tv 60 Minutes CBS December 18, 2022 7:00pm-8:00pm PST
7:00 pm
the joy in 2-year-old melania defied both cancer and war. but if she was to live, her family had to escape ukraine. as missiles flew and doctors rushed the sickest children underground, a renowned american hospital and 21 countries improvised a flight to safety called the convoy of life. litigation funding is a new type of investment that's become a multibillion dollar industry.
7:01 pm
so these are all lawyers? >> indeed they are. >> reporter: in essence, investors bet on the outcome of large lawsuits the way traders bet on stocks. how often are you right? >> we're right about 90% of the time, and we're wrong about 10% of the time. >> reporter: the problem is this market is exploding with nearly no rules or oversight. ♪ do you believe in miracles? well, "60 minutes" traveled to the sanctuary of our lady of lourdes in southern france where 70 medical miracles have been recognized by the catholic church over 160 years. and tonight, you'll hear a miracle story and from the renown doctors and researchers who investigated it. ♪ i'm lesley stahl. >> i'm bill whitaker. >> i'm anderson cooper. >> i'm sharyn alfonsi. >> i'm jon wertheim. >> i'm scott pelley. those stories and more tonight on "60 minutes."
7:03 pm
if you still have symptoms of moderate to severe rheumatoid arthritis or active psoriatic arthritis after a tnf blocker like humira or enbrel, rinvoq is different and may help. stand up to your symptoms with rinvoq. rinvoq is a once-daily pill that tackles pain, stiffness, swelling. for some, rinvoq significantly reduces ra and psa fatigue. it can stop further irreversible joint damage. and rinvoq can leave skin clear or almost clear in psa. that's rinvoq relief. rinvoq can lower your ability to fight infections, including tb. serious infections and blood clots, some fatal; cancers, including lymphoma and skin cancer; death, heart attack, stroke, and tears in the stomach or intestines occurred. people 50 and older with at least one heart disease risk factor have higher risks. don't take if allergic to rinvoq as serious reactions can occur. tell your doctor if you are or may become pregnant. ask your rheumatologist for rinvoq.
7:04 pm
rinvoq. make it your mission. learn how abbvie could help you save. young lady who was, you know, mid 30s, couple of kids, recently went through a divorce. she had a lot of questions when she came in. i watched my mother go through being a single mom. at the end of the day, my mom raised three children, including myself. and so once the client knew that she was heard. we were able to help her move forward. your client won't care how much you know until they know how much you care. tyson boneless buffalo bites and hot wings have that tasty kick of flavor... ...so they're perfect for any get-together... ...if there are any left when your guests arrive. tyson any'tizers® chicken. more kicks of flavor. more smiling snackers. more to love. tyson. i don't know if we can be trusted m with such a weapon.. [ suspenseful music playing ]
7:05 pm
but we have no choice. half the people of ukraine are without power, as low temperatures drop into the 20s. russia is attacking civilian utilities with new waves of missiles in relentless assaults that the united nations calls, war crimes. even before russia's invasion last february, more than 1,000 ukrainian children were already at war. they were fighting cancer.
7:06 pm
russian attacks on hospitals put these fragile children in immediate danger. the first lady of ukraine asked the world for help, and a renowned american hospital and 21 countries answered the call. what followed was an improvised flight to safety that ukraine called, the convoy of life. the joy in 2-year-old melania defied both cancer and war. but if she was to live, her family had to escape ukraine. in february, her mother roksolana semeraz joined the jam of thousands of refugees struggling to cross into poland. people were walking for miles, she told us. leaving their cars and belongings behind. they would only take with them their most precious ones, their children and pets. my heart was tearing apart.
7:07 pm
at the border, roksolanda's desperation rose with the temperature of melania's cancer drug she was carrying. it had to be refrigerated, but now they were trapped. >> translator: after waiting in line at the border for over 24 hours, and it would get warmer during the day, i had no storage for the medication. and that's when i would become desperate. i didn't know what to do. how to have hope for the treatment of my child. >> reporter: mothers across ukraine were losing hope for their sick children. this was the scene in the capital kyiv outside the window of this children's hospital. dr. lysytsia told us as the missiles flew, she rushed patients to the basement, many on chemotherapy. all of the patients were very sick, she told us.
