the u.s. house just voted to hold bill barr and wilbur ross in contempt this hour, and they are now responding. justice department saying it's a new low. ross saying this was unnecessary, and, quote, unfortunate. we wanted to give you that update. that does it for us. "hardball" starts now. the race race. let's play "hardball." good evening. i'm chris matthews from washington. president trump is hitting the campaign trail tonight with his attacks on four democratic congresswomen. at any moment, he'll speak at a reelection rally, there we are, in north carolina. this just a day after he was condemned by the u.s. house of representatives for his racist tweets which were aimed at those very four women. well, leaving the white house a short time ago, he said he plans to keep the fight hot.

>> i do think i'm winning the political fight. i think i'm winning it by a lot. >> why? >> i think that they are not espousing the views of our country, the four congresswomen. >> well, the "new york times" reports that trump's relentless assault on those four congresswomen who style themselves the squad is part of a calculated strategy. quote, president trump and the republicans have sent the clearest signal yet that their approach to 2020 will be a racially divisive reprise of the strategy that narrowly helped trump capture the white house in late 2016. late last night he tweeted so great to see how unified the republican party was on today's vote concerning statements i made on for democratic congresswomen. he added they are now the top most visible members of the house democrats who are now wedded to this bitterness and hate. earlier today trump tweeted "thank you to the vicious young socialist congresswomen, america will never buy your act." in an interview this afternoon

with "the daily mail," trump said he was not unhappy with the uproar over his racist attacks. and later today he was asked if he is relishing the fight. >> i'm not relishing the fight. i'm enjoying it because i have to get the word out to the american people. it's not a question of relishing. they're wrong. they're absolutely wrong. that's not where our country wants to be. we're not going to go, and we're not going to be a socialist country. it's not going happen. >> for more i'm joined by donna edwards, former maryland democratic congresswoman and "washington post" contributing columnist. michael steele, former rnc chairman. jeremy peters, politics editor for "the new york times" and former deputy national security adviser for president obama. thank you, all. it's a great quartet to try to figure this thing out. michael, is this strategy to say he is going to go to north carolina and repeat all these attacks on these four women congresswomen, or did he make a stupid mistake and he is trying

to find some advantage in it? >> no, it's not stupid. it may be stupid but it's not stupid in the sense oops, i didn't mean to say that. what trump does in moments like this, it gives him an outlet to vent exactly what he feels and what he thinks about these women when he sees them. they cause in him something that's visceral, and he responds to that. and he is using 1950s language, communism and social -- no one is talking about this. they all failed. communism doesn't exist. >> is this about ideology or ethnicity? >> oh, both. that's the beauty of it. he intertwines them both. it is about ideology because to his base, it plays on an old narrative of how they look at people and how they think about philosophically and politically individuals who disagree with them or they disagree with. but it's also about race, because now he's got these faces, these black faces that he can talk about in terms that he knows is going to spark a

reaction. he knows it. this is a man of a certain age from a certain time. he's 70 plus years old from the 1950s. so when he says go back where you came from, he knows exactly what that triggers. he knows exactly what it means when he says it, and he knows how people are going to react to it. >> when they're sitting around the white house wherever they meet to talk about this thing, do they think they see goldenness or have to do some damage control? what's going on here with the trump trumpees? >> well, it looks like when you watch trump, he does something. he lashes out. and then they tell everybody it was a strategy. that's generally been the pattern throughout, that essentially he pops off on twitter. he makes racist comments like this. he picks fight, and then they all explain to us why it's such a smart strategy and why he is playing three dimensional chess, and that is what he has done throughout. the fact of the matter is i was sitting in the white house back in 2011 when he launched the

birther movement. and when people failed to adequately call this out and people gave this a platform. people said it was racially tinged or divisive or it was a conspiracy theory without calling what it was, and he got away with it. and he's gotten away with it throughout. i do think people need to take a principled stand, whoever the political prognosticators might say. >> you know, i'm older than you. i'm older than everybody. i've been watching the republican party since the '40s. it does socialists up in the bronx, bella absug, it was tip o'neill. there is always someone vaguely ethnic from one of the coasts, adam clayton powell, they always turn and say that's the democratic party. and they seem to know how they do this. it doesn't work all the time, obviously. >> i would argue that i think it's the only thing that trump knows that can help him win. it's his playbook from 2016 that he is using in 2020.

i mean, this wasn't new. he knows that for those suburban -- not even suburban, but white world voters that are his base that this is how they respond to that. it's what was described i think in a "washington post" piece yesterday as white identity politics. >> yeah. >> and he doubles down on it. >> i think you're right. that's what it, by the way. >> i do. i think that he thinks that that works for him. and frankly, if he doesn't have that, he ain't got nothing when it comes to the 2020 election. >> i want to suggest something to trump. not only is he wrong ethnic, i think he has bad optics onnestist in. for some it's just as nasty. he had an opportunity he blew last week. ayanna pressley had come out and say black members of congress should vote black. they couldn't have an independent view of anything. that was a perfect example for him to jump on it and say identity politics, this is what is wrong. instead he jumped on it and gave her a pass. she was one of the victims then.

