c4 frustration is about idaho. three weeks to the day after the horrible murders of those for college students there. police have no suspect, no murder weapon, and no motive. hello everyone welcome to "fox news live" i am eric shawn. arthel: hi eric hello everyone i am arthel neville. police are now beginning to rule out people as suspects. the victims families are fuming over conflicting statements and a lack of clear information. the parents of victim kayleigh

are speaking out saying they are losing confidence in the investigation. >> i did to sit with the investigator the lead investigator and i looked in his eyes and i got a sense this guy was going to do everything in his power to figure something out. but if the evidence isn't there, that's the part i am concerned. eric: christina kallman is live and moscow, idaho with the very latest there. >> hi eric growing frustration in kayleigh's mother says this horrific attack this is what nightmares are made of it. she is a desperate for answers but in an interview on lawrence jones cross-country her father says that he has been meeting with law enforcement has met with them repeatedly. he knows they are working hard. he does support law enforcement paid but again he is very frustrated with the lack of information being released to

the public. >> its day after day after day every day you wake up and think today's the day. were going to hear something and you see the other break in the case and you are just stupid. >> on the least i was never there. stop playing games. this is serious these are people's lives this is the future of this community. >> i mean you can just tell how upset they are. you can hear in their voice. they did that interviewed last night. hours later they were also on fox and friends early this morning. they are determined to keep this case out there in the public cyber they do not want this case to go cold. kaylee's father expressed frustration of the investigative police investigation? and the people investigating right now? >> i do not feel confident. that is why i push the envelope

and say a little bit more i hate to be that guy. but there is a job to do. everybody has a job in a role to play in this. this is my role as a parent. >> but idaho state police maintain this investigation has been conducted appropriately. they said moving forward properly they are working with fbi. they continue to state they're not going public with some information they do not want to compromise this investigation. >> we do know there is a person or persons that is in our community or someone's community out there that hasn't murdered four people. and so we recognize there is a fear in the public. we are trying to work through that part of her trying to complete our investigation and work on an arrest were trying to advise the public of where we are at that's where they are comfortable. >> in the latest update from moscow police which we got late yesterday again they did not

state there is any arrest in this case. they've not tracked down a murder weapon yet or pinned down a motive for the sake of getting a lot of help from the public for law enforcement has received nearly 3000 tips in this case. you're going to review that is part of this ongoing investigation. back to you. eric: a lot to go through christina thank you, arthel. arthel: eric, for more on this the victims families questioning how authorities are really out suspects apart are going to bring in steve rogers retired new jersey 26 active lieutenant and former member of the fbi national joint terrorism task force. so steve can't explain why they're rolling out suspects and also what kind of evidence and information gathering might investigators being not making public. >> to begin with arthel and believe the police are doing the best they could press the father so eloquently articulated he is supporting the police but i will say this for the parents are rights. look, i've been a police officer

38 years. when they started releasing names of people who are cleared, i got a little concerned about that. the police seemed to be and i did read a report regarding that they're trying to control the narrative on social media concerned about people who are assuming who is guilty, who is not, et cetera. that's not the job of the police. the job of the police is to focus on the investigation like a laser beam. but people are going to believe what they want to believe you cannot control these narratives these days. the parents are right. with regard to the evidence, they are certainly doing a lot of work. forensic leviton's, criminal profiling that's what they need to focus on. and then feed the people especially the parents especially, feed them what they need to know without compromising the investigation. now look, i've heard on the news media statement from corners, politicians, police officials and on and on and on. they need one spokesperson to

get all the information together because the key is confidence in the police. arthel: sure that's why we have you here, steve byrd you have done these types maybe not this exactly type of investigation but you have done investigations out so i'm trying find out two things again, we understand you say they should speak to the family for their so much they can tell the family because they do not want to compromise the investigation. is there something they could have information that could have evidence or eyewitnesses or something some sort of interview that could help them find the suspects, find the killer? and then also wild you are at it i did read you can speak to this as well for me that part of the reason why they are releasing suspects because of social media and threats to people. that is where we are now. so that does change you are right it's not the job of the police. but that is where we live now in this new society where people are threatened and many people act on threats that are posted