7:08 pm
being moved to the basement definitely didn't do any good to their health. dr. lysytsia specializes in eye cancer and in the treatment room they displayed their rage. we are continuing to work despite the war, and we are going to win this war with russian soldiers and kill cancer. maybe they didn't need the sign. dr. lysytsia's look said it all. she told us, their lives depend on the hospital supplies, such basic supplies as blood, for example. you can't delay an operation for an oncology patient for a week or two. you can't stop their treatment because timing is crucial. if you delay chemotherapy for two weeks, then you've lost some percentage of their chance to survive. >> reporter: the plight of
7:09 pm
desperate children touched the first lady of ukraine, olena zelenska. we met in kyiv in september. elegant but weary, she seemed to bear the burden of 44 million ukrainians. kids with cancer were among the first to find her empathy. how did you work with other countries to evacuate these cancer patients? >> translator: on my level, i can speak with the first ladies. for this convoy to work, they needed to set up the system in their countries, making sure that physicians and hospitals in their country would accept the children for treatment. jill biden responded for the united states. brigitte macron for france. agata kornhauser-duda for poland and many others. they helped activate charities and medical societies. we had a big team. everyone helping each other, and
7:10 pm
i am very grateful for that. that team likely saved the life of 17-year-old zhasmin alkadi. a woman who impressed us with the creativity, personality and love of life that are rich in those who know they can lose them. in february, doctors ordered her into chemotherapy to save her leg from bone cancer, but before that happened, russia invaded. in march, zhasmin alkadi joined the convoy of life. patients throughout ukraine took buses and trains to a children's hospital in lviv, near poland. after treatment there, the children and their families crossed the border where they boarded a medical train. the entire route could take days or weeks, but throughout the exhausting journey, at least zhasmin had her mother to lean on.
7:11 pm
when we see you on the train, you are moving into the unknown in that moment. >> translator: yes, zhasmin told us. on that journey we didn't know what country on the destination list we would end up in. you're on the train, hoping for the best, trusting doctors, hoping it will all be fine. but as you said, you're moving into the unknown. where will i be tomorrow? >> reporter: the answer turned out to be this improvised triage center in poland set up by an american hospital st. jude children's research hospital of memphis, tennessee, named for the the patron saint of hopeless causes. >> there are patients who are more likely to get sick than others. and so we want to identify those patients so we can pay attention to them when we get here. >> reporter: that's dr. marta
7:12 pm
salek of st. jude who helped organize the triage center in an empty hotel in the polish country side. >> the children would get escorted from lviv to the border so they didn't have to wait in line and cross the border into poland. the children who were sick would go straight to the hospital with an ambulance, sometimes a helicopter. the ones that were stable would take this really impressive medical train that had medical staff, they had an icu and a surgical theater and take this train to a city closed to where our unicorn clinic was. >> reporter: the unicorn clinic was the name they gave to the hotel that could hold 300 refugees. patients and their families. medical records were translated and hospitals found for treatment at no charge in 21 welcoming countries. i suspect you never heard of memphis, tennessee? >> translator: i just knew there was such a place, but not much
7:13 pm
else. >> reporter: in march, zhasmin alkadi arrived in memphis for treatment at st. jude. what are the doctors telling you now? >> translator: i have a few rounds of chemotherapy left. everything is going well. i already had my leg amputated unfortunately. the doctors said it was too late to save the leg and it was le i just need to finish my chemotherapy and i can then continue living my life as before. >> reporter: also living a rambunctious life at st. jude is 2-year-old melania semeraz, the girl who had been stuck at the polish border with her refrigerated medication. >> how are you today? >> reporter: her mother, roksolana semeraz told us there is hope that melania can be cured of fibroid carcinoma.
