that unlimited 2% cash back from spark means thousands of dollars each year going back into my business... that's huge for my bottom line. what's in your wallet? the war between bernie sanders and the democratic party. good morning. i'm jonathan capehart. thanks for getting up with us. big developments overnight in the fight between the bernie sanders campaign and the democratic party. the details on that are ahead. we're also learning more about the president's visit last night with the victims' families and first responders of the san bernardino shooting. we'll be joined by a former white house staff member whoing a companied the president to newtown connecticut three years

ago to discuss his touching account of what it was like when president obama met with the sandy hook families. we'll have more on that in just a moment. plus what the president had to say in his final press conference of the year. also this morning, it's now officially year two of the improved relationship between the u.s. and cuba. new details about what exactly the new friendship will look like. we'll also be joined by the south carolina lawmaker who wants to make men jump over the same hurdles to get a viagra prescription that women have to clear in order to access abortion services. we begin with president obama making a visit to have been on his way to hawaii to visit with victims' family members and first responders. those meetings lasting much longer than expected. morgan rat ford has the dehe tails. >> reporter: between morning. governor jerry brown has declared a state of emergency to help the community recover. this comes 16 days after attack.

president obama offering comfort, meeting privately friday with families of the 14 victims who lost their lives in the san bernardino massacre. >> despite the pain and the heartache that they're feeling, they could not have been more inspiring. and more proud of their loved ones and more insistent that something good comes out of this tragedy. >> words of encouragement to a community rocked by the attack. and now haunted by what could have happened. in a 36 page affidavit, prosecutors say syed farook and his longtime friend enrique h marquez planned to attack riverside city college in 2011. >> it's crazy that you wouldn't want to hurt so many people that you know since he was a student here. >> reporter: and it didn't stop there. they also planned to throw pipe bombs on to a stretch of busy freeway with no exits to maximize the number of casualties. and then farook would walk between each of the cars

shooting drivers one by one while marquez fired shots from the hillside. >> i drive every day to take my daughter to school on the 91, so it's very scary. >> reporter: marquez was arrested this week on three criminal charges. he bought two guns for farook in 2011 and 2012, guns later used in the san bernardino attack. but prosecutors say there is no evidence marquez knew what farook and his wife, tashfeen malik, had planned. in fact, he called 911 when he realized what had happened, telling the praoperator telling the can trace all the guns back to me. the operator asking you said he used your gun? marquez, yes, oh, my god. but the question remains how do they go undetected for so long. >> our intelligence efforts are excellent, but we don't have an stray f x-ray for a man's soul. >> reporter: marquez remains in custody. meanwhile so many unanswered

questions for this community still in shock. jonathan. >> morgan rad ford, thanks for joining us. last night's meetings were private as they should have been, so it's difficult for to us know exactly what happened. but we've seen images from similar events in recent years. this is president obama in july 2012 hugging stephanie davies who helped her friend alley young stay alive after she was shot during the movie theater massacre in a in aurora, califo. and this is the president comforting a woman sitting in the family section at a memorial service for the victims of the washington manavy yard shootingn september 2013. and is thisthis is is photo of holding the grantd daughtddaughe slin principal in newtown. we're learning more about what that day was like. in a new memoir, joshua dubois

writes, quote, person after person received an engulfing hug from our commander in chief. he'd say tell me about your son. tell me about your daughter. and then hold pictures of the lost beloved as their parents described favorite foods, television shows and the sound of their laughter. for the younger siblings of those who had passed away, many ever them two, three, four years old, too young to understand it all, the president would grab them and toss them laughing up into the air and then happened them a box of white house m and ms which were always kept at close hand. in each room, i saw his eyes water, but he did not break. and then the entire scene would repeat for hours. over aover and over again, through well over 100 relatives. each one equally broken, wrecked by the loss. we spent what felt like a lifetime in those classrooms.

and every single person received the same tender treatment, the same hugs, the same looks directly in their eyes. the author of the president's devotional and former director of the white house office of faith based and neighborhood partnerships joins us thousan s. thanks for being here. >> thanks for having me. >> as we see the first pictures of the president in his meetings with the families in san bernardino, what went through your mind and what do you think was going through the president's mind at that time? >> i was thinking about how this is such a grim responsibility of the presidents, one that he and the first family have had do far too many times, but one that they don't do out of any obligation. this is simply about walking alongside those who mourn and letting them know that tear comma their commander in chief and their country is tappi istandin them. they know being there won't change what happened.country is. they know being there won't change what happened.

it won't fix everything. but if they can provide a glimmer of hope, a little briitf the comfort, even just stand along them in their sadness, it's something that the president wants do. and it's not just him. the first lady is there with him both supporting the president and these terribly emotional times, but also comforting folks herself. she went to oak creek, which isis which is after the temple there was shot up by a mad man, by a white supremacist. and spent time with those families, as well. this has unfortunately been a big obligation, a responsibility of this white house. and of this president. but it's something that they know that they need do and that they want do. >> i was going to say, we have been -- we have watched this president unfortunately sadly do this over and over and over again with all the mass shootings that we as a nation have endured. and i'm wondering where does the

president find the strength to do this? because as you said, he's under no obligation do this, but as a moral man, he feels com presentlied do this. but this is tough work. where does he find the strength to be the rock for these grieving families? >> i can't speak for the president, but i imagine he finds strength from a few places. certainly from his family, michelle is his rock. the first lady is his rock as are his girls. i think he finds strength in d god. he's a committed christian. his faith he keeps close to hart and leans on in tough times. and quite frankly from the folks impacted by the tragedy, they have shown friday courage.times. and quite frankly from the folks impacted by the tragedy, they have shown friday courage. they are inspiring themselves and he feels it's the least he can do to be there for them. so i think it's a few places, but i imagine does have to take

a toll on him. >> and since you were in newtown and you were in the room with the president as he talked to the families, talk to us about the families' reactions to the president coming in and grieving with them. >> very widely certainly there are some folks who it was just a little bit of a break to be able to meet a man that they heard a lot about and to spend a little bit of i'm with him, just a little bit of an important distraction in a terrible, terrible time in their lives. some folks were just overcome by emotion, still processing what it means to lose their loved ones and sharing with the president their loved ones' quirks and favorite jokes and favorite meals and so forth. and so we have all had to be there for people that we love and care about in their time of need. and it's similar to that unfortunately, something take just happens over and over again. i think they said the president spent three hours with these folks yesterday. and i think that's one of the things he always wants people to

know is that take as much time as you need. and he'll be there. >> joshua, let me bring in our panel into this discussion. david corn is an msnbc political analyst and bureau chief for mother jones magazine. tom doherty, republican strategist and former adviser to george pataki. and jenelle ross is my colleague, reporter for the "washington post" the fix. your reaction to what joshua is talking about, but also the president once again consoling grieving families. >> you you know, it's not part of the official job description. and i think when he got the job, he didn't expect to be doing it so much. and i think it's wonderful that he does, that he's able to according to josh and others maintain this sort of one-on-one connection with these victims and their families and not become jaded to it even though we have politically become jaded. and to inject a little bit of

politics into this, this is msnbc, i wonder what would be happening if we had a republican president overseeing all these shootings. because obama at least has this position that he wants to do something, enact some laws. people can argue whether that's the right recourse or not. a lot of families tend to want to see gun safety measures endorsed. not the all, but some afterwards. so he's been trying to fight for this, as well. so it's not just consolation. he has prescription to kind of move forward. and most republicans are not in that position. >> well, try to move forward. >> i have a question for josh. is there a time frame that sort of having been through newtown and now, san bernardino, that is appropriate? the president has gotten i think unfair criticism that this is sort of a fly by, he's on his way to hi. this obviously means a lot to the families. is there a time frame that you wait a week, two weeks?

