Skip to main content

tv   The Rachel Maddow Show  MSNBC  September 6, 2014 3:00am-4:01am PDT

3:00 am
n forum. this is what membership is. this is what membership does. something amazing happened. it didn't have anything to do with the president himself, but it was amazing. >> so with that let me take a few questions. i'll start with julie pace of the associated press. >> thank you, mr. president. i wanted to go back to the situation in ukraine. >> angela king. >> as you know, secretary kerry today. >> julie davis. >> is the goal to ultimately -- secretary kerry said there's no containing that. >> one last question. colleen nelson of the wall street journal. >> how do the concerns of other democrats influence your
3:01 am
thinking. >> notice anything? those were the four questions to the president at his formal press conference today in the uk, all four of them from women journalists. i don't actually think it was on purpose. i think it just sort of worked out that way. that's cool. and while we're on the subject, quiz time. all right. who was the first moderator of "meet the press"? "meet the press," the longest running broadcast series in the history of television. debuted in 1947 on nbc. before that it had been a radio show for a couple years. that's basically your hint to this quiz. the person who hosted "meet the press" as a radio show before it was ever on tv also was the first moderator of "meet the press" when it became a tv show. they brought that person over from radio to tv. who was the first moderator? the first moderator of "meet the press" was martha rountree. it was a woman.
3:02 am
and nobody remembers that now. but it was martha rountree. she was a print journalist starting at the "tampa tribune" i believe. she did sports reporting under the biline m.j. rountree. in radio, she started a program called "leave it to the girls" which was basically, like discussing current events. she also in the same year 1945 founded a program on mercury radio called american mercury radio presents. "meet the press." martha rountree was the moderator and booked someone to face off against a panel of supporters, unscripted. it was a big success. two years into its radio run, nbc brought that program to tv and martha rountree held the reins for the first six years on tv after running it on the radio for two years before that. "meet the press," the longest running show in the history of american television and, of
3:03 am
course, an institution in american politics. and this weekend, the newest iteration of "meet the press" debuts. the new host is our own chuck todd. chuck has already announced plans to try to steer the show back to martha rountree's original roots, a place where at least for some guests the newsmaker will face off against a panel of questioners from the media. they tell us to expect that that's the direction the show is going to go back toward. but this sunday for chuck's first show, his first debut hosting of "meet the press" chuck has a live one-on-one interview scheduled with president obama. and if there was ever a time to try to get this president into a deep conversation, a revealing conversation one-on-one, this is probably the time you'd like to do that. >> you can't contain an organization that is running roughshod through that much territory causing that much
3:04 am
havoc, displacing that many people, killing that in innocents, enslaving that many women. the goal has to be to dismantle them. what we can accomplish is to dismantle this network. we have to act as part of the international community to degrade and ultimately destroy isil. we are going to achieve our goal. we are going to degrade and ultimately defeat isil. the same way that we have gone after al qaeda. we have been very systemic and methodical in going after these kinds of organizations that may threaten u.s. personnel and the homeland. and that deliberation allows us to do it right. >> that deliberation allows us to do it right. and let's be honest, that deliberation also makes everybody crazy in washington. so that's one thing going on
3:05 am
right now. right? is as president obama is basically setting out to assemble the world, to assemble an international coalition involving basically all allied western countries and as many countries as possible in the middle east, a gulf war i style global coalition to fight against this sunni militant group. isis desperately wants itself to be at war with the united states. they want a one-on-one bilateral fight where they're the muslim side and america is the other side. they want america to be at war with them. instead of giving them what they want, president obama is instead basically pulling a pappy bush and colin powell a la gulf war i trying to organize the whole world to a unified action against isis as a universally reviled threat. that's a very tall order and one america politics probably will not have much patience for. if there is going to be a new u.s.-led international coalition
3:06 am
military effort to attack this group, isis, there really is going to have to be a congressional vote on it. in fact, there's going to have to be a congressional vote on keeping up the u.s. air strikes that have started already against isis in iraq. those air strikes legally have to stop at the end of the first week in october unless congress votes to authorize them. so these names you see on screen are all the members of congress who have said so far they support congress debating and voting on u.s. military action against isis. there are 88 members of the house, 6 members of the senate so far. the number has been going up every day. we've been keeping a whip count at our blog if you want to let us know whether your senator, member of congress, ought to be in our whip count. whether they're on board with a debate and vote on this military action. so, that's one thing that's going on, right? there's this very short fuse right now in washington on how
3:07 am
quickly congress needs to get it together to stop just pounding their chests about how terrible isis is and instead start considering what a real military strategy would look like against isis. and whether they want to vote for that military strategy. i mean, this is right now. congress is back as of next week after five weeks off. but once they come back, they've got to get that vote done. they've got to get that debate done and that vote done within the month, or the air strikes end and all the u.s. personnel come back, legally speaking. so getting congress to both do that and to do it quickly, that is not going to be pretty. also today, speaking of not going to be pretty, here's what president obama said today was going to be his homework on the plane ride home from wales. >> what i'm unequivocal about is that we need immigration reform, that my overriding preference is to see congress act. we had bipartisan action in the senate. the house republicans have sat on it for over a year. that has damaged the economy.
