to debunk it a lot of times they double down the beliefs, that maybe you could starve the oxygen and not see this stuff, is very appealing. but also in some sci-fi way, it's like who is pulling the strings on what we know. chris mooney thank you very much for joining us. really appreciate it. >> great to be here. that is "all in" for this evening. "the rachel maddow show" starts right now. >> i would trust your algorithm any day. >> that is the sweetest thing anybody has ever said to me. >> it sounded kind of robotic when i said it. thank you, my friend. thanks to you at home for joining us this hour. happy wednesday. good news for anybody who is rooting against isis. look at this footage today. look at this. this was shot today in a suburb of tikrit. in northern iraq. isis the isis terrorists in control of tikrit and the surrounding suburbs for months now, what this footage from today shows is the celebration of the people of this one

suburb the suburb called al alum, people celebrating and dancing and cheering because the iraqi government troops and the militia they're fighting with defeated isis there, and kicked isis out of this town. at one point in this footage, you see a guy, he comes up to the troops and he's holding a pot of coffee. this guy here. he's holding a pot of coffee. and you can hear what he's saying here if we up the sound a little bit. he says and we translated the arabic, he said we welcome you. you are welcome, welcome. may god protect and bless you. he gives the coffee to these iraqi soldiers. the little girl you just saw, she gets asked again, in arabic, how do you feel right now? the little girl answers back i am very happy, because you came and rid us of the militants. and then the soldiers here dancing, and cheering and jumping up and down also this group of iraqi women you can see dancing and cheering and chanting. what they are saying in arabic

is sunnis and shiites are brothers. we will never sell this homeland. sunnis and shiites are brothers. and then of course a lot of this footage, because they're happy, they shoot their guns in the air. sunnis and shiites are brother. this is a reason to are cheerful all over the world. in part because sunni and shiite able to get along. it is also 100% totally key to what it means to fight against this barbaric terrorist group isis. if you are rooting against isis if you are concerned about the fight against isis the fight against isis is not an esoteric thing right now, it is an active fight under way with real bullets and real guns house-to-house, town-to-town, happening right now. a region in iraq that is sunni. isis is also sunni.

very sunni terrorist group. these troops and these militias that have come in to fight isis in western iraq for the most part they are not sunni. most of them at least are shiites from the iraqi military. and these mostly shiite militias that the iraqi military is fighting with. so these shiite groups are coming into this sunni area and they are having some success fighting against the sunni terrorist groups isis. if that is making the people on the ground this these towns sing shiites and sunnis are brothers, if that is making the sunni towns people liberated from the terrible sunni terrorists, if it's making them give coffee to the shiite soldiers who rescued them to thank them that progress across the sectarian divide in a place where that sectarian divide can be everything in the whole world, that progress is both fascinating to see, and heartening. amazing as that footage is today, and it got wide play

today, here's the thing. here's the thing that is tricky specifically for americans who are, you know understandably psyched about seeing isis get their butts kicked in this one part of iraq what's tricky about that even though it is heartening, is that, yeah it's the iraqi military kicking isis' butt in this part of iraq but honestly, the only reason they're able to do that is because they're getting a lot of help from a country called iran. the shiite militias fighting alongside the iraqi government and beating isis those shiite militias are being coordinated by iran. they're literally being led on the ground by iranian revolutionary guard generals who are there in person on the front lines in iraq in the fight against isis. that is awkward for americans, because, i mean there's us and iran. basically we're the great satan to them. they're the great satan to us. and so you have to be able to

absorb a little more nuance than that. because iran hates isis. we hate isis. iran is fighting isis. we are fighting isis. and isis in places like this little town, where we got this footage from today, isis is paying a price for that for having powerful enemies of all different stripes. but our american politicians here at home are also paying a tiny little price for it themselves. because apparently it is hurting their brains to try to understand this tiny little single nuance. in washington today, the senate foreign relations committee held high-level hearings with the joint chiefs of staff, and secretary of defense and secretary of state, the fight against isis of course is also under way. the u.s. has led more than 2,700 air strikes against isis targets both in iraq and in syria. but congress has never weighed in on it. president obama has just ordered those strikes, ordered this

month-long offensive on his own authority. even though congress likes to talk about isis and how tough they want to be about fighting isis, congress has actually not been tough enough to formally debate that action let alone go on the record about it and take a vote about it to decide whether or not it should happen or whether that military effort should happen in some other way. they like to talk about isis as a threat and how tough they feel about it. they have not yet done anything anything practical about making any sort of decision about how to fight isis. so today this hearing in the senate was supposed to lay the groundwork for congress starting to have that discussion. congress eventually maybe even taking a vote on the way president obama has already started this war against isis. but iran is also fighting a war against isis. we are prosecuting a war against isis with or without congress. iran is fighting a war against isis. we are fighting on the same side as iran against the same enemy.

