tv Hardball With Chris Matthews MSNBC August 26, 2019 4:00pm-5:00pm PDT
4:00 pm
>> ginsberg will be returning to the bench in october for the next supreme court session. that does it for me. you can catch me every morning on 1"first look" at 5:00 a.m. eastern. "hardball" with chris matthews is up next. mission for moscow. let's play "hardball." good evening. i'm chris matthews in new york. president trump is on his way back to washington tonight after acting as russia's ambassador to the democratic nations. and as business promotor of his florida golf resort. before heading home, trump tried to put a rosy spin on the three days of g7 talks. >> this is a truly successful g7. there was tremendous unity. there was great unity. if there was any word for this
4:01 pm
particular meeting of seven very important countries, it was unity. i think most important of all, we got along great. we got along great. >> nice try. but "the new york times" reports any signs of unity were largely for show. quote, behind the scenes at the annual gathering of the some of the world's leading powers, president trump still found himself at odds with his counterparts. on sunday over issues like trade, climate change, north korea, russia and iran. at today's news conference, the president continued to push for russia to be added back into the group after being exiled from the g7 after it annexed crimea back in 2014. well, after conducting what he, himself, called a lively discussion about his desire to welcome back russia at a group dinner on saturday, today the president appeared to act as an agent again for moscow. >> why do you think it's appropriate to invite russia to the g7 given that they've meddled in the 2016 election? and are you worried that if russia does come to the g7 that
4:02 pm
it might hurt you politically because it's only going to be a couple of months before the 2020 election? >> a lot of bad things happened with president putin and president obama. he was outsmarted by putin. he was outsmarted. president putin outsmarted president obama. wait a minute. and i can understand how president obama would feel. he wasn't happy. and they're not in for that reason. i think it would be better to have russia inside the tent than outside the tent. i do nothing for politics. >> well, next year's g7 will be hosted by the united states and the president has already floated the possibility that it will take place at his own golf club down in miami but wouldn't rule out the possibility of inviting russian president vladimir putin himself to join the group. >> as the g7 host next year, you're allowed to invite other countries to come, guest countries even though they're not necessarily part of the overall group. would you consider inviting vladimir putin under those circumstances? >> well, i don't know that he'd accept. those are tough circumstances. would i invite him? i would certainly invite him.
4:03 pm
whether or not he could come psychologically, i think that's a tough thing for him to do. >> for more, i'm joined by yamiche alcindor, you saw her there for pbs "newshour" traveling with the president in france. brad stevens, op-ed columnist for "the new york times." what a group. thank you. yamiche, that question you put to him i think is serious, and i -- he -- doesn't he understand that it looks like a continuing pattern of his agency for russia? that the whole question of the scandal involving russia getting involved with our elections in 2016, his role in playing footsie with him, if you will, and then he continues to play the role of russian friend as if the dossier was in technicolor and he's afraid they're going to drop it tomorrow. he's shameless. your thoughts? >> well, opponents of the president would say there is something obviously weird going on with russia.
4:04 pm
his opponents would say that he obviously has some sort of affinity for russia. maybe he's even feeling pressured by his business connections with russia. of course the president himself would say that he is really is interested in having russia being part of the table because so many people are talking about russia. so many people are talking about annexing russia. when i pressed him and said why do you keep changing and doubling down on the idea that obama was outsmarted when every other country in the world has said that it's because russia annexed crimea why they were kicked out of the g7. he wouldn't answer that question. instead he went back to what opponents say is his nervous tick, to blame president obama for all sorts of stuff. in this case, he's blaming obama for the g7, immigration, not being tough on china. but there, his opponents would say, something weird going on with president trump and russia in this case. >> ambassador mcfaul, your thoughts on what the russians must think at the highest levels at this american president operating as their agent? >> well, they're delighted by
4:05 pm
it, of course, because it divides the g7 at a time when we could actually really use unity, on how to deal with the global economy, how to deal with china. instead we're having ridiculous, i want to emphasize that adjective, ridiculous discussions about inviting vladimir putin back to the g8. you know, i'm not -- i didn't write "art of the deal," but i did do some diplomacy. i don't understand why president trump continues to offer something for nothing. why is that a good deal for the american people? let's let him come back in for nothing. he has to do nothing. obviously nobody else is going to agree with him and i really cannot understand why the president continues to double and triple down on this courtship, this fawning of vladimir putin. >> well, you're a columnist. you're entitled to speculate, sir. it really looks like he wants to keep putin happy. >> that's definitely the appearance and it's against political interests, which makes it that much more curious, but, you know, i think what
4:06 pm
ambassador mcfaul is so important to emphasize. i mean, by all means let's invite russia back to the g8 after they've withdrawn from crimea, after they've stopped waging war in eastern ukraine, after they've accounted for an act of terrorism that brought down a malaysian airliner, after they dealt with nuclear terrorism against dissident figures in great britain and, most of all, after we've had a full reckoning with them about their attempts to undermine democratic elections in the united states. that's exactly the kind of deal by which you could imagine russia coming back into a knew sort of g7 plus one or g8. but, you know, there is also -- >> there could be another thing -- you're talking geopolitically and what a fair deal would be state to state. about trump personally, i wonder, why is he doing it personally? he's not doing it in the interest of the united states, which is what you'd be discussing. those trade matters would be important for him if he was a statesman. he's not a statesman. he's donald trump. >> look, however you feel about
4:07 pm
the outcome of the mueller report, one thing that is absolutely clear is that donald trump gave his adversaries every reason to have good suspicions about ulterior motives when it came to his thinking about russia because some of -- some of his positions simply are nonsensical unless there is some motive that none of us fully understand. >> well, yamiche mentioned right there, she also pushed the president today on why he continued to blame former president barack obama for russia's exclusion from the g7 and offered his own revisionist history about russia's annexation of crimea. >> why did you make the misleading statement that russia outsmarted president obama? >> well, he did. >> when other countries said the reason that russia was kicked out was very clearly because they annexed crimea. why keep repeating what some people would see as a clear lie. >> i know you like president obama, but it was annexed during president obama's term. that was not a good thing. it could have been stopped. it could have been stopped with the right whatever.