7:14 pm
a cancer of the connective tissue in her leg. >> translator: we fled the war from people who just wanted to kill, roksolana told us in november. and here people are greeting you and want to give you the best help. they did so much for us and are still doing. this is something incredible. >> reporter: what does the world need to know about this war? >> translator: it is scary that in our century people still believe that war is worth something. there are so many real problems in the world, such as cancer. why doesn't russia fight cancer? >> reporter: but rather than fight disease, russia is attacking medicine. the u.n. says russia has assaulted hospitals and clinics,
7:15 pm
630 times. this is a hospital in mykolaiv, a hospital in mariupol. and the luhansk children's hospital and a maternity hospital in kyiv. what are the russians trying to do? >> translator: they are waging war against civilians, first lady zelenska told us. they're trying to scare people away, make them flee, leaving empty cities and villages behind. and then they would come and seize these lands using scorched earth tactics. >> reporter: since our visit with mrs. zelenska russia has devastated ukraine's power grid. the kyiv children's hospital we visited sent us images of surgeries illuminated by generators and the neonatal intensive care unit swaddled in sandbags. dr. lysytsia remains at work.
7:16 pm
what has the war taken from ukrainian children? >> translator: childhood. the most valuable thing that children have. they stole childhood from our children. and we now have a lot of kids who are mentally broken no matter how hard we try to rebuild their lives. >> reporter: the mass evacuation of children with cancer ran last spring from march through may. dr. marta salek of st. jude told us a few children did not survive the journey. >> and so there were some instances where children would die on the journey, but i think those children would have died if they had stayed in ukraine. it was the gift that we could give to the families to give them that hope that the child could die peacefully in a safe environment and not have to worry about the effects of war. >> reporter: a gift? >> yeah. >> reporter: what do you mean? >> i can't imagine being a
7:17 pm
parent who has a child that -- with a chronic condition that is approaching end of life and th family member has to worry, will the hospital be struck by a missile? at the time the decision was to evacuate those children with the risk that they might die on route. but if that would bring peace to the family, as they were going through this terrible circumstance that was also now affected by war, then it felt like the right thing to do at the time. >> reporter: providing these children with a safe place to die? >> yeah. it's really important. and so we honored that request. >> reporter: by recent count, the convoy of life evacuated 1,119 children into a welcoming world. allowing their families to fight one war at a time. i wonder what you would like to say to the americans who have welcomed your family?
7:18 pm
>> reporter: wherever i go, i want to say thank you to every person that i meet. i feel like i want to scream outloud to everyone, thank you. america gave this to us. and i would like to have a chance to help others, too. so that people believe that kindness wins. we need to do more good things. stories of the sick who stayed. the children fighting cancer in a war zone. at 60minutesovertime.com. [ "pure love" by olly alexander ] ♪ ♪
7:19 pm
(woman vo) sailing a great river past extraordinary landscapes into the heart of iconic cities is a journey for the curious traveler, one that many have yet to discover. exploring with viking brings you closer to the world, to the history, the culture, the flavors, a serene river voyage on an elegant viking longship. learn more at viking.com
7:20 pm
7:21 pm
7:22 pm
say someone was wronged by a big corporation but has no money to sue it. a litigation funder will pay for their court battle. in essence, they're betting on the lawsuit the way traders bet on stocks. if it's successful, they make money, sometimes a lot of money. if it fails, the funders get nothing. their investment is lost. litigation funding can help in cases where otherwise the little guy who is suing would just get crushed or lowballed by defendants with deep pockets. problem is this market is exploding with nearly no rules or oversight. >> this is quite an honor to be able to drive you around in my truck. >> reporter: we start our story in the rolling hills of ventura county, california. >> this is one of our fields. >> reporter: this one, too? where craig underwood's family
7:23 pm
farm had been growing jalapenos for three decades. so you used to have peppers as far as the eye could see? >> as you were driving through the valley, peppers were every place. >> reporter: but i heard that you had one customer? >> one customer. >> reporter: they make the world famous saracha hot sauce. in 2016 they abruptly severed ties with underwood. his business dried up overnight. is there anything growing here at all? can you tell? >> there's nothing planted here and up here it's just weeds. >> reporter: facing ruin, he sued the company for breach of contract and won $23 million. >> reporter: but they appealed. >> they appealed. >> reporter: you couldn't collect any of the money. >> no. we were looking at whether we could survive or not. you know, every week we were trying to find enough cash to pay the bills, make sure we could make payroll. >> reporter: he couldn't afford to keep fighting until he heard
7:24 pm
of an investment firm that backed people in his situation. >> we make the playing field level. and that's what people should be wanting in litigation. >> reporter: christopher bogart is the ceo of burford capital. he funds litigants and takes a chunk of their reward if they win. >> we are a multibillion dollar company because litigation is expensive and there's an awful lot of demand from businesses for this kind of solution. >> reporter: so is it a loan? >> it's a nonrecourse financing. >> reporter: what does nonrecourse -- what does that mean? >> what it means is that if the case that we're financing doesn't succeed, then we don't get our money back. and so it's different from a loan in the sense that a loan obviously you're always having to pay back the principal. >> reporter: if your side loses, you get nothing? >> that's correct. >> reporter: still, craig underwood was torn because if he won the appeal, burford would get a big chunk.hechce4 llion f.