i think that is a nuance too far. for some of the great minds in the world's greatest deliberative body. >> iran's goal is to become the regional -- >> probably true yes. >> they're never excited to see additional american troops anywhere in the middle east. that's a fair statement? >> i can't tell what excites them. i can't imagine that our bombing isil is unwelcome to them. >> okay. so this is ash carter the new defense secretary, saying i don't know what excites them senator, but whatever else you think about iran honestly iran is psyched that we are bombing isis. >> i can't imagine that our bombing isil is unwelcome to them. but i don't know that because i don't know what they're thinking. >> well, bombing isil is unwelcome to them. >> no backwards. bombing isis is very welcome to them.

again, there's not that many pieces on this chessboard. iran is fighting isis. we are fighting isis. us bombing isis iran likes that. that is welcome. marco rubio thinks it's the opposite. his office told us today that he misheard what the defense secretary said today at that hearing. he must have really misheard it because marco rubio kept repeating it today. >> because as we heard from secretary carter they are not fans of us bombing isis because it involves our presence in the region. >> no! they are fans of us bombing isis, senator. he said the opposite. iran is fighting isis. they don't like us. but they do like us bombing isis. it is not that complicated. but apparently it is just too complex to grasp in washington right now. again, senator rubio's office told us he misheard the defense secretary ash carter on this today. that's why he kept talking about it backwards. it was not just today.

senator rubio has made this mistake before. >> i understand why the president has not put in place a military strategy to defeat isis. if we wanted to defeat them militarily, we can do it. he doesn't want to upset iran. that's why we haven't done it. >> it would not upset iran for the united states to militarily defeat isis. iran is fighting isis, too. we may disagree with iran on lots of stuff. but when it comes to isis this one thing, us and iran, we feel the same. but it is -- marco rubio is a part of this. but he is part of a deep tide of, i don't get it right now on foreign policy on one side of american politics. and i say it's only happening on one side of american politics because there is this tide now, of not just democratic astonishment, but astonishment from the mainstream media, and from mainstream republicans that is cresting right now against what senator rubio, and most other republican senators just fundamentally don't understand

about this really big issue of iran. the "new york daily news" front page this week they called these republican senators who signed the letter to iran this week, called them traitors. that is the thing that has obviously got the most attention in terms of the media response to what republican senators have done about iran this week in sending them this letter. but even beyond the "new york daily news" traitors front page the nation's editorial pages on this subject are just as off the charts. for example, here's the concord monitor from new hampshire. the republican senators who wrote the letter to iran this week quote, are playing a political game dangerously out of bounds. if the open letter to iran represents the path forward for u.s. foreign policy, chaos is the destination. it is simply stunning they write, that new hampshire senator kelly ayotte and 46 other senators cannot see that. unlike the thousands of other times senator ayotte signed her

name, she will remember this signature. it's not every day that a united states senator attempts to undermine foreign policy and weaken the nation in one feld swoop. that's kelly ayotte's hometown paper. in kentucky they lead their editorial bluntly. has congress gone crazy? that's what many u.s. observers and much of the world must be wondering after a group of rogue are republican senators wrote a letter to iran. among the 47 senators signing the letter kentucky's mitch mcconnell the new senate majority leader and rand paul with presidential aspirations. this is the paper calling out the two home state senators. mr. mcconnell took over the leadership post this year to end dysfunction and return the senate to a working body. that effort appears off to a poor start. and if mr. paul's signature represents his grasp of foreign

policy republicans should be justifiably leery of him of a presidential nominee. whatever the outcome of negotiations with iran the 47 senators have done irreparable harm. it is regrettable that kentucky's two senators were among them. louisville courier journal. here's a headline in the salt lake city tribune in utah. utah senators increase risk of war. senators lee and hatch join a foolish campaign. it will be up to history to judge whether the latest partisan stunt joined by utah senators mike lee and orrin hatch ends a wartime warmongering or just another bit of buffoonery on the world stage. the republicans who dispatched this letter have disgraced themselves and undermined the credibility of the nation of the constitution they took an oath to uphold. rand paul marco rubio and ted

