tv 60 Minutes CBS December 15, 2024 7:00pm-8:00pm PST
7:01 pm
[stopwatch ticking] [stopwatch ticking] an entire generation of syrians has never known freedom, and, so when it swept over them last sunday, there was shock, then joy, and a desperate hope that it might last. damascus is a city nearly 5,000 years old. but, over this decade, the war has seemed like the end of civilization. i've even seen on social media platforms, people showing before and after photos, what are clearly high school girls, and i've like, reverse-imaged searched, and they're, like, high school swim meet girls. adult content is made of them, not consensually, and posted on social media. >> i think a lot of parents would be surprised if you post a picture of your child on your
7:02 pm
instagram account, a naked photo of your child could end up out there. >> yeah. on a rainy afternoon, we watched as the director of hermes turned his attention to the designs. the only part of the process that happens quickly is this. he chose the colors for next season's scarves in less than an hour. >> i'm a happy man. when i look at the disaster, mountain of hope, reduced to ashes. [stopwatch ticking] i'm lesley stahl. >> i'm bill whitaker. >> i'm anderson cooper. >> i'm cecilia vega. >> i'm scott pelley. those stories and more tonight on "60 minutes." [stopwatch ticking] isher investr investments we may look like other money managers, but we're different. (other money manager) how so? (fisher investments) we're a fiduciary, obligated to act in our client'' best interest.
7:03 pm
(fisher investments) so we don't sell any commission-based products. (other money manager) then how do you make money? (fisher investments) we have a simple management fee, structured so we do better when our clients do better. (other money manager) your clients really come first then, huh? fisher investments: yes. we make them a top priority, by getting to know their finances, family, health, lifestyle and more. (other money manager) wow, maybe we are different. (fisher investments) at fisher investments, we're clearly different. for more than a decade farxiga has been trusted again and again, and again. ♪far-xi-ga♪
7:04 pm
7:06 pm
tonight, the middle east is reeling from the astonishing fall of bashar al-assad, former president of syria. scott pelley is in the syrian capital, damascus. >> an entire generation of syrians has never known freedom, and so, when it swept over them last sunday, there was shock, then joy, and a desperate hope that it might last. damascus is a city nearly 5,000 years old. but over this decade the war has seemed like the end of civilization. half a million syrians are dead. 13 million have been forced from
7:07 pm
their homes. this past week we traveled 300 miles on the road to damascus to meet a people awakening from 50 years of dictatorship. take the road to damascus from the east, and you find the suburb of ein tarma. the outskirts of one of the great cities of history has been bombed into the stone age. this was president bashar al-assad's answer to mostly unarmed protests that began in 2011. many who rose against assad then, are still here. that's the zidane family. >> we were living here in peace. when we just demanded freedom and to be able to earn our daily bread, the assad regime started bombing us. >> mohammed saeed zidane and his wife nihal have lived here two
7:08 pm
years. >> when you came back here after the shelling, what did you see? what did you think? >> we couldn't hold back our tears when we came back here. we're not nomads. but what could we do? >> no electricity, no running water. fifteen families in the zidane building alone. six flights up, 70-year-old najah zidane burns rags to cook. there's no fuel, no trees. the ceiling looks exhausted and winter comes this week. we'd like to show you the immensity, but we can't because the ruins run for miles in every direction. and this is what you would see in most every syrian city. to stay in power, assad left his people to starve.
