a jury found these two men guilty of murder. a judge sent them away for life. but we proved they were innocent. >> your motion to vacate your convictions is granted. thnc thncht. >> this prisoner heard about that case and asked us to look into his case. >> i need somebody to prove i didn't do this. >> it was a murder in harlem. he had an ally buy. >> i had son was not where they said say he was. police had witnesses.

what they told detectives changed his life. >> they said show us the murderer and they pointed their fingers at you. >> what those witnesses told us could change it again. >> i don't know if i really picked out the right person. >> one man's story. >> he's living everyone's worst nightmare. >> of "conviction." thanks for joining us. i'm lester holt. it was one of the first murders of the year at a time when new york's homicide rate was plunging, but that wasn't why police were all over this case. this one was personal. the victim was a retired cop and it didn't take long for an arrest. the young man convicted of that murder now spent half of his life behind bars but many say he shouldn't have spent a single day. here's luke russert with a hidden camera investigation. >> do you know what i am?

i'm buried alive. i'm dead to society. i don't exist in society. >> if you walk through any maximum security prison, you're likely to hear the same thing over and over again. i'm innocent. but every once in a while, you hear an inmate's story that makes you wonder, maybe this time it's true. >> i should not be here because i didn't commit this crime. i wasn't at the scene of the crime or anything. >> meet new york state inmate number aa 2023, jon-adrian velazquez, always known as j.j., convicted of killing a police officer during a botched robbery in harlem, a conviction he's always claimed has been unjust. >> an innocent man has done 14

years incarcerated while another man who is a killer may be on the train with you when you go to work. >> "dateline" first heard from velazquez ten years ago when he began writing us letters telling us -- >> i don't belong here. and my children should not be denied the presence of a loving and capable father. seeing my son struggling for attention is killing me softly. >> his letters made us curious to know more, and what began as a one-day prison visit by a "dateline" producer in 2002 has turned into a ten-year odyssey in a search for the truth. his story begins in january, 1998, that's j.j. velazquez at 22 years old, when he was living with his longtime girlfriend vanessa and their two young sons. what kind of guy is j.j.? >> lovable.

friendly. family oriented. >> vanessa says velazquez was studying to become a computer programmer and was taking a short break from school to help with their newborn. that's when the call came that changed everything. >> it was a saturday morning, and i received a phone kohl that the police were looking for me. you know? and that came to me as a shock. but what came to me as even more of a shock was the fact that they said i was a suspect for shooting a police officer. >> and why was that so shocking to you? >> because i've never shot anybody in my life. i mean, shooting a police officer? my father's a cop. >> his father, jon-adrian sr. was a police officer for amtrak and had recently passed away. the death of your father had a tremendous effect on you? >> absolutely. he was more than my father. he was my best friend. >> he went to catholic school. he was very sociable. >> velazquez's mother, maria, a

union labor organizer said her son was a typical boy. >> he had a lot of friends. i used to feel like a taxi driver taking them to the movies, bowling, all kinds of things. >> only child? >> my only child, yes. >> maria says she was stunned when she heard that her son was wanted for killing a retired cop. >> i called my son and said, what's going on. he didn't know what was going on. >> velazquez said he had nothing to fear, so he turned himself in and agreed to appear in a lineup, but it was at that lineup that eyewitnesses identified him as the shooter and jon-adrian velazquez was charged with first degree murder. you say you had nothing to do with the crime, you were nowhere near close to the scene. why is it that you were picked out? >> that's probably the best question in the world. because i don't know the answer. >> regardless, in october 1999 velazquez was convicted of murder and sent to prison.

he says the situation has left him angry, bitter and determined to prove his innocence. >> actions speak louder than words. what i would say to anybody who doesn't believe me right now is go out there and prove that i did it. >> so with no idea what we'd find, we agreed to take him up on his challenge. and for years we've been gathering the long-forgotten files, thousands of pages that make up his case. from the beginning, velazquez knew we weren't making any promises. you're not lying to us in any way, right? >> not at all. >> we're going to go back through this, we're going to pore over this stuff, there's no lies in there, there's nothing that will -- >> it's a waste of my time and your time. >> in our search we had to go back to the beginning. we relived the crime, we examined the trial, we tracked down long gone eyewitnesses, all to find out if jon-adrian velazquez is really an innocent man locked up for a crime he did

not commit. >> when we come back, what really happened the day of the crime? >> all hell breaks loose. he takes out the gun. >> i heard all these shots, boom, boom, boom. [ engine revs ] [ male announcer ] strip away the styling. strip away the rearview monitors, tv screens, bluetooth, and even the cup holders. you know what's left? the only s.u.v.s with american-built f-alpha truck frames. the ruggedly capable pathfinder, xterra, armada. nissan. innovation for all. ♪ ♪ nissan. innovation for all. ♪ feel the power my young friend. mmm! [ male announcer ] for excellent fruit and veggie nutrition... v8 v-fusion, also refreshing plus tea. could've had a v8.