4:08 pm
>> christopher, i have never seen more ridiculous blame shifting. you take a country that grabs another country, grabs crimea out of ukraine, and he blames obama. talk about blaming the victim. he's blaming obama because he didn't send the troops in? >> yeah, because he didn't want to go to war with a nuclear power to try to save crimea. yeah, exactly. and what's his answer? he could have done whatever. oh, come on. it's absolutely absurd. but i think coming back to the question of inviting russia back to the g8, it was invited in the first place in the 1990s not because it deserved to be a member. it wasn't one of the most eight most industrialized economies. it was a fledgeling democracy that the g7 wanted to encourage to become more democratic. well, since vladimir putin has been president or ruler of russia, it hasn't been a fledgeling democracy, and it's done all of those things that
4:09 pm
bret rattled off in russian crimes. since it shouldn't have been in in the first place and since it was brought in to be something that it's not, why even begin to talk about bringing it back in now? and even putin knows it's ridiculous. that's why when he's been asked about it, he said he thinks the g20 is a more suitable place for him to be and the g20 basically accounts for 80% of the world's domestic product, whereas the g7 or g8 only accounts for about 40%. >> that was well said. thank you. because i do remember yeltsin, he stood up to the red army personally. at personal physical risk and changed history over there. and putin brought it back the other direction. >> absolutely. >> as i mentioned earlier, the president suggested he may host the g7 summit. somebody's laughing already. at his trump national dural golf resort near miami, despite concerns it would violate the constitution's emoluments clause
4:10 pm
prohibiting officers of the u.s. government accepting a thing of value from a foreign state, in this case seven countries including russia, he wants to give them a break. anyway, it clearly states -- this is in the constitution. no person holding any office of profit or trust under the united states shall without the consent of the congress accept of any president emolument -- present, rather, office or title of any kind, whatever, from any king, prince or foreign state. the president downplayed and turned today's news conference into an infomercial. here he is like a pitchman on the atlantic city boardwalk selling, in this case his dural country club. >> dural happens to be within miami. it's a city. it's a wonderful place. it's very importantly only five minutes from the airport.
4:11 pm
the airport's right next door. with dural, we have a series of magnificent buildings. we call them bungalows. they each hold from 50 to 70 very luxurious rooms with magnificent rooms. we have incredible conference rooms, incredible restaurants and we have many hundreds of acres so that in terms of parking, in terms of all of the things that you need, the ballrooms are among the biggest in florida and the best. each country can have their own villa or their own bungalow. >> i don't know what to say except, ambassador -- ambassador, he wants -- this is a trade show. this is the marketing director for dural in the guise of a u.s. president and world leader. >> since when do we need ballrooms for g7 summits? i have a suggestion. there is this place called camp david. i don't know if the president's heard of it. he's been there a few times. it's a government property. fantastic security. president obama hosted the g8 summit there in 2012.
4:12 pm
i think that's a fantastic alternative. >> you know, i was wondering, bret, this is rich for a column, so i'm going to let you columnize here. the president of the united states blatantly pitching for his own property in the face of the emoluments clause. i want your money. >> right. i mean, look, this is -- this is -- they made bad "b" movies in the 1980s about dictators in distant countries behaving -- >> right. >> -- in the fashion that you just witnessed with the president, but, you know, look, it also says something important, which is that the president has never stopped being essentially a grifter looking out for the interests of the most important organization in the united states, which is not the white house, not the u.s. -- not the federal government, it's -- it's the trump organization. >> the trump family. >> which is, of course, the trump family. and so in that sense you really have -- excuse me.
