tv Ronan Farrow Daily MSNBC March 24, 2014 10:00am-11:01am PDT
10:00 am
kinds of decisions. >> you and the president will have a child, any more children? >> well, no but i wouldn't mind one of those grandchildren that i heard so much about. >> light hearted words from former secretary of state hillary clinton. today we have sad news in the search for flight 370. malaysian authorities have announced their finding conclusively that the jet and all passengers on board are gone. according to malaysia's prime minister, new analysis using satellite data shows the flight was last positioned in the middle of the indian ocean. you see it there, far from any possible landing sites. >> it is therefore with deep sadness and regret that i must
10:01 am
inform you that according to this new data, flight mh 370 ended in the southern indian ocean. >> families were informed just moments before the press conference by a text message. part of the text, we deeply regret we have to assume yopd any reasonable doubt that mh 370 has been lost and that none on board have survived. it is quite a text to receive. one of the loved ones who got that text on her phone is an american sara bajc. we were interviewing sarah this morning at the very moment when she received the devastating news. this footage that we've chosen not to air out of respect for her privacy and dignity and the
10:02 am
same privacy and dignity of all of these grieving families. she did send us an e-mail, quote, the announcement is on data only and no confirmed wreckage and no real closure. we're going to return to what's ahead for the families but first i want to go to keir simmons in kuala lumpur and joins us with the latest on this announce. . thank you so much. what's the atmosphere like right now there on the ground? >> reporter: pretty somber. this is the hotel where some families have been staying. there have been other families but we are here when a small group of relatives gathered in the area behind me there to listen to the prime minister's news conference to hear him make the announcement remember, what they were listening to was him making an announcement that their 29-year-old son was on and the boys father sat stoney faced
10:03 am
silence. his wife, the boy's stepmother just gently stroking his arm in tears. and then at the end, because he isn't able to speak english, one of the relatives had to lean in and explain to him what had just been announced and he just got up and walked away as you can imagine. and took some time with his family to compose his thoughts and think about what he just heard and came back and said he actually wants to know more, wants to know more of the detail before he makes any kind of statement. asked about the question how the relatives were told and he says that they were -- that they weren't given a text message or e-mail and weren't told in advance. they watched on television and that's where they first heard about it. so a pretty astonishing way to hear the news, ronan. >> keir, how do you think it is that malaysian authorities came to this conclusion right now?
10:04 am
>> reporter: >> i don't know if you asked me another question but i can't hear you very well, i didn't hear that question so well. let me just explain that the families here have been waiting all of this time for news. they have been waiting for two weeks for news and now really they are going to end up waiting again until tomorrow to get more detail and then of course despite this research, some of the folks i've been talking to have be saying, well, actually we still want to know whether or not the debris that is being seen in the ocean is connected to flight 370. we need more closure than this and need to know what that is. >> thank you so much. keir simmons, a shaky connection there with him all the way in the field. we appreciate that update on what it's like in the thick of the announcement. >> let's drill down on that question i just asked, how is it that malaysian authorities have come to a definitive verdict and
10:05 am
why now? joining us for the latest is nbc's former veteran aviation correspondent bob hager. thank you so much for joining us. >> sure. >> you're one of the smartest voices -- >> thank you. >> been through this a lot of times. >> a lot of times. >> the fact that the united states is dispatching and i want the terminology right, a ping locater, this black box. >> like a microphone under water. >> what does that tell you about the search? apparently the latest is this is being lootded on a plane bound for perth and you see a picture of the device right there. what does it say to you about what they found or haven't found that they are deploying this device? >> the mere fact they are shipping it out there, they want to get it near the action. because take -- sending anything halfway around the globe takes a while. but the point is that never mind these calculations, which
10:06 am
confirmed that the plane was on this southerly route, what they really need for the investigation is wreckage. and then that surface wreckage is going to be light stuff, skin and things like that from the airplane, airplane skin. they've got to find where the main body of wreckage first hit the water. to do that, if they can find this surface material and calculate back where the main body of the wreckage is, then they listen with these devices such as the one you showed and think of it as an underwater microphone from pinging. and the cockpit voice recorder at the bottom of the sea bed. they have got to know more about where is the wreckage and where the main body hit to get an area where the boats can tow this. it only goes 5 to 10 miles at the outside. you have to get that close to it with a boat. >> why do you think it is they've come to this conclusion now? what is your instinct on what type of data they are looking at?