v8 v-fusion, also refreshing plus tea. [ cell phon conquer your busy day. ♪ burn! let's do it! hello, jenny! ♪ thank you. [ cellphone rings ] working on it. ♪ hi. hi. how are you? [ female announcer ] outlast your day, any day, with secret's 48-hour odor protection technology. new secret outlast. ♪ when your chain of supply goes from here to shanghai, that's logistics. ♪ ♪ chips from here, boards from there track it all through the air,

that's logistics. ♪ ♪ clearing customs like that hurry up no time flat that's logistics. ♪ ♪ all new technology ups brings to me, that's logistics. ♪

jon-adrian velazquez is doing hard time at sing sing. he's convicted of killing a retired new york city police officer. >> to this day it's still a mystery why out of millions of people i was the one chosen. if i knew the answer, i'd be a step closer to society right now. >> to find out, we went back to the day of the crime. >> it was a tuesday, january 27th, in 1998. >> attorneys bob got leeb and celia gordon have represented

velazquez for the past two years. >> there was a numbers spot, an illegal gambling joint in harlem owned by a retired police officer by the name of albert ward. >> and there were plenty of people inside. >> the people we're talking about were all drug dealers, drug users. >> people like lorenzo woodford. >> i started using drugs when i was about 10. >> he said he came to the numbers spot that day about noon to buy heroin. a few minutes later two men barged in. it was a robbery. >> i heard someone say give it up [ bleep ], give it up. this guy stuck a gun in my face. oh, man. >> one guy had a gun and the other duct tape. they began tying people up. >> all hell breaks loose. ward, who is a retired police officer, has a gun, he takes out the gun. >> there was a struggle, then gunfire. >> i heard all these shots, boom, boom, boom. >> albert ward was killed, shot once in the head. >> immediately upon albert ward dropping to the floor, the two

individuals take off. >> the robbers weren't the only ones who fled. >> before i got a chance to even think anything, i jumped up and ran. >> lorenzo woodford and another eyewitness, woodford's heroin dealer took off. that drug dealer, a man named augustus brown, would turn out to be critical to the case. in the meantime , a retired cop was down. the nypd responded swiftly and with force. >> there's captains, lieutenant, police presence. >> the eyewitnesses, the once who didn't run, gave detectives very descriptions of the shooter and his accomplice. >> the gun man was a light-skinned black male with braids and the other was a dark-skind male black. >> at the precinct eyewitnesses were shown hundreds of mug shots, none recognized the shooter, but one did pick out a photo of the dark-skinned male, the killer's accomplice. >> the dark-skinned black male was identified as dario daniels

who had a long criminal history. >> he was picked up, placed in a lineup and, after being identified by three eyewitnesses, he was charged with murder. next police focused on finding his accomplice. >> the police artist sketches a drawing of what the gunman purportedly looked like. >> this sketch was plastered all over harlem, a place where the streets talk and the cops were listening. tips came in from all directions, but one name kept coming up over and over again. mustafa. >> they find out from three separate sources that a guy by the name of mustafa may have been the gunman. >> and those tipsters said mustafa fit the exact description of that sketch. >> he's a light-skinned male black, he's got braids. there's a police memo that's written where it specifically states primary target mustafa. >> while detectives search for

mustafa, they were also looking for the two eyewitnesses who fled from the club. heroin addict lorenzo woodford and drug dealer augustus brown. they found woodford first. he told detectives the shooter was a black male with corn rows. and then woodford led detectives to augustus brown. >> augustus brown is selling heroin on the street. and they bring him to the police precin precinct. they then take him to where they have photographs on a computer. he looked at hundreds of photographs. >> after more than eight hours, brown picked out a photo. but it wasn't a man who fit the description given by eyewitnesses. >> he picks out the photograph of jon-adrian velazquez and said, that's the man or that's your guy. >> and that's when the search for mustafa ended, but for jon-adrian velazquez, it was only the beginning. >> once augustus brown picks out jon-adrian velazquez, there is no need to look for mustafa.

