Skip to main content

tv   The Rachel Maddow Show  MSNBC  October 24, 2018 9:00pm-10:00pm PDT

9:00 pm
good night from nbc news headquarters in new york. thanks for watching. and thanks to you at home for joining us this hour. in may of 1972, a bomb exploded in a private home in macon, georgia. when police arrived, they found the bomb had been contained in a package, and the package was addressed to be sent to a car dealer. turned out, that was the car dealer who had recently repossessed the car of the man who lived in that home where the bomb went off in macon, georgia. unfortunately, that man did not live in that house alone. what prosecutors later pieced together is that this man, the man who lived in the house, assembled this bomb, put it in a package, addressed it to the car dealer who had repossessed his car.
9:01 pm
but then his wife came across the package and his wife opened it in their home. and that is when the bomb detonated and his wife was injured by the bomb. the woman's husband, the man who apparently made the bomb, was named walter moody. he was arrested in that case in 1972. he was ultimately convicted of possessing explosives, and on the basis of that conviction, he did three years in federal prison. mr. moody then apparently became absolutely obsessed with what he believed to be the injustice of that conviction. after he did his three years in the federal penitentiary, he got out and concocted a whole elaborate scheme, wherein he thought he figured out a way that he would trick police and prosecutors into reopening his case, because he was going to blame that bombing that injured
9:02 pm
his wife on a fictional, mysterious new suspect who he had invented. prosecutors say he was so obsessed with this plot and with getting cleared of this case, that he even started paying people off to serve as fake witnesses for this fake story he had invented to try to sell to authorities, to get his conviction overturned. he was obsessed. he worked on it for years. it did not work. but he pressed at it at every level of the legal system. he pressed it all the way through the court system. by june of 1989, the federal appeals court, where he lived, in his region of the country, they ultimately affirmed that old conviction from 1972, and said, yeah, this is not going to be overturned. there was a three-judge panel. he appealed to the full court in the 11th circuit, that they needed to reconsider it again. in august of 1989, 17 years after his initial conviction,
9:03 pm
the full court was like, no, dude, your conviction stands, this is it, end of story. end of the road. we realize you're obsessed with this, but you were rightly convicted, it stands. in response to that rejection from the courts, in august, 1989, that guy decided he would start building bombs again. and on august 21st, 1989, he mailed a bomb that was packed with tear gas to the naacp offices in atlanta, georgia. that bomb went off inside the offices of the naacp. didn't kill anybody, but it did blow up and disburse tear gas throughout that office. it was terrifying. it was intended to be. along with that bomb that day in august, 1989, walter moody sent threatening letters to tv stations across the country and sent a threatening letter to that federal appeals court that had turned down his case. he said that was his declaration of war, and he would start bombing and sending poison gas all over the country, and the
9:04 pm
country should brace itself for his war. then he started making more bombs. took him a couple months to get all the materials he needed and get all his ducks in a low. but in december of that same year, december of 1989, he started mailing out the new set of bombs that he had made. and this new set of bombs he had made, they were not designed to disburse tear gas or scare people, these new ones were designed to kill people. one of them went to another naacp office. this time the office in jacksonville, florida. that package in jacksonville, it was intercepted before it exploded. police were able to grab that bomb. they were able to defuse it safely. another one of his bombs was sent at the same time to that federal courthouse, to the 11th circuit u.s. court of appeals. the court that had turned down his case when he was trying to get his conviction overturned earlier that year.
9:05 pm
and, again, that bomb, too, it was intercepted before it could be detonated. it was defused safely. we have some remarkable footage from that time of what that bomb -- this is the bomb that was sent to that courthouse, what it looked like on the x-ray machine that they put it through at the courthouse that allowed them to catch it. those are batteries and wires. that's what allowed them to catch that bomb and set it aside and defuse it before anyone opened it. we have this incredible footage. look. this is the bomb disposal unit getting that actual device out of the courthouse in 1989. using the technology they had at the time, after they realized they had a live bomb. they called in the bomb disposal unit to take care of it and that's them doing it. so, like i said, he sent out four bombs that december in 1989. all of them designed to kill. that's two of them, the one that gets intercepted at the naacp office in jacksonville, florida, and the one intercepted at the federal courthouse.