3:08 am
it has held america back. it is a mistake. and in the absence of congressional action, i intend to take action. i suspect that on my flight back, this will be part of my reading. taking a look at some of the specifics that we've looked at, and i'll be making an announcement soon. but i want to be very clear, my intention is in the absence of -- in the absence of action by congress, i'm going to do what i can do within the legal constraints of my office because it's the right thing to do for the country. all right? thank you very much, people of wales. i had a wonderful time. >> any minute now, within the hour, actually, the president is due to arrive back at the white house from wales. and according to him, what he said he's going to do on the plane by the time he lands, he will have read up on what he's going to do on immigration without congress. president said earlier in the
3:09 am
summer that he would make that announcement about immigration by the end of the summer. look around you. it's the end of the summer. so, whatever that gets announced, that's going to be like a bag of minx playing with pop rocks and he's leading a nato effort right now which is now repeatedly punching russian president vladimir putin in the kidney over and over again. nato is doing a partnership with two more eastern european countries that vladimir putin likes to think he controls. the president announced today nato would be doing new partnerships with moldova and georgia. that's going to upset vladimir putin. oh, by the way, the national ebola outbreak. if that wasn't enough to gray his hair, as he left wales, a charter flight with americans on board leaving afghanistan trying to fly to dubai was basically forced down inside iran. a plane full of americans ordered to land inside iran by iranian air traffic controllers.
3:10 am
that's in today's news. aren't you glad you're not president? joining us now, andrea mitchell, nbc news chief foreign affairs correspondent and host of "andrea mitchell reports" on msnbc. great to see you. thanks for joining us. >> good to see you. thank you, rachel. i'm always grateful not to be president. right now feels like a particular mess. >> me, too. >> let me ask you about that last point, specifically on this plane. it was -- it seems to have been a charter plane leaving bagram. leaving a u.s. air base in afghanistan, carrying roughly 100 americans. why did it have to land in iran, and how did this situation resolve tonight? >> well, this is actually the only good thing that happened, perhaps, today, in that this was a mistake. it was basically a messup. this is a typical chartered flight. registered to dubai that comes
3:11 am
from bagram and goes through iranian airspace as american flights don't, and was taking 100 americans, 140 people in all, there were some canadians and others, they are contractors, and all sorts of contractors, of course, work at bagram, you know, in afghanistan and in iraq. we have thousands of contractors who are remaining security people, even the people who do food and other services for the military. civilian contractors. they were coming out going to dubai and the flight was delayed for whatever reason, four or five hours. so the flight plan was no longer accurate, and the iranian air traffic controllers didn't recognize this flight and so it had to be worked out. and it was worked out peacefully and diplomatically and easily as it turned out. they weren't forced down as some initial reports said by fighter jets. the air traffic controllers just said, land here in southern iran. and work it out. they sent another plane in to get them out. they lifted off a couple of hours later. they're safely in dubai. it didn't become an international incident. it was worked out between the dubai charter company, and they
3:12 am
didn't even to have bother the american diplomats at the very highest level, the deputy secretary of state who is in geneva right now negotiating the stalled iranian nuclear deal with his iranian counterparts. they didn't get involved. >> wow. so while the iranian nuclear deal is being negotiated and the president is involved in all of these different international negotiations, basically we have the plot of a "three's company" episode unfolding around that plane. okay. that is the good news today. on the more complicated news today, then, there's this issue of the president and the military force he's using and wants to use against isis. the president tonight sent another notification to congress under the war powers resolution, more troops to iraq to protect the embassy in baghdad. what do we know about how the white house and congress are approaching this? are both sides expecting that congress is going to vote at some point? >> both sides are expecting that congress will vote the money. it's becoming more and more clear. i talked to bob menendez, chair of the senate foreign relations committee today. he's called a hearing for
3:13 am
september 16th with both kerry and also hagel coming to testify. after they do their middle east tour. which will start sometime early next week. and so he wants them to testify and hold hearings and have the foreign relations committee at least put something out there. he thinks there will be a debate on the floor. it may not be the formal debate authorizing the use of force that you and i have been wanting to hear. you've been calling for it and making the point in both previous iraq engagements and principally in desert storm, the first one under bush 41, there was a really important debate. it was on a saturday in the senate. it was one of the great debates. you had players on all sides in the democratic and republican parties, crossing lines. it wasn't partisan. it was basically those who felt it was the right thing to do. saddam hussein invaded kuwait. it was a different situation. we were not the initiator but coming at the request of those who had been invaded. >> going to be fascinating to
3:14 am
see how this plays out. we're expecting the president to be at odds with congress over the issue of immigration as he mentioned today. as far as you know, when the white house is approaching these issues about potential authorization for the use of force, at least potentially asking for money to do this stuff, all of these sensitive foreign affairs issues that they are handling now. do they factor in the sort of matrix of how well they're getting along with congress on domestic issues? because i'm imagining this immigration thing, if they make an announcement in the next couple of weeks, it really is going to be pretty nuclear in washington. >> well, in fact, i think what you heard from the president today is kind of a delaying process. what we are hearing from our reporting from people in the white house is they're going to hold off until after the election. they don't want to rock the boat right now for those democrats in red states except for colorado where there are tough races. all of the others, in arkansas, in louisiana, these are places
3:15 am
that do not want a full-throated immigration debate before the election. so with everything so tight right now, there doesn't seem to be any will to take on congress, to do things by executive action. to push that button before the midterms. >> we shall see. fascinating times. andrea mitchell, nbc news chief foreign affairs correspondent. andrea hosts "andrea mitchell reports" every weekday which you should be watching every day. all right. much more ahead including one of the jurors in the bob mcdonnell corruption trial is going to join us next live. one more thing about president obama's trip to wales for the nato summit. this is in wales at the nato summit. prince charles hosting a reception for all the world leaders including the prince, himself, standing at the door greeting all the leaders one by one. they all make small talk and have long awkward handshakes. the president of slovakia did the awkward handshake with. angela merkel. waiting next in line to go meet the prince. her turn for the long awkward handshake followed by small talk. yes, weather's great, how do you say wales in german?