on social media. >> are absolutely right. guess back to my point look at how many people are going to assume who said this who did that it is just uncontrollable. the police need to focus not be distracted but be focused on this investigation. now they can certainly set down the parents and give them everything that they have it. and i support that and i'm sure the parents of a very cooperative and not talk about that. but with regard to the evidence it is clear to me it's clear to me because it basically admitted that they have no solid evidence leading to those suspects. i would never release that. guess who is watching, the killer you're giving the killer a lot of information that he or she does not need to know. so my experience has been essay enough that will certainly be credible but at the same time not compromise the invest investigation. and build public confidence in the police but it's pretty easy to do it's the way we did in the old days.

arthel: isn't unusual there is no murder weapon or suspect three weeks later? >> not unusual with this type of crime it. i'm speaking to some very well experienced homicide detectives. they have told me look there's been many investigations they have been on there were no murder weapons. however what i think is unusual and may be a little bit more involved is a what's unusual is a known blood from the suspect in this type of case. especially when they believe there is a bit of a struggle. they may have information and evidence that will lead them to a suspect. but at this point in time they're not sharing that with a speed that but do not go off on a tangent releasing names of people who are cleared how does that help the investigation? spray for okay did you have question is there's one question burning you right now but i've got to go if there's you could answer that is there one question you would like answered?

>> i want to know who made the 911 call. i want to know exactly who made that call i want to know if they leaned over, looked at the body and that's when they conclude it was unconscious but you're going to lean over and look at body you're going to see blood the burning question is still in my mind. arthel: steve rogers thank you so much we want those families to get some sort of relief here and answers to the gruesome murders of their children, retired new jersey police detective lieutenant steve rogers thank you so much. so far are so into it arthel thing for this been arrested in texas a fedex driver in custody and charged with capitol murder. police say he has confessed to kidnapping and killing little 7-year-old athena strand for the driver allegedly abducted her from her driveway after delivering a package to the family's home in paris, texas is north of fort worth. charles watson live with the very latest on this breaking case, charles. parks had a good afternoon eric. you can imagine the family of

7-year-old said their absolute heart broken after the young girl's body was found on friday. the 7-year-old's mother paid tribute to her on social media this morning riding in a facebook quote her name is athena press late monroe strand she was perfect. she was born perfect and beautiful. daddy and mommy were scared of how beautiful she has always been the proof you like we failed you. no one deserves what happened to you but especially you. i love you and love does not even cover it. mommy's heart broken without you. the county sheriff's office at strand suspected killer 31-year-old fedex driver tanner was arrested and charged after confessing to abducting strand from her father's home in paradise, texas late last week and shortly thereafter killing the young girl, take a listen. >> you think athena died within just a very hour or so the very hour or so after her departure

from her home. >> is one of the toughest investigations i have been involved in. because it is a child. cracks and so now i texas woman says she has been sounding alarms for years the post to facebook at 23 old woman we are keeping private for the moment says assaulted her eight years ago when she was a minor. she writes taylor lynn horn the men who rape me at 168 years ago murdered athena strand the seven year old girl. i hope the family gets a justice they deserve. i hope he rots and i hope everyone who did not believe me when i talked about this for eight years does now produce not clear whether there was or will be in investigation into these claims are at this point is not been charged in connection to the assault allegations. meantime fedex is seeking out a riding in a statement their

thoughts and prayers are with the strand family pair they also say they are cooperating with police. as for horner police have not released a motive as to why he abducted this young girl. and allegedly killed her pretty still being jailed $1.5 million bonds, eric. eric: r8 charles thanks so much arthel. arthel: it's very upsetting for another senseless crime in new york city for the same crime video. men >> in the back of the head with a baseball bat happening in broad daylight just as people are heading to work the victim's head in the hospital. nate's is live in new york city with disturbing details have they found the suspect? parks arthel, they have not found the suspects. in fact the identity of the suspect is not known. he is still out there right now print that is my nearest city police are releasing the shocking video. hopefully someone can identify him and they can track them down for and i want to show you the video part i want arbutus or know it is very disturbing to

