tv Nightline ABC June 5, 2018 12:37am-1:07am PDT
12:37 am
this is "nightline." >> tonight, cake controversy. >> this is not about hate. this is about not creating a message and a government forcing me to. >> the baker who refused to make a cake for a gay wedding on religious grounds. >> it's about the right of people to receive equal service at a place of business that anyone else would. >> and the couple who says he violated their civil rights, making their cases to "nightline" just days ago. what they're saying now after supreme court ruling today. and the impact of the decision across the country. plus, revenge rampage. a four-day killing spree, multiple legal and mental health professionals murdered. today the suspect tracked down. >> the s.w.a.t. team filling the
12:38 am
12:39 am
i support the affordable care act, and voted against all trump's attempts to repeal it. but we need to do more. i believe in universal health care. in a public health option to compete with private insurance companies. and expanding medicare to everyone over 55. and i believe medicare must be empowered to negotiate the price of drugs. california values senator dianne feinstein
12:40 am
thanks for joining us. a supreme court ruling today that could have ripple effects for businesses and the lgbt community across the country. the justices siding with the christian baker who famously refused to create a wedding cake for a gay couple, saying his faith forbade it. today he is celebrating what he calls a victory for religious freedom, while the couple worries this could spark a nationwide backlash. jack phillips says he's not just a baker, he's an artist. >> part of it icing and piping. part of it is paintbrush. part of it is airbrush, create the leaves and the flowers. >> reporter: his canvas, takes like these. >> we paint on cakes. we sculpt cakes. we sketch cakes. design what we're going to do. >> reporter: deeply religious, phillips says his christian faith guides everything in his life. >> this one is a first out of first corinthians. stand firm, be strong and
12:41 am
immovable. always work enthusiastically for the lord. >> reporter: including his refusal to bake a wedding cake for a gay couple. >> that cake is that strong of a message in our culture. and marriage in general between a man and i woman across all cultures, religions, is an inherently religions event. >> reporter: that faith part of an epic legal clash between religious liberty and gay rights. all of which began when charlie craig and dave mullins walked into masterpiece cake shop in 2012. >> like any couple charlie and i were really excited to be getting married. >> reporter: same-sex marriage was still not legal in colorado. sought couple was planning to get married in massachusetts, followed by a reception back home near denver. >> and on this particular day when we were going to sample wedding cakes -- >> and when david and charlie came in we introduced ourselves, what can i do for you. we're here to look at wedding cakes. it's for our wedding p. >> it was a really special day because charlie's mom was in town. she does not live in denver. so she was particularly excited.
12:42 am
>> so i realized right then that this is not a cake that i'm going to be able to design and create for them. so i tried to apologize to them and say i'll sell you cookies, brownies, birthday cakes, anything else in my store. >> but we weren't in there for brownies for my birthday. we were in there because we needed a cake to serve at our reception. >> at which point they both jumped up, swore at me, stormed out of my shop. >> you know, charlie had a binder full of ideas and concepts. you know, but we never even got a chance to open the binder. >> you don't see it as an act of discrimination. >> i see it as an act of following my faith. it's not just a cake. it's an iconic. >> of a wedding. this is a religious ceremony that goes in direct conflict with my faith. >> when i realized exactly what had happened in the car, you know, i broke down and started crying. >> reporter: that one encounter at this unassuming cake shop in lakewood, colorado -- >> here's to your legal fee. >> reporter: -- propelled both
12:43 am
the cake baker and the couple into the center of a scorching national debate. that went all the way to the highest court in the land. and today in a 7-2 decision the supreme court ruled in favor of the baker. >> it's good for jack. it's good for businesses who want to run their businesses according to their convictions, whether they're christians, muslims, jews, secular, whatever the case might be. i think it's good for that. >> reporter: and celebrations erupted outside phillips's store. >> it's a good day to have cake. >> i'm very excited. >> reporter: craig and mullins say they were blindsided by the decision. >> the first emotions were just shock and disappointment. >> the bakery may have won the battle but it has certainly lost the war. the court really recognized today that deep harms of discrimination and those harms apply equally when it comes to lgbt people. >> reporter: we were in doll colle colorado just last week only days before today's far-reaching decision. for mullins and craig even over five years later that brief interaction still stings. >> i was mortified.