do you let things settle down for the families? >> and it's been more than those two estimates of course. over and over again, and jonathan quoted some at the top of the segment. even down in charleston. most of it is driven by the families in my experience. the white house is in constant communication with those who are affected, with the first responders, with the leadership in the town that is sort of overseeing investigations. and they really try to take their cues and work around their schedule where possible. i know that's what happened in newtown, certainly what happened in charleston with the funeral there and i'm sure they were in close coordination with the families in san bernardino, as well. >> so jenelle. >> i'm curious about where the president i guess has gone for guidance on the right way to act out this role as a national mourner in chief and what is appropriate and when it is appropriate. i'm wondering if there are any particular past presidents or

individuals that the president has turned to for guidance. >> you know, my sense is that he really does go with it himself in times like this and consults scripture and certainly talks to the first lady and staff and just sort of hashes it out. but mostly this is just sort of an interpersonal dynamic between ima him and those impacted. he looks them in their eyes and asks them to tell their what's on their heart and put around arm around them and hold them close for a bit and just provide whatever comfort he can. it's not very complex, but it is very heartfelt. >> interesting this is happening in a very political moment, too, because the republicans in presidential debates basically saying the president is incompetent, a weakling, donald trump says putin is a better leader. and yet we see him in this role which is just pure leadership.

it's not about politics or policy. and seems to be wearing this very heavily but actually doing the job very well. >> we have seen since president clinton in the oklahoma city bombing is where people say that president clinton found his sea legs as president of being consoler in chief. and unfortunately, because of the mass shootings that we've seen over and over and over again during this president's tenure, that he has unfortunately mastered the role of being consoler in chief. josh joshua, thank you very much for being with us. up next, one 24rthreat, two ver different reactions from two of the largest school systems. their response is presenting a major challenge. what are authorities looking for to determine how legitimate a threat really is? the holidays bring many challenges to the feet.

by day, they must stay warm. but by night, beautiful, smoother and ready to impress the other party animals. dr. scholl's dreamwalk express pedi just serve classy snacks and bew a gracious host,iday party. no matter who shows up. [cricket sound] richard. didn't think you were going to make it.

hey sorry about last weekend, i don't know what got into me. well forgive and forget... kind of. i don't think so! do you like nuts? marie callender knows that a any occasion feel more special. so she makes her pie crust from scratch. and sprinkles on brown sugar streusel. so that you can spend more time making special moments... ...with your family. marie callender's it's time to savor.

is our partnership with habitat for humanity. pg&e is committed to clean energy and part of that commitment our mission is to build homes, community and hope. our homeowners are low-income families, so the ability for them to have lower energy cost is wonderful. we have been able to provide about 600 families with solar on their homes. that's over nine and a half million dollars of investment by pg&e, and that allows us to provide clean energy for everyone here. it's been a great partnership. together, we're building a better california.

earlier this week the nation's two largest school systems received nearly identical threats of a terrorist attack on the very same day. but the two cities reacted very differently. new york city determined the threat was not credible, but ladies and gentlemen matt tmade the unprecedented decisions to serve the schools. >> based on the information we have, this was a very generic piece of writing stoeent to a number of places apsz written in a fashion that suggests it is not plausible and we've come to the conclusion that we must continue to keep our school system open. in fact it's very important not to overreact in situations like

this. >> when parents make their determination about the decisions that were made today, i would ask them to look at this way. if you knew what the superintendent and the school board knew at 5:30 thorn when t this morning when the decision had to be made, would you have sent your kichild to school. and every parent i've asked has said no, of course not. i think that should be the test of all of us to ask our school to pass. joining me now to discuss the challenges of assessing terror threats, former new york homeland security director michael balboni. thank you very much for being here. here is what the los angeles school superintendent had to say about the decision to close the schools. he said, i go back to 9/11. people knew something. maybe they didn't know enough, but they knew something and they didn't act. and i was not going to let something happen to my watch. i knew i had do something

quickly if i was going to do something. >> tremendous pressure. and it's really a no win situation. because if you do something and it turns out not to happen, then you're the goat. and yet obviously if something does happen and you haven't reacted. but in this case, one of the things that really was puzzling, the e-mail itself, now that we know, it had similar language. i'm a student, we're here, i'm in l.a., i'm in new york, we're going to attack. that's what the e-mail message said. so a quick little calibration and communication between the two different districts, what are you seeing, that would have been a very significant tell as to whether this was real. but here is the other thing. anybody who has any experience with al qaeda or isis knows that they don't forecast when they're going to attack. they never do. they never say we're going to come because they want to come when you're not watching. so what is the process, right? you take a look at what is the threat. how specific it is.

is it reasonable. could somebody actually do it. what is the capabilities that they're expressing. and then you talk about what is your risk, what is your vulnerability, and are there ways to mitigate that. so what is so extraordinary about this is the size of the district. they said from one minute to the next, we're not going forward. and you're decide doing something different. >> what is interesting here is what you were describing between new york and los angeles, they both got this e-mail, but what i'm wondering is do they talk to each other? it's like they're reacting in isolation, but should we be talking about a district that -- the top five school districts should at least if they get a threat zap it around to each other and say do you know anything about this. >> i would argue that the department of homeland security intelligence analysis center, that they take information, they put it together, and then they will send it out to the localities. they should have been the adults in the room to sit there and say, well, wait a minute, are you seeing the same thing, let's

take a look at this this, what is the background. can we find the server from where it is sent. all these things that said, yeah, it just doesn't sound credible. but it's a terrible decision for a local school district to have to make. >> and on that note, michael baboni, thank you very much. still ahead, is it just a matter of time before the death penalty in this country is a thing of the past? we'll take a look at what is behind the steep decline of executions. but first, the ongoing dispute between bernie sanders campaign and dnc. what really happened. and a preview of tonight's debate is next. here's dad. mom. the twins. aunt alice... you didn't tell me aunt alice was coming. of course. don't forget grandpa. can the test drive be over now? maybe just head back to the dealership? don't you want to meet my family? yep, totally.

it's practically yours, but we still need your signature. the volkswagen sign then drive event. zero due at signing, zero down, zero deposit, and zero first months payment on a new jetta and other select models. and i'm still struggling with my diabetes. i do my best to manage. but it's hard to keep up with it. your body and your diabetes change over time. your treatment plan may too. know your options. once-daily toujeo® is a long-acting insulin from the makers of lantus®. it releases slowly to provide consistent insulin levels for a full 24 hours. toujeo® also provides proven full 24-hour blood sugar control and significant a1c reduction. toujeo® is a long-acting, man-made insulin used to control high blood sugar in adults with diabetes. it contains 3 times as much insulin in 1 milliliter as standard insulin. don't use toujeo® to treat diabetic ketoacidosis, during episodes of low blood sugar, or if you're allergic to insulin.

allergic reaction may occur and may be life threatening. don't reuse needles or share insulin pens, even if the needle has been changed. the most common side effect is low blood sugar, which can be serious and life threatening. it may cause shaking, sweating, fast heartbeat, and blurred vision. check your blood sugar levels daily while using toujeo®. injection site reactions may occur. don't change your dose or type of insulin without talking to your doctor. tell your doctor if you take other medicines and about all your medical conditions. insulins, including toujeo, in combination with tzds (thiazolidinediones) may cause serious side effects like heart failure that can lead to death, even if you've never had heart failure before. don't dilute or mix toujeo® with other insulins or solutions as it may not work as intended and you may lose blood sugar control, which could be serious. pay no more than $15 per prescription for 12 months. eligibility restrictions apply. learn more at toujeo.com/info or call 800-580-3421.

also, 9 out of 10 medicare part d patients can get toujeo® at the lowest branded copay. ask your doctor about the proven full 24-hour blood sugar control of toujeo®. the citi double cash® card comes in very handy with cash back twice on purchases. earn once when you buy, and again as you pay. that's cash back now, and cash back again later. it's cash back déjà vu. the citi double cash card. the only card that lets you earn cash back twice on every purchase with 1% when you buy and 1% as you pay. with two ways to earn, it makes a lot of other cards seem one sided.