3:16 am
next in line, british prime minister next in line after angela merkel. david cameron comes in. right? they obviously already know each other. quick bow. they say hello. look what happen, look what happens when president obama gets there. one of these kids is not like the others. president obama arrives. look what happens. they burst into applause. look. it's him. it's him. i don't know why president obama got the round of applause for his handshake with prince charles. unlike all the rest of them today. but if barack obama does want to run for office again after he is no longer president, it sounds like wales would be happy to have him. all right. we'll be right back. ♪
3:17 am
♪ fill their bowl with the meaty tastes they're looking for, with friskies grillers. tender meaty pieces and crunchy bites. in delicious chicken, beef, turkey, and garden veggie flavors. friskies grillers.
3:18 am
who's more excited about back to school savthe ladies?ples? these guys? or these guys? when you get guaranteed low prices
3:19 am
on everything you buy the most, everybody gets excited! staples. make more happen for less. welllllllll, not when your travel rewards card makes it so hard to get a seat using your miles. that's their game. the flights you want are blacked out. or they ask for some ridiculous number of miles. honestly, it's time to switch to the venture card from capital one. with venture, use your miles on any airline, any flight, any time. no blackout dates. and with every purchase, you'll earn unlimited double miles. from now on, no one's taking your seat away. what's in your wallet? don't have allergies every night... just on allergy nights. [ sneezes ] [ male announcer ] that's why there's new vicks qlearquil for night. the powerfully effective, take it only when you need it, so you can have a good night allergy medicine. one by one, family and friends coming here to the mcdonnell family home after
3:20 am
learning the former governor and his wife were found guilty in a slew of corruption charges. >> he's a good man and bob will rise again. >> this family friend who only wanted to be identified as terri takes the groceries inside, gets dinner started and then returns to dish on a verdict the family is finding hard to swallow. >> everybody's devastated. they're in disbelief. i have friends who are attorneys, judges, and they've all said to me, bob must have done something to upset someone in the federal government because this jury would be hard pressed to find any corruption. i think maybe people think this was all fabricated. >> no, this is all too real, says this family friend. now focused on trying to bring comfort and support during a very dark time. >> it's unbelievable. compare it to christ. christ didn't do anything. and they went after him. >> yes. yes, they did go after christ.
3:21 am
noted. noted sort of without comment. that's local coverage from the nbc station in washington, northern virginia, nbc 12. we set aside for the moment the issue of going after christ. i should also tell you that they do also go after and catch a member of congress or a governor about every two years now in our country. in the past decade, we've been on a pretty tight two-year schedule of locking up members of congress and/or governors every other year. we seem to like to do that in odd numbered years. so start, say, 2005. it was john roland. the republican governor of connecticut. he resigned while being investigated for corruption. got convicted and sentenced to a year in prison. incidentally, john roland is out of prison but back in court on other corruption-related charges. also in 2005, corruption charges against duke cunningham, republican member of congress from california. he was sentenced to eight years in prison for bribery and corruption.
3:22 am
in 2007, it was ohio republican congressman bob ney, first elected official convicted in the jack abramoff schedule, luxury vacations and fancy meals and sky box seats. bob ney sentenced to 30 minutes in prison. he actually got more than the prosecutors had asked for. the judge in the bob ney case told him at the sentencing, "as a member of congress, you have the responsibility above all else to set an example and uphold the law." then the judge sentenced him to more than the prosecutors asked for. is what the prosecutors asked for plus an extra three months. rear. then two years later, it was democratic congressman william jefferson of louisiana, he was 2009's poster boy. he was the guy with the cold hard cash. bundles of large denomination bills wrapped up in aluminum foil and stuffed into his freezer. sentenced in 2009 to 13 years in prison. one of the longer sentences in this cast of characters. but then two years later, it was rod blagojevich, the democratic
3:23 am
governor of illinois, sentenced to an also impressive 14 years in prison after he was convicted on 17 corruption charges including soliciting bribes to sell an appointment to barack obama's u.s. senate seat. then, every two years, two years later, this time 2013, back to illinois, for congressman jesse jackson jr. sentenced to 2 1/2 years in prison for redirecting his campaign funds to buy things like expensive michael jackson memorabilia. and those are the ones just off the top of my head. i mean, those are just the household name corruption and bribery convictions that resulted in members of congress and governors going to prison. but those household name ones, it's interesting, they do for whatever reason seem to happen every two years. '05, '07, '09, 2011, 2013. we just found out in 2015, 6 days into 2015, right on schedule, we're due for another. they're going to be sentencing the next american governor to go to prison on multiple felony corruption charges. it's going to be bob mcdonnell of virginia.