12:44 am
i mean, neither one of us had ever been treated this way before at a business. >> reporter: dejected and furious, the couple posted about their experience on facebook. >> we wrote just a small modest post that said hey, we were discriminated against at this cake shop. >> reporter: the post went viral. >> we received this outpouring of support from people literally around the world. >> reporter: encouraged by the public response, the couple filed a complaint with the colorado civil rights commission. colorado is one of 21 states that prohibits discrimination based on sexual orientation. colorado's civil rights commission ruled in favor of the couple. describing the baker's refusal based on his religious beliefs as one of the most despicable pieces of rhetoric. that decision was upheld by the colorado court of appeals. >> it made us feel like we were valued members of our community. >> it's not about hate. this is about not creating a message and a government forcing
12:45 am
me to. >> because people have called you a bigot. >> i'm not. i serve everybody who comes in my store. i just don't create cakes -- every cake that people ask me to create. >> reporter: as part of the ruling the commission ordered phillips to retrain his employees and serve everyone wedding cakes regardless of sexual orientation. so he stopped making wedding cakes altogether. >> and here is a sample of the brownie. >> reporter: his refusal, he says, cost him 40% of his business and worse. >> we've had death threats. we've had e-mails, phone calls. our lives have been turned upside down. >> reporter: aided by the alliance defending freedom, a christian advocacy organization, phillips petitioned the supreme court to take his case. >> we were asking the court to look at it as creative professionals. should they be forced to violate the first amendment, or deeply held religious beliefs to create art that violates those beliefs? which is more important? >> reporter: saying the state of colorado violated his first
12:46 am
amendment rights of freedom of religion and speech. >> and there's the slippery slope of does this chip away at other artisans, whether it's a jeweler or a makeup artist or others who would then have the ability to essentially boycott gay marriages? >> i think that the supreme court is looking at all that. those were good questions that they asked. in my case, however, that's not an issue. what i do, i paint on cakes. i sculpt cakes. it's clearly art. it's clearly protected. >> this isn't about a cake. it's about the right of people to receive equal service at a place of business that anyone else would. >> reporter: the news that the court would take up the case was a shock to everyone involved. the weight of both movements sitting squarely on their shoulders. >> i know it's hard to predict how you will feel, but if it came down in your favor how would you react? >> i would be probably overjoyed.
12:47 am
>> couldn't you create a generic wedding cake that would be available for anyone who walked in and then customized for certain people, or is that against the -- >> that would be sidestepping the issue. that's still the government forcing me to create cakes for ceremonies that go against my faith. >> i think sadness and fear over what the future will look like for people based on this precedent. >> so this was a 7-2 decision, but there was actually a lot of disagreement even among the justices who agreed with the outcome in the case. justice anthony kennedy wrought opinion for the court. the only dissenting justices were justice ruth bader ginsburg and sonia sotomayor. >> reporter: today's ruling a narrow victory for religious rights advocates. at least four justices affirming gay rights but ruling in favor of the baker because ironically they say it was he who faced anti-religious bias, calling out the colorado commission's language as disrespectful and hostile towards his sincere religious beliefs. >> i think it's hard to know just reading the opinion what it's going to mean kind of on
12:48 am
the ground in practice. coming out of this i think we know that it's important for state officials to approach these kinds disputes respectful of the claims on all sides. >> reporter: lgbtq groups including glaad worry this ruling could open the floodgates for victory. >> we must love and support one another! >> reporter: hiding behind religious exemptions. >> you're well aware that history, historically, businesses have used religious exemptions to deny service to african-americans at hotels or restaurants or -- >> i can't answer for that. all i can say is that's not my belief at all. >> there's no question that opponents of lgbt equality will and already have seized on today's opinion as standing for far more than it does. this indicaticase was never abo and we know our opposition won't stop. >> reporter: at the cake shop today the mood was celebrately. but dave mullins and charlie craig say the fight for equal
12:49 am
rights is far from over. >> the struggle is real. and you know, civil rights aren't gained overnight. and you know, we hope that we've raised awareness not just in colorado but across the country of how this form of discrimination affects lgbt people across the country every day. up next, a killing spree now over. many of the victims connected to the suspect in the same way. they played a role in his divorce. it's a long-distance run. and you have the determination to keep going. humira has a proven track record of being prescribed for over 10 years. humira works inside the body to target and help block a specific source of inflammation that contributes to symptoms. in clinical trials, most adults taking humira were clear or almost clear and many saw 75% and even 90% clearance in just four months. humira can lower your ability to fight infections, including tuberculosis.
12:50 am
serious, sometimes fatal, infections and cancers, including lymphoma have happened as have blood, liver, and nervous system problems, serious allergic reactions, and new or worsening heart failure. before treatment, get tested for tb. tell your doctor if you've been to areas where certain fungal infections are common, and if you've had tb, hepatitis b, are prone to infections, or have flu-like symptoms, or sores. don't start humira if you have an infection. join over 250,000 people who have chosen humira. ask about the #1 prescribed biologic by dermatologists. humira & go. shark has added a rotating soft brush. so while deep-cleaning carpets, you can also grab large particles, pull in piles and directly engage floors. duo clean. invented by shark. your hair is so soft! duo clean. did you use head and shoulders two in one? i did mom. wanna try it? yes. it intensely moisturizes your hair and scalp and keeps you flake free. manolo? look at my soft hair. i should be in the shot now too. try head and shoulders two in one.