4:13 pm
i'm almost insulting third-world countries, but the third-worldization of america, in which the interest -- the personal financial interests of the president and his family are the central consideration in statecraft. that's amazing. and, you know, you're watching this and you're thinking, what -- what -- what combination of drugs did i take this morning that i actually saw that on tv? >> well, let's go to yamiche who is a student of this president -- >> if i could. >> i wonder if you could, yamiche, tell us as a reporter, analytical question, not exactly reporting, but analysis here. is there something going on with this guy? i mean, greenland, dural. it's like he's become -- he's met forev metamorphasized into the cartoon of donald trump. do you notice anything different or is this standard m.o.? >> well, the president the moment he took office was really saying that he was going to be a businessman, that the country
4:14 pm
needed that. what he's really exhibiting is an interest in his personal business, making money some people would say off the presidency. i've been talking to watchdog groups, including the citizens for responsibility and ethics in washington. they're looking at possibly having a lawsuit against president trump because they think there might be an ethical violation there. you also hear the president saying he was going to lose between 3 and $5 billion from being president. analysis from "the washington post" and others he's made millions of dollars first by actually physically going to his properties on several weekends in new jersey and in florida, and also the trump national hotel in washington, d.c., a lot of international leaders and republican lawmakers have held fund-raisers there. so we see that the president has already been making millions of dollars off the presidency. i think what we've seen in the last couple of weeks, people would say and some of hi opponenhis opponents would say is the president trying to maximize the profits he's been making off the presidency. >> i don't know what to say.
4:15 pm
we had great presidents. fdr, eisenhower, kennedy all in a row and then we get this guy. anyway, yamiche alcindor, mike mcfaul, bret stephens, christopher dickey. coming up, it gets worse, dirt ball politics. trump allies are unleashing dogs on journalists releasing oppo research and compiling dossiers on potentially embarrassing social media posts in order to try to intimidate reporters. he wants the media to stop reporting on him objectively. he's going after people's families, people who work for them in their organizations, anything to stop people from reporting on him. plus, bombshell new poll numbers tonight show a major swing in the democratic race for president. the poll shows a virtual three-way tie right now. it could be an outlier but it's fascinating, except for joe biden because biden in big trouble here. he's now slipping behind the two progressives on the left, behind bernie, behind elizabeth. we'll get much more on that tonight. a lot of news tonight on this monday. stick with us.
4:16 pm
4:17 pm
ancestry specifically showed the regions that my family was from. new features. greater details. richer stories. get your dna kit today at ancestry.com. they give us excellent customer otservice, every time.e. our 18 year old was in an accident. usaa took care of her car rental, and getting her car towed. all i had to take care of was making sure that my daughter was ok. if i met another veteran, and they were with another insurance company, i would tell them, you need to join usaa because they have better rates, and better service. we're the gomez family... we're the rivera family... we're the kirby family, and we are usaa members for life. get your auto insurance quote today.
4:18 pm
from the 5am wakers, to the 6am sleepers. everyone uses their phone differently and in different places. that's why xfinity mobile created a wireless network that auto connects you to millions of secure wifi hot spots. and the best lte everywhere else. xfinity mobile is a different kind of wireless network designed to save you money. save up to $400 a year on your wireless bill. plus get $250 back when you buy an eligible phone. click, call or visit a store today.
4:19 pm
as you know, i have a running war with the media. they are among the most dishonest human beings on earth. >> a few days ago i called the fake news the enemy of the people, and they are. they are the enemy of the people. >> you know, you read the fake news. it's fake. and disgraceful. >> just stick with us. don't believe the crap you see from these people, the fake news. and just remember, what you're seeing and what you are reading is not what's happening. >> what he says is happening is happening. welcome back to "hardball." president trump has made no secret about his disdain for the news media, or his fear, rather. frequently naming them the enemy of the people for his purposes. this weekend we learned that president trump's allies are escalating his war on journalists. according to "the new york times," a loose network of conservative operatives allied
4:20 pm
with the white house is pursuing what they say will be an aggressive operation to discredit news organizations deemed hostile to president trump by publicizing damaging information about journalists. those operatives have already released information about journalists at cnn, "the washington post" and "the new york times." one source tells "the times" that operatives have closely examined more than a decade's worth of public posts and statements by journalists. the research is said to extend to members of journalists' families who are active in politics and other opponents of the president. arthur schwarz, an informal adviser to the president's oldest son donald trump june r. believed to be one of the operation's leaders. unable to challenge the accuracy of our reporting, political operatives have been scouring social media and other sources to find any possibly embarrassing information on anyone associated with "the times." their goal is to silence critics and undermine the public's faith in independent journalism.