3:24 am
convicted along with his wife on 11 felony charges of corruption yesterday in richmond. and one thing i learned this week is the guidelines for sentencing in federal cases are publicly available. you can look at the sentencing guidelines yourself with the google. you can build your own federal sentencing guidelines matrix for your favorite federal convict. so in the case of bob mcdonnell, you go here to the united states sentencing commission guidelines manual. it's posted online. it's publicly available. just google it. you skip down to chapter 2, part "c." that's offenses involving public officials. and then you at home can calculate what the offense level was and, therefore, how much time he might get offered for offering, giving, soliciting, receiving a bride, extortion, fraud involving the depravation for honest service, that's bob. that's level 14. bob mcdonnell is a public official. that's offense level 14. write that down. did the offense involve more than one bribe or extortion? if so, increase by two levels.
3:25 am
okay. 14 plus 2. did the value of the payment or the benefit received exceed $5,000? it did. then it brings you to another table which gives you the range. yeah, he was more than $120,000, but less than $200,000. so add 10 to his offense level. if the offense level involves not just an elected official, but an official in a high level decision-making or sensitive position, governor counts for that, right? then you add another four. so, then the rest of the stuff, it's like, about, sneaking people into the country and something like that. i'm not a lawyer, but i don't think he did that. so that's how you come up with the guidelines. you add up all those various levels of offense in the bob mcdonnell case, i'm not a lawyer, this is a layman's guess. i do 14 plus 2 plus 10 plus 4.
3:26 am
carry the 1 and that means offense level of 30. put that on the sentencing table. that's the "y" there. the only other thing you need to figure out for the guidelines is bob mcdonnell's criminal history category. doesn't have any criminal history. that puts him at a zero there. that just means you got your matrix there. figure it out. it tells you what it is. according to the guidelines, that means bob mcdonnell is looking at 97 months to 121 months in prison. 97 months to 121 months in prison, divide by 12, there you go. that means he's looking at eight to ten years. that's what the federal sentencing guidelines say. and these guidelines, i should say, are "a" interpreted by lawyers and judges and not by jerks like me on tv, "b," these federal sentencing guidelines are not binding. they don't have to sentence him to that. they're suggestions to the judge. that's the range and the federal sentencing guideline in his case and does give you some idea about what the government might
3:27 am
ask for in terms of how long bob mcdonnell is going to go to prison. of course, it will be up to the judge to decide how long he goes for and the judge will look at those guidelines and will consider the severity of the case, will consider the overall judicial imperative of deterrence in a case like this. deterrence, when you're talking about this type of crime, public corruption by a high-level official, it's a small audience of americans who you are trying to deter from doing this. right? it's governors and members of congress and other people in high-level positions of public officialdom. right? who might be tempted to sell their power, to sell their office for ferrari rides and rolexes. the judge has to decide in this case whether the length of the sentence has to be so draconian that it will make would-be corrupt politicians think of bob mcdonnell instead of just thinking of a payoff when they get offered the bribe in the future. or the judge could decide that,
3:28 am
you know, the sentence length here isn't going to make the difference. he can afford to be merciful because the conviction of bob mcdonnell, itself, the conviction enough is a shock enough to the system in virginia that that, alone, will provide necessary deterrence. it's worth considering whether or not the conviction of bob mcdonnell has been a shock to the political system in virginia. there are some indications already in the days since the verdict that virginia is not all that shocked. at least not shocked into thinking they're doing anything wrong or they need to change anything. i'll give you an example. the top republican in the virginia state senate gave a statement to the "washington post" after the guilty verdicts were announced yesterday. here was his take on his state's governor being found guilty on all those corruption counts. his name is thomas, the top republican in the virginia senate, he responded to the convictions this way. "bob mcdonnell served virginia with distinction." is there a but coming? nope. "bob mcdonnell served virginia with distinction. governor mcdonnell served virginia, an impressive record of accomplishments."
