tv Farage GB News November 12, 2024 7:00pm-8:01pm GMT
7:00 pm
will. >> will. >> very good evening to you. it's 7:00 pm. welcome to the farage show on gb news with me . farage show on gb news with me. i'm martin daubney standing in for the big man nigel farage tonight. on tonight's show, justin welby announces his resignation as the archbishop of canterbury after mounting pressure from both within the church and the country at large over revelations that he'd failed to disclose information about child abuse in the church of england. is it too little, too late? or is the church of england about to get the great reset that it so desperately needs ? and the first draft of needs? and the first draft of the controversial assisted dying
7:01 pm
bill was published yesterday as supporters reaffirmed the legitimacy and robustness of safeguards within it. but would they be enough not only to protect the most vulnerable, but also to win over critics and become law? well , richard tice, become law? well, richard tice, the deputy leader of the reform uk party, who is voting in favour of this controversial motion. he joins me in just a moment . and mps are voting this moment. and mps are voting this evening on whether to remove hereditary peers from the house of lords, with the 92 who do remain being the only ones to be elected to the upper chamber is this a necessary progression of democracy or a gratuitous socialist act of class warfare? and at cop29, the pointless cop29, the azerbaijani president blasted western nations for hypocrisy, buying his gas while preaching climate action, and even call fossil fuels a gift from the gods. the only. keir starmer, representing major
7:02 pm
western leaders . is starmer, representing major western leaders. is this a wake up call on the uk's net zero agenda? now that's an action packed menu. but before all of that, here's your headlines and it's sophie reaper. >> thank you martin. it's just after 7:00. let's take a look at your latest gb news headlines in the last couple of hours. a spokesperson for avon and somerset police has given a statement following the death of a 17 year old girl on the m5 motorway last night. let's take a listen to what they had to say. >> this is a hugely distressing incident and one that will no doubt cause great shock amongst the public. our thoughts and our sympathies are first and foremost with the girl's family . foremost with the girl's family. a specially trained officer has been assigned to keep them, keep providing them with updates and support , not only today but in support, not only today but in the weeks ahead too. due to the seriousness of the incident and mandatory referral was made to the independent police office for police conduct in the early
7:03 pm
hours of the morning. the iopc has notified us that it will investigate the incident independently . independently. >> a spokesperson for the prime minister has said that sir keir respects the decision of the archbishop of canterbury to resign. justin welby stepped down earlier this afternoon following a report into a prolific child abuser associated with the church of england. the reports concluded that welby had failed to act after learning about the abuse by john smyth qc. in 2013, terminally ill adults who are expected to die within six months would be able to request assistance to end their own life under the proposed end of life bill. but someone with a disability or mental health issues would not be eligible. the controversial bill has raised some concerns that people could feel pressured into ending their lives prematurely. mps will have their first vote on the proposal on the 29th of november, a once a
7:04 pm
day pill that could help tens of thousands of people give up cigarettes and prevent thousands of smoking related deaths each year will be rolled out on the nhs. the pill works by tackling nicotine cravings and also helps with withdrawal symptoms such as irritability and trouble sleeping. official estimates say it could help more than 85,000 people give up on smoking over the next five years, as well as prevent up to 9500 smoking related deaths . queen camilla related deaths. queen camilla will return to public duties today after her chest infection. the queen will attend the booker prize reception at clarence house later today, but will meet guests for a shorter period than initially planned. she was forced to withdraw from her dufies forced to withdraw from her duties last week, as well as missing out on the weekend's remembrance day commemoration events . and gary lineker will events. and gary lineker will step down as the host of match of the day at the end of the current season. the 63 year old former england striker has presented match of the day since
7:05 pm