10:07 am
>> they have two things. the data from which today's announcement is made is pure satellite data. it's an interrogation system on the plane where routinely sends out a signal and never mind a lot of stuff on the plane had either shut down or been disabled. the plane automatically sends out this signal once an hour, just searching for satellites and the satellite can tell if it gets hit by the signal. so a single satellite owned by this british company got that inquiry from the plane. so they plot that back down and something in the news calculations, they were able to eliminate that arc that we saw in the north going through the himalay himalayas, eliminate that and say yes, it was on that southerly route. i think we're getting enough signs of wreckage now that they do seem to be in the right area. >> it's important you mention the satellite data. they did mention they were using a new analytical technique. it will be interesting to see
10:08 am
how it plays out. >> thanks, bob hager. seen a lot of this and we may come back to him as this all develops. first, i want to return to this topic of the families and what they are going through and what could be next for them. joining us to tackle this, lisa bloom, legal analyst and someone who is experienced in helping families through traumatic and legally complex situations like this one. lisa, thank you so much for joining us. >> thank you, ronan. >> tell us the chinese families were informed of the tragic news by text message, saying malaysian airlines deeply regrets we have to assume beyond any reasonable doubt that the flight was lost and none on board survived. couldn't they found a better way to deliver the news. >> certainly a phone call would have been better. we're talking about hundreds of people in a rapidly developing situation. i wonder why this announcement had to be made today and what i
10:09 am
learned representing so many families of generally crime victims is what they want is information. they don't want a con clusry statement. they want to know every deal that's available. and as these family members pointed out, we don't have a plane. we don't even have pieces of a plane. we have satellite information and we know based on the fuel of the plane it probably couldn't have gone much further than that. the conclusion has got to be the correct one that the plane has gone down and everyone has perished. but the families are going to want more information as the days and weeks develop. >> you say of course that the heart of this their desire for information. there have been a lot of complaints about how information has been doled out. do you see foresee legal actions to the search and parties responsible for dispersing information? >> absolutely, not to mention the airlines and everybody else involved. i am optimistic that eventually the plane or pieces of the plane are going to be discovered. and the families have not been
10:10 am
handled well as far as i can tell based on press accounts, that leads to angry people. most of the people i represent say look, in this tragedy i just wanted an apology. i wanted to be treated right. that's what leads people to going to lawyers when any can't get the information in a proper manner. >> as i understand it under international law, malaysian air is already required to make advance payments to the family for travel and related expenses and if there were legal settlements in this that would be governed by international treaty. how big a part of the jurisdiction is international law? >> i think a lot. we have a plane that was starting in one place in malaysia and going to china. we have people from all different countries in the world. international law governing planes and planes going down. if they will would handle this right now, they could avoid a lot of litigation in the future. i'm not seeing that. >> thank you so much, lisa
10:11 am
bloom. don't go away, we'll come back to you later on in the hour for your thoughts on another story, particularly startling one about discrimination in schools. stay tuned for that. first, just ahead on "ronan farrow daily," president obama is meeting with world leaders right now. trying to unify european support for sanctions he announced against russia. >> growing sanctions would bring significant consequences to the russian economy. >> we have got a live report on the president's unity mission coming straight up. and also later in the day, washington state's governor is declaring a state of emergency after the deadly mud slide that is now the size of almost 500 football fields. the latest on the search for survivors is just ahead. [ children yelling ] [ telephone rings ] [ shirley ] edward jones. this is shirley speaking. how may i help you?