3:29 am
he said this after the conviction, "ultimately the ordeal of this trial should not diminish that record." the trial did find him guilty of 11 felony counts of corruption. that shouldn't affect how we see the record that he accumulated while also doing 11 felonious -- apparently that is still considered a distinguished record and serving with honor if you ask the top republican in the virginia state senate. amazing. how hard will the judge in the bob mcdonnell case come down on governor mcdonnell? and in a not unrelated question, how hard was it to convict him? how hard of a time did the jurors have in coming up with this devastating list of 11 verdicts for this virginia governor? one of those jurors joins us live, next. this is mary, a woman who loves to share her passions. grandma! mary has atrial fibrillation, an irregular heartbeat not caused by a heart valve problem. that puts her at a greater risk of stroke. rome? sure! before xarelto®, mary took warfarin, which required monthly trips to get her blood tested.
3:30 am
but that's history. back to the museum? not this time! now that her doctor switched her to once-a-day xarelto®, mary can leave those monthly trips behind. domestic flight? not today! like warfarin, xarelto® is proven effective to reduce afib-related stroke risk. but xarelto® is the first and only once-a-day prescription blood thinner for patients with afib not caused by a heart valve problem that doesn't require regular blood monitoring. so mary is free of that monitoring routine. for patients currently well managed on warfarin, there is limited information on how xarelto® and warfarin compare in reducing the risk of stroke. xarelto® is just one pill a day taken with the evening meal. spinach? grazie! plus, with no known dietary restrictions, mary can eat the healthy foods she likes. don't stop taking xarelto®, rivaroxaban, unless your doctor tells you to. while taking xarelto®, you may bruise more easily and it may take longer for bleeding to stop. xarelto® may increase your risk of bleeding if you take certain medicines.
3:31 am
xarelto® can cause serious bleeding, and in rare cases, may be fatal. get help right away if you develop unexpected bleeding, unusual bruising, or tingling. if you have had spinal anesthesia while on xarelto®, watch for back pain or any nerve or muscle related signs or symptoms. do not take xarelto® if you have an artificial heart valve or abnormal bleeding. tell your doctor before all planned medical or dental procedures. before starting xarelto®, tell your doctor about any conditions, such as kidney, liver, or bleeding problems. switching to xarelto® was the right move for mary. ask your doctor about once-a-day xarelto®. no regular blood monitoring; no known dietary restrictions. for information and savings options download the xarelto® patient center app, call 1-888-xarelto, or visit goxarelto.com
3:32 am
oh, he fakes a handoff quaand he's making a run..... for mattress discounters fall kickoff sale! right now, save up to $300 on sealy posturepedic and serta mattress sets. even get 24 months interest-free financing on every tempur-pedic. you're going to love their football field-size selection. this calls for a little touchdown dance. don't miss the fall kickoff sale at mattress discounters. ♪ mattress discounters
3:33 am
anything to say for all the virginians watching out there? >> all i can say is my trust remains in the lord, and thank you. >> my trust remains in the lord. sentencing for governor robert mcdonnell and his wife, maureen, is scheduled for january. after they were convicted yesterday in federal court in richmond. joining us now for the interview, kathleen carmody, she was one of the 12 jurors in this trial. miss carmody, thank you very much for being willing to talk to us tonight. i really appreciate your time. >> certainly. good evening. >> good evening. this was a long trial. weeks of testimony.
3:34 am
more than 60 witnesses. the governor, himself, testified for more than 20 hours. can you just describe for those of us who have never done anything like this, describe the experience overall and how much -- how difficult it was for you, how much work it was? >> it was very difficult. there was a lot of information provided. testimony. exhibits and actual items as well. over the course of those five weeks. it was a lot to take in and a lot to digest, really, and all the information coming at us. >> in terms of the judge and his facilitating your being able to come to a verdict, a lot was made about how long those jury instructions were. something like 89 or 90 different jury instructions over a period of a couple hours, took a break in the middle of instructing you. was that essentially a clarifying point in the process for you? getting those instructions about how to consider the evidence, how to sort out all the different things you'd been presented? >> yes.
3:35 am
yes. it was. and i thought they were very clear. >> okay. how -- how did you assess the importance of the defense saying in essence that the mcdonnells' marriage was bad and that was very legally -- very legally relevant? i mean, we're all -- none of us can tell what their marriage is like from the outside. i've always believed that you can only tell what a marriage is like if you're in. but did you believe that case from the defense? did it matter to your assessments about guilt and innocence? >> i -- i heard it and i did not doubt that there was strain in the marriage and stress and that mrs. mcdonnell was having a difficult time adjusting as first lady of virginia. however, they remained under the same roof during all this time, up until the time of the trial. they were under the same roof. they vacationed together. we saw evidence of text messages, phone messages. it just -- i don't doubt that there was some strain, but it did not, to me, come across as being as broken as portrayed.
