tv Hardball With Chris Matthews MSNBC December 2, 2015 4:00pm-5:01pm PST
4:00 pm
barricaded in a church that is something obviously we're going to continue to follow. we're told police are closing in right now. so we are monitoring that, getting more information fro both pete williams, our justice correspondent, and also from the folks at our affiliate knbc in los angeles. and with that, we want to toss it over to chris matthews, who continues our coverage now out of washington. chris? >> well, good evening, i am chris matthews in washington. here we are with the news. and it's extraordinary. it's an opportunity to see the power of television tonight in a tragic situation where the tv camera, we're looking at it right now is ahead of the reporting. you're hearing the reporters think about what they think is going on here and we're watching, trying to decipher what is going on. three police cars surrounding a car, a dark suv which was the suspected vehicle all along this afternoon. and they circled it. and we're trying to figure out now what kind of a standoff this is and what the police officers, the s.w.a.t. team is worried
4:01 pm
about in terms of the wariness they're showing in approaching the vehicle. they're obviously very concerned of a possible either a person still alive in the vehicle, or more likely they're worried about some sort of explosive device that may be detonated while they go and approach it. they may fear that their own approach may cause to it detonate. because they're being very wary of approaching it. we also saw what looked like a body being called from the car right now, but we're not sure. live picture news from san bernardino, california. in the hours since we saw the tragedy, which cost the lives of 14 people and 14 were wounded. let's go now to the press conference for an update from the police in san bernardino. well, we're watching the police officer.
4:02 pm
there she is, the police officer ready to give us the report. but we have been watching it. as i said, so amazingly ahead of the actual human reporting of what is going on. but we'll get a full update now, i believe, given what has happened already. >> is everybody ready? okay, again, my name is sergeant vicki cervantes with the san bernardino police department. as an update, officers that are working this active shooter case were doing follow-up work when they located what appeared to be the suspect's vehicle. somehow during that contact, shots were exchanged between the suspects and the officers. one officer was injured. however, he was transported to a local hospital and it does not appear to be a life threatening injury. i believe he is a san bernardino police officer. additionally, some suspects or a suspect has been hit. i believe there is still
4:03 pm
possibly a suspect outstanding. so it is still, again, a very active, fluid situation. we don't have a lot of answer yet. they're still trying to sort through what they've encountered on the other end at the other scene. chief burguan is going to be coming here at 4:45 with sheriff mcmahon and again do a press conference so that you can speak to him directly. and he can update you with any information. >> vicki, what is the suspect count at this point? >> i'm sorry? >> how many suspects are there? >> i don't know. i believe that there are two at this time being dealt with. >> and there is one on the run? >> if there were originally three suspects, there is still possibly one outstanding. but, again, i don't know. >> the suspect who was hit dead? >> i don't have that information. >> is there another suspect not hit in custody? >> i don't have that information
4:04 pm
either. i don't know. their investigation just took them in that path. >> have they searched the building entirely at this point? [ inaudible ] >> i don't know. >> could one of the suspects be at the meeting this morning and then return? >> i don't know. that's information i've not been given. [ inaudible ] >> how many suspects are in custody? >> i don't have any of those details. the chief will provide those at 4:45. he is being briefed on that as we speak. we're just speaking here because we committed to talking to you on the hour. and i apologize we don't have all of the information. >> the building? >> that i don't know. >> the officer that was struck, can you tell us where the wound is? >> i don't have that information
4:05 pm
either. i just know it's not life threatening. >> is the suspect dead? >> i don't know if the suspect has died. we have not been given that. >> how many have been hit? how many suspects have been hit? >> i couldn't tell you that. but if you're back here at 4:45, chief burguan and sheriff mcmahon will be here. and they will probably have many more answers for you. again, it's very active. it's not far from that -- or from here. stay here and let's be vigilant because there very well may be a suspect still out here. and we all need to be careful. >> but, again, the officers came in contact with that suv because they were doing follow-up investigation? >> that's correct. it led them that way. correct. >> and they saw the vehicle? >> i don't know who fired first. i don't know. all right. again, at 4:45. >> thank you. >> thank you. >> bringing in right now jim
4:06 pm
cavanaugh, an msnbc law enforcement analyst. he is a retired agent with the atf. lot me ask you, jim, we're watching an amazing bit of television here following this tragedy. we watched the police, the s.w.a.t. units surround that car, approach it very warily for fear that the suspect may still be alive inside, or that there may be some kind of a bomb set that might explode. also now we're watching police going door to door with police dogs, looking for another suspect apparently. this is one of those rare times when television cameras are so far ahead of the reporting. what can you tell from this yourself? >> you know, that's exactly right. it appears that they're searching for another suspect, at least one more. there has been reports of one wounded, one killed, one captured. but it sure looks like there is an active search going on. but of course they're trying to be thorough. we don't know all the facts. we're probably not going to get any more on that until the chief of police talks again in a few minutes, 45 minutes.
4:07 pm
but they sure have an active search that they haven't called off. and like you say, chris, the television cameras are showing minute by minute. all the citizens on the side of law enforcement calling in what they see, you know, to spot a vehicle, to spot a person. >> right. >> that's probably giving them an edge to locate that suv early on. >> you know, it's interesting. just moments ago, actually about an hour or two ago, we heard it was a dark suv that was the escape vehicle, if you will, for the three people, apparently three people who committed these crimes, the killing of 14 people, the wounding, shooting wounding of 14 others at that development facility. and now you're finding out the police chief was very calm about it, their surveillance was pretty darn good because they managed to track down that vehicle lickety-split, that dark suv. they stopped it. they had a shoot-out with it. and what we were able to see when the helicopter arrived is we saw what looked to be a standoff situation. but apparently, or it looks like now the suspect that was still
4:08 pm
in that car was dead at this point. and they're worried about something happening afterwards. >> right. it looks like they might have stabilized it as far as anybody in there shooting at them. they moved that ballistic shield up so they can get a real close look on what is in there. they don't appear at the moment to be negotiating with anybody. so they may just have a dead suspect in there, or it could be empty. and they're going to want to sweep it for explosive devices, which would be the normal protocol. it does look to be all shot up. it's all shot up through the front glass, all shot up. so probably they did have -- were engaged with that vehicle somewhere on that road, or around the corner. and they had a pretty good shoot-out wit. i think probably called in a tip by citizens, or patrol car. because all the patrol officers were out, looking, going on every street. if one of those vehicles is creeping around like that, they're going to spot it. and the citizens are going to call it in. it's all over the news. everybody is on your side.