10:12 am
oh hey, neill, how are you? how was the trip? [ male announcer ] with nearly 7 million investors... [ shirley ] he's right here. hold on one sec. [ male announcer ] ...you'd expect us to have a highly skilled call center. kevin, neill holley's on line one. ok, great. [ male announcer ] and we do. it's how edward jones makes sense of investing. ♪ [ female announcer ] covergirl janelle monae. blend of punk and funk. her trublend? deep 6. it blends seamlessly for a flawless nudeo lok. even up close. [ female announcer ] find your trublend. covergirl makes it easy, breezy, beautiful.
10:15 am
welcome back, everybody. at this very hour, president obama is in europe meeting with other leaders at the g7 at the hague. russia's take over of crimea is topping the agenda for that conversation. did you notice that number? it's g-7. not g8. russia is on the outs. the president and european allies are meeting on the sidelines of something that was previously scheduled at the hague, but the renewed focus on russia has given the conversation a clear focus, send a message to vladimir putin that his power play has made him an outsider. earlier today he declared the g7 united in their resolve to punish putin for his actions. >> europe and america are united
10:16 am
in our support of the ukrainian government and the ukrainian people. we're united in imposing a cost on russia for its actions so far. >> this is likely to be an awkward conversation laugh lavrov is still present at the summit but not any meeting. he has to convince allies that united states has the teeth to keep putin in check. what was putin's response to this meeting of the g7? he tightened his hold on crimea. just before dawn, russian troops rolled into new territory and seized their third crimean naval base. chuck todd, nbc news chief white house correspondent and host of the daily rundown earlier in the day here traveling with president obama, chuck always a pleasure to have you on the
10:17 am
program. what is the single most important thing you think the president needs to accomplish at today's meeting. >> it's going to be about unifying europe to do more than just agree to a rerhetorical denuns yags of putin. getting the europeans united on tougher sanctions against russia, that's the difficulty. that's the tricky diplomacy here. the european economy as a whole, particularly some countries more than others, they are finally tied into russia. they have more fragile recovery from the great recession than the united states has. think about our economy and how our own citizens believe it's an uneven recovery at best, majority think we're in recession. the feelings are even worse here in europe. sanctioning russia, there is fears among some that it could just make an already mediocre economy in europe even more so. he's got to figure out how to keep the fragile coalition together.
10:18 am
at the same time there are some europeans nervous, is the united states willing to use nato in the way it was intended to be? there is a two-way diplomacy going on here. but the single big. accomplishments, getting the europeans more comfortable with tougher and tougher sanctions, not just at russian individuals but perhaps certain sectors of the russian economy. when the president signed that executive order that gave him the power to target certain sectors of the economy, they didn't do it yet. it's like a gill lo teen hoping that the europeans would climb on board. that's what his hope and his challenge is today. >> he's using both sticks and carrots here. thank you, chuck todd in the netherlands with president ob a obama. >> you got it. >> you can kauch the daily rundown at 9:00 a.m. on msnbc. with president obama facing one
10:19 am
of the biggest foreign policy challenges, keeping a tight european pecoalition of allies going to be more important than other. joining us now, chris hill. thank you very much ambassador for joining us. >> pleasure. >> tell me, the president is saying he's got this united front with his g7 allies, how do ut assess the strength of those relationships right now? >> certainly this is very complex. and i think his main task is to maintain some kind of united front. but most importantly to make sure it does not appear there's a division even if there are internal disagreements. certainly he wants to see sanctions tightened but he also wants to be careful not to feed this narrative we're into a new cold war. that's not something the europeans are going to go along with. he needs to talk about the long-term challenge without it
10:20 am
turning into a cold war. secondly and this is very important. there are a lot of new nato members poland, hungary and baltic states, he needs to be reassuring to them that nato really means something, that if they are attacked, it would be an attack on all of us. he needs to be reassured and being tough in his approach without causing problems on the western side where some of those european union members really don't want to see this kind of talk of cold war two coming about. it's a tough mission for the president. but i think so far he's handling it really well. >> tlsz the desire of cold war part 2 but specific desire not to lose the very important business interests with russia. do you think that's the biggest obstacle president obama faces in advocating for more robust