4:21 pm
this represents an escalation of an ongoing campaign against the free press. that's the publisher of "the times" talking. for more i'm joined by reporter and co-author of that piece in "the new york times." and david corn, washington bureau chief for mother jones. congratulations. thank you so much. how did you get to this story about this guy schwarz and what they've been up to in terms of intimidating reporters or trying to do by uncovering facts people that aren't that important to news editorial content or family members or when they were 15 years old. how are they hurting people's ability to honestly report? >> one of the things that struck us initially was looking at who is the target of these exposes, chris. when we noticed they were lower level people, people that often didn't have anything to do with coverage of trump or his administration, that made us realize that this is probably a pretty sophisticated effort, an effort that goes back and has
4:22 pm
looked at years and years, hundreds potentially maybe even thousands of people. and what our reporting led us to was the answer that, yes, that's indeed what's happened. this is a coordinated effort by president trump's allies, people with close ties to president trump's eldest son donald trump jr. who are not seeking to hold newspapers to account, but who are seeking to intimidate and embarrass journalists who do work that is exposing things that the trump administration is doing, that they disagree with, they think is unflattering. and that's what's so different about what this effort really is. it's not an effort to say we want to hold media accountable, it's an effort to intimidate, and what they've done is they've cast a dragnet here. this is not specific going after individual reporters who have written stories saying we take issue with this person or this story, this is saying we are seeking to discredit your entire organization by finding as many people as we can inside your
4:23 pm
organization who may have tweeted something ten, 15 years ago that is reprehensible, but we are going to use it to tarnish you all. >> you know, my friend, david, this is exactly what joe mccarthy did. he didn't find any significant communists. he found a dentist in new jersey who had been part of the communist party. a dentist. that was his job in the army, to be a dentist. he found this guy was an old lefty, a member of the party and he used that to make the case that the united states army had been infiltrated by the reds. and that was the whole thing about him in the army in mccarthy hearings, all about that dentist. this sounds like the same tactic. >> well, it is. i'm jealous of the story. congratulations to jeremy and ken vogel who did it. and, you know, if someone has a problem with "the new york times," cnn, mother jones, msnbc, the way to deal with it is to say here are the facts that are different than what you report and challenge them on that basis. that's not what's being done here. this is an intimidation
4:24 pm
campaign. we're going after families. and in some ways not entirely new in that the right going back to richard nixon's enemies list, to jesse helms going after dan rather and cbs, has long looked at the media as needing to discredit the media in order to preserve political power. and this is what we see now with donald trump. he's calling, you know, the media not just the enemy of the people, but he says i'm asked about -- at the g7 why people in the media hate america. so he's already turning us, all of us collectively into the enemy here, not vladimir putin, he's not the enemy, the media is. so this is going to lead to, you know, we've talked about this before, to i think some real dangerous turn of events. i don't want to be hyperbolic here, but what's happening with this arthur schwarz campaign is in sync with what the president is doing. and it's what authoritarians always do, discredit possible critics. >> as david just said, president trump continued his assault on
4:25 pm
the media this weekend, tweeting "the question i was asked most today -- this is supposed to be an honest statement. "by fellow world leaders, who think the u.s. is doing so well and is stronger than ever before happens to be -- this is trump reporting here. mr. president, why does the american media hate your country so much? why are they rooting for it to fail? that's trump's idea of reporting news. while he provided no evidence to support his claims. trump said in a follow-up tweet, in france we are all laughing at knowingly inaccurate the u.s. reporting of the events conversations at the g7 is. fake news. that's an example if donald trump were our reporter, right? he's telling us what he said happened over is that they're all coming up to him and feeling sorry for him because the media is out to get him. your thoughts? >> right. well, his version of events is often not reality, chris. we all know that. and what the president is ultimately doing, what this
4:26 pm
effort by allies of the president that we uncovered is attempting to do is to discredit legitimate news reporting. and legitimate news reporting, unfortunately, sometimes for people in power reveals things that are unflattering about our leaders, and president trump has shown that he has been unable to handle that type of criticism, has. unable to withstand that type of scrutiny and won't be held accountable. and what he does is try to shame and intimidate and defame the people who end up trying to hold him accountable. >> david, have you seen any examples of this working, the chilling effect, the fear of somebody in your family did something wrong and they'll throw it in the face of the reporter or the organization or going after somebody, what they wrote when they were 15 like this egyptian guy in the story that jeremy reported? does that work anywhere? have you seen it? >> i haven't seen it and i hope it doesn't work. right now the targets of this campaign, as jeremy noted, have been what you would call maybe
4:27 pm
midlevel staffers, peoples whose names aren't known. if they start taking up people with more notoriety, it will. this is a roy cohn move. if you can't win on the facts, try to insult, bully and intimidate. right now it's not working and i hope it doesn't. >> well, thank you. i wish they were the only people who have done this. i've seen something like this done in politics in recent american history. i didn't like it then. i hate it more now. thank you. up next, a second republican challenger challenges trump for the nomination last year. his own case of conspiracies and incendiary marks to deal with as he tries to call the president out on his behavior. this is not exactly as clean as a whistle character coming into this race. you're watching "hardball." his . [ applause ] it's an honor to tell you that liberty mutual customizes your car insurance so you only pay for what you need.
4:28 pm
and now we need to get back to work. [ applause and band playing ] only pay for what you need. ♪ liberty. liberty. liberty. liberty. ♪ i like to make my life easy. ( ♪ ) romo mode. (beep) (bang) good luck with that one. yes! that's why i wear skechers slip-ons. they're effortless. just slip them right on and off. skechers slip-ons, with air-cooled memory foam. that's ensure max protein, with high protein and 1 gram sugar. it's a sit-up, banana! bend at the waist! i'm tryin'! keep it up. you'll get there. whoa-hoa-hoa! 30 grams of protein, and one gram of sugar. ensure max protein.
