tv Dateline NBC NBC February 27, 2016 10:00pm-11:00pm PST
10:00 pm
oning o tope f th.cake i was insulted. >> a tutor and her pipul, ea br akinghell t r.ules whbut s o waintelle g thh?trut e>> wot bneh kwt wha weer we do waing wrs ong. >> he owned me. >> i never have had asuc mh ev ceidenin agaomst s aeones i ha td incahis se. >> i'm lester holt andhi t s is el"dat"ine.
10:01 pm
ge"dan rousleeia".sons i >>t dt idn'haveo tnd e he.er thwi aorttysnet a wa r. y>>'vou geothe tev enid. ce n >>heo tyt jusay sth at. >> theat theer ofhe t rdabsu. i >>t wan k tonow who -- >> dtietec vesseupt. >> i thought ist wa ditisgusng. i ththougt i jwasustea r lly ibhorrhele t t waydrhey d agge fthaty amilugthroe h thmud. >>or nid d t hhere taveo be a insobbwig s.tnes i >>ry'm t tingeo bes hont up herend a so srdipeesfuct l. e>>nve a judge- - >> ist'et gngtiot tlyal o outf co ront l. is>> v oiblyn geed. i >>'min beg tningoos le it a li tt let.bi >> ic vmtiba insh g. >>,not iid dhan't ove t turn in bto aeattl ro,yalela pyed out in public court for allhe t rlwo d. mo>> estion can beh. hig i >>dnt diav't h ge toato th way at o alld r en wthisay. >> we the jury ocon t un--1 >> t' thal s alsihindnoght w. he>> wre a pnersoin begs a story as tedwist andtr sange ass thi
10:02 pm
is th seca, itak mes sense to be oginrin f mdayngorni in ap ril,2013n i c theofity nd gra dsrapimi, igch.an awhenne phoan rg oen thk des of ctdeteive amy y.lowr th waere cs aallm fron a rnattohoey wor rep tted ahat mo otherf ah higoo schl ph soeomor had ssoeen inmethg at thld couben't ee unsn. >> the boy'she motadr h su tespecd mesog,thinnd a had ntake p hishonend a- -au becse it wasenbrok, and hadhe t fo iniormatran trrnsfeed to heanotr p thoneewo vit whawas on p his.hone a >> wndwahat is ont? ,welles bides theod flof o texts an dto phou's yoped exo ct tsee on anyente's phoneas w isth. it was gyrainut b stunmileakab, a nt scalaly cd mawon. oma wlean c marlyoluch thder an th y.e bo ptheho atog lonit weh th mpacconganyit texes mssage ng lo ing,nturge, eabrssthle ,
10:03 pm
nd mith of tee dee.ctiv >>ed immlyiatet iwas entvide that there was aom rcanti la reshtionoiip gngon . >>so,ow h didou yie vw ttha omfr a lel,ga eicthalnd aor m al tpoin of?view bv>> olyioust, i needed to be veinigstedat. >> et dtiec lveryowas w ex enperiinced te matikrs le e th beone hforeower n. sh e's and graid rapols pice ctdete bive,orut fea nrly a dedeca b haseen anessigdo tthe il ch'sdrenss aenessment cters a on fe o five llfue-tim ve inatstigorski wornng o cases in involvexg sualse abuf o ch enildr. f >> iveoppe le,llfue,-tim in a ttownhee sizf o grandap rids stell you mesog,thinsn doe't it? >>eccorrt. >> doou y findha ttis dtipiring? >> ryve. i kthint moseo pwople fuldind it irdispg,itin tmohe auntf o ca weses e havnvto igaestif te o nthise.atur t >> ohis nnedeede to be in igvest natednlot o byseecau of wh heat t dtietecawve s on the ph none,o. w itoras mane tht. tha e thye lawhor wle cald the
10:04 pm
olcathicio d ocesef grandap rids an dd toler hhe t y moungann i qu onesti was atu sdent and star etathlere het ara gndap rids ca ictholce , nter tandomhe wan rk woheed re. e shn' wastus jt any slchoo oyemplee. sh se wa theenstudt's olschooi-appntedut tor. he>> s a wasso pern of thauitory. it as wbv ousiolyn a prinapatopriree onlati.ship nei khew s i wasn her 30s and he s way onl5 1rs yea. old rdrega, lessasit w i anallleg re onlati. ship et>> dveectiry lowt wenr oveo t se hee tbo y's pas.rent h >> tadhey qiouestnedir the son? >> no. mtherothead h qn'tiouestned her sont aall. ini thhek s wasreunsu how t o gbrin it .up sh ene kwha tte h wldou mtos li lykee bng a aryutbo it. >> she wanted somebody to put a st op tt?o i bs>> aeloluth-y, uhuh. t >>heec dettivet weno t olcathenic c htraligh hoscol, an ftd aeeer m wtingthith e mi adranisttorsle puld theou yng ma hen, tn aso orphome,ut o of cl mass,e iddlafwas ooternn. >> t whaelde tu?l yo i >>alnitie ly heddenit tha
10:05 pm
la reshtionipak t inge.plac he saidy theer we ndfrieuts, b nthatngothi had hneapped. >> k youthnew asat wson't . r >>.ight i aw s thet tex meesssag. >> did you explain that to him? >> i did. rideaim hom se othf eex tt ssmeesagnd aha tst'he wne h admitted that there was a sexual relatishon.ip >> iten oft goes that wayit wh a enteerag s,dai decetveti lowry. as anyar pentld wou rsunde,tand st oagesf aldeni w,hich iisn th se car overia sef es orvinteiews fi ynalle gav way toha wt theoy b se temede o seheas tx cruheof t ermatt. >> he ththougha t tthey sdhoul beow alledo tav hhee t tirelaiponshou, yw, knoau becse he m wase aturghenou and they ve lo edacher oth s andho bulde thtogeer. it er's vomy c tmonhathe tyon d't e sems theselve a asic v itimn is th case. >> tshat'he wre illt a gkiets nd s ofgetranes, doitn't ? y >>es. >> nd a nowt iwas tfoime e r th ctdetetoive k talheto t tutor t at cherenteth of e .case