4:09 pm
and so you get a tip, hey, there is a black suv going down fifth street. and so you can center on it. >> you should have seen the scene over here a few minutes ago. me and the producers of the crew were all staring at the television from about two inches away trying to see what is very hard to see from the helicopter even now with the s.w.a.t. team still being very wary of what is in that vehicle. they're still worried about something being detonated. let me get back to something you said a couple of hours ago when this horror first occurred. the idea of three human beings copping in with long guns and shooting it out with people they don't even know, lots of people they didn't know, without getting into the specific criminality here which is obviously a crime, what would motive three people to go into what could be a suicidal situation to commit a mass shooting? >> right, chris. i would just add this to your thought. >> it's your thought, jim. you jumped on that right away. this is the oddest human behavior. usually there is an impulsive
4:10 pm
crime of passion of some kind or someone reacting in a fight scene if you will, in a bar. there is a reaction by a human being. when you a situation where the guy brings in two other people to share in the passion of the moment to start killing people. >> that's right. and here is an important fact in this. they were seen with masks, masks. that's a reason for escape. if you're going somewhere to commit the shooting and barricade and die in a blaze of glory, or be a martyr, you're not wearing a mask. when you wear a mask, there is a reason for that. masks around your face are not comfortable. they're not easy to breathe through. you know, no matter what they are, they're all sort of cumbersome. so you have a reason for that. and your reason is escape, probably in this case because we saw that they did escape. so you got your black mask killing uniform on. maybe some sort of tactical or ballistic vest, your long guns. you have two confederates, and you have masks. this is a real dedication for mass murder here.
4:11 pm
>> and how many people sit around with, oh, let's go get the masks now. go shoot a bunch of people. it's extraordinary and terrible. anyway, msnbc's jacob saverff. can you see the s.w.a.t. cars surrounding this dark suv which has been shot up? >> i can't see those particular ones, chris, but i can see very similar ones in a different location. i see probably 10, 15 on the back of a heavily armored vehicle with what looks like someone in the gunner position at the top of the vehicle at the intersection just a couple of blocks away from what you're looking at davidson and richardson. you can hear the sirens. >> yes. >> at first it sounded like there was somebody potentially in a church because an alarm went off. then i saw them move around the block to where they heard a dog barking. they're looking for something very aggressively out here, chris. >> what do you know about the three people? according to the fbi, we're going to get more from pete
4:12 pm
williams. but we've been hearing that one person is dead. and one or two have been captured. that's what we know. >> from this location, we're not hearing any of that information, chris. what we are seeing, though, is again, just to reiterate, what looks like a very aggressive manhunt continuing from my perspective, despite what you're seeing, from the sky on television at the position with the black suv. >> do you see the patrolmen going door to door with police dogs? >> yeah. basically, this is a neighborhood with, you know, chain-link fences, not quite thicket fences but metal fences. it's an ordinary neighborhood. we've got sheriff's deputies, very heavily armed tactical sheriffs officials, and other law enforcement officials, just as you said quite literally going door to door here, looking for someone, chris. >> hold on there. i want to bring in mark glazer who is sitting here with me. you have a concern here. what all these mass shootings have in common is the shootings
4:13 pm
themselves. whether it's something along the lines of racial or it's anger over school, kids having anger problems at school. and it all comes down to the availability of guns and people willing to get out there and shoot lots of people they don't know. >> that's right. as you were saying there is a lot we don't know about the shooting and won't for a while, we know this. 14 are dead and 14 are wounded in a situation where three men apparently came in with masks on. >> right. >> and something that might have been stimulated by something that happened today. >> you know, it recalls a little bit the columbine mass shooting which is the last time i can remember that more than one deranged -- >> student anger. >> exactly, was involved in a mass shooting. here is what we do now. this is the 21st mass shooting in the united states in the past year. and a great nation where you and i -- >> define mass shooting so we know. >> four or more people are killed. >> okay. in a great country that we love to live in where nevertheless you and i are 20 more times to be killed with a gun than people who live in any other country. we know how to fix it.