cruz, at minimum, signing such a letter should disqualify each man from holding the high office they seek to degrade. here's the pittsburgh post gazette. the letter sent monday by 47 republican letters to iran was damaging to america's role in the world. the senators who signed the letter should be ashamed. senator john mccain, who was one of the senators who signed this letter, now seems to be expressing some regret about having signed it. he told greta van susteren maybe that wasn't the best way to do that. senator bob corker who chairs the foreign relations committee, he said he's surprised so many republican senators signed on to this thing. he did not. did not think the letter would be helpful. senator susan collins who also did not sign on to this letter she told reporters now, quote, it did not seem to me to be appropriate for us to be writing

the ayatollah at this critical time during the negotiations. after getting just absolutely shellacked, just absolutely beat up coast to coast, within their own party, in the press, not just by democrats and the white house, but by everybody, after getting absolutely shellacked for what they did with this amazing letter to iran in "the daily beast" today republicans in the senate tried to do sort of a take back. they tried to come up with an alternate explanation for why they made this decision that everybody thought was such a terrible idea. their new explanation for what they did with this letter and why is that they didn't really mean it, it was a joke. they didn't mean it seriously at all. look at this from "the daily beast" today. republican aides were taken aback by the response to what they thought was a lighthearted attempt to signal to iran and the public that congress should have a role in the ongoing nuclear discussions.

describing the letter as a cheeky reminder. one top republican senate aide said the administration has no sense of humor. why don't anybody realize we were totally kidding when we wrote this letter to iran saying don't listen to our country about your nuclear program. don't listen to our president. obviously we thought that was hilarious. why is nobody laughing? at one level, this is a 2016 story. right? here's hillary clinton tweeting today that the republican letter to iranian clerics undermines american leadership. she said no one considering running for commander in chief should be signing on. marco rubio's pitch to republican donors about why he should be seen as a serious presidential contender for the republican party this year that all these republican governors in the race they don't have foreign policy expertise. not like he marco rubio. not like he does. because of his time in the senate, misunderstanding what iran is.

if this is what passes for republican expertise on foreign policy, we're about to have another stupid presidential election cycle when it comes to foreign policy. you thought it was bad with mitt romney, right? right now, among the 2016 republican presidential contenders, the who guys trying to position themselves as the smart ones on foreign policy are marco rubio, and also rick perry. whew! so one level of this iran debacle this week and the continuing problem honestly, it just -- of republican foreign policy illiteracy it is at one level a 2016 story. and a more pressing level, though, at a more real level, that affects all of us 2016 is a long ways away right? and we have a lot to fight about when it comes to 2016. but right now, we really do have

an active war going on against isis in iraq and syria. and it involves thousands of u.s. troops. and a very complicated set of you know not alliances, and very fragile coalitions where everybody's very testy. that is happening right now already. that is under way. that is a military campaign of considerable scale, and it has been under way for months. and our congress is technically trying to start, maybe, to debate that for the first time right now. the first day of formal debate on this today was humiliating for its ignorance. but the consensus in the beltway media and the people who watch this stuff in congress, when it comes right down to it there will ultimately be no vote in war on congress against isis that our men and women in uniform fighting on behalf of a country who can't get it together to figure out what they're doing, let alone make a decision about it.

that is not a 2016 problem, that is a here and now problem that needs to be fixed. ah... (boy) i'm here! i'm here! (cop) too late. i was gone for five minutes! ugh! move it. you're killing me. you know what, dad? i'm good. (dad) it may be quite a while before he's ready, but our subaru legacy will be waiting for him. (vo) the longest-lasting midsize sedan in its class. the twenty-fifteen subaru legacy. it's not just a sedan. it's a subaru. so,as my personal financial psychic, i'm sure you know what this meeting is about. yes, a raise. i'm letting you go. i knew that. you see, this is my amerivest managed... balances. no. portfolio. and if doesn't perform well for two consecutive gold. quarters. quarters...yup. then amerivest gives me back their advisory... stocks. fees. fees. fees for those quarters. yeah. so, i'm confident i'm in good hands. for all the confidence you need. td ameritrade. you got this.