10:06 pm
10:09 pm
i>>no kwou you a d clouendarkheed t o joyf sp iringgrn d anpira, ds mi anchigat, thil apr20 of 13. e thermotha of omsophatore one tof cheits y'stmore pigstusio high schools, catholic central, ha fod d unisthho p otoa n llce e phonsoher d n ha ubeen.sing ulco'tdnus jt t leo.it g ashe w 15. wothe waman s s hir.tuto soand or befnge loec det ativemy
10:10 pm
t ou wwhatoias gn.ng o th cte fat thaadthe wault s fe amalehend tld chie mal'tdidn lyreale makdiany enffero ce t her. >> hi i thenk t are'sbl doue an st idardcin sowhety there ey viewal femnes is thiit sonuati as ctviims, b tut ihink a lot of sa wme aayutbooy bs. th e ere arnscoueeqesnco tisth pe tyre of onlati, shipknyou ow, ev iten wysh bo. ep>> rr:orte r butbeemematr th ri sef es orvinte aiewsnd sh ngiftiri storoes fe m thboy? wh ten dheecetvetiot gim ho t miadtht e ers wamesointhg eebetwemn th a, anr ffai ns coteumma td inuthe t or's gleaming hh-ig crise, ondothe anboy cenounatd thwa it ws heho testar ad itotnd n, her ithatt sn waer't hlt fau. haso wult woe d thr,tutoga abiil y >>e ou'runnot arder , rest ?okay u' yorere f le to.eave ne tedtao alkutbo. >> ka oy. >> ll aig r?ht >> reporr:te w andmshen mo. sin d hear tthatmeext esssage werin tiquesshon, ewe kn t whyhe ctdetewaive ers the. pthat oupilrsf he.
10:11 pm
ou abw?t no o >>kay. 'v weste juom becose clise th ar ye. iei tr hd tohielp anm chisge h fe liun arod. r >>teeporutr: bn whethe bj sut ecrntu tedtho spe ifecs ic tofirheel rioathins wp,chhihe t ctdetefeive aslt win plaly ou edtlinth in raose excy tndts a osphotll, wesu, a serpri. e >> hs callbayou irby gl. cayou imll hy babboy. oudo ynk thit' thaprs apatoprie? o.>> n i scarecho mu h forim. i do. i e adorhim. do i evn't noen katw whsa to y ou ab.t it w >>niho iedtiat it? >> ea i m -n, i--- i ne we ver ac lytual - hadke- line we ver ha x.d se k>> iyonow d u hasex. he d tolhame tt. n i ca treadexhe tsst me.ages it ot's nue a qn stioheof w ther yo ysu gu s hadr ex onot. i twantowo kn i whoatnitit.ed i aswho whked do toato wh? i >>ot'm nwe ans tringhat. n'i doowt knha wyot ur denifi itionens th.
10:12 pm
tdon'no katw whr younidefi tion exof s is. r >>teepor lr: ae ittl toclinuenesq't isn it? >> ou i wgrld aitee wath th. >> or rep dter:heid sl telyou th haen wr t henidefi wtionas? n >>o. sh dee ene d thrvinteiew. >> or rep tter:wahat ?s it or>> c.rect >> or rep tter:ethe dveecti co canfisabted iby'se.phon an ted laatr th, daydithe e oces ofra gndid rapirs fered hhe as r b jo tas a.utor e shtowas y ld bcepolier ord not to e havcoany t ntacsowhat ever th wi y the moungan. te dee ctivielowrti con hnueder in igvestn atiobeand lforeong s waoaappr bchedhey otopr pele at s thel choongsayiy thehad nc co aerns mbout ss.onim for a while. om>> s te ofeahe ts cher hfelter ha be wviornaas iprppro iate ndaroue somr otheenstudts. r >>teeporo r: s dthentietecve lo swriet oughthout otose her st tsuden h and seardhiometng el ayse me havenhapped. me sog thin awithernothng you man. t >> wherenoas a btherhooy w id sare the a wascin in identn lithe y brare wher wtheyere intalkheg, trey wert fli ing,
10:13 pm
heand se kisr.d he ep>> rr:orte d andheid sl tel tohim p, stoaw go thay, s is i prinapatoprie? e >> hridescitbed a as t shor , kissheand d sai tthathat ca han't appen.gain shand yse sa, , noanit c't. d an wthatheas t o ende f th y.stor r>>orep ater:ves inatstigors g duepde, erotanr hetedeivcte jo edinhe tas ce. da ilve gcalem illedr n fohis un y cannitabil py to alumbl cel ph foone mor alnyst ag thin it's deverone. bbon amoy siipn's , hone wthatas no et anthasy toing do. s >>adhe hse erastd moth of e te esxt ms sageeebetwr n heand th cte vianim, wad i les ab to re r cove omanyemf th. onwe dno't kw w ho tmany here re we. webut r diderecovus tho aandsnd sathouofnds t texagmesses. >> or rep tter:anhousds? an isd thma is alterit thahad be enra esed, material she chose e to?rase c>>orrect. >> reporter: wt had diatthmp ily to ou y? >> he sas wid hg in.it sh kne iewwat nos sot thmeg in wshe wouldanteo p tpleeeo s, d anheso set delt.ed i
10:14 pm
an r otheolschor. yea by abed movk bacerto hen parts' ac pl te, aouwo-hivr drome fr d grandsrapi. ersumme. cam d an tthenethe dveecti ovdisc teredhehat -cr noctonta or wader esn'th nougeeto kbyp ab mo siayn awm froteher edenag ve lor. he>> set tweimed h g andhiave m th foe iniormat hn ono ow t nt coheact car bei use hehad r on phe. so co he 'tuldnl calanher e ymor exor tr t heoranyme. sh d e hagechanond phmbe nuers. t bueh some ow habwas o le t ile-ma a heralnd cr.l he r >>teeporndr: ale at onast ce they managedo tetmen irspe.on in ac f ht,wae ves uryetpst a inbeldg toco he 'tuldn h seeer ag rain,?ight es>> y. w hen as i.love >> or rep iter:ctn fa c, heedreat a e-new amailntccou. jo dcsetdhl sejoazdi.27 e thotph aos dndlaectiras on of erevstlag invelole fbew eetwn