democrats are set to carry off tonight for their third debate, but it's the fight between bernie sanders campaign and democratic national committee making headlines. they reached a deal to gain access to the party voter database after a staffer allegedly accessed the data improper improperly. for more on this, we head to new hampshire and chris dekristen w. what is the latest? >> reporter: it has been a stunning 24 hours. and now bernie sanders is under fire really for the first time in his campaign. and clinton is on the attack, her campaign accusing him of stealing their private voter information. now, even though the legal issues appear resolved this morning, the gloves have clearly come off. overnight a deal, the democratic party agreeing to give bernie sanders' campaign access once again to a database of potential voters. this after a firestorm of controversy. sanders facing questions about why one of his staffers took advantage of a computer glifrp glitch in the democratic national committee data files. the staffer was fired. >> i did not download any voter

file data. >> reporter: the sanders campaign sued the dnc for temporarily cutting off access to its own files. outraged, sanders supporters signed and online petition accusing the party of trying to guarantee a clinton win. a consistent accusation from team sanders. the dnc chair pushed back. >> if the zshoe were on the othr foot and the clinton campaign had accessed sanders campaign data inappropriately, the sanders campaign would expect me to react in the exact same way. >> reporter: the dnc gave in on sanders' demands before they were to appear in court saying in a statement that the campaign agreed to cooperate with the party investigation and that, quote, we are glad that all parties are moving forward and that the candidates and party can refocus on engaging voters on the issue it is that matter to them. and while sanders gave clinton a pass over her e-mail controversy in the first democratic

debate -- >> the american people are sick and tired of hearing about your damn e-mails. >> thank you. >> reporter: the question now, will clinton attack him tonight for this breach. the democratic frontrunner surgeon at times acting like the nominee already. >> as president, i would work with responsible gun owners. >> reporter: now, the dnc is launching an independent audit. the clinton campaign said this morning, quote, we believe this audit should proceed immediately and pending its findings, we expect further disciplinary action to be taken as appropriate. and jonathan, you can expect this to really overshadow at least the first part of tonight's debate. back to you. >> absolutely. kristen welker, thanks very much. now, that fired staffer talked with our very own steve kornacki yesterday. take a listen to this. >> we didn't actually like use it for anything valuable. and we didn't take custodian ship of it. we didn't -- it's like the

equivalent of maybe somebody leaves the front door open for the fifth time, although this was the first time that they made a mistake like this, but somebody leaves the front door open and you left a note inside the front door saying you left the door open. and then maybe you wouldnyou we chekd checked the side door, too. >> okay, now, first your reaction to that explanation and then did the dnc as a result of that explanation, did the dnc overreact? >> well, i think overall this is a tempest in a thumb drive. it will disappear after the debate. but, you know, if the door to your neighbor's house is open, you can walk up, you can go, hey, anybody home, and then you close the door and walk away. if you have to call the cops, you call the cops. it's a bad examination. but everybody in this case has overreacted. dnc overreactednation.

but everybody in this case has overreacted. dnc overreacted and sanders overreacted. >> what about what deny bbie wasserman schultz said, that if the clinton campaign had done this, what would the reaction be. >> i think there are two things going on here. one, this situation seems to run sort of counter to the narrative that the sanders campaign has wanted to put out about itself. and that i think voters believe and understand about sanders. that they are running sort of an outsider campaign, they're the underdog, they have to fight harder, et cetera, et cetera. now we've crossed the line into something that seems like some possible cheating so to speak, right? and furthermore, in listening to the gentleman who was fired speak, i can given to understand why shall peopome people's eyeb up. this young person sounded like a student trying to justify plagiarism. oh, it's not that bad, just two

sentences. listen, you either close the door and do your civic duty and walk away and alert your neighbor that your front door was open, or you walk in and look arounded a lea ed and leav. >> and we're talking about four people who saved stuff. >> they turned the tvo and sat away and watched a football game and they had let's get out of here before they find out. i didn't recognize that isn't it silly for the dnc to be hosting all of this information that is really clinton information or sanders information? they just put themselves in a position where something like this would happen where they're stealing from one another. you would think you would want to host it in your own site that no one can get a hold of. >> there is a reason. i thought that, too, at first. but the explanation they gave yesterday is that all this voter data information will eventually be used in the general election. and so they're as accept blsemir

them. it's the vender that screwed up and then the bernie sanders campaign that sat down and looked at the pachbti ipanties,. >> if hillary had done this, we'd be talk about this for the next three weeks. >> let's talk about tonight's debate. one of the issues here is that bernie sanders has been sort of knocked off his stride. he's going into this debate a lot of people thinking he's been off message, especially because terrorism and international issues have taken over the conversation as opposed to domestic policies and economic issues, which is senator sanders' strength. what does he have do tonight to sort of get back the burn, if you will? >> i think he has to demonstrate some actual and clear confidence on straight up core foreign policy issues and homeland security yissues. and he probably does need to display some ability to connect

the issues that he cares most about or that he is most deeply connected to, which is economic instability to shows issues. it's not impossible, but it has to be done with care and artfully. >> and this guy knows what the nuclear triad is. he he's worked a lot on foreign policy issues. but his cause has been economic insecurity and inequality.e he' policy issues. but his cause has been economic insecurity and inequality. he's policy issues. but his cause has been economic insecurity and inequality.he's policy issues. but his cause has been economic insecurity and inequality.'s ju turns a different way, it looks like he's not engaged. but he has the intelligence to address that. one question i think we have here, at what point does it become too late to close the gap between him and hillary clinton that seems to be there at least in the general national polls. >> he needs to win new hampshire is what he needs do. and so he has to focus on voter turnout is the first step for him. i mean, he'll have a ground

game. what he says tonight is less important to what happens in new hampshire. because he doesn't get through new hampshire with a win, it's over. >> and i agree with you, tom. still ahead, why in my opinion ben carson won tuesday night's republican debate without having to say a single word. and next, why filling a viagra prescription may be getting a little tougher in one southern state. stay with us. thousands of people came out today to run the race for retirement. so we asked them... are you completely prepared for retirement? okay, mostly prepared? could you save 1% more of your income? it doesn't sound like much, but saving an additional 1% now, could make a big difference over time. i'm going to be even better about saving. you can do it, it helps in the long run. prudential bring your challenges (politely) wait, wait, wait! you cayou have to rinse it first. that's baked-on alfredo. baked-on? it's never gonna work.

dish issues? trust your dishwasher with cascade platinum. it powers... through... your toughest stuck-on food. better than finish. cascade. put under a microscope, we can see all the bacteria that still exists. polident's unique micro clean formula works in just 3 minutes, killing 99.99% of odor causing bacteria. for a cleaner, fresher, brighter denture every day. that's why i switched from u-verse to xfinity. now i can download my dvr recordings

and take them anywhere. ready or not, here i come! (whispers) now hide-and-seek time can also be catch-up-on-my-shows time. here i come! can't find you anywhere! don't settle for u-verse. x1 from xfinity will change the way you experience tv.

i tabut with my back paines, i couldn't sleep and get up in time. then i found aleve pm. aleve pm is the only one to combine a safe sleep aid plus the 12 hour pain relieving strength of aleve. i'm back. aleve pm for a better am. what would ham if men had to jump over the same hurdles to get viagra as women have to clear in order to gain access to abortion services? that's the question a state represent the difference in south carolina is hoping to answer with new proposed legislation.bill would limit the ability of men to get erectile dysfunction drugs unless they undergo a 24 hour waiting period, they submit a notarized affidavit from at least one sexual partner affirming that

the patient has experienced symptoms of e.d. within the last 90 days and they are examined by a state licensed sex all therapist to make sure their e.d. is not attributele solely to one or more sig lodpsycholog conditions. and finally, within six month, patients must attend three outpatient counseling sessions where they will pursue celibacy. she joins us to tell us more. now, why did you introduce this legislation? >> well, you know, i'm just fed up with with the way we do things in south carolina. and i'm certainly not saying that abortion and erectile dysfunction are the same. but surely one can't happen

without the other. so i just think it's time that we focus on both sides of the edivision. >> you join a growing list of female state lawmakers who are trying to counter the wave of recently passed anti-abortion laws. in ohio, state senator nina turner countered a fetal heart break bill with a measure similar to yours in south carolina. in virginia, state senator janet howell you sought an amendment that would require a rectal exam. and in new york, kelly cassidy wanted to mandate that men watching graphic video about the potential side effects. and also bills that would restrict men's ability to get vasectomies only if their life depended on it. in all three cases,s measures failed. so what has been the reaction from your colleagues to your proposed legislation? >> the reaction from my colleagues has been interesting.

not really strong. i've gotten a much stronger reaction from constituents and others outside of south carolina who see the need for this type of legislation. >> you don't think your legislation will pass, do you? >> in a male dominated legislatu legislature, it's not likely. but i do think that it has ignited a conversation that we certainly need to have. >> there are 231 new laws restricting abortions and the supreme court will hear a challenge to one of those laws passed in texas. how has the national debate over abortion in your view changed since roe v. wade?