4:14 pm
congress resolutely refuses to do it. these things are happening so often and they're so severe that i think the public attitudes are shifting and politicians are going to have to catch up or they're going to have some tough questions. >> were you stunned as an advocate to hear mike huckabee say the problem is it was a gun-free zone? the problem there weren't enough armed people there to defend themselves? that was his argument. >> this is sort of a tape to feel nra which is in the business of raying money and selling guns. schools are generally gun-free zones. >> planned parenthood attendants and doctors are suppose to carry guns when they perform surgeries. >> and first grade teach shores have shoot-outs over the heads of our kids. that's the rationale of the nra. but you know, regards of columbine, regards o virginia tech. >> there was a policeman at planned parenthood. >> in a situation like this, very often the perpetrators intend to commit murder or suicide by cop. so whether or not there are armed guards there, it's not going to make any difference. >> thank you, mark. stay with us. let's get back to the hunt right now. because it is a hunt. we don't know who is still at
4:15 pm
large. gene o'donnell is a former new york city police officer. thank you very much, mr. o'donnell. tell us what these pictures are telling us. again, the great irony here that we're seeing pictures ahead of the reporting. we're going get a press conference in a half hour now. we have been looking at what we thought was a standoff with a number of s.w.a.t. teams all in vehicles, all surrounding an suv, a dark suv. all the windows have been shot out. now we're watching people scrambling around, patrolmen with police dogs looking for someone. what can you tell here? >> well, i think the real concern, two big concerns. one is the information coming out to the people in the field. and that's problematic in realtime there is moving pieces here. and i'd be concerned that the cops are not able to catch up with what is happening. and also, real concerned that ordinary cops with ordinary weapons are going to encounter heavily armed people. and that's a great concern in these situations. and we're talking about the need to control guns. nobody can claim to be pro police and allow a country where these kind of people can walk in with these weapons and literally
4:16 pm
you're not only terrorizing ordinary people, the police themselves are at extraordinary risk in happening upon these guys, doing a car stop, pulling them over. their lives could be lost. we saw that in boston, by the way. that campus cop was executed by those brothers, shot between the eyes. so it's not only endangering the american public, but the cops at this point. and it's changing policing. we've had this argument about militarization. here you go. when you got a country where the people can pick up weapons at will, you're going to have to equip the police. and that makes policing change in a way that is not good. >> you know, you remind me that the police officers are often the victims in the case of john f. kennedy assassination. we had an officer killed within moments after the kennedy assassination. >> planned parenthood, right? planned parenthood a cop who happened to be a pastor, you know. we talk about the stereotype of policing. there is a person who was killed defending people's rights, the legal rights there.
4:17 pm
>> let's talk about the picture we've been watching. i have to tell you, i've been mesmerized by the picture, which i tell you again astoundingly is so far ahead of the actual report. we're watching three or four squad cars, armored personnel carriers all around thing around within feet of a car in which the suspected vehicle had been shot at. there may be somebody in there still dead or perhaps still alive. and the cops were so careful in the way they approached that vehicle. they were really wary. >> well, jim cavanaugh indicated correctly, of course. the concern here is to make sure there is not explosives. these guys come looking to cause mass destruction and death. and they're equipped to the teeth. and so there has to be concern when they're an a hending them. and there is no rush here. bring the technology in. they have some very advanced sophisticated technology, telescopic technology. there is absolutely no rush. they may be tempted to rush because there is helicopters hovering overhead they should
4:18 pm
take a deep breath, the protection of their lives and try to get these guys into custody without any further bloodshed is a top priority. >> well said. nbc's tom costello, my colleague is here from the newsroom with the latest on what we do know right now. tom, thank you. >> here is where we stand right now, chris. as you're looking at that split shot there, on the left you're looking at the police who are looking for one suspect who remains at large. there had been multiple reports throughout the san bernardino area of a suspect fitting descriptions of missing suspect. everybody in this area is on alert and on edge. and they're calling in anybody who is suspicious. because san bernardino authorities tell us that one suspect is still at large. on the right, you have that suv which was involved in the shoot wout the police. we believe that there is perhaps one individual wounded inside that -- inside that suv, and another individual who we believe is dead. now i think what you're going to see here is this is a videotape on the right-hand side. and you're going to see them
4:19 pm
pull somebody or something out of the suv. we believe that that is one suspect who was killed in a shoot-out with police. another individual wounded in a shoot-out with police. we believe may still be in that vehicle. and then we have on the left the search for the third suspect. police are very confident that that suv, that black suv is in fact the one that they have been searching for the last few hours. it was involved in the shooting at this community center at 11:30 or so pacific time. the initial reports, the bolo as they say, the be on the lookout radio call that went out from the san bernardino authorities was to be on the lookout for a black suv. and as they were pursuing the course of their investigation, they said that they were looking for specific follow-up opportunities, or they were investigating information, looking for the suspects. and that's when they came across that suv and engaged in a shoot-out. as you can see, a violent shoot-out with police on that black suv that had its windows
4:20 pm
blown out. and again, one individual we think dead. one wounded. so now what we're looking at, again, bringing us back to what is happening right now is we believe this ongoing search for that third suspect. and as you can see, they've got the police bearcat involved here. that's the s.w.a.t. unit. there are multiple s.w.a.t. teams in action from various jurisdictions across this entire region of southern california. we've got multiple agencies contributing their s.w.a.t. apparatus, along with their street cops to find this missing suspect. and these individuals, of course, have also been engaged in very active and heavy gunfire this afternoon. this has been an extremely dangerous situation with mass killers on the streets of southern california. and now the search for one of them continues. chris? >> tom costello, great reporting there. we're watching that picture right now. the s.w.a.t. teams around the car. they may contain as tom pointed
4:21 pm