12:51 am
searching for answers may feel overwhelming. so start your search with our teams of specialists at cancer treatment centers of america. the evolution of cancer care is here. learn more at cancercenter.com/experts brushing only reaches 25% of your mouth. listerine® cleans virtually 100%. helping to prevent gum disease and bad breath. never settle for 25%. always go for 100. bring out the bold™
12:52 am
when the worst oil spill hit san francisco, first responders went to work. and mayor gavin newsom, he went to hawaii. man: newsome left the day after the spill for a four-day vacation in hawaii. the same gavin who said his job as lieutenant governor was so dull, he only showed up for work at the state capitol one day a week, tops. gavin's not gonna work as governor.
12:53 am
♪ seresto,jake...o, seresto ♪ seresto, seresto, seresto whatever your dog brings home to you, it shouldn't be fleas and ticks. seresto gives your dog 8 continuous months of flea and tick protection in an easy-to-use, non-greasy collar. ♪ seresto, seresto, seresto oh no, jake. seresto. 8-month... ♪ seresto, seresto, seresto after a four-day killing
12:54 am
spree in arizona a suspect finally tracked down today, found holed up in a hotel room. and unfortunately two more victims found nearby. abc's chief national correspondent matt gutman is in arizona, where police say they have uncovered a high-profile connection between the victims. >> reporter: tonight more details emerging of the string of murders that terrorized the phoenix area over the past four days. >> last 96 hours reflects one individual's actions that are the worst of humanity. >> reporter: police now say the shooter, 56-year-old dwight lamon jones, targeted mental health workers and lawyers who were involved in his brutal, nasty divorce. a murderous rampage that left six people dead. >> when people go and commit homicides of people that have been in their lives, it's usually because of revenge. >> reporter: it was last week when the terror began.
12:55 am
witnesses say they heard dr. steven pitt, a world-renowned forensic psychiatrist, arguing with someone outside his phoenix office. gunshots soon ringing out. the 59-year-old left dead on the ground. less than 24 hours later police respond to 911 calls at a scottsdale law office where two paralegals had also been shot. one of the women, veleria sharp, managing to crawl outside to this bus, asking a driver to call 911. >> she is bleeding from her face. she says she thought she may be dying. >> reporter: and dying at the hospital soon after. authorities followed her trail of blood, leading them inside the office, where they found laura anderson, who was pronounced dead at the scene. a day later just after midnight, psychologist and hypnotherapist marshall levine was found dead from two gunshot wounds inside his scottsdale office. these murders occurring within a 30il radius. police saying jones used the
12:56 am
same gun for all of the murders. >> we again had a match linking the homicide to the others. >> reporter: yesterday, after surveillance evidence placed the shooter near the residence, officials went to this fountain hills neighborhood. >> they used a ladder. they got to see through an upstairs window. and they immediately recognized that there was a gentleman inside that appeared to have been shot. they forced entry, and upon doing so found another victim, a woman, who had also been shot. and both were deceased. >> reporter: and now police are saying this almost all of these horrific crimes were linked to one event -- jones' acrimonious divorce from his ex-wife, dr. connie jones, a texas-based radiologist. court records showed that his ex-wife filed for divorce in 2009. jones had been charged with assault days earlier. he had pleaded guilty to disorderly conduct. records show his wife sought an order of protection and psychiatric evaluations were requested for jones.