3:36 am
>> the importance of them communicating throughout this time, having contact living under the same roof, it meant legally they could have conspired or communicated about these criminal acts? >> well, there certainly could have been opportunity. >> yeah. why didn't you convict on the relatively simple charges, lying to the banks? when i looked at these charges just as a layman, somebody not on the jury, that part, at least, seems pretty clear, they didn't tell the truth to the banks. why are those charges ones on which they were acquitted? >> well, we looked at every one of the 26 charges and presumed innocence and went through all the evidence one by one to see if there was something that it could be disproved. those were the two that we could not find evidence to support. and that's why they were not
3:37 am
guilty on those bank statements. >> one last question for you. and it's, again, about this issue of i guess the style of the defense but also the fact this was a joint trial. did you want to hear from mrs. mcdonnell? do you think that would have been helpful either to your understanding of the totality of the case or to one side or the other? >> it -- i don't think it would have swayed me one way or the other. maybe it would have been of, you know, certainly of interest to hear her perspective, but it certainly for me would not have swayed me one way or the other. there was sufficient testimony and evidence provided already. >> kathleen carmody, serving on a jury is always a solemn experience. people worry about how tough it would be. this seems like it was absolutely grueling. thank you for doing your civic duty and talking to us about what it was like. i really appreciate it. >> you're welcome. thank you. all right. we have lots more ahead tonight at the end of this very, very busy news week. we'll be right back. stay with us. ave surface
3:38 am
pores where bacteria can multiply. polident kills 99.99% of odor-causing bacteria and helps dissolve stains. for a cleaner, fresher, brighter denture everyday. when folks think about wthey think salmon and energy. but the energy bp produces up here creates something else as well: jobs all over america. engineering and innovation jobs. advanced safety systems & technology. shipping and manufacturing. across the united states, bp supports more than a quarter million jobs. when we set up operation in one part of the country, people in other parts go to work. that's not a coincidence. it's one more part of our commitment to america. it's so simple. it's just game. like my car insurance. i saved 15% in fifteen minutes. don't live in shirlee's world, live in the modern world. where you could save money on car insurance in half the time. esurance, backed by allstate. click or call. while a body in motion tends to stay in motion.
3:39 am
staying active can ease arthritis symptoms. but if you have arthritis, this can be difficult. prescription celebrex can help relieve arthritis pain, and improve daily physical function so moving is easier. because just one 200mg celebrex a day can provide 24 hour relief for many with arthritis pain. and it's not a narcotic. you and your doctor should balance the benefits with the risks. all prescription nsaids, like celebrex, ibuprofen, naproxen and meloxicam have the same cardiovascular warning. they all may increase the chance of heart attack or stroke, which can lead to death. this chance increases if you have heart disease or risk factors such as high blood pressure or when nsaids are taken for long periods. nsaids, like celebrex, increase the chance of serious skin or allergic reactions, or stomach and intestine problems, such as bleeding and ulcers, which can occur without warning and may cause death. patients also taking aspirin and the elderly are at increased risk for stomach bleeding and ulcers. don't take celebrex if you have bleeding in the stomach or intestine, or had an asthma attack, hives, other allergies to aspirin, nsaids or sulfonamides.
3:40 am
get help right away if you have swelling of the face or throat, or trouble breathing. tell your doctor your medical history and ask your doctor about celebrex. for a body in motion. [ mala bit of italy when ycomes home with you. bertolli. your house? [ laughs ] [ male announcer ] with the taste of our chicken florentine farfalle skillets for two. bertolli. italy is served. i feel honor bound to tell you that there is a cocktail moment coming up at the end of the show tonight because no reason. but it's a really excellent cocktail moment and happy friday and that's ahead. stay with us. [ male announcer ] if you're taking multiple medications,
3:41 am
does your mouth often feel dry? a dry mouth can be a side effect of many medications but it can also lead to tooth decay and bad breath. that's why there's biotene. available as an oral rinse, toothpaste, spray or gel, biotene can provide soothing relief, and it helps keep your mouth healthy, too. remember, while your medication is doing you good, a dry mouth isn't. biotene -- for people who suffer from dry mouth.
3:42 am
a dry mouth isn't. stronger than peoples twice her size.er was and that strength inspired his liquid muscle cleaner. it lifts tough dirt so you do less scrubbing. and its nozzle stops by itself... ...so less is wasted sure made grandma proud. mr. clean liquid muscle. veggies you're cool... reworking the menu. mayo, corn dogs...you are so out of here! ahh... the complete balanced nutrition of
3:43 am
great tasting ensure. 24 vitamins and minerals. 9 grams of protein... with 30% less sugars than before. ensure, your #1 dr. recommended brand now introduces ensure active. muscle health. clear protein drink and high protein. targeted nutrition to feed your active life. ensure. take life in. sweater, extra sweater oh and this is the xfinity tv go app. he can watch live tv from over 50 channels and xfinity on demand movies and shows wherever he wants. have fun, make some friends. alright? did i mention his neck pillow? (blowing) ♪
3:44 am
the nba playoffs this year were particularly good. in the end, it was the san antonio spurs from the west and the miami heat from the east. it was the spurs who won the whole enchilada this year in the nba, but there were a lot of good games throughout the whole playoffs including one truly excellent nail biter of a game between the oklahoma thunder and memphis grizzlies. the two teams played a total of seven games in the series. this was game five. and it really, really went down to the wire. the thunder was hosting. the game was on their home court in oklahoma city. in the end, it came down to a one-point game.