>> why were you in the photo that augustus brown selected? >> i have done some thing i regret, not proud of no more. i realized they were wrong. >> months earlier he'd been arrested for drug possession. while he was never convicted of that or any other crime, police still had his mug shot in their files. remember when velazquez heard he was wanted he turned himself in and volunteered to appear in a lineup even though he said his attorney was against it. >> i said whose choice is it? i have nothing to do with this, i have nothing to hide. >> you're pretty confident. >> i had every right to be confident. >> he didn't run, he didn't flee, he didn't go and try to hop a plane. >> it was velazquez's mother maria who dropped her son off at the precinct. the last time she saw him as a free man. >> i drove to the corner and i can't forget how i felt. i let out this scream.

it was such a loud scream. >> inside the precinct, three eyewitnesses from the numbers spot identified velazquez as the gunman and he was charged with first degree murder. what's going through your mind? >> i wouldn't be able to tell you what's going through my mind. all i know is i'm stuck in a cage, laying on a cold slab. >> soon darrely daniels would plead guilty to robbery. for a ten-year sentence. but he would claim he didn't know daniels and he was innocent and told his lawyers no deal. >> i don't want to hear about a plea bargain. i'm going all the way. no way i would concede to this. >> he would be held at rikers before a jury would hear his story. >> i was feeling confident. i was feeling confident that, you know, the truth will set me

free. >> coming up -- a showdown in court. a prosecutor versus a mom. >> when the d.a. said that i'm just a mother who would do anything to save my son, that felt like a rock had hit my chest and blew the wind out of me because i told the truth. ♪ uhh! [ alyson ] just keep walking... ♪ oh, come on! ♪ ugh, again! [ sniffs ] that's what i'm talkin' about. [ female announcer ] new head & shoulders green apple, with an enticing scent. works on the scalp for up to 100% flake-free hair that's irresistibly fragrant. [ both laugh ] [ female announcer ] new head & shoulders green apple.

a, the appearance. amber. [ jim ] b, balance. sam adams has malt sweetness, hoppy bitterness. [ jim ] c, complexity. pine notes, grapefruit notes. only believe your own pallet. go taste them. are you guys okay? yeah. ♪ [ man ] i had a great time. thank you, it was really fun. ♪ [ crash ] i'm going to write down my number, but don't use it. [ laughing ] ♪ [ engine turns over ] [ male announcer ] the all-new subaru impreza®. experience love that lasts. ♪

wait. ♪ it's morning in the himalayas... [ male announcer ] it's sweet. it's nutty. it's absolutely delicious. kellogg's crunchy nut. it's morning somewhere. a living, breathing intelligence teaching data how to do more for business. [ beeping ] in here, data knows what to do. because the network finds it and tailors it across all the right points, automating all the right actions... [ beeping ] ...to bring all the right results. it's the at&t network -- doing more with data to help business do more for customers. ♪

in october 1999, the people of new york versus jon-adrian velazquez was called to order. has there ever been any physical evidence to link you to this crime? >> none whatsoever. >> there was no dna, no fingerprints, no blood, no weapon introduced in trial. the district attorney's case was based solely on eyewitness testimony. who is the first main eyewitness that they called to implicate you? >> i believe it was augustus

brown. >> augustus brown that drug dealer who first linked velazquez to the crime picking him out from hundreds of mug shots. >> he's the reason why we're here right now. he's the reason why i'm in jail. >> brown testified there is no doubt velazquez was the shooter, that he'd seen him on the streets some time before the crime. after brown, three more witnesses testified that velazquez was the killer. heroin addict lorenzo woodford and two other men who were there that day, brothers robert and philip jones. people walked into that courtroom and they said, show us the murderer. and they pointed their fingers at you. >> it felt like a slap in the face, a stab in the gut. >> but when one of the prosecution witnesses testified, an 88-year-old woman named dorothy kennedy, something very unusual happened. bob got leeb and celia gordon are velazquez's current lawyers. >> she testified before the jury