9:06 pm
the other two bombs he set out in december of 1989, they were not caught and defused. they reached their targets, and they killed their targets. one of them arrived at the office of robert e. robinson, an african-american civil rights attorney in savannah, georgia. he had done work for the local naacp. he was killed instantly when that bomb exploded at his office in savannah. the other target, the fourth bomb, went to the alabama home of judge robert vance, federal judge who sat on the 11th u.s. circuit court of appeals, the court on which this bomber had declared war after they turned down his somewhat nutty effort to get his old conviction overturned. the bomb was wrapped in a brown paper package. it arrived at judge vance's home a week before christmas. he got the package, i believe out of his mailbox, brought it into the home, put it on the table. he sat down at the kitchen table
9:07 pm
across from his wife. the judge was killed instantly, his wife was seriously wounded. of course, the question you can't help but ask in a circumstance like this is, why? what were the -- why did this guy do it? what are the intricacies of the motive here? this was multiple bombs, right? there were threats and it was a progression, and the pattern here, multiple naacp offices, some of the other messaging, certainly made it seem at the time like this was a racist murder campaign, right? this was an anti-civil rights murder campaign at least. the initial news coverage of the murder of judge vance specifically focused on the fact that he had recently been part of a three-judge panel that heard a case involving the klu klux klan and it went against the klan, so maybe this is the klan itself taking revenge or maybe a klan sympathizer.
9:08 pm
the fbi seems to have not believed that was it. the fbi still has up a web page about this case. they say that they later decided once they got working into this case that all the racial elements of the story may have been red herrings. that the motivation for walter moody terrorizing and killing people in his bombing campaign in 1989 was all about his obsession over his old court case, and the fbi came to conclude that he only hit civil rights targets to try to throw investigators off his trail. to make them think he was some other kind of person motivated by some other means. but, you know, by the time walter moody was executed for his crimes, which only happened earlier this year in alabama, he was 83 years old when alabama executed him in april of this year. by the time of his execution, the press in the south that's
9:09 pm
been following this case for so many decades, they essentially settled on the motive issue just not being clear. maybe race was a red herring like the fbi concluded. maybe race was the prime motivator, like it looks like on the surface. maybe it was a mixture. when moody's effort to get his old conviction was rejected, there's been indication that he was mad at civil rights cases, because civil rights cases were getting prosecuted years after those crimes had taken place, because civil rights cases weren't bound by the same statutes of limitations that resulted, he believed, in him not getting his court case overturned, which is what he wanted from the courts. so maybe that was his grudge on civil rights, which is about race, but it's not just being a racist murderer. is that it? ultimately, who knows? ultimately, is that the most important thing about the story, right?
9:10 pm
i mean, it's impossible not to focus on the motive and the intention when it comes to terrorism, when it comes to terrorist attacks and bombings and attempted murders. but what seems obvious initially about the intention and motivation of the criminal, of the terrorist in a case like this, it doesn't always turn out that way in the end when you get all the facts, at least it doesn't turn out that simple. sometimes these things are crafted to be deliberately misleading. that's what the fbi concluded about walter moody. that said, sometimes these things are what they seen and the target list tells you exactly what motivated the killer. some of the time they follow some internal logic that must make sense to the would-be murderer or terrorist, right? not just perfect sense, but imperative sense. but to all the rest of us, it doesn't follow any logic that we can recognize as sane. in the case of walter moody and his mad, terroristic bombing
9:11 pm
campaign in 1989, certainly terrorized the southeast, killed two people, including a sitting federal judge. turns out his motives and his intentions are sort of vaguely discernible if you squint at the right angle. but what arises from that story, now that he's dead and it's over and we know everything we can know about it, is the fact that he was extreme and cruel and twisted enough to do it. that's what arises as the only clear truth. i mean, had they known more about the motive, would that have helped them solve the crime? had they understood more about what was just a red herring. what they did have in the case of walter moody and what ended that string of bombings and put him in prison and brought a
9:12 pm
close to that nightmare episode in 1989, what they did have was his work product. the thing that ended up being most important about that case and that man and what ended what he was doing to our country is that they had unexploded examples of his bombs. that's how they caught him. his whole saga, remember, started way back in 1972, when that bomb blew up in his house and injured his wife, right? because he was apparently mad about the repo guy from his car. in the investigation into that initial bombing, authorities discovered that he was frequently experimenting with bomb making. 1972, that's what they discovered about that base, when they looked into his bombs that injured his wife in 1972. fast forward 17 years later to 1989, when he declares he's going to terrorize people all over the south. 17 years after the initial investigation into this guy setting off bombs in his own house in georgia, 17 years later, two of his pipe bombs
9:13 pm
blew up at the judge's house and killed their targets. but authorities were able to contain and defuse his other two bombs, from december, 1989. from the naacp office in jacksonville. and from the courthouse. and when the fbi and the atf and the police and the postal inspectors and all the rest of them were working to solve that case and catch that bomber, it was an atf agent, an old school, old guy atf agent who helped defuse one of these walter moody bombs in 1989. and he realized, you know what? this bomb rings a bell for me. atf officer recognized the way that bomb was built. one of those bombs that didn't go off in 1989, that was intercepted and defused, one of the guys involved in defusing them recognized that bomb, recognized that technique. he remembered he had seen a bomb like that before. back in that old case from macon, georgia, 17 years earlier.