7:09 pm
so mohammed zidane built a furrow from broken bricks to farm radishes, spring onions and coriander. >> when you first heard that assad was gone, could you believe it? >> we felt like everyone else, like we were in a bad dream and finally woke up! >> she said we're still in shock. is he gone for real? >> on the road, the signposts of history tell the backstory. hafez al-assad, the father, ruled from 1970. the bullet holes give you a sense of how he's remembered. then, in the year 2000, the son, bashar, continued the brutal police state. we've been covering the civil war for 12 years. it began with an exodus of
7:10 pm
millions at the time -- the greatest humanitarian catastrophe since world war ii. >> this berm marks the border between syria and jordan. the refugees that we ran into were coming across the top of the berm and turning themselves in to the safety of the jordanian border officers here. >> we reported on the relentless bombardment of civilians and the rescue work of syrians known as the white helmets. they're civil defense volunteers who have given thousands a second chance at life. we covered assad's 2013 nerve gas and chemical attacks that killed an estimated 1,400 civilians. by 2015, russia and iran had joined the war to prop up
7:11 pm
assad's forces. russian airstrikes saved assad. and we saw bombed hospitals in rebel territory, a war crime. >> everyone's afraid of being beside a hospital because they know the hospital is going to be a target in an airstrike. >> and, with half a million syrians dead, we met a generation of orphans. last year, we reported on syrians left destitute, by a massive earthquake in rebel territory. until this fall, the rebels had been cornered in the north. assad had all but won the war. but this month, his allies abandoned him. vladimir putin had exhausted russian forces in ukraine. iran was fighting israel. so three weeks ago, the rebels saw the chance and swept through
7:12 pm
the major cities to damascus. assad's army, hollowed out by corruption, simply ran away. the dictator fled to moscow. we found nearly all you need to know about assad's rule in examination room two at damascus hospital. these corpses are assad's prisoners from a notorious jail. dr. ayman nasser told us that he received 35 bodies. >> there is one with severe signs of torture. he said many of the bodies show signs of malnutrition or lack of oxygen from overcrowding in the places where they were kept. the cause of death was most likely multiple organ failure caused by malnutrition. >> starved to death in a prison. they were the last to die of
7:13 pm
untold thousands of political opponents who vanished into assad's jails over the decades. when word spread on facebook that 35 were here, the desperate came searching for the damned. >> who are you looking for? >> her son was arrested. >> there are so many like my son, from our village alone, about 70 prisoners. we are drowning in sorrow, our hearts are burning. i am like every mother here. crushed by pain every day. the regime killed two of my sons. one was killed by a sniper for no reason. the other died rescuing survivors from airstrikes when
7:14 pm
planes bombed them again, and he had a girl and a boy. >> who are you looking for? my son, susan al-tunji told us. like many, she received a death certificate from the prison years ago but no body, no proof. >> how long has he been missing? >> twelve years. i pray i find him. even if he is dead, it's okay, just give me the body. all i want is to find some rest. >> forensic pathologists compare photos, and teeth. t his doctor asks a relative. >> do you have a picture of him smiling? >> in this way, they have identified eighteen so far, dr. nasser told us. >> we empathize, and we do our best to help. but the pressure from the families is overwhelming. >> we saw that when we met the
7:15 pm
rage of people who have never known justice. taghreed al-badawi's son disappeared 12 years ago. >> assad is a war criminal. someone like him should die like a dog. he and the assad family should be executed for the horrors we now see. >> who is this, sir? this is my son, he told us, arrested in 2013. they took him at a checkpoint. he was driving a bus for a living. >> who is this? >> my brother. >> show me, this is your brother? what is his name? >> in 2012, her brother was arrested on his way to a store. >> they gave us his id card and told my mother never to ask about him again. they are a bunch of butchers.
7:16 pm
>> who is this? >> my brother. >> and how long has he been missing? >> thirteen years now, sednaya. >> thirteen years in the prison? you did not find him here? >> no. >> do you have hope that you will find him? >> we do have hope, he said, god willing. >> hope and apprehension are spilling into the streets of damascus. most of this city of about two and a half million people is intact because this was the dictator's stronghold. no one under the age of 54 has ever known freedom, has ever been able to speak of politics above a whisper. that's a tough memory to break. one man told us, “we got assad out of syria now we have to get him out of us.” there was joy in the crowd headed for friday prayers.