that she looked directly into the eyes of the gunman and that she would never forget his face. and she's asked while she's on the stand, do you see the person who shot and killed albert ward in the courtroom and she says yes. >> you know what happens? you know who she points out, juror number six. the jury's there laughing. but this ain't a joke. this is my life on the line. >> it was fun ne a sense. >> 14 years later we found juror number six. his name is ramon. >> i saw the other jurors looking at me. i realized, whoa, did she just pick me out? >> the defense then presented its case beginning by pointing out that velazquez did not match the original description of the shooter. >> we have every eyewitness say the persons involved were male blacks. lo and behold when they have the lineup, you have jon-adrian velazquez who is hispanic. did you ever have dreadlocks? >> absolutely not. >> how long was your hair back

then? >> shorter than yours. >> the defense introduced this photo showing velazquez with short hair just one month before the crime. and the defense made another argument, velazquez had an ally buy. >> the minute that they spoke about that day, january 27th, it stuck out like a sore thumb. that was the day before my father's birthday. >> his father had passed away six months earlier. >> if you can see on the tombstone, january 28th is his birthday. >> so this would be the first time that my father's birthday would come around, and we wouldn't spend it with him. >> and that's why velazquez, who testified in his own defense, says he remembers being on the phone with his mother that day. >> that was the day when i spoke about going to the cemetery to see my father's grave. >> this phone bill shows a 74-minute phone call from maria's home to her son's apartment in the bronx exactly when the crime was unfolding in harlem.

>> if jon-adrian is on the phone with his mother, there's no way that he could have been at the numbers spot in harlem shooting and killing albert ward. >> velazquez's mother maria took the stand testifying she remembered that phone call. >> my son was not where they say he was. he was on the phone with me. >> next to testify was velazquez's girlfriend vanessa. >> i know where he was at. he was on the phone. >> vanessa says she remembers going tout buy milk for her newborn that morning. >> i came back from the store and he walked in and hes with on the phone. >> you physically saw him holding the phone. >> yes. >> but in his closing statement, the prosecutor argued they were all lying and that it was actually vanessa who was on the phone with maria. >> did you ever get on the phone with her that day? >> no. >> when the d.a. said that i'm just a mother who would do anything to save my son, that felt like a rock had hit my

chest and blew the wind out of me because i told the truth. i told the truth. >> the jury was sequestered for three days. >> they're supposed to find the defendant guilty beyond a reasonable doubt. three days? three days and only three days of reasonable doubt? couldn't there have been some doubt in three days? obviously, they were doubting something. what takes so long? >> all the time we were frustrated. it was heated. >> juror number six, ramon aviles remembered most of the discussion centered on the girlfriend's testimony. >> it seemed planned, scripted, actually, that's the perfect word. >> he said the jury wrote her off as a girlfriend just trying to cover for her boyfriend. >> every time she said something, it started to feel like it was further from the truth and she was covering a lie with another lie. >> with each passing day, he says, the deliberations grew

more tense and stressful. >> nobody got physical, but it was just -- you can see the toll it was taking especially on some of the older jurors. people talking about they need to get back into their life. you can see that it was getting to them. they were saying, wow, we're going to get sequestered one more night? >> the verdict comes back, what are you feeling right then? >> the first verdict was not guilty. >> of first degree. >> and i felt great. and i knew i was walking out. >> but in the end, the jury believed the eyewitness at the numbers parlor. he's found guilty of second degree murder. >> then i remember a sharp pain, a real sharp pain in my heart because i found out that i may never see the streets again. >> this whole thing has been a very painful experience for me, very painful. >> i heard my mother, i heard her scream, i heard vanessa

scream. she cursed. she said something. they were telling her to make jacob be quiet because jacob was crying. i don't think i looked back. i don't think i had the heart to look back at my family's eyes. >> my son is not a murderer. he is not. >> velazquez's sentence? 25 years to life. and soon the life he knew on the outside, the things that made up his world faded away. >> hi, christmas tree, i love you! >> vanessa, the mother of his two sons moved on the a new relationship the year after velazquez went to prison. so you separated yourself? >> separated myself, completely. i had to let him know it was just too much as a single mother with two young kids, to do this. >> i understood where she was coming from. when i got arrested, i was 22