9:14 pm
he remembered the bomb, he remembered the case it came from and he remembered the guy's name who had made it and had gone to prison for it. that's how they got him. they catch these guys. that's how they do it. we're good at this as a country. today, police and federal authorities are in the possession of five unexploded bombs that were sent to 88-year-old activist, philanthropist, investor george soros. and former president barack obama, and former attorney general eric holder. we know another was sent to the home of billary -- excuse me, bill and hillary clinton in new york, specifically addressed to former secretary of state hillary clinton. another bomb addressed to john brennan, care of cnn, where he does not work, but the cnn offices in new york city were evacuated in dramatic fashion.
9:15 pm
after that bomb was discovered in a mail room at their offices. law enforcement officials tell us all of the five devices that they have got have the same characteristics. the bombs were made from pvc pipe containing a timer, which looks to be a digital alarm clock, again, according to these three law enforcement sources who have spoken to nbc news, the explosive powder inside the pipe bomb appears to have come from fireworks. and, quote, "x-rays though there was likely shrapnel inside the pvc pipe as well." because of the list of targets whom they were sent to, and there's also late-breaking reports about a device maybe having been sent to congresswoman maxine waters tonight, again, that's late
9:16 pm
breaking news. we don't have the same information about that device that we do about these other five where we have law enforcement sources speaking to nbc about the character of those devices. but because of the list of targets, which includes these people, including also congresswoman maxine waters, there's been lots of inference and speculation today, unavoidably, over the intent and motivation of the bomber. the person who is sending out these devices. obviously, all of these people and institutions have been targets for invective and condemnation by the president and his supporters and conservative media. george soros personally even today stars in an official new republican party ad as an evil, shady financier the national republican party is trying to associate with democratic congressional candidates. even after the bomb arrived at soros' house yesterday, the national republican party put out that ad today. so it is -- it is hard to not
9:17 pm
jump to conclusions about who might have sent these bombs, and why they might have picked these targets. i understand the almost irresistible urge to do that. but i'm here to tell you, that we don't need to do that. because we will know soon enough. because with five unexploded devices, and all of the forensic trails that lead from these devices, and from the packaging material that they were in, and everything else the federal investigators will be able to derive from the material they have from these apparently linked bombs, i'm telling you, we will know soon enough. after judge robert vance was killed in alabama in 1989, his eldest son, bob vance, jr., went on himself to become a judge in the great state of alabama. his daughter-in-law, married to judge vance's eldest son, went on to become a federal prosecutor in alabama. and there's not that many alabama cases that rise to the
9:18 pm
level of national news, but the killing of judge robert vance in alabama was one of those cases. killed him with that pipe bomb stuffed with shrapnel that went off in his kitchen in 1989. another alabama bombing case that made national news was part of the string of bombings carried out by the atlanta olympics bomber eric rudolph, who bombed the olympics, an abortion clinic and a lesbian bar between 1996 and 1998. the bomb prosecutor who handled the bombing of the abortion clinic in birmingham was the daughter-in-law of judge robert vance, who himself was killed in that terroristic bombing nine years earlier. we actually contacted that former prosecutor today when these bombs started turning up in democratic party and media mailboxes up and down the eastern seaboard. she told us today, "bombs have
9:19 pm
signatures." she told us the fbi and the atf have some really amazing bomb experts who will recognize the signature. she told us, these guys are very good once they get a peek. joining us now is that former u.s. attorney from alabama who handled, among other cases, the eric rudolph bombing and the daughter-in-law of judge robert vance who was killed with a pipe bomb in 1989. joyce vance, thank you very much for being here and for letting me tell some of your family history. >> hi, rachel. >> you bring some specific expertise and experience to bear on this. when you told us bombs have signatures and the atf and fbi are very good when it has something to look at here, can you explain what you mean by that and why you have such confidence in that aspect of the investigation? >> well, sure. bombs are as individual as their makers.