12:57 am
and the psychiatrist ordered to conduct that court-ordered evaluation, dr. pitt, the man jones had killed. dr. pitt was a prominent forensic psychiatrist whose resume of work included several high-profile cases including the murder of jonbenet ramsey, the columbine high school massacre, and the trial of jodi arias. >> we have been able to tie the -- or basically determine that the shooting on 1st street is related to the shooting of dr. steven pitt. >> reporter: but that's not the only connection. dr. connie jones's lawyer is a partner at the same law firm where two of the other victims, paralegals sharp and anderson, were murdered. their law firm released a statement calling anderson a "friend, mother, grandmother and wife who gave all of herself to her family, her friends, and her work," adding that sharp was a "treasured member of our work
12:58 am
family." officials say the hypnotherapist marshall levine was collateral damage who simply shared an office with another therapist involved in the divorce proceedings. >> you do wonder is this a disgruntled client of mine that was looking for me? i mean, i doubt, it but it can could be. >> reporter: the shooter also allegedly post aid series of videos before his rampage maligning his ex-wife and dr. pitt. >> the reason killers post things online knowing that they're probably going to be dead when we see them is this is always about glory. glory of taking charge. glory of feeling powerful. >> reporter: the shooter's ex-wife and her lawyer both called in tips to police identifying jones as a possible suspect. >> it was his dna on those shell casings that took us through all those scenes. we had that proof, and we knew that he was our suspect and murderer. >> reporter: officials tracked him down to this extended stay america hotel and began
12:59 am
surveilling him sunday afternoon before deciding to move in early monday. >> i stay on the third floor. >> reporter: this eyewitness was staying at the hotel when she heard it was being evacuated. >> when i left the room, there was a bunch of s.w.a.t. team filling the hall and said be very quiet. so i was escorted. >> reporter: s.w.a.t. teams swarmed. the suspect then opened fire. >> we have the hotel locked down and there's been shots fired. >> somewhere between seven and eight rounds were fired. all officers were safe and okay. >> there are shots on the interior of the unit. >> reporter: when they found jones, he had apparently committed suicide. >> it's terrifying. >> yeah, it is. >> reporter: investigators still say they're poring over all aspects of the shooter's life. >> we're taking our time and making sure that we don't miss anything and that we give these victims and their families the justice that they deserve. >> reporter: tonight law enforcement is being credited with likely saving the lives of
1:00 am
other potential victims. >> today is not a success story, but it is a story that has closure. >> reporter: for "nightline" i'm matt gutman in scottsdale, arizona. up next, new images from the deadly volcanic eruption in guatemala. hear that sizzle? yeah. red lobster's lobster & shrimp summerfest is back! get all the lobster and shrimp you crave, together in so many new ways. there's new cedar plank seafood bake. tender maine lobster and shrimp, cedar roasted to perfection. or new caribbean lobster and shrimp. sweet pineapple salsa on grilled rock lobster, paired with jumbo coconut shrimp. and wait. there's lobster & shrimp overboard! it's a seafood party on a plate. so hurry in. 'cause lobster & shrimp summerfest won't last. touch shows how we really feel. but does psoriasis ever get in the way? embrace the chance of 100% clear skin with taltz.
1:01 am
up to 90% of those with moderate to severe psoriasis had a significant improvement of their psoriasis plaques. most people were still clearer after one year. with taltz, 4 out of 10 even achieved completely clear skin. don't use if you're allergic to taltz. before starting, you should be checked for tuberculosis. taltz may increase risk of infections and lower your ability to fight them. tell your doctor if you have an infection, symptoms, or received a vaccine or plan to. inflammatory bowel disease can happen with taltz, including worsening of symptoms. serious allergic reactions can occur. ready for a chance at 100% clear skin? ask your doctor about taltz. we believe nutrition is full of possibilities to improve your pet's life. we are redefining what nutrition can do. because the possibility of a longer life and a better life is the greatest possibility of all. purina pro plan. nutrition that performs.
1:02 am
hey, want thedone.est internet? and now, xfinity mobile's included. you could get up to five lines. you could save 400 bucks or more a year, which you could spend on a funk-tastic music video. ♪ dance party boom. ♪ simple. easy. awesome. get started with xfinity internet, with three times the speed of at&t and directv, and tv for $35 each a month for a year when you buy both. and ask how you can save with xfinity mobile.
1:03 am
1:04 am
helping boys become men. i beat the nra in court, defending gun laws that save lives. today, a new generation is rising, and this is our moment. in the streets and in the capitol, i'll stand with them. jeff bleich. democrat for lieutenant governor. marshall tuck will change that. in california, 3 million kids can't read at grade level. tuck turned around struggling schools, raising graduation rates over 60%. marshall tuck for state superintendent.
1:05 am
marshall tuck. and finally tonight, guatemala's volcan de fuego, living up to its name. abc's victor oquendo is there. >> reporter: the urgent search for survivors continues into the night in guatemala. >> oh, my god. >> reporter: the fuego volcano erupting sunday, spewing rock and ash. lava barreling down the side of the volcano, upwards of 100 miles per hour, at temperatures of 1300 degrees. panicked residents, even police, desperately trying to escape. the death toll is staggering. more than 65. that number is expected to rise. "we lost three of our family members. my two brothers and my nephew."
1:06 am
but there are signs of hope. rescuers still finding people alive, pulling them from the ash. including miraculously this baby wrapped in a blanket. as others begin the long cleanup process, sweeping layers of ash away from homes, driveways, and rooftops. for "nightline" i'm victor oquendo in antigua, guatemala. >> and the cleanup is just getting started. thanks for watching "nightline." and as always, we're online at our "nightline" facebook page. good night, america.
1:07 am
139 Views
IN COLLECTIONS
KGO (ABC) Television Archive Television Archive News Search ServiceUploaded by TV Archive on