developing news that we're keeping an eye on tonight out of florida. search and rescue operations have just been put on hold tonight for marines on a black hawk helicopter. it's believed to have gone down into water near the santa rosa peninsula there. off the florida coast. east of pensacola. it happened last night around 8:30 p.m. eastern time. the downing of the chopper is believed to have happened shortly after it lost contact with the air force base nearby. there was very dense fog in the area. 11 servicemen took off for a nighttime training exercise. it was already very foggy. at this point it is unclear exactly what brought that chopper down. sadly, some human remains, and

some pieces of wreckage from the chopper did wash ashore today. pentagon officials said tonight that all 11 service members onboard the black hawk are presumed to be dead even as search and rescue operations continued today. vice president joe biden addressed this crash earlier at an event in washington. he offered his condolences to the families of those who were lost. >> the tragedy like this cannot go unspoken to. we -- i think we sorely underestimate the constant commitment that only 1% of all the population makes on behalf of our security. 99% of the rest of us owe them a debt of gratitude and thanks and our hearts go out to the families of the servicemen and women involved. >> reportedly they're from a special operations unit from camp lejeune in north carolina. the aviators are based in

hammond, louisiana. search and rescue efforts have been paused operationally, but are scheduled to continue in the morning as weather permits. we'll have more details on this as they become available tonight. stay with us. nd the country talking to people who made the switch to ford. the brand more people buy. and buy again. oh i love it... we test-drove the escape... we both said, "i think that's the one"... and i really enjoy the pep in its step... that's the ecoboost... when the four of us go out we don't take their car... we always take our car. this was like a huge upgrade. it's awesome! the new image of ford now looks really refined... this is a very nice car. for us, the escape was just right. see your ford dealer today. why do i take metamucil everyday? because it helps me skip the bad stuff. i'm good. that's what i like to call, the meta effect. 4-in-1 multi-health metamucil is clinically proven to help you feel less hungry between meals. experience the meta effect with our multi-health wellness line. i take prilosec otc each morning for my frequent heartburn. because it gives me...

zero heartburn! prilosec otc. the number 1 doctor-recommended frequent heartburn medicine for 9 straight years. one pill each morning. 24 hours. zero heartburn. i hate having to say this. we have late breaking news about the agency charged with protecting the president of the united states. secret service. the reason i hate having to say this we've got late breaking news on the secret service, is because lately when there has been late breaking news about the secret service, it has not been for good reasons, and tonight is no exception.

the "washington post" broke this story tonight. the administration is investigating allegations that two senior secret service agents including a top member of president obama's protective detail drove a government car into white house security barricades after drinking at a late night party last week. carol cites two unnamed sources in her report tonight, one current and one former government official. a secret service spokesman said an investigation is in fact under way. these are high ranking officials within the secret service. one man is a senior supervisors in the d.c. field office the other is second in command within president obama's personal detail. i'm going to repeat that for a second. one of the two senior secret service officials under investigation for allegedly crashing a government car into a barricade at the white house after a night of drinking at a late night party last week one

of them is second in command on president obama's personal protective detail. ga! this reportedly happened a week ago tonight. late last wednesday night, march 4th. the two men were reportedly at a retirement party at a d.c. bar, for a spokesman who was retiring. sometime after leaving that party, the two men allegedly tried to drive their secret service car with the overhead flashing lights on onto the white house grounds. according to witnesses the men turned on their overhead flashing lights on the car, showing their badges when their vehicle drove straight through security tape and then hit the barricades on the white house grounds. according to carol's report tonight, quote, officers on duty who witnessed the march 4th incident wanted to arrest the agents and conduct sobriety tests, but the officers were ordered by a supervisor on duty that night to let the agents go home.

again, that is reporting tonight from carol at the "washington post." nbc news has also now confirmed the story. in september it was carol who was the first to report on an incident in 2011 in which a gunman fired shots into the white house. how the secret service bungled its response to that incident. it took the secret service only figured it out with a chunk of concrete where the bullet hit the building four days later. it surfaced around the same time last september, the security detail allowed a security contractor who was not allowed to be there to board an elevator with the president. the man had a gun. and the secret service had no idea who he was, and they let him onto an elevator with president obama. later that month secret service agents failed to stop an

intruder, he l a knife on him, made it into the white house and through much of the first floor of the white house and all the way into the east room before an agent finally tackled him. in the wake of all of this the head of the secret service and a number of top officials within the agency resigned. now according to the "washington post" tonight, the problems have apparently continued. under the new director of the agency, a responsibility for the investigation into this latest alleged incident has apparently been given to the inspector general's office at the homeland security department. they reportedly did that rather than keep the investigation internal because the secret service officials involved in this latest alleged incident are so high ranking. again, the breaking news tonight is that the secret service confirms that an investigation is under way into an alleged incident one week ago tonight in which the number two official on president obama's personal security detail and a senior supervisor at the d.c. field office for the secret service allegedly crashed a secret