9:20 pm
there are a lot of different ways that you can put an explosive device together. and so individuals who are bombmakers tend to repeat. they might change a little bit, but will use a lot of the same tools in the same way of putting a basic pipe bomb together. so i should say we had a full team in birmingham that worked on the rudolph case, and all of the prosecutors on that team, myself included, we relied heavily on the expertise of the agents who were so good at understanding bomb components and using that knowledge to help identify the bomber. >> when it came to that eric rudolph case, was there any important lead in that case? any important specific information that was derived specifically from the forensics of the bomb, sort of being able to have access to the materials he used to put together those bombs? >> rudolph was a very different case. it didn't involve a mail bomb, rather, rudolph planted physically and personally planted a bomb outside of the
9:21 pm
all-women abortion clinic in january of 1998 in birmingham. so he was actually seen by an eyewitness who observed him leaving the scene. that helped with his identification. but the agents who looked at the bomb, both physically, the components that were used to build the bomb, but also some decorative leaves on top of the bomb and some of the other housing for it, and they were able to track those components, identify rudolph as the person who purchased them. it was a pretty immaculate process that they pursued for linking rudolph to the bomb components. >> being able to track the components, the store where they were sold and the fact that he was the person that bought them. part of the reason i wanted to talk about this story, about walter moody tonight is because it seems instructive to me and helpful in terms of historical context here, in terms of everybody sort of jumping to try to explain this based on motive tonight. looking at the list of targets,
9:22 pm
i should tell you the fbi has confirmed two additional packages were both addressed to congresswoman maxine waters that are similar in appearance to the other packages. so the list of people we're talking about is the greatest hits list of people who the president has been targeting by name and with specific invective over the last year or so in terms of his political appearances and particularly his rallies. how does that factor in when it comes to pursuing this as a law enforcement matter? i was struck by the fact that in the walter moody case, there seemed to be a lot of strong evidence about the motive, but in the end, it all felt very much like a gray area and it doesn't seem like it was crucial to nailing down that case and getting him arrested. >> you know, that's right. motive is never an element of proof that prosecutors are responsible for in a federal case. motive can help you understand what happened and who did it. but it's not critical that you assess the motive.
9:23 pm
so agents, and it's still early hours in this investigation, the agents won't be quick to rule any possibility out. they'll acquire all of the information that they can, look at all of the possibilities. on the one hand, i think it's very difficult to ignore that people who received bombs today are all people who have been in the line of strong invective from the president, many in the last week. by the same token, as in the moody case, is something that someone might use to try to divert law enforcement's attention from their true purpose. the fbi, atf, the postal inspectors, they will chase this one straight down to the truth. >> joyce vance, really appreciate your time tonight. thanks for helping us with this and letting me tell that story. i really appreciate it. >> thanks, rachel. some breaking news from "the new york times" to get to. do stay with us. n struggle with large debris and stuck-on dust, so shark invented duoclean, replacing the front wall with a rotating soft brush.
9:24 pm
while deep cleaning carpets, two brush rolls pick up large particles with ease, make quick work of stuck-on dust, giving hard floors a polished look, and fearlessly devour piles. shark duoclean technology, designed to do more on carpets and floors, available in corded and cord-free vacuums, and only available from shark.
9:25 pm
on carpets and floors, available in corded whooo! want to get a move on your next vacation? tripadvisor now lets you book over a hundred thousand tours, attractions, and experiences in destinations around the world! like new orleans! from cooking classes, to airboat tours, tripadvisor makes it easy to find and book amazing things to do. and you can cancel most bookings up to 24 hours in advance for a full refund. so your whole trip... will be smooth sailing! read reviews check hotel prices book things to do tripadvisor
9:26 pm
we've hadfor a long time.is in san francisco and half-measures haven't fixed it. homelessness doesn't just hurt homeless people. it hurts all of us.