4:29 pm
age-related macular i've degeneration, with which could lead to vision loss. so today i made a plan with my doctor, which includes preservision. because it's my vision, my morning walk, my sunday drive, my grandson's beautiful face. only preservision areds 2 contains the exact nutrient formula recommended by the national eye institute to help reduce the risk of moderate to advanced amd progression. because it's my sunset, it's how i see my life. it's my vision. preservision you don't let a cold ruin your day. you take dayquil severe liquicaps and crush it. dayquil severe. the daytime, coughing, aching, stuffy-head, fever, sore throat, power through your day, medicine. that's why with dell small business technology advisors. you'll get tailored product solutions, expert tech advice and one-on-one partnership. call an advisor today at 877-buy-dell. ♪
4:31 pm
welcome back to "hardball." president trump's facing another challenger for the 2020 republican nomination. this weekend conservative radio host and former tea party congressman joe walsh announced his candidacy, arguing that trump is unfit to hold office and that he, joe walsh, can help defeat him. walsh called out the president's offensive comments but walsh himself has a long unfortunate history of obnoxious comments, having engaged himself in the birther conspiracy and demonizing muslims. >> there is a radical strain of islam in this country. it's not just over there.
4:32 pm
trying to kill americans every week. >> in fact, walsh referred to former president obama as a muslim on multiple occasions. as recently as the summer of went, wal went, walsh tweeted this comment about senator kamala harris. senator harris said something really dumb. if you're black and a woman, you can say dumb things. lowered bar. that's walsh taking. walsh says he's sorry for his past comments and his role in getting trump elected and says now he's a changed man. >> i've just got to own that stuff, apologize for that stuff, mika, and to compare it to trump again, correct me if i'm wrong, this man's never apologized for anything. so here i am in front of you this morning, yes, raising my hands. i helped put trump in the white house. i'm ashamed of that. this election is a referendum on him, the man. he's unqualified. he's unfit. he's a child.
4:33 pm
he's reckless. he's erratic. he's a narcissist. he's mean. he's cruel. he lies every time he opens his mouth. >> well, the road to damascus is really crowded these days. while president trump faces another primary challenge, a new poll could be pointing to a significant shake-up over on the democratic side, big shake-up for the democrats. that's coming up next. stick with us. there's everything from happy to extremely happy. there's also angry. i'm really angry clive! actually, really angry. thank you. but what if your business could understand what your customers are feeling... and then do something about it. turn problems into opportunities. thanks drone. customers into fanatics change the whole experience. alright who wants to go again? i do! i do! i have a really good feeling about this.
4:34 pm
i'm a faster laptopd could help. plus, tech support to stay worry free. worry free. boom! ha.ha. boom! now get 10 reams of paper only $34.99. $34.99 at office depot officemax or officedepot.com. ohone day you'll tell yourse grandkids about it. and they'll say, "grandpa just tell us about humpty dumpty". and you'll say, "he broke his pelvis or whatever, now back to my creamy heinz mayonnaise". heinz mayonnaise, unforgettably creamy. whyou should be mad that airports are complicated... he's my emotional support snake. ...but you're not, because you have e*trade, whose tech isn't complicated. it helps you understand the risk and reward potential on an options trade. don't get mad. get e*trade. [ soft piano music playing ] mm, uh, what do you do for fun? -not this. ♪ -oh, what am i into?
4:35 pm
4:36 pm
welcome back to "hardball." heading into the first presidential debate in june, former vice president joe biden had a big lead in the national polls. we all know that. according to monmouth university poll, in fact, biden as at 32% in june followed by elizabeth warren at 15. well down. bernie at 14 and kamala harris at 8. well, now after two debates and a lot of shuffling it's a virtual three-way tie tonight. in the new monmouth poll out tonight. senators warren and sanders are tied at 20 followed by, key word, followed by vice president biden at 19. so they're all together there.
4:37 pm
biden has lost 13 points in two months. it appears that most of that support he lost shifted over to warren and sanders. look at the math, they picked up the arithmetic. senator kamala harris a mystery to me has stayed exactly at 8 despite her very impressive performances. she doesn't change. be we're going to have to wait and see if the poll is an outlier. a margin of error of 5.7, a big margin of error. for more i'm joined now by expert steve kornacki of msnbc and danielle moodie-mills. sirius xm host. i want your thoughts -- no, your thought first. >> okay. >> what's going on with biden? >> i think that biden is doing what he has done in the past two times that he has run for president. he comes in very strong. he has hard name recognition. people are very excited by him. in this particular election, he is the security blanket, he's the nostalgia candidate, he reminds us of a forgotten time.