>> wow. the national discussion has chang chang changed drastically. >> for the better or worse? >> for the worse. and that has prompted me to introduce legislation like this. because every year, we waste an extraordinary amount of time and tax dollars in my opinion debating anti-abortion bills, requiring women to jump through additional hoops and hurdles. and to investigate women's health care centers without cause. those are reasons to broaden the discussion and to look at both sides of the equation. i mean we've only been debating one. and that has got to change. >> i look forward to the sdugts coming out of south carolina because of your bill. thanks very much for being here. >> thanks so much for having me. up next, a look behind the

sudden decline in death penalties nationwide. stay with us. music: "another sunny day" by belle and sebastian ♪ ♪ ♪ such a shame it's labeled a "getaway." life should always feel like this. hampton. we go together. always get the lowest price, only when you book direct at hampton.com carnie wilson. thank you. can you hold on? ♪ hold on for one more day really? hey, i know there's pain. why do you lock yourself up in these chains? ♪ this would be so easy if you had progressive. our mobile app would let you file a claim and help you find one of our service centers where we manage the entire repair process. things will go your way if you hold on. [ sighs ] someday somebody's gonna make you wanna turn around and say goodbye.

♪ say goodbye no, you just made it weird. technology empowers us it pushes us to go further. special olympics has almost five million athletes in 170 countries. the microsoft cloud allows us to immediately be able to access information, wherever we are. information for an athlete's medical care, or information to track their personal best. with microsoft cloud, we save millions of man hours, and that's time that we can invest in our athletes and changing the world. just serve classy snacks and bew a gracious host,iday party. no matter who shows up. [cricket sound] richard. didn't think you were going to make it. hey sorry about last weekend, i don't know what got into me. well forgive and forget... kind of.

i don't think so! do you like nuts? spending the day with my niece. that make me smile. i don't use super poligrip for hold, because my dentures fit well. before those little pieces would get in between my dentures and my gum and it was uncomfortable. even well fitting dentures let in food particles. just a few dabs of super poligrip free is clinically proven to seal out more food particles so you're more comfortable and confident while you eat. so it's not about keeping my dentures in, it's about keeping the food particles out. try super poligrip free. ♪ (vo) some call it giving back. we call it share the love. during our share the love event, get a new subaru, and we'll donate $250 to those in need. bringing our total donations to over sixty-five million dollars. and bringing love where it's needed most.

love. it's what makes a subaru, a subaru. an historic drop to report in our nation's use of the death penalty this year. executions have fallen to their lowest point in more than two decades. only 28 people were put to death in 2015, all of those executions taking place in just six states. a 27 year low. just as significant, the number of new death sentences dropped to a four decade low, 49 death sentences were handed down this year. that compares to 315 death sentences in 1996. behind those numbers is a falling murder rate and juries increasingly opting for life without parole. the drop also comes as states continue to have difficulty obtaining the drugs used in lethal injections. there is also the botched execution in oklahoma in 2014. and the issue of innocence

continues to make headlines with six more death row inmates exonerated this year, bringing the total to 156 sunince the 1970s. joining me now, anti-death penalty activist and author of dead man walking, sister helen. and also co-director of the innocence project. thank you both for being here. sister helen, let me start with you. the support for the debt penalty has declined from 80% in 1994 to 61% today. what is behind those numbers and how do you respond to the fact that a majority of americans still support the death penalty? >> well, the majority of americans that support the death penalty is a theoretical death penalty. if there is a terrible crime and person is guilty, are you for the death penalty. but when you give the american people the choice, which are you for, the death penalty or life without parole, a majority now support life without parole. and you can see it in practice. so what has happened over these

years since we've had it is i'm going to speak from the end of educating the public. because i've been involved in six executions, worked with victims' families, wrote the book dead man walk. and we had a great film. just to help them understand. they don't have real information of how selective the death penalty has been from the very beginning, how it's almost always eight out of ten cases only when white people get killed that it's sought, never people of color. and people don't know any of those things. and when you can bring them close to it and then what i did in the book and what we do in the film is just bring them into the killing chamber. here is somebody who is guilty, but let's look at what it means for us as a people to decide that we will kill a human being. >> and, barry, you have the innocence project. there are people on death row

who are innocent. what role is that and the publicity as we just said, six people exonerated out of death row. what role does innocence play in this debate? >> innocence is i think really changing it in a very profound way. because it's not just the 154 death row exonerations or the six last year. but when you look at the 336 post-conviction dna exonerations, when you look at the noninondna and dna exonerat which is are over 1500, people begin to realize that they can't trust the state to get it right and there are provide found issues of doubt about whether somebody is really guilty of some of these crimes. and that makes a huge difference in the way people think about the ultimate punishment. >> and sister helen, six states have abolished the death penalty

with nebraska's likely going before the voters next year. should we be expecting more states to abolish the death penalty any anytime soon and what do you expect to happen in nebraska? >> in nebraska, i just happened to be with the two senators in rome who led that legislation. and they said it was a tough fight, but it's that education of the people. and also a significant factor i want to add in here, too, is the role that victims' families that are speaking out saying that the death penalty doesn't help them, it's eight years since new jersey did away with the death penalty and 62 murder victims' families said this doesn't heal us, this doesn't give us closure to wait years and years. that's been a factor, as well. and if you look across the whole spectr spectrum, what you look for first is practice begins to diminish. the last thing that will happen is that it will be repealed on the books.

supreme court may itself in the death penalty, from justice breyer strong dissent. looking at the practice. supreme court has never looked at the practice. they keep holding on to the theory of it. but will this practice, it's never worked because from the very beginning, the supreme court gave us the guidelines to the states, only go after the worst of the worst murderers. nobody knows what that is. >> before we go, let me bring in barry on this. as sister helen is bringing up, the supreme court, we've got two justices who just in june said it's highly likely that the death penalty is unconstitutional. what is the likelihood that we will have the high court hand down a ruling? >> i think it's very good. the death penalty is only for a few states. 93% of the executions have only been in four states, two-thirds of the death sentences are

coming from 2% of the counties. so the supreme court is looking at all the other states that are not executing people and not putting forward death penalties and they're putting that in to the mix and that would an key to the decision they ultimately renter here. >> and on that, we have to go. sister helen, achbtd barnd barr you both very much. we're following a developing story in iraq where the u.s. military says a coalition air strike against isis may have killed iraqi soldiers. iraqi officials saying an officer and minine soldiers wer killed or wounded. this is the first known incidence of friendly fire. we'll bring you more information as it becomes available.

♪ it's the final countdown! ♪ ♪ the final countdown! if you're the band europe, you love a final countdown. it's what you do. if you want to save fifteen percent or more on car insurance, you switch to geico. it's what you do.

if you have high blood pressure many cold medicines may raise your blood pressure. that's why there's coricidin® hbp. it relieves cold symptoms without raising blood pressure. so look for powerful cold medicine with a heart. coricidin® hbp.

we're getting our first look this hour at president obama's arrival in hawaii earlier this morning. the president flying overnight following his stop in san bernardino, california.

he and the first family will be spending 16 days in in the aloha state for the holidays. the state where president obama was born and raised. and as we look ahead to tonight's democratic debate, i want to point something out about this week's republican debate in las vegas. specifically my contention that when it comes to style, ben carson emerged from that debate the winner. simply because he was the only candidate to wear a blue tie in a sea of red. how do you think i noticed this? because of how remarkably similar ben carson looked to you how i look almost every day, today included. so i want it ask the panel, does style actually matter when you're running for president or is it only about substance in? >> you need to look the part. clearly as a republican, you put the red tie on and it's a good day.

>> donald trump has the best style ever of anybody who ever ran forrd. so i think you'll get a call from him after this segment is over. >> i'm willing to take his call. i think i has my number. jenelle, what do you think? >> i think the same rule applies to presidential candidates that it does to all of us. if you come somewhere looking really crazy, people really don't hear what you have to say. so style matters quite a bit. i have to say that there were some particularly interesting fashion choices on that stage. >> such as? >> there was a lot of red. as you know, you and i have discussed, carly fiorina is in an interesting position as the only woman on the stage. and it is in that sense relatively easy to stand out. of course shee's wearing an all-red suit to match with the all red ties save dr. carson. however a lot of suit and a lot of jewelry.