9:27 pm
that's why we're all voting "yes" on c. the plan is paid for by corporations that just got a massive tax break. it's time for them to give back by helping all of us to fix our homeless crisis. with more affordable housing... expanded mental-health services... clean restrooms and safe shelters. vote "yes" on c. it helps all of us. sometimes there are certain things you want the people around you to go ahead and tell you. even if it's embarrassing. like, if your zipper is down, right? or if you have spinach in your front teeth.
9:28 pm
or if, for pete's sakes, you are the president of the united states and you are haplessly ascending the stairs of air force one with, wait for it, what is that? what is -- wait a second, is that toilet paper? is that a napkin? what is that on the bottom of his shoes? cameras are clicking and rolling. turns and waves. i know you're all looking at me. even if this went perfectly, the whole world would see this, but because you're stumping up there with those four pieces of charmin stuck on your foot, this image will be everlasting. this will be the story. i was sure that was a fake when those images first came out, but that was totally real. the president of the united states, literally trailing a gigantic piece of toilet paper on his shoe onto air force one. after that happened this month in real life, to the president, part of what everybody wondered was why nobody told him, right? maybe, best case scenario, nobody around the president saw
9:29 pm
the paper stuck to his shoe until he had climbed to the stairs and maybe it fell off before he got on the plane. i don't know. maybe they all did see it but thought it would be hilarious and were laughing at him. maybe nobody saw it until it was already happening and the cameras were already clicking. we don't know. but after seeing this new news story that broke in "the new york times," the story that would be the dominant story in the country tonight if not for the most famous democrats in the country and cnn getting bombs in the mail today, i'm willing to float a different theory about the president and the paper stuck to his shoe. but here's the story that "the times" just broke, this is the headline. when trump phones friends, the chinese and the russians listen and learn. when president trump calls
9:30 pm
old friends on one of his iphones, american intelligence reports indicate that chinese spies are often listening, and putting to use invaluable insights into how best to work the president and affect administration policy. aides have warned him that his cell phone calls are not secure, but aides say the president has still refused to give up his iphones. white house officials say they can only hope he refrains from discussing classified information when he's on those calls. so the idea here, in this new "new york times" report that's just dropped tonight is that the president is sitting around, talking on his personal phone, and on any given day, for any conversation, spies for china are listening to those calls. they're totally not secure calls, totally open to foreign countries listening to them and recording all of them. presumably since they're recording them, they can also doctor those recordings and release them to the world as if the president said something he
9:31 pm
didn't actually say or release what he actually said. who knows what would be more scandalous? but what u.s. intelligence has further turned out is that china is using what they're hearing on these calls to come up with new ways to manipulate the u.s. president to china's advantage. the american public has known that the president has kept his personal phone, the beltway press has a bunch of references to white house staffers and friends wishing somebody would take away the president's phone so he would stop tweeting things to create political messes, blah, blah, blah. we've had the president and his phone as a story already. but this is new. american spy agencies learned that china and russia were eavesdropping from human sources inside foreign governments, and intercepted communications between foreign officials. the chinese have pieced together a list of people with whom president trump regularly speaks in hopes of using them to influence the president. among those on the list are
9:32 pm
steven schwartzman, and steve wynn, who stepped down from his company after serious sexual misconduct allegations earlier this year. both men, who frequently speak with the president, have a history of major business ties in china. that's handy for the chinese government, right? the chinese are now relying on chinese businessmen and others with ties to beijing to feed arguments to the trump friends. the strategy is that these people will pass on what they're hearing and beijing's views will eventually be delivered to the president by trusted voices. you know how the president still and now other republicans too, they get crowds, republican crowds to scream, "lock her up, lock her up" at rallies and events about hillary clinton? what that is supposedly about is about her using a private e-mail server when she was secretary of state. oh, the horror.