watch, take a look. this playing out tuesday morning just after 8:00 a.m. in upper manhattan parade the man dressed in black sneaks up on the guy in a red he let the bystander walked by pulls a baseball bat out from under his close take a crow hop, hits the man in the back of the head producer he goes down he then stands over the victim he appears to be yelling at the victim. it's not known at that entity in any interaction before this for the good news is the is in stable condition ceased able to sit up and should be okay pretty want to show you a picture of the suspects face. take a look because in the video you just saw, arthel his face was covered. this picture from the same day you can see his face. again the attack played out tuesday please release these images yesterday in hopes of being able to identify this man. fortunately this is a trend -- unfortunately as the trade in new york city. crime is up 26.8% in new york city a felony assault like we

just saw up 13-point to percent print some blame manhattan's progressive d.a. alvin bragg for but so far this year he's downgraded 52% of all felony cases to misdemeanors. that is up from 39% in 2019. back out here live arthel police are hoping to really generate some tips after releasing that video. most if they can identify and track down that suspect in the coming days will send it back to you. >> indeed. elon musk study will reveal on how twitter worked to suppress the hunter biden laptop story and had the 2020 election friday's revelation still pouring in. alexandria hoff has those details. >> last night elon musk hosted a live q&a on twitter amir bus was asked if he and the relationship between twitter and the democratic party amounted to

election interference, here's how he responded. clearly if twitter is doing their bidding before an election, shutting down voices on voter election that's a very definition of election interference. what dhec else, yes progress musk had teased perhaps more documents would come out yesterday. one set of those been publicly released he said the entire trope was made available to subsector writer barry weiss who is reporting is in addition to the lengthy tweet threat released friday by a fellow writer mats. in that musk provided internal communication showcasing the internal debate within twitter, whether to suppress in your post story on hunter biden's laptop. it was eventually categorized as a breach of the companies hacked materials policy. e-mails are also revealed routine requests by the biden team to review tweets which were

then quote handled by staff. reaction from republicans has been swift. >> what elon musk has been able to do now we know why the white house wanted to fight so strongly against him owning twitter all he has done is put out the truth. now we need to start looking at facebook, google requests yesterday's twitter's new ceo asked white so many mainstream media companies are downplaying or ignoring the twitter files altogether. musk said quote because were complicit, eric. quicksort alexander thank you, arthel. suite five lesson 48 hours until the polls open georgia senate run offered both camps are stomping across the peach state today and they are bringing some big names with them. we are live from the campaign trail up next

arthel: the countdown is on senator raphael warnock republican challenger former football star herschel walker are both making their final pitches to voters. congressional correspondent is live in loganville, hyatt

aishah. >> herschel says it feels great about his chances on tuesday. he's wrapping up an event right here in loganville bird short of a shaking hands and hugging his supporters right now. he just took the stage with senators tim scott and john kennedy. they are trying to get out the vote because he does not have much time left to close that four-point gap that is separating him from raphael warnock pretty needs that voter turnout. if early voting numbers are any indication of what is to come, arthel get ready. secretary of state's office reports a whopping 1.8 million georgians voted early or by absentee ballots. that's a quarter of active voters in the peach state with officials preparing for a very long nights. >> i anticipate we may not know on tuesday night. it really depends. it is up to the voters and they are showing up in droves. 1,000,008 here 52000 is a ridiculous number no consults and talked to republican or

democrat or election people have seen this early there's always a lot of enthusiasm. hooks out today center warnock is also hitting the trail hard just held a rally in gainesville with two more scheduled in athens tonight but still no visit by president biden who just push for georgia to be on the first frame primary states and believes that this race is a critical for his agenda and the next two years. democrats of course once the seat they want some wiggle room diminishing the leverage centrist senators joe manson and kyrsten sinema hold all republicans of course want this seat so they can have equal representation on senate committees. back out here live with all of that in play, you can see some big crowds everyone expecting pretty high voter turnout on tuesday, arthel. aishah i think earlier i think he said scooby wonder was going to be performing down there did

that happen? >> he's doing a virtual event it's not actually happening in georgia he's going to do that virtually for senator warnock urban center warnock has had quite a few people come down for him different celebrities, singers, rappers and more to come on tuesday as well or monday excuse me. >> i was just going to get jealous if you get to see scooby live that is everything. >> exactly. that would have been a dream it. [laughter] yes yes. alright aishah like to see a good job. eric. >> that would be something. meanwhile republicans swept every race for state office in georgia. this is her second senate run off into years. what does that that mean for republicans in the state? longtime democrat political activists great to see you. they're having a rally for walker but he's just not getting the attraction of the republican candidates have why do you think that is so?