>> the pop culture sized cross. but that's a whole other discussion. we have more to talk with in the next hour. another hour of news and politics, we promise, still ahead. stay with us. he nation's capital to support an important cause that can change the way you live for years to come. how can you help? by giving a little more, to yourself. i am running for my future. people sometimes forget to help themselves. the cause is retirement, and today thousands of people came to race for retirement and pledge to save an additional one percent of their income. if we all do that we can all win. prudential bring your challenges®

for called "squamous adnon-small cell",er previously treated with platinum-based chemotherapy, it's not every day something this big comes along. a chance to live longer with... opdivo, nivolumab. opdivo is the first and only immunotherapy

fda approved based on a clinical trial demonstrating longer life... ...for these patients. in fact, opdivo significantly increased the chance of living longer versus chemotherapy. opdivo is different. it works with your immune system. opdivo can cause your immune system to attack normal organs and tissues in your body and affect how they work. this may happen any time during or after treatment has ended, and may become serious and lead to death. see your doctor right away if you experience new or worsening cough; chest pain; shortness of breath; diarrhea; severe stomach pain or tenderness; severe nausea or vomiting; loss of appetite;... ...swollen ankles; extreme fatigue; constipation; rash; or muscle or joint pain, as this may keep these problems from becoming more serious. these are not all the possible side effects of opdivo. tell your doctor about all your medical conditions including immune system problems or if you've had an organ transplant, or lung, breathing or liver problems. a chance to live longer.

ask your doctor if opdivo is right for you. bristol-myers squibb thanks the patients and physicians who participated in the opdivo clinical trial. president obama's year end report card. thanks for staying with us. i'm john thnathan capehart. president obama begins his christmas vacation in the state before he was borned and raised, but not before a visit to san bernardino as well as his final press conference of the year. all the details in just a moment. donald trump's support keeps on growing in the new e. poewes. so what about those who predicted he had reached his ceiling. plus the surprising new numbers that show how americans really feel about assault weapons. also it's officially year

two of the improved relationship between the united states and cuba. how long will it be before americans will be making the trip to thhavana? the new scoop from the state department. and as star wars takes over the white house for a day, if seems you don't have to be a full blooded star wars geek to get caught up in the excitement of the latest installment. i'll be joined by my favorite star wars geek in just a bit. but we begin with president obama and the first family touching down in hawaii this morning to officially begin their annual christmas vacation. on his way cross-country, the president stopped in san bernardino to visit with the families of the 14 people killed in the december 3 massacre and the first responders. >> some described their loved ones who had come to this country as immigrants, others who had led grs lived in the area all their lives. all of them extraordinarily proud of the work they were

doing to keep people healthy and safe here in this community. and as difficult as this will time is for them and for the entire community, they are also representative of the strength and love that exists in this community and this country. >> and president obama was in the white house briefing room for his last press conference of the year. he appeared to take a victory lap of sorts. >> i look back on this year and one thing that i see is that so much of our steady persistent work over the years is paying off for the american people in big tangible ways. ju i want to point out i said interesting stuff happens in the fourth quarter and we're only halfway through. >> the president cited the improving economy, the surging number of americans with health coverage and his historic deals

with iran and cuba. he also took a swipe at the republicans who threatened to derail the agreement he hammered out in paris just last week. >> right now the american republican party is the only major party that i can think of in the advanced world that effectively denies climate change. it's an outlier. maef many of the key signatories to this deal, the argarchitects of deal come, from center right governments. even far right. they may not like immigrants, but they admit, yeah, the science tells us we have to do something about climate change. >> the president also pushed back on the criticism he's weathered on saying on the eve of the paris attacks that isis was contained. >> whenever i say that we have made progress squeezing the

territory that they control or made inroads against them, people will say if something happens around the world, then obviously that must not be true. but in any battle, in any fight, even as you make progress, there are still dangers involved. >> looking forward, the president promised to remain productive and relevant in his final year in office. >> since taking the office, i've never been more optimistic than i am right now. in 2016, i'll leave it all on the field. >> i want to bring back the panel but show yet one more clip. this time president obama discussing his relationship with newly minted speaker of the house paul ryan. >> i will say that in his interactions with me, he has been professional, he has reached out to tell me what he can do and what he cannot do.

i think it's a good working relationship. we recognize that we disagree on a whole bunch of other stuff. he is respectful of the process and respectful of how legislation works. >> so are we in a new era here? we got a budget passed with no ceilings or crises. they talked. the president and speaker of the house talked publicly. even the speaker of the house had a dinner with the former speaker of the house, house minority leader, nancy pelosi. new era here this washington? >> isn't that the way it's supposed to be? >> but it's not the way it's been. >> but the difference -- on one hand he loves to play the politics with tclimate change. he took a heavy bat to the republicans. if you look into work and get a deal done, you would think that you would be not swinging a bat and ripping their heads off before you sit down at the table and discuss the deal. on the other hand, he said some

very nice things about the speaker who he needs to deal with and i think that relationship has got off to a good start. i wish he would take the politics out of it sometimes and say i wish the republicans as opposed to even the far right groups away the world and civilized world. >> he's the president. >> you worked for governor pata pataki. when he was this charge of a committee at the council of foreign relations that put out a great report a couple years ago on climate change and called for basically all the steps that the president is trying do now, the republican party is just so far off the map on this and they were out there attacking paris and they were saying to the president, you know what, this is meaningless, we'll laugh you out of town on this. he has to fight back on this because they are wrong, they're wrong for -- >> but they should fight back on the facts. the facts are on his side. and that's what he should talk

about because republicans like myself who agree with him on this. stay to the facts. he would win on the -- >> i was going to say, the republicans on the hill who are not in the reality based community that you are -- >> but you're only going to get them farther into their corner by whacking them with it. >> we'll see how that goes. >> do you think that this really incredible period that we're in between both ends of pennsylvania avenue will continue or is this the last positive thing that we will see from speaker ryan because the far right factions that drove out boehner will set their sights on paul ryan? >> i think there is reason to be hopeful. the reason that i get i would say there is probably reason to be somewhat hopeful that there will be some sort of functional relationship is that paul ryan was the speaker who came in and basically set some terms for own

she sheer speaker didship. so assuming he can hold his caucus together and hold them to their agreement, then i think you should expect to see at least some reasonable levels of communication. >> that may be true between ryan and the white house. i still think every time people have said in the last six years the tea party will have to get reasonable, they will have to make a deal, they will have to realize how washington works and be part of that, they basically have proven that they can do that for maybe 20 seconds at the longest amount of time. so you have rush limbaugh and all the other talk show rush wannabees out there, you have donald trump and ted cruz and others out on the stump and they will be fanning the flames of this sort of internal gop civil war. so that will continue. i guess the big question, maybe you have an idea, what is the next front for the tea party rebellion to come back on against the establishment.

>> i think that we're going to make a decision whether or not as we did in 2014 where we did not talk about palin, cruz, the farther right. we ran reasonable ditd respect and we won election. the question is have we learned from that or have we shown that we can't control ourselves and we are really a midterm party. >> we only have about 45 seconds left, but we can't go without talking about the president commuted sentences of 95 yesterday. what kind of criminal justice push do you think we'll see from the president in his final year in office? >> i think there are people who are certainly hoping that will be a real emphasis in the last year for a number of reasons. certainly i think there are some pretty wide scale agreement that the drug war has not worked or our approach to the drug war has not worked. but also because of the shear costs of the human cost and the

fiscal costs of incarcerating this many people is really unsustainable. >> and that is the reason why you're seeing both the far left and the far right joining together in the capitol to get this done. up next, the new war of words about immigration between two sons of immigrants who are running for president. (donkey noise) (elephant noise) (mic screech) there's a big difference between making noise... (mic tap) ...and making sense. (elephant noise) (donkey noise) when it comes to social security, we need more than lip service. our next president needs a real plan to keep social security strong. (elephant noise) hey candidates! enough talk. give us a plan.