that's a stupid mistake. >> well, it shows you there is no strategy here, this is all impulse. >> but you guys said it was strategy. >> no, no, we didn't say it was strategy. his aides conceded that this was something that caught them off guard, and then they kind of rethetetroactively explains why >> so you fall into the mud and say it feels good? it's a mistake and you're call it a victory. >> once it's done, now we can see a way it's good for him. but republicans ra also telling us it's bad for him. it's united a fractured democratic party where a week ago it was squabbling. you had the squad versus nancy pelosi. and now you them all united around the squad. also, i think you can't overlook the fact that this is trump picking his enemies. so regardless of whether or not he intended to do this, what he has done is he is picking his opponents before the democrats can do that. >> three you have been in politics. i want to ask you this. back in 2016, a million years ago. >> yeah. >> i knew we all knew about the

white anger, the white grievance, we know all the words now, white identity, a more frequent word, a current one, but we say there is not enough of them because there are a lot of minorities and a lot of sophisticated suburbanites that are going to trounce these people. well that. >> didn't trounce them. the numbers were off. my question is trump now off of the numbers? it comes down to short numbers. 50,000 votes here, 20,000 vote here is. are there as many angry people now there as were four years ago? are there enough white people to cover the bases for this guy? >> i'm telling you, chris, i still don't trust the narrative out there that suddenly the system, the voting system is going to be overwhelmed by all of these minority female votes that are going to swamp what we saw in 2016. i don't trust it because i have an instinct about people, and people are not necessarily being truth and faithful to the cause, if you will. trump has a bedrock of support, no doubt.

but that support is there for him. and so that white vote that trump grabbed in 2016 was off the radar for 30 years, all right. he tapped into that vote and pulled it out. yes, there were a lot of dems who stayed home, and they can come back. but don't understand estimate the possibility that more of that white vote is out there. >> that's exactly what they're doing. >> exactly. >> they are spending tens of millions of dollars trying to find new voters because trump has not shrunk -- >> he needs mike pence. >> but he also needs the white identity politics and white resentment. so it's both. he needs the evangelicals. they need more evangelicals to come out. but they also need in rural areas across wisconsin, pennsylvania and michigan conservatives to come out who would have voted for trump last time but stayed home. >> it's all numbers. >> it is. but i would say but 2018. because what happened in 2018, and they were midterm elections, but you had a huge surge in voter turnout. those white suburban college

educated women turned -- and noncollege women turned against donald trump. and i think democrats -- >> 49% of the vote for republican-backed candidate or trump-backed candidate in 2018. the white educated female vote in '16 was 53% for trump, 49% for trump candidate in 2018. >> let me go to bed on this question. i wonder if trump is afraid that his candidate against him, the one that gets picked by the democrats next spring isn't going to be easily categorized. first, it's elizabeth warren who is from oklahoma. she doesn't seem coastal, although she is working at harvard, has worked at harvard. there is something about her that is a little rural to me. she might be tough. biden might be hard to nail or pegged as a leftist, whatever. are they afraid of that? is he just not sure? he doesn't know if he is knock their block off. ben? >> yeah, i mean, chris, part of what you have to remember about 2016 is yes, he ginned up a certain white identity vote that

had been somewhat dormant. but there is a backlash to the obama legacy. obama still won a resounding election in 2012 because he did two things. he motived the young voters, the minority voters, the women voters to turnout, and he ran a populist message against mitt romney. and if you look at the democrats running, if you look at someone like elizabeth warren, you to do two things. you have to stand up to trump. you have to give that part of the democratic coalition a belief that you're fighting for them, that you're principled, that you're giving them reason to turn out like they turned out in 2012 and 2018. and go right at trump and say this guy said he was going stand up for you and the only thing he did is stand up for his friends and rich corporation. a tax giveaway that is in your expense. trump has a democratic house. he has no legislative agenda. he has nothing to talk about when it comes to health care or the issues that americans actually care about, right. so the democrat has to do both. and elizabeth warren has done a great job doing both. >> mitt romney gave you guys a

break when he got caught by the bartender saying 47%. that doesn't hurt either the house vote tonight to kill impeachment resolution introduced by al green of texas citing the president's racist comments about the four congresswomen. this morning speaker pelosi waited on that impending vote. >> we have six committees that are working on following the facts in terms of any abuse of power, obstruction of justice and the rest that the president may have engaged in. that is the serious path that we are on, not that mr. green is not serious, but we'll deal with that on the floor. >> well, the move to start impeachment proceedings was defeated by a vote of 332 to 95 with 137 democrats joining republicans to block the effort to consider articles of impeachment this week. noticeably, the 95 democrats voting not to table the resolution is greater than the 86 democrats who publicly support impeachment.