quicksort is that saying "stranger things" can happen. i do not think that applies to this race. you have got an unconventional candidate in herschel walker ending this campaign this runoff race in a very unconventional way or the press is literally asking him if his campaign is trying to hide him from voters and the press. what we are looking at is that senator warnock has had the consistent lead. i think many people are surprised with just how close this race still is given the accusations about pressured abortions and abuse. for herschel walker to pull this out on election day i think it's going to have to be his biggest comeback ever. eric: he was on with maria in the hour before this and that was a rerun of "sunday morning futures". he sounded confident. you've got that record turnout,

how do you interpret what that record turnout means for this race? be absolutely happy with the 1.8 million people who turned out to vote early voting. if you look at where the 1.000000 voters have turned out it isn't democratic strongholds. since that doesn't bode well for senator warnock. we do not know what type of enthusiasm we will see on election day but is why you haven't democrats and saw herschel walker really pushing to get out the vote. trying to get all those votes out with a runoff it's always about your turnout operation brickwork that is the case. meanwhile some republicans, man oh man lieutenant governor duncan has been harsh and critical of walker and the choice of walker as the republican candidate. he said he did not vote for him. he did not vote for the center to either, here's what he had to

say. i've got to kids that can articulate the platform better than donald trump and his group support all across the country. this is not the right brand i think herschel walker will probably go down when the worst republican candidates in our party's history progresses did not mean to cut you off you heard what he said herschel walker he thanks is going to announce the worst republican candidate in history. wow he's taking no prisoners on that. >> vampires and werewolves decide that decision was made by former president trump. at the end of the day have got to say from lieutenant governor that is a copout. you have got to vote. a deep record number people did it he should've made that choice too. >> we have the privilege and it is our right and absolutely agree we should get out and vote. good to see you as always we will see what happens 48 hours from now brickwork nice seeing you eric. c5 all right, high inflation is

not slowing down holiday shopping. in fact sales from black friday and cyber monday broke records. this assigned the economy is strong support of a temporary trend? we will ask founder former ceo of sharper image. he is up next cityserve, started rescuing women, children and the elderly. and as winter approaches, they need our help sincec5 the city of waukesha

wisconsin who in their christmas parade a little more than a year after the deadly attack ended 2021 parade. darrell brooks drove his suv through the parade route killing six people and injuring 60 more. more than 60 per he was sentenced in october to life in prison. parade organizers say this year's theme is a peace on earth and. they expect a record attendance for taking a life like now in downtown the city administrator says there are extra security measures in place including barriers, and a larger police presence there.

we'll have a reaction as well as highlights on the fox report at 6:00 p.m. eastern. >> despite inflation still at a nearly 40 year high this shopping season is in full swing. americans are spending money again sales from black friday and cyber monday reaching records for some companies. estimating the holiday sales could top $9 billion. our next guest knows a lot about the seas author of the book the sharper investor when it comes to items that are sharper he is the guy's founder and former ceo of the retail giants, the sharper image. richard joins us now. shoppers back in stores have we recovered largely from the pandemic? >> thank you for having me er erica. the accumulated money during the first covid pandemic when we

were locked down pretty much. so they have cash to spend. eric: having cash to spend how does that help all of us in the economy? you see that continuing throughout the christmas season? >> think everyone has been pleasantly surprised how strong the spending has been. this will probably prevent a hard recession and cushion the blow if we do have a recession. >> use a hard recession there are predictions of a possible recession. we see some companies retrenching layoffs and industries in this sort of thing. what will happen on the horizon over the next year or do we have to look out for? >> everyone has been analyzing it over and over in trying to decide are we going into a serious recession or can it be what we called a mild recession which may last for two quarters

