboni: president trump's ban goes into effect tonight at midnight. seven states across the nation are suing to stop the revised executive order. hearings taking it placed to in
9:30 am
two federal courts, one in maryland and the other in hawaii. this is what we know. this ban is a bit different than the first ban. people with visas are permitted to come in-and-out. one country is off, things of this nature. does it make it more likely to succeed? >> steve: there's a legal answer to that. my non-expert interpretation of the first one. is that actually the grounds for objecting were not particularly strong legally. they just got the process wrong. i think that the constitution and previous law gives the president a lot of discretion on immigration. i don't think that's changed. i think it's helpful that will they've got rid of some of the things that caused people to be really upset, green card holders and so on, interpreters in iraq got a lot of people anxious and upset f those things are dealt with, that helps politically. the fundamental the point to me is the real need here is what he
9:31 am
promised in the campaign which is extreme vetting. not just people from these countries but every one. so much time has gone by. why don't we just go to the extreme vetting. >> eboni: this does feel more like a vocal focus on national security. do you think that helps? the trump supporters are on board, but those that were alarmed at the first ban, does this feel better for them? >> elizabeth: personally, i think it should feel better for them because this is about region, not religion, as muslim reformers have repeatedly told us on camera. to steve's point, i think it's important. extreme vetting has to go to extreme vetting of etiology and you do not support sure ri allow, will not try to impose it in this country. it's unacceptable to our values of to lance, it's against our constitution and bill of rights.
9:32 am
>> sandra: the role out is going to look and feel so much different than the first time around. we won't see the delays and chaos that was striped and put ahead lines all over the world. that's going to feel a lot different. will that have any effect on the way this is perceived? >> steve: to a certain extent the heat has gone out of it. that was a very hot time indeed. actually some of the other things have happened since. that's a good point. i don't think it's going to be the same kind of feeling. but i don't know. if i'm right, they wanted 90 days for the ban. while they put extreme vetting in pleas. a good chunk of that time has been used up. i think that's the fundamental point is we need better security and the vetting of everyone. this travel order was always temporary any way. >> i want to the get to you meghan. hawaii's argument is a bit different. in some of the initial lawsuits there was a question in the legal community around standing. do the states have legal
9:33 am
standing around this? hawaii has a real plaintiff this time, a muslim doctor who is saying that his sir ian mother-in-law will not be permitted to visit. it will be interesting it see what hawaii does there. >> meghan: hawaii's big ar ument is it still is religious discrimination. we had intent coming into play when it comes to legal cases, meaning the quote muslim ban from the campaign trail words from mayor juliani and donald trump. do you think those will come back? >> speaker6: i expect the lawyers to make that argument. they have a strong counter argument which is national security. i think the closest they're going to get is this first amendment is kind of establishment clause. due process s. all of these things, that's going to be their best chance. they still might come up short.
9:34 am
msnbc's, rachel maddow -- president trump's tax returns, whether they did that and whether she wound up discrediting herself in the process. stay with us.
9:35 am
♪ when you have digestive sensitivities,
9:36 am
life can feel like a never ending search for food that won't cause bloating, gas, or inner turmoil. try pronourish. a delicious nutritional drink that makes a great mini meal or snack that has protein and fiber. and pronourish has no gluten or high fructose corn syrup. and is low in fodmap ingredients that can trigger digestive sensitivities. the search is over. pronourish. nutrition you can feel good about. hi hey you look good. thank you, i feel good. it all starts with eating right. that's why i eat amaz!n prunes now. they're delicious and help keep my body in balance. i love these. sunsweet amaz!n prunes, the feel good fruit.
9:37 am
9:38 am
>> major back lash over rachel madd maddow's alleged scoop on president trump's tax returns. both liberals and conservatives are accusing her of over hyping what they had and playing raters for ratings. she said breaking, we have trump's tax returns, and then clarifying what we've got is from 2005, details tonight,
9:39 am
9:00 pm. msnbc, the network clicking off the seconds to her time. when 9:00 pm eastern rolled around, this happened. >> without further ado i pass the baton to my colleague, rachel maddow. your show starts now, good evening rachel. it's been a little hullabaloo around here. >> people were tweeting shut up, get to rachel. >> you can't before 9:00 because i'm not sitting here until 8:59. thank you. thank you to joining us for the next hour. you may have heard, we've got some significance breaking news tonight. donald trump's tax returns. breathe. >> oh my gosh, it took her 20 minutes to get to her story. and then when they are show ended msnbc's lawrence oh done he will invited maddow to his set before talking but not before gushing to her about her reporting. >> you know normally at 9:00 pm
9:40 am
i have some stuff to do to prepare for a 10:00 pm live tv show. all that stuffy made sure was done at 8:59 p.m. [ laughter ] >> i got to watch every minute tonight. this has been riveting television, an amazing level he will have legs. >> okay. viewers were not impressed. some tweet saying odd and blatantly vague. she's now nothing more than a girl who cried wonderful. rachel maddow turned a scoop on donald trump's taxes into a cynical self defeating spectacle. she is no journalist. she did trump a major favor. he paid more taxes than obama and even bernie. i have so much to say on that. so much to say. i will start with you, steve. i -- it's one of the more bizarre things i've seen on television in my entire life and i'm 32 years old. >> steve: i was battling through the elements to get here from california. i missed it. i didn't see it.