4:38 pm
eight years ago he reminds us of eight years of president obama, eight years of a new camelot, and i think that what is happening is that as the -- as people are getting closer and closer to understanding who he is, differentiating him from the field, we're asking ourselves what is his policy initiates? >> yeah. >> what are his great big ideas and we are unsure of what those are. >> what's he communicating? >> you know what? >> what does biden say to people? >> i think it's what they receive from him. because when you look inside the numbers here, what jumps out the most at me is a massive -- in a way i can't remember seeing before, generational divide on this thing. >> you said today. i was watching you all day. you said people over 50. >> this is basically half the democratic party is over 50 years old. half is under 50. use that as a dividing line. over 50 biden is running away with this. >> are they more politically moderate or more cautious or more aware of what happened in the past with people like mcgovern? do they have a memory of
4:39 pm
disaster when the party goes too left? >> my sense of it is it's about caution, it's a strategic sort of thing. i sense that's what it is. the electability argument is going to play with 50-plus more than it's going to play with 18 to 49. he's at 6% with democratic voters under 50 years old. >> i think we have one hire. i think you are, too. let me ask you this -- >> i think that's problematic. >> i like the guy. i'm a moderate -- moderate left. i thienk he's been running as te designated driver. i can get you home tonight. what is the designated driver? someone who drives safely and gets you home. they don't take you somewhere, they take you home. >> designated drivers are important. security blankets are security for a reason. i think that this particular election needs more than that. i think needs vibrancy. i think it needs passion. i think it needs focus. >> who is the best bet to beat trump? >> anyone. >> no, come on. who is the best -- >> come on, chris, anybody in the top five they tell us 7 percentage points -- >> everybody has an equal
4:40 pm
chance? everybody has an equal chance? >> everybody has an equal chance. there are some that right now, 435 days away, have a little bit better. biden is one of those people that has a little bit better -- >> let me ask you about what happened to kamala. kamala seems to be good on television. she comes across well. she's sparking with life. there is nothing deadhead about her. she's smart as hell and she's aggressive. why isn't she working? >> you've got this monmouth poll beginning to summer and end of summer. it looks like she hasn't moved. some pollsters who tracked it regularly did see movement towards her after the first democratic debate. >> she blew him away. biden was on the floor. >> after that second debate, it started to go the other way. >> because tulsi gabbard went after her from the left. >> in that one moment there with biden. you saw something with kamala harris. she is a prosecutor. she is prepared. she came to deliver the moment and she delivered it. when she was caught off guard maybe in that second debate, it played differently with voters. >> as it stands now, ten
4:41 pm
candidates qualify for the third debate in two weeks down in houston. we'll see biden, sanders and warren probably all putting together in the middle of the stage. we know how they stage these things. for the first time. how is that going to look with the three of them bunched? >> i think for the first time voters are really going to pay attention because they're going to see everybody on stage together, they're going to see how they play together. frankly, biden two debates down, he is not doing well. >> what's his problem? >> he has not shown up. i think he's unprepared. why does biden every time he's asked a question, why doesn't he follow through? why does he cut himself off, right? a debate is an opportunity for you to show your message. >> to exploit. he doesn't exploit the moment. >> he stops himself. oh, i'm out of time. >> he did it the first time. >> he did it twice. before the moderators say to you, you know what, you're out of time or the light comes up on his stand, he stops himself. he needs to run through the tape like it's a race because it is and he hasn't done that again. >> i think he memorizes since the first debate. i think message rise material
4:42 pm
shows. when the moderator says you're out of time he just stops. whereas if you had a point -- when kamala has a point, she keeps talking. >> but the contrast. when you think back, why was joe biden vice president in the first place? why did barack obama turn to him in 2008? one of the reasons. you remember the democratic debates in 2007, 2008, biden stole the show at half of them. he was impressive and the obama campaign saw something in that. is this a politician -- is he in prevent defense. is he there to avoid giving up the big play. >> like the speaker of the house is doing on impeachment. no, it's a great question because i think biden actually worked for the white working class guy. he was -- as i always say, he put the apostrophe in obama. he made him one of the boys. he wasn't an intellectual like obama. i'm not sure voters want that kind of character as their standard bearer.
4:43 pm
>> again, joe biden shows himself to be a security blanket. >> that's so negative. >> is it? everybody loves a security blanket. >> when you're 1 year old you do. >> no, many people wrap themselves in that and move forward with it. but the idea is this, that he's not offering anything that is a spark. >> i agree. >> that is different than donald trump. he is -- he is offering the other side of the coin, which is problematic to me. he is still talking to the white working class, right, in a way that they are the only people that we need to be getting a vote from, and i'm saying to myself, why? why are they the only ones that you're going after? why are they the ones that you're offering a nostalgia case to? why not offer something big and bold like warren and bernie sanders. >> because he's nostalgic. let's talk republicans. john kasich, we talk to people, the one candidate who could challenge trump for his base. >> i don't -- >> he's not running yet. >> i don't see it. it the trump's approval rating with republicans is 88%.