7:25 pm
soon after, he won the appeal and the 23 million, but then he had to pay his lawyers and square away with burford. >> we had to give them $8 million to pay for the 4 that we got and the 4 that was their -- >> reporter: did you think when you realized they were going to charge you 100%, that that was predatory? >> some people might think that. i didn't feel that way because -- >> reporter: you didn't? >> they stepped in and helped us out when we couldn't have gotten money from anybody else. they basically rescued us. >> reporter: founded in 2009, burford is the world's largest litigation funder with $5 billion invested in multiple lawsuits. is it actually safer in today's environment to invest in litigation than in the stock market? >> well, the benefit you get from litigation is that litigation doesn't fluctuate the
7:26 pm
same way the markets do. >> reporter: what's your average investment? >> when we're financing a single piece of litigation, it would be very rare for us to be below $5 million and it goes up from there. >> reporter: let's say you have a huge case with tens of millions of dollars. >> uh-huh. >> reporter: what kind of percentage do you expect to win at the end? >> on an average basis, we'll largely double our money. >> reporter: are there cases where you actually walked away with more money than the plaintiff, the person who was wronged? >> so that doesn't happen very often. >> reporter: but occasionally. >> it certainly can happen. >> reporter: there's no legal limit on how big a chunk litigation funders can take. and the deals are confidential. bogart argues the reason they demand so much is because of the big risks they take. but actually they pick their cases very carefully. so these are all lawyers? >> ndeed they are. >> reporter: and what are they doing?
7:27 pm
>> they are fundamentally vetting potential cases that we might finance for corporate clients. we certainly do due diligence on those matters to chose ones that are meritorious and will be successful. >> reporter: how often are you right? >> right about 90% of the time and wrong about 10% of the time. >> reporter: wow. what if the client that you've given all this money to, invested in, wants to settle and you think that's a mistake? >> clients are free to run their litigations as they see fit. they're free to work with their lawyers as they see fit. and we don't interfere with that relationship. it's not uncommon for them to come and ask for our advice, but it's advice. the client is free to disregard that advice and take its own path. >> reporter: but maya steinitz, a law professor at the university of iowa, says there are ethics rules for lawyers but not for these investors. >> funders are not regulated. there's nothing precluding them
7:28 pm
legally from pressuring a client to settle. the rules of ethics are very clear that the lawyer has to abide by the wishes of the client, but human nature is human nature. there may be an inclination to be pulled towards the person who is paying. >> reporter: why is this important? why should someone out there who is not involved in a lawsuit care? >> for multiple reasons. first of all, there's this new industry and new type of player, litigation funders, who reshaping every aspect of the litigation process, which cases get brought, how long are they pursued, when are they settled? but all of this is happening without transparency. so we have one of the three branchs of government the judiciary, that's really being quietly transformed and there's very -- >> reporter: very little oversight. >> very little oversight. >> reporter: who is working to impose regulations, insist on transparency in this industry? >> one entity that's been very vocal is the u.s. chamber of
7:29 pm
commerce that represents big businesses because the sector that's most concerned about this is big corporations. and there's money to persevere and not to settle early at a discount. >> reporter: big business would like to have regulations. how interesting because they don't like regulation. >> generally. >> reporter: except when it helps them. >> generally. >> reporter: burford usually funds big cases involving big sophisticated corporations. there's only a handful of invest ment firms like it whose business is solely investing in litigation, but hedge funds, foreign government funds and wealthy individuals are also getting into this market. but because there are no regulations, and most cases litigation funders remain anonymous in court. in 2012, a billionaire peter teal, secretly funded wrestler hulk hogan's invasion of privacy lawsuit against the website gawker that drove it out of business.