3:45 am
the grizzlies won by a score of 100-99. the thunder would have won the whole thing at the last fraction of the second if their very last shot at the buzzer which went in, if that shot had been ruled eligible, they would have won, but that last-second shot was ruled not eligible so the grizzlies won. just a thrilling game. would have been great to be there. if you are an oklahoma thunder fan and had a chance to be there at that home court game, there's probably nothing that could have kept you home from that, right? that was true at least for oklahoma's governor. mary fallon. because that's where she was that night. she was there at game five. a week before, the state supreme court in oklahoma had issued a stay of execution for an oklahoma prisoner, but the governor thought the supreme courts was wrong to to that, she thought the state should go ahead and kill the prisoner anyway so he issued an executive order defying the supreme court and scheduling that man's execution for april 29th.
3:46 am
night of the thunder/grizzlies game she was planning to go to. also same night that another execution was already planned in execution -- in oklahoma. excuse me. that executive order from oklahoma's governor, set up oklahoma to kill two men in one night. a back-to-back execution for the first time in 77 years. they also planned to do the execution with an experimental drug combination that they had never used before in the state. and then their usual doctor, the doctor who usually does all the lethal injections in oklahoma, he backed out of doing the executions that night. he backed out two days before. so, overruling the supreme court to make the execution go forward, making it a double for the first time in 77 years, using a new drug and losing the
3:47 am
doctor. heading into that on the night of april 29th, governor mary fallon went to the basketball game then the killing of the first of the two prisoners that night went very, very wrong. they said he was unconscious but he came back during the process. he spoke. he writhed. he gasped. they pulled the curtain. they say they considered trying to revive him. they thought about trying to call an ambulance in the middle of the execution to take him to a hospital since he wasn't dying and they didn't have any plan to bring him back. ultimately, they never did bring him back. and they never re-opened the curtain to the witnesses who were supposed to be watching him die. and they said he eventually just died of a massive heart attack. we now know governor mary fallon of oklahoma was at the basketball game on the phone with the prison while they couldn't get him to die and while they couldn't get him unconscious, either. we now know on the phone from the nba playoffs, mary fallon was about to order a stay of execution but he finally died while they were on the phone while she was at the game and decided maybe not to try to kill the other prisoner who was waiting for his turn that night and the game went on.
3:48 am
now oklahoma has released their own internal review into how they did that night at the state prison. >> the execution has widely been described as botched. was it a botched execution? >> you know, different people have different perspectives. and how you described this execution is how you describe it. >> where was governor fallin when the call was made to her autopsy that only one vein was viable, and who made the final call to proceed once that was clear? >> you know where the governor was at, captain? >> i'm not certain exactly where she was. >> i don't know where the governor was physically located at. >> the governor was a the chesapeake energy arena in oklahoma city, in fact, watching basketball. the night she was overseeing her state killing two prisoners on her orders. now that they've reviewed their
3:49 am
own actions, are they going to start right back up again the same way day were going before? joining us, ziva branstetter, an investigative reporter and the enterprise reporter for the "tulsa world" newspaper, one of 12 media witnesses to attend the execution of clayton lockett. thanks for being here. appreciate your indictment appreciate your time. >> thanks for having me, rachel. >> how did you find out governor fallin had been at the basketball game on the night the two executions were scheduled because of her order? >> we heard this actually yesterday from sources that we have. they didn't want to be identified. she was asked during her press conference where she was. she said at an event downtown. she was asked, were you at a thunder game? she said, yes, i was at an event downtown. so we made sure to follow up with her spokesman and they confirm can she was at a thunder game. >> one of the issues was the attempted and somewhat failed
3:50 am
injection of the lethal injection into the groin of this prisoner. what is the state now explaining what what went wrong and how it went so wrong? >> the report released yesterday said they made roughly 12 attempts to start an iv in various areas of the inmate's body. however, it was improperly inserted. the doctor didn't have the right-sized needle. he asked for longer needles, was told the prison didn't have any. the paramedic didn't have any tape to tape down one of the iv attempts. so there was missing medical equipment, and they decided to go forward any way. there was also no ultrasound machine on hand which would have helped this process, as well. >> overall, with those kinds of basic errors, you heard the way the state official there tried to answer questions about whether this was botched. do you expect that they are going to have changed very much at all before they try again?
3:51 am
i understand they've got the next one of these scheduled for november 13th. >> they do. they haven't said whether they're going to be ready on november 13th. there's a lot of unanswered questions. we don't know whether they're going to use this drug which hasn't worked very well. there's a lot of changes they need to make, including having life-saving equipment in case the execution is stopped. so it will be interesting. but they haven't said what they're going to change. >> remember again this was also the execution that sparked a doj investigation into death penalty means around the country. thank you very much for helping us understand this tonight. i appreciate it. >> thank you, rachel. >> we'll be right back. stay with us. ♪
3:52 am
♪ fill their bowl with the meaty tastes they're looking for, with friskies grillers. tender meaty pieces and crunchy bites. in delicious chicken, beef, turkey, and garden veggie flavors. friskies grillers. don't just dream of being the hero.