9:41 am
that's the first time i've seen it. it is kind of ex screws yat withing. you watch that, and you're, oh wow. i think to me this is -- this illustrates a bigger the point which is for weeks and weeks and weeks we've just seen this endless speculation and conspiracy theories and trying to make something out of nothing. and it's just really, i think there's a sort of nervous breakdown going on the left and the in the media. who are just so desperate to prove that theory, that obviously, it can't be a straightforward as donald trump won the election. because people wanted change in america, that it has to be beca russians conspired. and they're so desperate to prove that they'll go to any lengths. it's really embarrassing. >> she has producers, i found out this was reported that donald trump paid $38 million in taxes. i don't know what the giant
9:42 am
reveal was on this last night. >> why was it significant as they presented it last night. the story line was from the democrats that donald trump has paid no taxes. he has been paying taxes. even the white house the scooped rachel maddow because it took her an hour and-a-half to get to the story, cnbc said this, they put up the piece said trump just got a nice victory thanks to rachel maddow. people were wetting out it takes less time to fill out your taxes than to get to the so-called scoop. >> meghan: it was like the reality show was hyped. much like the bachelor finale was, we're going to have the big reveal coming up at 9:00 pm, the most dramatic tax return ever. i agree the left is having some sort of maybe divorce want from reality right now. >> sandra: the president used a good word, desperation. i was like you meghan, i tuned
9:43 am
in, even though i knew that the white house had already scooped her report on this and put the taxes out there. and i watched it. i feel like her viewers, that i kind of want an apology for wasting my time. >> 100%. i miss the a finale last night. >> then i switched over to tucker. . >> eboni: rachel and her producers were genuinely very excited, we got the tax return. the thing that donald trump never wanted us to get our hands on. that part was very exciting for them. the other part, what's actually on the tax returns, seems to have discouraged them. >> it shows he paid -- this was missing in the reporting. this is what happens when you stand in the a men corner talking to each other and you don't do reporting. that's what the problem is going on at msnbc. i don't care what their ratings are. it's not fair and it's not
9:44 am
journalism. they didn't report that obama had a lower tax rate and bernie sanders lower, comcast, owner of nbc, lower. warren before you et al., lower. >> meghan: political implications, it was a very good night for donald trump last night. thank you rachel maddow for proving to your trump haters and followers how successful donald trump and that he paid $40 million in taxes, tweeted donald trump jr. that was the big reveal, he paid his fair share. . >> eboni: they were concerned with the reveal that we got what he said we couldn't get. they missed on you important the substantive reveal it is >> meghan: i don't see how you miss something like that. if i was tweeting something as hyped as this. we got it y'all, and no one bothered the read the $38 million line. >> as stupid as my brother that sends me things on line that shows me the lock necessary monster exists.
9:45 am
no offense to my brother. a case in the courts right now that could have an impact on people known as dreamers. a judge's recommendation for his case and the president it could set for everyone else covered by the obama's administration deferred action on deportation.
9:46 am
9:47 am
9:48 am
9:49 am
moment. first to steve scott with what's coming up in the second hour of happening now. >> new charges in the major hacks of yahoo. justice department blaming russia. this all comes as we await news from fbi director about investigations into russia and the charge by president trump that he was wire tapped. also expecting a news conference from freedom works on the republican plan on healthcare. they say they want a full repeal of obamacare. could be another blow to the healthcare that is facing major head winds on capitol hill. we'll update you on happening now. >> sandra: big test for the 800,000 so-called dreamers in the united states. centering around the outcome of this case. covered by daca, damage
9:50 am
republican president obama's deferred deportation policy for those brought here illegally as children. he was arrested on suspicion of having gang ties, which he denies. now a judge in washington state rejecting his request for relief and recommending instead of immigration court this case should go to federal court. a decision could be made on whether his arrest and detention violated his constitutional rights. quote, courts have recognized that daca confers lawful pence but courts have not defined the rights that flow from this lawful presence. he be on buy, to you first, with our legal mind on the couch. >> eboni: this is going to be a fantastic test case to tell us what the daca, deferred rights really mean. how wide do they go? what the scope en tailings. we know it means you can have legal presence in our country,
9:51 am
if you were born here, before the age of 14, we know that much. what this case will tell us, does that mean you get the constitutional rights of actual united states citizens? due process rights, those types of rights? that's a huge question that in twitter, i have debates about this all the time. are you treated the same as a united states citizen just because you have residency rights? so i think this is going to be a brilliant very important very critically the important test case, constitutionally for us to have an answer, definitive answer around how broad that scope of rights are. >> elizabeth: how were his rights violated if he was arrested for gang ties. >> steve: surely criminality. >> eboni: he was arrested under suspicion of that. i'm not sure of the probable cause. they talk about gang tattoos. he was key tand around immigration. this was around an immigration hold. that's the question. so it's the -- how those two go
9:52 am
together. the immigration rights. that's why this was taken out and put into federal courts. we want to test the issue of how broad your constitutional rights really go. >> what do you see happening here? >> elizabeth: i think this is a battle roy yal. it could be a game changer case. there are due process rights that have already been afforded to illegals here. that's the way the courts have ruled in the past. however i think if he is guilty of gang ties, that's an issue. >> eboni: that's what i want to make clear, that's a cripple cal issue and certainly he will be convicted if that's the case. that's different from his immigration status. >> elizabeth: this will be the wrong test case for this. >> eboni: when we ta. >> meghan: there are many tent at that kls when it comes to immigration. we're not going to let them into without recourse.