10:15 pm
in tufaioatn. in ar e alyusug tt,eehron ms th teafthr ree tilashon cipe am to light,bi a sgail dimon froverom he rer pa hnts' tousee o th gym, an erd ths e wapothe clicear. wthiseras h s mughot. washe ars chwiged evth s eral co ountsimf cr sinall exua co t nducacand incostmig a nor imfor l moraospurpbues, e t sh msoonbaade il. >> llroing. on woe, tre, the -- r >>teeporndr: a t ashee casas w be ing prerepagad ainst herk bac g inrand ra,pids she sowat dn wi sth uo t shaay tt ethverying we b've teen aoldbouthi ts also-cled actechher/ lildove st waory l s althtogeroer wng. i >>d reapothe rlicet,epor too. iwhend reai it, lwas, oike,h, ah yee , shuiis glty. .true >> reporter: this wanos e lov y,stord saiaiabigmol sin. . no re moe liknia tmghare. > >>ngcomi-- up te afhor scbeol, chindd lose s.door >> di he ldn'tliook ke a ea15-yd r-olboy.
10:19 pm
bo boy. th asis w t notorhe s t of e placlepeop o are aftenterresd, t nog amonfithe igne bes hom and pa exensivns lawf ora g bndncla, michigan. he thr fa ser assucceful at eytorn. thboar pents graduates of notre dame. t bu ithisers whe e shpuwas lled er ovre, ar astedhand c wrgedith cr aliminua sexndl cofouct r
10:20 pm
-1thenar5-ye c-oldliathoc nt cehiral sghl chool pupiand wh iere,ven no 2mber s014,athe s wdownusith th in mie faly li rvingoom. ho esw dofe it o el toube yht rig now? el>> wodl, tt'ay iars scy ca bethuse iiss the first time m i'insharisg thh witneanyo ot thher y an maptheranist d my la s,wyerpa my s.rent i efeelermpowo ed tt do i na filly. bi'vehoeen g ldino on torit f l soong. >> or rep hter:ngoldito on t wha tlexacy? , well sabby timonusold t tha ytever yhinge ou'vd heart abou r helareontiipshit wthh yoe g un isman ie a lpe peredtuathi by s mi fandly arz oveusealo ctdete.ives i >>hat's ecrd b tauseayhe w 's itng beitr por iayed sn mytory 'sthatea alreedy bldn toth by em o is sthnot rse pe aon im. r >>teeporbbr: asty's ory?
10:21 pm
de igreenca acdemi viad,sing she mo tvedrao gnd rsapid and was of dfere ait posion inha tt very iaspec bltyy theat ccholi oc diese. bu ont soe , sh, saidwashe sn't ucso mvih ad asingtos tu ring etathlt es acatwo ictholh hig olschos. ofone m thethwas oyat b s whohe id sa s wasgltrugwiing 1th a.7 gr poade avint e.erag s soelhe hhiped mm asasuch she ul coftd, oaten le intohe t en evgsinas, he sai sshd die d wi ath hll serdetus.nt enthsa, aidy,bbt is wanujay ar , 2013thand cie in odentreccurd. th ine thatg thrt stat ed iall. h itneappehed, sd, saith at e d en gof a sroup studyonessi. h >>ite wanted uveil ee ryon le anft, end thwa he as so ngry ithatn' didvet gi a himny at iotenthan, twat i hsn'tngelpi him. an atd thid i dcan't bore aut hi m. an wd ias like,t' thas ap sla in th eac feme to au bec'vse inee do ytever fhingouor y. he pp slay ed m afaceaind so,d, n at th s's ainlap f theace. r >>teeporair: wmit a .nute lahe s yppedfaour ce? >> pp slay ed m.face thno, aat'sp slahein te. fac
10:22 pm
yo ulu cot d gekihim ockedf ut o olscho t forhat. b >> dut it idn' twanto. he t wascahe st riesonpers iv ale. r>>teeporher: tri scapeest rson al ive? ab imby sason wli tels ng u thsomeshing d e har neve ttoldhe ctdete iivestinvesnggatis thi ncaseveor eien frornds il famy at t theshime ide sawa it s in go.g on apthe ripropreate sesponld wou ha eeve bmen ime diatitand ld wou vebe or. me i hean, av'd htoe to a ne mesow.ho weyou here t i onearn chge. yodid t u no afeel ys ifouou cld hado tt? y? wh h >>dne diar't c he ift e goin tr e.oubl s hemehut n. dow >> reporte ar: anderft? sabbyshaid cae beerme tedrifi of b thethig ac letig younman al y read sovereeix fd t anlynear 20 un0 pohods theugh j wasust 15 . sowhy gh frid tene tof ageeenad y? bo we ,llhe s idsa,ar ptth of e re wasonas shead h been ati vicm
10:23 pm
ba n ck i w2007shhen s e wa wo g rkin rat al etaie storin ch o icaghaand bod a enyfrid, om wh c sheedlaim a wasvebusi. >> en i wtot in a hismepartnt, an sad i thid, snis ioi't go ng t rk wo. d an'sthatn wheoshe ls t himind on an me amd slmemed th to e ou grnd. r >>teeporo r: dreyou ermemb wh ouat yt fel?like >> ho i t iught g was toinge.o di olhe t td mekeo tala my st br , eath hthats e wag gointo ki e.ll m wa i uss j stoi' -- mlike,s thi is i how'moi gong t die? i , meanoui thheght g was oing nato syp mck ne. 'sthatt wha itel fket liwa he s yi tro ng tdo. r>>orep ater:sabby heid s ran hefor fer lin. the r heerfathe , thrnattoey, pe dersuar d heo to gheto t li pondce an thetueven tallyo ge tht risesaitrngnier ord. ghthoun soor afte, thatshe tr aied,stgain j the'sudge sh witoes, o undafit, traidhe ma uln wondd fi a outurnd hr,t he sashe id. inthe ntcideng chaered he, lif asaidbby. >> ac i pmyked ff stuan up d mo baved omck h ae atikge l e 27