10:21 am
sanctions from the european allies? >> i would agree with that. to understand some of these big business interests, on the one hand yes, there are european countries who stand to lose as chuck todd said, do have fragile economies, but there's also a body of opinion that says in the long run. the way the russia problem if you will is going to be solved by bringing russia into the family of western nations and if you kind of throw them in the deep freeze so to speak, that's not going to happen. so there are a lot of people who not just for short term commercial gain but rather for long-term strategic gain want to see the door left open to bringing russia back. that's obviously a tough mission with vladimir putin and no indication that vladimir putin cares about russia becoming a western nation. so i think the president needs to convey that without kind of spooking the europeans into
10:22 am
believing that somehow u.s. simply doesn't care and we're ready to let russia go back in the deep freeze for the rest of his tri. >> throughout the first obama administration and certainly while i was an official, the big point over and over was the pivot to the east asia pacific region. does this throw a wrench in that? >> i think so. we've had wrenches thrown ever since it was announced. first of all the idea we get from the mid east and get into east asia came in conflict with the arab spring with the perception we were leaving the region. that was a bad signal and secretary john kerry has been trying undo that. there was another unintended sequence, which was the notion that somehow the europeans felt like chopped liver as we're going off to east asia and
10:23 am
focusing there. so clear we're back to dealing with europe and back to dealing with traditional trans atlantic issues in a way that probably was in no way could have been anticipated just a couple of years ago. this however, does not mean that we shouldn't be focusing on china. certainly we don't want to see a new russian chinese and russia and china coordinating their policies. we need to be engaged there as well. i think this is the fate that the united states has. we need to be engaged in a number of places at the same time. >> all right, back to europe as center piece of american foreign policy interests. the more things change, the more they stay the same. thank you, ambassador. >> sure. >> all right, just ahead on "ronan farrow daily," the search for survivors in a wave of mud. nearly 20 feet deep. >> the conditions are very, very
10:24 am
muddy in places it is still like quick sand. >> many are still missing. we've got the latest on washington's deadly mud slides up next. if i can impart one lesson to a new business owner, it would be one thing i've learned is my philosophy is real simple american express open forum is an on-line community, that helps our members connect and share ideas to make smart business decisions. if you mess up, fess up. be your partners best partner. we built it for our members, but it's open for everyone.
10:25 am
there's not one way to do something. no details too small. american express open forum. this is what membership is. this is what membership does. add vanishing deductible from nationwide insurance and get $100 off for every year of safe driving. we put members first. join the nation. ♪ nationwide is on your side
10:26 am
she loves a lot of it's what you love about her. but your erectile dysfunction - that could be a question of blood flow. cialis tadalafil for daily use helps you be ready anytime the moment's right. you can be more confident in your ability to be ready. and the same cialis is the only daily ed tablet approved to treat ed and symptoms of bph, like needing to go frequently or urgently. tell your doctor about all your medical conditions and medications, and ask if your heart is healthy enough for sexual activity. do not take cialis if you take nitrates for chest pain, as this may cause an unsafe drop in blood pressure. do not drink alcohol in excess with cialis. side effects may include headache, upset stomach, delayed backache or muscle ache. to avoid long-term injury, seek immediate medical help for an erection lasting more than 4 hours. if you have any sudden decrease or loss in hearing or vision, or if you have any allergic reactions such as rash, hives,
10:27 am
swelling of the lips, tongue or throat, or difficulty breathing or swallowing, stop taking cialis and get medical help right away. ask your doctor about cialis for daily use and a 30-tablet free trial. welcome back. uphead on today's show, we're going to introduce a call to action that touches all of our lives very acutely. you won't want to miss that. first up, we're going to give you an update on the devastating news at washington state. rescuers have received numerous reports of missing or unaccounted for people. the exact number of missing is still unknown. at least eight people are confirmed dead near the town of oso. washington state patrol released this helicopter footage to join the sheer scope of the disaster. the mud slide covers nearly a square mile and more than 15 feet deep in some parts.