out, tom costello pointed out, may have a dead person and a wounded person with still another person out in the streets somewhere. we're watching -- we've been watching this patrolman out there standing out there, looking for him with the help of dogs. anyways, nbc's blake mccoy with us with from near the site of today's shooting. blake, what can you tell us? >> i'm at the site of the original shooting. i can tell you when all of this activity about two miles away started occurring a little more than an hour ago, there was flurry of police activity. helicopters started taking off from the site of the original shooting and heading to that location. right now we're getting same information you are. one person dead in that car. another person injured, and a search for a third suspect. and we've been talking about the severe threat that these officers are under which is why they are in such heavy tactical gear. you have to keep in mind that the people in this original shooting reported that those three shooters had heavy tactical gear themselves on as well as long guns. that's in the word of police. they would not speculate on what type of weapons. 17 people injured, 14 killed at
4:22 pm
this site. so they are being very careful as they try to move in around the potentially third suspect who is at large right now. and we have reported already that one police officer was injured in that shoot-out about two miles away from here. the san bernardino police officer we're told was taken to a hospital and is expected to be okay, chris. >> well, thank you very much. nbc's blake mccoy. now let's go to manny gomez. he is a retired fbi agent and retired sergeant with the nypd. what do you make of this? there has been a lot of confusion in the reporting so far because this is a live event that we're ahead of on television in many ways. we've been watching this standoff which may involve a dead person being dragged from a car. one of the suspects. another suspect wounded perhaps in that car still. and now we're getting word that a third suspect is on the loose. police are chasing him on foot with the help of dogs, sniffing dogs. and the question is my god, this is one of the rare case, i'll say it for the 100th time
4:23 pm
tonight where we're watching events occur before they're getting even minimally reported. what do we know about the police activity right now? mr. gomez? >> well, the good news is that they've apprehended or they neutralized two out of the three. the bad news is there is one at large. but i have every confidence that they will shortly capture this individual. once they have fully identified the first two, they will probably be able to quickly determine who the third fugitive is. ag and bring him to justice or neutral either way in a short time. the fact that we're watching this live as it's unfolding is truly unbelievable. also, the fact that this happened again. it seems to me that although there are instances throughout the world, it seems in the u.s. it's become an epidemic that every other week we have some sort of active shooter situation. >> but think about the -- well, the strangeness and the horror of this combined. 14 people dead now who were alive this morning. they got up, brushed their teeth, put on their clothes,
4:24 pm
came to work. in fact, they came to a facility to improve themselves because they were in rehab of some kind. autism people, people with all kinds of problems, trying to get better in their lives, improve themselves. physically. and then they come and they're dead. 14 dead, 14 wounded. and we don't know how bad their wounds are at this point. three men apparently went in there with long guns with masks on. three men sharing enough zealotry and evil, if you will, to want to kill basically strangers out of what? it's a strange thing to put all that together. it doesn't fit any of the models, if you will, of what we've seen before in mass shootings. >> no, it doesn't. years ago what we had was hostage situations. and we became subject experts in dealing with hostage negotiations and trying to release the hostages. now we've quickly learned in the last few years that the new active shooter scenario is a scenario where these people are going in. and their only goal is to kill as many people as possible before they kill themselves, get
4:25 pm
killed by the police, or in this case, successfully escape. it's very strange indeed that the lack of respect for life that this type of individuals have. and it's also very strange that they plan an escape strategy that succeeded. this is new. i hope that this does not feed into the word that you use, zealotry of other particular people that may be on the fence, looking to jump in to this active shooter scenario that we've been seeing in so many states in this country recently. >> well, thank you, manny. stay in there. let me go back to you, gene o'donnell. the question is what made these three men think they could escape? they did elude authorities for an hour or two, but they were picked up on the highway. they didn't have a secret bat cave or something to go to. they were out on the highway. with a car that had been identified by the victims or close to the victims. they said it was dark suv.
4:26 pm
not hard to pick out in helicopter surveillance. >> most of these guys are dead-enders. they have no hope of really getting away. and they generally don't want to live either. they either are killed by the police or killed by other people or kill themselves. >> well, what is with the masks? >> obviously they didn't want to get caught. but at the same time you must know when you engage in a crime like this that there is an extraordinarily high likelihood that it's going to wend your life being forfeited. that's must know that. >> gene, what about the idea that it's always been historically a fact. and if you get into a barricade situation, you're doomed. once people have surrounded you, it's a matter of time and casualties. but you're finished. and these guys were basically putting themselves in a situation where all they had was a vehicle, and they were going to shoot a whole bunch of people. they killed 14. they wounded 14. and then they get in their car. and they raise away. i don't see the logic to that
4:27 pm
in terms of an escape plan. >> we got to change the thinking about this. because it's clearly obvious now that the old days, the cops showed up. they isolated and contained the guy. they brought in the negotiators. and people had nonviolent resolution. this is a scary time in this country. there is every reason to believe this is going to continue. weapon the weaponry that is so easily available to these guys. and i don't know how concerned they are about really getting away. they're certainly concerned about slaughtering innocent people and taking on the police if they have to. that's another worrying thing here. their willingness to shoot it out if necessary with the police. >> why long guns? why would three men, they are men, why would they come into a closed situation, a conference room where there is some sort of banquet going on in this development facility, hoping to improve themselves physically who have disabilities and come in there with long guns. that the only guns they could get their hands on? it seems to me in that situation you would want semiautomatic
4:28 pm
pistols. but why would they come in with long guns in a situation like that? >> it's hard to say there is so much derangement, that perfect storm if you will of derangement, the ability to get guns and i think social media honestly creates some really crazy ideas in the minds of people. and so that's a lethal mix when people are exchanging bizarre ideas and are able to get these kinds of weapons. and there is a lot of aggrieved people out there. let's be clear about that. an aggrieved person with a perceived slight can pick up a heavy weapon and go in and kill people, this is extraordinary. it's sort of a watershed. it's been coming for a long time there is every reason to believe this is going to continue now. >> yeah, i think that's well said, given what we're getting now. our preliminary discussions or the possibility that this was an impulsive attack that somebody was offended by something and went out and got two other people and came back and committed this horrific mass shooting. thank you, gene o'donnell.