7:17 pm
75% of syrians are from the largest branch of islam, the sunnis. and the rebel leaders are sunni fundamentalists. but no one knows yet how minority muslim sects and christians will be protected. the leader of the rebels is 42-year-old ahmed al-sharaa. in 2013, the u.s. named him a terrorist and, later, put a 10 million dollar bounty on his head. but so far, al-sharaa has kept order. there's little sign of destruction, looting or reprisals, and government workers are on the job. the people do not know yet how they will be governed. peace seems to be in the hearts of many. but, the shooting hasn't stopped entirely. israel, last week, grabbed the chance to bomb what's left of syria's military. the u.s. is hitting remnants of
7:18 pm
isis terrorists in central syria. as for russia, satellite pictures of its major naval base on syria's mediterranean coast, now reveal that the ships are gone. back where we began, in the damascus suburb ein tarma, we saw the immensity of what lies ahead. it will take hundreds of billions of dollars to rebuild syria, and syria is destitute. mohammed zidane and his wife are resigned to live here. besides, a new home is not what they want the most. they want their 39-year-old son. in 2012, he was stopped at an assad regime checkpoint and they never heard from him again. >> what does that mean for your lives now that assad is gone? >> this feels like a new birth, a new beginning. though my hair has turned grey,
7:19 pm
and my time has passed, we feel, thank god, young again. we hope, by the hands of our young people, god willing, it will be better than it was before. >> a new syria is likely to be built by the kind of people who look out on despair and somehow see a future. experience tells syrians they have no reason to hope that freedom will last, and yet, that hope endures. [stopwatch ticking]
7:20 pm
when my hair started to thin, i thought, am i going to have any hair left. after i gave birth, my hair wasn't even thinning. it was gone. when i spoke to my dermatologist, he immediately pointed me in the direction of nutrafol. it's 100% drug free and clinically tested. within 3 months, my hair was fuller. its' longer, it's so much thicker. i had more scalp coverage. it's so nice to be noticed for my hair after hiding it for so many years. start your hair growth journey at nutrafol.com this week on chewy, shop and get a $30 egift card to use on treats they want, toys they love or food they devour. at prices everyone feels jolly about. for low prices for holidays with pets, there's chewy. ♪♪ some people just know they can save hundreds on car insurance
7:21 pm
by checking allstate first. like you know to check your school's saying first before saying it. high tide! [cheering] high tide, guys! high tide! high tide! it's “roll tide”. uh, shoot. yeah, checking first is smart. so check allstate first for a quote that could save you hundreds. roll tide! you're in good hands with allstate. when i was a kid, my mom would always put harry & david pears in our stockings. and if you got that gold one, it was like you had won christmas. my grandmother started it and now it's a tradition that i get to pass on to my kids. and that means a lot.
7:23 pm
in october last year, a 14-year-old girl named francesca mani was sitting in her high school history class when she heard a rumor that some boys had naked photos of female classmates. she soon learned her picture was among them, but the images were doctored, created with artificial intelligence using what's known as a nudify website or app, which turns real photos of someone fully clothed into real-looking nudes. we've found nearly 30 similar incidents in schools in the us over the last 20 months and plenty more around the world. we want to warn you. some of what you'll hear and see is disturbing, but we think unveiling these nudify websites is important. in part because they're not hidden on the dark web.
7:24 pm
they are openly advertised, easy to use, and, as francesca mani found out, there isn't much that's been done to stop them. >> when you first heard the rumor, you didn't know that there were photos or, or a photo of you? >> no, we didn't know. i think that was, like, the most chaotic day i've ever witnessed. >> in a school, somebody gets an inkling of something, and it just spreads. >> it's like rapid fire. it just goes through everyone. and so then when someone hears, hears this, it's like, "wait. like, a.i.?" like, no one thinks that could, like, happen to you. >> francesca mani knew nothing about nudify websites when she discovered she and several other girls at westfield high school in new jersey had been targeted. according to a lawsuit later filed by one of the other girls through her parents, a boy at the school uploaded photos from instagram to a site called clothoff. we are naming the site to raise awareness of its potential dangers. there are more than a hundred of these nudify websites. a quick search is all it takes
7:25 pm
to find them. clothoff is one of the most popular, with more than 3 million visits last month, according to graphika, a company that analyzes social networks. it now offers to nudify males as well, but female nudes are far more popular. “have someone to undress?” clothoff's website asks. you can upload a photo or get a free demonstration, in which an image of a woman appears with clothes on. then a few seconds later her clothes are gone. we are blurring it out, but the results look very real. francesca mani never saw what had been done to her photo, but according to that lawsuit at least one girl's a.i. nude was shared on snapchat and seen by several kids at school. what made it worse, francesca says, is that she and the other girls found out they were the victims,when they were called by name to the principal's office over the school's public address system. >> i feel like that was a major violation of our privacy while, like, the bad actors were taken out of their classes privately.