7:30 pm
teal had his own long-standing score to settle with the site. >> if you've been injured in an accident -- >> reporter: but litigation funding isn't just for giant cases worth gazillions. >> you can get cash as soon as the same day. >> reporter: these ads are for a whole other category of litigation funding companies that offer quick cash -- >> you can get cash in as little as 24 hours. >> reporter: directly to individuals who are suing in smaller cases. usually over personal injury accidents. >> from 500 to -- >> reporter: they need the money to pay their household bills so they can hold out for larger settlements. >> the beauty of presettlement funding is that if you lose, you don't have to pay back anything. >> call now -- >> reporter: but in the ads it's easy to miss that if you win, you might have to pay a hefty sum. this group of litigation funders charges so much because, again, they say the risk is so high especially given that the applicants for these advances
7:31 pm
are often broke, injured, out of work and with no assets. but we found rates running highn minimal o risk ctakee of former officer donald sussex who was entitled to money from the 9/11 victim's compensation fund. he became ill after he raced to ground zero. and how long did you stay? >> i stayed there approximately nine days. >> reporter: inhaling all that -- >> yes. >> reporter: dust. >> yes. there was so much dust down there that you could not see your hands in front of your face. >> reporter: so obviously you had medical issues. >> yeah. i couldn't run. i couldn't breathe. >> reporter: so you're entitled from that victim's compensation fund -- >> yes, i was. >> reporter: to get $90,000. >> yes. >> reporter: you were told you would get 90,000. >> yes. >> reporter: you got 10,000 up front. >> yes. >> reporter: he knew he would eventually get more. but in the meantime, he needed
7:32 pm
money for his medical care. so an ad in the paper caught his eye. >> it said r & d legal funding can get your money faster. we can cut through the red tape. >> reporter: huh. >> so i called r & d legal funding but then after i signed all the documents and sent over to them, they came back at an interest rate that i couldn't even figure out. the document was very confusing. i couldn't even understand it. >> i'm a lawyer, 40 years. i couldn't understand it. >> reporter: michael bearish is sussex's lawyer. >> they lent him $25,000. he had to repay $64,800. >> reporter: that's 150%. and you paid it? >> i had no choice. i had no choice. i paid it. out of the $90,000, i ended up with about 30,000 of it. i feel totally just taken advantage of. >> reporter: the argument from this industry is that they take
7:33 pm
a big risk when they invest this money. >> this is not a car accident case against a small insurance company. this was 9/11 victim compensation fund created by congress and backed by the u.s. treasury. >> reporter: the company told us sussex's contract was clear, but his case was part of a lawsuit against r & d legal brought by the new york attorney general. it settled last month. the company denied wrong doing but had to provide over $600,000 in debt relief to harmed consumers, stop doing business with recipients of the 9/11 victim compensation fund and pay $1 penalty. so how do litigation funders like this get away with charging such exorbitant rates? if you take out say a car loan, laws that prevent predatory per reme, thesaren't loansate. .
7:34 pm
they're investments. litigation funders for giant and personal cases argue that this market is offering a lifeline to those who have nowhere else to turn. and legal scholars like maya steinitz agree. >> accessing the courts in a civil process is a luxury good in today's america. lawyers charge hundreds of dollars by the hour, so if you've been injured, if you've been discriminated against, if a contract that you have entered into has been breached, it is simply too expensive to bring your case in court. so i think litigation funding is essential. however, personally i think that litigation funding should be regulated. but i certainly don't think it should be prohibited. s music] ♪ ♪ ♪ weathertech gift cards have the power to wow everyone on your holiday list.