judiciary committee chair jerry nadler was among those voting against tabling saying they should have sent it to his committee for first consideration. the president reacting after landing in north carolina tonight. >> we have just received an overwhelming vote against impeachment, and that's the end of it. let the democrats now go back to work. >> i'm afraid friday the 13th is coming back on this guy. freddie krueger is not dead. i'm telling you. whatever you think of impeachment is not going away. 95 is the high watermark. >> yeah, it is. >> of those who want to impeach. >> i think the best description i've heard of this is nancy pelosi and the democratic leadership for the most part know that they want a wounded trump, not a martyred trump. an impeachment would give them a martyred trump. >> and an acquitted trump. >> exactly. it doesn't make a whole lot of sense. >> how high will nancy pelosi let that number go.

you know she counts. will she corral 150, as long as it's not 218? >> let me just say if you look at the vote when al green put forward his last impeachment vote, it got 66 votes to move forward this time 95. and there are, i think, 86, 87 democrats who are already on record of starting an impeachment proceeding. and i think after the mueller testimony next week, that number is bound to go higher. >> is this a defense by nancy? did she say i'll let you have all the joy of saying you want to impeach, but it ain't going to happen. >> could she send any more signals that she doesn't want to it happen? my fear i think is for the base of the party and for all those activists out there, people you want knocking on doors and being enthusiastic, you will dampen their enthusiasm by not going head-on at this president. and besides that, it's about the constitution. >> your point, there should be impeachment? >> i believe there should be impeachment. how do you let this kind of

lawlessness go? and michael is right and say, heaven forbid, he does win reelection, democrats won't be able to do a single thing with him because then he really will be able to say you know what? the voters knew what they got, and i'm okay. >> i think that -- >> bad news. >> i appreciate the will and the sentiment among democrats to impeach, but that is not the will north the sentiment of the american people. nancy pelosi knows that. it is not a card she needs to play because the votes aren't there for it outside of capitol hill. number one. number two, what's the greater cause here? impeachment as you noted, jeremy, with no resolution in the senate because he will not be -- >> not with 2/3. >> not with 2/3. he will not be removed from office by the senate. or leave it to the american people. make your case. to your point about the turnout, if that base is really juiced and want donald trump out, their best way and the only way

effectively to do it is at the ballot box. not through a political process in the house where there is no resolution in the united states. >> there has never been a resolution on impeachment in the united states senate. not a single time it's been done. >> andrew johnson skated and so did nixon. let me go to ben rhodes, his political calculation. this is a tough one. you're a democratic campaign manager for whoever wins. what's the strategy to beat trump? is it to try to get the base of minority voters out, try to get the cities really up there in terms of hype, the big vote out, trying to work the women in the suburbs and hope your numbers will win, or to try to move to the center and get some of those blue collar democrats back home? >> no, i think you need to run with the clear message that can both motive your base, but also peel off some of those people. and the way to do it, chris, is by not taking the bait. have your message. be disciplined to it. kit be a strong progressive message. it can talk about things that people care about, including racism, including issues like

climate change that motive young people. elizabeth warren has been talking about which way donald trump has sold out. as long as you're disciplined and run your campaign, not his, you have the chance to do both. >> i think we should go back to the history books and look at harry truman. you play your strengths on jobs and issues that matter to people, especially the working people, and you get those issues out front, and you basically tear the other guy apart. you got to do both. thank you. you don't play it just soft. it ain't going to be defense. you're dead right. don't play defense. you got play offense and sell what you got. it's what you do with what you got that counts. thank you, donna edwards, jeremy, michael steele and ben rhodes. coming up, how did they find this stuff? from mar-a-lago, 1992, a little sleazy here, shedding light on the relationship. it looks pretty intimate there. look, look, look, pretty close

between him and epstein and accused sexual predator jeffrey epstein. what was going on in trump's great gatsby days when he was holding those parties. plus, william barr and wilbur ross in criminal contempt. is this another symbolic gesture by democrats or will they ever find a way to hold the trump administration truly accountable. and trump's schoolyard attacks. when he is accused of something like racism, he tries to turn the tables like on a schoolyard. the number of times trump used that baby defense. much more ahead. stick with us. i went straight to ctca. after my mastectomy, it was maddening because i felt part of my identity was being taken away. when you're able to restore what cancer's taken away, you see that transformation firsthand knowing that she had options that she could choose, helped restore hope. my team made me feel like a whole person again. cancer treatment centers of america. appointments available now.

who used expedia to book the vacation rental which led to the discovery that sometimes a little down time can lift you right up. expedia. everything you need to go. expedia. i was on the fence about changing from a manual to an electric toothbrush. but my hygienist said going electric could lead to way cleaner teeth. she said, get the one inspired by dentists, with a round brush head. go pro with oral-b. oral-b's gentle rounded brush head removes more plaque along the gum line. for cleaner teeth and healthier gums. and unlike sonicare, oral-b is the first electric toothbrush brand accepted by the ada for its effectiveness and safety. what an amazing clean! i'll only use an oral-b! oral-b. brush like a pro.