10:28 am
look at this. this is the before photo of the area affected by this conflict -- i'm sorry, this landslide, the ground simply gave way over the weekend apparently and here is how it looks after. the mud slide left a wake of devastation equal to nearly 500 football fields. we'll be following that story as it develops. there's also sad news in chicago where 32 people were injured when an 8-car train sped past the end of a platform and ended up going up in a escalator leading to terminals at o'hare international airport. according to the fire commissioner the train jumped up on the sidewalk and went on the stairs and into that escalator. we felt we had to bring you dramatic images. none of the injuries are reported to have been serious. but we'll be keeping an eye on that. now is your chance to tell us what underreported story you want us to cover next.
10:29 am
you've been sending in your nominations throughout the week under the hash tag rfd under. we'll have you vote on your top responses at the bottom of the hour. still ahead on ronan farrow daily -- you won't want to miss the shocking results of 15-year study from the government. we're asking for o help from you, we're bring to bring you our call to action right after the break. stay with us. quit smoking with. as a police officer, i've helped many people in the last 23 years, but i needed help in quitting smoking. [ male announcer ] along with support, chantix varenicline is proven to help people quit smoking. chantix reduced the urge for me to smoke. it actually caught me by surprise. [ male announcer ] some people had changes in behavior, thinking, or mood, hostility, agitation, depressed mood,
10:30 am
and suicidal thoughts or actions while taking or after stopping chantix. if you notice any of these, stop chantix and call your doctor right away. tell your doctor about any history of mental-health problems, which could get worse while taking chantix. don't take chantix if you've had a serious allergic or skin reaction to it. if you develop these, stop chantix and see your doctor right away, as some can be life-threatening. tell your doctor if you have a history of heart or blood-vessel problems or if you develop new or worse symptoms. get medical help right away if you have symptoms of a heart attack or stroke. use caution when driving or operating machinery. common side effects include nausea, trouble sleeping, and unusual dreams. i did not know what it was like to be a nonsmoker, but i do now. [ male announcer ] ask your doctor if chantix is right for you.
10:32 am
oh, there's a prize, all right. [ male announcer ] inside every box of cheerios are those great-tasting little o's made from carefully selected oats that can help lower cholesterol. is it a superhero? kinda. ♪ kinda. ♪ see what's new at projectluna.com kinda. welcome back, everybody, march 31st, next monday, is the deadline to sign up for health insurance through healthcare.gov. as that deadline looms the debate about health care in this
10:33 am
country is raging more fiercely than ever. wherever you fall on that debate about obama care, the conversation about health care in general is urgently needed. according to the national academy, quote, americans live shorter lives and experience more injuries and illnesses than people in other high income countries. most of us don't have to look far in our own lives for loved ones to see that. ahead of the deadline, we want to turn to all of you to help capture the challenge of health care in this country. here's this week's call to action for you guys at home. please send us your photo with a sign telling us how much your medical costs are per month. or just the cost this very last month. you can tweet your responses to ronan daily or e-mail to them at ronanfarrow daily or let us know on facebook.
10:34 am
each day we're going to bring you a different facet as this call plays out. today we start by looking at whether obama care is the answer through the lens of its closest precedent. that's the massachusetts health care law known as romney care. here to discuss what lessons can be learned from that precedent and where we go moving forward based on that, our former democratic massachusetts congressman barney frank and roy, a former health care adviser to the romney presidential campaign. congressman, i want to start with you. you served in massachusetts during governor romney's statewide health care mandate. what do you think we should learn from that experience? >> well, i apologize, i'm not very good person to ask that. it is true i was serving in the congress during that time. i was not in legislature and wasn't directly involved. the one thing i can tell you is that i would hear from constituents about this or that
10:35 am
problem during the time since it was signed and whatever 2000 -- 2006, i haven't heard any complaints about it at the state it worked well. in terms of lessons, i must tell you i do not sufficiently familiar with it to do that. and voted on and was supportive in general of the affordable health care act although parts i would like to have seen done differently. i was spending most of my time on the financial reform bill so it's probably one of the ones i'm not as good on details as i should be. >> that is a general massachusetts perspective. i'll come back to you on the national question of health care. first, let me ask you, there are a number of specific differences between romney care which played out before hand in massachusetts and obamacare, they allow you to calculate whether a employee is
10:36 am
full-time or part-time in different ways and you can talk about that. also, it allows businesses to deduct the romney care penalties from their taxes which is distinct from how obama care handles this and romney care penalties are much more modest. a number of business owners that i talked to have therefore praised romney care and dinged obamacare. do you think the massachusetts rollout handled better? >> stepping asides from the technical details the biggest difference it was a state based reform and obamacare was a federal based reform. it only added exchanges to the existing architecture to the existing health care system where obamacare had to do significant changes to the health care system which are more disruptive and have people unhappy. the other thing to mention, of course, how the exchanges were implemented. they worked relatively smoothly, the enrollment started slow and