years old. how can i expect a woman who wasn't even 25 years old to wait for me to come home 25 years? was that realistic? >> years passed. two appeals were filed. both were denied. he was now on his own. >> for a long time i was private about my matters. when individuals started to find out i was innocent, they said, yo, what are you doing in the yard playing handball? sure, you can play. what are you doing playing basketball or softball? you need to be in the law library. i had to create my own future. i needed to learn the language that they used to destroy my life. >> so you go and study the law? >> so i go and i study the law. >> from behind bars, velazquez went to work trying to prove his innocence. and that's when he started writing us those emotional letters. >> that is all that i want, the

truth. >> when we come back, a witness recants. >> so that's all true? >> that's all true. >> and new questions about the real identity of the shooter. >> was there any evidence that they knew each other, that never hung out on the corner together? there's nothing. >> zeer pope a route map shows you where we go. but not how we get there. because in this business, there are no straight lines. only the twists and turns of an unpredictable industry. so the eighty-thousand employees at delta... must anticipate the unexpected. and never let the rules overrule common sense. this is how we tame the unwieldiness of air travel, until it's not just lines you see... it's the world. ♪ oh, my maltipoo's depressed. but my affordable prius c means i can pay for his acupuncture. whew. i love my pooch.

oh no! my homemade sushi... turned p-ushi! use estimated 53 mpg to find a gluten-free alternative. look, this means i'm a chef. [ male announcer ] be a winner with the all-new prius c from toyota. ♪ that's good morning, veggie style. hmmm. for half the calories plus veggie nutrition. could've had a v8. my high school science teacher made me what i am today. our science teacher helped us build it. ♪ now i'm a geologist at chevron, and i get to help science teachers. it has four servo motors and a wireless microcontroller.

over the last three years we've put nearly 100 million dollars into american education. that's thousands of kids learning to love science. ♪ isn't that cool? and that's pretty cool. ♪

rehberger. here's what's happening. yemeni government officials say a man linked to al qaeda may be behind the killing of an american there today. the u.s. embassy is not confirming the victim's name but he was gunned down as he drove to his job as an english teacher. a former u.s. soldier kidnapped in iraq has been identified as randy michael hultz. he was taken hostage nine months ago. now back to "conviction."

his trial was over. >> justice is hard to earn once you have been convicted in this country. >> time was passing, and j.j. velazquez's chances of getting a second look were dimming. >> i needed to be heard. i needed somebody to look into this. i needed somebody to prove what i've been trying to prove all along. i didn't do this. >> from inside prison walls, he had heard about another "dateline" investigation involving two other lifers who were vindicated after our broadcast. >> your motion to vacate your convictions is granted. >> and that's when he began sending us those letters. since then we've gathered all we could on his case, thousands of documents, police reports, trial transcripts, court filings, piecing the story together for

ourselves. it all comes down to those four eyewitnesseses who identified velazquez at trial, drug dealer augustus brown, philip and robert jones and heroin addict robert woodford. with hidden cameras rolling we found him in connecticut. he's one of those witnesses that fled right after the shooting. >> i went to another friend of mine's house. i stayed there, i was just so scared. >> police did not locate him until five days later when he was brought in to view a lineup. at that lineup he did not identify velazquez. police reports quote him as not positive about anyone. there is more. he admitteded he was high on heroin during the crime. >> i've been going to jail all my life. >> but then it all changed. at trial he testified he was sure velazquez was the gunman. today woodford says he sticks to what he said in court. >> with the kid that i said did it, that's who did it.

>> but he was surprised his testimony was all that important. >> i didn't turn him in. somebody else turned him in. they had to have some kind of evidence. they did not take my word for it. >> detectives didn't take his word. they had several other witnesses. velazquez's new lawyers celia gordon and bob gottlieb have been conducting their own investigation into the case. >> we located philip jones and spoke with him. >> he gave the lawyers a sworn affidavit where he recanted all of his testimony. raising serious doubt about who actually committed the murder. >> you know philip jones? we wanted to confirm his story, so we went looking for him. i'm looking for philip jones? >> no. >> eventually we found him outside his homes in queen, new york. he asked us to come inside where we read his affidavit back to him. on 2-2-98 i did a lineup where i