4:29 pm
let's go back to msnbc's jacob saberoff. >> you can hear around me the sound of barking dogs in this residential neighborhood, the choppers that are overhead right now. in my line of tight, up and down a street that is totally sealed off, richardson street here in san bernardino. i see 20 or 30 heavily armed tactical officers. one in essentially the gunner position at the top of the vehicle, the hood of the vehicle, lifted up with sitting outside. you know, they're going door to door here, chris. looking for somebody. and it's not stopping any time soon. >> are their guns drawn? >> we see them with their assault weapons sort of holstered for lack of a better term, in their hand, pointed down at the ground. but every one of the officers that i see right now, and i
4:30 pm
count over 10, 15 at least, all have assault weapons in their hands right now. you know, you're also seeing them, chris, in the back of just regular pickup trucks, driving up and down the streets, sitting in back of pickup trucks, using whatever vehicles they can at this moment to leave no stone unturned in this residential neighborhood. >> are the people opening their doors? >> people are -- we're not seeing them go directly right now to anyone's doors. but what you do see is residents in the neighborhood coming out of their homes, peering over the fences in front of their houses, looking at these law enforcement officials. right now it looks like, you know, the one group of officers i'm watching is staging to do whatever their next move is going to be here in this neighborhood. >> tell us where your positions are. are you where the car was stopped, the suv, the dark suv that was the suspect's vehicle, their escape vehicle? are you closer to the original crime scene? >> no, i'm quite near there i'm almost in between, i believe, those two locations. although i'd have to take
4:31 pm
another look to make sure. but i'm at the intersection of what is called richardson street and gould street. san bernardino avenue is several blocks to the north of me. the 10 freeway i would say is a mile or less to the south of me. i would say the 10 freeway is the main artery here in southern california into and out of los angeles. it goes all the way to phoenix and beyond. so this is an area where it is very, very heavily trafficked, chris. but right now on this street there are not many people. certainly no cars at all going up and down it. >> do we know whether all three suspects escaped in the suspected escape vehicle or one was left behind? because if one was not left behind, why are we looking in the area where the original shooting occurred? >> well, it would certainly suggest there is one suspect that was not involved, but they're looking for somebody. they're looking for somebody that obviously they believe to be armed and dangerous. otherwise they wouldn't be out here.
4:32 pm
looking essentially like they're in a war zone. >> we're going to be getting for everybody watching right now, we're watching a live -- well, it's a fugitive situation. we're chasing -- the police are chasing after in san bernardino are chasing after what may be -- this is all somewhat speculative. the third suspect in a mass shooting at a developmental facility there in san bernardino which is part of the great inland empire of course in southern california. and we're talking about the police action right now that we're watching. we're watching the police cars, the black and white vehicles out there on the car right now. they're all crunched together on the corner there. they have stopped a vehicle they believe to be the escape vehicle. there may be a dead person, one of the three suspects in that car. or he may have been removed. we think he might have been removed. we're not sure. and secondly, there is another suspect who is apparently wounded somewhere. there is nearly no one in actual custody right now, at least formal custody with handcuffs on or on their way to a prison hospital or a police hospital. what we're basically looking at is a live search for certainly
4:33 pm
for one of the three suspects in this mass shooting, one of many mass shootings we have suffered through in this country most recently with the planned parenthood facility in colorado. and of course in oregon more recently than that. just before that when it's been a horrific season for us, five months, mark glaser. >> that's right. >> five mass shootings, major mass shootings. >> that's right. >> in just six months. >> that's right. and again, 21 this year. i think something like 150 something since the newtown mass shooting when there was hope in the country we might do something about this. >> is it accelerating? >> it is. it's been accelerating since the year 2000 and has picked up particularly over the last two or three years. >> what is the factor? >> it's complicated. but lot of socialologists believe there is a copycat factor, especially with trouble with young people in mass shootings. but mass shootings do not tell the full story of gun violence in america. 80 something people are killed with guns every day. 30 something of them are
4:34 pm
murders. every single day in this country, they're not mass shootings, they take place in our streets, in our homes and urban and rural areas. and we know how to stop it. tougher gun laws to keep guns out of the hands of people who should not have them. but congress and legislate chers -- >> they use the gun to carry out their business? and what percentage of crimes are impulse and anger? >> it's hard to say because we don't have great record keeping on that. and the nra doesn't like us to do research about the causes of gun mortality. but a relatively percentage of people are recidivists who have been in prison who have committed serious crimes and are doing it again. >> really? >> a lot of them are accidents and a lot of them are suicides. and we know the sort of public policy solutions that would help with both of those things. one of the biggest things is background checks. >> let's go to blake mccoy with real life information at the scene of the shooting. blake? >> well, as authorities scour that neighborhood right now
4:35 pm
looking for the third possible suspect, police have come us to and said please urge people in that neighborhood to stay inside. right now they are aware that some people kroare coming out o their homes. they say stay inside. this third suspect is possibly armed and very dangerous. police also did confirm for us that two suspects are down. that's their words. we don't know if they're killed or injured. two suspects down in that black suv. the third suspect was seen running from the suv into the neighborhood nearby. and that is why they have descended on that area, an army of police looking for this person. >> we're getting a clear picture right now. we'll be right back with you. let's go to jacob soboroff. two suspects down if you will, dead, probably dead, maybe both dead. one still on the loose. but the one who is on the loose escaped from the vehicle. all three of the suspects escaped from the crime scene where they shot people or killed 14 and wounded 14 others. and they all escaped in that
4:36 pm
vehicle. but once when that vehicle was stopped, one of them made a run for it. >> that's what we're hearing, chris. right now i'm in a very resident neighborhood here. richardson, you can see behind me right now. heavily tactical law enforcement officers here. i don't know if you can see them in this location as i walk around here, you'll be able to see them. now you can see them there. also on the roof of their houses, chris. people with homes in this neighborhood, they're out. very, very -- that this situation is going on. there is no way not to be. >> that's jacob soboroff. jacob, we can't hear you. we'll have to get back to you. that's interesting we're getting an update there are three suspects down or in custody and one on the loose. three men. put on masks and arrived at a
4:37 pm
facility that treats people with epilepsy and autism. just regular people with problems, with challenges, and shot a bunch of them and killed 14 and shot another 14. just life's -- these are not big shots. these aren't the leaders of our country or anything else. these are going after the people that are most vulnerable. >> right. and there is one reason. >> what could be the motive. we've got to find this out. >> very hard to know the motive. but there is within reason this happens here so much more often than it does in great britain, where culture is quite similar, where they watch american movies, they play american video games. they're not less mentally ill. their health care is not better. but we have 20 to 25 times the murder rate. the only difference is in the way we control who has access to guns. >> we all have experiences with people from canada. but look at the cultural difference here. in this country, about 30 people per million are killed. by guns. >> right. >> in canada, it's five. >> that's right. >> 6-1. is the culture that different?