10:37 am
worked up. there weren't complaints about the technical challenge. in terms of sign-ups for obamacare, massachusetts is dead last in the country, they are having a lot of difficulty having the obama care interact with romney care. >> if mitt romney had become president, how do you think it would be playing out differently? >> it would be different because he would be trying to make executive orders and regulations and what he would try to get through congress. in terms of basic stuff that needs to be executed to get the law up and running so people weren't so dislocated, i would like to think he would do a better job. very experienced at just that sort of thing. >> going back to you congressman frank, you were in office both democratic pushes on health care, including that from senator kennedy and also as i said, mitt romney's rollout of that massachusetts health care plan, without getting into technical details, what would you like to see happen next in the national conversation about
10:38 am
health care? >> well, that's a very important point. i count it as a great advantage we did this on the national level and not the state level. the single best part of that health care bill was the expansion of medicaid. you talked earlier about the difference in lifespans. well the different in the lifespan in america is a very different one within america according to people's income and social economic standing, wealthy americans do very well, part of the reason for our lower level is the excess of inequality we have and the problems that causes for people at all levels. so that's something that couldn't have been done at the state level. expansion of medicaid and i've been appalled at some states where they've rejected federal assistance to help people just above the poverty level get into medicaid. that's one of the ones that i would -- i would approve on. we try to make that mandatory,
10:39 am
the u.s. supreme court upheld the overall bill but threw out the mandatory part. yes, i care about massachusetts but i care about poor people in many of those states who are terribly deprived and aren't getting any assistance. so i would like to mandate and we're talking about 90% -- >> if i can jump in there, one thing i would say, it's far from clear that medicaid actually solves the problem of life expectancy being lowered for poor people. all of the literature, one published in the new england journal of medicine, showed med okay had no impact on health outcomes, there's a problem with discrepancies but it's not clear it is addressing the problem? >> i disagree with that. >> there is literature that suggests that it -- >> there's literature on a variety of things. the fact is there are -- and i
10:40 am
know this from people i've talked to, there are clearly people who don't get as much medical care as they should. the fact there's no immediate impact within a few years on life expectancy doesn't resolve that issue. there is a quality of life question. and the notion that people who are just above the poverty line that they are better off running a charity medicine and the kindness of strangers, rather than having medicaid, i disagree with. i know there are people -- they were people conservatives who don't like medicaid who would like to cut it way back. i think it is clear that lower income people are better off without it. i know that was true in the district i represented. it does the no have an immediate increase in long he havety within a five or seven year period does not make medicaid not a good thing. we do -- >> there are alternative solutions i would say. >> we can continue this
10:41 am
conversation about the specifics of medicaid at other time. i think you both raise important points. i think congressman frank's point about quality of life is important. how this does disproportionately affect the have-nots. and we want to hear from every one of you with what your challenges are. remember, please for the call to action, send ugs a photo on a sign or piece of paper telling us how much your medical costs are per month. you can take a look at mine. i'm not going through any big medical trauma this month. those costs are modest. around the ofrs we've seen a range of expenses, some devastating, some modest. we home you help us report out the scope the problems across the country. thank you for joining us for this. we hope all of you will continue to respond at home. also, up next, an alarming new report finds a pattern of in
10:42 am
equality along racial lines for young minority students. we're going to dive deep into a disturbing new study up next. salesperson #1: the real deal's the passat tdi clean diesel gets up to 795 highway miles per tank. salesperson #2: actually, we're throwing in a $1,000 fuel reward card. we've never done that. that's why there's never been a better time to buy a passat tdi clean diesel. husband: so it's like two deals in one? avo: during the salesperson #2: first ever exactly. volkswagen tdi clean diesel event, get a great deal on a passat tdi, that gets up to 795 highway miles per tank. and get a $1000 dollar fuel reward card. it's like two deals in one. hurry in and get a $1,000 fuel reward card
10:44 am
it's where you email, yshop, even bank.e here, but are you too comfortable? these days crime can happen in a few keystrokes. american express can help protect you with intelligent security that learns your spending patterns, and can alert you to an unusual charge instantly. so you can be a member of a more secure world. this is what membership is. this is what membership does. humans. even when we cross our t's and dot our i's, we still run into problems. namely, other humans. which is why, at liberty mutual insurance, auto policies come with new car replacement and accident forgiveness if you qualify. see what else comes standard at libertymutual.com. liberty mutual insurance.