1999, but now mark chapman, gabby logan and alex scott are the current front runners to replace the former england star. for now, those are the latest gb news headlines. i'm sophie reaper more from me in the next houn >> for the very latest gb news direct to your smartphone, sign up to news alerts by scanning the qr code or go to gb news .com forward slash alerts . .com forward slash alerts. >> thank you very much , sophie. >> thank you very much, sophie. now, justin welby, the archbishop of canterbury , has archbishop of canterbury, has announced his resignation today amid increasing pressure from both within the church of england and the public at large. the announcement follows revelations that he failed to disclose critical information about instances of child abuse within the church, a scandal that has sparked widespread outrage. as the highest ranking figure in the church of england,
7:06 pm
welby's decision to go appears to only have come after immense pressure from within his own clergy, rather than an admittance of failure or even of conscience. well, just on friday, gb news approached lambeth palace for comment to which they responded the archbishop reiterates his horror at the scale of john smyth's abuse, as reflected in his pubuc abuse, as reflected in his public apology, and he said he would not be stepping down on this issue and rejects the claim that he was aware of the allegations or had any suspicion of the allegations before he was told in 2013. now, was welby's position completely untenable? was he right to go and what must the church of england do to fix it? so tonight i am asking you the big question. please get in touch. was the archbishop of canterbury right to resign over this abuse scandal? let me know by retweeting. by tweeting hashtag farage on gb news or email us at farage. as gb news
7:07 pm
.uk. well, to discuss this further, i'm now joined by the church of england vicar, the reverend dan beasley. reverend beasley , welcome to the show. beasley, welcome to the show. this is an enormous scandal and the archbishop has stepped down. and there's a great feeling that he was shoved rather than going of his own accord. do you think it was the right thing for him to do, to have gone ? to do, to have gone? >> yeah. i think his position, as everybody had said at newcastle came out, which again, is unprecedented. it was untenable after he didn't follow up on the disclosure that was made in 2013. and i don't think there was anything else he could actually do. it . you know, he is actually do. it. you know, he is the head of the church of england. well, jesus, let's put that out. first of all, jesus is the head of the church, but he is leading the church of england. he is the leader of safeguarding. it has also improved under his tenure , but improved under his tenure, but to improve safeguarding while
7:08 pm
having this hanging over himself as well is it just made his position untenable. >> and of course, dan, the huge question is this time frame of when he knew and what he knew? we don't know the details . 1981 we don't know the details. 1981 is the word. when he was first tipped off, something maybe going wrong. and we definitely know for sure that 2013, he knew . know for sure that 2013, he knew. and of course then in the intermittent five years john smyth passed away in cape town, in that precious five years, something perhaps could have been done even earlier. something could have been done to perhaps prevent the abuse of over 130 boys. this is a scandal that runs deep. this is the scandal that will cast a huge and long and dark shadow over the church of england. what can the church of england. what can the church do to salvage its shattered reputation ? shattered reputation? >> well, obviously there needs to be a change of culture
7:09 pm
because the safeguarding has improved and it has improved since the 70s. and 80s, when smyth and many other abusers have been in the church of england. and let's not forget, there's other denominations out there. these people will work their way in, and we have to make safeguarding, you their way in, and we have to make safeguarding , you know, so make safeguarding, you know, so strong in our churches to make sure that they don't come in. and that's what we're doing today on the parish level. the safeguarding in parish churches is really strong . but let's talk is really strong. but let's talk in reality. there was a russian report back in 1982 that spoke about smyth , and this should about smyth, and this should have been stopped then. it should never got to 2013. and yet it did. and there were many instances across the that time, that time span, 40 years of abuse. he was able to do both in england and in zimbabwe and south africa. and every time he got caught, he he moved himself on.and got caught, he he moved himself on. and if the safeguarding was robust enough and referred to the police at the right time.