3:53 am
make it happen. i can't believe we're missing the game for this. we're not-- i've got xlte. it doubles our 4g lte bandwidth in cities nationwide, so be that guy with verizon xlte. now get 1gb of bonus data, and our best pricing ever on the more everything plan. (vo) ours is a world of the red-eyes. (daughter) i'm really tired. (vo) the transfers. well, that's kid number three. (vo) the co-pilots. all sitting... ...trusting... ...waiting... ...for a safe arrival. introducing the all-new subaru legacy. designed to help the driver in you... ...care for the passenger in them. the subaru legacy. it's not just a sedan. it's a subaru. smoking with chantix. as a police officer, i've helped many people in the last 23 years. but i needed help in quitting smoking. along with support, chantix (varenicline) is proven to help people quit smoking. chantix reduced the urge for me to smoke.
3:54 am
it actually caught me by surprise. some people had changes in behavior, thinking or mood, hostility, agitation, depressed mood and suicidal thoughts or actions while taking or after stopping chantix. if you notice any of these, stop chantix and call your doctor right away. tell your doctor about any history of mental health problems, which could get worse while taking chantix. don't take chantix if you've had a serious allergic or skin reaction to it. if you develop these, stop chantix and see your doctor right away as some could be life threatening. tell your doctor if you have a history of heart or blood vessel problems, or if you develop new or worse symptoms. get medical help right away if you have symptoms of a heart attack or stroke. use caution when driving or operating machinery. common side effects include nausea, trouble sleeping and unusual dreams. i did not know what it was like to be a non-smoker. but i do now. ask your doctor if chantix is right for you. virtually all your important legal matters in just minutes. now it's quicker and easier for you to start your business, protect your family, and launch your dreams. at legalzoom.com we put the law on your side.
3:55 am
you know you care. pro football is back. last night the nfl season got under way. seahawks hosted the packers. seattle dominated 36-16. they looked every inch like the defending super bowl champs they are. last year they hosted the lombardi trophy for the first time. the super bowl trophy is named for vince lombardi, the green bay coach who is a football icon and american icon. vince lombardi was a man who said things like, winning is not a sometimes thing, it is an all the time thing. you do not do things right once in a while, you do them right all the time. he also said, the harder you work, the harder it is to surrender. he had hundreds of those. if vince lombardi fails to inspire you, it's probably your problem. and because he is vince lombardi the hero, every year, every player in the national football
3:56 am
league chases a trophy named lombardi. that includes as of this week a player named michael sam who was cut by the st. louis rams who drafted him back in april in the 7th round. he was cut by st. louis, but the university of missouri defensive end, s.e.c. co-defensive player of the year, he got signed by somebody else, he got picked up by the dallas cowboys. dallas has what could politely be called defense issues this year. they could really use mr. sam's pass rushing ability. they need defense, they picked him up. that said, he's michael sam. you may also know him in this context. >> i'm not afraid to tell the world who i am. i'm michael sam. i'm a college graduate. i'm african-american. and i'm gay. >> since that announcement, michael sam and will the league accept an openly gay player,
3:57 am
that's become a sports media freakout beyond anything anyone could have imagined. and yet second guessing his talents and speculation about his showering habits, really, seriously? michael sam went to work, had a solid preseason, sacked johnny manziel. the sky didn't fall. now he gets to play football in texas. vince lombardi, whose trophy everybody was chasing, is from a different era. but he might have made a great coach. in a biography of lombardi, the story is told of a running back named roy mcdonald who, in 1968, was arrested for a public sexual encounter with another man. >> coach lombardi could have none of it, and one of the
3:58 am
reasons was, his own brother was also gay. vince did know that herald was gay. here's where the coach shared app open mind. he ignored catholic teaching against homosexuality and considered gays another group deserving respect like blacks and italians, american indians. in later years, he would have players that were gay and would quietly root for them. players like michael sam, right? vince lombardi died in 1970. 44 years later an openly gay player is making a living playing a game they both loved. winning is not a sometimes thing. in honor of coach lombardi and
3:59 am
michael sam, all the players and the fact that the season starts this weekend, your simple cocktail moment this weekend, i make a bastardized version of this, because i believe in deliciousness over purity when it comes to cocktails that have beer in them. you want a delicious mexican beer like modelo, juice of one good lime. you want a couple teaspoons of a nice hot sauce, i recommend something like a chilula. two teaspoons of the magic ingredient here, which is called magi, which i don't freaking know what it is. you want equal parts of that and hot sauce and black pepper. worcestershire saw. and if you're really, really not watching your sodium intake, you should also salt the glass before you start the whole thing. my doctor won't let me do that anymore. so salt your glass.
4:00 am
they don't need clamato juice. happy nfl season starting. congratulations. take care. still a mystery. the search for the so-called ghost plane that crashed somewhere near jamaica. there's new information today. taking up the fight. president obama says at least nine u.s. allies will join force toss destroy isis. who are the nine and how might they help? a juror in the bob mcdonnell trial is talking. plus, a gauge on the chances that the governor could spend 25 years in jail. the death of joan rivers. questions are still swirling about how she died, even after a medical examiner's report. good morning,