4:38 pm
>> it's a pretty tough country up there. >> they're t canadians are really tough. they're tough people. but they dent resort to guns. >> they don't resort to guns. >> killing people. >> because it's simply not part of the culture, and because they regulate guns and access to them much more strictly than we do. because they understand there that you can be a hunter. you can have a gun in your house for self-protection. but that doesn't mean we ought to open the floodgates so we have what we have in this country today which is more guns than we have people which makes ate much harder problem to solve. >> does this go back to our revolution? we're revolutionary people. we don't believe in government? >> there are some people who believe we're going to need another revolution some day. they cannot accept the fact that 1500 atf agents are going to come knocking on their door one day and give them obamacare and take away their gun there is a complete overlap between people who really dislike and don't trust the government and people who want not just a gun, but lots and lots and guns.
4:39 pm
the nra stokes this pair i knowia. >> it's semiconductor lar. back here watching this thing. and it's still going on. let's go to jim cavanaugh. your hunch has been very interesting so far from the beginning of this developing story about the wonder, to use a ipo word for a horrible situation of three men in masks with long guns going to a facility, which treats people with autism and epilepsy and all kinds of problems, trying to better themselves every day. and shooting so many people. almost 30 people shot. >> yeah, chris, you know, and you're feeling that, the awfulness of this crime. i mean, we all feel it. and that also goes to the motivation. it's deep seated motivation. what can get someone to do that in the instant case? you had mention of an l.a. times reporter serrano. he is one of the great journalists out west there. he's got sources. he said it might be something
4:40 pm
kicked out of a meeting. it could be. but to be able to do that, to come back, that would be a revenge motive. and a deep seated revenge motive, to come back and shoot all these people, you know, and to get others to help you. like i say, you could have family members. we could all site a few cases where people, multiple actors have done this. so it's not out of the realm of possibility. it's just more the unusual. >> by the way, how do they get the masks, the masks? >> yeah, the masks. and the full ballistic outfit and the rifles, you know. circling back around to see the crime scene maybe and they're still in the neighborhood there is a whole lot of moving pieces to this that we just don't know. the chief may clear up some of those, chris, in the next few minutes. but always the most interesting thing on these is motive, the human mind. what makes people want to do these things. and we all want to study them to see that we can stop them.
4:41 pm
and, you know, it is just such an unusual target, unusual event. and a vicious, vicious crime. i mean, we're on the heels of paris. we're on the heels of planned parenthood. you know, we're seeing the world sort of unravel in this gun violence thing for a lot of dierent reasons. a lot of different criminal purposes. that's just the world we live in. but we've still got to try to break it down so we can do the best committee can to stop the next one. >> well, we're just hearing now, our reporting is that the school lockdown has ended. so that part of the drama has end. msnbc's jacob soboroff is back with us with a better voice now. he is near the police who are searching for that third suspect. this is the live danger here. jacob? >> chris, so i don't know if you can see my pictures right now. but the law enforcement officers, in fact right here directly next to me are setting up police tape in one of the
4:42 pm
heavily armed tactical sheriff's deputies here told me to step back and quote/unquote take cover. i don't know if that's precautionary. words to get me become or get us media back. but he did mention the word explosives. this is the word of a sheriff's tactical deputy to me here on the street. again, i don't know if that's just a precautionary language for this sheriff's deputy to use to move us back here. but that's what they told us. and as you can see, if you can still see my pictures. >> yes, i can. >> they have an expanded perimeter here. >> you close to the suspects' escape vehicle? >> i would say we're about -- and you can see there, chris, that there is a woman who is poking her head out. her house now is cordoned off within the police tape. and she is sort of looking out worriedlied a the sheriff's deputies, tactical deputies are outside of her house. i'd say we're in between where the event took place this morning and the event that took place this afternoon where the officers encountered this
4:43 pm
suspect's vehicle. that's suspects plural. >> part of so many strange aspects, the suspect vehicle is so close to where the crime scene occurred. it looked like all the hours that were available to get away, they weren't really exploited to get away. am i right about that, jacob? >> well, i can tell you again, chris, that this manhunt is going on. you know, with this walking distance, it might be a little bit of a walk, but walking distance within the events of this morning. and that was at 11:00 this morning pacific time. it's now 4:45 pacific time here in the san bernardino county, los angeles area. and, you know, that is not far away from the events of this morning. >> yes, striking. let's go back. thank you. hold on there, jacob, and keep taking the pictures. clint van zandt is an fbi profiler. he is an msnbc analyst. i've been waiting to hear from you, my colleague. please tell us if you can figure out what is going on here. >> well, what i think we need to understand, chris, is as soon as we get this third person in
4:44 pm
custody, and perhaps anybody who supported them is what was the emotional glue that would enable three people to bind this close. we always deal with this lone white nut who goes in and shoots a place up and commits these verbal acts. we know this is the worst mass shooting in america since sandy hook. so the question we're asking is, you know, we understand, unfortunately, we terribly understand in this country that one person can go in and commit a terrible act like this. but what is the emotional glue that would bond three people together that, you know, you would put your hands on top of each other and say, okay, the three of us are going to go in. we're going to commit an act of mass murder. and we're going to fight to the death. chris, of about 150 mass murderers that the fbi has studied, only two of the 150 had more than one shooter. so there is still pieces that we
4:45 pm
don't have of this to understand. and we're likely to find out there is more of a support system perhaps than this last shooter that law enforcement's desperately looking for before day turns into night. >> you know, i remind myself of a movie buff, as everyone knows now from watching this program. all i can think about is the behavior of those brother gangs from like "shane", the ryker gang. >> sure. >> they all come in and they all get killed. and they go in to kill. and that is the kind of dramatic horror we're looking here. some strange strain of anger that has brought them into this situation. it's not impulsive. you don't wear masks, dow you've don't carry long guns on an impulsive situation. let's go to the police with the latest official word from the san bernardino police at this press conference. well, it's coming up yet. it's coming up soon. it was going to happen at 4:45 their time, 7:45 our time back here in washington. we're look at everybody getting ready for this kind of thing.