4:44 pm
if you look at the past presidents who have gotten any kind of primary challenge, they've not been at that level. jimmy carter with ted kennedy, under 50% with democrats. >> he still beat him, though. i was there. >> sure. i'm just saying to even get into trouble in the first place. george h.w. bush was at 73% and falling fast with republicans when buchanan got in. 88%, not a lot of room for a challenger. >> you were hitting on something. i'm the history guy around here. so i remember 1979, roger mudd, one of the greatest reporters ever in television, asked ted kennedy, a very attractive candidate, why do you want to be president? he didn't have the answer. and that's the biden question. >> that is the biden question, and i think that he wants to be president because he thinks that he's electable. i think he wants to be president for the same reason that dr. jill biden came out and said sometimes you got to swallow a pill. >> did she say that? >> she said it and i didn't understand why. >> thank you very much. you're so tough but so smart. thank you danielle moodie-mills
4:45 pm
and thank you, steve kornacki. i love this sort of chat. i love you at the board, too. i love this chat. up next, the once crowded field of 2020 democratic candidates is slowly narrowing. it's like an agatha christie play. down to about ten. the third debate lineup now set. is there still a path forward for those who didn't make the top ten or the cut, i should say. we're going to talk to one of the guys who didn't make the cut who still has a voice. more "hardball" after this. oh, don't worry. voya helps them to and through retirement... ...dealing with today's expenses... ...like college... ...while helping plan, invest and protect for the future. so they'll be okay... without me? um... and when we knock out this wall imagine the closet space? yes! oh hey, son. yeah, i think they'll be fine. voya. helping you to and through retirement. yesss, i'm doing it all. the water. the exercise. the fiber. month after month,
4:46 pm
and i still have belly pain and recurring constipation. so i asked my doctor what else i could do, and i said yesss to linzess. linzess treats adults with ibs with constipation or chronic constipation. linzess is not a laxative, it works differently. it helps relieve belly pain and lets you have more frequent and complete bowel movements. do not give linzess to children less than 6, and it should not be given to children 6 to less than 18, it may harm them. do not take linzess if you have a bowel blockage. get immediate help if you develop unusual or severe stomach pain, especially with bloody or black stools. the most common side effect is diarrhea, sometimes severe. if it's severe, stop taking linzess and call your doctor right away. other side effects include gas, stomach area pain, and swelling. i'm still doing it all. the water. the exercise. the fiber. and i said yesss to linzess for help with belly pain and recurring constipation. ask your doctor. carl, i appreciate the invite here. as my broker, what am i paying you to manage my money? it's racquetball time.
4:47 pm
(thumps) ugh! carl, does your firm offer a satisfaction guarantee? like schwab does. guarantee? (splash) carl, can you remind me what you've invested my money in? it's complicated. are you asking enough questions about the way your wealth is being managed? if not, talk to schwab. a modern approach to wealth management. if not, talk to schwab. but it's not really something yoyou want to buy.. it's not sexy... oh delicious. or delicious... or fun. ♪ but since you need both car and home insurance, why not bundle them with esurance and save up to 10%. which you can spend on things you really want to buy, like ah
4:48 pm
4:49 pm
welcome back to "hardball." it appears that only ten candidates have qualified for the third presidential debate which means the others running for the democratic nomination won't be appearing on america's tv screens in two weeks. new york city mayor bill de blasio is one of the candidates who won't be on the debates. i thought you fought way above your weight in a couple of debates. you didn't wait to be called on which was -- you're laughing. >> you know, as a new yorker, you don't wait to be called on. >> you were jumping ahead of somebody in the cab line. how are you going to win now when you can't get on that stage? >> the debate's just one piece of it. i mean, you know, look what you just saw in that poll. one candidate great in the debate. went up, went right back down. the debate's one piece of the puzzle. >> kamala. >> right. people are not voting for most of six months. there's a whole lot to play out here, and in the age of social media you can go from someone like me still not that well known to totally well known in a matter of days in the right
4:50 pm
circumstance, so there's a lot to play out, but, look, the previous discussion, i want to reference this. this campaign has to be about the democrats putting forward a candidate who will derive passion from people. we saw in 2016 our own people didn't vote. >> you look at the 15,000 people out for elizabeth warren in seattle yesterday. >> that's a good thing. >> that's passion. >> i'll tell you something, in 2016 our own folks didn't come out to vote. those younger voters you were referring to earlier, they didn't come out to vote. a lot of people of color didn't come out to vote. a lot of progressives didn't come out to vote. we need a nominee to excite -- >> the way the democrats did that in '08 was have an african-american candidate who can win. >> right. >> that got them people of color out. nothing else. that did. >> and a vision. the vision of hope. but i'm telling you right now, what we learned from the 2016 election which, remember, is post-great recession. we can't forget this. the great recession changed our politics fundamentally. we're still figuring it out right now. donald trump won on the strength of the great recession. donald trump appealed to all those voters who felt their lives were stuck economically. he said, i'm going to rock the
4:51 pm
boat, i'm going to change the system. our candidate, unfortunately, was not a believable change agent. i'm running because i've made change in new york and i'm running because i believe a candidate who comes forward and says we're not accepting the status quo in america. >> give me your preview. if you jumped the line again and jumped elizabeth warren and bernie sanders and joe biden and you're at the top of that and you win the nomination, and you're sitting right here next to trump. >> yeah. >> i'll play trump. >> okay. >> get the hell out of here. >> and i'd say you lied to the working people of this country. you gave away the store to the wealthy, to the corporations, to wall street, biggest tax giveaway in a generation, to the 1% and you told working people you'd be with them but you stabbed them in the back. and donald trump has a glass jaw. >> and i'll say, what, do you read "the new york times"? >> yeah, right. seriously, donald trump has a glass jaw. when you confront him. >> have you ever seen anybody knock him out. i watched -- hillary was just
4:52 pm
sort of the gentle person there. she wasn't ready for this godzilla number. you're taller than him. he can't loom behind you. remember marco rubio tried to talk dirty with him, talked trash with him, he looked like an idiot. >> first of all, if you're going to confront him, you have to have it in your heart and soul. can't be staged. hillary talked about his character. that's not how you win. you talk about what he's doing to people. look, there are so many people in this country that actually put some faith in him, they might be will to rock the boat and he will do something for them. the didn't. he lied to them. he will not have an answer for that. right now folks are watching this economy crumble. you talk to farmers out in iowa, the tariffs are killing their market, folks worried about a recession. the bloom's off the rose right now. >> i hope not. >> i hope it doesn't happen either but i'm telling you he's incredibly vulnerable. >> i watched one of the earlier programs at 6:00 we had kirsten gillibrand on. she made a pitch, please send a dollar. what's your pitch? go ahead.