7:26 pm
when i left the principal's office, i was walking through a hallway, and i saw these group of boys laughing at these group of girls crying. and that's when i realized i should stop crying and be mad, because this is unacceptable. >> that afternoon, westfield's principal sent this email to all high school parents, informing them “some of our students had used artificial intelligence to create pornographic images from original photos.” the principal also said the school was investigating and “at this time we believe that any created images have been deleted and are not being circulated.” francesca's mom dorota, who's also an educator, was not convinced. > do you think they did enough? >> well, i don't know, anderson. you work in television. is anything deleted in the digital world? >> you feel like even if somebody deletes something somewhere, who knows where these images may be? >> who printed? who screenshotted? who downloaded? you can't really wipe it out.
7:27 pm
>> dorota says she filed a police report, but no charges have been brought. she was shocked by the school's handling of the whole incident. >> the principal informed me that one boy receives one-day suspension, and that was it. so i ask her if this is all. are there gonna be any other consequences? and she said, "no, that's, for now, this is all that is going to happen." >> the school district wouldn't confirm details about the potos, the students involved, or any disciplinary action. in a statement to 60 minutes, the school superintendent said the district revised its harassment, intimidation and bullying policy to incorporate a.i., something the manis said they spent months urging school officials to do. >> you feel like the girls paid a bigger cost in the end? >> yeah, they did. >> than the boy or boys? >> yeah. >> who were involved in this did? >> because they just have to live with knowing that maybe an image is floating, their image is floating around the internet. and they just have to deal with what the boys did.
7:28 pm
>> kolina koltai has been looking into clothoff and other nudify sites for more than a year. she's a senior researcher who specializes in the misuse of a.i. at bellingcat, an international investigative group. >> this site, as soon as you get there, it says, "you have to be 18 or over to use the website. you can't use others' photos without their permission. you can't use pictures of people who are under 18. is there any way for them to actually check if you're -- >> no. >> --under 18 or over 18? >> you'll see, as we click accept, that there's no verification. and now we're already here. >> and immediately, you're getting very explicit photos. >> and then they have the poses feature, which is one of their new settings, which is the different sex poses, which is the premium feature. >> wow. so, wow. >> this is the preview. we haven't -- >> clothoff and other nudify sites encourage customers to promote their services on social media, and users often show off their favorite before and after a.i. nudes. >> i've even seen on social media platforms people showing before and after photos of what are clearly, like, high school
7:29 pm
girls. and i've, like, reverse image searched the original photo. and they're, like, a high school girl's, like, swim meet. you'll see these are very clearly, these are minors. and adult content is being made of them non-consensually, then also being posted on social media. >> i think a lotta parents would be surprised to learn that you post a picture of your child on your instagram account, your child could end up, a naked photo of your child out there. >> yeah. and so you have a registration. >> to nudify a photo on clothoff is free the first time. after that, it costs from $2 to $40. the payment options often change, but there are always plenty to choose from. >> it's giving me everything from crypto using a credit card for a variety of different credit cards. we got paypal here. google pay. >> i would imagine some of these companies are not thrilled that their services are being used by these websites. >> yeah. and in many of these cases, it, it directly violates their policies. >> to trick online payment services, kolina koltai says, clothoff and other nudify sites, redirect their customers'
7:30 pm
payments through phony websites like these pretending to sell flowers and photography lessons. >> say, for example, you want to pay through paypal. so we click this, and it'll take a second. so it's now redirecting you. >> it's redirecting through a dummy -- >> a dummy website. >> --website. >> so that way, on paypal's end, it looks like you may be purchasing anything from motorcycles or beekeeping lessons or rollerblade lessons. and so now we got to a paypal screen. but we can see down here it says, "cancel and return to innernookdesigns.motorcycles." >> so that's what paypal is being told is the website that's asking for the, the charge. >> yes. >> paypal told us it banned clothoff from its platforms a year ago and shuts down the accounts for these redirect sites when it finds them. the problem is clothoff often just creates new ones. and that's not the only deception it relies on. its website lists a name, grupo digital, with an address in buenos aires, argentina,
7:31 pm