4:46 pm
but i'll tell you, let me good right now. let me go to blake mccoy. let me ask you what you have. we're now pretty much zeroed in on three suspects. one still at large. >> one still at large. two down in that vehicle. and chris, it's really remarkable to think that all of this is taking place just a mile or two away from the initial shooting that occurred just about a block away from me here. >> yes. >> four hours later is when the suspects' vehicle was tracked down. and when they started following it. four hours. and those suspects were still in this immediate area. you have to think officers thought they were long gone by then. and when that suspect vehicle was found and they were cornered, officers hightailed it over there, lights and sirens. police helicopters took off from this location and are now searching for that third suspect. we do know two are down in that suv. but remarkable to think that with that much time that passed, that they were still in this area four hours later. >> well, the interesting thing is, the police were still on the
4:47 pm
lookout for a dark suv within walking distance. i would have thought they had given up, that the perimeter would have been so wide at the point a couple of hours later that they would have given up on a dragnet. here they picked it up in a very tight dragnet. >> and you would have thought that with that much time they could have switch vehicles or at least made it far outside of san bernardino county and they didn't. they were right here. it will be interesting to see what the motive was, who these three people were. we do know 14 people killed, of course, 17 people injured. it appears this happened at a community room, some sort of gathering place at that site that was perhaps being rented out by other county health employees. that's what we're hearing hath at this point. we're still working to confirm all that information. >> well, thank you for that again. i want to remind everybody about the strangeness of this reporting tonight. and if it seems uneven, let me explain. this is the first time we've had television pictures because of a helicopter way ahead of the actual human reporting. we've been trying to get information from the official
4:48 pm
sources, from the authority there's. of course the san bernardino police. and we're waiting for press conferences every hour or so, which we're going to have one any moment now. but of course we've been watching the action way ahead of the reporting, and certainly way ahead of the official word. so we're getting this in stages. we're seeing some of it before we know what we're look at. we watched what looked to be a standoff for very many moments there, maybe an hour. turns out the standoff was police surrounding a car. the suspect vehicle there. we're watching it right now. the escape vehicle, if you will, with apparently two people in it. one dead, one wounded. we believe as of now at least with one of the suspects, the third having escaped somewhere into that neighborhood, which another irony here, which is very much where the crime occurred itself. so they didn't race to escape. they didn't seek to get on to a freeway and head for mexico or anywhere else. they just stayed in the area with their long guns, and maybe with their masks. so this is a -- it's a repellent situation to report on with anyone. let me go to manny gomez in this. we have a moment or two.
4:49 pm
manny, how do you put this together? >> they're not small homes. >> obviously planned this escape. this wasn't something that was put together overnight. and lo and behold, they had plenty of time to get away further. they had plenty of exit routes, whether it was south to mexico, east to las vegas. but they chose to stay in that nearby neighborhood. we'll probably find out in the not so far future why, but more importantly we need to get that third probably very desperate. >> yes. >> -- fugitive that is still out there. we don't know what he has in terms of weaponry. does he have any explosive devices. the first responders i'm sure are making every effort to try to put that community in lockdown and to protect the citizens in those homes. but at the same time, they also have to protect themselves from this guy. >> yes. >> who is out there running amok. >> armed and dangerous would be
4:50 pm
an understatement. let's go to nbc's morgan radford who is outside the loma linda hospital where some of the victims of the shoot having been taken. morgan, give us a report on the victims. >> that's right. we're standing outside of loma linda hospital. but, in fact, there was a bomb threat that was called in within the past two hours, and it was just lifted within the past hour. and you can imagine that's in the middle of a very chaotic scene here. choppers leaving the hospital and emergency vehicles coming in. we actually spoke to a woman who's guarding the family entrance to this hospital. and she spoke to three or four members of different families, one of whom was a young man who was just waiting to hear any news he could on his uncle. so the families of the 17 victims that we now know of are waiting. and officers from the hospital have said they do not expect any new victims to come in tonight, but we did just see in the last hour, an officer who did suffer nonlife-threatening injuries, but injuries related to today's shooting, coming into this
4:51 pm
hospital. so right now it's a waiting game. >> it looks like they made to the hospital fast enough to deal with trauma. is that case? you're not hearing horrific stories of people dying in the hospital. was that the case? they got there fast enough to deal with the shock trauma? >> reporter: that does appear to be the case, although it's still a very fluid situation. people are coming in, and you can probably even sirens behind me now. it's unclear exactly what state people were in when they arrived here and what conditions their health was in, but we're keeping an eye on it for you right now. >> not bad news from the hospital, at least yet. thank you so much for that reporting. let me go back to jim cavanaugh. i'll leave you at any moment probably for the night. the hour is getting near the end with it and we're still hit with a situation of a lot of information, but nothing coming together yet, jim. >> chris, you know, i think it's interesting the point you're discussing with clint, with manny gomez there, these guys were not far away. but i don't find it necessarily unusual in this kind of criminal
4:52 pm
behavior. when we think guys want to escape and get far away, we're usually thinking about motives of greed and robberies and bank robberies and they're going to have a reason to get away. and a lot of these killers like this look at paris, even though that was a terrorist motive, we don't know this will be that, but he went back to the scene, for 45 years in bomb and arson investigation, we talked about and taught and had suspects return to the scene. they wanted to watch what was going on. and this is also something we see in these shooters. these guys didn't want to leave. they want to see their work, and the chaos and see what's going on. and i don't think they live very far away. they're people that live maybe in the county, maybe in the neighboring county, but they're not people who have traveled
4:53 pm
across the country for this. they're not really afraid of a patrol officer encountering them, because they believe they could kill and get away again. that's kind of the criminal mind that's taken over here in this masked killing. almost a bomber-type mentality, mass killing and they want to see the chaos. >> let me get you to flesh that out. most of us grew up with the idea the criminal returns to the scene of the crime, whether that's legend or reality, but you say there's something to it. would they have stuck around and watched people suffer the from their wounds? >> i think so. i think they want to see all the action. you know, we see this in arsonists sometimes. they want to see the fire trucks screaming to the scene, they want to see the blaze, they want to see the hospital. in this case, think of the chaos there. the fire engines, the paramedics, the people screaming, the news media, the helicopters. they want to see all of this, chris, because they did all of this.