picked out the shooter. he said that police pressured him to make an identification. >> i told the police this was the guy and i felt sure this was not the truth. i thought they were going to arrest me and my brother robert. jones was in jail. but the d.a.'s office promised it would send a letter to the parole board saying he cooperated as a witness. today philip jones said he always knew that velazquez was the wrong man. >> i knew i had picked out the wrong guy. and the guy on trial i had never seen before. >> there you go. there you go. >> so that's all true? >> that's all true. >> according to velazquez's lawyers philip's brother robert, another eyewitness tells the us he also has doubts velazquez was the shooter. >> he's a witness to a crime. >> now the lawyers say there's even more reason to doubt their client's guilt because they say there's no proof velazquez even knew the man he's accused of

committing the crime with darrely daniels. was there any evidence before that day. >> no. >> that they ever knew each other, ever hung out on the corner together? >> zero. >> but in his plea he said that velazquez was his accomplish, but velazquez says daniels way lying. did you know darrely daniels? >> no. >> he served his ten years and today he's a freeman. a "dateline" producer daut up wi caught up with him. we tried to show him a photo of velazquez. he would not look at it. that left one witness. the first person to bring velazquez into the case. drug dealer augustus brown. >> everything changes with augustus brown. coming up -- 14 years ago what this man told police changed his life.

what he told us could change it again. >> somebody doing life because i said it was them and it possibly not have had been them. [ male announcer ] this is lois.

the day starts with arthritis pain... a load of new listings... and two pills. after a morning of walk-ups, it's back to more pain, back to more pills. the evening showings bring more pain and more pills. sealing the deal... when, hang on... her doctor recommended aleve. it can relieve pain all day with fewer pills than tylenol. this is lois... who chose two aleve and fewer pills for a day free of pain. [ female announcer ] try aleve d for strong all day sinus and headache relief. [ female announcer ] try aleve d ♪ when your chain of supply goes from here to shanghai, that's logistics. ♪ ♪ chips from here, boards from there track it all through the air, that's logistics. ♪ ♪ clearing customs like that hurry up no time flat

that's logistics. ♪ ♪ all new technology ups brings to me, that's logistics. ♪

jon-adrian velazquez has lived in a cramped prison cell for more than a third of his life. >> you can touch both sides of the wall. >> over the years he's learned how to survive in prison. >> most people sleep with their head to the back because it's dangerous to keep your head there not knowing who can come by and do something to you.

my kids. the main question they ask, when you coming home, dad? and daddy tells them, i don't know. >> he's only gotten to know his sons from this short time together in the prison visiting room. >> my sons know that i love them. my sons know that i'm innocent. >> for years, the weekend ritual for j.j. jr. and jacob has been the same, going to the prison with grandma. >> this is the jail that my dad is in. >> jacob only knows his dad because i've taken him to visit his dad. he was a baby. i put him in his arms so he would know his father and his father would know him. >> but as his older son became a teenager he'd sometimes go months without visiting his fath father. >> i love my father, i do want to see my father. i have nothing against him at all, it's just jail and stuff like that. [ sirens ]

>> how does it make you feel not being able to be there for him? >> i've been dehumanized. i never took my children to a ball game. i wasn't there at my children's graduation. when my children needed to ask a question that they felt a woman couldn't answer, i wasn't there to answer it. how do i feel? i feel like less of a man. >> velazquez and his lawyers know the only chance they have to free him is to successfully challenge the credibility of the only evidence that exists, the eyewitnesses. so far one is sticking to his story. this eyewitness has recanted. and a third eyewitness told the lawyers he was never certain that velazquez was the shooter, but there's still that key eyewitness, the one who first linked velazquez do the crime. drug dealer augustus brown. >> did you ever know augustus

brown? >> no, i didn't. >> you had no relationship with him prior? >> absolutely not. >> velazquez's lawyers say finding out why brown picked him out in the first place may be the only way to know if velazquez got justice. >> augustus brown, the 20-year-old heroin dealer is this case. >> we're on our way to elmyra prison right now to go see augustus brown. we found augustus brown in state prison where he is serving time for forgery. we were led into a conference room and turned on our hidden camera. he told us about the day of the crime, how he met lorenzo woodford at the club. >> he was a heroin addict. >> brown said he fled right after the shooting, but dkts tracked him down. >> they snatched me up off the street early. >> he set he was in the precinct all day. that police sat him in front of

a computer screen and asked him to look at pages of mug shots. he was shown 230 pages, eight photos per page, that's 1800 photographs. finally he says he spotted someone. you just picked out the one that you recognized? >> i thought it might be him. >> but there's more to what happened in the precinct that day. he told us detectives were pointing the finger at him as a suspect. >> they threatened to charge me with conspiracy to this saying that -- soncht the police were going to say you were a part of this robbery? >> yes, saying that i set this up for them to come in and rob him. >> but you didn't do it? >> no me having that on my record, a young black man, i ain't got no job. i'm not in school or nothing. so that's what came about me pointing the finger at smn. >> if that's true, velazquez's lawyers say his testimony can't be believed.