9:33 pm
now we know that, as president, even though his staff have told him foreign spy agencies can listen in to all his calls if he uses a private phone, he's still using his private phone. so the chinese, according to american intelligence reports, are not only listening in on his calls, they're using what they're obtaining from the fact that they're listening in on his calls to manipulate him and u.s. policy to their advantage. now, there is one little silver lining that "the times" is reporting, one little upside in this story. "administration officials say they have confidence the president has not been spilling secrets, because he rarely digs in to the details of the intelligence he is shown, and he's not well versed in the operational specifics of military or covert activities." so you can't leak what you don't know. he doesn't pay attention to his briefings, so the good news is,
9:34 pm
he doesn't know all that super secret stuff. or he doesn't understand it when we tell him. there's no chance he could repeat it. are you kidding? when he's telling everything he knows to the chinese government, the best hope for national security is that maybe he just doesn't know that much. if u.s. intelligence and the white house knows he has this problem with china and apparently russia as well, listening in to his private calls, the president's staff knows he has this problem. why is he still talking on his private phone, first of all? and why tonight are administration officials talking about this to "the new york times"? "mr. trump's use of his iphones was detailed by several current and former associates who spoke on the condition of anonymity so they could discuss
9:35 pm
classified intelligence and sensitive security arrangements, the officials said they were doing so, meaning they were talking to "the times" tonight not to undermine president trump, but out of frustration with what they considered to be the president's casual approach to electronic security." so for the officials who were talking to "the times" about this, the story tonight, this is their way of, like, tugging on the president's sleeve, psst, sir, i have to tell you, there's a problem. they've been telling him in private there's a security issue. he does not care. so now they're telling him in big, bold letters in the newspaper. in this case, this is them telling him, hey, sir, you've got a little spinach in your teeth. and he's like, oh, yeah? get me a poppy seed bagel, see if i can get some of that stuck in there, too. sir, you have four pieces of charmin on your shoe. cool, can we get some on the other foot, too? can we get six or eight pieces to stick? they've been warning this is a security problem. he's like, whatever. i mean, when you are warned that adversaries are listening to your calls and using that surveillance to manipulate you
9:36 pm
for the advantage of those foreign countries, and the president doesn't care and he keeps doing it anyway, what do you do with that? this is -- this is more than worrying, this is weird, right? how does this get fixed? -these people, they speak a language we cannot understand. ♪ [ telephone ringing ] -whoa. [ indistinct talking ] -deductible? -definitely speaking insurance. -additional interest on umbrella policy? -can you translate? -damage minimization of civil commotion. -when insurance needs translating, get answers in plain english at progressiveanswers.com. ♪ -he wants you to sign karen's birthday card. it's a high honor.
9:37 pm
starts with great sleep. and the sleep number 360 smart bed is my competitive edge. it intelligently senses our movements and automatically adjusts our firmness and support on each side to keep us both incredibly comfortable. it can even warm our feet to help us fall asleep faster. it's great sleep i can feel and see. better sleep keeps me at the top of my game. for this team... and the home team. the new sleep number 360 smart bed, from $999.
9:38 pm
it's proven quality sleep.
9:39 pm
so we're back now with this remarkable "new york times"
9:40 pm
report that's just out tonight about u.s. intelligence reports indicating that chinese and russian spies have been listening in regularly on the president's personal cell phone calls. calls that he's been making from his personal iphone since he's been president. the chinese at least have been using what they're hearing on those calls to set up influence operations targeted at the people who the president speaks to on a regular basis. so his trusted friends who he speaks to regularly end up telling him things that serve the interest of the chinese government. the president's staff apparently decided to take this fact to "the new york times" tonight, because they can't get him to stop doing this otherwise. no matter how many times they've warned him about how dangerous it is, he apparently doesn't care, or he doesn't care enough. there is one hint in the "new york times" story about why the president might have kept doing this despite the security warnings. officials said the president does have two official iphones that have been altered by the national security agency to
9:41 pm
limit their abilities and vulnerabilities. as well as a third personal phone that is no different from hundreds of millions of iphones in use around the world. president trump keeps the personal phone, white house officials said, because unlike his other two phones, he can store his contacts in it. that seems way more important than, you know, the national security consequences of the president's personal communications all being listened to on speakerphone. joining us now is jeremy bash, former chief of staff at the cia and department of defense. nice to have you here tonight. thank you for being here. >> hey, rachel. >> did you see this coming? >> i did not, but i think, rachel, tonight, we're seeing two aspects of the president's behavior that are troubling. first, he's talking on unsecured telecommunication devices, and he's making himself vulnerable to chinese and russian influence
9:42 pm
operations. both are going to be major concerns for the u.s. intelligence community. >> in terms of these influence operations, the "times" report goes into detail about how the chinese are trying to do this. they name a couple of people who the president is regularly in contact with. they are people who have extensive business connections in china. according to the reporting, what the chinese spy service decided to do is to get chinese business persons and other people related to the chinese government to essentially run influence operations, targeting those friends of the president to convince them of things that are beneficial to the chinese government. the president will then hear those things from his trusted friends and take action based on that advice to benefit chinese interests. does that seem byzantine to you, or is that the kind of influence operation that you would typically look for in a national security context at a very high level? >> that's pretty standard,
9:43 pm
rachel. that doesn't surprise me at all and won't come as any surprise to anybody who has experience in the national security community. the question is, what are the defenses against those kinds of operations? the key defense is, you have to make sure that your conversations are done with discretion. i don't think it's an understatement to say that the president is not a model of discretion. he likes to talk, he likes to blab, he has no filter. he talks with his friends and colleagues all the time. you know, it's not per se a problem if he's having unclassified conversations. what is a problem if he goes into sensitive areas and reveals things that make him and his team more vulnerable to influence and coercion and reveals information that could benefit america's adversaries. >> one of the things that strikes me as a potential risk here is if russia and china and who knows who else are able to freely listen in on the president's calls whenever they want and make recordings of the president.