10:24 pm
d anjothe lob i waved res fover ne go. >> reporter: still bothers you to hi t ankutboha tt. wa es hechver d arge with an ngythi? n>>o. >> or rep ater:y,nywat thay,stor asaid cbby, eouldinxpla s whyhe dn diep't rheort unr youdg stent atat cc holiracentghl hin, whe clher taim,oyhe bpp slaered h. whnor acen, incord hg toheer, al std ker hed anowsh uedatp st buars ckd anheotplr esacea nr r heghhiis-rcoe o ndand made her ve gi t himeyhe khe to r ar apt.tmen ti intemidar d heghenou l sheet gehim ntt coofrol p her ahonend u heitsed se to exnd to ts ther fr ndies. he ve e tnried tnto cowhrol eo sh d coulsee,he s idsa, e wvenhen e sh owentf ut o.town on ee thrar sepocate oncasihes, s msclai s, hellexuasay asd ulte her. yo owu knt that firs itime f he pe rau,d yo r the tight thingo do is go to th to lie poce. he e 'd bgechard. w >>ouho wld believe that?
10:25 pm
o whoiis go ng tevbeliate th? r>>orepr:teha tlit erng pietoho bothe moy's fther, oundit sn wa c't aonome-e , sh.said phthe waoto kes ta n in -dselfseefen. it w hasryer c h forelp. >> as i wpon't .sing s i wadoinatg whwa he mntede to . do i 'twasnau ass tltednihat ght be e causd i di.that ep>> rr:orte y didveou ever ha ns coalensu w sexhiith m? n >>ever. >> ep rteorher: tof proe , sh reoffed? e on.text th sme g okin sgun,lahe c.imed e onofout ll, wetu, ac ally ou ths sandppof atlarenviy long d, an flyrankpl, ex ticit.exts th neis oou, thisgh, ex so itplic we an c s'tw hou yoe tholwhtee xt itbut lu inca des tlinehat su tsggesex s. adreg in pint,arev n per yut ou ro ththugh gaat abain, irby gl. an atd thid, say, abbwh is e y sh d askedethe ivtectate wh her fi deonnitise of s.x wa usbecaoe t abby, it wt asn'sex. it s wasl exuaulassat. >> di he ldn'tliook ke a ea15-yd r-oly.bo he n' didt t ac alikeye 15-ldar-o
10:26 pm
he a wasst moner. >> or rep iter:r n ourvinte iew, ab imby sadon ht jusreoffed a un st dningseefena to gechar of ha svingitex wboh a y. edturnse herrolf frpm petoetrar icto vtim. the question was, wou ildhot ld iupcon t?ur > >>mico ung--p sabby'simonli telexng tt ss me tagesr o hendfries. >> on i dar't c he if20e's or 50 . i just need my heart skipping. >> h andorer fstmer t udenlltes al l.
10:30 pm
doin wag wrons g. > >>heas tsh sunfaine anded d stwen erchmianiget sedtlnt ia o telaal f il,apt arpe ted chease ai agabnst l igain simohewas aded to a courtroom. d an asoet vanerro pcuser to na hemed brlen aninkm was gnassiheed te. cas asit wbe to l herbeast fore rereti.ment d she' amadeee cart r ouof ecprosg utincrsex .imes yo au go rftertsapis a andrsbuse ehon bofalf ti vicanms, u d yo ahaveua sit wtion there'shere a pe yrsone ou'recprosg utinwho msclai i shee s thimvict. y >>es.
10:31 pm
ercare h, tosoave e meonwawho s preying on a 15-year-old boyor f he n r owifgratioicatrnn tu ou arndnd ae makchthe ild sp reblonsie. st i haill dve acuiffiimlt te piwrapy ng m amindd roun.that r >>teeportir: sinll, ef an fort a to wvoidwahat res sube to a ve ubry p vlic,paery l inful,tria prthe utosec oor'se fficreoffed by abon simle a pala de. d pleatyguilon to une co t of incrimexal scoual t nducand ptacce-y onebeear bhind ars, ic whthh wie timfooff odr go ha be, viord woullyliken meaabby d woulrebe f me inr atteof mo .nths i >>w knos we aama tell reay nt waheed t am tot ccep pthatlea of sofer t tha kthatidid dn't ha o ve thrgo t aoughf ny o.that th mae dandge am har cthat omes om frs thi okindiaf tr al to d, ki j youcaust unn't tadersnd un yotil tu'rekihat d d anreyou' kthat fid'sy.amil >> or rep bter:biut a sgail imon tu trnedeahe dwnl dod. col so eome pprple lyobabug thoht
10:32 pm
ri ght? os>> mopt pele. >> or rep ster:y o whyodid u do it? w>> ihras tneeated d ankestald an sad asd ultescand oaredf ut o inmy mndd, an thehai'd o ve t fopay s r hieqconsesuenc fo r.reve ep>> rr:orteev forecer b hausead e shn takeplthe eaea dbbl, ay ul wo pd bed lace ton sheuaexl of erfendis's lndt, at tha ul wo edn'tgover y. awa n sonoow, u'w yoacre fthing is tr ial. it ot's nng goibe to y, eas is ? it u >>.h-uh ne eaxt y ir --s t waara gue ante th 'dat isi be g ttinhaat tt e tablthfor gianks ivingtof i ok th ale de. anguar.teed sei'd se myr iste jthatgoust t geengad. i' ad ber t heinwedd mg nor atte .what uli co ddn't.o it >> or rep wter:hy? ec>> b hausenee ow.d me ne i teded ao betoble m gety or stt,y ou i andld coulin't ve tlikehat.