>> i don't care who is watching tonight. put yourself in that position, the police start pointing a finger at you where suddenly you're worried you will be thrown in jail. >> so this 20-year-old is sitting by himself for hours in a police precinct thinking i better name someone or i am not going home tonight. >> he had reason to sweat. when police pulled brown in for questioning, they found ten bags of heroin hidden in his underwear. after he picked velazquez, brown says he was allowed to leave with the drugs. why didn't they charge you with that? >> i don't know why they didn't charge me. you know what i mean? they had the dope and everything. >> we asked the new york city police department to speak with us about brown's story and velazquez's case. they declined to comment. bottom line, augustus brown says he was never certain that jon-adrian velazquez was the shooter. you think the guy behind bars is the guy who did it? >> that's something that i've been struggling with.

i don't know if i picked out the right person. i don't know if it was him or not. somebody doing life and it possibly could not have been him. >> the eyewitness telling us it was possible he picked the wrong man. you think about this when you go to bed at night? >> it always crosses my mind. >> after an admission like brown's, not to mention the statements of those other recan'ting witnesses, lawyers gottlieb and gordon say you can only come to one conclusion. >> he's as innocent of albert ward's murder as i am. >> he's innocent. >> i'm certain. >> they're about to take this investigation to the manhattan district attorney, but some legal heavyweights in new york say this case is no slam dunk. >> once the defendant is convicted, it is an uphill battle and the odds are against you. coming up -- j.j. doesn't just want the d.a. to believe him. there's someone else who may matter even more.

>> i'm almost there, jay. i'm almost there. people believe in me. you need to believe in me, too. ♪ [ female announcer ] introducing new nature valley protein bars. 100% natural ingredients like roasted peanuts... ♪ ...creamy peanut butter, and a rich dark chocolate flavor. plus, 10 grams of great tasting protein in every bar. so it's energy straight from nature to you. new nature valley protein bars. find them in the granola bar aisle. wait. ♪ it's morning in the himalayas... [ male announcer ] it's sweet. it's nutty. it's absolutely delicious. kellogg's crunchy nut. it's morning somewhere. let me get that door for you... [ man ] i loved my first car...

sometimes the door gets stuck... oh sure. ooh! [ man ] ...and then, i didn't. um... [ sighs ] [ man ] so, i got a car i can love a really, really long time. [ male announcer ] for the road ahead, the all-new subaru impreza. ♪ experience love that lasts. in here, the landscaping business grows with snow. to keep big winter jobs on track, at&t provided a mobile solution that lets everyone from field workers to accounting, initiate, bill, and track work in real time. you can't live under a dome in minnesota, that's why there's guys like me.

[ male announcer ] it's a network of possibilities -- helping you do what you do... even better. ♪

>> he's living everyone's worst nightmare. >> lawyers celia gordon and bob gottlieb now say the witnesses who have changed their stories is proof that jon-adrian velazquez is an innocent man. >> everything about this case screams innocence, everything. >> and they say it underscores an even larger point, the proven unreliability of eyewitness testimony in general. >> since 1998 when this happened, there have been a legion of scientific studies

that say that eyewitness identification is the major cause of wrongful convictions. >> but it may be too little too late. >> this is an extremely difficult fight for any convicted defendant to undertake. >> steve cohen is a former federal prosecutor. >> once somebody goes to trial, 12 jurors say guilty, once you're in that place, it is extremely difficult to overturn a conviction. >> years ago cohen was also a defense attorney and helped in the exoneration of those two other men "dateline" profiled several years back. >> when you look at the totality of the evidence here, there's no question this is a thin case. that doesn't make it easier. in an odd way, that makes it harder, and it makes it harder