4:54 pm
and so, you know, it's part of their whole operation. like i say, terrorists in paris want to do it and even wants to film it with a cell phone, maybe for later propaganda, that's a little different twist on it, but they do want to see their work and the chaos they've ro t wrought on people. >> we return right now to wait for the police update. right now we're joined on the phone by officer christina wood with the california highway patrol. give us a sense of the police action we're watching now on television. >> yes, thank you for having me. you know, first as part of the california highway patrol, we want to send our condolences and our heartfelt -- just, as you can tell, we're still active in this and still fluid and kind of all thinking in here. our hearts go out to the victims and their families, first and foremost. this is a very scary situation
4:55 pm
and it's a situation that we train for. >> when you're hunting for someone armed and dangerous, what's the rules of engagement? shoot on sight or what? >> stop the threat. learning to engage an active shooter, we're trained to go towards the shooting, you know, we're the one that goes towards it while everyone else goes away. that's what we're here to do and that's what we did. >> did it surprise you that these suspects, two of them in custody, one dead, of course, the other one wounded, apparently, in custody, two of them down, altogether, one still at large, that they didn't really try to get away. they're still in the area. >> you know, every situation is different. every suspect is different, and in this case, it seems that they stuck around. it's not always the case, but we're always on our toes for
4:56 pm
that instance. in this case, it paid off. >> what is your sense, as an officer confronting people with long guns, as opposed to people with pistols? what do you make of it? the fact that all these of these men had masks on, they committed this mass shooting. they tried to kill 30 people. they killed 14. certainly, bullets were fired at people successfully up to 17 and 14, it's 31 now. what does it tell you that they had long guns and one of them may have one now? >> you know, obviously, the fact that they were -- the descriptions that we go as far as long guns and maybe what they were wearing, you know, they were prepared. this was planned. and it's a scary world right now that we're seeing this more and more. and while we hope we never have to respond to an active shooter incident, being prepared through
4:57 pm
training as law enforcement ensures our response to provide immediate life-saving assistance. that's our goal. >> if you're out there right now going door to door, looking for a suspect in a major mass shooting where 31 were shot and 14 are dead already, would you assume that that suspect, that fugitive did not want to get caught? >> absolutely. >> he did not want to be taken alive. >> he may have stayed in the area, but of course they don't want to get caught. >> or taken alive. >> that's subjective, you know, who knows? we come across all sorts of people. people who do suicide by cop or people who run from us. you never know who's going to come across. >> what does suicide by cop mean? >> unfortunately, some people, they put themselves in a situation where, you know, it requires us to take action and sometimes that involves lethal action. it's never what we want.
4:58 pm
it's not how we want it to end. thank you so much, christina wood of the california highway patrol. thank you for joining us. we'll go right now to the press conference and find out what we can officially right now from the san bernardino police officials, including the chief. it keeps being delayed. i keep thinking we're going into this, we're not. there you can see the cameras and the microphones are set there for all the various organizations who are covering this. of course, this is one of those stories that has grabbed the nation's attention. this is not a local story. it's become a pattern. mark? >> it's a pattern now. >> it's an absolute pattern and one that's been accelerating for reasons that are complicated, except the fact that congress refuses to do anything about it. here's a way how it's local. >> have you noticed the conservatives are all saying, we're going to pray for the victims. >> we're all going to pray for the victims. >> that's not really their role. >> step two after you're a policy maker after you give your regards and sympathies is to actually do something about it. and they don't do it, because they're afraid of the gun law.
4:59 pm
but california has something interesting going on. they have pretty good gun laws, but they could be better. the lieutenant governor of the state, gavin newsom are working to put an initiative on the ballot that would significant tighten gun laws in ways that may have been relevant to the shooting. we don't know about this shooting, but almost always -- >> california is a state that doesn't seem to me that intimidated by the gun lobby. feinstein's been out there for years, tough. >> and there's also a tough and aggressive anti-gun control group out there that does its best. >> it's not like pennsylvania or ohio. >> it's not, there are a few nra members and more people who, because they live in concentrated areas, want to do some good. but there's going to be a ballot initiative that might or might not have affected this. it's going to ban magazines. >> we're expecting a live news conference with the police in san bernardino, california. they promised to update every hour, on the hour. right now, msnbc's coverage of
5:00 pm
the mass shooting continues with chris hayes. >> thank you, chris. it's 8:00 p.m. here in the west, 5:00 p.m. in the west. and if you're just joining, if you've looked at the internet today, you know there's been a horrific mass shooting. it's the worst mass shooting in this country since sandy hook that killed more than two dozen children in a school. that mass shooting today taking place at the inland regional center. it's a social security nonprofit with over 600 employees, it serves 35,000 people, many of them with developmental challenges. it appears the target of the mass shooting was a conference center inside that facility in san bernardino, a conference center that had been rented out for the day to the county department of health, which was holding, essentially, a christmas banquet. reports that as many as 200 people were in that room, around 11:20 local time, when we are told three gunman burst into that room and started firing with long guns.
182 Views
IN COLLECTIONS
MSNBC West Television Archive The Chin Grimes TV News Archive Television Archive News Search ServiceUploaded by TV Archive on