9:53 am
dreamers is a big issue, children brought here under the age of ten and grew up here and for all intents and purposes pr americans. i know dreamers, it is a very emotional topic for me. i'm very hard lined on immigration except on this specific issue. when you're talking about the beta test case it will be interesting to see where this goes. each person president trump has indicated he would be more compassionate toward dreamers. >> steve: that's important. he has a big job to do to deliver on important issues on immigration, on controlling it better, on making sure that people who have committed crimes aren't allowed to stay. if he's going to win those arguments, he can't be hard line on the dreamers. i think that's part of getting this -- >> eboni: some buy in. >> steve: this is a legal issue note a political one. it's so easy for those things to be muddled up. >> eboni: i think the politics drip into the legality of this
9:54 am
case. this is around intention. children don't have the negative intention behind violating immigration status. that's why we have this type of statute hut. it's going to be interesting. >> sandra: we want to save time to talk about steve's new show. more outnumbered in just a moment. your insurance company
9:55 am
9:56 am
won't replace the full value of your totaled new car. the guy says you picked the wrong insurance plan. no, i picked the wrong insurance company. with liberty mutual new car replacement™,
9:57 am
you won't have to worry about replacing your car because you'll get the full value back including depreciation. and if you have more than one liberty mutual policy, you qualify for a multi-policy discount, saving you money on your car and home coverage. call for a free quote today. liberty stands with you™. liberty mutual insurance. with 9 lobster dishes.est is back try succulent new lobster mix & match or see how sweet a lobster lover's dream can be. there's something for everyone and everyone's invited. so come in soon. >> a big announcement for our one lucky guy today, steve helton. he is launching a new show right
9:58 am
here on fox news channel called "the next revolution." it will air sunday nights at 9:00 eastern it will focus on the populist uprising that has upended politics from the u.s. to the u.k. steve, congratulations pray tell us about it. >> thank you, it all started here with my time that i've loved getting to know everyone, meeting everyone here. it is such a wonderful opportunity. i'm really excited to be doing it. it's going to be fun. slightly different from the west coast, as you mentioned, every sunday night, 9:00, starting probably in a couple months, not quite sure about that yet. any month soon, and i think that as well as being focused on the populism that is really changing everything from brexit in the e.u. last year and donald trump selection, elections this year, there's a bit of a global focus but also because we are on the west coast, sup technology and they are and how our lives are being shaped by that. lots of fun stuff. >> i do not think you will be
9:59 am
short on content. >> exactly. >> i just want to know if you're going to dress casual on your show. i hope so. >> i may vote for dressing casual, i like it. >> especially on the west coast. >> this is sort of your signature look. >> that is how i feel comfortable. i hope the viewers will come along and join us when we get going. >> will there be a lot of viewers in europe watching you? >> i don't know about that. these days, people can watch all over the world and fully we have stuff people are interested in online in things they can check out. it's going to be fun. >> you have an amazing background, amazing to have you as one lucky guy today. >> wonderful to be able to talk about it. and like i said, just join us in los angeles whenever you are there. >> we will be tuning in with that shout launches, steve hilton, thank you for being here. ou all here as well. we are going to keep it right
10:00 am
here for "outnumbered" overtime on the web and find us on facebook at facebook.com/outnumberedfnc. we are back at noon tomorrow, and "happening now" starts right now. >> jon: we start with a fox news alert, president trump's pick for national intelligence director cleared for a confirmation vote in the u.s. senate. >> heather: making it all but certain that senator dan coats will be confirmed as the nation's top and judge dulac intelligence official. we're covering all of the news "happening now" ." >> jon: the fbi director expected to reveal whether that department is invested getting claims by president trump that his predecessor ordered wiretaps on trump tower during the 2016 campaign flared plus the white house working toward a compromise on health care amid defections from our republican lawmakers. house leader kevin mccarthy updates as. and... a powerful winter storm now moving through canada. we will take you live to one of the hardest

266 Views

1 Favorite

info Stream Only

Uploaded by TV Archive on