7:10 pm
so, you know, as safeguarding has improved through the church over the years , the question is over the years, the question is why hasn't people looked back? so the archbishop said he made a mistake or he didn't understand or whatever it was in 2013. a safeguarding has got better. why did it take channel 4 in 2017 to bnng did it take channel 4 in 2017 to bring the smyth abuses to light? you know, as as we look back, we have to look back on those things as well. so a culture change really has to come in and we have to look at ourselves quite seriously and why we there's the its victims at the end of the day. and they have to be at the forefront. they've been let down time and time again and this cannot happen anymore. >> dan can i ask you a question about an attitude which many feel exemplifies now the church of england ? and it's one it's a of england? and it's one it's a phrase that involves moats and planks, holier than thou, holier than thou, about climate change, about racism, about immigration, about racism, about immigration, about vaccines, about brexit,
7:11 pm
about vaccines, about brexit, about lgbtq. you get my point. and yet, seemingly not having a houer and yet, seemingly not having a holier than thou attitude about the most important people in the church, and that is your own flock. where have you gone so wrong ? wrong? >> again, i'm going to come back , >> again, i'm going to come back, andifs >> again, i'm going to come back, and it's been out there all afternoon since the archbishop's resignation. there seems a divide. what we are doing on the ground. and yes, there is that ideology in the church of england. but we got to get back to what is the church is called for and that's to preach the gospel and to be there for those who are most in need and to be in that public square, speaking out for those most vulnerable. so, for example, the pensioners who lost their heating allowance, you know why we need to be speaking about that. and just yes, that's the right things that we should be speaking about. but we're not houer speaking about. but we're not holier than now. we're all fallen. we that's that's our christian belief. we're all fallen, but we've got to rebuild. in that sense, the church we got to get rid of this
7:12 pm
divide. but again, the church is divided. we are divided over same sex blessings. divided. we are divided over same sex blessings . that's divided. we are divided over same sex blessings. that's going to come up next year again in the general synod, the job for the general synod, the job for the next, the next archbishop of canterbury is huge. but we have to get back to what we are known for. so many people keep telling me, you know, you're christians, aren't you? why aren't you talking about the christian values which the country was built upon? why have you gone away from that? so maybe this is just a great opportunity for us to once again get into that pubuc to once again get into that public square, speak about the hope of jesus christ and speak against some of the values that are just come in, not to only society, but into the church as well. >> we have to leave it there. thanks for your expertise. and joining us tonight. that's the reverend dan beasley, church of england vicar. thank you very much. now let's get to my superstar panel. tonight. i'm joined by the former conservative mp ranil jayawardena and of course the former labour advisor matthew laws. gentlemen, welcome to studio. ranil, i'm going to
7:13 pm
start with you. what's your take on today's decision? he had to go. it was inevitable. but where doesit go. it was inevitable. but where does it leave the church? yeah. >> i mean, i think he clearly did have to go. and it's. it is at least good that he did take that decision. now rather than leaving it lingering any longer because it was bringing the church of england as a whole into disrepute. i do find i'm a pcc member, a parochial church council member myself, and i do find it rather at odds that we as pcc members, even if we have no ministry of our own, no care directly of any individual in our parish, we have to complete huge amounts of safeguarding paperwork and courses and so on. and yet it seems that there are all sorts of other things happening up the line at the centre of the church. and, you know, the church has been hugely centralised under archbishop justin welby. and i think it is now, as the reverend beazley said, an opportunity for the church to perhaps reset and to reflect on what it should be.
7:14 pm
for it is it's perfectly right that the church should express its views on certain issues, that it feels strongly about, but i'm afraid it has become far too political, and that has meant that many parishioners feel very uncomfortable in what the archbishop, the titular titular head bar the king, of course, of the church of england, is saying on their behalf. >> matthew laza get your take on what you make of justin welby's resignation. but also this nofion resignation. but also this notion that in many ways, the church doesn't seem to represent any of the values of its flock any of the values of its flock any more. it's obsessed with identity politics, with issues. let's face it, most people go to church or pensioners. they're elderly , white british elderly, white british pensioners. that's the that's the demographic on the whole. outside of all this language about climate change, greta thunberg with a robe on is completely out of touch. yeah. >> well, look, i mean, i think clearly he had to go. i think the issue is that the church, it's not so much that the church is woke that the church ties itself in knots. i mean, one of
7:15 pm