service field into barricades on the white house grounds after a late night of drinking in washington, d.c. god save us all. joining us is the national reporter for the "washington post." carol, thank you very much for your time tonight. >> sure. glad to be here, rachel. >> i tried to summarize the details as i understand them. did i leave anything out? >> you got everything right. i have two small tweaks, these are allegations that are under investigation right now. and we don't know exactly what happened. we know what sources have told us. and it led to the secret service confirming that these allegations of two agents being intoxicated, or suspected of being intoxicated are indeed something they're looking into. the other small tweak is as far as we can tell from the sources who have reached out to us about this the car crash was relatively minor in the big scheme of things. they essentially ran into

temporary barricades. we don't know if there's damage to the car. what we are being told essentially is these guys appeared intoxicated, were behaving erratically, and again, sources are saying that they were driving essentially through a secure zone that had been cordoned off because of a suspicious package that was under investigation. and that was very worrisome to the secret service officers and the metropolitan police department officers on the scene, because you don't cross an area with a suspicious package in it and these individuals were acting as though they were a big deal. and they could go through whatever they wanted to go through. >> carol do we know in terms of the specific circumstance, do we know if the suspicious package is why they had come back to the white house? if they had been out drinking at a late night party, allegedly, there's a question about why they ended up back at the white house grounds at all. was it because of that

suspicious package call do we know? >> it does not appear that their return to the white house had anything to do with the suspicious package. it appears that their reason was essentially they were in a downtown bar for this retirement party. the other senior official who is very, very well respected and liked at the secret service, and he -- these individuals, rather also very senior people were returning to retrieve their government car. as you may know or as some of our viewers, your viewers may know secret service agents particularly high ranking ones have government cars that they drive to and from work. so this may have been the means to get home. >> i got it. one last question for you, carol. you reported, and this i thought was a particularly shocking thing in your report today, that even though officers on the scene wanted to arrest these two agents essentially give them sobriety tests, a supervisor said no let them go home. in the "washington post" tonight

you published the names of the two men who were allegedly in the vehicle in this incident. do you also know who the supervisor was? >> i think i'd rather not answer that at this moment, rachel if it's okay with you. we're working on our reporting as we go. we published those individuals' names because we were very very sure that those were the people under investigation. and as you know from reading our account and others the secret service is confirming that the two individuals under investigation have been reassigned temporarily. but i think we'll just say stay tuned on the other part. >> i get it. carol leonnig, thank you very much for helping us understand it. i appreciate it. >> you bet. thank you, rachel. lots still ahead tonight, including pure joy on toast. . and then you totaled him. you two had been through everything together. two boyfriends. three jobs. you're

like "nothing can replace brad!" then liberty mutual calls. and you break into your happy dance. if you sign up for better car replacement, we'll pay for a car that's a model year newer with 15,000 fewer miles than your old one. see car insurance in a whole new light. liberty mutual insurance. doers they don't worry if something's possible. they just do it. at sears optical, we're committed to bringing them eyewear that works as hard as they do. right now, buy one pair and get another free.

alright, so this tylenol arthritis lasts 8 hours, but aleve can last 12 hours... and aleve is proven to work better on pain than tylenol arthritis. so why am i still thinking about this? how are you? aleve, proven better on pain. i'm jerry bell the second. and i'm jerry bell the third. i'm like a big bear and he's my little cub. this little guy is non-stop. he's always hanging out with his friends. you've got to be prepared to sit at the edge of your seat and be ready to get up. there's no "deep couch sitting."

definitely not good for my back. this is the part i really don't like right here. (doorbell) what's that? a package! it's a swiffer wetjet. it almost feels like it's moving itself. this is kind of fun. that comes from my floor? eww! this is deep couch sitting. [jerry bell iii] deep couch sitting! in our house, we do just about everything online. and our old internet just wasn't cutting it. so i switched us from u-verse to xfinity. they have the fastest, most reliable internet. which is perfect for me, because i think everything should just work. works? works. works! works? works. works.