his day of coaching begins with knee pain, when... this is brad. hey brad, wanna trade the all day relief of two aleve for six tylenol? what's the catch? there's no catch. you want me to give up my two aleve for six tylenol? no. for my knee pain, nothing beats my aleve. this holiday, i can count on my going off list.again, and knowing right when my packages arrive. so that's two things. introducing real time delivery notifications. sign up at myusps.com

a new poll released just last night shows republican frontrunner donald trump leading at 39%. up 11 points since november. senators ted cruz and marco rubio round out the top three. this after trump responded to praise this week from russian president vladimir putin who said in a news conference that trump was a, quote, bright personality and talented person. and so here is what trump had to

say about that on yesterday's "morning joe." >> did you like you vladimir putin's comments about you? >> sure. when people call you brilliant, that's always good. especially when the person heads up russia. >> well, he also is the person that kills journalists, political opponents and invades countries obviously that would be a concern, would it not? >> he's running his country and at least he's a leader. unlike what we have in this country. >> you obviously condemn vladimir putin killing journalists and political opponents, right? >> oh, sure, absolutely. i've always felt fine about putin. i think that he is a strong leader. he's a powerful leader. >> trump taking just a little too long there to condemn putin such as it was. meanwhile, senators marco rubio and ted cruz are still fighting over immigration apnd the gang f eight immigration bill. cruz pushing back on rubio this week saying he never supported

legalization for undocumented immigrants. >> i oppose amnesty. marco rubio supports it. i oppose citizenship. marco rubio supports citizenship. i oppose legalization. marco rubio supports legalization. i opposed and led the fight to defeat the gang of eight bill. marco rubio authored and led the unsuccessful fight to pass the gang of eight bill. >> i'm puzzled by his attacks on this since he's the one that for example supports doubling the number of green cards. he supports a 500% increase in guest workers into the united states. and he's the one that supported legalization. >> kasie hunt joins us live from cedar rapids with more. how do you see the dynamic between these top three candidates playing out over the next few days? >> reporter: jonathan, good morning. we're here in a very chilly cedar rapids ahead of a big donald trump rally.

he of course is the national frontrunner, although a couple polls have shown him falling back in iowa, losing to ted cruz. and that's the dynamic that you're seeing play out right now. and rubio's campaign has really managed do a pretty remarkable thing. he is somebody who was an author of this gang of eight bill that included the path to citizens p citizenship. he dropped it pretty quickly once he realized that the right wing media has turned on him in this regard. but they have always known that it was going to be a weakness for him in especially a place like iowa where immigration is such a front burner issue for so many voters. and he's managed to put cruz who frankly has as you know from washington a pretty fiery reputation as being some whob is aggressively conservative, isn't somebody who changes his positions. and all of a sudden you've seen on the airwaves cruz having to defend himself. >> securing our borders and

stopping illegal immigration is a matter of national security. that's why i fought so hard to defeat president obama and the republican establishment gang of eight amnesty plan. their misguided plan would have given obama the authority to admit syrian refugees, including isis terrorists. that's just wrong. >> reporter: so there you go, it's already into the ether here in iowa. the cruz campaign clearly feeling pressure to make sure that they're getting their message out on this. and the reality is cruz did try to attach a poison pill amendment to that bill. it would have killed the bill, it included a path to legalization that if you'll remember at the time was for democrats completely unacceptable, democrats insisted that it be a path to citizenship instead of legalization. rubio campaign saying ted cruz secretly wants to provide amnesty to all these undocumented immigrants who are already in the country. cruz's campaign is caught between a rock and a hard place frankly because this makes him look like he was making a

political calculation. and it there is anything that is dangerous for ted cruz and how voters perceive him, it's issues of personality, issues of him being seen as too political. >> that's a great point. i'm throw this open to the panel. tom, on her point about ted cruz being caught between a rock and a hard place looking political, isn't thatten would have ted cruz's biggest problem to begin with? >> that is his biggest problem. for those who love ted cruz, he's a man of principal and this is what he believes. so any problem that he has in that area or that he's wiggling or changing position, it poses a potential problem. but i still believe that as trump falls or if trump were to fall, all of that vote goes to ted cruz. >> according to a ppp poll of republican primary voters, 42% said they would choose trump over cruz and rubio if those

were the only three choices. and if it was just cruz and rubio, 48% say they would vote for ted cruz. so that's to your point, but then what does that mean for marco rubio? >> i believe what happens is that that vote at some point goes to the right, it goes to the left and we wind up with two candidates battling wiing it ou. and who they are right now- >> so is that rubio or trump on the left? >> on the left in my party, moderate establishment side, it will come down to chris christie, jeb bush, marco rubio, john kasich. >> i'm sure chris christie would love to be called a leftish republican. can i share an epiphany about lieu tin? it seems if you're a narcissist, how do you judge other people around you. you judge them by what they think of you. so if putin says trump is brilliant, trump will love putin. it didn't matter that he's

killinged journalists and is a thug. to him the most important thing is what putin thinks of him. and so that's why with "morning joe," he was hesitant to criticize putin because he loved the guy you because he loved him. >> jenelle, real fast. >> it was remarkable, i have to agree. it really was centered around you but continue's putin's assessment of him, but joe scarborough did clearly send him some hints of how other people feel. >> and kasie, bringing it back to donald trump and ted cruz, the "times" has a story about the fact that donald trump has been trying to recruit a bunch of people in each of the state's 1681 republican precincts by thanksgiving. they had a heating in west des moines where 80 people showed up

with about 50 participating online. given that, is trump's organization even capable of beating ted cruiz in iowa? >> reporter: some are operating under the assumption that trump supporters can get them out to caucus. the question is whether he can convert people into actual caucusgoers. it's more difficult on the ground. but i do think that the open question is how many new voters are they going to bring into the process. if the answer is not very many, then donald trump will have a tough time beating ted cruz on the ground here. but if the answer is all of these thousands of people who are showing up, then it's a totally different story. so i think to a certain extent there is a sense that he does have a team that knows iowa very well. chuck lautner worked for rick

santorum back in 2012. but the question is whether or not that's ultimately going to translate. and the reality is no one actually knows at this point how this will go for them. >> you're absolutely right. kasie hunt there in iowa, thank you very much. coming up, we'll head north to new hampshire for a review of tonight's democratic debate. ♪ (vo) some call it giving back. we call it share the love. during our share the love event, get a new subaru, and we'll donate $250 to those in need. bringing our total donations to over sixty-five million dollars. and bringing love where it's needed most. love. it's what makes a subaru, a subaru.

hey! so i'm looking at my bill and my fico credit score's on here. yeah! we give you your fico credit score. for free! awesomesauce! the only person i know that says that is... lisa? julie? we've already given more than 175 million free fico credit scores to our cardmembers. apply today at discover.com overnight the bernie sanders campaign struck a deal with the dnc giving back the sanders campaign access to its voter data. leaving the big question in the wake of that brief and intense one day conflict, how will it be talked about in tonight's democratic debate? the third time the candidates will face off. it's taking place in new hampshire, a must win state for sanders where hillary clinton has surged to a virtual tie. she's also solidified her lead nationally, up nearly 2:1 over

sanders. sand sanders's fight with the democratic party is what everyone is talking about. for more on what might happen tonight, we're joined by former michigan governor and senior adviser for correct the record, also a hillary clinton supporter. governor, thanks for being here. >> jonathan, great to be on. wish you were here, wish i were there. >> i bet you. >> it's a little chilly here. sdl let me ask you, how do you expect hillary clinton to respond to the data breach at the debate tonight? >> well, you know, honestly, it will probably be the first question, right, and it will probably go to bernie sanders and then she'll be asked to react to that. but the issue is thank goodness resolved. i think everybody wanted to make sure that bernie sanders had access to his data, but he didn't have access to her data. and that's what the campaign had been pushing for. although i must say, this was not a small thing. if you -- anybody who knows

anything about the data gathering process in campaigns, it is millions of dollars and thousands of hours that go into building the data that goes in there. and it's extremely sensitive stuff. so it is no small breach, but the bottom line is it's behind us thank goodness and then they can go on to talk about the issues. >> so the breach in question is behind us, so then if you're sanders there your perspective, how do you get back on track tonight and is this make or break for him? >> i do think that the debate itself is important for all of them, right? they haven't had a chance to talk about for example domestic homeland security and in the wake of san bernardino. and hillary clinton has come out with very strategic comprehensive 360-degree plan that talks about yu how to prot us here, protect our troops and our national security there, and online. and i think obviously this is her strong suit. so it will be interesting to see