-keith used to be great to road-trip with. but since he bought his house... are you going 45? -uh, yes. 55 is a suggestion. -...it's kind of like driving with his dad. -what a sign, huh? terry, can you take a selfie of me? -take a selfie of you? -yeah. can you make it look like i'm holding it? -he did show us how to bundle home and auto at progressive.com and save a bunch of money. -oh, a plaque. "he later navigated northward, leaving... progressive can't protect you from becoming your parents. but we can protect your home and auto when you bundle with us. but we can protect your home and auto mno kidding.rd. but moving your internet and tv? that's easy. easy?! easy? easy. because now xfinity lets you transfer your service online in just about a minute with a few simple steps. really? really. that was easy. yup. plus, with two-hour appointment windows, it's all on your schedule. awesome. now all you have to do is move...that thing. [ sigh ] introducing an easier way to move with xfinity. it's just another way we're working to make your life simple, easy, awesome. go to xfinity.com/moving to get started.

welcome back to "hardball." last week, president trump told reporters he was, quote, not a fan of jeffrey epstein. >> i haven't spoken to him in probably 15 years or more. i wasn't a big fan of jeffrey epstein, that i can tell you. >> i was not a big fan of jeffrey epstein, that i can tell

you. newly unearthed nbc footage from 1992 shows you just how comfortable the two men were with each other. the video comes from years before epstein plead guilty to a state charge of soliciting a minor for prostitution. in the video, which you see here, trump greets epstein and two others at his mar-a-lago estate, escorting them into a party. and during that party which was being filmed for a show about his life, donald trump appears to be talking to epstein about the female guests. at one point, he appears to tell epstein about one of the guests, look at her. she is hot. the video also shows trump surrounded by women, and at one point he grabs and touches one of them. epstein's arrest has renewed attention on their friendship, that the two men had been friends for years until a falling out roughly 15 years ago. tomorrow a new york judge will decide whether to grant epstein's bail request. for more i'm joined by megan twohey, "new york times" investigative reporter and author of inside the gates of

power at president trump's presidential palace. lawrence, i want to start with you. what is the culture of mar-a-lago that would have this character in such celebrated position? why would this guy before and after his arrest and that wrist slap he got for 15 months where he could go to work six days a week, is he still part of the social circuitry down there? >> in trump's palm beach, all that matters is how much money you have. he loved young women and trump admired that in him. that footage shows precisely why these two guys were close friends. >> so he could go to a party and have a husband say to his wife, i'd like you to meet jeffrey epstein. you probably heard about him. it's okay. >> yeah. epstein flew down on trump's plane. he showed up late one time and trump was upset with him. of course he was close to him. >> how long ago was that? >> about 1990. >> okay. >> but you know as well as i do, whatever trump says is the truth, that's the truth. now he is not a friend. but of course he was a close

friend of his. >> what was the nature of their relationship? we're showing all the showing off of the cheerleaders. admittedly they're the cheerleader for the buffalo bills and the miami dolphins. what do we make of their actual relationship, megan? >> right there. is evidence. this isn't the only party that jeffrey epstein attended at mar-a-lago. there was a second party in 1992 that epstein attended with trump and a couple of business partners he had and like a beauty pageant competition and the beauty pageant contestants. that was actually a gathering in which one of the women has since alleged that donald trump sexually assaulted her there. so there is allegations that both men have faced coming out of some of the socializing that they did in palm beach at the time. what we also know is that so while they partied together and were seen together in the 1990s, in the early -- i think it was in the early 2000s, there was a young woman who was working at mar-a-lago who was recruited

into epstein's home with promises of becoming a masseuse and earning a lot of money, and she is now one of his accusers, a woman who says she was then sexual abused and -- >> how old was she at the time? >> she says she was 16 at the time. and her allegation didn't come out until 2009. and when that allegation came out i think was the moment that trump said i need to remove my association with epstein. and by many accounts was actually visibly very angry that there was an accusation that he had -- that epstein had actually recruited a woman, a young girl out of mar-a-lago out of his alleged sexual exploitation. >> all the steamy atmosphere of that party going on some for the camera, the cheerleaders, what is wrong? what do we say here on a political show about trump's relationship with this guy who's clearly got not legal jeopardy, he deserves legal jeopardy. all these cases where he was a

predator with young women in some sex trafficking thing that was going on, and what was trump's connection to it besides he likes to hang out with sleaze balls with roy cohn? he seems to like their company. what do we know? >> what we know is -- as we understand it, there were rumors that had circulated about epstein's sexual predation for years, but it wasn't until 2008 that he actually faced criminal charges. and so for years and years, epstein was able to draw cover for his alleged sort of misconduct and bad behavior through powerful connections, his wealth, his money, his powerful connections. you know, he had powerful connections that in the political realm from the clintons. he had powerful connection was harvard in the academic setting. he had powerful connections within sort of the british royalty with prince andrew. so there were a lot of ways he was able to kind of create cover for his alleged misbehavior.