or three quarters. that would be great news for the stock market and for peoples in general spending and the employment if we could keep it to be a mild recession. >> what in terms of a mild recession method to client only two or 3% that is mild and we will not even notice it. why are some industries are they preparing ahead of time anticipating go have a downturn ahead of that? >> correct that i met unemployment remained low. what are companies do to prepare for? they have been doing layoffs honestly. this is a first time we have seen any layoffs in the past five years that is unusual. on the other hand unemployment

rate is still at a historic low. anyone who wants the job can find the job it's amazing pe people. it's amazing the analysts there is still such a strong demand for workers and it's not being filled. >> we are seeing gasoline prices go down. what do you expect will happen to the next year as those prices decline? unemployment low as you say why does that mean for the rest of us? how do we prepare? is there anywhere to prepare for a recession whether or not it's harder or mild as we would help if there is one? >> how do we prepare? gosh. well, people are definitely spending less on food. org downscale with their having to buy part having a macaroni and cheese instead of filet mignon. i'm sort of joking that people do have the ability to move up and down with the purchase of

the grocery store. in terms of a parable we have seen is a decline in prices. all the major retailers order to much in late summer. and as a result they've been giving heavy discounts. consumers are finding some real bargains when they go out black friday and black monday. we are preparing by moving down what we purchase. eric: bargains are good news pay finally richard in the sense, do you have any reassuring news? i guess there is some reassuring news for our viewers and for americans about what is going to happen through the next year. but what should we look out for? don't spend it all, don't put it all of the credit card. >> writes. when we talked last i predicted we would see inflation begin to turn by this november. and in fact it has. it's going down slowly mainly instead of 9% it's only 7% this

month. but by january or february it will probably be down to 6%. by april probably 5%. the markets and people in general and the companies are going to be encouraged by this trend. we have really everything to look forward to is good news i think in the coming six months. before you can get better from santa claus with that. inflation going down, gas prices going down but keep a little money on the side just in case. richard is the founder of sharper image and author of the book the sharper investor. richard think he will check back with you after the holidays, take care. >> thank you. by eric. arthel: we are taking you to the white house now live checking out the kennedy center honoree's meeting with president biden and vice president harris. this year's honorees that legendary iconic gladys knight, george clooney, and others.

the candy said the honorees chosen for the impact on american culture and everyone will head over to the kennedy center after this reception we are watching here at the white house. the kennedy center honors always a hot ticket. good stuff. president biden said he is open to meeting with vladimir putin about ending the war in ukraine with conditions for the white house as there are no plans for that right now. so what needs to happen before real peace talks need to begin? that is up next a chip in your windshield...yt trust safelite. this couple was headed to the farmers market... when they got a chip. they drove to safelite for a same-day repair. and with their insurance, it was no cost to them. >> woman: really? >> tech: that's service the way you need it. >> singers: ♪ safelite repair, safelite replace. ♪

hi, my name is tony cooper. and if you have both medicare and medicaid, i have some really encouraging news that you'll definitely want to hear. depending on the plan you choose, you may be eligible to get extra benefits with a humana medicare advantage dual-eligible special needs plan. all of these plans include a healthy options allowance. depending on the plans available in your area, you could get up to $1800 a year to help pay for essentials like eligible groceries, utilities, rent,

pet care and over-the-counter items. like vitamins, pain relievers, first-aid supplies and more. other benefits on these plans may include free rides to and from your medical appointments. you could pay nothing for covered prescriptions all year long. most plans have dental coverage, which includes 2 free cleanings a year, plus dentures, crowns, fillings and more. they also have vision coverage, including eye exams and eyeglasses. and hearing coverage, which includes hearing tests and hearing aids. you could also get many no-cost vaccines, including the shingles vaccine, at in-network retail pharmacies. plus, your doctor, hospital and pharmacy may already be part of our large humana network. so, call the number on your screen now to speak with a licensed humana sales agent. you may be able to enroll in one of our plans several times throughout the year. wouldn't you love benefits like up to $1800 a year to help pay for eligible groceries, utilities, rent,