7:35 pm
7:36 pm
[ suspenseful music playing ] order the weatherte 3...ft card 2... 1... this holiday master your kitchen with wayfair. ♪ ♪ keep it fresh with colorful cookware. whip up holiday treats with ease. slice and dice with the best of them. and with wayfair, you can express yourself. ♪ ♪ wayfair, holiday your heart out. ♪ wayfair, you've got just what i need ♪
7:38 pm
[narrator] everyone needs quality health insurance, even if you're healthy and active. covered california is a free service to help you get covered. 90% of members have received financial help and every plan offered is comprehensive, covering preventive care, doctor visits, emergency care, and more. regardless of your income, check today to see how covered california can help you. and if you have questions, there's free assistance every step of the way. covered california, this way to health insurance. enroll by december 31st at coveredca.com.
7:39 pm
get exclusive offers this way to health insurance. on select new volvo models. contact your volvo retailer to learn more. with a grueling pandemic and gruesome political season, you'd be forgiven for giving up on the idea of miracles. but tonight, we will take you to a place that's known for them. the sanctuary of our lady of lourdes in southern france is the site of 70 medical miracles recognized by the catholic church. the marian shrine is famous to the faithful, but less well known is the lourdes office of medical observations. that's where world-renown doctors and researchers conduct decade long investigations into
7:40 pm
the countless claims of cures reported over the years. they determine which cases can be medically explained and which cannot. it's those church officials might call a miracle. for the doctors, it's a lesson in the limits of medicine. for the devout, it's divine intervention. ♪ this small french town of lourdes tucked in the foothills of pyrenees mountains, draws more than three million pilgrims every year. more than travel to mecca or jerusalem. and almost every one you meet will tell you they've heard stories of miracles here. but we heard none more inspiring than that of sister bernadette moriau. >> translator: i really tried everything i could. but this is something that cannot be healed. >> reporter: what was your prognosis? >> translator: total paralysis. the prognosis was really dark.
7:41 pm
>> reporter: strolling with 83-year-old sister moriau through the chapel grounds in bresles, france, we found it hard to believe that for half her life she suffered from cauda equina, a disorder from the nerves and lower spine. you wore this all the time? her left foot she said was twisted and limp. to walk at all, she needed this back and leg brace and implant to null nerve pain and massive doses of morphine. she told us she had exhausted all treatment options. so in 2008, her doctor convinced her to make a pilgrimage to lourdes. did you believe in miracles at the time? >> translator: i always believed in miracles, but not for me. >> reporter: why did you decide to go? >> translator: well, i didn't go there for a miracle. i just went thto pray with others. lourdes is a place where the smallest people, or the sickest, or the poorest, they come first.
7:42 pm
>> reporter: the sickest, the poorest, the diseased and debilitated baring wounds visible and hidden come from all over the world seeking to be healed by the shrine's natural spring waters and the power of prayer. >> so i asked for complete healing or super long remission. >> reporter: this was kim's first pilgrimage. she found out last year she has incurable blood cancer and came all the way from kansas to cleanse herself in the waters of lourdes. are you expecting to be healed? >> not necessarily. ask for as much as i want, and maybe i will be blessed with part of it. which will be okay. >> reporter: she was aided by her son sean. we couldn't help but notice there are as many volunteers as sick here. the ouiterican
7:43 pm
travel fmiota for his 18th visit. >> even though they can't -- i have a condition and a chair, when i'm here, i don't have a condition. >> reporter: jensen's condition is cerebral palsy, al those trips to lourdes haven't given him the physical miracle he wanted, but maybe he says, he got the miracle he needed. >> i was very bitter, very angry with myself. >> reporter: did coming to lourdes change your heart? >> very much. >> reporter: do you consider that a miracle? >> i do because there's a -- there's a peace within myself. >> holy mary, mother of god -- >> reporter: stories of inner
7:44 pm
peace and acceptanc office of m observations. and with just 70 medical miracles recognized in 160 years, you'd have better odds playing the lotto, yet thousands of faithful line up at the baths and at this grotto, where the first miracle is said to have occurred. ♪ >> reporter: the sanctuary with its three basilicas and 25 chapels is laid out like a grand theater complex. its many stages offering dozens of pyas performances throughout the day. ♪ the finale, a candle lit procession every night. ♪ there would be none of this were it not for saint bernadette, according to catholic lore, in 1858 a mysterious woman appeared in this grotto to bernadette soubirous. a 14-year-old peasant girl.