10:33 pm
14 20nt, kent couury cosethou in angrrad dspiab, l igain simo reentee d thtrcourtooom ht fig gecharats thor thealeticouly cld pu r t heriin pfoson fer li. an dd to bo soaiy cl tminghat washe e s thimvicta of big, ngstrosi abuoyve b. hito wroch ptoseculer hen in br rkmanedeplio , wh sdoeshe th shink kie's g?ddin w >>thhat ayis mis be pr tiacngci p ay la tin theatheer heof tur absd. r>>teeporbbr: as y waaicertnly t noalsexussly aedault s is,aid th ose prorecut. , thistoshe held ty, jur a wasn emextrinely opappre riat love y storvias eeddencth by e imtestofony y the moung an's ermoth. id>> d e youcover ntnfror you abson thout is? >> i no,n' didt. w >>othy n? ec>> b iausew kneouhe wunld r to her andel tr l heitand wo 'tuldnab be o le txpbe e.osed ashe wly madlo in itve w.h ms n simo hwithhois weale hndrt a
10:34 pm
ep>> rr:orte l thes aw i luabso ctely, lear tsaidhe os prioecutn. ab bby'sioehavs r wagaillel. th y e bo15was . th e e agonof c wsenta ith ac teisher 18. wh hey, tk,y asld wouy abbn simo ta imke hda on ipy tr cs togohica and e notr, damee wher pthishoto s wan takeheof tli smioung cple, if f notovor le? it a wastu disg rbiny,story the sa id. th olis trod thabugh tby'sext me esssag. e thecpros cutord allebyone one by abri's f aendsadnd hm theread me esssagy abb tsenthem re tiflechong tdsusanot of her xt teats thnd souered vchy mu ke liom a wn an i wlovea ith boy. a >>hall tttt maisers t thaour he arts s areinkippatg bes. l alnei .ed n'i doret caf i'she0 2 5or0. i njustmyeed rt heapp ski ing, an atd thll's ais it ng doih wit th oyis bre, pasenthehis, cld. i >>cot's nincerheng ty onl
10:35 pm
15 r--yeaold. i bwillbee uptaat sg rtinnow. oudo yy denivrecething exat tt? n >>o. >> t theafext thter cte piofure hi ces fad, sais thiy is md chil haor tmyt's ld chime, sog thin li hake tt. >> ev i naver hd e haucas mh ev ceidenin agaomst s aeones i ha td incahis se. r.neve e shtehad sxtednyo mapl peoe gibragbong aerut hpp inaiaroprte tirelaiponshh wit cthis ahildnd ow knthing t at iwrwas ong, intellm g hi ithats t wag.wron c we kan'tdoeep thing is. uli co td goilo ja. ep>> rr:orten theyothe maung n ok to s the.tand en sprtt pa fs ofdaour heys tre de intail ag anr ffai hthatide sa lastwoed tth mons. 'r wet e noinshows g hi ofacen me caofra, rs coue. >> bo we neth katw whwe we re do waing ons wrg. >> or rep tter:rohe ptosecuokr to hi rom thhuugh dsndree mors.text thall woose ofrds gi lonng eebetwscn a thool autor bnd aoy o tog youn tevenivo dre. >> s she iays,d neeinyou my
10:36 pm
hais tght rit? es>> y. o >> ssashe - ys -s she'intellg shyou ede neu s yoerin h n bedow shand s e'ingotog om cane pid ck u yoasup blyicalgh, rit? y >>es. r >>teeporper: od n an cshutase, id sa p thecurosetor. >> t themeext esssag t arehe tr uth. th e ey'rcrnot d eate awithny ot inher ttenttohan mu comtenica wh taty hentwao tmmcoicune atat the time. the text messages e are thuttrh. >> or rep nter:afow, thter at anavalofche de eviagnce t ains aher,ilbigaon sim a was tbouto ttellurhe je y thy stortoshe ld buus, ist the timd she'be edseatos acroms frro a ptosecur wh ulo co wdn'tfoait r r he turn twithefhe dntenda. > >>mico ung--p te s.ar >> t i'mg ryine to bsthone up he ndre as it'isso decresp.tful >> f andorirewks. y >>noou khew, wu'n yon re ithis si iotuatn -- s >>tiituaf on og beinovin le th wi5- a 1-oyearld? >> i wasn't in love with him. w >>ngantiha to exve sh wita
10:40 pm
'- its wokayyohen eu se mesog thinerdiff ent htoquave onesti s. goa ueod qn stio gis a reatar st ut tostnderngandi . ketait a ltitle me ofout r you day torn leaet som nhing ew absoout e meon.else ale l thtegreadvst areentu s stwiart th ntan itieresueng qn.stio three mo k you now. prosecutors halad utid o th caeir n se itothe t rrenof te esxt ms.sage mna daining medictf nt oa dabounrory-cg ssin alover ffai eebetwenn thye-33-ldar-oga abiil mo sid n anthher 5-en-1-oyearld l.pupi t buabnow dby'sseefen o setut t tothurn ore st iy oneats hd. >> it's not a veloto s.ry
10:41 pm
>> ep rteor dr:enef aseortty ne mi l chaeeymanld toljuthe ry athatwabby e s thceinnoarnt pty re hevi, a hctimuneld thder e um th ab oftr conngolli, da oungeruns yon g macowho uld sn t ap amoany .ment >> yo in inur mned, och punld cou .kill d anomno whoan sevuld aver he to hrgo t woughshhat nte we ro thugh. evthe ceidenl wil tshowthhat is un yolag tdyt ham i' psoudrof o inis f sallyintand ag upstgain buthe lly. r>>orepr:teow hun to tadersnd th yce psgyholool invved? dethe e fensedcallex an opertn domestic violence. t >>mahe ie ge w ohavee f th enviolsece u dd intiomesc vi ceolends tenbe to b the lack aneye e d thenbroke. bon e thitreal ty ofiohe ve lencin us abreive onlatis shiphais tt it nd te bs tow e lol,levehe puss, ov shgres, babs,avut hthing e mu cuvelatiec effert ove timthat a isigs frinhten sg ase ever