because without something very new, what you're really doing is attacking the same evidence that the jury based its conviction on. >> and cohen says anything new velazquez's lawyers have might not be enough. >> i don't want to suggest the recantations are nothing, but they're not dna. they're not somebody who you now believe was the actual shooter. you don't have that here. >> the last two years j.j. has lived in sing sing's honor block, and he's been going to school at the prison. >> you want to see what the teacher graded me on? >> yeah, let me see it. >> see what the topic was? >> what was it? my incarceration's impact on my family. >> right. >> his youngest son jacob has never known his father as a free man. his oldest, j.j. jr., was 3 when his dad was sent away. today he's 17. because of his age, prison rules prohibited j.j. jr. from visiting with his father by himself. >> he's never had an individual

time where it was just father and son. he doesn't know what that is. i don't know what that is. >> but now that he's older father and son will finally have a visit alone for the first time. >> i really want to know how my incarceration has affected him, you know, what effect has that had to grow up without a father? >> what's up, kid? >> love you. >> love you, too. >> definitely growing, man. glad to see you here today. my life has affected you. i know that what's happened to you is a product of what happened to me, and you have a right to be angry about it. >> i didn't always get what i was supposed to have when i was a child. >> you had a rough upbringing,

man. you spent five days a week during your childhood going to school, and on the sixth day you spent in the penitentiary with your father. >> i never hated you. i just hated coming to see you. >> i'm proud of who you are, and i love who you are. there's nothing you can do to change that. >> their visit lasted more than four hours. i'm almost there, j. i'm almost there. people believe in me, and you need to believe in me, too. >> if they are ever to meet outside prison walls -- >> there you go, folks. >> it may be up to his next visitors. >> nice to see you. >> his lawyers have come to sing sing with the 80-page brief they will be presenting to the d.a. >> what we're asking the district attorney to do is investigate all of these leads. here it is on a silver platter. >> the witnesses have recanted their identifications and changed their trial testimony so

that's the hook. that's the new information. we'll see. >> all right. >> it's going to take time. >> all i know is time. that's all i know. i appreciate everything you're doing, and i know there's a possibility i might spend the rest of my life in prison. this is the best i've ever had. i've never had a second chance, you know. this is it. thank you. thank you. >> in october 2011 velazquez's lawyers delivered their brief to the manhattan district attorney's office asking him to reinvestigate the case. >> we have no reason to believe that the d.a. is going to do anything else other than conduct an objective, thorough, independent investigation. >> we continue as an office -- >> in 2010 cyrus vance jr., the newly elected manhattan d.a., formed a team called the conviction integrity unit. its mission is to investigate claims of wrongful conviction,

and while the manhattan d.a.'s office declined to discuss details of the case, they told us they are reviewing it. recently velazquez's story has begun to hit the press, and it's attracted hollywood actor and activist martin sheen. >> how you doing? >> jon-adrian velazquez. >> a pleasure to meet you. >> in december the actor went to the prison to meet velazquez. >> your statement at your sentencing, that there was a miscarriage of justice and that you trusted the system and you trusted your own innocence, you trusted god that you would be exonerated. >> right, i still do. >> yes, of course. that's why we're here. >> and then there's juror ramon aviles. he says he's always had his doubts about the verdict. >> what did i do? did i do something wrong here? i think i did something wrong. >> he told us he began to question his decision the moment the verdict was announced. >> once it was announced, i looked at the mother, and then i looked away.

in other words, i didn't know where to put my face. i guess that's what i had to live with from that time on. >> steve cohen says that admission by a juror will not necessarily help velazquez. >> he's already been convicted. 12 people said guilty, and now to come in and say i want you to look at it again. i want all of that work to be washed away because there's a grave injustice here, the system doesn't really work that way. >> in the meantime, one of the original defense lawyers on the case, norman reimer, has written the manhattan district attorney. he says he believes there's a substantial probability that velazquez was wrongly convicted. but for now all jon-adrian velazquez and his family can do is wait. >> in god we trust, because men make mistakes. i trust in god. >> do you have hope? >> i have too much hope.

i know he's coming home. >> when you walk out in that prison yard, you have one of the most beautiful views of the hudson river that anyone could ever see. what's that like? >> sweet torture. i see freedom before my eyes. it seems tangible, but it's not. i watch it at night with the bright lights. i watch it in the day. i see the ferry riding by. i see the sail boats sailing by. that's freedom. it's right there. it's sweet torture, that's what it is. you'll find more information about this story at msnbc.com. that's all