10:45 am
responsibility. what's your policy? welcome back. a shocking, and i mean this, shocking new report on education is out at signs that black students are suspended and expelled three times more often than white students. maybe even more shocking, that trend starts as early as preschool. black students in that grade face tougher discipline than other students. take a look at these numbers. while black children in preschool comprise 18% of the population, they make up 42% of preschoolers who are suspended at least once. having grown up with black siblings and having heard my sister get called the n word at school when she was a little kid, this is heart wrenching on a personal level. but it also has repercussions
10:46 am
for the fabric of all of our lives. joining me now are msnbc political analyst and former rnc chair michael steele, always a pleasure to have you on. >> nice to see you. >> and lisa bloom, "today" show analyst and author of "suspicion nation", the trayvon martin injustice and why we continue to repeat it. lisa, i cannot even wrap my mind around the scope of the stats and how early this discrimination appears to start. what do you attribute that to? >> this is a department of education study of all 97,000 public schools in america. so it's a very broad study and not by some radical outside group. listen, i have a chapter about this in my book as well. to me this is the primary reason why there's still so much racial equality in america. at the beginning, in schools there's so much racial inequality. most americans go to segregated
10:47 am
schools and kids in majority black schools get less funding than kids who go to majority white schools. kids in black schools less likely to have teachers who are competent or proefficient. the schools are crumbling and toxic, toilets don't work. the list goes on and on. we cannot claim to be a legaltear yan country as long as we allow this to continue. >> what are kids that young getting suspended for? >> that's a very important point. we know from a lot of psych log c cal studies that african-american boys are perceived to be more hostile and threatening than white boys who engage in the same behaviors. i think the huge rise in suspensions and expulsions of african-american boys is in large part a result of that. i talk in the book, for example about trayvon martin, who we know suspended three times, as you say spended for tardyness and one incident of graffiti on a locker and marijuana residue in a bag gi.