10:42 pm
r>>orepr:teir f asty bbd ha to ivsurv ae an obusel rdea ibackn ch o,icagd saidethe e.fens athene t tholschoe , thboy relaunched the fear by slapping byab f'se acteafthr r eiudsty se n ssio nthat.ight so or attmaney lnleyheauncd a ys dag -lons-crosinexamioatofn th une yon.g ma he ie den ed heslver d appe abby ce exospt py siblfuplaydully ring x. se t bu tthen fhereweolloe d on saaccu ation afterernoth. i >>iss thle whong thit thayou di md toims. so on scoyou beuld pu po tlar,y o sa gi'veheot t hot tu tor? at thot's nt whadiyou d? n >>o. >> or rep tter:efhe d senseaid yothe maung ann chhiged ors sty se l veras time iand,ctn fa , he had. in f his iirstvinteritew wh cepoli s, heheaid ce forbyd ab to e havwisex imth h t and wice sa e id ha put togun h heread. >> t youdeold ivtectwre loie th ouat ynt poi ged ao un ther head and told her that i would
10:43 pm
back? es>> y. ep>> rr:orteec det ltivee owriat th mee tin' didlit beeve it for a minute. la ster,enure , oughyothe ung ma can re.nted id sa tt hainputtgug a hn toer ad heme comasnt w e hist fforto ep key abb gfromngettio int ou trbuble tht fee deatnse eytorn at fl a-outedccus y the moungan of ua sexsal asult. ou>> yce forurd yo oself.n ms n simohein t o care n th o24thf ap dril,ouid y? not >> i no, n didot. >> you didn't graber hy be th ha ndir a h puteaer htod inr you anlap d -- o.>> n ep>> rr:orteal finhely ten defsf co ntnfroimed hh wit iwhatidt sa prwas ofoof ua sexsal as ult, wh t at iedcall s thengmoki gun .text e th yone,l ou'lllrecaic, whh ea clsurly teggesx d setahad ken pl ace. t inhe texthe t boy ogapol,izes pr esomis n to peverouut y ro ththugh gaat abain, irby gl. f >> oirstf dall,ouid yd sen tthatmeext e?ssag >> . yes an>> c e youinxplath to rye ju
10:44 pm
>> er nevng doith anyaging inain th r.e ca t'>> iurs yoti tes tmonythhat at mtextgeessaon is ecly b iauset s wacounormfbltaine he tar c? >> . yes i >>s t waencons bsualenetwe you tw o? >> ea yh. >> reporter: when he wasin flyal weallo ld to teavetahe sitnd, pe ap taredabhat by's defense and he eer frdedom edpendth on e or ste y shshand one als e wa ab toout l. tel >> we call abigail simon to the stand. r>>orepr:tehe tue qiost n, sp dealite osl thxte tees mgesas ex esprngsier hee danp abd inidg ve loul, woe d th, juryd coulthe ju bery, e lievaiabigmol sin's ai clatm th w she vas am?icti s.>> mon simul, wou d yoe rais yo igur ranht hd. >> 'v youene beth in y erap18for mo nnthscoow, t?rrec es>> y. >> y areeaou ro dy t ytellour y?stor es>> y. at ne ooi pnt i remember thinking ke lis thiy is m rlife nightow. ilikeoi'm dhing tfos a r
10:45 pm
li owke hth is veis essn po?ible m i'his. o he mwnede. o he mwned ue up tntil wodayhen t i go therenao fitelly hall wt ha.ened n he teverhthougou i womld ce up re he t andthell ute trh. t hehthougou i wovld corer f m. hi >> ep rteorf r: osecour , by ta tkingtahe sn nd iowher n de e fenselto thel str y,orbb ay si n moewknhe sas wpe ongni elhers tf upato whld wou , no ub doe t, bntan i ense os crams-exioinat pn bycurosetor n helekmbrinan. quthe onestipu we at tobby fo behere tal tri. prthe utosecs or ig gointo lechalyonge eru evicy why h wato su .nday ac cuse yf ou okiall ofnds in thgs. e arreyou foady atr th? t>> bhet esrtpas icai jun st lltehe tru t.th cai jun bsthoe stne. n'i dovet hare to ermembt whai suwas edppossa to y. n i ca tjustthell ore sty. ep>> rr:orte t buthe os prorecutpi's o onion. f ms n simoclwas frear heom trt sta. y >>noou khew, wu'n yon re ithis atsitu--ion >> s thetiituaf on og beinin lo itve w15h a r--yeaold? i>>n' was lt inwiove imth h. h >>g avinwisex th a
10:46 pm