how the others who don't have as much experience in this area respond to her and what their plans are. to me that will be one of the biggest points of conversation. obviously democratic voters are really interested both in the economic and in national security and anti-terrorism strategies. and i think both of those topics will be, you know, the absolute focus tonight. at least for the candidates. who knows what the moderators will be asking. >> governor, is there any concern -- democrats at all talked that this is the third debate and it's on a saturday night, days before christmas with an nfl football game? is there anybody who is really going to watch this debate tonight? >> well, i think this kerfuffle of the past couple days maybe gets a few more eyeball, but i know there are a lot of us who would love to see more people watching. i'd say on the hillary clinton team, you know, she does really women in these debates after every one these debate, we're saying why aren't we doing more

of these debates. so i think that because it's a network and not a cable outlet, they maybe don't want to give up week nights because they have other programming that makes them money. >> governor, there are conspiracy theories out there that the fact that they're on saturday nights during football games is being done on purpose to protect secretary clinton. >> doctwhy would that protect h? she's a great debater. what would be in her interests to hide the debate strategy? it doesn't make sense. >> i yield the floor to david corn on that. >> governor, then can we get hillary clinton to say explicitly that she'd like to have more debates even before the voting and caucusing begins on a weekday night? just say that the dnc schedule

doesn't seem to be fair to those democrats who want to see wider viewership participation and more discussion? can we get her to say that? >> i think her campaign has said that they are totally willing to do more debates. >> so what is the problem here is this because we certainly know bernie sanders wants to. so is the problem the dnc and does that give people reason to believe that the dnc is trying to play something here? >> you know, i don't think it's fair to say that the it it dnc trying to splay somethiplay som. the whole kerfuffle yesterday, truly debbie wasserman schultz has a really good point. which is that this breach, there was an audit trail was released by the company, and it's not like anybody made this up. there were 24 attempts to draw out information, information was saved by the sanders people. so it's not like she was making

that up. these conspiracy theorists, i don't buy it at all. i haven't talked to debbie wasserman schultz about their strategy, but i don't think the clinton campaign is afraid of debates. >> i want to bring back to sanders. and the gop debate this past week was focused heavily on terrorism, international affairs. senator sanders seems to have a problem with terrorism, foreign affairs, international relations. he doesn't want to go there. can he get away with that tonight if all of the questions are about terrorism and paris and san bernardino? >> no, he cannot. he can't avoid this issue. this is at the top of minds of all citizens. i don't think that -- he can't come in and i don't think it

would be a wise strategy, i'm sure it's not his strategy, to just pivot back to the economy which is what he tends to do. it's also interesting and one other point to make, the republicans have avoided talking about the relationship between access to guns and domestic terrorism. and democrats need to push on that, too. and i know people have said that bernie sanders has -- there is sensitivity there on the guns because he voted against the brady bill, et cetera, but he will have to address that nexus, too. because you better believe that hillary clinton and martin o'malley will be talking about why republicans are not voting to deny guns to those on the terror watch list and other things. >> governor, let me bring this question -- >> the governor raised two issues that, one, they would like to talk to foreign policy which they believe is hillary's strength, they would like to talk about guns which they feel is a negative for better than a bernie sanders. i still say you go to your strength. he needs to talk to your foreign policy, but go to your strength.

income inequality. those are your voters. foreign policy is not his vote. >> but he can't -- if he's asked a direct question on foreign policy, he can't just pivot. he has to answer it. >> and i have no doubt that he can. i have said this earlier in the show. he's been a senator and member of the house, he's work order foreign affairs issues to decades now, as well. and so to me, it's a question of basically where his head is at and whether he can sort of do what you suggest, tom, speak to his core issue, but also at the same time use his experience and intelligence from the years and make strong points on those terrorism and overseas policy issues. >> in the last debate just after paris, he gave a half a phrase to paris and then pivoted to the economy. >> and he got a lot of governor

for that. the question is whether he learned from that and it will take a different tact this time. >> do you think he will take a different tact this time? >> i have no doubt his campaign staff has explained how and why he can ck staff has explained how and why he can ccan do that. and there is an opening here which was completely devoid in the gop debate the other night, the matter of foreign policy or domestic security or international security is not limited simply to issues of war. and physical defense and good posturing and looking strong. and that is pretty much where the discussion stayed the other night. there are a whole list of issues that can be talked about you including aid, trade, medicine, science, certainly climate issues and some of the instability that can flow from any of those things. and that is where senator sanders could really sort of make his mark. >> governor, you wanted to jump

in? >> yeah, i just want to say i think you're totally right even on this issue of terrorism, the republicans only -- they were one note which is more military aggression. they didn't talk about the more new answ nuanced issues about tlp are 50 muslim countries, majority muslim countries in the world, 2.1 billion people. i mean, the democrats i think will be united in say wlag a terrible strategy to alienate those who you would want to enlist in creating a sunni-led army against terror. so i think you will see uhe in an nimity there. but it's also important about what you do you at home including the online stuff, including training and providing support to local law enforcement. so there is a whole raft of issues that the republicans did not address other than carpet bombing isis. >> and on that positive note,

thank you very much for braving the cold and joining us today. up next, why fewer americans favor an assault weapons ban in the wake of yet another mass shooting. thousands of people came out today to run the race for retirement. so we asked them... are you completely prepared for retirement? okay, mostly prepared? could you save 1% more of your income? it doesn't sound like much, but saving an additional 1% now, could make a big difference over time. i'm going to be even better about saving. you can do it, it helps in the long run. prudential bring your challenges

tand that's what we're doings to chat xfinity.rself, we are challenging ourselves to improve every aspect of your experience. and this includes our commitment to being on time. every time. that's why if we're ever late for an appointment, we'll credit your account $20. it's our promise to you. we're doing everything we can to give you the best experience possible. because we should fit into your life. not the other way around.

whfight back fastts tums smoothies starts dissolving the instant it touches your tongue and neutralizes stomach acid at the source tum, tum, tum, tum smoothies! only from tums

theand the kids always eat sky their vegetables.e. because the salad there is always served with the original hidden valley ranch. you you don't stop the bad guys by taking away our gufns. you stop the bad guys by using our guns. >> that was senator ted cruz speaking just days after the terrorist attack in san bernardino sharing one of the main arguments against gun reform in this country, that innocent americans will have a better chance of surviving a mass shooting if they're equipped with their own guns to fight back. according to one poll out this week, more and more americans are beginning to agree with with that thesis. this this week for the first time in more than 20 years, a majority of americans say they now oppose a ban on assault weapons. those numbers have flipped since january 2013 when the same poll was taken just one month after newtown.

and although support is for an assault weapons ban has steadily declined over the years, we're only seeing this crossover now and this might be why. in the same new poll, 56% of americans say they are less confident in the government's ability to prevent a large scale attack. even more are less confident it can prevent a lone wolf attack like the one in san bernardino. and of those people, 47% believe that a better way to respond to terrorism is by having more people carry guns legally. something to keep an eye on as this debate continues to unfold. up next, can a visit cuba by some of major league baseball's biggest stars improve relations between the u.s. and the island nation?

the state department announced thursday that it has reached a deal to resume commercial flights from the u.s. mainland cuba for the first time in 50 years. what will eventually be 110

round trip flights day. the announcement comes one year after the u.s. and cuba agreed to resume relations. and we got a closer look at what that relationship will look like this week as major league baseball took its first ever goodwill tour of cuba with players hosting clinics in the baseball country and even reuniting with long lost family members. and raul castro capped off the week with a rare televised address to the cuban people reiterating his support for normalizing relations, abobut h also you weurged the u.s. devel to stop radio and television broadcasts. a sign that things still remain the same. thank you both for being here this morning. chris, let's me start with you. what is the biggest impact this travel deal will have?