7:45 pm
jean marc micas, the bishop of lourdes, says the woman spoke with her several times over five months. >> and once, the 25th of march, the day of announceuation, she said i am the immaculate conception. >> reporter: when word got out the immaculate conception, the virgin mary had appeared in lourdes, people flocked to this grotto and within days started making claims of miracle cures the ability to walk, restored sight. worried about fueling mass hysteria, the church set up the office of medical observations in 1883 to investigate the claims. which brings us back to the other bernadette in our story. 14 years ago, sister moriau found herself in a wheelchair, in a procession at lourdes, seeking the intervention of saint bernadette. >> translator: and i really had
7:46 pm
that feeling that the lord was walking with us. and i heard him giving me these words, i see you're suffering and that your sick brothers and sisters. just give me everything. >> reporter: you heard the voice of jesus? >> translator: yes, i heard this inner voice. i can't really tell you whose voice it was. it was like a spiritual experience. >> reporter: she said she returned home rejuvenated spiritually but physically she felt worse. after three days in excruciating pain, she told us she suddenly found the strength to walk to the chapel and pray. >> translator: then i felt some kind of heat coming into my body. i felt relaxed, but i didn't really know what that was meaning. and in my room, i heard this inner voice again telling me take all your braces off. i didn't think twice. and i started taking my foot brace off. and my foot that used to be crooked was straight. and i could actually put it on the ground without feeling any pain.
7:47 pm
>> reporter: all of a sudden your foot was straight? >> translator: yes, like that. like the way it is just now. and so i kept going. >> reporter: she says she took off the braces and stopped the morphine all at once. did this make sense to you? >> translator: no. i knew it was impossible. >> she came to my door with her doctor and she said, last year i came to lourdes on a pilgrimage and three days after i got back home i was cured. >> reporter: this doctor hears stories like that all the time. as the president and residing physician at the lourdes' office of medical observations, the former pediatrician's job is to determine whether there is more to those stories by applying seven strict criteria established by the church. >> and we are looking for a diagnosis. and if that diagnosis is a diagnosis of a severe disease, with a severe prognosis. then we want to make sure that that person is a person that was cured in a way that one would
7:48 pm
say suddenly, in an instantaneous way, in a complete way, in a way lasting in time. and my seventh criteria that has to match is it must be no possible explanation to that cure, sister moriau. >> here on the end -- >> reporter: he showed us the archives which holds thousands of recorded claims of cures. >> this feels like it's almost 10 pounds. >> ten pounds. >> reporter: the doctor, a practicing catholic told us what separates the more than 7,000 claims of cures from the 70 the church calls miracles is an ungodly amount of medical documentation and patients like sister moriau, willing to put their lives under a microscope. >> we sent to different neurologists. we sent her to different rheumatologists because of the specific case of her disease. we asked to repeat twice, also to imagery.