implying that's where clothoff is based, but, when we sent our cameras, there was no grupo digital there. it turned out to be the office of a youtube channel that covers politics. and, when we knocked on the door, the employee who answered said she never heard of clothoff. clothoff also made up a fake ceo, according to kolina koltai, complete with what she says is an a.i.-generated headshot. >> there is a really inherent shadiness is happening. they're not being transparent about who owns it. they're obviously trying to mask their payments. but you look at the sophistication of these really large sites, it's completely different than say some guy in a basement that set up a site that he's trying to do it on his own. when these sites launched, and the way that they've been developing and going this past year, it is not someone's first rodeo. it's not the first time they set up a complex network. >> clothoff claims on its website that “processing of minors is impossible.” we emailed what the site says is a
7:32 pm
press contact, asking for any evidence of that and to respond to a number of other questions. we didn't hear back. >> a lot of people might say, "well, these images are fake." but we know victims will but we know victims will suffer humiliation. they'll suffer-- you know, mental health distress and-- and reputational harm. in a school setting it's really amplified, because one of their peers has created this imagery. so there's a loss of confidence. a loss of trust. >> yiota souras is chief legal officer at the national center for missing and exploited children. her organization regularly works with tech companies to flag inappropriate content on their sites. >> in at least three cases, snapchat was reportedly used to circulate these photos. in one instance, a parent told us that it took more than eight months to get the accounts that had shared the images taken down. >> their responsiveness to, to victims, that is a recurring problem that we see across tech companies-- >> so it's not as, it's not as easy as a parent --
7:33 pm
>> no. >> --sending a note through snapchat, "hey, this is happening. my child has been exploited." >> no. it's, it's entirely unclear why it is not a faster process. we can actually notify tech companies as well and ask them to take that content down. >> and in your experience do they? >> much faster than when an individual calls. yes, that isn't the way it should be. right? i mean, a parent whose child has exploitative or child pornography images online should not have to rely on reaching out to a third party,and having them call the tech company. the tech company should be assuming responsibility immediately to remove that content. >> why are they not doing that? >> because i do not think there are ramifications to them not doing so. >> social media companies are shielded from lawsuits involving photos someone posts online due to what yiota souras considers an outdated law. >> under section 230 of the communications decency act, a law from 1996, so very different world back then. online platforms have near
7:34 pm
complete immunity for any liability arising from content that a user puts on their system. the section 230 protection is really what allows this very loose ecosystem to exist in terms of nudify apps and websites that cause harm to children. >> we asked snapchat about that parent who told us the company didn't respond to her for eight months. a snapchat spokesperson told us they've been unable to locate her request and said in part, “we have efficient mechanisms for reporting this kind of content” and added “we have a zero-tolerance policy for such content” and “act quickly to address it once reported.” a.i. nudes of minors are illegal under federal child pornography laws, according to the department of justice, if they depict what's defined as “sexually explicit conduct.” but souras is concerned some images created by nudify sites may not meet that definition. >> there is this gap in the law around a nudify app that desperately needs to be shut.
7:35 pm
>> what are the gaps in the law? >> currently, a nude image of a child that does not include sexually explicit conduct is not illegal. and that is a serious gap that exists for real children and that exists certainly for images of nude children that are created by a nudify app. >> send a clear message that what the boys had done -- >> in the year since francesca mani found out she was targeted, she and her mom have urged schools to implement policies around a.i. and worked with members of congress to try and pass a number of federal bills. >> the take it down act does two things. >> the take it down act, co-sponsored by senators ted cruz and amy klobuchar, made it through the senate this month and is now awaiting a vote in the house. it would create criminal penalties for sharing a.i. nudes and require social media companies to take photos down within 48 hours of getting a request. >> schools don't really know how to address this. police in many cases don't do much at this stage.
7:36 pm
and the sites are making, i presume, millions of dollars off this. so can it be fixed? >> absolutely. if we have the appropriate laws, we will have the criminal consequences, first of all to deter offenders. and then they'll be held liable if they are still using these apps. we would have civil remedies for victims. schools would have protocols. investigators and law enforcement would have roadmaps on how to investigate. what charges to bring. but we're a long way from that. we just need the laws in place. all the rest will come from that. [stopwatch ticking]
7:37 pm
alright, we got your home and auto bundled and you saved hundreds. oh, that's nice, with the economy and all. what's the economy? [chuckling] where do we start? what isn't the economy? yes. [ laughter ] uh, it's -- it's so many thing. right. look, all you really need to know is that progressive can save you money without sacrificing quality coverage. you follow? i'll just look it up. hmm. that went well.