and when these charges did come out, when the allegations did start to surface in the mid 2000s, he brought in these expensive high-powered attorneys like alan dershowitz who kind of came in and minimized the charges so that he was able to walk away and tell people who knew him that he was guilty of nothing more than soliciting a prostitute. so i think that that all helped give him cover, and his associates cover, those who did like to party with him, and those who donald trump himself has been quoted as saying in 2002 saying that he liked jeffrey epstein and that they both liked the company of beautiful women. >> younger. >> and in epstein's case, even recognizing that they were much younger. >> it seems wonderful that everyone has a right to a legal defense, megan and laurence. in the case of the very wealthy, the dream team, ken starr, dershowitz, the works. in 1992 the footage was shot for a faith daniels talk show called a closer look, which profiled the then newly divorced trump. during that episode, faith daniels and trump described the

circumstances of how he ended up on the show. let's watch. >> i don't know why i'm even on the show except we want to give you good ratings. i said to faith -- >> how generous. >> major, major ratings. you are. you're going to get big ratings. >> tell the rest of the story, though. i saw you at the celebrity chef dinner here in new york. >> and what a kiss. >> you kissed me on the lips in front of the paparazzi. and i said that will cost you. i'm booking you on the show. >> it was so good. so open and nice. she is a fabulous woman. >> so open and nice. >> and her husband is a handsome devil. >> this evening we reached out to the white house to respond to this exchange. we're waiting for a response. however, the unprompted kissing that trump describes to faith daniels in the clip describes the behavior we later saw in the infamous "access hollywood" tape. >> i'm automatically attracted to beautiful. i just start kissing them. it's like a magnet. just kiss. and when you're a star, they let you do it. you can do anything. >> whatever you want?

>> grab them by the [ bleep ]. do any of that. >> laurence, you cover this stuff. >> not any longer. it's so disgusting on so many levels, isn't it? >> i wonder this. why is he still socially -- miami beach, from what i know about it, palm beach, rather, is a lot of people with money. they get really dressed up at night. they're somewhat older. they're sort of a wasp crowd and a jewish crowd, whatever. but they're all in common is money and showing up and looking well at nighttime and being somewhat classy in your demeanor. how does trump fit into that? >> well, it's his world. meaning he can create the illusion of classiness as well. if you've got $200,000, you can join mar-a-lago too. you can be one of them. >> you can buy your way to class? >> exactly. >> wonderful. thank you, megan twohey. lawrence, great respect for you. lawrence leamer.

up next, the householding william barr and wilbur in criminal contempt for stonewalling congress on the census controversy. you're watching "hardball." maria ramirez! mom! maria! maria ramirez... mcdonald's is committing 150 million dollars in tuition assistance, education, and career advising programs... prof: maria ramirez mom and dad: maria ramirez!!! to help more employees achieve their dreams. why go with anybody else? we know their rates are good, we know that they're always going to take care of us. it was an instant savings and i should have changed a long time ago. we're the tenney's and we're usaa members for life. call usaa to start saving on insurance today. about the colonial penn program. here to tell you and we're usaa members for life. if you're age 50 to 85

and looking to buy life insurance on a fixed budget, remember the three p's. what are the three p's? the three p's of life insurance on a fixed budget are price, price, and price. a price you can afford, a price that can't increase, and a price that fits your budget. i'm 65 and take medications. what's my price? you can get coverage for $9.95 a month. i just turned 80. what's my price? $9.95 a month for you, too. if you're age 50 to 85, call now about the number one most popular whole life insurance plan available through the colonial penn program. it has an affordable rate starting at $9.95 a month. no medical exam, no health questions. your acceptance is guaranteed, and this plan has a guaranteed lifetime rate lock, so your rate can never go up for any reason. and with this plan, you can pick your payment date, so you can time your premium due date

to work with your budget. so call now for free information. and you'll also get this free beneficiary planner, and it's yours just for calling. so call now. our mission is to provide complete, balanced nutrition for strength and energy! whoo-hoo! great-tasting ensure. with nine grams of protein and twenty-six vitamins and minerals. ensure, for strength and energy. and twenty-six vitamins and minerals. lick fast like a cookie dough ninja. apply that same speed to the ford hurry up and save sales event. for the first time ever get 20% estimated savings on select ford models, plus earn complimentary maintenance through fordpass rewards. it all adds up. don't you love math? so get here asap because tasty deals and summer

go fast. get in or lose out on 20% estimated savings on select ford models, plus earn complimentary maintenance through fordpass rewards. welcome back to "hardball." in a dramatic move late today, the house of representatives voted to hold attorney general william barr and the commerce secretary wilbur ross in criminal contempt of congress for withholding subpoenaed

documents from the oversight committee. as nbc news points out, the vote marks close to the second time in american history that an american attorney general had been found in criminal contempt, the first being eric holder seven years ago. the subpoena documents that barr and ross withheld about the administration's failed effort to add a citizenship question to the census, and they could reveal the president's ulterior motive perhaps in paging that census fight. according to "the new york times," the democrats believe, quote, the democrats' long stated rationale for collecting the data, to better enforce the voting rights act was merely a cover for a politically motivated attempt to eliminate noncitizens from statistics. the question was necessary ruling that their justification seems to have been contrived. i'm joined right now by congresswoman debbie wasserman schultz of florida who serves on the house oversight committee.