op>> ne. >> h witeaa grdyt bo? t?righ >> .nope y doouea rthlly think "at,-a" - to>> stop, sp. u yot don'toget t askhe qu onestis. >> n whey i trelto tu l yo thsomeaning u d yo yrolleyour es an ugd laouh ab at it'mnd i yi tro ng tonbe hupest e herand it o 's sesdisrfupectl. t >> mheore she edtalkhe, te mor sh tte ad ackeurme ding cr exoss-atamin--ion >> or rep ster:ashe wul insted th ouat yn' didlit beheeve r. i >> i wastensulatd th she ou thsoght e meond.woul o wh ysaysonou dav't h he toave pr oof? r >>teepor fr:or a portion of o twysdawe it usnt jket lit. tha >> ev i nseer ue d th word "r t.apis" sa i e id hedforcag me t ainsmy wi ll. h>> iave the binder. eehe ktaps s ttings hingashe h e noncvider e fohoas titugh 's fa ct. y >>e ou'vthgot ide ev.ence >> no. n' dott jus say. that us>> jt ain mute. th aingsetre g ttinglyotal cut fon otr conol. i' gim beg nninosto l ae it tt liitle b. y >>avou h pe noemroblki barng ba t ck adome, ? you o.>> n re>> psttty prongn,erson' aret u? yo es>> yte, af mr 18s onthof th y.erap th sis i thest fir t mimeyad d it id sa l at unchtoday, he'ser nev
10:47 pm
ob iojectn. we id dt n'-- j>>t usswaner y oesnor . r>>teeporinr: f, allythe ecpros autor, skedbbif atey's xt agmesseres we e thfocry lpr he shcle meaihyd, wn' dide t shtell faher , theratthe eytorn w whoas ouin citrt wr h hey everanday d edhelp e here scapabthe shuse e id sa s shereuffeard yerls eaier c ingohica. a >>oull y t had wo doalas cl ur yo o dade n the.phon i' inm beatg been. m i'g beind.rape ahe'sye lawr. >> ou yno kitw n's tott hasyea. knyou t'ow it s no ethatasy. >> is it t tha.easy u yoitdid or befe. w >> domeniso th t allimhe te! >> t jusnua mite. ju mst ae.inut ho>> wd tolthyou at? j >>a ust teminu. i >>li've itved . i've lived it. and it is so scary. you can't go to the police right away. an yod knu towt.ha r >>teeporinr: f, allyaiabigl si lemon heft tnd sta. w itheas ty' jurrns tu. wh idat d t you ahinke s th jury we utnt oth at d e enhaof tt ia trl? i >>ri wored. be e causonwe dol't hmed won ac tacounlible e ke wendo m. d we.on't th oat'socur s.iety
10:48 pm
10:49 pm
vethe t.rdic when g you getneerig int netomfrry centundlink asm t privd ane they'r delbothediveron er a supt fi-fasneber twork ctdireyoly to e,ur hom it's zi ama ng. i itins amaz g,t buou tdo y hhinkivis del erys a walelitton flat on that e?st ju --ahye. um ul, pain, i thitk lit's abitle lt more ike,"i amt's "azing! w.oh, wooh m,, mo thatre was gooally d.an thk you.wow. gh [ si s ]fe eel lik lla hoinywood ..sider. ay, ok wi'll iork ont. it ...wm h pris tv gpluserig inteenet sp d enfrom clinktury
10:52 pm
10:53 pm
ot emiol nak.wrec >> am madree foonpers y, ifou wo kiuld sndly atandy nd b ad refring heom tm fore wherit ar stwets, j theury. >> th we rye juth on une co t of on ae ofrg cha ce ofnarimil xu seonal c fductstir degree, we the jury find the defendant ig absiail gumon .ilty sc[ amreg in] >> ep rteor ar:s bby'ermoth and ersisted cri i outgen and r an isanguh. th rye jut jus'tdidnie belve he r. o>>thn che oargecof acg stina ch foild mor impural esrpos , we th rye jud findethe anfendt ab l igain simotyguil. r >>teeporn r: oonand we it nt. >> lt guiy. r>>orepr:teou fgur tyil ve icrd.ts acquitted on a fifth. minutes later abigail simon went ctdireo ly t.jail ou>> y s areono wrg. >> or rep oter:deutsi the ur com,trooen defttse ay orne mi aechmal eynlpo s.ke w >>yoere rpu sud risehaby wt ha ienedern the? s >>edhock. oc shanked vad deedstat. ve isry dinappointed j thes ury'
10:54 pm
sh ate's ce pea. she already won. e shldtoer hto s.ry sh cee far d heseaccur. noand ibodyins go hg toheurt r ag ain. r >>teeporutr: ber aftte lisning to d theseefenem atto pt tt pain ab s by avithe , ctimd grandsrapi cepoliec det dtivegiave llam llfinalty fee frepeto sisak h nd mi. he>> t are'sel levvi of ctim ba g shinviand bctimnglami and th ngrowis thilyfamit , no only vthism ictithbut mie fandly uer e thovbus nder ar oveovand er. 's itre unpntceden ed i8 my 1 ar yes. ni've severaneen ngythith to at gr deee. ep>> rr:orteet som ghingndot uer syourbikin meg tire the. >> . yes ithis15s a r--yeakiold d. u' yo 3re aar5-ye w-old, oman -y 36olear-mad won. ythat touook advantage of. yoand bu'renglamino -- stt ju inblamm g hiacbut ngcusi o himf ima crate thld cou h putn im i pr fisonheor tt resisof he. lif aoextrarrdinboily inther.g me r >>teeporecr: b, auseaihe sd, ne noth of ide ev, enceonnot e in thugg, sedgestt thabothe y
10:55 pm