7:38 pm
when you live with diabetes, progress is... having your coffee like you like it without an audience. ♪♪ [silence] the freestyle libre 3 plus sensor tracks your glucose in real time so everyone else doesn't have to, and over time it can help lower your a1c confident choices for more control of your life. this is progress. learn more and try for free at freestylelibre.us ♪♪
7:39 pm
it is inevitable. chloe! hey dad. they will grow up. [cheering] silly face, ready? discover who they are. [playing music] what they want from this world. and how they will make it better. and while parenting has changed, how much you care has not. that's why instagram is introducing teen accounts. automatic protections for who can contact them and the content they can see. ♪♪ san francisco ballet's nutcracker, a cherished tradition set in 1915 san francisco. delight in a fun-filled holiday experience.
7:40 pm
♪♪ tickets on sale now at sfballet.org [stopwatch ticking] in greek mythology, hermes, the son of zeus was imagined with winged sandals and a winged hat, symbols of his celebrated speed. today, the french fashion house hermès that shares his name is also known for its accessories, elegant scarves, ties and handbags, all meticulously made, but at a glacial pace. it can take years for monied customers to get their hands on
7:41 pm
certain hermès handbags, a process steeped in more mythology than even the greeks could've imagined. the craft and culture behind the brand has been preserved for nearly 200 years by one family and is seldom seen by outsiders. but this spring, we were invited to paris to spend some time behind the silk curtains of the house of hermès. on a rainy afternoon, we watched as pierre-alexis dumas, the artistic director of hermès, turned his discerning eye to dozens of potential scarf designs. colors and patterns displayed on what looked like the world's chicest clothesline. hermès scarves are screened and stitched by hand. some designs two years in the making. the only part of the process that happens quickly is this. dumas chose the colors for next season's scarves in less than an hour. >> i'm a happy man. bravo!
7:42 pm
>> merci! pierre-alexis. >> et voila. look at the disaster, a mountain of hope reduced to ashes. >> the house of hermès wasn't built on silk but rather, saddles. in 1837, thierry hermès began selling bespoke harnesses in paris. that led to luggage and eventually handbags. more than a century later, hermès is a more than $200 billion dollar luxury brand with a catalog that includes everything from ready-to-wear to jewelry and furniture. pierre-alexis dumas is the sixth generation of his family to take the reins. >> i think it's a wonderful way to enter the store. >> he took us through a tunnel of orange boxes into 24 faubourg in paris, hermès flagship and heart for more than a century. >> my grandfather worked here, and then my father worked here. when i was a child, his office, just on the first floor. now it's the jewelry section.
7:43 pm
>> the store is like the louvre of luxury goods, complete with reminders to look but don't touch. the brand's masterpieces include this $48,000 purse. and, if you have money left over, this $272,000 pool table. >> do you ever make a decision based on cost? budget? like, "this will be less expensive if we do it this way." >> i can't work like that. i've always heard that hermès is very costly. it's not expensive. it's costly. >> what's the difference? >> the cost is the actual price of making an object properly with the required level of attention so that you have an object of quality. expensive is a product, which is not delivering what it's supposed to deliver, but you've paid quite a large amount of money for it, and then it betrays you. that's expensive.