pet care, and over-the-counter items? so, if you have medicare and medicaid, call the number on your screen now and speak with a licensed humana sales agent. if you're eligible, they can even help enroll you over the phone in a humana medicare advantage dual-eligible special needs plan. so, call now. better care begins with listening. humana. a more human way to healthcare. when moderate to severe ulcerative colitis persists... put it in check with rinvoq, a once-daily pill. when uc got unpredictable,... i got rapid symptom relief with rinvoq. check. when uc held me back... i got lasting, steroid-free remission with rinvoq. check. and when uc got the upper hand... rinvoq helped visibly repair the colon lining. check. rapid symptom relief. lasting, steroid-free remission. and a chance to visibly repair the colon lining. check. check. and check. rinvoq can lower your ability to fight infections,

including tb. serious infections and blood clots, some fatal; cancers, including lymphoma and skin cancer; death, heart attack, stroke, and tears in the stomach or intestines occurred. people 50 and older... with at least 1 heart disease risk factor have higher risks. don't take if allergic to rinvoq... as serious reactions can occur. tell your doctor if you are or may become pregnant. put uc in check and keep it there, with rinvoq. ask your gastroenterologist about rinvoq. and learn how abbvie could help you save. >> needs to speak with president zelenskyy and understand how we settled this war. putin is not planning to end this war. but the settlement needs to be achieved at this point. on this is why as the president of the free world, he needs to put pressure on zelenskyy to come up with the realistic war

aims. right now zelensky's goals are unrealistic. that's former defense intelligence agency rebecca casler to press later on way to bring about a peaceful end to russia's war on ukraine. the conflict continue to take a heavy toll for both sides. either putin nor zelensky has shown much interest in direct talks to ending the fight. is ap still possible? bringing in doctor rebecca gr grant. with national security and military analysts. doctor grant, do you think president zelensky should propose terms or a compromise and peace talks? is that president biden's call? >> not right now. do not blame zelensky for the war that started. zelenskyy back in april had a peace deal including keeping crimea and russian hands for 10

years. putin responded with more barbaric attacks. i think after you went all through nato is an agreement right now. this is no time to pressure zelensky into premature peace talks i would leave ukraine walking into a trap. ukraine needs to defeat russia on the battlefield. >> can they win? >> a yes. think ukraine does have the momentum and most of the pieces in place to win over time. they need continued support. but we have seen their advances on the ground i have given them a realistic path to military victory parade that's an excellent question can they really win? is what their suffering and going through worth it? might military analysis is yes they can win in that is nato and the other nations in that group are so supported. it's why it's worth it to get in the aid they need to what has

been a very successful military campaign. >> if president zelensky or to submit another peace offering and putin effectively gets away with this unprovoked and heinous war on ukraine the question is then what is next? it's in no mood to truly negotiate. europe cannot be secure there is a cease-fire after 2015. all it did was give putin a jumping off point for this fresh invasion in 2022. we have to see russia's forces out of ukraine away from the nuclear plants. away from the black sea ports. in back in a posture where they cannot just restart the missile attack or restart the invasion again. there's a lot of work to do in military terms to even get to a cease-fire that would have to come before any real peace ta talks. arthel: the poor civilians there

in the ukraine going through it i cannot even put into words how horrible what's happening there. is there a scenario in which this war could end sooner than later? >> i agree with you. it is so heartrending to see it. the effect on ukraine's people seems one 100% to be for them to redouble their commitment to free their country from the russians. it is a tragic and hard to watch. and so unnecessary. it has just increased ukraine's resolve. that again it's also way we have got to breed with they've got to fight they need to fight with got to continue to back them up for their fight for their freedom and the security of the world honestly. >> lastly and quickly we have to back them meaning ukraine, will china continue to back russia? >> exactly. china is still supporting russia that is actually prolonging

their brutality and violence in ukraine. so even just for that reason alone we need to continue to support ukraine. it is the right thing to do. ukraine has a good path to victory. we can all make this happen. >> thank you very much doctor rebecca grant always good to talk to you, think if urinalysis take care. >> fascinating part switching gears one of new jersey's top republican lawmakers also happens to be a standup comedian. the sidesplitting state senator his shtick and a series of political message up next here on fox news. it's