the issues, you know, in all the reports, what's going to be in the inbox of the of the new incoming archbishop, one of the issues, of course, is that the church still ties itself in knots about things like lgbt rights. and, you know, justin welby was very i mean, he got a bit better in his tenure, but he was very, very, you know, trying to hold a line and not have any blessing of same sex or committed same sex relationships in church . in church. >> well, not church care about this. >> well, some people do, but but what he was doing is he wasn't. whilst whilst he was tearing himself into knots about, you know, the sort of fourth line of a of an agreement of a declaration about lgbt rights, what he wasn't doing was asking enough questions about this guy and what i think is particularly scandalous tonight is let me make sure i get the bishop of lincoln's name right, which is bishop conway. bishop stephen conway, who is the bishop of lincoln , who is even more lincoln, who is even more heavily criticised in the report that criticised justin welby, where the report said that he was the person in a position. this is a quote to stop john smith bringing him to justice and he fundamentally failed tonight. he's not only still the bishop of lincoln, and this
7:16 pm
relates to the discussion we're going to have in a moment. he also sits in the house of lords. so i think we need further resignations from the church before we can say that this is in any way and all victim survivors groups are calling for the bishop of lincoln's resignation tonight. >> but the leadership in the church, you know, under welby , church, you know, under welby, has focused on things like the two child benefit cap, which is very popular with the country. and yet he's decided to stand against it. he's stood up on issues like tax avoidance, when actually he should have been deaung actually he should have been dealing with people's lives, being damaged. and, you know, whether it's refugees, employment rights, these are not necessarily things that parishioners across the country want the to archbishop do. so he's he's had his eye off the ball. >> yeah, i think i mean, i think the problem is, is that, as you said in the interview with the reverend beasley, is that it's about the holier than thou attitude. sometimes i think it's perfectly okay to ask moral questions on these big issues, but to say that you have all the answers on things that are, you know, clearly some way away from scripture are very much about interpretation. >> i think, gentlemen, we have to leave it there. we have to call time and read out a statement from justin welby, who has said this. it is very clear
7:17 pm
that i must take personal and institutional responsibility for the long and retraumatising penod the long and retraumatising period between 2013 and 2024. i hope this decision today makes clear how seriously the church of england understands the need for change and our profound commitment to creating a safer church . as i stepped down, i do church. as i stepped down, i do so in sorrow with all victims and survivors of abuse. i believe that stepping aside is in the best interests of the church of england, which i dearly love, and which i have been honoured to serve. i pray that this decision points us back towards the love that jesus christ has for every one of us. well, coming up next, the first draft of the controversial assisted dying bill was published yesterday as supporters reaffirmed the legitimacy and the robustness of safeguards within it. now, would they have been? but would they be enough not only to protect the most vulnerable, but also to win over critics and become british law ? well, richard tice, british law? well, richard tice, who is voting in favour of this controversial motion, he joins
7:21 pm
welcome back to farage with me. martin daubney covering for nigel farage on gb news. now, before the break, we asked you, was the archbishop of canterbury correct to resign over today's abuse scandal? and irvin says this if my memory serves me correctly , well be described the correctly, well be described the rwanda plan as ungodly. i wonder what he would have called his actions concerning this abuse scandal. the man is a disgrace to all civilised, decent people, let alone the church of england . let alone the church of england. and alex, as this the archbishop had to go. we now need a christian religious leader , not christian religious leader, not someone who is full of wokery and politics. alex. so many people have been echoing that sentiment. get back to your flock and stop being obsessed
7:22 pm
with identity politics now. the first draft of the highly contentious assisted dying bill was published yesterday, with supporters emphasising the bill's comprehensive safeguards, asserting that they are both legitimate and robust and designed to protect vulnerable individuals who critics say are at risk of the law being abused and unjustifiably killed . let's and unjustifiably killed. let's take a listen to what the bill's biggest cheerleader, cheerleader, labour's kim leadbeater, had to say earlier . say earlier. >> if you're saying it's fine that we've got people taking their own lives, being forced to go to other countries, having horrible deaths despite good palliative care , then you vote palliative care, then you vote against the bill, you abstain. but that's not right. and i would say to anybody, speak to those people, speak to those organisations who do this work and you will see very clearly that the law as it stands is not fit for purpose . fit for purpose. >> as labour's kim leadbeater put. questions do remain. all these safeguards stringent
7:23 pm