10:48 am
i drilled down on his schools own rules which don't provide for suspensions in two of the three situations that are current for him. i theink he's an example. >> he has come to represent so much also representative of this startling trend. i want to turn to you for policy angle. secretary duncan and eric holder have been doing a lot to emphasize the so-called school to prison pipe line. one of the proposals for ameal yor ating that is decrcreating t of guidelines so kids aren't just expelled ash trarly, do you see that happening? >> i hope so. it's a lot more than just a federal, you know, policy to try to deal with this issue at a national level. this boils down to what lisa was saying, it's at the local level. you need governors and state legislators and school boards to
10:49 am
focus in. because at the end of the day, the federal government can say what you can and can't do but it's what happens in the classroom, what the teachers -- how the teachers perceive that child, what they do about that child's behavior, that really drives it and puts the kid in a pipeline if you will, that will lead to problems down the road. i think at the one level we can talk about the federal policy but it really is a very much a local issue. >> all right, thank you so much. michael steele and lisa bloom. i definitely want to come back to this story. it means so much to me and a lot of our viewers and has a profound effect on equality all around us. we'll come back today with a look at one more issue that we feel is underreported and that we looked at all last week and you were all em passioned about, the homelessness crisis. we have a moving story coming up next. ♪
10:50 am
10:53 am
welcome back, everybody. remember, las vegas week we asked you which stories you thought were underreported. and one of your top answers was the heartbreaking increase in homelessness across america right here in new york city, the number of homeless has hit a record high and all last week, we covered different facets of this story through our call to action. we wanted to bring you one final story. one of the most moving that we've found. >> how hard is it to stay positive given the circumstances and where you're living now? >> it's really hard. >> if you pass her on a street, you'd likely have no idea she woke up that morning in a homeless shelter. the 32-year-old mother and her children have lived in a shelter since april. >> everyone in the shelter talked about how hard it is to come forward with these stories. there's a lot of stigma. have you faced that? >> yes. it's been situations where i
10:54 am
didn't want anyone to know where i got off the train because everyone knows that area. everyone knows that building. >> she says she fled an abusive relationship in florida leaving behind a business and a home. for the comfort of her hometown, new york. but when she arrived, she couldn't find work. >> i've been working ever since i was 18 years old. >> and no work meant no money for a home. now, she and her children are just some of the 53,000 who seek refuge in new york city's shelters every single night. 53,000. that's enough to fill every seat in yankee stadium and then some. and the ferocious debate over what to do about homelessness in america, some blame a lack of work ethic. a surprising fact suggests otherwise. the number of homeless men and women with jobs is growing. >> are a lot of the people you're staying with at the
10:55 am
shelter working while they're in the shelter? >> most people are working, yes. most people had jobs, and they just had unfortunate circumstances where they had to live in a shelter. but most everyone there is working, yeah. and it's normal people you would never realize that were in a shelter. >> in fact, there are now more working among the homeless in new york than ever before. according to the city's own data up 57% in just the last three years. >> meet these incredible women that are sometimes holding down two minimum wage jobs. >> mary leads new york's coalition for the homeless. she sees untapped potential. >> homeless people have overcome amazing hurdles in their lives. and so you see that resourcefulness, that resiliency, and that's the kind of thing that you can't buy in somebody who has been given a free pass their whole life. >> nobody is handing her free passes. but she remains hopeful. she's finding job training
10:56 am
programs wherever she can trying to get back on her feet for herself and for her children. >> on the horizon up there somewhere, something's going to turn up. >> and remember, you can vote on the next underreported story we cover on our website. stay with us. up next, "the reid report" is on. put it on my capital one i earn unlimited double miles. hey, you're not the charles barkley? yes i am. nah charles barkley is way taller. there's my picture on the wall. yeah that could be anyone. what about my jersey over there?
10:57 am
oh yeah, that's your jersey. there's my bobble head right behind you. alright well let me see you bobble. yeah, i'm just not buying it man. earn unlimited double miles with no blackout dates from the capital one venture card. my brother john, he works here. john, you know this guy? what's in your wallet?
10:58 am
10:59 am
♪ [ male announcer ] our priority has always been saving the day. because our priority... amazing! [ male announcer ] ...is you! the amazing spider-man 2 delivered by the united states postal service. happy monday, readers, this is the "reid report." and we're following a number of quickly developing stories today. in a moment, president obama in europe, and the big question for u.s. and its allies. what consequences will the west impose on russia to prevent another crimea? and later, hillary clinton and jeb bush offering a possible 2016 preview in texas today. we'll talk the politics and prognostication on the senate and the white house as well as
11:00 am
get you an update on voting rights. but we start with the latest on missing malaysian flight 370. today, there's a particularly difficult development for the families of the passengers and crew. as malaysia's prime minister and airline officially declare that all onboard have been lost. even as crews in australia wait for daylight to renew the search for possible debris. the prime minister of malaysia informed the world that based on new analysis of data, the plane did fly south in the direction of the search area. and that it did, indeed, go down in that area. >> this is a remote location. far from any possible landing sites. it is therefore with deep sadness and regret that i must inform you that according to
140 Views
IN COLLECTIONS
MSNBC West Television Archive Television Archive News Search ServiceUploaded by TV Archive on