congresswoman, it's great to have you on. >> thank you. . can you figure out what the trump people were up to, and including that citizenship question? what was their political dream here? >> well, it certainly wasn't what secretary ross testified under oath which was that the sole reason he said that they wanted the citizenship question on the census was to enforce the voting rights act. and president trump himself basically outed secretary ross as a liar last week when he said publicly that the purpose was for partisan gerrymandering. and you know, we had two cabinet officials defy bipartisan congressional subpoenas. and the administration is not above the law. and so we have to use every tool at our disposal to be able to use the oversight authority we have to get answers to the questions, because if this was really about partisan gerrymandering, if the documents had been revealed which we know

have said what the administration was really trying to do was to suppress hispanic representation and make sure that brown people weren't represented the way they should be just on their numbers, then we had to do this. >> so the purpose was to scare people who have some people in the family or the household who are undocumented not to participate, and thereby reduce the number of people being counted in that area. >> right there. is a reason, chris, that it's been 70 years since a citizenship question has been on a census. and i was at the hearing when we had secretary ross there. and very clearly we pointed out that you don't need a citizenship question to enforce the voting rights act. you don't need -- we have smaller surveys that they do where we include it now. but the president himself said last week that it was partisan gerrymandering that was her own motive. he outed his own cabinet secretary. we've been trying to get documents. the oversight committee's role is to make sure that we can get

to the bottom of the motivations of the administration. that's why our founding fathers set up three branches of government. it's our job in congress to get answers to questions. it's the administration's job to act on it. >> the president is telling wilbur ross don't participate. don't answer their subpoena. ignore them, basically. that's an amazing statement. >> this contempt vote allows us to -- it's a criminal contempt resolution. and now it allows us to go to court and enforce our subpoena authority. >> it's great to have you on. >> get answers to this question. >> it's great to have you on. debbie wasserman schultz, thank you so much for coming on. >> thank you. up next, president trump is in north carolina tonight, as we said, hoping to rally his base. he has a crowd there, possibly with fresh criticism aimed at the four women, the self-styled squad. will this become a tape of his campaign? you betcha'. you're watching "hardball." you're watching "hardball. look limu. a civilian buying a new car.

let's go. limu's right. liberty mutual can save you money by customizing your car insurance, so you only pay for what you need. oh... yeah, i've been a customer for years. huh... only pay for what you need. ♪ liberty. liberty. liberty. liberty. ♪ w...that keep us active every day.... like you, your cells get hungry. feed them... ...with centrum® multigummies. so you can be unstoppable. now improved! better tasting! feed your cells today.

my bladder leak underwear.orried someone might see so, i switched. to always discreet boutique. its shape-hugging threads smooth out the back. so it fits better than depend. and no one notices. always discreet. we carry flowers that signifyn why we want to end the disease. and we walk so that one day, there will be a white flower for alzheimer's first survivor. join the fight at alz.org/walk.

welcome back to "hardball." you're looking at live pictures right now at president trump himself on stage in his campaign rally in greenville, north carolina. north carolina of course he won narrowly in 2016. president trump just responded to tonight's vote by the house to kill a resolution on impeachment. >> i just heard that the united states house of representatives has overwhelmingly voted to kill the most ridiculous project i've ever been involved in, the resolution, how stupid is that, on impeachment. i want to thank those democrats because many of them voted for us. the vote was a totally lopsided

332-95 to one. >> the president is looking to rally his base obviously the day after the house passed another resolution, condemning him for having legitimized fear and hatred of new americans and people of color. it appears president trump is going to ignore that condemnation and continue to adjust what he is doing and got condemned for it. two senior officials told nbc news that the president is expected to continue his attacks on the four congresswomen tonight in what they say is a preview of a 2020 strategy that is resonating with his base, they think. trump tweeted this morning big rally tonight in greenville, north carolina. i'll talk also about people who love and hate our country, mostly love. as "the new york times" reports, a major component of the president's reelection strategy is to portray his opponents as not merely disliking him and his policies, but also disliking america itself. and "the washington post" points out tonight's rallies like all the others the president has held this year have been in

states he won in 2016, and he has no interest in tone do you think the incendiary rhetoric that has made him unpopular among black, hispanic and female voters. his old go-to defense right out of a schoolyard playbook, and that's next. you're watching "hardball." then i left my business to combat climate change, fix our democracy, and hold president trump accountable. last year, we ran the largest youth voter mobilization in history - helping double turnout and win back the house. i'm tom steyer and i approve this message. let's make change happen!

♪ ♪ ♪ ♪ about the colonial penn program. here to tell you if you're age 50 to 85 and looking to buy life insurance on a fixed budget, remember the three p's. what are the three p's? the three p's of life insurance on a fixed budget are price, price, and price. a price you can afford, a price that can't increase, and a price that fits your budget. i'm 65 and take medications. what's my price? you can get coverage for $9.95 a month. i just turned 80. what's my price? $9.95 a month for you, too. if you're age 50 to 85, call now about the number one most popular whole life insurance plan available through the colonial penn program. it has an affordable rate starting at $9.95 a month.

no medical exam, no health questions. your acceptance is guaranteed, and this plan has a guaranteed lifetime rate lock, so your rate can never go up for any reason. and with this plan, you can pick your payment date, so you can time your premium due date to work with your budget. so call now for free information. and you'll also get this free beneficiary planner, and it's yours just for calling. so call now.