7:44 pm
>> a distinctly french philosophy stitched into the dna of hermès. dumas says the company has never had a marketing department. its allure, he says, comes from a century of superb craftsmanship and serendipity. take this trapezoid-shaped purse. in 1935, dumas' grandfather designed the bag. it wasn't a hit. but, as legend has it, 20 years later, an expecting grace kelly used the bag to hide her belly from peering paparazzi. soon women flooded hermès, asking for what was eventually renamed the kelly bag. hermès scarves have been favored by american royalty and actual royalty for decades. the kind of product placement money can't buy. even the brand's famous citrus-colored boxes, a color the company trademarked in the u.s., was a happy accident of the 1940's. >> in 1946, there was shortage of everything. and, when my great uncle went to
7:45 pm
see his supplier of paper, manufacturing boxes, the supplier said, "i'm sorry, we don't have that beige paper anymore." >> because of the war? >> yeah, because of the war and short supplies. and he said, "i only have that stock of that roll of orange paper that nobody wants." >> eyes light up when they see that orange. >> serendipity. >> and it was serendipity that led to the piece de resistance at hermès, “the birkin,” designed in 1984 by dumas' father after he was seated next to british actress jane birkin on a flight to london. >> and she told him, "well, let me tell you, i'm not happy about my bag. i want something more loose with bigger handles, and ease and, and always open when i carry it." and, as she was talking, my father was very good at sketching. >> he sketched it right there in that moment? >> yeah. but just an idea, you know? "a bit something like that?" and she said, "yeah. that would
7:46 pm
be great.” >> it was. today, the birkin is the most coveted and costly handbag in the world. a birkin retails around $9,000 and at auction can fetch upwards of hundreds of thousands of dollars. but here is the surreal twist of hermès exclusivity. even if you can afford to buy a birkin bag chances are you can't. the stores typically don't have any to sell. dumas says hermès simply can't keep up with demand. >> if somebody wants the bag, how do they get the bag? >> well, you have to walk into an hermès store, and uh, you have to be patient. >> but you know the world we live in, right? you know that if somebody's, has the funds and they want the bag, they want the bag now. >> yes. um, i have children, too. and i have desires, too. but i'm saying it's a long process. you go to a store. you get an appointment. you meet a salesperson. you talk about what you want. it's not available. you'll have to wait. they'll come back to you. it takes a long time. eventually, it's gonna happen.
7:47 pm
>> store managers act as gatekeepers for disciples of the brand. there are stories of years-long waiting lists for bags and waiting lists to get on the waiting list. along with whispers from wall street that the company is brilliantly gaming the customer. >> hermès has been accused of, you know, creating this artificial scarcity to pump up demand. how do you respond to that? >> it makes me smile that this is a diabolical marketing idea that can only come out of people obsessed with marketing. but we don't have a marketing department at hermès. so first of all, when i heard that, i was like, "what? oh. okay, i get it. yeah, well, no." whatever we have, we put on the shelf, and it goes. >> there's not a room where you guys are holding all the bags back and saying, "let's see what happens." >> maybe we should.
7:48 pm
>> the simple truth, dumas says, is that hermès doesn't have enough artisans to build the bags, which for a century he says have been made from start to finish by a single craftsman. >> so i always like to say that hermès is an old lady with startup issues, cause we've grown so fast in such a small period. how can you grow so fast without changing what makes you strong? >> how can you grow so fast without changing your values? >> by training people. training a lot of people. for a profession which will be a life profession. they will finish their career at hermès. >> in 2021, the house opened a training center in leatherwork where 400 graduates a year are schooled in the art of “savoir-faire” or know-how of making things by hand. that includes mastering hermès' signature “saddle stitch.” >> when you have a carriage which is pulled by five horses, you
7:49 pm
better make sure that all the equipment you're using is going to be strong. so saddle stitching techniques were not about trying to be hidden. they were about being strong and functional. >> today, it is a hallmark of the hermès bags. >> and here is a stitch. >> dumas learned to saddle stitch as a boy, upstairs at the faubourg, in the workshop where they still build saddles today. he thought it was the perfect place for a lesson. >> you're gonna hold by applying a gentle pressure with your legs. >> with my thighs. >> yes, with your thighs. you're gonna be able to hold it, that little piece of leather, so that your hands are free to stitch. >> okay. >> with needles in both hands, you're supposed to pull a strong linen thread coated in beeswax into precise loops. >> so i have to have the hands of a heart surgeon and the thighs of a professional wrestler, right? >> that's a very extreme, but, yes, if you manage to do that, you got a job.