eric: you on the how we all make for the politicians. one top politician does just that to on stage. legislation and laughs with a meaningful message. correct new jersey state senator spends his days addressing serious issues of public interest. but politics is his day job. catch him at night and this top elected official is doing standup. [laughter] >> just add some insult to injury i am also a new jersey politician. which means you can trust everything i'm about to tell you. [laughter] x they are shocked when you get the look they don't quite get it. they go like excuse me? you are standup comedian? and i walk out like this. they think i am like the manager i'm going to tell them where the fire exits are paid. >> trades the state house chamber floor for the stage or comedy clubs for his public position unexpected sidelight that enables him to poke fun at

his fellow competitions in his public views of his presentation. >> out of you just saw the most recent polls about the new jersey legislature, they weren't great. only 11% of people in new jersey thought we were doing a good j job. that wasn't so bad until he read the rest of the ball 14% of people in new jersey thought they saw ufo last week. [laughter] town hall meetings are very dangerous. so stands up what he going to do about high taxes transportation problems, expensive housing and i said i am moving. [laughter] tendinitis and stand up for years after using the funniest lawyer in jersey at a comedy contest. >> the bad news is you paid money to see a lawyer pay jokes. >> he delights audiences with this unexpected humor, or in the same dark suit and legislative pen that reflects the halls of power, not punchlines. >> people want you to be

authentic. they do not really want soundbites. they do not want political speaks of people, pay you are the funny guy, right? if they came up and saying where the politician you're going to lose it. one of the reasons trump one or the like him or not he was authentic. chris christie had the same kind of approach. the new politician cannot select the old politician. it also helps me politically. and when you are with people democrats and republicans together. if you can lighten the atmosphere in a little bit, ronald reagan did all the time too. >> his book why people don't like you shows you hoisting a drink in one hand, the mic and another. he has performed in atlantic city and other comedy clubs throughout the state of florida and volunteers for an auctioneer for charities. >> sugars are you ready for your ethics training? rule number one you cannot take cash in an envelope. i said i never take the envelope. [laughter] >> he says standup touch could

help get things done in washington. >> in the senate in the house with all the divisions we have in this country now, what advice would you give them? >> spend more time with each other and with each other's families. get all of the families together. spend some time and then stop. i don't think hate is a political strategy. you hit me on a subject i really love. >> standup comedian has a snack sure if you are in the area it's going to beat scotty's comedy club this coming friday decembew jersey. if you're the state capitol of trenton tomorrow you can catch jon bramnick the state center the statehouse. and arthel as you heard his humor does have a serious point for all of us and for what we've seen in washington as he just said hates is not a political strategy. arthel: no it's not. we are going to be sharing some laughs tonight by the winter holiday specialty great christmas debate. fox favorites go head to head

there going to discuss the moor's divisive topics of the season like is it diehard a christmas movie? realtor your victory? that's tonight at 10:00 p.m. eastern. what do you lease a dude you put up a reel to request a request go to central park and i cut it down. [laughter] [laughter] he hasn't delivered trust me he goes, he points and the guy comes and brings it to the door. that's what happened before that's what happens in new york city. what you do? you have a realtor your victory? arthel: we have both it just depends for think this year we have one we purchased and i think were going to put the not surreal tree up this season. but it's going to be a lovely just the same. christmas is special no matter" if you ha“e a fake or real tree it is all real there you go g that special place that you want to keep in the family...

...or passing down the family business... ...or giving back to the places that inspire you. no matter your purpose, at pnc private bank, we will work with you every step of the way to help you achieve it. so let us focus on the how. just tell us - what's your why? ♪

hello everyone. good sunday evening. i am with jenkins. welcome to the big sunday show. here is what is on tap tonight. >> the father of one of the university of idaho students brutally murdered shares new information about the investigation we have not heard yet and it could help reveal a motive. >> the mainstream media scrambles after elon musk shows twitter staff worked with bide