9:44 pm
the release by a foreign intelligence agency or foreign government of a private conversation by the president, what it was undoctored or whether it was doctored to make it appear that he was saying something that he didn't actually say, that seems to me like the kind of risk that the white house and that the national security sort of infrastructure in our country would have to be very concerned about. because if a hostile power decided to use that in a way that was designed to undermine the united states or our interests, it seems like a straightforward way to do it. >> yeah, it's going to be a problem. whenever the president is having conversations that can be recorded, it's not limited to mobile phones. i think he has to be careful on any unsecured land lines. and really in any phone conversation and any system, e-mail, text, there's no such thing as a bulletproof system, and cyber security isn't about technology, but about the discretion and mindfulness of people who have sensitive
9:45 pm
information and who have to understand that their information can be used against the united states. and this issue that you pointed out about them doctoring videos or audios to something that's attracted the attention of the intelligence oversight committee as they've been warning with these deepfakes where people take videos and dub audio over them. this is a new world we're living in, in the era of social media and other sophisticated telecommunications technologies. >> jeremy bash, former chief of staff at the cia, thank you very much for being here. >> thank you, rachel. one of the other remarkable things here, and i'm not much for, like, psychological profiles of people in this administration, but there is something important here about the fact that people who have been warning the president about the national security implications of what he's doing with his phone and china listening in, people who have been warning him feel like he doesn't care about the warnings. so they have gone to "the new york times" with this information as a way to try to influence the president that
9:46 pm
way. that itself will end up being one of the important things about this at the end of the day. lots more to get to tonight. stay with us. ♪
9:47 pm
♪ the new capital one savor card. earn 4% cash back on dining and 4% on entertainment. now when you go out, you cash in. what's in your wallet? now when you go out, you cash in. our because of smoking.ital. but we still had to have a cigarette. had to. but then, we were like. what are we doing? the nicodermcq patch helps prevent your urge to smoke all day. nicodermcq. you know why, we know how. you need insurance. but it's not really something you want to buy. it's not sexy. or delicious. or fun. but since you need both car and home insurance,
9:48 pm
why not bundle them with esurance and save up to 10%? which you can spend on things you really want to buy, like... well, i don't know what you'd wanna buy because i'm just a guy on your tv. esurance. it's surprisingly painless.