if the hillary clinton e-mail story is starting to annoy you, if it's starting to seem like a lot of speculative poking at something where people are trying to find political implications way before they understand the facts from which those political implications might reasonably derive, you're not alone. there is at least one part of this story that is legitimately important, and already very very well understood. we've already got the facts on it. it's probably the most important thing about this whole scrum,

and that story is next. they call it planning for retirement because getting there requires exactly that. a plan for what you want your future to look like. for more than 145 years, pacific life has been providing solutions to help individuals like you achieve long-term financial security. bring your vision for the future to life with pacific life. talk to a financial advisor to help build and protect your retirement income. pacific life. the power to help you succeed. the volkswagen jetta is really fun-to-drive. go for it. okay. wow... woohoo! i'm dreaming... pinch me. no, not while you're driving. and, right now, you can get a one-thousand-dollar volkswagen credit bonus on jetta models. seriously, pinch me. it's not a dream. ow! it's the volkswagen stop dreaming, start driving event. stop dreaming, and test-drive one today. hurry in and you can get 0% apr plus a $1000 volkswagen credit bonus

on 2015 jetta and passat models. i will live the life of now with the skin of then olay total effects vitamin-enriched. to fight the 7 signs of aging. in 4 weeks skin looks up to 10 years younger. 7 in 1 from the world's #1 olay. your best beautiful there's nothing more romantic than a spontaneous moment. so why pause to take a pill? and why stop what you're doing to find a bathroom? with cialis for daily use, you don't have to plan around either. it's the only daily tablet approved to treat erectile dysfunction so you can be ready anytime the moment is right. plus cialis treats the frustrating urinary symptoms of bph, like needing to go frequently, day or night. tell your doctor about all your medical conditions and medicines, and ask if your heart is healthy enough for sex. do not take cialis if you take nitrates for chest pain as it may cause an unsafe drop in blood pressure. do not drink alcohol in excess. side effects may include headache, upset stomach, delayed backache or muscle ache. to avoid long-term injury, get medical help right away

for an erection lasting more than four hours. if you have any sudden decrease or loss in hearing or vision or any symptoms of an allergic reaction stop taking cialis and get medical help right away. why pause the moment? ask your doctor about cialis for daily use. for a free 30-tablet trial go to cialis.com trey gowdy is the chair of the house select committee on

benghazi. ever since it was revealed that former secretary of state hillary clinton is only a private e-mail account on a private server when she was secretary of state, congressman gowdy has insisted that his committee should have access to more of her correspondence from that time. earlier today i was on my colleague andrea mitchell's program here on msnbc, and i said this about that. the republican chairs that committee saying on the network this morning, he wants to go through all of her personal e-mails and decide to his satisfaction what counts as personal and what doesn't. >> since i said that this morning, we've heard from congressman gowdy's office. his office clarified to us he does not personally want to be the one who goes through hillary clinton's e-mails, he instead wants to set up a system by which that will happen. he wants a third party am some kind to take custody of hillary clinton's e-mail server from her house, and he wants that third party to read through all of

hillary clinton's e-mails and decide which of those e-mails are private and which are work related. so again, to be clear, trey gowdy said he does not want himself to rummage around in hillary clinton's personal e-mails. what he is demanding is that she turn over her e-mail server to someone else who will then rummage around in her personal e-mails and handle the ones that are not personal over to him. okay, then, i'm happy to clarify. after secretary clinton gave her big press conference at the state department yesterday, her office put out a nine-page statement about her e-mails, and her e-mailing as secretary of state. and we did learn a couple of news things. for instance when secretary clinton handed over more than 30,000 e-mails to the state department, here's a reasonable question, why was the state department given printed copies? that is a fair question right? you've got all these tens of thousands of e-mails, why not just put them on a flash drive, or forward them. hillary clinton's office says

that is not allowed. so maybe you're thinking oh okay, that must be for security reasons. the printed e-mails are handed over in person to prevent hacking or leaks or something? no, that is not the reason. quote, the instructions regarding electronic mail in the foreign affairs manual that says until technology allowing archival capabilities for long-term retrieval of e-mail messages is available and installed, those messages warranting preservation as records must be printed out and filed. they can't handle it if you forward them to them. when it comes to e-mails, the state department archives paper, that are printouts of e-mails. we should all plant a tree in their name. the state department is not alone in having a complicated relationship with technology. but as far as record keeping and handling requests for the records it keeps, the state department apparently is in a league of its own. a new report from an independent group called the center for

effective government ranked the state department as the worst agency in the entire government for responding to freedom of information act requests. they gave the state department a grade of "f" for how slowly it processes requests and how unclear its rules are. not only does the state department just fail to respond to tons of requests for information, it actually flat-out denies nearly half of them that it does respond to. no other agency even comes close to refusing that many requests for what are government documents. the public has a right to see the public documents, or at least has a right to get an explanation of why we cannot see them. the state department is in a league of its own when we say no as a request from the public or press. the associated press decided they had enough. the associated press today filed a lawsuit against the state department demanding that the state department hand over public documents that its reporters and editors have been asking for for years. and for which they feel they