7:50 pm
>> hermès says the criss cross of needles that make the knot can't be replicated by a machine and can take years to master. but those who do, are typically offered positions at one of 23 leather workshops that hermès has built in villages and towns all over france. this is one of them, in tournes, a three-hour drive from paris in the french countryside. the workshop is quiet. there is no jamming of sewing machines, just artisans performing a silent dance with dueling needles. the morning we visited, we met amandine and watched as she put the finishing touches on a kelly, the most difficult bag to build. it starts with 30 distinct cuts of leather and can take 20 hours to complete, four hours for just the handle. there are no manuals or cheat sheets. artisans rely on their training and muscle memory to make every bag. >> which bags do you know how to
7:51 pm
make? >> le kelly, le birkin, le lindy, uh le jypsiere, le shoulder. >> that you've memorized. >> she told us she started making bags at hermès 15 years ago and went through two years of training. >> so you're able to talk to me and do a saddle stitch at the same time. >> oui. c'est possible. >> no one seems to be rushing at the workshop. the pace is leisurely. no looming clocks or quotas. just the slow pursuit of perfection. and when the bag is completed -- >> do you have a special stamp you put in the bag? >> "yes, we do sign our bags." >> yes, we do, she said, but it's a secret. a secret because that hidden mark of the artisan is how hermès bags are authenticated. by creating their own pipeline of craftsmen, hermès says they have been able to produce more of their coveted handbags than ever. although, they won't disclose the exact number. that, too, is a secret.
7:52 pm
this year, some customers were so exasperated by all the mystery and their years-long odyssey to secure a birkin they've sued hermès. pierre-alexis dumas says building something timeless takes time. he urged patience, while nearly losing it with us. >> if i went to the mercedes dealership and i said, "i would like that car." and they said, "okay, you're gonna have to wait five years," they'd be out of business. >> but you're talking about industrial production. you're applying your thinking structure of industrial production to craft. we're about craft. we're not machines. and we are not compromising on the quality of the way we make the bags. so if the craftsperson is not at the level, his or her bag would not go into the store. >> even if they've invested that 20 or 30 hours making it? >> yeah. >> and there's no way of speeding it up and keeping quality.
7:53 pm
>> well, speed is the structuring value of the 20th century. we went from horse carriages to the internet. are we going to be so obsessed with speed and immediate satisfaction? maybe not? maybe there is another form of relation to the world, which is linked to patience, to taking the time of making things right. you cannot compress time, at one point, without compromising on quality. [stopwatch ticking] how hermes create thes one kind products from leftover products at "60 minutes" overtime. with nurtec odt, i found relief. nurtec odt can provide relief in two hours which can last up to two days when used...
7:54 pm
...for the acute treatment of migraine with... ...or without aura in adults. to those with migraine... ...i see you. don't take if allergic to nurtec odt. allergic reactions can occur even days after use, like trouble breathing and rash. get help if you have trouble breathing, swelling of the face, mouth, tongue, or throat. common side effect is nausea. it's time we all shine. talk to a doctor to see if nurtec is right for you. (vo) sail through the heart of historic cities and unforgettable scenery with viking. unpack once and get closer to iconic landmarks, local life and cultural treasures. because when you experience europe on a viking longship, you'll spend less time getting there and more time being there. viking. exploring the world in comfort.
7:57 pm
7:58 pm
white house staff, fbi agents, cia & military officers and their families. last week, the house intelligence committee published the results of its new investigation that indicates many of the havana syndrome cases were attacks committed by a foreign adversary. that contradicts what the intelligence community, led by the cia, has been saying for years. the congressional report went further, accusing the intelligence community of obstructing its investigation. the report also referenced our story, targeting americans, when military investigator greg edgreen said he had seen evidence of who was behind havana syndrome. >> are we being attacked? >> my personal opinion, yes. >> by whom? >> russia. >> i'm lesley stahl. we'll be back next week with another edition of 60 minutes.
7:59 pm
sfoich sfoich when you hit 65, your risk of hospitalization from flu and covid goes up. last year, one million people 65 and older were hospitalized from those viruses. so update your vaccines and keep doing you. this week on chewy, shop and get a $30 egift card to use on treats they want, toys they love or food they devour. at prices everyone feels jolly about. for low prices for holidays with pets, there's chewy.
0 Views
IN COLLECTIONS
KPIX (CBS) Television Archive Television Archive News Search Service The Chin Grimes TV News ArchiveUploaded by TV Archive on