♪work so hard give it everything you got♪ ♪strength of a lioness tough as a knot♪ ♪rocking the stage and we're never gonna stop♪ ♪all strength, no sweat... just in case you forgot♪ ♪all strength, no sweat... ♪no no no sweat... (driver) relax, it's just a bug. that's not a bug, that's not a bug! (burke) hit and drone. seen it, covered it. at farmers, we know a thing or two because we've seen a thing or two. ♪ we are farmers. bum-pa-dum, bum-bum-bum-bum ♪ welcome back to "hardball." tonight the president is holding his first rally since he relaunched husband reelection campaign. it comes a day after the house

condemned him for some of the same language he is putting on wild display tonight again. i'm joined by cornell belcher and rick tyler, a republican strategist. let's talk turkey. i know we have to talk morality because we have moral standards in our country, including here. but why does trump get the ride? why does he get people that probably go to church on sunday. they teach their kids to use good manner, not to use racial slurs, and yet they put the maga hat on and they applaud like crazy people for this guy. >> catastrophe. and i wrote about this in my book from two years. it was catastrophe of the election of barack obama for a certain group of people was a catastrophe. it was a changing of the guard. i was the first time in the history where the vast, vast majority of white voters could vote one way and the country could go in a different way. >> did the whites vote against obama? >> obama lost white voters in '08 and even larger in 12. >> the crowd, by the way, we're

going get the tape in a minute is showing "send her back." in the spirit of trump. >> so when you have a catastrophe, all rules and sort of norms go out. so once upon a time, donald trump -- >> you makes this sound like the palestinian attitude toward the founding of israel. >> for somebody it's a catastrophe. donald trump you know well pablo ran for years. pablo couldn't win a republican nomination. now all of the sudden my friends in the republican party is no longer ronald reagan's republican party. it's donald trump's party. >> he did it? he is a genius? >> no it's a driving of the resentment. and he has captured this resentment and this fear about the changing of america. >> you know, when the republicans run in '48, they didn't run any communists. by '52 they learned to be smart about it. who switched to being a tribalist party? an ethnic tribalist party. >> the math is against them. you have a base, and you try to

build out from the base. trump has done nothing to build out from the base. >> w. tried to. w. tried to bring. he got about 35, 40% of hispanic voters. >> he was pretty successful at it. look, on both sides, politics parties have devolved into i liken it to team sports. so let's say there is a bad call in a super bowl game, and everybody can look at the jumbotron, and we'll call that truth. everybody can see that he stepped out of the bounds, it was a good call. that's the truth. but to have half the stadium, that's a bad call, because that means my team loses. and the other half saying that's a good call. the truth, we're in a post truth politics world. >> we don't have a camera in politics that tells us what was the call? >> yeah, that's true. the media is the camera. but he is saying the media is corrupt and the referees are corrupt. they're not telling. >> so for the first time, all the major newspapers, they're mostly owned by republicans. editorially they're probably more liberal.

all the newspapers have called him racist. that's the first time that's happened. >> and that's i think a term for the best. we can't go down this hole trump is trying to take us down. guess what? america is not getting whiter. you and i have going to have to get along and our children are really going to have to get along or we're going lose the future to the rising pacific countries, because we're going to go down a rat's hole. >> how does this square with kids in their 20s and 30s today? my kids are in their 30s now. when they were at school, and they had an african american teacher, they never told us. it didn't click with them as a significant fact. >> right, right. >> that's different than when i went to school, because we were all basically effectively segregated. so now a kid who is now 25, 32, are they going to listen to trump? >> they're growing up in a more diverse world. the millennials are the generation where america will become a majority minority

country. so they kind of have to get along. >> let's take a look at this. the trump rally just now, you would hear, they used to yell "lock her up", meaning hillary clinton. tonight there is a new one. let's take a listen to the latest chant. >> these left wing ideologues see our nation as a force of evil. they want to demolish our constitution, weaken our military, eliminate the values that built this magnificent country. you to look at some of their recent comments, which are never talked about. when you see the four congresswomen, oh isn't that lovely? i'll give you just a couple. i've had pages and pages. but we don't want to bore you. we don't want to go too long. omar has a history of launching

vicious anti-semitic screens. >> send her back, send her back, send her back! send her back! send her back! >> you know, the anti-semitic thing, that is an aspect, but it's not the main point of what these women have been saying at all. that's one case. >> but it sort of paints them as evil, crazy doers. i think it's stark. when you look at how that reagan launched his reelection, "good morning america," w has talked about a more hopeful mark. bill clinton was a bridge to the 21st century. whether they're democrat or republican, you had them launching campaignses in a hopeful bringing america together. it's dramatically different. >> it showed in the cabinet, whatever you think of the guys, that i did try to diversify their cabinets, w. and more recent republicans, until this