have been stonewalled by the department of state. joining us now is jay ward brown, he's lead counsel representing the a.p. in this new lawsuit against the state department. mr. brown, thank you very much for being with us. >> my pleasure. >> so when and why did the associated press decide that it was necessary to bring this as a lawsuit instead of continuing just to pursue it as a request? >> well this has been a five-year odd es why i for some of the requests that are at issue in this lawsuit. the earliest of the six requests at issue were made with the state department in 2010. and although the freedom of information act, the federal statute that requires agencies to release records to citizens provides that the government is supposed to release those records in 20 days as you just pointed out in the report that you cited, the statutory deadline is not even in the breach. but rarely if ever. and that's especially so with the state department. it becomes a process of negotiation between the news organization making the request,

and the agency. and you have to keep nudging the agency along. as the a.p. reporters, and their editors did here. but there does come a point when as is the case here the agency isn't responding at all, that litigation is the only option. and the statute provides for litigation. to have a judge, a federal judge resolve the dispute over release of the records when the agency doesn't respond to the request. and that's what's happened here. >> can you tell from what you know about your client's case or is it material to the case you are bringing, some theory about why the state department is so much worse than everybody else? does the state department give explanations that are different than the kinds of explanations that other agencies give? are they nonresponsive more often than other agencies are? do he seem confused or lost as to what they have? >> i think the state department says two things. one, they mention publicly a number of times that they receive over 19,000 formal requests a year.

admittedly that's a lot of requests. nevertheless, they've got a legal duty under a statute passed by congress to process those requests in a timely way, but they would tell you they're behind because they get so many requests. secondly, in fairness to the department, some of the requests do implicate information that affects national security. that's obvious that an agency like the state department. but there are also procedures and protocols for dealing with that. and it's really hard to understand how with respect to the requests in question here for example, the earliest request filed by the a.p. in this case were for copies of secretary clinton's engagement calendar. her official engagement calendar for a limited period of time during her tenure. can't be that many pages involved in that. and one would think in fewer than five years, the state department could have responded to that request. but to date other than playing vanilla communications saying we're working on it the state department has produced no materials, no records in response to that request.

or to any of the six requests that are at issue, except for three documents produced in response to one subpart of one request about a defense contractor called bae systems. and it's really hard to understand how that kb. >> yes. and particularly and this is not the scope of your case but particularly given the other independently arrived at information about how poorly the state department fares in its response rate compared to other agencies. regardless of who the secretary is of that agency whoever's last ought to be forced by some means to catch up to everybody else. your case may be the one that does that. jay ward brown, thanks very much for helping us understand this. >> certainly. coming up, we did a thing on this show last month that involved the state of oregon and an owl. and there's news on that tonight that makes me so happy, i can't bref it.

the garden is the story of our lives... told and retold. it's as old as our time on earth. and as new as tomorrow. you can have a yard. or slightly less. gardening isn't about where we choose to live. it's about how we choose to live. miracle-gro. life starts here. when you set out to find new roads you build the chevrolet malibu ranked highest in initial quality and long-term dependability by jd power. ♪ chevrolet, the most awarded car company over the last year. get this epa estimated 36 mpg highway

2015 chevy malibu with 0% apr financing for six years plus $500 purchase bonus cash. find new roads at your local chevy dealer. i will take beauty into my own hands... where it belongs. olay regenerist. it regenerates surface cells. new skin is revealed in only 5 days. without drastic measures. stunningly youthful. award-winning skin. never settle for anything less. the regenerist collection. from the world's # 1 olay. your best beautiful. good people of salem,

oregon, beware it has happened again. the angry owl patrolling your local park is still at it. i spoke with the salem parks department, they tell us today that after the four angry owl attacks on joggers that we reported in the state capital of oregon earlier this year now there has been a another one, number five. the owl did not hurt anybody, but the owl did swoop in close and scary, according to the parks department quote, warning them just who they were messing with. the owl scared somebody else. this scared jogger was forewarned, after that string of earlier owl attacks this year. salem oregon parks department installed owl attack warning signs, that was originally a graphic for this show. we were very happy to help. those beware of owl signs went up last month in salem. to our lasting delight. it turns out they have a use

beyond warning people about owls in the park because it turns out people want to own them. one person wanted a sign so badly they tried to take the sign right off the post in the park. scary owl sign. the salem parks foundation has decided to make these scaled down 12 x 12 replicas of the sign and offering them for a $30 donation to the benefit of the city's parks. i love this so very much. it might be the best thing that's ever happened to this show. but it's not the best new thing that happened today. that's still ahead. stay with us.