>> i think the most important thing is that we're supporting the cuban people who are now engaged in private enter prize. raul castro has initiated reforms that permit people to have their own businesses, private restaurants for example are booming. and we're able to support this initiative. >> paul, one year later the embargo remains in place, but what purpose could it still have and what can we -- when can we expect to be lifted? >> i don't think it's going to be lift ted until the congress plays a greater role in this. and i appreciate what chris said about more tourism. certainly hundreds of millions of dollars have been going into cuba in the last year since the president's initiative. the problem is the average cuban cannot use the convertible peso. so most of the money coming in from tourism is skimmed off by the government. they control the labor, they control investment, they control

those little bitty businesses because those people cannot operate in a free economy. they are not even as free in their economy as the chinese were. so more needs to be done on the castro side. >> and the head of north american affairs says economic effects have been barely visible one year this later. allow do you expect this travel deal will help regular everyday cubans? >> it really is helping they will. for example, i to thedo these motorcycle tours and we're staying in private homes. using private restaurants almost exclusively. we hire the old '50s cars. so this is money directly into the hands of cubans. and it is actually incorrect just i wanted to correct that cuba can indeed use the convertible peso. that's what we're paying them in as travelers. and that channels through the economy from one private

individual in cuba to another private business, et cetera. >> paul, the castro regime hasn't made many if any concessions on freedom for cubans, dozens of dissidents arrested just a week ago. how and when this will change? >> with all due respect to chris, no law has been changed in cuba. so any kind of exchange of convertible peso is because someone is favored enough to be able do it. but the law hasn't changed. but you're right, persecution has not only continued a pace, it has actually increased. we're on track this year for a record number of arrests. probably 8,000. hundreds of people regularly beaten and arrested. and nothing has been done about that. and that's why this policy has always been so unfortunate. the president missed an opportunity to use leverage to get the castro regime to do what

this needs to do to truly have a free cuba and one that can actually prosper instead of just having a little more money in the coffers of the regime. >> lpolitico wrote that 134 som members of congress are warming up to relations. where does that leave centers li senators like marco rubio? >> i think some are warming up because the chamber of commerce wants them to. they're looking for deals for its members. but people like marco rubio and ted cruz will highlight that people are getting beaten every day for speaking out. and the president and congress need to respect that. >> thank you both to joining us today. up next, just how much of a box office force is the new star wars movie? we'll take a look right after will. (donkey noise)

(elephant noise) (mic screech) there's a big difference between making noise... (mic tap) ...and making sense. (elephant noise) (donkey noise) when it comes to social security, we need more than lip service. our next president needs a real plan to keep social security strong. (elephant noise) hey candidates! enough talk. give us a plan. wheall i can think abouthit, is getting relief. only nicorette mini has a patented fast-dissolving formula. it starts to relieve sudden cravings fast. i never know when i'll need relief. that's why i only choose nicorette mini.

count on being slammed this hwith orders. we're getting slammed with orders. and my customers knowing right when their packages arrive. totally slammed! introducing real-time delivery notifications. one more reason this is our season. ok, wehere's dad. mom. the twins. aunt alice... you didn't tell me aunt alice was coming. of course. don't forget grandpa. can the test drive be over now? maybe just head back to the dealership? don't you want to meet my family? yep, totally. it's practically yours, but we still need your signature. the volkswagen sign then drive event. zero due at signing, zero down, zero deposit, and zero first months payment on a new jetta and other select models.

okay, everybody, i got to get to "star wars." >> the force was strong at the white house yesterday. with character visits and a screening for gold star military families as the new "star wars" film spent its first full day in theaters. as we look at more images from the white house, let me add that the force awakens, the seventh film in the "star wars" series, shattered box office records on opening night and it's now on track to make more than $200 million this weekend alone. the new film picks up 30 years after "return of the jedi" left off as han solo, princess leia, look skywalker, pick up new fans and make a lot of old ones very, very happy. joining us from washington is my favorite self-professed "star

wars" geek, alexandria. thanks for getting up early to be here. >> thanks for having me. >> i didn't see the movie so i wouldn't provide any spoilers. first thing's first, no spoilers, what did you think of the film? >> no spoilers, i loved it. if you enjoyed the original "star wars" movies, you will love this, because it is a movie made by someone with "star wars" coming through his pours and it has all those things you remember. stormtroopers. it's got the bigger death station-type thing, all your favorites. >> the death star. a lot of people were let down by the prequel. can you tell us how this film succeeds where the others failed? >> well, there's no jar jar, that's the number one thing. but the number two thing i think is that all the complaints i've had coming out have been, like, substantive complaints.

like, why was that character doing that? because everyone talks like a real person and they have relationships like real people and they interact normally. it's amazing and beautiful. >> i want to bring the panel in on this. has anyone else other than tom see the movie? >> i saw it and it was spectacul spectacular. it really was just spectacular. >> have you seen it yet, david? >> no, i skipped the prequels because the first trilogy was very important to me when i was in high school and i saw it on opening night. went back the next day. my only question is, can't millennials can't get their own sci-fi trilogy? why do they have to go back to my childhood and do this again? i'll see it this weekend, i hope. we need to advance the ball and get some new sci-fi fantasy trilogies going out there. >> when it's this good though, why not continue the run? janell, have you seen it? >> i have not and i won't be seeing it unless somebody makes me. >> whoa! >> ooh! >> so you're one of them. you're one of those people --

>> i'm not a hater. i'm just one of these people -- no, it's not my particular set things but, you know, i am excited by how excited everybody else is. >> hey, alexandra, for folks who don't know, is a huge "star wars" fan. like, she is -- you're a professional at this. you go to festivals and things. you were at the "star wars" -- >> conventions, celebrations. >> does she dress up? >> you do dress up? >> i do. >> as what? >> jabba the hut actually. >> that's okay. so alexandria, what's your reaction to people like janell who don't -- who don't like "star wars"? they're not even interested in it? >> well, you know, honestly i'm just really sorry for having -- for you having to live through this week with all of us just being like we love this thing, it's our favorite thing in the world, take joy in it, you know, i understand what it feels like to be left out of a pop culture phenomenal.

i would say take "star wars" into your heart. it's kind of a cult but in the best possible way. >> and real quickly, you wrote a column about the "star wars" episodes from c-3po's perspective saying it's his continual nightmare. real fast in 15 seconds. >> c-3po's the english major of the galaxy, none of his skills are useful. the original trilogy starts where he's evacuating his workforce with his crazy colleague who says, i'm going on a secret mission, we need to walk through a desert. then he gets dismembered. none of his friends respect his abilities. finally, in "return of the jedi," he gets w s worshiped by group of teddy bears with bad teeth. for the most part, he's just kicked around and insulted by his closest companion. he's got a festive red arm, he's out to party. i'm excited. >> that is great. alex alexandra, i'm so glad you were

you. thank you for joining us. our panel, thank you for being here and thank you for getting "up" with us today. up next, melissa harris perry. joy reid is in for melissa today. republicans are ready for war and questions justice for freddie gray. that's all coming up. glad i could help you plan for your retirement. alright, kelly and promise me that you'll try that taco place on south street. and we have portfolio planning tools to help you manage your ira.

yeah, you're old 401k give me your phone. the rollover consultants give you step-by-step help. no set-up fees. use your potion. sorry, not you. my pleasure. goodnight, tim. for all the confidence you need. who's tim? td ameritrade. you got this. you're down with crestor. alright! now there's a way you can get crestor for $3. adding crestor, along with diet, lowers bad cholesterol. crestor is not for people with liver disease, or women who are nursing,pregnant, or may become pregnant. tell your doctor all medicines you take. call your doctor if you have muscle pain or weakness; feel unusually tired; have loss of appetite, upper belly pain, dark urine or yellowing of skin or eyes. these could be signs of serious side effects. ask for the crestor $3 card. ask your doctor about crestor. just serve classy snacks and bew a gracious host,iday party. no matter who shows up.

[cricket sound] richard. didn't think you were going to make it. hey sorry about last weekend, i don't know what got into me. well forgive and forget... kind of. i don't think so! do you like nuts? redid you say 97?97! yes. you know, that reminds me of geico's 97% customer satisfaction rating. 97%? helped by geico's fast and friendly claims service. huh... oh yeah, baby. geico's as fast and friendly as it gets. woo! geico. expect great savings and a whole lot more.

this morning, my question, will there be justice for freddie gray? plus, now everyone has a plan to be a war time president. and the christmas carol. first introduced on this day in 1843. but first, it's fight night for the democrats. tonight. and they're already throwi inii punches.