enough to dispel the fears of critics and the measure has defied critics and the measure has defied the opinions across the political spectrum, including figures like reform uk's deputy leader richard tice, who is in favour of this controversial motion. i'm delighted to say that richard now joins me in the studio . richard tice, welcome to studio. richard tice, welcome to the show. thank you . probably the show. thank you. probably one of the few times you ever agree with kim leadbeater on anything. >> i've had good discussions with kim. i made it clear very early on that i think this is i think it is the right thing to do already. just in your intro. it's not assisted dying, it's actually the terminally ill adults bill. and it is for those who are who are terminally ill, who are who are terminally ill, who are who are terminally ill, who are expected to live no longer than six months. the safeguards are very, very strong. it's got to be signed off by two independent doctors by a judge in a high court and, and then it and you have to be compos mentis. so it's not someone else administering it. it is. it is you administering
7:24 pm
it . and it's based on the it. and it's based on the safeguards of this bill. are based on what works very successfully for some 25 years in the state of oregon , in the in the state of oregon, in the united states, where they've used very similar safeguards . used very similar safeguards. and if you actually look, you know, they haven't had abuse , know, they haven't had abuse, they haven't had the pressure to extend it . and it's but it's a extend it. and it's but it's a very personal thing. it's not a party political thing. it's deeply personal. and for those who've seen loved ones die in excruciating agony knowing what faces them, you know , those, faces them, you know, those, those last couple of days , weeks those last couple of days, weeks can be truly, truly awful. i've had that experience. it's seared me, and it's why i have the position. i completely respect those who have a different view. and but i think the great thing is we're talking about it. we're debating it. it seems to come up once every ten years. this bill is the strongest safeguard safeguards, i think, that's ever been discussed, possibly the strongest in the world. and
7:25 pm
there's a lot of misinformation out there, martin. people saying it's only going to be discussed. it's being rushed through in a couple of weeks. no, it's not what's going to be debated on friday. the 29th of november is the second reading. there will be six months of debate committees, discussion, votes in the house of lords, back to the house of commons. so there's lots of time to discuss this . lots of time to discuss this. and fundamentally it's actually about freedom of choice for someone who knows what's ahead of them in a, in a in what in those situations is a really horrific, painful , awful way to horrific, painful, awful way to depart. and i think people should be given and allowed to have that freedom of choice. it shouldn't just be for the wealthy who can afford to go to switzerland now, a lot of people have grave concerns about this. >> they have worries about what happenedin >> they have worries about what happened in canada, for example, when this was brought in and it was robust then. but of course, it was liberalised and it became easier for people to die and the system was abused. one person who does have concerns actually
7:26 pm
is reform uk leader nigel farage. and here's what he said to gb news on friday. >> so there are people that die in the most appalling circumstances. as an mep, i was lobbied on that issue more than any other during my 20 years there, so i completely understand why people want this to be law , but i need a lot of to be law, but i need a lot of convincing that it won't be abused. >> and that's the joy that this is not it's not a party issue. it's a very personal issue . and it's a very personal issue. and it's a very personal issue. and i think it is good that we debate it. we discuss it. i hope lots of mps come on that friday and listen to the debate. and it's not being rushed through, but when i look at my postbag from constituents, it is meaningfully in favour so far. and we'll see the no doubt, you know, there's lots of lobbying on both sides, as you would expect. >> now, mr farage, there was referring to appalling abuses. and again, bringing back to canada, gb news went to canada to toronto, spoke with people
7:27 pm
involved in the assisted dying legislation there. and it undeniably had been abused disabled people who were granted the right but to gb news go to oregon. well, in canada. let's discuss this. they were granted the right to die early for being disabled soldiers with ptsd who didn't feel like they could carry on, and that's obviously daft. but they weren't being offered therapy. they weren't being offered help. they were being offered help. they were being offered help. they were being offered a quick, fast. >> let me stop you there. track to the canada example is a nonsense . we know it's nonsense. we know it's appalling. this is completely different and frankly, gb news should go to oregon. see how it's worked for 25 years very successfully in oregon in order to have a balanced view. we know what's not working. we've got the most respected legal system in the world. frankly, if we can't design some appropriate safeguards and guardrails for this work , then frankly, shame this work, then frankly, shame on us and shame on us for not having the courage to try and to look at it. and that's how you
7:28 pm
make progress in life, is you try things and if it's not quite working, if it needs a bit of tweaking , a working, if it needs a bit of tweaking, a bit of working, if it needs a bit of tweaking , a bit of reviewing working, if it needs a bit of tweaking, a bit of reviewing and a review is built into this, this bill and all of this can be debated over months. but if you're never prepared to try and make progress, and for those who say we need to focus on palliative care, of course, but they're not mutually exclusive. you know, palliative care hospices, but there's some pain relief that just doesn't touch the sides. >> what do you say to people who say politicians have no right to play say politicians have no right to play god, but they're not. >> they're actually giving the right to the individual. 4488 00:28:36,
7 Views
IN COLLECTIONS
TV-GBNUploaded by TV Archive on