about a week after the shooting death of michael brown in ferguson, missouri last summer, there was one truly strange moment of news in the overall chaotic response to that shooting. it happened when the police chief tom jackson called a press conference which he said he would release the name of the officer involved in that shooting. to everyone's surprise he also released some surveillance footage, which chief jackson said showed the victim in the shooting michael brown, participating in a strong arm robbery not that long before he was shot. the release of that surveillance video of michael brown at a convenience store was unexpected. then the chief gave a second press conference that same day where he gave this verbal explanation for why he felt compelled to release that tape.

>> we've got a lot of freedom of information requests for this tape and at some point it was just determined we had to release it. we didn't have good cause, absent any other reason to not release it. what i did was release the videotape to you because i had to. i've been sitting on it but i -- too many people put in a request for that thing and i had to release it. >> why would you release the video of the robbery. what is the explanation for the timing? >> you asked for it. i held it as long as i could. >> nobody asked for it. nobody knew it existed. his explanation why he was releasing that powder keg of tape is because reporters had been demanding it be released. there were no requests for that tape because nobody knew it was there. it was one of the weirdest things that happened in the immediate aftermath to the michael brown shooting.

now tonight, that ferguson police chief has finally left his job and became the latest high ranking official in ferguson to resign. he'll leave the force effective next week. that makes it six people who have gone in the city of ferguson so far. it's the police sergeant the his captain. one of the judges it's the city manager of ferguson. we reported that last night. now it's the police chief. ferguson still needing the fix itself but the process of ferguson sloughing off the people who did the stuff that made it nationally famous the process of stopping the bleeding and holding people accountable for what they have done that is underway. who knows, maybe there will more. lawrence o'donnell will have much more next hour. so please stay tuned.

some questions can't wait until morning. so i'm one of many nurses at cigna with answers anytime, day or night. i'm lauren, and i've got your back. can't say thank you enough. you have made my life special by being apart of it. (everyone) cheers! glad you made it buddy. thanks for inviting me. thanks again my friends. for everything for all your help. through all life's milestones our trusted advisors are with you every step of the way. congratulations! thanks for helping me plan for my retirement. you should come celebrate with us. i'd be honored. plan for your goals with advisors you know and trust. so you can celebrate today and feel confident about tomorrow. chase. so you can. colourists know roots take colour one way, and previously coloured hair another.

new vidal sassoon salonist. first, brush roots then, blend through lengths. our most advanced system outside the salon. it's more than colour. it's a work of art. doers they don't worry if something's possible. they just do it. at sears optical, we're committed to bringing them eyewear that works as hard as they do. right now, buy one pair and get another free.

best new thing in the world. there's a whole range of emotions that can happen over the course of the day. if you like sports even if you're not watching a game that day. so like today, after several days of unrelenting depression of the fact that this man was leaving my favorite football team. today, i had the elation about the reports that maybe, maybe my beloved vince wilfork might stay with new england. my spirits soared. he's a well conditioned athlete, the pulsing, throbbing emotional core of the patriot's defense. his wife is as adorable as he is. i love the wilforks. he might stay. the feeling of elation. totally outside the news cycle about what's important in the world, if you are a person who loves sports, you tend to have

feelings about it. even if you don't love sports the best new thing in the world today is something that feels really good. it happened last night in an exhibition tennis match when roger federer, arguably the greatest tennis player ever. and the 23-year-old up and coming star. they put on a show for the fans. at one point, they exchanged between the leg shots, both of them. that is worth the price offed a vision itself. if you were catching this game you felt like you were seeing something cool. but that was before this happened. >> gregor will bass the baton here to a young guy. looks like he's ready to go. >> look at this. roger freaked out. he hit the pass.

>> he then beats roger federer, fair and square with a lob over federer's head and he does it while wearing jeans. he's like, yeah that's what i meant to do too. look at him. so cool. best new thing in the world today. that does it for us tonight. see you again tomorrow. now time for "the last word with lawrence o'donnell." good evening, lawrence. >> we're going the add to what some of you had to say about that secret service scandal. there's now congressional reaction to what happened there. >> there should be. >> another amazing story. well hillary clinton issued a challenge to the other potential presidential candidates today. that's also coming up. >> the city of ferguson police chef