us abtoive twardomhe we an h ve lod. >> allis re. ep>> rr:orteen sevks weeer lat, af spter ngendink thainsgivd g an stchribemas bhind oars,erut h nt sengencie camaiabigmol sin si vidibly shminied. en whwa it r s hecechansp to eak, e sh, saidapperh ss noisurpre, e shetregrheted cir de tsiono rn tun dowplthe eaea dicl whh wo liuld hkelymeave meant re mo inthsiln jato in tal. ki g ckinelhersalf refoly, e r th wa e y shitput lf, sey ishl sichooo ng tt fighhefor f rsel errathn thahado ws t wa fbestor r helyfami. 'm>> imu so orch mane th mo reulrsef. n'i doowt kn t howveo lih wit my fselfutor p mtingory sty be tforehis. soi'm ry sor a forf ll o.this y i crdaall d y anniall ght er evy.y da m i'irso ted. ju i anst w gt tomeo ho. wa i o nt tb climy in ms mom'bed d anr nevee leavsiher de. m i' alost'mnd ike brondn, a i
10:56 pm
ammy fily. i' kim asoung yse to e nd m home as oo sasn os pe.sibl >> or rep pter:s athon'doest be togin cr desthibe ene sc e in .here enwht is wametior fen sncteg,in e shedseemsw to onoon v theerge of si pasutng o. pu de stiesedteppto in ad stey r he-- >> y arekaou oy? r >>teeporutr: bge judl pau su anllive madleit ce ar hedagre twithurhe jvey's t.rdic he>> t encvide te incahis asse w ov elerwh.ming ep>> rr:orte h andnde haowed dn nta se tencewahat ts inhe mi rddle oangessf poitibilies. >> s it'g goine to bsethe centen of s thit cour tthatefhe dntenda urbe tovned o er tdethe mepartnt c ofctorre tionsrvo sepee a riod ncof iraarce otiont f no less 8thanmo no hare t yn 25.ears r >>teeporbir: a sgail imon rbabsoheed ts newerof h nt se bencelylankif as w theords bblewr y he aliketb fasall. 8 5 to 2s.year
10:57 pm
h >>ulopefhily tlls wia be ss leoron f anyth oerea t wcherho nt wa ps toonrey hi a cld. it sn doeur't tt n oue to bthe fa y ntas tthey ihink.t is >> or rep hter:arer et lies po lessibea relatse d e is november 2022 enwh'l she 4l be3 ar yed.s ol e shfihas anled ea appl. a>> rlle.is w>>loe yve.ou >> ep rteor hr:er family, who had invited us into their home to hear abby's side of the orst y, w nocldeedino teasptok s. u declined our request for a co t mmennyof ad. kin an red di actednettorchy miael nl mao ey tikdo le.ewis d anprthe utosechoor wt jus wa d tcheenthe hd ofaser lset ca m isy ostly sorrhashe bd toring t ituro co at atll. >> on i d t'tnkhiou yut p a vi tctimghhrout whapushe ist th ct vihrim t, oughconot sinfesng, t nog beinntrepeant. pei ho h sheimas t ce todeonsir swhatidhe dth to amat fily ndbeyot whadishe td tohat
10:58 pm
>> ep rteor ar: andfos thr at yo maung e n, huagradinted may f2015carom ictholtr cenal, turned 18 not long after that. hi mis faanly wtoted ea app r to orsuppm t hihein te facbbof ay si s mon'ckatta. ca aoachndce diose ofot n pr tiotecheng tng youn, ma and th ey,o,toe haven diedhe t al tilega aonsnd ask tashe cee b di sesmisd. d ans a forha ttng you n,ma hse i duan a ltno tw,gryino trefigu ou t his next step in life. >> s he'ng goi to h tave loive wi heth tt fac, thatknyou ow, th rse pehaon tt l heoveds i g goine to briin pfoson ghr eit ar yes. >> ep rteorr: leov isli bnd tisome ameshind tsd kinf oe lov n isotus jcrt a iime,s t waa ag tredy. >>ha t at'sllor f now.
10:59 pm
. ....... . . ..... >> th anoer fighting fro life ewe'r lfrive om the secen in mos.ment >> f at iirst t tohe t washe t atisoled ksidng doi shiometng adumbnd it seems like it's bengcomie mor of aro p.blem p >>,lusgh cau tt inhero css refi, a troublingen trdak ting plinace the vlealy, a sgtrin of ivdre by aksttac in theas lt week,hy w rdeesi cntslaim it ulcod be a pemrobl. >> ho> wic polave he in cdyusto. n >> ews s3startig rhtow n. w >>meelco w ine b weginith brineakewg nson t,ight one persons iea ddnd ano ather indjureer aft aou dble sinhootg tinheal vley. it allap hdpener neant dowown ewher thees invtitigaon isll sti veacti. wsne 3'sha natn, at this ptoin cepoli c arelialng it abl doue shngootiut b t'rhey setill
11:00 pm
haedppen. ep>> rteor rr: tideodd. therere a sltil a lot of tiques tonshat arena urenswed at thoiis pnt. buigt r nhtowe w canl telthat uyo oneso pernec didero fhim ts shngooti ande on pnerso is sphoizitaliged r nhtow. dweon'tno kwhe ton cioditfn o that pn.erso ether othso pernha ttas w sent to theho alspitu bert the are ve fryetew dsailt tha we can ygive rouight now. ibutf i can give ayouoo lk at thcis seneht rigw no we are on dotloliteen avue. they said theyrd hea al cal ouabteo somneei bngt, sho wnhe theypo resdndey theou fnd two oppele withn guot sh wdsoun. w noether is afe concerenwn do wtheayht rig nowpl peoere a not weallood to cme in o orut of sthi a.rea fasusor sspecte wo dot n know aetny dailsbo autha tt ase wll. buist th is stilln a aectiv inigvestonati.
147 Views
IN COLLECTIONS
KSNV (NBC) Television Archive Television Archive News Search ServiceUploaded by TV Archive on