7:49 pm
eelectro physiology. all we would do in medicine to be sure of her diagnosis, and there was. >> reporter: but he wanted to confirm something else. >> translator: i was asked to meet with two psychiatrists in paris. they wanted to know if i was lying. if i had already had hallucinations or levitating. i remember answering no, doctor, i never left the ground floor. >> reporter: satisfied they sent sister moriau's case to a group of 33 doctors and professors called the interneshl medical committee of lourdes. its job is to determine whether a cure is what they consider medically unexplained. >> we're not trying to reel something in or reel something out. we're trying to be objective. >> reporter: you could call them the doctor's advocates. dr. michael moran-a surgical oncology. dr. a professor of urology at
7:50 pm
johns hopkins and dr. kian moriarti, scrutinized sister moriau's case. is there any -- anything that could have caused her response? >> no treatment would be that effective that quickly. >> reporter: does religion enter into your medical conversation? >> we cannot separate ourselves as people who have been deeply immersed in the culture and the traditions of lourdes and the church, but make no mistake, we're just as technical as a forensic pathologist when it comes to looking a the technical details of the case. >> reporter: after eight years of investigation, the committee determined that sister moriau's case was medically unexplained. so when you do a survey, the investigation of sister bernadette's or other cures, this is done on a ly ba sng tt could be revwed by other
7:51 pm
physicians outside -- >> they are peer reviewed. >> i can affirm with absolute certainty that the case of sister bernadette has been reviewed, read, by at least 300 physicians. 300 physicians. and if tomorrow morning, any of our viewers is a doctor and one day he stops in southern france and comes to see me and wants to look into the file of sister bernadette, i would be delighted to show him because we have -- everything is open and collegial and no secrets. >> reporter: the secret is the mystery of it all. and on that, the church gets the last word. in 2018, a decade after her cure, sister moriau's case was declared the 70th miracle of lourdes. >> declaring a miracle is saying god did something. this is the miracle.
7:52 pm
and the doctors cannot go on that land, on that field. >> reporter: when i told people i was coming here, i got a lot of people who told me, oh, come on. there's got to be some explanation, that we just don't know. what do you say to the skeptics? >> come and see. be open. don't be narrow minded. be open to believe that the real world is wider than the visible one. ♪ >> reporter: it's been said about lourdes for those who believe no explanation is necessary. for those who do not, no explanation is possible. ♪ ♪ cbs sports hq is present th.
7:53 pm
jenkins jacques a past to jolt the jacks to victory. tom brady giveth and the bangles take away. the saints left as winners. the steelers ground and pound and take the panthers down. chiefs, chiefs, chiefs, chiefs, chiefs, chiefs. yeah, that makes seven. for 24/7 news and highlights go to cbssportshq.com. -[ gasps ] that's me. just leaving you a voicemail. my number is 618-437-7425. okay. can anyone tell me what julie did wrong there? you got to repeat the number. i mean, no one's ever gonna get it the first time. -nope. -didn't leave her last name. no, the -- the phone tells you who called. she didn't mention a good time to call her back. how am i supposed to know when to call her back? no. she just shouldn't have left a voicemail. 9 out of 10 times, a text will do. progressive can't save you from becoming your parents, but we can save you money when you bundle home and auto with us. your heart is the beat of life. if you have heart failure, entrust your heart to entresto,
7:54 pm
a medicine specifically made for heart failure. entresto is the #1 heart failure brand prescribed by cardiologists. it was proven superior at helping people stay alive and out of the hospital. heart failure can change the structure of your heart, so it may not work as well. entresto helps improve your heart's ability to pump blood to the body. and just imagine where a healthier heart could take you. don't take entresto if pregnant; it can cause harm or death to an unborn baby. don't take entresto with an ace inhibitor or aliskiren, or if you've had angioedema with an ace or arb. the most serious side effects are angioedema, low blood pressure, kidney problems, the steelers ground and pound ask your doctor about entresto for heart failure. entrust you heart to entresto.
7:57 pm
7:58 pm
days grow short and light is at a premium, the department of energy brought good news from the laboratory often associated with atomic armageddon. the lawrence livermore national laboratory after decades of disappointing experiments has achieved a nuclear fusion reaction that produces more power than it consumes. fusion energy, the same process the sun uses to create heat and light, promises to be clean, cheap and nearly unexpendable. it produces neither greenhouse gases nor nuclear waste. the breakthrough's practical applications are years, even decades away, but in this season of hope, it sheds a little light in the darkness. i'm bill whitaker. happy hanukkah and merry christmas. we'll be back christmas night with another edition of "60 minutes." with unitedhealthcare my sister has a whole team to help her get the most out of her medicare plan.
7:59 pm
8:00 pm
511 Views
IN COLLECTIONS
KPIX (CBS)Uploaded by TV Archive on
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/c9f99/c9f99977e9fe3b4ebd288c7c2026bcd869094dba" alt=""