9:49 pm
it's softer than ever. charmin ultra soft is softer than ever so it's harder to resist. okay, this is getting a little weird enjoy the go with charmin what sore muscles? what with advpounding head? .. advil is... relief that's fast. strength that lasts. you'll ask... what pain? with advil. big national races almost always come down to battleground states. that's how presidential races go, right? in the same way, statewide races often come down to big battleground counties. right now in georgia's super close governor's race, gwinnett county is big, almost 1 million
9:50 pm
people live there. also the most diverse county, not just in georgia but the whole southeast. 60% of the people there are nonwhite. early voting started in georgia last monday. by the count of the "atlanta journal-constitution," almost 41,000 people in the county have cast their ballots in the first nine days of early voting. what does that mean? for context, that is quadruple the number of people who voted early by this point in the last midterm in 2014. four times the number of people who voted in the last midterm. but something else is happening in these really high numbers in the county. absentee ballots have been being rejected. in you voted early in georgia over the past nine days, if anything about your ballot didn't match state records, including if an election official didn't think your signature looked exactly the same as signature on file, that election official could have rejected your ballot, could have thrown out your ballot and you might not find out your ballot has been thrown out until after
9:51 pm
the election is over. so, multiple civil rights and voting rights groups challenged the state, sued the state for allowing those absentee ballot rejections. turns out the county with the highest rejection rate is gwinett county. they said, quote, "it's more than three times the average rejection rate than all of the counties in georgia. it's higher than all other atlanta metro area counties." last week the aclu in georgia filed a suit against gwinett county and had one of those aclu lawyers who brought the case last week to explain the suit, explain the goal, to stop the state from throwing out those ballots as soon as possible, to actually notify any affected voters to give them time to remedy the mistake. the aclu was in court yesterday for the first hearing in that case.
9:52 pm
and today in georgia they won. a federal judge in this case filed a ruling today, ordering brian kemp, ordering the georgia secretary of state to tell every election official they are no longer allowed to throw out absentee ballots just because they don't think the signature on the ballot matches the signature on file. the judge says in those cases, election officials have to count them as provisional ballots. and crucially they have to notify the voter in time for the voter to fix the mistake. that aclu lawsuit covered it last week, and as of today they are winning. the state has until noon tomorrow to respond. watch this space.
9:53 pm
i never thought i'd say this but i found bladder leak underwear that's actually pretty. always discreet boutique. hidden inside is a super absorbent core that quickly turns liquid to gel. so i feel protected and pretty. always discreet boutique.
9:54 pm
back pain can't win. now introducing aleve back and muscle pain. only aleve targets tough pain for up to 12 hours with just one pill. aleve back & muscle. all day strong. all day long. our because of smoking.ital. but we still had to have a cigarette. had to. but then, we were like. what are we doing? the nicodermcq patch helps prevent your urge to smoke all day. nicodermcq. you know why, we know how.
9:55 pm
9:56 pm
i mentioned earlier tonight that the fbi had identified five pipe bombs sent to philanthropist george soros, to hillary clinton, to former president barack obama, eric holder, and former cia director john brennan, which was sent to him care of cnn even though he doesn't work there. law enforcement officials say those five suspicious packages all contained pipe bombs that were all substantially similar. well, as i also mentioned, we've now received confirmation from the fbi that there were two devices, two bombs additionally sent to democratic congresswoman maxine waters of california.
9:57 pm
she, like the other targets, is someone who has been frequently singled out for criticism by the president in recent months. well, the fbi now says, quote, we have now confirmed two additional packages both addressed to representative maxine waters are similar in appearance to the other packages. so, you know, we've been conservative in our reporting on this today. that's because you often expect early reports to be wrong in terrorism cases like this, especially when there are multiple targets and they're all over the country. but it is now confirmed by the fbi that the list of people receiving similar bombs, similar packages, includes maxine waters, too. so it's clinton, obama, soros, eric holder, john brennan care of cnn, and maxine waters. the important thing, from a law enforcement perspective, is number one, no one's been hurt by these packages and number two, law enforcement has all the bombs, has all the unexploded devices. and that's the best lead they could possibly have in figuring
9:58 pm
out who did this and getting them. we'll be right back. done! simply enter your destination and dates... and see all the hotels for your stay! tripadvisor searches over 200 booking sites... to show you the lowest prices... so you can get the best deal on the right hotel for you. dates, deals, done! i'm not picking it up. you pick it up!
9:59 pm
i'm not picking it up. i'll pick it up! they're clean! ♪'cuz my hiney's clean.♪ ♪oh yeah i'm charmin clean.♪ charmin ultra strong just cleans better. enjoy the go with charmin.
10:00 pm
one last thing that i want to mention before i go tonight that is slightly self-serving, i'm sorry. i have mentioned a couple of times this week that i'm putting out a podcast next week for the so i want to say thank you to everybody who subscribed to it. but also this does not helping me with the number one point, that i'm nervous about it. see you later. it's time for the "last word" with lawrence o'donnell. though alilvelshi in is for lawrence tonight.