guy came along. >> after world war i, warren harding's slogan was return to normalcy. maybe adopted by the democrats. look, he does -- this is the thing that he actually does best, right? this roving i don't know -- >> troubador. >> some show. and he gets the crowd all ginned up and he says these ridiculous things because the one-offs aren't working. so mr. kim, tear down that curb, that didn't work. build a wall, mexico is going to pay, didn't work. we're going to take china trade. we don't have any trade with china that didn't work. we're going to redo nafta. we don't have a redone nafta. nothing has been passed or ratified. this is all he has. >> all he has is racism. >> last week's of being a rapist. he says terrible things about ethnic groups. the gunfire says anything he wants. it's almost up to the level of i should shoot somebody on fifth avenue. why are they with him that

strongly? >> because he is their tribal strongman. listen, i don't let democrats off this either. when donald trump stands up and says i'm going to give you back your country, we knew what he was doing. and democrats' response to that was raising the minimum wage. we have to speak to this tribalism. >> well said. thank you. up next, liberal justice john paul stephens died yesterday. that man served 35 years in the u.s. supreme court, and donald trump has his eyes on two future conservative justices serving at least that long. you bet. he gets back in there, that will make it 7-2 conservative. you're watching "hardball."

you don't really talk about your insurance unless you're complaining about it. you go on about how... ...it's so confusing it hurts my brain. ya i hear ya... or say you can't believe... ...how much of a hassle it is! and tell anyone who'll listen... (garbled)....it's so expensive! she said it's so expensive. tell me about it. yes.. well i'm telling the people at home. that's why esurance is making the whole experience surprisingly painless. so, you never have to talk about it, unless you're their spokesperson. esurance. it's surprisingly painless. that's ensure max protein, with high protein and 1 gram sugar. it's a sit-up, banana! bend at the waist! i'm tryin'! keep it up. you'll get there. whoa-hoa-hoa! 30 grams of protein, and one gram of sugar. ensure max protein.

i went straight to ctca. after my mastectomy, i felt like part of my identity was being taken away. my team made me feel whole again. cancer treatment centers of america. appointments available now. (a blend of quality probiotics new align whole food probiotic, and fermented whole food botanicals. expertly curated to naturally support your gut health everyday. go with align whole food blend. from the pros in digestive health. sir, you're a broker. what do you charge for online equity trades? uh, i'll look into it. (phone rings) lisa jones! lisa: (on phone) hey carl, what are you charging me for online equity trades? (nervous chuckle) lisa: and do i get my fees back if i'm not happy? like a satisfaction guarantee? ugh. schwab! lisa: oh right, i'm calling schwab. thanks, carl! wait, lisa! lisa... are you getting low costs backed by a satisfaction guarantee?

if not, talk to schwab. a modern approach to wealth management. if not, talk to schwab. here, hello! starts with -hi!mple... how can i help? a data plan for everyone. everyone? everyone. let's send to everyone! [ camera clicking ] wifi up there? -ahhh. sure, why not? how'd he get out?! a camera might figure it out. that was easy! glad i could help. at xfinity, we're here to make life simple. easy. awesome. so come ask, shop, discover at your xfinity store today.

our thoughts tonight about the death of john paul stevens. justice stevens was 99 years old when he died yesterday. most justices, most people are not so fortunate, of course. stevens was the third longest serving justice ever, retiring from the supreme court in 2010 after 35 years. during his time on the bench, he was part of the more liberal branch of the court saying the two biggest mistakes made by the supreme court when he was there were bush v gore and citizens

united. we can agree on that. we should therefore consider the prospect of the court's likely future. that tells us the historic nature, by the way, of this 2020 presidential election coming. if donald trump gets a second turn, he will get the chance to move the supreme court from its present 5-4 conservative to 7-2 conservative. and just think how easily he and his partner mitch mcconnell could pull that off. they could do that very swiftly, moving the court right ward, right ward enough to put a generations long lock on the supreme court, a move made easier by the current gop habit of picking youngsters for the high court, getting them young enough to spend the shank of their career there's, which brings us to the 2020 election and the need to pick a winner, especially for those who care about people's rights and about fair elections. we need justices that will reflect the entire will of the american population, not just those able to jump through the hops the republicans have held out there, hoops especially challenge fog interest old and less educated.

my point is basic and undeniable. the republicans play for keeps. you want to beat them, do the same. and when it gets down to picking the person you want picking the next members of the supreme court, find yourself a winner. that's "hardball" for now. thanks for being with us. "all in with chris hayes" starts right now. tonight on "all in" -- >> i knew him like everybody in palm beach knew him. >> as the president tries to separate himself from jeffrey epstein -- >> i wasn't a fan. i was not. >> tonight, new video released by nbc news showing the future president partying with the future felon. then, what we learned from today's vote on impeachment resolution. >> we cannot wait. >> as new polling suggests racism as a political strategy is actually bad. >> i do think i'm winning the political fight. plus, senator cory booker on the president's remarks and more, and senator brian schatz on his new push to address climate change in the senate,