4:53 pm
>> i'm not in the debate yet, but i'll tell you this, we need the most progressive voices we can get on that stage. i'm standing up for working people. i'm standing up for labor unions. i'm standing up for universal health care and calling out the fact that the democratic party, if we don't make clear that we're on the side of working pie people, we're going to lose again in 2016. i'm asking folks to go to billde blasio.com. please give at least one dollar. when you hear more progressive voices, it helps push this party in the right direction. >> how do you ask people to give you money if you can't get on the debate. >> i got in two debates. this one doesn't look like i'm going to be in. october is the same exact standards and we have a month more to get the support. >> thank you, mayor bill de blasio. up next, on trump's euro trip, he showed us the difference between being a business person and a true public servant. don't you think? out schilling for his hotel. you're watching "hardball." as soon as the homeowners arrive, we'll inform them that liberty mutual customizes home insurance,
4:54 pm
so they'll only pay for what they need. your turn to keep watch, limu. wake me up if you see anything. [ snoring ] [ loud squawking and siren blaring ] only pay for what you need. ♪ liberty. liberty. liberty. liberty. ♪ he borrowed billions donald trump failed as a businessman. and left a trail of bankruptcy and broken promises. he hasn't changed. i started a tiny investment business, and over 27 years, grew it successfully to 36 billion dollars. i'm tom steyer and i approve this message. i'm running for president because unlike other candidates, i can go head to head with donald trump on the economy, and expose him fo what he is: a fraud and a failure.
4:55 pm
the first person to survive alzis out there.ase and the alzheimer's association is going to make it happen by funding scientific breakthroughs, advancing public policy, and providing local support to those living with the disease and their caregivers. but we won't get there without you. join the fight with the alzheimer's association. "fine. no one leaves the table "fine! we'll sleep here."." "it's the easiest, because it's the cheesiest" kraft. for the win win. quietly running the world. creating jobs and fueling the economy. you're small business owners,
4:56 pm
4:57 pm
want to know what the difference is between a public servant and a business person? watch how donald trump behaved this weekend in france. a public servant would have been interested in the world and its future. a business person would be interested in profits for his own resort down in florida. president trump skipped the session on climate with other world leaders. there is an empty chair there, his. white house press secretary stephanie gresham said the president, quote, had scheduled
4:58 pm
meetings and bilateral so a senior member of the administration attended his in stead, but trump did make time to make a pitch for the next g7 meeting to be held at his dural golf course. want to know what this president's interested in? all you have to do is listen to him. if he cares, he says so. if he doesn't, he doesn't even show up. we already knew trump wasn't interested in climate discussion. "the new york times" reported on friday that french officials conceded there is no hope that mr. trump joins the group despite news that fires in the amazon rain forest could accelerate the planet's environmental crisis. the president struggled to avoid questions on climate change throughout the weekend, and here he is declining to engage in any serious discussion on climate with a reporter. >> mr. president -- what are you thoughts on the working session on climate? >> i think we made big progress with respect to iran with unity. there has been great unity. really, it's been flawless in that sense. we had a lot of fake news
4:59 pm
saying, oh, there's no unity, there's no unity. it's like total unity. >> ignored the question. here he is again. >> i know in the past you've offered some skepticism of science and climate change. what do you think the world should be doing about climate change and do you still harbor that skepticism? >> in a nutshell, i want the cleanest water on earth. i want the cleanest air on earth. and that's what we're doing. and i'm an environmentalist. a lot of people don't understand that. i have done more environmental impact statements probably than anybody that's -- i guess i can say definitely because i've done many, many, many of them, more than anybody that's ever been president or vice president or anything even close to president. >> skipped it again. trump has long suggested the scientists studying climate change have a political agenda. here he is on "60 minutes" last october. >> yeah, but what about the scientists who say it's worse than ever? >> you'd have to show me the scientists because they have a
5:00 pm
very big political agenda, leslie. >> i can't bring them in. >> scientists also have a political agenda. >> well, it's clear that trump's agenda is, it's getting his dural resort packed by the next g7. again, want to know the difference between a public servant and a true business person? watch donald trump in action. and that's "hardball" for now. "all in" with chris hayes starts right now. tonight on "all in." >> it's tremendous wealth. i'm not going to lose that wealth. >> the president skips out on climate as the world's most important resource burns. >> i'm not going to lose it on -- on dreams, on windmills. >> tonight, trump's head-spinning turn on the global stage as it relights to china, russia and a planet in crisis. then as the impeachment count grows again, did the president just announce high crimes and misdemeanors in france? >> dural happens to be within miami. it's a city. it's a wonderful place. plus, the
233 Views
IN COLLECTIONS
MSNBC WestUploaded by TV Archive on
![](http://athena.archive.org/0.gif?kind=track_js&track_js_case=control&cache_bust=1837568111)